C-kinase manipulations disrupt activity-driven retinotopic sharpening in regenerating goldfish retinotectal projection

Arachidonic acid as a retrograde signal controlling growth and dynamics of retinotectal arbors

In the developing visual system, correlated presynaptic activity between neighboring retinal ganglion cells (RGC) stabilizes retinotopic synapses via a postsynaptic NMDAR (N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor)-dependent mechanism. Blocking NMDARs makes individual axonal arbors larger, which underlies an unsharpened map, and also increases branch turnover, as if a stabilizing factor from the postsynaptic partner is no longer released. Arachidonic acid (AA), a candidate retrograde stabilizing factor, is released by cytoplasmic phospholipase A2 (cPLA2) after Ca(2+) entry through activated NMDARs, and can activate presynaptic protein kinase C to phosphorylate various substrates such as GAP43 to regulate cytoskeletal dynamics. To test the role of cPLA2 in the retinotectal system of developing zebrafish, we first used PED6, a fluorescent reporter of cPLA2 activity, to show that 1-3 min of strobe flashes activated tectal cPLA2 by an NMDAR-dependent mechanism. Second, we imaged the dynamic growth of retinal arbors during both local inhibition of tectal cPLA2 by a pharmacological inhibitor, arachidonic tri-fluoromethylketone, and its suppression by antisense oligonucleotides (both injected intraventricularly). Both methods produced larger arbors and faster branch dynamics as occurs with blocking NMDARs. In contrast, intraocular suppression of retinal cPLA2 with large doses of antisense oligos produced none of the effects of tectal cPLA2 inhibition. Finally, if AA is the retrograde messenger, the application of exogenous AA to the tectum should reverse the increased branch turnover caused by blocking either NMDARs or cPLA2. In both cases, intraventricular injection of AA stabilized the overall branch dynamics, bringing rates down below the normal values. The results suggest that AA generated postsynaptically by cPLA2 downstream of Ca(2+) entry through NMDARs acts as a retrograde signal to regulate the dynamic growth of retinal arbors.

Activity-driven sharpening of the retinotectal projection: the search for retrograde synaptic signaling pathways

Patterned visual activity, acting via NMDA receptors, refines developing retinotectal maps by shaping individual retinal arbors. Because NMDA receptors are postsynaptic but the retinal arbors are presynaptic, there must be retrograde signals generated downstream of Ca(++) entry through NMDA receptors that direct the presynaptic retinal terminals to stabilize and grow or to withdraw. This review defines criteria for retrograde synaptic messengers, and then applies them to the leading candidates: nitric oxide (NO), brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), and arachidonic acid (AA). NO is not likely to be a general mechanism, as it operates only in selected projections of warm blooded vertebrates to speed up synaptic refinement, but is not essential. BDNF is a neurotrophin with strong growth promoting properties and complex interactions with activity both in its release and receptor signaling, but may modulate rather than mediate the retrograde signaling. AA promotes growth and stabilization of synaptic terminals by tapping into a pre-existing axonal growth-promoting pathway that is utilized by L1, NCAM, N-cadherin, and FGF and acts via PKC, GAP43, and F-actin stabilization, and it shares some overlap with BDNF pathways. The actions of both are consistent with recent demonstrations that activity-driven stabilization includes directed growth of new synaptic contacts. Certain nondiffusible factors (synapse-specific CAMs, ephrins, neurexin/neuroligin, and matrix molecules) may also play a role in activity-driven synapse stabilization. Interactions between these pathways are discussed.

Presynaptic protein kinase C controls maturation and branch dynamics of developing retinotectal arbors: possible role in activity-driven sharpening

Visual activity refines developing retinotectal maps and shapes individual retinal arbors via an NMDA receptor-dependent mechanism. As retinal axons grow into tectum, they slow markedly and emit many transient side branches behind the tip, assuming a "bottlebrush" morphology. Some branches are stabilized and branch further, giving rise to a compact arbor. The dynamic rate of branch addition and deletion is increased twofold when MK801 is used to block NMDA receptors, as if this prevents release of a stabilizing signal such as arachidonic acid (AA) from the postsynaptic neuron. In optic tract, AA mediates NCAM and L1 stimulation of axon growth by activating presynaptic protein kinase C (PKC) to phosphorylate GAP-43 and stabilize F-actin, and, if present in tectum, this growth control pathway could be modulated by postsynaptic activation. To test for the effects on arbor morphology of blocking PKC or AA release, we examined DiO-labeled retinal axons of larval zebrafish with time-lapse videomicroscopy. Bath application of the selective PKC inhibitor bisindolylmaleimide from 2 or 3 days onward doubled the rate at which side branches were added and deleted, as seen with MK801, and also prevented maturation of the arbor so that it retained a "bottlebrush" morphology. In order to selectively block the PKC being transported to retinal terminals, we injected the irreversible inhibitor calphostin C into the eye from which the ganglion cells were labeled, and this produced both effects seen with bath application. In contrast, there were no effects of control injections, which included Ringers into the same eye and the same dose into the opposite eye (actually much closer to the tectum of interest), to rule out the possibility that the inhibitor leaked from the eye to act on tectal cells. For comparison, we examined arbors treated with the NMDA blocker MK801 at half-hour time-lapse intervals, and detected the twofold rise in rates of branch addition and deletion previously reported in Xenopus larvae, but not the structural effect seen with the PKC inhibitors. In addition, we could produce both effects seen with PKC inhibitors by using RHC80267 to block AA release from DAG lipase, indicating that AA is the main drive for PKC activation. Thus, the results show a distinct role of AA and presynaptic PKC in both maturation of arbor structure and in the dynamic control of branching. The effects on branch dynamics were present regardless of the level of maturity of arbor structure. The fact that they mimicked those of MK801 suggests that presynaptic PKC may be involved in the NMDA receptor-driven stabilization of developing retinal arbors.

N-methyl-D-aspartate-induced alpha-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazoleproprionic acid (AMPA) receptor down-regulation involves interaction of the carboxyl terminus of GluR2/3 with Pick1. Ligand-binding studies using Sindbis vectors carrying AMPA receptor decoys

The dynamics of alpha-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazoleproprionic acid (AMPA)-type glutamate receptors, as represented by their exocytosis, endocytosis and cytoskeletal linkage, has often been implicated in N-methyl-d-aspartate (NMDA)-dependent synaptic plasticity. To explore the molecular mechanisms underlying the AMPA receptor dynamics, cultured hippocampal neurons were stimulated with 100 microm NMDA, and the biochemical and pharmacological changes in the ligand binding activity of AMPA receptor complexes and its subunits, GluR1 and GluR2/3, were investigated. The NMDA treatment reduced the total amount of bound [(3)H]AMPA on the surface of the neurons but not in their total membrane fraction. This process was mimicked by a protein kinase C activator, phorbol ester, but blocked by an inhibitor of the same kinase, calphostin C. The NMDA-induced down-regulation of the ligand binding activity was also reflected by the decreased AMPA-triggered channel activity as well as by the cells' reduced immunoreactivity for GluR1. In parallel, the NMDA treatment markedly altered the interaction between the AMPA receptor subunits and their associating molecule(s); the association of PDZ molecules, including Pick1, with GluR2/3 was enhanced in a protein-kinase-C-dependent manner. Viral expression vectors carrying GluR1 and GluR2 C-terminal decoys, both fused to enhanced green fluorescent protein, were transfected into hippocampal neurons to disrupt their interactions. The overexpression of the C-terminal decoy for GluR2 specifically and significantly blocked the NMDA-triggered reduction in [(3)H]AMPA binding, whereas that for GluR1 had no effects. Co-immunoprecipitation using anti-Pick1 antibodies revealed that the overexpressed GluR2 C-terminal decoy indeed prevented Pick1 from interacting with the endogenous GluR2/3. Therefore, these observations suggest that the NMDA-induced down-regulation of the functional AMPA receptors involves the interaction between GluR2/3 subunits and Pick1.

Subcommissural organ-Reissner's fiber complex of the teleost Clarias batrachus responds to GABA treatment

Subcommissural organ (SCO) is a highly specialized ependymal gland located in the roof of the third ventricle. The secretory products of the SCO, which condense to form Reissner's fiber (RF), were recently found to cross-react with the anti-calcitonin antibody. To understand the mechanisms regulating the formation of the RF and the possible function of these discrete structures, we studied the response of the SCO-RF complex to intracranially administered GABA, using immunocytochemical labeling with anti-calcitonin antibody. Although the SCO-RF complex of control fish was intensely immunostained, 1 h after GABA treatment, the ependymal cells revealed partial loss of immunoreactivity; the RF showed occasional loss of immunoreactivity with its diameter increased by about 56% of the control value. Following 2 h of GABA treatment, the SCO revealed dramatic loss of calcitonin-like immunoreactivity from the ependymal cells. The RF showed a dual response in this group, while in some segments the RF appeared conspicuously thick, elsewhere it appeared thin. The mean diameter was, however, not significantly different from the normal. Following 4 h of GABA treatment, while calcitonin-like immunoreactive material made its reappearance in the SCO, the RF diameter was uniformly reduced to about 35% of the control value. The responses by the RF as well as the SCO to intracranially administered GABA were blocked by pretreatment with bicuculline, a GABA(A) receptor antagonist. The results suggest that GABA, acting via GABA(A) receptors, may trigger the release of secretory material from the SCO and induce histomorphological changes in the RF indicative of discharge of stored material.

Up-regulation of protein kinase C in regenerating optic nerve fibers of goldfish: immunohistochemistry and kinase activity assay

Protein kinase C (PKC) activation has been associated with synaptic plasticity in many projections, and manipulating PKC in the retinotectal projection strongly affects the activity-driven sharpening of the retinotopic map. This study examined levels of PKC in the regenerating retinotectal projection via immunostaining and assay of activity. A polyclonal antibody to the conserved C2 (Ca2+ binding) domain of classical PKC isozymes (anti-panPKC) recognized a single band at 79-80 kD on Western blots of goldfish brain. It stained one class of retinal bipolar cells and the ganglion cells in normal retina, as shown previously. Strong staining was not present in the optic fiber layer of retina or in optic nerve, optic tract, or terminal zone in tectum, with the exception of a single fascicle of optic nerve fibers that by their location and by L1 (E587) staining were identified as those arising from newly added ganglion cells at the retinal margin. Normal tectal sections showed dark staining of a subclass of type XIV neuron with somas at the top of the periventricular layer and an apical dendrite ascending to stratum opticum. In regenerating retina, swollen ganglion cells stained darkly and stained axons were seen in the optic fiber layer. In regenerating optic nerve (2-11 weeks postcrush), all fascicles of optic fibers stained darkly for both PKC and L1(E587). At 5 weeks postcrush, PKC staining could also be seen in the medial and lateral optic tracts and stratum opticum at the front half of the tectum and very lightly over the terminal zones. PKC activity was measured in homogenized tissues dissected from a series of fish with unilateral nerve crush from 1 to 5 weeks previously. Activity levels stimulated by phorbols and Ca2+ were measured by phosphorylation of a specific peptide and referred to levels measured in the opposite control side. Regeneration did not increase overall PKC activity in retina or tectum, but in optic nerve there was an 80% rise after the first week. The increased activity verifies that the increased staining in nerve represented an up-regulation of functional PKC during nerve regeneration.

Taurine-stimulated outgrowth from the retina is impaired by protein kinase C activators and phosphatase inhibitors

Taurine increases neurite elongation of post-crush goldfish retinal explants, as well as the number of outgrowing isolated cells from goldfish and rat retina in culture. The trophic effect of taurine is related to an elevation in calcium flux rather than increased cell proliferation. Since taurine regulates phosphorylation in rat retina, we investigated if this process could be involved in the mechanism of taurine action on outgrowth. Control and taurine-supplemented post-crush goldfish retinal explants were cultured in the presence of protein kinase C activators or phosphatase inhibitors, and the length of neurites was measured after five days in culture. In some cases, there was an inhibition of the stimulatory effect of taurine without a modification in basal outgrowth. In others, outgrowth of control explants was also reduced. A certain level of protein phosphorylation seems to be critical for the trophic effect of taurine in the retina.

The contribution of protein kinases to plastic events in the superior colliculus

1. The superior colliculus (SC)/optic tectum is a multi-layered midbrain area that harbours representations of visual and auditory space and somatic body surface. The development and maintenance of these sensory maps has been shown to involve activity and experience-dependent mechanisms. 2. The implantation of an extra eye primordium into the developing forebrain of Rana pipens results in the formation of dually innervated tecta that would have normally be solely innervated by the contralateral retina. The retinal projections are arranged in an interdigitating pattern of alternate stripes of terminations from each retina. The establishment of this striped pattern requires retinal activity and depends on N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptors. Manipulation of protein kinase activity leads to the formation of an abnormal stripe pattern. 3. Regeneration of the goldfish retinotectal projection, following crush of the optic nerve, occurs in an activity dependent manner involving NMDA receptors. Furthermore, a critical period exists, during which retinal activity is vital for reformation of the visual map. Protein kinase manipulations during this period disrupt normal reformation. The same manoeuvres at other time points have little effect on map reformation. 4. An unusual form of long-term potentiation (SC-LTP) has been demonstrated in the in vitro preparation of the guinea-pig SC. By stimulating the optic layer of the SC, a postsynaptic potentiation can be recorded in the superficial grey layer. The expression of SC-LTP is masked but not prevented by blockade of NMDA receptors. The role of protein kinases in this form of synaptic modification has also been studied using various manipulations and inhibitors with varying substrate specificity. Whereas H7, an inhibitor reputed to be protein kinase C specific, only masks the expression of SC-LTP, K252a which has a broad substrate specificity blocks the induction of SC-LTP. 5. Experience-dependent formation of the auditory space map in the deeper layers of the SC is believed to be under the instruction of the visual representation in the superficial layers. Furthermore, a crucial period exists during which normal auditory and visual experience are required for successful establishment of the auditory map. Chronic exposure to 5-aminophosphonopentanoic acid (AP5) during this time prevents the formation of the map. Chronic exposure to K252a, a broad kinase inhibitor, over the same time period, also disrupts the formation of the auditory space map. 6. Taken together, these models emphasise the role of protein kinases in synaptic plasticity observed in the SC. Furthermore, interference with protein kinase activity at crucial stages of regeneration or development appears to disrupt the sequence of events that lead to the consolidation of SC receptive fields.

Spinocerebellar mossy fiber terminal topography in the NR2C/PKC gamma double mutant cerebellum

The spatiotemporal expression patterns of the NR2C subunit of the NMDA receptor and PKC gamma isoform during cerebellar development suggests that both proteins are involved in the molecular mechanisms of synaptogenesis. However, the topographic distribution of WGA-HRP labeled spinocerebellar mossy fiber terminals in NR2C/PKC gamma double mutants (n = 4) appears similar to controls (n = 3). While the results do not rule out a role for NR2C receptor subunits and the PKC gamma isoform in cerebellar synaptogenesis, they indicate that neither is necessary for the formation or maintenance of normal spinocerebellar mossy fiber afferent maps.

Rapid activity-dependent sprouting of optic fibers into a local area denervated by application of beta-bungarotoxin in goldfish tectum

The retinotectal projection is known to be capable of extensive long-term expansion of connections, but it is not known how fast such changes can occur or what triggers sprouting of terminals. We studied sprouting of optic fibers into an area denervated by local microinjection of beta-bungarotoxin (beta-BTX), a specific presynaptic neurotoxin with phospholipase A2 activity that destroys nerve terminals at the neuromuscular junction. After injection of 0.1 pmol of beta-BTX, the optic terminals fired spontaneously with decreasing amplitude and became silent within 1 to 2 h. Outside the injection zone, the retinotectal map was normal, so the silent zone was associated with a scotoma in the visual field. Horseradish peroxidase (HRP) staining of the entire optic nerve showed a denervated region at the injection site with beaded, degenerating fibers at its edge. Between 3 and 9 days later, optic units were recorded within the injection zone whose receptive fields lay just outside the scotoma in the visual field, indicating that intact surrounding terminals had sprouted into the area. These sprouts made functional connections, as indicated by field potential recordings and current source-density analysis. At this time, HRP staining also demonstrated retinal innervation within the injection zone. By 12 days, normal maps with no scotoma were recorded and HRP staining was normal at the injection site, indicating that the beta-BTX-damaged fibers had regenerated to reclaim their tectal sites. The results show that the retinotectal projection of goldfish is very dynamic, since intact optic fibers can sprout into adjacent vacant postsynaptic territory within 2 to 3 days, much faster than previously reported. In a final experiment, we showed that this sprouting is activity-dependent, since it could be prevented by blocking retinal activity with intraocular tetrodotoxin (TTX) during the first 2 days postinjection, even though TTX block of activity does not block regeneration in this system. One possible mechanism for this rapidly triggered sprouting is that arachidonic acid liberated by beta-BTX acts as a sprouting factor to attract surrounding healthy fibers into the denervated region but requires activity at the terminals to be effective.

The modulatory cholinergic system in goldfish tectum may be necessary for retinotopic sharpening

The cholinergic circuit within the tectum and the cholinergic input from the nucleus isthmi mediate a presynaptic augmentation of retinotectal transmitter release via nicotinic receptors. In this study, the cholinergic systems were either eliminated using the cholinergic neurotoxin AF64A or blocked using nicotinic antagonists to test for effects on the activity-driven sharpening of the regenerating retinotectal projection. The effectiveness of the AF64A was verified by recording field potentials elicited by optic tract stimulation and by immunohistochemical staining for choline acetyltransferase (ChAT). At 1 week after intracranial (IC) injection of AF64A (12 to 144 nmoles) into the fluid above the tectum, field potentials showed a selective dose-dependent decrement of the cholinergic polysynaptic component with no effect on the amplitude of the glutamatergic monosynaptic component. The decrement was only partially recovered in recordings at 2 and 6 weeks. In normal fish, the ChAT antibody stains a population of periventricular neurons, their apical dendrites, and a dense plexus within the optic terminal lamina that consists of their local axons and fine dendrites and of input fibers from the nucleus isthmi. One week after IC AF64A injection (48-72 nmoles), most immunostaining in superficial tectum was lost but most neuronal somas in the deep tectum could still be seen, and staining in the tegmentum below the tectum was completely intact. At 2 weeks and later, the staining of neuronal somata largely recovered, but staining of the superficial plexus did not. AF64A treatment at 18 days after nerve crush, when regenerating retinal fibers are beginning to form synapses, prevented retinotopic sharpening of the projection. Recordings showed a rough retinotopic map on the tectum but the multiunit receptive fields (MURFs) at each tectal point averaged 34 deg vs. 11 deg in vehicle-injected control regenerates. AF64A treatment before nerve crush also blocked sharpening, ruling out a direct effect on retinal growth cones or retinal fibers, as AF64A rapidly decomposes, whereas its effect on the cholinergic fibers is long-lasting. IC injection or minipump infusion of the nicotine antagonists alpha-bungarotoxin (alpha BTX), neuronal bungarotoxin (nBTX), and pancuronium during regeneration also prevented sharpening (MURFs averaging 29.4 deg, 33.0 deg, and 31.4 deg, respectively). Control Ringer's solution infusions or injections over the same period (19-37 days postcrush) had no effect on regenerated MURF size (11.7 deg). The results show that the cholinergic innervation, which modulates transmitter release, is required for activity-driven retinotopic sharpening, thought to be triggered by NMDA receptor activation.