Accuracy of three transcutaneous carbon dioxide monitors in critically ill children

Accuracy and Interpretation of Transcutaneous Carbon Dioxide Monitoring in Critically Ill Children

OBJECTIVES

Transcutaneous carbon dioxide (Tc co2 ) monitoring can noninvasively assess ventilation by estimating carbon dioxide ( CO2 ) levels in the blood. We aimed to evaluate the accuracy of Tc co2 monitoring in critically ill children by comparing it to the partial pressure of arterial carbon dioxide (Pa co2 ). In addition, we sought to determine the variation between Tc co2 and Pa co2 acceptable to clinicians to modify patient care and to determine which patient-level factors may affect the accuracy of Tc co2 measurements.

DESIGN

Retrospective observational cohort study.

SETTING

Single, quaternary care PICU from July 1, 2012, to August 1, 2020.

PATIENTS

Included participants were admitted to the PICU and received noninvasive ventilation support (i.e., continuous or bilevel positive airway pressure), conventional mechanical ventilation, or high-frequency oscillatory or percussive ventilation with Tc co2 measurements obtained within 15 minutes of Pa co2 measurement.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Three thousand four hundred seven paired arterial blood gas and Tc co2 measurements were obtained from 264 patients. Bland-Altman analysis revealed a bias of -4.4 mm Hg (95% CI, -27 to 18.3 mm Hg) for Tc co2 levels against Pa co2 levels on the first measurement pair for each patient, which fell within the acceptable range of ±5 mm Hg stated by surveyed clinicians, albeit with wide limits of agreement. The sensitivity and specificity of Tc co2 to diagnose hypercarbia were 93% and 71%, respectively. Vasoactive-Infusion Score (VIS), age, and self-identified Black/African American race confounded the relationship between Tc co2 with Pa co2 but percent fluid overload, weight-for-age, probe location, and severity of illness were not significantly associated with Tc co2 accuracy.

CONCLUSIONS

Tc co2 monitoring may be a useful adjunct to monitor ventilation in children with respiratory failure, but providers must be aware of the limitations to its accuracy.

Recent Technologies for Transcutaneous Oxygen and Carbon Dioxide Monitoring

The measurement of partial pressures of oxygen (O2) and carbon dioxide (CO2) is fundamental for evaluating a patient's conditions in clinical practice. There are many ways to retrieve O2/CO2 partial pressures and concentrations. Arterial blood gas (ABG) analysis is the gold standard technique for such a purpose, but it is invasive, intermittent, and potentially painful. Among all the alternative methods for gas monitoring, non-invasive transcutaneous O2 and CO2 monitoring has been emerging since the 1970s, being able to overcome the main drawbacks of ABG analysis. Clark and Severinghaus electrodes enabled the breakthrough for transcutaneous O2 and CO2 monitoring, respectively, and in the last twenty years, many innovations have been introduced as alternatives to overcome their limitations. This review reports the most recent solutions for transcutaneous O2 and CO2 monitoring, with a particular consideration for wearable measurement systems. Luminescence-based electronic paramagnetic resonance and photoacoustic sensors are investigated. Optical sensors appear to be the most promising, giving fast and accurate measurements without the need for frequent calibrations and being suitable for integration into wearable measurement systems.

Nocturnal Transcutaneous Blood Gas Measurements in a Pediatric Neurologic Population: A Quality Assessment

Objective: To assess the quality of SpO2 and PCO2 recordings via transcutaneous monitoring in children with neurological conditions.Methods: Overnight transcutaneous SpO2 and PCO2 were analyzed. The presence of drift and drift correction was noted, and the rate of disrupted recordings scored (0: absence, 1; presence). The quality of recordings was also scored (0, 1, 2 for poor, medium, and high).Results: A total of 228 recordings from 64 children aged 9.7 ± 6 years were analyzed of which 42 used positive pressure respiratory support. The mean quality of the recordings was scored as 1.27 (0-2). PCO2 drift, drift correction, and disrupted recordings were present in 25%, 58%, and 26% of recordings, respectively. Satisfactory clinical decisions were taken in 91% of cases.Conclusion: The quality of transcutaneous sensor recordings was acceptable and clinical findings were deemed as satisfactory in the large majority of cases. Correction of PCO2 drift was challenging.

Comparison of arterial CO2 estimation by end-tidal and transcutaneous CO2 measurements in intubated children and variability with subject related factors

Transcutaneous PCO₂ (P_TCCO₂) and end-tidal PCO₂ (P_ETCO₂) measurement methods serve as alternatives to arterial PCO₂ (PaCO₂), providing continuous non-invasive monitoring. The objective of this study was to evaluate the P_TCCO₂ and P_ETCO₂ methods with actual PaCO₂ levels, and to assess the variability of measurements in relation to subject-related factors, such as skin and subcutaneous adipose tissue thickness and presence of pulmonary diseases. P_TCCO₂, P_ETCO₂ and PaCO₂ were measured at the same time in intubated pediatric subjects. Subjects' demographic characteristics, clinical features, laboratory parameters, skin and subcutaneous adipose tissue thickness were identified. The study was carried out on 102 subjects with a total of 1118 values for each method. In patients with non-pulmonary disease, the mean difference between P_TCCO₂ and PaCO₂ was - 0.29 mmHg (± 6.05), while it was 0.44 mmHg (± 6.83) bias between P_ETCO₂ and PaCO₂. In those with pulmonary diseases, the mean difference between P_TCCO₂ and PaCO₂ was - 1.27 mmHg (± 8.32), while it was - 4.65 mmHg (± 9.01) between P_ETCO₂ and PaCO₂. Multiple linear regression demonstrated that increased subcutaneous adipose tissue thickness, core body temperature and inotropic index were related with higher P_TCCO₂ values relative to the actual PCO₂ values. Other factors, such as skin tissue thickness, presence of pulmonary disease, measurement location and measurement times were non-significant. The P_TCCO₂ method has higher reliability than the P_ETCO₂ method, and P_TCCO₂ measurements are not influenced by most subject-related factors; however, core body temperature, inotropic index and subcutaneous adipose tissue thickness can lead to significant differences in PCO₂ measurement.

Randomized clinical trial of high concentration versus titrated oxygen use in pediatric asthma

OBJECTIVE

To compare the effects of high concentration to titrated oxygen therapy (HCOT) on transcutaneous carbon dioxide (PtCO₂ ) level in pediatric asthma exacerbation. Titrated oxygen therapy (TOT) in acute asthma will avoid a rise in PtCO ₂ in the pediatric population.

METHOD

The study design is a prospective, randomized, clinical trial comparing HCOT (maintain SpO2 92-95%) while being treated for asthma exacerbation in the emergency department (ED).

INCLUSION CRITERIA

2 to 18 years, previously diagnosed asthma with acute exacerbation (asthma score >5). PtCO₂ and asthma scores were measured at 0, 20, 40, 60 minutes and then every 30 minutes until disposition decision. The primary outcome was a change in PtCO ₂ . Secondary outcomes were admission rate and change in asthma score.

RESULTS

A total of 96 patients were enrolled in the study with a mean age of 8.27 years; 49 in HCOT and 47 in the TOT group. The 0 minute PtCO₂ was similar (35.33 + 3.88 HCOT vs 36.66 + 4.69 TOT, P = 0.13); whereas, the 60 minutes PtCO ₂ was higher in the HCOT (38.08 + 5.11 HCOT vs 35.51 + 4.57 TOT, P = 0.01). The asthma score was similar at 0 minute (7.55 + 1.34 HCOT vs 7.30 + 1.18 TOT, P = 0.33); whereas, the 60 minutes asthma score was lower in the TOT (4.71 + 1.38 HCOT vs 3.57 + 1.25 TOT, P = 0.0001). The rate of admission to the hospital was 40.5% in HCOT vs 25.5% in the TOT (P = 0.088).

CONCLUSIONS

HCOT in pediatric asthma exacerbation leads to significantly higher carbon dioxide levels, which increases asthma scores and trends towards the increasing rate of admission. Larger studies are needed to explore this association.

End-tidal carbon dioxide measurement in preterm infants with low birth weight

Objective

There are conflicting data regarding the use of end-tidal carbon dioxide (PetCO₂) measurement in preterm infants. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of different dead space to tidal volume ratios (V_D/V_T) on the correlation between PetCO₂ and arterial carbon dioxide pressure (PaCO₂) in ventilated preterm infants with respiratory distress syndrome (RDS).

Methods

We enrolled ventilated preterm infants (with assist control mode or synchronous intermittent mandatory mode) with RDS who were treated with surfactant in this prospective study. Simultaneous PetCO₂ and PaCO₂ data pairs were obtained from ventilated neonates monitored using mainstream capnography. Data obtained before and after surfactant treatment were also analyzed.

Results

One-hundred and one PetCO₂ and PaCO₂ pairs from 34 neonates were analyzed. There was a moderate correlation between PetCO₂ and PaCO₂ values (r = 0.603, P < 0.01). The correlation was higher in the post-surfactant treatment group (r = 0.786, P < 0.01) than the pre-surfactant treatment group (r = 0.235). The values of PaCO₂ and PetCO₂ obtained based on the treatment stage of surfactant therapy were 42.4 ± 8.6 mmHg and 32.6 ± 7.2 mmHg, respectively, in pre-surfactant treatment group, and 37.8 ± 10.3 mmHg and 33.7 ± 9.3 mmHg, respectively, in the post-surfactant treatment group. Furthermore, we found a significant decrease in V_D/V_T in the post-surfactant treatment group when compared to the pre-surfactant treatment group (P = 0.003).

Conclusions

V_D/V_T decreased significantly after surfactant therapy and the correlation between PetCO₂ and PaCO₂ was higher after surfactant therapy in preterm infants with RDS.

Transcutaneous PCO2 monitoring in infants hospitalized with viral bronchiolitis

Our objective was to assess within a feasibility study the correlation and agreement of transcutaneous carbon dioxide (PtcCO2) monitoring with venous carbon dioxide (PvCO2) in infants with bronchiolitis in the emergency room (ER) and pediatric department. Sixty infants (aged 3.6 ± 3.3 months) admitted to our ER with bronchiolitis were included. PtcCO2 measurements (SenTec Digital Monitoring System) collected prospectively were compared with simultaneous PvCO2 drawn for patient care. Analysis included 100 measurements. The correlation of PtcCO2 and PvCO2 (r = 0.71, p < 0.001) was good, and the agreement (mean difference ± standard deviation of the differences 1.9 ± 7.0 mmHg) was adequate; average PtcCO2 was slightly lower than PvCO2. Changes in PtcCO2 and PvCO2 for consecutive measurements within each patient correlated (r = 0.41, p < 0.01). The level of PtcCO2 correlated with disease severity clinical score (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

PtcCO2 monitoring was feasible in the ER and pediatric department and was found to have a good correlation and adequate agreement with PvCO2 in infants with bronchiolitis. Because the standard deviation of the differences was relatively high, though comparable to the literature, we suggest that PtcCO2 should not replace blood gas but rather serve as a complementary tool for trending and for real-time continuous assessment of the CO2 levels.

Evaluation of a transcutaneous carbon dioxide monitor in patients with acute respiratory failure

BACKGROUND

Non-invasive measurement of oxygenation is a routine procedure in clinical practice, but transcutaneous monitoring of PCO(2)(PtCO(2)) is used much less than expected.

METHODS

The aim of our study was to analyze the value of a commercially available combined SpO(2)/PtCO(2) monitor (TOSCA-Linde Medical System, Basel, Switzerland) in adult non-invasive ventilated patients with acute respiratory failure. Eighty critically ill adult patients, requiring arterial blood sample gas analyses, underwent SpO(2) and PtCO(2) measurements (10 min after the probe was attached to an earlobe) simultaneously with arterial blood sampling. The level of agreement between PaCO(2) - PtCO(2) and SaO(2) - SpO(2)was assessed by Bland-Altman analyses.

RESULTS

Both, SaO(2) from blood gas analysis and SpO(2) from the transcutaneous monitor, and PaCO(2) and PtCO(2) were equally useful. No measurements were outside of the acceptable clinical range of agreement of ± 7.5 mmHg.

CONCLUSIONS

The accuracy of estimation of the TOSCA transcutaneous electrode (compared with the "gold standard" blood sample gas analysis) was generally good. Moreover, TOSCA presents the advantage of the possibility of continuous non-invasive measurement. The level of agreement of the two methods of measurement allows us to state that the TOSCA sensor is useful in routine monitoring of adults admitted to an intermediate respiratory unit and undergoing non-invasive ventilation.