Daytime sleep latency in medication-matched Parkinsonian patients with and without sudden onset of sleep

Sleep Attacks in Patients With Parkinson's Disease on Dopaminergic Medications: A Systematic Review

Dopaminergic medications are used as first-line treatment for Parkinson's disease (PD). In 1999, a case series was published describing 9 patients who took dopamine agonists (pramipexole or ropinirole) and experienced sudden irresistible sleep attacks. Sleep attacks have subsequently been reported with other dopaminergic medications, including levodopa. Because these symptoms might not be rare and can affect health-related quality of life, we set out to review the prevalence and clinical characteristics of sleep attacks in patients with PD on dopaminergic medications. We conducted a systematic literature review using the terms parkinson* AND dopamine* AND narcolep* OR sleep attack in multiple databases (PubMed, Embase, and PsycINFO). The systematic literature review yielded 23 relevant articles, including nine case reports or case series and 14 original studies. According to the pooled data from the five studies reporting prevalence figures (n = 10,084), sleep attacks occur in 13.0% of patients with PD on dopaminergic medications. Our analysis failed to show significant differences in the Epworth Sleepiness scores between patients with and without sleep attacks (mean difference: 2.92; 95% confidence interval: -0.47-6.31). The I² value of 76% indicated high heterogeneity among the studies. Sleep attacks are not a rare occurrence in patients with PD on dopamine agonist treatment. We found conflicting results on whether sleep attacks in PD resemble narcolepsy. The pathophysiology of these symptoms might be related to dopamine D2 and D4 receptor gene polymorphisms. The most effective management strategies were dose reduction and discontinuation of the offending drugs.

The nature of excessive sleepiness and sudden sleep onset in Parkinson׳s disease

Objectives

Excessive daytime sleepiness (EDS) and sudden sleep onset (SOS) episodes are frequent in Parkinson׳s disease (PD). The objectives are to identify clinical characteristics and factors associated with EDS and SOS episodes.

Methods

Clinical demographic data were recorded (N=100, mean age=65.0±10.4). EDS was identified by the Epworth Sleepiness Scale (ESS>10) and SOS episodes were registered. Disease severity was evaluated by the Unified Parkinson׳s Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS, I, II, and III), sleep disturbances by the Parkinson׳s Disease Sleep Scale (PDSS<100), depressive symptoms by the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI>10) and rapid eye movement (REM) sleep behavior disorder (RBD) by the REM sleep behavior scale. Levodopa equivalent dose was measured.

Results: PD patients with EDS (67%) were predominately male (73.1%) and had worse disease severity (UPDRS II and III p= 0.005); SOS episodes (39%) were associated with disease duration, diabetes, sleep disturbances (PDSS Scale), disease severity (UPDRS I, II, III) and RBD symptoms (p<0.05). Stepwise regression analysis showed that EDS was independently associated with motor-symptoms severity (UPDRS III scale, p=0.003). SOS episodes were independently associated with disease duration (p=0.006) and sleep disturbances (PDSS scale, p=0.03): patients had more uncomfortable immobility at night, tremor on waking and snoring or difficult breathing.

Discussion

EDS and or SOS episodes are frequent and manifest a differential pattern in PD. SOS episodes are associated with longer disease duration, diabetes, sleep disturbances and RBD symptoms indicating that these “sleep attacks” are of multifactorial origin and probably influenced by brain structural abnormalities.

Daytime sleepiness and Parkinson's disease: the contribution of the multiple sleep latency test

Background. Sleep disorders are major nonmotor manifestations of patients with Parkinson's disease (PD), and excessive daytime sleepiness (EDS) is one of the most common symptoms. Objective. We reviewed a current literature concerning major factors that influence EDS in PD patients, using Multiple Sleep Latency Test (MSLT). Methods. A Medline search found 23 studies. Results. The presence of EDS was observed in 12.7% to 47% in patients without complaints of daytime sleepiness and 47% to 66.7% with complaints of daytime sleepiness. Despite being recognized by several authors, major factors that influence EDS, such as severity of motor symptoms, use of dopaminergic medications, and associated sleep disturbances, presented contradictory data. Conclusions. Available data suggest that the variability of the results may be related to the fact that it was conducted with a small sample size, not counting the neuropathological heterogeneity of the disease. Thus, before carrying out longitudinal studies with significant samples, careful analysis should be done by assigning a specific agent on the responsibility of EDS in PD patients.

Daytime REM sleep in Parkinson's disease

BACKGROUND

Previous studies have demonstrated both clinical and neurochemical similarities between Parkinson's disease (PD) and narcolepsy. The intrusion of REM sleep into the daytime remains a cardinal feature of narcolepsy, but the importance of these intrusions in PD remains unclear. In this study we examined REM sleep during daytime Maintenance of Wakefulness Testing (MWT) in PD patients.

METHODS

Patients spent 2 consecutive nights and days in the sleep laboratory. During the daytime, we employed a modified MWT procedure in which each daytime nap opportunity (4 per day) was extended to 40 min, regardless of whether the patient was able to sleep or how much the patient slept. We examined each nap opportunity for the presence of REM sleep and time to fall asleep.

RESULTS

Eleven of 63 PD patients studied showed 2 or more REM episodes and 10 showed 1 REM episode on their daytime MWTs. Nocturnal sleep characteristics and sleep disorders were unrelated to the presence of daytime REM sleep, however, patients with daytime REM were significantly sleepier during the daytime than those patients without REM. Demographic and clinical variables, including Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale motor scores and levodopa dose equivalents, were unrelated to the presence of REM sleep.

CONCLUSIONS

A sizeable proportion of PD patients demonstrated REM sleep and daytime sleep tendency during daytime nap testing. These data confirm similarities in REM intrusions between narcolepsy and PD, perhaps suggesting parallel neurodegenerative conditions of hypocretin deficiency.

Daytime alertness in Parkinson's disease: potentially dose-dependent, divergent effects by drug class

Many patients with idiopathic Parkinson's disease experience difficulties maintaining daytime alertness. Controversy exists regarding whether this reflects effects of antiparkinsonian medications, the disease itself, or other factors such as nocturnal sleep disturbances. In this study we examined the phenomenon by evaluating medicated and unmedicated Parkinson's patients with objective polysomnographic measurements of nocturnal sleep and daytime alertness. Patients (n = 63) underwent a 48-hour laboratory-based study incorporating 2 consecutive nights of overnight polysomnography and 2 days of Maintenance of Wakefulness Testing. We examined correlates of individual differences in alertness, including demographics, clinical features, nocturnal sleep variables, and class and dosage of anti-Parkinson's medications. Results indicated that, first, relative to unmediated patients, all classes of dopaminergic medications were associated with reduced daytime alertness, and this effect was not mediated by disease duration or disease severity. Second, the results showed that increasing dosages of dopamine agonists were associated with less daytime alertness, whereas higher levels of levodopa were associated with higher levels of alertness. Variables unrelated to the Maintenance of Wakefulness Test defined daytime alertness including age, sex, years with diagnosis, motor impairment score, and most nocturnal sleep variables. Deficits in objectively assessed daytime alertness in Parkinson's disease appear to be a function of both the disease and the medications and their doses used. The apparent divergent dose-dependent effects of drug class in Parkinson's disease are anticipated by basic science studies of the sleep/wake cycle under different pharmacological agents.

Continuous sleep EEG monitoring in PD patients with and without sleep attacks

The pathogenesis of sleep attacks in Parkinson's disease (PD) is still unresolved. We investigated seven matched pairs of PD patients with and without a history of sleep attacks using continuous sleep EEG recording. According to the event marker altogether 12 sleep attacks were identified in three patients with a history of sleep attacks. All sleep attacks were characterized by NREM stage 1 and 2 sleep, whereas no sleep onset REM episodes were recorded. Five sleep attacks fulfilled our criteria for microsleep episodes lasting less than 120 s. The cumulative duration of microsleep episodes during the day was 27.7+/-20 min in patients with a history of sleep attacks vs. 6.4+/-4.1 min in patients without a history of sleep attacks (p=0.03), i.e., the majority of microsleep episodes were not perceived by the patients. In summary, our study suggests that sleep attacks are intrusions of NREM stage 1 and 2 sleep into wakefulness and can be identical to microsleep episodes. Future studies should systematically address the awareness of short sleep episodes in patients with PD and other disorders with increased daytime sleepiness.