Survival differences between black and white women with breast cancer

Cancer of the breast: 5-year survival in a tertiary hospital in Uganda

The objective was to investigate survival of breast cancer patients at Mulago Hospital. A retrospective study of the medical records of 297 breast cancer patients referred to the combined breast clinic housed in the radiotherapy department between 1996 and 2000 was done. The female/male ratio was 24 : 1. The age range was 22-85 years, with a median of 45 years and peak age group of 30-39 years. Twenty-three percent had early disease (stages 0-IIb) and 26% had metastatic disease. Poorly differentiated was the most common pathological grade (58%) followed by moderately differentiated (33%) and well-differentiated (9%) tumours. The commonest pathological type encountered was 'not otherwise specified' (76%). Of all patients, 75% had surgery, 76% had radiotherapy, 60% had hormonotherapy and 29% had chemotherapy. Thirty-six (12%) patients received all the four treatment modalities. The 5-year survival probabilities (Kaplan-Meier) for early disease were 74 and 39% for advanced disease (P=0.001). The overall 5-year survival was 56%, which is lower than the rates in the South African blacks (64%) and North American whites (82-88%).

Ethnic Disparities in Adjuvant Chemotherapy for Breast Cancer Are Not Caused by Excess Toxicity in Black Patients

BACKGROUND

Black patients with breast cancer may be at greater risk for chemotherapy-related hematologic toxicity than white patients because of lower baseline blood cell counts. We hypothesize that these baseline differences could lead to excess hematologic toxicity and greater modification of chemotherapy dosing in black patients and that this may contribute to the poorer survival observed in black patients with breast cancer compared with white patients with breast cancer.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We performed a retrospective cohort study of black and white patients with breast cancer treated with adjuvant chemotherapy at an academic medical center over an 18-month period. Clinical chart review and pharmacy records were used to collect data on the following: modification of chemotherapy dose or administration; hematologic toxicity; blood cell counts before, during, and after therapy; occurrence of febrile neutropenia; use of prophylactic antibiotics; and use of granulocyte colony-stimulating factor in order to determine whether ethnicity was an independent predictor of these outcomes.

RESULTS

Among 23 black patients and 98 white patients with breast cancer treated with adjuvant chemotherapy, modification of chemotherapy administration occurred in 56 patients (46%). Modification was more common among black patients (65.2% vs. 41.8%; relative risk [RR], 1.56; P = 0.04). Black patients were more likely to receive reduced cumulative doses of adjuvant chemotherapy (RR, 2.49; P = 0.03).

CONCLUSION

Our findings suggest that hematologic tolerability of adjuvant chemotherapy is similar in black and white patients. Strategies aimed at improving psychosocial barriers to adjuvant therapy and at reducing surgical complications in black patients may improve overall breast cancer outcomes in this group.

Race, socioeconomic status, and breast carcinoma in the U.S: what have we learned from clinical studies

BACKGROUND

Whether African-American women have biologically more aggressive breast carcinoma compared with white women and whether race acts as a significant independent prognostic factor for survival have not been determined. Alternatively, race merely may be a surrogate for socioeconomic status (SES).

METHODS

A literature review was performed of clinical trials and retrospective studies in the U.S. that compared survival between white women and black women with breast carcinoma after adjustment for known prognostic factors (patient age, disease stage, lymph node status, and estrogen receptor status) to assess the impact of race and SES.

RESULTS

Single institutional and clinical studies suggest that, when black patients are treated appropriately and other prognostic variables are controlled, their survival is similar to the survival of white patients. Twelve retrospective studies and 1 analysis of a clinical trial included SES and race as variables for survival. Only three of those studies revealed race as a significant prognostic factor for survival after adjusting for SES.

CONCLUSIONS

SES replaces race as a predictor of worse outcome after women are diagnosed with breast carcinoma in many studies. However, black women present with more advanced disease that appear more aggressive biologically, and they present at a younger age compared with white women. Further research should be conducted concerning the precise elements of SES that account for the incidence of breast carcinoma, age at diagnosis, hormone receptor status, and survival to devise better strategies to improve outcome.

Comparison between African-American and white women in their beliefs about breast cancer and their health locus of control

The purpose of this study was to examine the health beliefs of African-American and white women about breast cancer and locus of control, using the health belief model and the health locus of control construct. The Health Screening Questionnaire, developed by Sugarek, Deyo, and Holmes, was used to collect self-report data about health beliefs related to breast cancer and health locus of control. Participants included 197 white and 152 African-American women, between the ages of 19 and 93, recruited from various settings in central Florida. Significant differences were found between the two groups on all of the health beliefs about cancer items. The African-American women were significantly more likely to believe in chance, or to depend on powerful others for their health. Perceived susceptibility to cancer, doubts about the value of early diagnosis, and beliefs about the seriousness of breast cancer all were significantly associated with powerful other scores among African-American women. There was no relation between health beliefs and years of education for African-American women, but for white women, those with the least education were more likely to believe that death was inevitable with a cancer diagnosis. These results add to the information needed for the development of effective programs aimed at increasing breast cancer screening among African-American women.

Menstrual cycle, race and task effects on blood pressure recovery from acute stress

This study examined cardiovascular recovery from two standardized laboratory stressors in 68 healthy black and white normotensive women and men (mean age 33 years). Women were studied in a randomized order at the same time of day on two separate occasions, once during the follicular phase (days 7 to 10 following menses) and once during the luteal phase (days 7 to 10 following the leutenizing-hormone surge) of the menstrual cycle. Men were studied twice approximately 6 weeks apart. There were differential effects of the tasks on blood pressure recovery (change scores) with a mirror star task yielding poorer diastolic blood pressure recovery (p = 0.004) and an interpersonal speaking task yielding poorer systolic blood pressure recovery (p = 0.003). Across both tasks, blacks evidenced greater diastolic blood pressure recovery as compared to whites (p = 0.02). Black women showed greater diastolic blood pressure recovery in the luteal as compared to the follicular phase (p = 0.01), whereas white women evidenced no such change across the menstrual cycle. Correlation analysis across testing sessions generally revealed comparable temporal stability values for recovery as compared to reactivity measures. The findings support prior studies indicating racial differences in recovery from acute stress and extend these findings by suggesting that the menstrual cycle may differentially affect recovery in black versus white women.

Trends in the survival of American Indian, Hispanic, and Non-Hispanic white cancer patients in New Mexico and Arizona, 1969-1994

BACKGROUND

The burden of cancer mortality falls disproportionately on cancer patients belonging to ethnic minority groups. In the U.S., African American, Hispanic, and American Indian cancer patients are diagnosed at a more advanced stage and receive less appropriate treatment, resulting in poorer outcomes and higher mortality, than white cancer patients. The authors hypothesized that cancer control strategies based on earlier detection and more effective treatment may be most effective in increasing survival in groups with more advanced disease at diagnosis, less appropriate treatment, and lower survival.

METHODS

Data collected by the New Mexico Tumor Registry, a member organization of the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER) Program of the National Cancer Institute, afforded the authors an opportunity to investigate this hypothesis by studying trends in cancer survival for American Indians, Hispanics, and non-Hispanic whites. The authors examined temporal trends and ethnic disparities in survival for in situ and invasive incident cancer cases at 25 sites diagnosed from 1969 through 1994 in New Mexico residents and in American Indians residing in Arizona.

RESULTS

The distribution of stage became more favorable and the percentage of patients receiving appropriate treatment increased for all three ethnic groups during the study period. Survival improved for patients with cancer at most sites in each ethnic group; however, because the increase in survival was greater for non-Hispanic whites than for American Indians or Hispanics, the number of sites associated with disparities in survival among non-Hispanic whites, American Indians, and Hispanics increased. Differences in the distribution of age, gender, stage at diagnosis, histologic grade, and treatment did not completely explain the improved survival or the ethnic disparities regarding survival.

CONCLUSIONS

Increased cancer control efforts were associated with earlier diagnosis, more patients receiving appropriate therapy, and improved survival for non-Hispanic whites, American Indians, and Hispanics. However, the improvement was greatest for non-Hispanic whites, and disparities in survival results for the different ethnic groups widened over the period of study. Cancer control strategies need to address the specific social, cultural, and biologic prognostic factors that affect different ethnic groups if disparities in outcomes are to be reduced.

Mammographic appearance of breast cancer in African-American women: report of 100 consecutive cases

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

The authors determined the mammographic appearance of breast carcinoma in African-American women and compared it with that in a white cohort.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The authors reviewed the mammograms, clinical records, and pathology records of 97 consecutive African-American women with 100 confirmed breast cancers and 110 white women with 111 confirmed breast cancers.

RESULTS

The mammograms obtained in African-American women were positive in 94 cases (94%), and those obtained in white women were positive in 99 cases (89%). Forty-seven percent of malignancies in African-American women appeared as calcifications, alone or with a mass, and 41% appeared as a mass only. There was no statistically significant difference in the frequency of these two findings between the African-American and the white populations. There was no statistically significant difference in the breast parenchymal pattern between the two groups. The most common tumor location in both races was the upper outer quadrant.

CONCLUSION

Breast carcinoma in African-American women is similar to that in white women in terms of mammographic appearance, location, and breast density. The mammographic appearance should not be an impediment to the detection of breast cancer in African-American women.

Establishment of breast cell cultures and lines from peoples of African origin

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of our study was to establish breast epithelial cell cultures and cell lines from peoples of African origin (blacks). It is presumed that the biology of breast cancer in women of African origin has unique aspects that can be explored using cultured breast epithelial cells.

STUDY DESIGN

Biopsy specimens were obtained from black women undergoing radical or modified mastectomies. Normal cell cultures were established using tissue from reduction mammaplasties or the milk of lactating mothers. The tissue specimens were lacerated, digested with collagenase solution, and plated on tissue culture plates. To extend the life of the epithelial cells in culture, they are transformed with SV40 virus.

RESULTS

We have maintained breast tumor cells in culture from a 27-year-old black woman for more than 1 month.

CONCLUSION

Despite the difficulty of establishing epithelial cell cultures, we have maintained breast tumor cells from blacks in culture for an extended period to allow characterization.

Importance of race on breast cancer survival

BACKGROUND

Breast cancer survival has been shown to be significantly less among black women than white women. The reason for this difference in survival is unclear.

METHODS

Data were obtained retrospectively on 439 women seen between 1985 and 1993 based on a detailed chart audit. The impact of race and several known prognostic factors on overall survival, time to relapse, and survival after relapse were studied.

RESULTS

Black women with breast cancer were found to have a greater risk of recurrence, shorter overall survival, and shorter survival after relapse than did white women. Black patients were found to be younger and have higher stage of disease and lower hormone receptor levels than were white patients. After adjustment for menopausal status and disease stage, a significant independent effect of race was observed on overall survival but not risk of recurrence. In multivariate analysis, a significant interaction was observed between race and age in some models. Survival after recurrence of disease was lower among black than white women after adjustment for menopausal status and estrogen receptor level.

CONCLUSION

Black women experience shorter survival times than do white women, including a shorter survival time after disease recurrence. Breast cancer in black women is associated with younger age, higher stage at presentation, and low hormone receptor levels. After adjustment for known prognostic factors, race remains a significant independent predictor of breast cancer survival.

The effects of the menstrual cycle, race, and gender on adrenergic receptors and agonists

OBJECTIVE

To examine possible effects of race, sex, and the menstrual cycle on adrenergic receptors (beta 2 and alpha 2) and agonists.

METHODS

Sixty-three normotensive black men and women and white men and women were studied twice, approximately 6 weeks apart. Women were studied once during the follicular phase and once during the luteal phase of the menstrual cycle. beta 2-Adrenergic receptors and adenylate cyclase activity were examined on lymphocytes, and alpha 2-adrenergic receptors were examined on platelets. Norepinephrine and epinephrine were determined in plasma.

RESULTS

Women showed greater lymphocyte beta 2-receptor sensitivity (isoproterenol-stimulated cyclic adenosine monophosphate; p = 0.009). Women also showed greater postreceptor adenylate cycle activity independent of the beta-receptor (forskolin stimulation; p = 0.006). When these differences were controlled for, the gender-related differences in beta 2-receptor sensitivity were no longer evident. Black women had a reduced beta 2-receptor sensitivity in the luteal phase compared with the follicular phase, whereas white women showed no significant change (p = 0.018). Black subjects had lower lymphocyte beta 2-receptor density (Bmax) values than white subjects (p = 0.047). There were no significant effects on alpha 2-adrenergic receptors.

CONCLUSION

The findings suggest that although there is no generalized effect of the menstrual cycle on adrenergic receptors in white women, such an effect may occur in black women. The findings also suggest that previously reported gender-related differences in beta 2-receptor sensitivity may be due to gender-related differences in postreceptor activity and not the beta 2-receptor per se.

Menstrual cycle effects on catecholamine and cardiovascular responses to acute stress in black but not white normotensive women

This study examined cardiovascular and catecholamine responses to two standardized laboratory stressors in 33 healthy age- and weight-matched black and white normotensive women (mean age, 32 years) during two phases of the menstrual cycle. Subjects were studied in a randomized order at the same time of day on two separate occasions approximately six weeks apart, once during the follicular phase (days 7 to 10 after menses) and once during the luteal phase (days 7 to 10 after the leutenizing hormone surge) of the menstrual cycle. Black women has higher systolic (P=.01) and diastolic (P=.01) pressures compared with white women. Black women showed greater diastolic pressure (P <.01) and plasma epinephrine (P <.05) responses to stress during the follicular compared with the luteal phase of the menstrual cycle; white women showed no significant changes in these variables. The findings extend the literature on race differences in responsivity to stress and indicate that in contrast to white women, reproductive hormones do influence cardiovascular and catecholamine responsivity to stress in black women.

Breast cancer

BACKGROUND

Breast cancer is the most common cancer and the second leading cause of cancer death among women in the United States; annual breast cancer deaths are exceeded only by those for lung cancer.

METHODS

Data from the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER) program registry of the National Cancer Institute comprising 158,621 invasive and 10,639 in situ cases of microscopically confirmed breast carcinomas registered for the years 1973-1987 have been analyzed. Relative frequencies, incidence rates, and 5-year relative survival rates were examined by selected variables of interest. Invasive and in situ breast carcinomas and sarcomas were analyzed separately.

RESULTS

Infiltrating duct carcinoma was the largest group of female breast cancer, constituting 67.9% of the total with a 5-year relative survival of 79%. All other invasive carcinomas were compared with this group. Lobular carcinoma was the second largest group, only 6.3%, and a 5-year relative survival of 84%. Medullary carcinoma was the third most common with 2.8% and a 5-year relative survival of 82%. Other types included mucinous (colloid) adenocarcinoma, 2.2%, 5-year relative survival of 95%; comedocarcinoma, 1.4%, 5-year relative survival of 87%; Paget's disease (nipple and other breast), 1.1%, 5-year relative survival of 79%; papillary carcinoma, 0.9%, 5-year relative survival of 95%; tubular adenocarcinoma, 0.7%, 5-year relative survival of 96% and inflammatory carcinoma, 0.5%, 5-year relative survival of 18%. Carcinoma in situ was registered as intraductal, lobular, combined ductal and lobular, papillary, and carcinoma in situ, not otherwise specified. The relative survival for all forms of carcinomas in situ was approximately 100%. Sarcomas and malignant tumors not further classified are also considered.

CONCLUSIONS

The various histologic types of breast cancer exhibit differences in regard to relative frequency, site pattern within the breast, and patient survival. The SEER program data base of breast cancer is the largest single population-based reference source for breast cancer in the United States. This program is a valuable resource for information on frequency, percentage, and incidence rates by histologic type as well as survival rates of patients with breast cancer.