ImmuKnow: a new parameter in immune monitoring of pediatric liver transplantation recipients

Current Status of Biomarkers and Molecular Diagnostic Tools for Rejection in Liver Transplantation: Light at the End of the Tunnel?

Strategies to minimize immune-suppressive medications after liver transplantation are limited by allograft rejection. Biopsy of liver is the current standard of care in diagnosing rejection. However, it adds to physical and economic burden to the patient and has diagnostic limitations. In this review, we aim to highlight the different biomarkers to predict and diagnose acute rejection. We also aim to explore recent advances in molecular diagnostics to improve the diagnostic yield of liver biopsies.

Serum extracellular vesicle MicroRNAs as candidate biomarkers for acute rejection in patients subjected to liver transplant

Acute rejection (AR) is a common and grave complication of liver transplantation (LT). The diagnosis of AR is challenging because it has nonspecific clinical features and requires invasive procedures. Since extracellular vesicles (EVs) are promising candidates as indicators for diagnosis of various diseases, this study aimed to identify serum EV microRNAs (miRNAs) as potential biomarkers for AR in patients subjected to LT. We collected clinical information and serum samples from the liver transplant recipients with and without AR (non-AR). EVs from the serum were isolated via ultracentrifugation and identified using transmission electron microscopy, nanoparticle tracking analysis, and western blotting. EV RNA was extracted and sequenced on an Illumina HiSeq 2500/2000 platform to identify differentially expressed miRNAs between the groups. Gene Ontology (GO) and Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) enrichment analyses were performed on the target gene candidates of the differentially expressed miRNAs to test their functions in biological systems. Then, we validated 12 differentially expressed miRNAs by quantitative real-time PCR. The results demonstrated that 614 EV miRNAs were significantly altered (387 up regulated and 227 down regulated) between non-AR and AR patients. GO enrichment analysis revealed that these target genes were related to cellular processes, single-organism processes, biological regulation, metabolic processes, cells, cell parts, protein-binding processes, nucleoid binding, and catalytic activity. Furthermore, KEGG pathway analysis demonstrated that the target genes of the differentially expressed miRNAs were primarily involved in ubiquitin-mediated proteolysis, lysosomes, and protein processing in the endoplasmic reticulum. miR-223 and let-7e-5p in AR patients were significantly up-regulated compared to those in non-AR patients, whereas miR-199a-3p was significantly down-regulated, which was consistent with sequencing results. The expression of serum EV miRNAs (up-regulated: miR-223 and let-7e-5p and miR-486-3p; down regulated: miR-199a-3p, miR-148a-3p and miR-152-3p) in AR patients was significantly different from that in non-AR patients, and these miRNAs can serve as promising diagnostic biomarkers for AR in patients subjected to liver transplant.

Immune cell function assays in the diagnosis of infection in pediatric liver transplantation: an open-labeled, two center prospective cohort study

BACKGROUND

Limited studies have been performed in assessment of immune status of pediatric liver transplants (PLTs). We conducted this study to evaluate Cylex immune cell function assay in diagnosis of infection and its potential clinical application in Chinese infant PLTs.

METHODS

In this prospective cohort study, 227 infant PLTs from two medical centers were enrolled, and 216 completed the study. Cylex ATP values were measured before and after liver transplantation (LT) at week 1, 2, 3, 4, 8, 12 and 24 respectively. Accordingly, patients' clinical records, including demographic data, liver function results, tacrolimus dosages and concentrations were collected and analyzed.

RESULTS

One hundred and sixty of 216 PLTs (74.1%) were diagnosed infection based on the parameters including abnormal vital signs, imaging changes, and pathogens detection, while 44 (20.4%) were clinically stable and 12 (5.6%) experienced acute rejection. The median Cylex ATP value in infant PLTs post-surgery reduced significantly in infection group compared to stable group (median, 137 vs. 269 ng/mL, P<0.001). Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis determined that the cut-off value of Cylex ATP was 152 ng/mL in diagnosis of infection [area under the curve (AUC): 0.784, 95% CI: 0.720-0.848]. Meanwhile, Cylex ATP value showed no correlation to tacrolimus dosage, blood concentration, dose-normalized concentration/dose ratio or Kaup index. However, it tended to correlate weakly with the white blood cell (WBC) number (R =0.462, P<0.0001) and lymphocyte counts (R =0.363, P<0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, we demonstrated that low Cylex ATP represented partly over-immunosuppression and had diagnostic value in infant PLTs with infections, which might assist individualized immunosuppression in PLT patients.

Impact of EBV infection and immune function assay for lymphoproliferative disorder in pediatric patients after liver transplantation: A single-center experience

BACKGROUND

Post-transplant lymphoproliferative disorder (PTLD) is a lethal complication after pediatric liver transplantation, but information regarding risk factors for the development of PTLD remains unclear. This study was to identify characteristics and risk factors of PTLD.

METHODS

A total of 705 pediatric patients who underwent liver transplantation between January 2017 and October 2018 were studied. Impact of clinical characteristics and Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) infection on the development of PTLD was evaluated. In addition, ImmuKnow assay was adopted in partial patients to analyze the immune status.

RESULTS

Twenty-five (3.5%) patients suffered from PLTD with a median time of 6 months (3-14 months) after transplantation. Extremely high tacrolimus (TAC) level was found in 2 fatal cases at PTLD onset. EBV infection was found in 468 (66.4%) patients. A higher peak EBV DNA loads (>9590 copies/mL) within 3 months was a significant indicator for the onset of PTLD. In addition, the ImmuKnow assay demonstrated that overall immune response was significantly lower in patients with EBV infection and PTLD (P<0.0001). The cumulative incidence of PTLD was also higher in patients with lower ATP value (≤187 ng/mL, P<0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

A careful monitoring of EBV DNA loads and tacrolimus concentration might be supportive in prevention of PTLD in pediatric patients after liver transplantation. In addition, application of the ImmuKnow assay may provide guidance in reducing immunosuppressive agents in treatment of PTLD.

Perioperative characteristics and management of liver transplantation for isolated methylmalonic acidemia-the largest experience in China

Background

There are few detailed consensus and guidelines on perioperative clinical characteristics of liver transplantation (LT) in patients with methylmalonic acidemia (MMA). This retrospective study investigated details of the clinical course and individualized treatment plan of the center with largest experience in China.

Methods

A total of 7 MMA patients undergoing LT in Beijing Friendship Hospital from June 2013 to December 2017 were enrolled in the study, whose clinical data (clinical characteristics, laboratory findings, chronological changes in urine MMA levels, treatment, etc.) during perioperative period were analyzed retrospectively. All the patients received strict postoperative management.

Results

All the 7 cases were confirmed to have isolated MMA, among which, 3 cases received living donor liver transplantation (LDLT), 4 cases received deceased donor liver transplantation (DDLT). A wild fluctuate of metabolic condition was observed within the first few days after surgery and two weeks after LT, the mean base excess of blood value (BE-B) restored to normal whereas plasma bicarbonate (HCO₃ ^-) was still below normal value even with intermittent sodium bicarbonate correction. It also showed marked reduction in propionylcarnitine (C3) and C3/C2 level and the mean urine MMA by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) was reduced by 81.7% (P<0.01) but remained >72× higher than upper limit of normal. The metabolism-correcting medications were administered as before. The renal function of one case with renal insufficiency before LT (serum creatinine rising) maintained stable by adjusting the immunosuppressive regimen during the observation period. All patients survive to date.

Conclusions

LT is an effective treatment to prevent metabolic crisis, but patients with MMA tend to be metabolically fragile even after surgery. During perioperative period, close monitoring should be given for acidosis episodes so as to implement sodium bicarbonate correction. Metabolism-correcting medications are still needed. Special immunosuppressive regimen is an effective way of maintaining renal function for those with kidney dysfunction.

Immune Status in Children Before Liver Transplantation-A Cross-Sectional Analysis Within the ChilsSFree Multicentre Cohort Study

Background: Both, markers of cellular immunity and serum cytokines have been proposed as potential biomarkers for graft rejection after liver transplantation. However, no good prognostic model is available for the prediction of acute cellular rejection. The impact of underlying disease and demographic factors on immune status before pediatric liver transplantation (pLTx) is still poorly understood. We investigated expression of immune markers before pLTx, in order to better understand the pre-transplant immune status. Improved knowledge of the impact of pre-transplant variables may enhance our understanding of immunological changes post pLTx in the future.

Methods: This is a cross-sectional analysis of data from the ChilSFree study, a European multicentre cohort study investigating the longitudinal patterns of immune response before and after pLTx. Immune cell counts and soluble immune markers were measured in 155 children 1–30 days before pLTx by TruCount analysis and BioPlex assays. Results were logarithmised due to skewed distributions and then compared according to age, sex, and diagnosis using t-tests, ANOVAs, and Tukey post-hoc tests. The association between immune markers at time of pLTx and patients' age was assessed using a fractional polynomial approach. Multivariable regression models were used to assess the relative contribution of each factor.

Results: Sex had no effect on immune status. We found strong evidence for age-specific differences in the immune status. The majority of immune markers decreased in a log-linear way with increasing age. T and B cells showed a sharp increase within the first months of life followed by a log-linear decline in older age groups. Several immune markers were strongly associated with underlying diagnoses. The effects of age and underlying disease remained virtually unchanged when adjusting for each other in multivariable models.

Discussion: We show for the first time that age and diagnosis are major independent determinants of cellular and soluble immune marker levels in children with end-stage liver disease. These results need to be considered for future research on predictive immune monitoring after pLTx.

The Value of Liver Transplantation for Methylmalonic Acidemia

Introduction: MMA is a rare autosomal recessive disorder with the manifestation of recurrent and severe episodes of acute metabolic decompensation or a variety of long-term complications that require timely treatment. While conventional long-term medical and dietary management cannot prevent rapid progression of conditions in patients with severe complications, LT, or CKLT has become an option. Methods: We reviewed the literature for MMA patients undergoing LT/CKLT published since 2006, and data on metabolic decompensation status, protein dietary, neurological damage, renal insufficiency, and developmental delay before and after transplantations were compared to evaluate the clinical value of the procedure in the treatment of MMA. Results: To date, some successful LTs/CKLT procedures have prolonged survival and resulted in better quality of life in patients (lowered urine/plasma MMA levels but still much higher than normal, reduced onset of metabolic stroke, occasional improved developmental delay, and relaxed protein diet), although these procedures cannot reverse neurological damage or thoroughly stop the progress of complications, such as renal dysfunction. Conclusion: LT is the only effective treatment for MMA patients with recurrent metabolic decompensation. However, it is still possible that neurological and renal damage remains irreversible. Metabolism-correcting medications should be administered even after surgery.

Delayed introduction of immunosuppressive regimens in critically ill patients after liver transplantation

BACKGROUND

The manipulation of immunosuppression therapy remains challenging in patients who develop infectious diseases or multiple organ dysfunction after liver transplantation. We evaluated the outcomes of delayed introduction of immunosuppression in the patients after liver transplantation under immune monitoring with ImmuKnow assay.

METHODS

From March 2009 to February 2014, 225 consecutive liver recipients in our institute were included. The delayed administration of immunosuppressive regimens was attempted in 11 liver recipients with multiple severe comorbidities.

RESULTS

The median duration of non-immunosuppression was 12 days (range 5-58). Due to the infectious complications, the serial ImmuKnow assay showed a significantly low ATP level of 64±35 ng/mL in the early period after transplantation. With the development of comorbidities, the ImmuKnow value significantly increased. However, the acute allograft rejection developed when a continuous distinct elevation of both ATP and glutamyltranspeptidase levels was detected. The average ATP level measured just before the development of acute rejection was 271±115 ng/mL.

CONCLUSIONS

The delayed introduction of immunosuppressive regimens is safe and effective in management of critically ill patients after liver transplantation. The serial ImmuKnow assay could provide a reliable depiction of the dynamics of functional immunity throughout the clinical course of a given patient.

Lowered Immune Cell Function in Liver Recipients Recovered From Posttransplant Lymphoproliferative Disease Who Developed Graft Tolerance

Tolerance after treatment and recovery from posttransplant lymphoproliferative disease (PTLD) have been described but little is known about the immunology. The objective of this study is to evaluate the immunity of pediatric recipients who recovered from PTLD.

High-dose immunosuppressant alters the immunological status of New Zealand white rabbits following skin transplantation

The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of an immunosuppressant on the immunological status of New Zealand white rabbits after skin grafting, and to evaluate a method for monitoring the immunological status of subjects with skin transplants. The rabbits were randomly divided into allograft rejection, autograft tolerance, nontransplant, allograft low-dose immunosuppressant and allograft high-dose immunosuppressant groups. The rabbits in the low- and high-dose immunosuppressant groups were treated with cyclosporine A intravenously 8 h prior to skin transplantation and once daily following transplantation at doses of 2 and 25 mg/kg, respectively. At 12 days after skin transplantation, the spleens of donor (female) rabbits and recipient (male) rabbits were harvested for the preparation of single-cell suspensions. The splenocytes from recipient and donor rabbits were labeled with 0.3 or 6 µM carboxy fluorescein diacetate succinimidyl ester, respectively, and a mixed cell suspension was prepared. The final preparation was intravenously injected into recipient New Zealand white rabbits. The ratio of the two fluorescently labeled cell populations in the peripheral blood was measured using flow cytometry at 1, 2, 4 and 8 h after the injection, and the cell death rate was calculated. Histological analysis was also performed on samples collected at the time of splenectomy. The cell death rates of the allograft rejection and low-dose immunosuppressant groups reached their highest levels 8 h after the injection of spleen cell suspension. Allogeneic spleen cells from donor male rabbits were almost completely removed within 8 h of injection. The cell death rate increased slowly in the nontransplant, autograft and high-dose immunosuppressant groups without specificity. This study provides a specific method for the in vivo monitoring of the immunological status of patients after skin grafting. This method can quickly and accurately detect the immunological status of recipients following the injection of a mixed splenocyte suspension, thereby indicating the strength of immune rejection by the immune systems of the recipients.

Clinical role of Foxp3+ regulatory T cell in Living donor related liver transplantation for prediction of life-threatening complications

PURPOSES

It is no doubt that regulatory T cells (Foxp3(+)CD4(+)CD25(+)T cells: Treg) play important roles in transplant immunity. We investigated the significance of Treg expression in acute stage of living donorrelated liver transplantation (LDLT) for the possibility of the sensitive marker for immunological state and homeostatic stress after liver transplantation.

METHODS

Peripheral blood was drawn from 5 recipients of LDLT preoperatively and on post operative 1, 4, 7, and 14 days. The peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) were stained with CD4, CD25, Foxp3, and were analyzed with FACScan. This data was compared with clinical output of LDLT.

RESULT

The populations of Treg were significantly decreased in all patients on day 1 after LDLT and significantly increased in patients who had early postoperative complications compared with patients who had no complications.

CONCLUSIONS

The population of Treg in peripheral blood may reflect the surgical stress such as life-threatening complications after LDLT.

Evaluation of the immune function assay in pediatric living donor liver transplantation

The immune function (ImmuKnow) assay is a measure of cell-mediated immunity based on the peripheral CD4+ T cell ATP activity. The efficacy of ImmuKnow in pediatric LDLT is not well documented. The aim of this study was to assess the correlations between the ImmuKnow and the clinical status in pediatric LDLT recipients. A total of 716 blood samples were obtained from 60 pediatric LDLT recipients (one month to 16 yr of age). The recipient's status was classified as follows: stable, infection, or rejection. The ImmuKnow values in the pediatric LDLT recipients with a clinically stable status had a lower immune response (IQR 85-297 ATP ng/mL) than that previously reported in adults. Meanwhile, the ImmuKnow values of the stable patients were not correlated with age. Furthermore, a significant difference was found in the ImmuKnow values between the bacterial or fungal infection and stable groups, but not between the CMV or EBV infection and stable groups. The ImmuKnow levels in the pediatric LDLT were lower than those observed in the adult LDLT. The proposed reference value is between 85 and 297 ATP ng/mL in pediatric LDLT recipients. We conclude that the ImmuKnow assay could be helpful for monitoring pediatric LDLT recipients with bacterial or fungal infections.

Serial ImmuKnow assay in stable kidney transplant recipients

Objectives

The ImmuKnow assay (cylex Inc., Columbia, MD) has been reported to measure the global immune monitoring tool for organ transplantation recipients. We assess immuKnow ATP values in stable kidney transplant patients.

Material and methods

Patients who were kidney transplanted between September 2008 and May 2011 were enrolled in the prospective serial ImmuKnow assay study. The criteria of inclusion were living donor kidney transplantation (KT), no evidence of hepatitis B virus (HBV) and hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection, and PRA less than 50%. ImmuKnow assay monitoring was performed at one day before operation, post operative weeks 4, 8, 12, 16, 20, 24, 36 and 52. We excluded patients who had undergone infectious syndrome or rejection episodes during the follow-up period.

Results

Among 71 patients who were enrolled in prospective serial ImmuKnow assay monitoring, 37 patients were proven to stable KT patients during the follow-up period. Two hundred and twenty-four samples from 37 patients were collected. ImmuKnow value and immunosuppression drug level were compared in post operative weeks 4, 8, 12, 16, 20, 24, 36 and 52. The value of ImmuKnow assay was significantly different depending on the length of time after transplant (p = 0.038). Interestingly, the pre-transplant ImmuKnow values were lower than those of the immediate post-transplant period.

Conclusions

The ImmuKnow value of stable KT recipients is different according to “time after transplant”. Therefore, “time after transplant” should be considered when applying an ImmuKnow assay in clinical practice.

Utility of an immune cell function assay to differentiate rejection from infectious enteritis in pediatric intestinal transplant recipients

The Cylex Immune Cell Function Assay measures cell-mediated immunity based on ATP production by stimulated CD4 + cells. We hypothesized that this test would discriminate acute cellular rejection (ACR) from infectious enteritis (IE) in pediatric intestinal transplant (ITx) recipients with allograft dysfunction. We retrospectively analyzed 224 Cylex assays drawn in 47 children who received 53 ITx. Samples were classified as stable, ACR, or IE based on clinical status. ATP values were analyzed using Kruskal-Wallis and t-tests. Overall, there was a statistically significant difference in ATP values based on clinical status (p = 0.03); however, overlap was observed between groups. The median ATP value during ACR was significantly greater than during stable periods (p = 0.02). No difference was seen in IE vs. stability (p = 0.8). The difference in median ATP value in ACR vs. IE approached significance (p = 0.1). Relative to previous levels, ACR episodes were associated with a median ATP increase of 101 ng/mL and IE episodes with a decrease of 3 ng/mL (p = 0.3). These data indicate that the Cylex assay has limited utility in differentiating ACR from IE, largely due to interpatient variability. Following longitudinal intrapatient trends may be an adjunctive tool in discriminating IE from ACR and guiding immunosuppression adjustments in select patients.

Comparison of several functional methods to evaluate the immune response on stable kidney transplant patients

The introduction of new immunosuppressive drugs in the last two decades has been associated with a significant decline in the prevalence of acute rejection and a huge improvement of graft survival. Monitoring blood levels of immunosuppressive drugs is the most common way to control drug doses in renal transplant patients. This approach is useful and widely used but doesn't give accurate information about the immune status of the patient. For this goal, there are many "in house" protocols which give more information, but cannot be standardized, limiting their applicability to compare results between different laboratories. In this study we compare three classical functional methods to evaluate the immune response: Mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR), phytohemagglutinin stimulated peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs), and anti-CD3 monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) against PBL with the only FDA-labeled assay to measure the patient immune status: Cylex ImmuKnow® that measures the intracelullar ATP in CD4+ lymphocytes. We used n=111 stable renal transplant patients, all the patients with more than one year functioning grafts. We referred the results to a control population of healthy blood donors (n=125).

RESULTS

Measurement of intracellular ATP in CD4+ lymphocytes is able to differentiate immunosuppressed populations in renal transplant patients from health controls (242.30±21.62 vs. 386.43±25.12, p 0.0001). By contrary, there were no differences between controls and renal recipients when functional response was measured by MLR, PHA and anti-CD3 mAbs (2.48±0.45 vs. 2.37±0.41; 2.84±0.76 vs. 2.37±0.32; 2.32±0.34 vs. 1.89±0.38 respectively). In summary, our results show that the measurement of ATP in CD4+ lymphocytes gives more accurate information in comparison to the classical methods.

Increased intracellular adenosine triphosphate level as an index to predict acute rejection in kidney transplant recipients

BACKGROUND

Peripheral blood CD4+ T cell adenosine triphosphate (ATP) release has been reported to be an adjunct tool to evaluate global cellular immune response in solid-organ transplant recipients. However, the correlation between the ATP level and rejection was controversial. The aim of this prospective clinical study was to explore the association between the intracellular ATP level and the occurrence, progression, and treatment of acute rejection (AR) episodes, determine the predicting value of intracellular ATP level for AR in kidney transplant (KT) recipients.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

In the period of October 2011 to October 2012, 140 KT recipients were recruited and followed for six months after transplantation. Patients were categorized into stable group and AR group according to their clinical course. Whole blood samples were collected pretransplantation, and at 7, 14, 21, and 28days, and at 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6months post-transplantation. Additional blood samples were obtained from AR patients on the day AR occurred, on the day before and 3 and 7days after intravenous anti-rejection therapy started, and on the day when AR reversed. The intracellular ATP in CD4+ T cells was detected by ImmuKnow Immune Cell Function Assay according to the manufacturer's instruction. The absolute number of CD4+ T cells and the trough levels of tacrolimus and cyclosporine were also measured.

RESULTS

The ATP level detected on the day AR occurred (627.07±149.85ng/ml) was obviously higher than that of the stable group (320.48±149.11ng/ml, P<0.05). ATP value decreased to 265.35±84.33ng/m at the end of anti-rejection therapy, which was obviously lower than that measured on the day before the anti-rejection therapy started (665.87±162.85ng/ml, P<0.05). ROC analysis revealed that increased intracellular adenosine triphosphate level showed better sensitivity and specificity than those obtained using single time point detection (89.5% vs 85.0%;95.0% vs 88.9%). The best cutoff value was 172.55ng/ml. A positive correlation between the intracellular ATP level and absolute CD4+ T cell number (r=0.656, P<0.001) was found in the patients with CD4+ T cell counts <200/μl.

Trial of complete weaning from immunosuppression for liver transplant recipients: factors predictive of tolerance

Recipients of liver transplantation (LT) may develop immunological tolerance. Factors predictive of tolerance are not clearly understood. Transplant recipients with normal liver function tests and without active viral hepatitis or autoimmune disease who presented with side effects of immunosuppression or a high risk of de novo malignancies were selected to participate in this prospective study. Twenty-four patients fulfilled the inclusion criteria and, therefore, underwent a gradual reduction of immunosuppression. Tolerance was defined as normal liver function tests after immunosuppression withdrawal. Basal clinical and immunological characteristics, including lymphocyte counts and subpopulations (T, B, natural killer, CD4(+) , CD8(+) , and regulatory T cells) and the phytohemagglutinin stimulation index (SI), were compared for tolerant and nontolerant patients. Fifteen of the 24 patients (62.5%) were tolerant at a median of 14 months (interquartile range = 8.5-22.5 months) after complete immunosuppression withdrawal. Tolerant patients had a longer median interval between transplantation and inclusion in the study (156 for tolerant patients versus 71 months for nontolerant patients, P = 0.003) and a lower median SI (7.49 for tolerant patients versus 41.73 for nontolerant patients, P = 0.01). We identified 3 groups of patients with different probabilities of tolerance: in the first group (n = 7 for an interval > 10 years and an SI < 20), 100% reached tolerance; in the second group (n = 10 for an interval > 10 years and an SI > 20 or an interval < 10 years and an SI < 20), 60% reached tolerance; and in the third group (n = 7 for an interval < 10 years and an SI > 20), 29% reached tolerance. In conclusion, a high proportion of select LT recipients can reach tolerance over the long term. Two simple basal variables-the time from transplantation and the SI-may help to identify these patients.

A quantitative assessment model of T-cell immune function for predicting risks of infection and rejection during the early stage after liver transplantation

Although more and more clinical studies indicated that ImmuKnow assay could efficiently assess the immune status of recipients, it still has the challenge to predict the occurrence of clinical adverse events. This study aimed to establish a quantitative assessment model, which could more efficiently predict immune function of T lymphocytes after liver transplantation based on three indexes: CD4+ T lymphocyte count (C), CD4+/CD8+ ratio (R), and ImmuKnow adenosine triphosphate (ATP) value (A). We selected 194 recipients and measured the A, C, and R index every week, then obtained the Fisher linear discriminant functions by SPSS 16.0. Next, we divided the recipients into three groups: infection, stable, and rejection groups according to clinical status. After calculating, the discriminant function, 0.012A + 0.019C + 1.322R (simplified into T = 2A + 3C + 200R), was selected to represent the T-cell-mediated immune function. Based on the model, the optimal cutoff T values for infection and rejection were 1415 (sensitivity = 80%, specificity = 79.9%,AUC = 92.3%) and 1939.5 (sensitivity = 93.9%, specificity = 77.6%, AUC = 88.6%), relatively (p < 0.001). In conclusion, this model may be a more feasible way to evaluate the cellular immune function status in liver transplantation recipients.

Cellular immune function monitoring after allogeneic haematopoietic cell transplantation: evaluation of a new assay

Managing the patient's immune system after haematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) is a challenge, mainly in the unstable period immediately after the transplant. Currently there is no standardized non-invasive diagnostic tool for the evaluation of immunological complications such as graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) and for managing the cellular immune function of the transplant recipient. The ImmuKnow assay for cellular immune function monitoring has been incorporated successfully into the clinical follow-up routine of solid organ transplant recipients. This study aims to explore the relevance and potential contribution of immune monitoring using the assay in the setting of HCT. We found that ImmuKnow-level measurement can distinguish between states of immune function quiescence and between events of acute GVHD. ImmuKnow levels were significantly higher in patients going through GVHD than the levels measured for the same patients during immunological stability. Moreover, we demonstrate a patient case where longitudinal monitoring using the ImmuKnow assay provided a trustworthy depiction of the patient's cellular immune function post-HCT. In conclusion, we provide evidence for the potential contribution of the ImmuKnow assay for longitudinal individualized cellular immune function monitoring of patients following HCT. Further studies are necessary in order to establish the optimal practice for utilizing the assay for this purpose.

Clinical value of a single determination of intracellular ATP levels in stimulated CD4+ T lymphocytes in pediatric patients with stable liver transplantation

In the follow-up of transplanted patients under immunosupression, the functional assessment of CD4+ T cells activation by measuring intracellular ATP levels in vitro, using the Immuknow test give information on how immune system is functioning. Therefore, it has been reported that low levels of ATP correlate with the risk of opportunistic infection. Although limited, comprehensive results in adult recipients as well as in pediatric transplanted patients have been reported. Forty stable liver pediatric transplanted patients (mean age: 11.0 years [SD 5.65]), within at least 1 year of transplant were selected for a scheduled review, and an unique determination of Immuknow was performed. Average ATP levels were 317 ng/mL (200-400 ng/mL) which were similar to the values observed in adult population. ATP values among patients with monotherapy Cyclosporin A (CSA) or tacrolimus (TAC) were significantly higher (P = .005) than in patients with double immunosupressive therapy using either CSA/TAC + Mycophenolate Mofetil (MMF). In CSA treatment, there are significant differences (P = .0003) between monotherapy and double therapy, but in the case of TAC we did not find differences (P > .1). A single determination of levels of ATP on CD4+ lymphocytes, can provide additional information that could be used as a complementary test to guide immunosuppressive therapy in paediatric liver transplant recipients.

Biomarkers for the diagnosis of acute cellular rejection in liver transplant recipients: A review

The gold standard for the diagnosis of acute cellular rejection (ACR) is a liver biopsy. The quest for an alternative non-invasive biomarkers has been long and is ongoing. However, an efficient and useful biomarker has not been developed yet. In this manuscript, we review all possible candidate biomarkers that have been studied in recent years, starting with cytokines and ending with an overview of different newly discovered "omics". Promising paths are being explored but a valid non-invasive biomarker has not been discovered yet.

Clinical operational tolerance in liver transplantation: state-of-the-art perspective and future prospects

BACKGROUND

Liver transplantation is the definite treatment for end-stage liver diseases with satisfactory results. However, untoward effects of life-long immunosuppression prevent the development of alternative strategies to achieve better long-term outcome. Achieving clinical operational tolerance is the ultimate goal.

DATA SOURCES

A PubMed and Google Scholar search using terms: "immune tolerance", "liver transplantation", "clinical trial", "operational tolerance" and "immunosuppression withdrawal" was performed, and relevant articles published in English in the past decade were reviewed. Full-text publications relevant to the field were selected and relevant articles from reference lists were also included. Priority was given to those articles which are relevant to the review.

RESULTS

Because of the inherent tolerogenic property, around 20%-30% of liver transplantation recipients develop spontaneous operational tolerance after immunosuppression withdrawal, and the percentage may be even higher in pediatric living donor liver transplantation recipients. Several natural killer and gammadeltaT cell related markers have been identified to be associated with the tolerant state in liver transplantation patients. Despite the progress, clinical operational tolerance is still rare in liver transplantation. Reprogramming the recipient immune system by creating chimerism and regulatory cell therapies is among newer promising means to achieve clinical liver transplantation tolerance in the future.

CONCLUSION

Although clinical operational tolerance is still rare in liver transplantation recipients, ongoing basic research and collaborative clinical trials may help to decipher the mystery of transplantation tolerance and extend the potential benefits of drug withdrawal to an increasing number of patients in a more predictable fashion.

Significance of CD4 T-cell adenosine triphosphate levels monitoring in elderly renal transplant recipients

OBJECTIVES

To find the significance of CD4 T-cell adenosine triphosphate (ATP) levels in elderly renal recipients in correlation with drug doses, levels, and clinical parameters.

METHODS

Drug doses and levels, CD4 T-cell ATP level (162 sequential samples), and other clinical data were collected and assessed among 31 elderly renal recipients who underwent transplantations from November 2007 to March 2011.

RESULTS

Among subjects with stable clinical status, the main ATP levels pretransplantation were not significantly different from those posttransplantation: 302.4 ± 97.5 ng/mL versus 288.8 ± 102.6 ng/mL (P > .05). There was no relationship between ATP levels and tacrolimus concentrations or doses. In 12 patients experiencing infection, the ATP levels were significantly lower then those of subjects showing a stable clinical status: 127.3 ± 92.8 versus 288.8 ± 102.6 ng/mL (P < .01). Six patients with biopsy-proven acute rejection episodes did not show significantly higher ATP levels compared with those who were clinically stable: 26.2 ± 224.8 versus 288.8 ± 102.6 (P > .05).

CONCLUSIONS

CD4 T-cell ATP levels were valuable to monitor immunosuppression among elderly renal transplant recipients.

Intracellular ATP production in CD4+ T cells as a predictor for infection and allograft rejection in trough-level guided pediatric liver transplant recipients under calcineurin-inhibitor therapy

BACKGROUND

The assessment of cell-mediated immune responses through the measurement of intracellular adenosine-tri-phosphate (iATP) production (Cylex ImmuKnow) as a pharmacodynamic biomarker of immune function represents a potential tool to optimize individual immunosuppressive therapy independent of drug dosage or trough levels. This study aims to investigate the correlations between iATP and adverse events, immunosuppression, calcineurin-inhibitor-trough levels, and age.

METHODS

In this prospective trial, 31 nontransplant pediatric subjects and 50 consecutive children were included after they underwent liver transplantation (LTX). During the study period, 4 allograft rejections and 3 acute infections occurred. The patients were treated with cyclosporine, tacrolimus, mycophenolate mofetil, and everolimus either as monotherapy or in combinations. The reactivity of the immune system was measured as iATP concentration in CD4+ T-cells after in vitro stimulation by phytohemagglutinin.

RESULTS

The iATP concentrations in patients with intercurrent, clinically significant infections were in the low immune response range (median iATP 181 versus 251 ng/mL, P = 0.308), whereas the patients with incidental allograft rejection had significantly higher iATP concentrations as compared with the event-free group (median iATP 444 versus 251 ng/mL, P = 0.017). However, there was a wide range of iATP concentrations in both nontransplant and LTX patient groups, and no clear iATP cut-off values for an increased risk of infection or rejection could be defined. Post LTX, stable-phase patients showed a significantly lower iATP compared with respective controls (median iATP 297 versus 384 ng/mL, P = 0.013). No significant correlation between calcineurin-inhibitor-trough concentrations and iATP was found. iATP was not correlated with age, but was inversely correlated with time after transplantation.

CONCLUSIONS

The observed correlation between clinical events and iATP concentrations is similar to the findings previously reported in adult patients who underwent transplantation. The lack of correlation of iATP with trough drug concentrations suggests that the ImmuKnow assay provides independent information that may be useful to guide immunosuppressive therapy in pediatric (liver) transplant patients. However, the wide range of iATP levels in event-free patients suggests that serial iATP measurements will be necessary to assess and guide the individual immunosuppressive therapy. Further investigations are needed to evaluate and extend these findings.

Confronting the challenge: individualized immune monitoring after organ transplantation using the cellular immune function assay

The survival of a transplanted organ is dependent on avoidance of rejection, achieved through continuous immuno-suppression. Management of the transplant recipient confronts the clinician with a key challenge of post-transplant immune monitoring. Early detection of an activated allo-immune response is a harbinger of incipient rejection. Thus, timely intervention may prevent acute and chronic injury to the transplanted organ. Similarly, over immune-suppression can lead to infections or malignancies, hence the importance of early detection of the precarious suppression. The need for non-invasive systemic immune monitoring of the transplant recipient is therefore imperative. This review describes the cellular immune function assay--a non-invasive diagnostic method for evaluation of the net state of the recipient's cellular immune function. We describe the background that brought about the need for a reliable diagnostic tool for serial immune monitoring, and we overview the main mile-stones in the assimilation of the assay and its implementation in the clinic. The arising conclusion presents a novel non-invasive diagnostic bio-marker for post-transplant immune monitoring which enables the clinician to intervene prior to manifestation of clinical complications. The usefulness of the assay in detecting a state of over-suppression has been consensually described in multiple publications while its contribution in detection and management of under-suppression conditions remains to be determined by means of prospective interventional studies. The cellular immune function assay can be useful and beneficial for patient care only if used for longitudinal monitoring through serial testing.

Invasive fungal infection after liver transplantation: risk factors and significance of immune cell function monitoring

OBJECTIVE

Monitoring immune status in transplant recipients is essential for predicting the risk of infections. The aims of the study were to identify the correlation of a low ImmuKnow adenosine triphosphate (ATP) value with the development of invasive fungal infections (IFIs) and whether this is an independent risk factor for IFIs in liver recipients.

METHODS

We followed up 248 liver recipients who developed 157 infectious episodes. Peripheral CD4(+) T cells were selected freshly for ATP detection. Percentages of T-helper (Th, CD3(+) CD4(+) ) and T-suppressor (Ts, CD3(+) CD8(+) ) lymphocyte subgroups were also examined.

RESULTS

Overall 44 patients (17.7%) were diagnosed as IFIs, of whom 9 (20.5%) died. The average ImmuKnow ATP value in the IFI patients (109 ± 78 ng/mL) was significantly lower than that in common bacterial infections (174 ± 106 ng/mL, P < 0.01) or stable liver recipients (314 ± 132 ng/mL, P < 0.01), while there was no difference in the Th/Ts ratio among each group. Logistic regression analysis showed ImmuKnow ATP value less than 100 ng/mL was an independent risk factor of IFI (OR = 3.44, P = 0.0237). ImmuKnow ATP values had no correlation with lymphocytes or their subgroups, but tended to correlate with the number of neutrophils and total white blood cells.

CONCLUSIONS

ImmuKnow assay monitoring has the potential to identify the patients at risk of developing IFI after liver transplantation (LT), which may provide a feasible measure for optimizing liver recipients' immune cellular function after transplantation.

Monitoring tolerance and rejection in organ transplant recipients

To avoid toxic side effects caused by permanent immunosuppressive treatment, research in transplantation focuses on new treatment strategies inducing tolerance or allowing drug weaning. Implementing drug minimization into clinical routine can be only safely achieved when guided by biomarkers reflecting the individual immune reactivity. We review recently described biomarkers and assays allowing identification of patients suitable for drug weaning or at risk of rejection. However, the majority of described biomarkers and assays have not been validated in prospective clinical trials. Thus, collaborative efforts are needed to design and perform prospective multicenter trials to validate the identified biomarkers across different laboratories.

The relationship between adenosine triphosphate within CD4(+) T lymphocytes and acute rejection after liver transplantation

BACKGROUND

There have been increasing interests in the relationship between CD4(+) T lymphocytes and acute rejection (AR) in transplantation. In this study, we explore the role of CD4(+) T lymphocytes after liver transplantation.

METHODS

  From February to October 2009, 87 patients underwent liver transplantation. They were divided into the AR group and non-acute rejection (NAR) group, with 56 healthy individuals in the control group. Blood specimens were collected preoperatively and at one, two, and four wk postoperatively for all groups and also on the day when AR occurred and one wk after intravenous glucocorticoid therapy for the AR group. Adenosine triphosphate (ATP) levels were measured using the ImmuKnow™ test kits for immune cell functions.

RESULTS

  After transplantation, the ATP levels within CD4(+) T lymphocytes were significantly elevated in the two groups when compared with the preoperative levels. It peaked in the AR group and was significantly higher than that of the NAR group (p < 0.05). By ROC curve analysis, the obvious elevation of the ATP value one wk after transplantation had better sensitivity and specificity in diagnosing the AR. The ATP sensitivity rate for early AR was 85.7% and specificity rate 80.9% when the cutoff value was 407 μg/L. The ATP value collected on the day of AR occurrence has apparently positive correlation with the rejection acting index (RAI) (p < 0.01). After the intravenous glucocorticoid therapy, all the ARs were reversed and the ATP value declined significantly compared with the control group and that on the day when AR occurred (p < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

  During the early postoperative period (especially at first week after liver transplantation), the elevation of ATP levels within CD4(+) T lymphocytes has good sensitivity and specificity in diagnosing the AR at early stage. And the degree of AR has positive relationship with ATP value. After the intravenous glucocorticoid therapy, the obvious declination of AR might be used in evaluating the effectiveness of anti-rejection treatment.

Biomarkers as a tool for management of immunosuppression in transplant patients

Therapeutic drug monitoring is a well-established approach in transplantation medicine to guide immunosuppressive therapy. However, it cannot always predict the effects of immunosuppressive drugs on immune cells, because it does not reflect any aspect of an individual patient's immune system. Pharmacodynamic monitoring is a more recent strategy to provide information about the biologic effect of a specific drug or drug combination on the individual transplant patient. Currently, there is a large number of different biomarkers that either directly (specific markers) or indirectly (global markers) relate to the pharmacodynamic effects of immunosuppressive drugs and are under investigation as potential candidates to be introduced in clinical practice. Such biomarkers may be useful to identify patients at risk of developing acute rejection, infection, or cancer as well as patients who are suitable for minimization of immunosuppressant therapy and may be helpful to manage the timing and rate of immunosuppressant weaning. Serial longitudinal monitoring may allow maintenance of an individualized immunosuppressive regimen. Thus, biomarker monitoring is a potential complementary tool to therapeutic drug monitoring. This review summarizes the current state of knowledge about the use of a number of global or drug-specific pharmacodynamic biomarkers. It is not a comprehensive overview of the literature available, but rather an evidence-based reflection by experts who are intensively involved in scientific work in this field.

Immune response of young children using ATP-based Cylex assay: a brief report

Data on immune responses of young children using ATP release-based Cylex assay are insufficient. This study measured the immune response of healthy children less than three years of age to mitogens, PHA and Con-A. Blood was obtained from children attending routine health care visits. The Cylex assay was used to measure ATP production by CD4+ and CD3+ cells in response to PHA and Con-A, respectively. Samples from 20 children less than three years (range 10-27 months) were evaluated. The mean ATP production by CD4+ lymphocytes following PHA stimulation was 376 ng/mL (95% CI 17.1-735), which was similar to the response of older children in Hooper et al.'s (Clin Transplant 2005;19:834) study (p-value 0.28). The mean and median ATP production by CD3+ cells following Con-A stimulation were 114 ng/mL and 93.3 ng/mL, respectively (95% CI for median 45.2,148.6). The data suggest that although the immune system of young infants and toddlers is evolving, they are still able to respond to mitogen stimulation similar to older children.

Individualized immune monitoring of cardiac transplant recipients by noninvasive longitudinal cellular immunity tests

BACKGROUND

Common immunosuppression strategies after heart transplantation (HTx) are based on accepted target drug levels, disregarding that drug levels do not correlate with the individual patient's pharmacokinetics or with the actual immunosuppressive drug effect on the patient. The Immuknow assay is used for immune monitoring and management of organ transplant recipients. This study evaluated the Immuknow assay for longitudinal immune monitoring of HTx patients throughout various clinical settings.

METHODS

The functional immune response as measured by the Immuknow assay was determined in 327 samples collected from 50 HTx patients at the Rabin Medical Center and was analyzed together with common clinical parameters.

RESULTS

The median Immuknow levels measured throughout the infection episodes and the episodes of biopsy-proven acute rejection were 129 and 619 ng ATP/mL, respectively. These values were significantly dissimilar to the median Immuknow level measured during clinical quiescence, which was 351 ng ATP/mL (P<0.05). Calcineurin inhibitors drug-level measurements did not provide a reliable depiction of the patients' immune function, because the median deviation from the recommended drug trough levels range was significantly higher than the median deviation of Immuknow levels from their expected immune response zones. Longitudinal monitoring of Immuknow levels through serial testing proved to be a reliable method for individual patient immune management.

CONCLUSIONS

The Immuknow assay reliably reflects the cellular immune function of HTx patients, thereby supporting the immune monitoring and management of these patients. Serial longitudinal Immuknow monitoring allows immune management of therapy according to the individual patient's immune status.

Immune cell functional assay in monitoring of adult liver transplantation recipients with infection

PURPOSE

To identify the levels of functional immunity measured by the ImmuKnow assay in Chinese liver transplantation recipients and its application in monitoring the risk of posttransplant infection.

METHODS

Forty-five apparent healthy Chinese and 106 adult liver transplant (LT) recipients were under investigation. LTs were grouped in stable status or infection according to their clinical diagnosis. Whole blood samples were collected freshly and cultured within 6 hr, the CD4(+) T cells were selected, and their adenosine triphosphate (ATP) value was assayed the next day. Before stimulation, we also examined the percentage of T-helper (Th; CD3(+) CD4(+)) and T-suppress (Ts; CD3(+) CD8(+)) lymphocyte subpopulations and the ratio of Th/Ts.

RESULTS

The average ImmuKnow assay in infectious LT recipients was 128 + or - 84 ng/mL, significantly lower (P<0.05) than that in stable LTs (305 + or - 149 ng/mL) or in normal adults (301+ or - 101 ng/mL). The ImmuKnow values in LTs had a good negative correlation to infection clinically (r = -0.6217, P<0.001). Infectious risk was high when the ImmuKnow value was less than 130 ng/mL (odds ratio=13, 95% confidence interval 6.0-29.4, P<0.01). The sensitivity of low ImmuKnow values in posttransplant infection was 85.2%, significantly higher than those of Th/Ts ratio and immunosuppressant trough levels (P<0.01); specificity was 76.3%, comparable with that of Th/Ts ratio (75.5%), but greatly higher than immunosuppressant trough levels (P<0.01). ImmuKnow ATP values had no correlation with Th/Ts ratio or immunosuppressant trough levels.

CONCLUSION

ImmuKnow ATP levels are lower in LT recipients with infection, which provides a new tool in monitoring posttransplant infection, and an index of tailoring immunosuppression clinically.

Pretransplant immune risk assessment

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Despite the introduction of advanced immunosuppressive drug therapies, clinical and subclinical rejections still occur in many graft recipients with a negative impact on the long-term transplant outcome. The immunological status of the patients awaiting the transplantation is a key factor for these processes. Here we summarize the recent efforts to identify and develop biomarkers and functional assays that allow an individual pretransplant risk assessment.

RECENT FINDINGS

New sensitive techniques assessing T-cell memory and B-cell activation have been developed. Furthermore, the expression level of soluble and molecular markers reflecting the activation state of the immune system and donor graft intrinsic factors have been shown to influence graft outcome.

SUMMARY

A variety of parameters and assays that determine the pretransplant immune activation status has been developed. Some of these assays have already been used prospectively to define high-risk patients receiving advanced immunosuppressive induction therapy.However, the conflicting results obtained in different studies show that biomarker analysis and functional assays performance need to be further standardized and validated in large prospective trials before they can be routinely implemented into a pretransplant risk assessment. Subsequently, a combined effort to design pretransplant risk stratification algorithms should lead to personalized immunosuppressive treatment regimes and improved graft survival and long-term graft function.

Pretransplant lymphocyte count predicts the incidence of infection during the first two years after liver transplantation

Patients with end-stage liver disease (ESLD) show a low absolute number of peripheral blood lymphocyte subpopulations (PBLSs). We investigated if the baseline PBLS could categorize orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) recipients into groups at high or low risk for infection after transplantation. PBLSs were prospectively studied in 63 consecutive patients (42 males; mean age +/- standard deviation: 53.5 +/- 10.3 years) with ESLD prior to OLT. Thirty-five patients (55.6%) developed a total of 79 infectious episodes during the first 2 years post-OLT. The median total lymphocyte count and PBLS levels [CD3+ T cells, CD4+ T cells, memory (CD45RO+) CD4+ T cells, T cell receptor alphabeta+ and gammadelta+ subsets, and CD19+ B cells] at baseline were significantly lower in patients with an infection compared with those without one (P < 0.05). There was a significant correlation between the risk of development of a post-OLT infection and a baseline total lymphocyte count < 1.00 x 10(3)/microL (P = 0.001), a baseline CD3+ T cell count < 0.75 x 10(3)/microL (P = 0.009), and a baseline CD4+ T cell count < 0.5 x 10(3)/microL (P = 0.008). In the multivariate analysis, this association between the baseline total lymphocyte level and infection remained significant (odds ratio: 10.1; 95% confidence interval: 1.9-39.5). In conclusion, the pre-OLT total lymphocyte count identifies a subset of patients at high risk for infection. PBLS monitoring prior to OLT may offer an opportunity for surveillance, tapering of immunosuppression, and preemptive therapy.

The immunological monitoring of kidney and liver transplants in adult and pediatric recipients

Over the last half century, kidney and liver transplantation have been recognized as the treatment of choice for adult and children with end-stage renal or liver failure. Infants present a relative naïve immune system, but they are capable of mounting both cellular and humoral immune responses to the foreign antigens presented by the allograft. Immune monitoring is a way of measuring functional and molecular correlates of immune reactivity which may provide clinically useful information for identifying patients who have an increase risk of acute rejection prior to clinical symptoms or develop transplant tolerance. However, although numerous assays have been shown to predict rejection, to date no assays have been demonstrated to detect or predict transplantation tolerance. This is a summary of the published literature on promising antigen-specific and non-antigen-specific assays used for immunological monitoring in solid organ transplantation. This work also attempts to review their applicability to pediatric transplantation, specifically, pediatric kidney and liver recipients.

Calcineurin inhibitor sparing in paediatric solid organ transplantation : managing the efficacy/toxicity conundrum

Despite their efficacy, the calcineurin inhibitors (CNIs) ciclosporin and tacrolimus carry a risk of debilitating adverse effects, especially nephrotoxicity, that affect the long-term outcome and survival of children who are given organ transplants. Simple reduction in dosage of CNI has little or no long-term benefit on their adverse effects, and complete withdrawal without threatening graft outcome may only be possible after liver transplantation. Until the last decade, the only option was to increase corticosteroid and/or azathioprine doses, which imposed additional long-term hazards. Considered here are the emerging generation of new agents offering an opportunity for improving long-term graft survival, minimizing CNI-related adverse events and ensuring patient well-being.A holistic, multifaceted strategy may need to be considered - initial selection and optimized use and monitoring of immunosuppressant regimens, early recognition of indicators of patient and graft dysfunction, and, where applicable, early introduction of CNI-sparing regimens facilitating CNI withdrawal. The evidence reviewed here supports these approaches but remains far from definitive in paediatric solid organ transplantation. Because de novo immunosuppression uses CNI in more than 93% of patients, reduction of CNI-related adverse effects has focused on CNI sparing or withdrawal.A recurring theme where sirolimus and mycophenolate mofetil have been used for this purpose is the importance of their early introduction to limit CNI damage and provide long-term benefit: for example, long-term renal function critically reflects that at 1 year post-transplant. While mycophenolic acid shows advantages over sirolimus in preserving renal function because the latter is associated with proteinuria, sirolimus appears the more potent immunosuppressant but also impairs early wound healing. The use of CNI-free immunosuppressant regimens with depleting or non-depleting antibodies plus sirolimus and mycophenolic acid needs much wider investigation to achieve acceptable rejection rates and conserve renal function. The adverse effects of the alternative immunosuppressants, particularly the dyslipidaemia associated with sirolimus, needs to be minimized to avoid replacing one set of adverse effects (from CNIs) with another. While we can only conjecture that judicious combinations with the second generation of novel immunosuppressants currently in development will provide these solutions, a rationale of low-dose therapy with multiple immunosuppressants acting by complementary mechanisms seems to hold the promise for efficacy with minimal toxicity until the vision of tolerance achieves reality.