Recent Advances in Effect-directed Enzyme Assays based on Thin-layer Chromatography

A simple thin-layer chromatography autography for the detection of peroxidase inhibitors

Thin layer chromatography bioautographic assays facilitate the acquisition of activity-profile chromatograms and assist in pinpointing active constituents within complex mixtures by observing the inhibition halos they produce. Peroxidase is an enzyme implicated in the browning of different fresh cut vegetables and in several diseases. A peroxidase bioautographic assay was developed, based on enzyme agarose immobilization and the 2,2'-Azino-bis(3-ethylbenzothiazoline-6-sulfonic acid) diammonium salt/radical cation (ABTS/ABTS·+) reporter system. Peroxidase was purified from potatoes with the aim to detect specific inhibitors. To reduce false positives, a non-enzymatic assay was also employed. The best results are obtained when a solution containing agarose, ABTS, hydrogen peroxide, and peroxidase in phosphate buffer is poured over the TLC plate (final concentrations: 0.031 mmoles/cm2, 0.239 µmoles/cm2, and 84.04 U/cm2) and incubated for 70 min. Limit of detection and quantification for quercetin is 0.16 µg and 0.54 µg, respectively. The developed system is able to detect quercetin in a Solidago chilensis Meyen extract and a peroxidase inhibitor in a Cichorium intybus L. extract. Therefore, the assay can detect inhibitory constituents in complex mixtures and differentiate between peroxidase inhibitors and ABTS·+ radical scavengers before any preparative fractionation, helping to take early operational decisions that can save time and resources.

Graphical abstract

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s13197-024-05946-w.

Progress, applications, and challenges in high-throughput effect-directed analysis for toxicity driver identification - is it time for HT-EDA?

The rapid increase in the production and global use of chemicals and their mixtures has raised concerns about their potential impact on human and environmental health. With advances in analytical techniques, in particular, high-resolution mass spectrometry (HRMS), thousands of compounds and transformation products with potential adverse effects can now be detected in environmental samples. However, identifying and prioritizing the toxicity drivers among these compounds remain a significant challenge. Effect-directed analysis (EDA) emerged as an important tool to address this challenge, combining biotesting, sample fractionation, and chemical analysis to unravel toxicity drivers in complex mixtures. Traditional EDA workflows are labor-intensive and time-consuming, hindering large-scale applications. The concept of high-throughput (HT) EDA has recently gained traction as a means of accelerating these workflows. Key features of HT-EDA include the combination of microfractionation and downscaled bioassays, automation of sample preparation and biotesting, and efficient data processing workflows supported by novel computational tools. In addition to microplate-based fractionation, high-performance thin-layer chromatography (HPTLC) offers an interesting alternative to HPLC in HT-EDA. This review provides an updated perspective on the state-of-the-art in HT-EDA, and novel methods/tools that can be incorporated into HT-EDA workflows. It also discusses recent studies on HT-EDA, HT bioassays, and computational prioritization tools, along with considerations regarding HPTLC. By identifying current gaps in HT-EDA and proposing new approaches to overcome them, this review aims to bring HT-EDA a step closer to monitoring applications.

Reversible polarity-switch of thin-layer chromatography by photo-induction with multi-regulation in spatial dimension

Generally, thin-layer chromatography always undertakes the indispensable role in rapid screening and identification of specific compounds. Stationary phase is the core part of thin-layer chromatography with fixed property, which leading to the limitations of separation mode of only regulating the composition of mobile phase. This work was an attempt to fabricate the unique photosensitive thin-layer chromatography to make up the above major drawback. 4-[3-(Triethoxysilyl)propoxy]azobenzene (azo-PTES) was synthesized as photosensitive modifier to fabricate the photosensitive stationary phase, and the transformation of cis-trans structure of azo-PTES proceeds along with polarity difference under 365 nm and 473 nm irradiation. Based on this, the proposed photosensitive thin-layer chromatography shows the reversible switch of polarity of stationary phase by photoinduction, followed by the deserved reversible separation behavior. Furthermore, multi-regulation in spatial dimension was achieved based on the high freedom of spatial regulation of photoinduction, which brings about the integration of stationary phase with different polarity, just by photoinduction. The concept of photosensitive thin-layer chromatography provides new idea for improving separation efficiency and developing multi-dimensional thin-layer chromatography on the one plate.

Application of effect-directed analysis using TLC-bioautography for rapid isolation and identification of antidiabetic compounds from the leaves of Annona cherimola Mill

INTRODUCTION

Type 2 diabetes mellitus is a globally prevalent chronic disease characterised by hyperglycaemia and oxidative stress. The search for new natural bioactive compounds that contribute to controlling this condition and the application of analytical methodologies that facilitate rapid detection and identification are important challenges for science. Annona cherimola Mill. is an important source of aporphine alkaloids with many bioactivities.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study is to isolate and identify antidiabetic compounds from alkaloid extracts with α-glucosidase and α-amylase inhibitory activity from A. cherimola Mill. leaves using an effect-directed analysis by thin-layer chromatography (TLC)-bioautography.

METHODOLOGY

Guided fractionation for α-glucosidase and α-amylase inhibitors in leaf extracts was done using TLC-bioassays. The micro-preparative TLC was used to isolate the active compounds, and the identification was performed by mass spectrometry associated with web-based molecular networks. Additionally, in vitro estimation of the inhibitory activity and antioxidant capacity was performed in the isolated compounds.

RESULTS

Five alkaloids (liriodenine, dicentrinone, N-methylnuciferine, anonaine, and moupinamide) and two non-alkaloid compounds (3-methoxybenzenepropanoic acid and methylferulate) with inhibitory activity were isolated and identified using a combination of simple methodologies. Anonaine, moupinamide, and methylferulate showed promising results with an outstanding inhibitory activity against both enzymes and antioxidant capacity that could contribute to controlling redox imbalance.

CONCLUSIONS

These high-throughput methodologies enabled a rapid isolation and identification of seven compounds with potential antidiabetic activity. To our knowledge, the estimated inhibitory activity of dicentrinone, N-methylnuciferine, and anonaine against α-glucosidase and α-amylase is reported here for the first time.

Planar chromatography - Current practice and future prospects

Planar chromatography, in the form of thin-layer or high-performance thin-layer chromatography (TLC, HPTLC), continues to provide a robust and widely used separation technique. It is unrivaled as a simple and rapid qualitative method for mixture analysis, or for finding bioactive components in mixtures. The format of TLC/HPTLC also provides a unique method for preserving the separation, enabling further investigation of components of interest (including quantification/structure determination) separated in both time and space from the original analysis. The current practice of planar chromatography and areas of development of the technology are reviewed and promising future directions in the use of TLC/HPTLC are outlined.

Effect-directed analysis in food by thin-layer chromatography assays

Thin-layer chromatography (TLC) is widely used for food analysis and quality control. As an open chromatographic system, TLC is compatible with microbial-, biochemical-, and chemical-based derivatization methods. This compatibility makes it possible to run in situ bioassays directly on the plate to obtain activity-profile chromatograms, i.e., the effect-directed analysis of the sample. Many of the properties that can be currently measured using this assay format are related to either desired or undesired features for food related products. The TLC assays can detect compounds related to the stability of foods (antioxidant, antimicrobial, antibrowning, etc.), contaminants (antibiotics, pesticides, estrogenic compounds, etc.), and compounds that affect the absorption, metabolism or excretion of nutrients and metabolites or could improve the consumers health (enzyme inhibitors). In this article, different food related TLC-assays are reviewed. The different detection systems used, the way in which they are applied as well as selected examples are discussed.

Establishment of Quality Control Standard and Efficacy Evaluation of Zhiqingshu Lotion Compound Preparation

OBJECTIVE

To establish the quality standard of Zhiqingshu lotion by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC).

METHODS

HPLC was used to determine emodin, chrysophanol, caffeic acid, and berberine hydrochloride content, key water-soluble components of rhubarb, dandelion, and Phellodendron amurense in Zhiqingshu lotion. The macrophage inflammation model was used to analyze the anti-inflammatory effects of Zhiqingshu lotion.

RESULTS

HPLC results showed that the contents of emodin, chrysophanol, caffeic acid, and berberine hydrochloride in Zhiqingshu lotion were 7.93 ± 2.25, 20.85 ± 4.27, 48.9 ± 6.79, and 58.4 ± 10.3 μg/mL, respectively. Moreover, RT-qPCR results showed that different concentrations of Zhiqingshu lotion significantly reduced the expression of inflammatory factor tumor necrosis factor- (TNF-) α and interleukin- (IL-) 1β in lipopolysaccharide-induced macrophages.

CONCLUSION

HPLC could quantitatively and qualitatively analyze and identify the main components of Zhiqingshu lotion as rhodopsin, rhodopsin, caffeic acid, and berberine hydrochloride. And Zhiqingshu lotion has an excellent anti-inflammatory effect. This method was simple and reliable and could be used for the identification of the ingredients and content of Zhiqingshu lotion, thus improving the quality control of the drug.

Development of a validated HPTLC-bioautographic method for evaluation of aromatase inhibitory activity of plant extracts and their constituents

INTRODUCTION

Aromatase is a CYP450 enzyme that catalyses the conversion of androgens into oestrogens, where the decrease in the production of oestrogens aided by aromatase inhibitors is considered a target in post-menopausal breast cancer therapy. TLC-bioautography is a technique employed for combining chromatographic separations on TLC plates with bioassays. This is the first report to evaluate aromatase inhibitory activity using this technique.

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study is to develop and validate a new TLC-bioautographic method for determination of aromatase inhibitory activity in 14 plant extracts. Two quantitation methods, the peak area method and reciprocal iso-inhibition volume (RIV) method, were compared and investigated to attain reliable results. Factors affecting the enzymatic reaction (temperature, pH, enzyme and substrate concentrations … etc.) were also investigated to attain the optimum parameters.

METHODOLOGY

TLC assisted by digital image processing was implemented for quantitative estimation of the aromatase inhibition of 14 plant extracts using chrysin as positive control. The fluorometric substrate dibenzyl fluorescein (DBF) was utilised for the assay, where inhibitory compounds were visualised as dark spots against a blue fluorescent background. Two software programs, Sorbfil® videodensitometer (in the peak area method) and ImageJ® (in the RIV method), were thoroughly validated using the International Council on Harmonisation (ICH) guideline and used for quantitation.

RESULTS

The RIV method showed superiority over the peak area method in the quantitation results of the tracks with non-homogenous background with %RSD values of 0.98 and 1.49 compared with 2.86 and 3.58, respectively. Further, the methods allow the comparison of the activity of different unknown inhibitory compounds without the need for a reference or a positive control.

CONCLUSION

Using the TLC-bioautographic method by image processing combined with the RIV quantitation method, simultaneous separation and quantitation of aromatase inhibitory components could be applied to estimate the relative activity of various plant extracts.

Recent advance in the discovery of tyrosinase inhibitors from natural sources via separation methods

Tyrosinase (TYR) inhibitors are in great demand in the food, cosmetic and medical industrials due to their important roles. Therefore, the discovery of high-quality TYR inhibitors is always pursued. Natural products as one of the most important sources of bioactive compounds discovery have been increasingly used for TYR inhibitors screening. However, due to their complex compositions, it is still a great challenge to rapid screening and identification of biologically active components from them. In recent years, with the help of separation technologies and the affinity and intrinsic activity of target enzymes, two advanced approaches including affinity screening and inhibition profiling showed great promises for a successful screening of bioactive compounds from natural sources. This review summarises the recent progress of separation-based methods for TYR inhibitors screening, with an emphasis on the principle, application, advantage, and drawback of each method along with perspectives in the future development of these screening techniques and screened hit compounds.

An Evolving Technology That Integrates Classical Methods with Continuous Technological Developments: Thin-Layer Chromatography Bioautography

Thin-layer chromatography (TLC) bioautography is an evolving technology that integrates the separation and analysis technology of TLC with biological activity detection technology, which has shown a steep rise in popularity over the past few decades. It connects TLC with convenient, economic and intuitive features and bioautography with high levels of sensitivity and specificity. In this study, we discuss the research progress of TLC bioautography and then establish a definite timeline to introduce it. This review summarizes known TLC bioautography types and practical applications for determining antibacterial, antifungal, antitumor and antioxidant compounds and for inhibiting glucosidase, pancreatic lipase, tyrosinase and cholinesterase activity constitutes. Nowadays, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic, it is important to identify original, natural products with anti-COVID potential compounds from Chinese traditional medicine and natural medicinal plants. We also give an account of detection techniques, including in situ and ex situ techniques; even in situ ion sources represent a major reform. Considering the current technical innovations, we propose that the technology will make more progress in TLC plates with higher separation and detection technology with a more portable and extensive scope of application. We believe this technology will be diffusely applied in medicine, biology, agriculture, animal husbandry, garden forestry, environmental management and other fields in the future.

Studies on the Polyphenolic Composition and the Antioxidant Properties of the Leaves of Poplar (Populus spp.) Various Species and Hybrids

The chemical composition in terms of flavonoid and salicylic compounds of leaves from 6 species and 3 hybrids of poplars (Populus) was identified with the use of TLC and HPLC-DAD/ESI-MS methods. Chromatographic analyses were carried out with 21 standard compounds including salicylic compounds (2), phenolic acids (3) and flavonoids (16). Moreover, on the basis of the obtained chromatographic data from the HPLC-DAD/ESI-MS and TLC separations, the presence of salicortin, tremulacin and chlorogenic acid was confirmed, depending on the analyzed poplar species or hybrid. The content of salicylic compounds was determined by HPLC-UV method and expressed on salicin as free and total fraction. Total flavonoid content was determined by spectroscopic method as quercetin equivalent. Significant qualitative and quantitative differences in the chemical composition of the analyzed leaves were demonstrated. The highest concentration of flavonoids (8.02 mg/g) was found in the leaves of Populus nigra, while the highest content of salicylic compounds (47.14 mg/g) was found in the leaves of P.×berolinensis. The antioxidant and xanthine oxidase inhibition properties of extracts from poplar leaves were investigated by TLC bioautography. It has been shown that the richest set of compounds with antioxidant properties are present in the leaves of P. alba, P.×candicans and P. nigra.

Development of chromatographic technologies for the quality control of Traditional Chinese Medicine in the Chinese Pharmacopoeia

As an important branch of medicine, Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) has been applied for the treatment of diseases for thousands of years in China and other countries in East Asia. The Chinese Pharmacopoeia (ChP) is a drug code formulated by the Chinese government, and it includes a special volume for the monographs of TCM, which plays an important role in ensuring the quality of drugs. The use of quality control technology has always been a complex and important factor in TCM. Owing to the chemical diversity of TCM, chromatography technology has been proven to be a comprehensive strategy for the assessment of the overall quality of TCM and has become the main analytical method in the ChP. This article provides an overview of the classical and modern chromatographic technologies applied in the ChP, and summarizes the advantages and disadvantages of each technique in the TCM monographs. In 2020, the new edition of the ChP (the 2020 edition) has been implemented at the end of 2020. This paper also contains a brief introduction about the application of chromatographic technologies in the new edition of the ChP.

•

An overview of the classical and modern chromatographic technologies applied in the ChP.

•

A discussion of the reason why each chromatographic technologies was chosen in the quality control of TCM.

•

Introduction of the chromatographic technologies applied in the 2020 edition of ChP.

TLC-MS Bioautography-Based Identification of Free-Radical Scavenging, α-Amylase, and α-Glucosidase Inhibitor Compounds of Antidiabetic Tablet BGR-34

BGR-34 is a polyherbal formulation frequently used to combat diabetes around the globe especially in Asian countries. It provides an attractive treatment option to prediabetics, diabetics, and in metabolic disorders by controlling the altered blood glucose level. The lack of phytopharmacological studies on BGR-34 prompted as to reveal the compounds responsible for the antidiabetic and free-radical scavenging activity of BGR-34. An attempt was made to assess in vitro α-amylase and α-glucosidase enzyme inhibition of BGR-34 along with its free-radical scavenging potential via DPPH scavenging activity. Further, HPTLC profiling and quantitative analysis of berberine and palmatine in BGR-34 were carried out. Thereafter, the TLC-bioautographic-MS analysis was performed to identify the compounds responsible for antidiabetic and antioxidant activities in BGR-34. The results had shown a significant and dose-dependent inhibition potential of BGR-34 against in vitro α-amylase and α-glucosidase enzymatic reactions along with significant inhibition in DPPH free-radical scavenging activity. The HPTLC profiling and quantitative validation studies showed the presence of berberine and palmatine 44.926 ± 0.2907 and 10.507 ± 0.154 μg/g, respectively. The TLC-MS bioautography revealed a total of four DPPH-active, two α-amylase-active, and nine α-glucosidase-active compounds in BGR-34. It was observed from the study that BGR-34 possesses verities of bioactive compounds, which are reasonable not only for its antidiabetic effect but also for its antioxidant activity.

Development of a thin-layer chromatography bioautographic assay for neuraminidase inhibitors hyphenated with electrostatic field induced spray ionisation-mass spectrometry for identification of active Isatis indigotica root compounds

The identification of neuraminidase inhibitors from natural products is a promising strategy in the field of anti-influenza research. In this study, a new thin-layer chromatography (TLC) bioautographic assay for the screening of neuraminidase inhibitors from natural products was developed. This TLC bioassay is based on the one-step reaction of neuraminidase with the sodium salt of 5‑bromo‑4‑chloro‑3-indolyl-α-d-N-acetylneuraminic acid (substrate) and the subsequent formation of blue coloured products. Neuraminidase inhibitory activity was shown by the development of white spots against the blue TLC background. The key factors affecting the assay (such as enzyme concentration, substrate concentration, incubation time, reaction time, and pH) were investigated and optimised by a combination of a one-factor-at-a-time design and a Box-Behnken design/response surface method. The developed TLC bioautographic method was applied to identify neuraminidase inhibitory compounds in the roots of Isatis indigotica. Eleven active compounds including six alkaloids, three lignans, one sterol, and one fatty acid were identified in situ by direct coupling with an electrostatic field induced spray ionisation-mass spectrometry approach through analysis of their MSⁿ (n = 4) data or comparison with reference substances. The developed TLC bioautographic assay is simple, rapid, and efficient for screening potential neuraminidase inhibitors from natural products.

Effect directed synthesis of a new tyrosinase inhibitor with anti-browning activity

The inhibition of enzymatic browning is an attractive target to elevate the quality of foods. The objective of this work is to describe a novel platform for the discovery of tyrosinase inhibitors, based on (a) one-pot preparation of a library of thiosemicarbazide compounds, (b) biological evaluation using tyrosinase TLC bioautography, (c) inhibitor identification via mass spectrometry coupled to bioautography. During these proof-of-concept experiments, the approach led to the straightforward identification of a new thiosemicarbazone with improved tyrosinase inhibition properties and fresh-cut apple slices antibrowning effect when compared to kojic acid. In conclusion, the platform represents an interesting strategy for the discovery of this type of inhibitors.

New planar assay for streamlined detection and quantification of β-glucuronidase inhibitors applied to botanical extracts

The inhibition of the β-glucuronidase released from gut bacteria is associated with specific health-related benefits. Though a number of β-glucuronidase inhibition assays are currently in use, none of them can directly measure the relevant activity of each single constituent in a complex mixture, without prior separation and tedious isolation of the pure compounds. Thus, the hyphenation of the high performance thin layer chromatography (HPTLC) technique with a β-glucuronidase inhibition assay was investigated and successfully demonstrated for the first time. A colorimetric as well as fluorometric detection of the inhibitors was achieved using 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl-β-D-glucuronide as a substrate. Hence, β-glucuronidase inhibitors were detected as bright zones against an indigo blue or fluorescent background. The established method was optimized and validated employing the well-known inhibitor d-saccharic acid 1,4-lactone monohydrate. As proof of concept, the suitability of the new workflow was verified through analysis of two botanical extracts, Primula boveana and silymarin flavonolignans from Silybum marianum fruits. The found inhibitors were identified by spectroscopic methods; one of them, 3ʹ-O-(β-galactopyranosyl)-flavone, is here described as a newly isolated natural compound. The new hyphenation HPTLC-UV/Vis/FLD-β-glucuronidase inhibition assay-HRMS covers four orthogonal dimensions, i.e. separation, spectral detection, biochemical activity and structural characterization, in a highly targeted time- and material-saving workflow for analysis of complex or costly mixtures.

•

Coupling of HPTLC to the β-glucuronidase inhibition assay is demonstrated.

•

Colorimetric and fluorometric detection of the inhibition was given.

•

A new β-glucuronidase inhibiting flavonoid in P. boveana was elucidated.

•

HPTLC-HRMS analysis of other β-glucuronidase inhibitors is shown for silymarin.

•

Analysis of rare plants (low extract amount) is possible with the new planar assay.

Enzymatic Bioautographic Methods

Enzymatic bioautography enables the detection of enzyme inhibitors absorbed on a thin-layer chromatography plate. Therefore, it is an assay format that is particularly useful for the detection of inhibitors present in complex mixtures. The inhibition properties of compounds separated by thin-layer chromatography can be directly analyzed to produce an inhibition profile. Here, we describe the conditions to detect inhibitor of the enzymes xanthine oxidase and β-glucosidase immobilized on agar gel.

A Tyrosinase Inhibitor from a Nitrogen-Enriched Chemically Engineered Extract

The enzyme tyrosinase is involved in the biosynthesis of melanin and the enzymatic browning of fruits and vegetables, and therefore, its inhibitors have potential to treat hyperpigmentary disorders or to function as food antibrowning agents. The use of hydrazine monohydrate as a reagent to prepare chemically engineered extracts can lead to semisynthetic compounds that contain the portion N-N, a fragment rarely found in natural products and present in some tyrosinase inhibitors. Here, we report the tyrosinase inhibition screening of a series of chemically engineered extracts that are diversified by reaction with hydrazine. LC-MS was used to evaluate the change in composition produced by the reaction. Bioguided fractionation of the most active chemically engineered extract, prepared from Matricaria recutita L., led to the discovery of a pyrazole that inhibits tyrosinase with an IC₅₀ value of 28.20 ± 1.13 μM. This compound was produced by a one-pot double chemical transformation of its natural precursor, which includes an unexpected selective removal of one -OH group.

Guided isolation of new iridoid glucosides from Anarrhinum pubescens by high-performance thin-layer chromatography-acetylcholinesterase assay

Plants are an important source of natural iridoids. This study demonstrates for the first time the acetylcholinesterase (AChE) inhibitory activity of iridoids belonging to the class of antirrhinosides. As iridoids distinguish the chemical composition of most species of the Plantaginaceae family, the active AChE inhibitors were investigated in the hydro-alcoholic extract of Anarrhinum pubescens Fresen. High-performance thin-layer chromatography (HPTLC) in combination with the AChE inhibition assay is a time and material saving methodology, and thus was employed to directly point to the individual enzyme inhibitors occurring in the plant. The effect-directed screening successfully discovered three active metabolites. These were characterized as antirrhinoside-derived iridoids. Two of these are here reported as newly isolated natural compounds. Identification of the two new metabolites was based on analysis of their collected spectroscopic data (HRMS, 1D and 2D NMR). Their structures were elucidated to be 6-O-, 6'-O-di-trans-cinnamoyl-antirrhinoside (1) and 5-O-, 6-O-difoliamenthoyl-antirrhinoside (3), while the previously known compound 6-O-foliamenthoyl-(6'-O-cinnamoyl)-antirrhinoside (2) was assigned by extensive analysis of its HRMS and HRMS/MS data. The activity of the isolated compounds was referred to the known AChE inhibitor rivastigmine, i.e. their activity were calculated and expressed as values equivalently to rivastigmine. This neuroprotective potential of iridoids mediated through AChE inhibition promote them to compete as natural curatives for neurodegenerative disorders like Alzheimer's disease.