Genetic alterations of p16INK4a and p53 genes in sporadic dysplastic nevus

Dysplastic nevi and melanoma: microRNAs tell a divergent story

BACKGROUND

dysplastic nevi (DN) share some clinical and histological features with melanoma and have been considered intermediate lesions toward malignant transformation. However, scientific evidence of DN representing melanoma precursors is still incomplete, and many observations pointed toward their being a distinct biological entity. The current definition of DN is also confusing and the practical consequence of this uncertainty is the excessive excision of DN with severe atypia. MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are small RNAs that regulate gene expression and whose global expression can classify normal and pathological tissues.

OBJECTIVES

given these considerations, we decided to perform a small RNA profiling study in a group of DN and invasive melanomas obtained from the same patient, to assess tumor evolution according to the global microRNA expression.

METHODS

we performed a small-RNA sequencing of 6 DN, 2 congenital nevi and 4 cutaneous melanomas obtained from 4 subjects and evaluated the global miRNA expression correlation between samples.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

the hierarchical clustering and principal component analyses of global miRNA expression, independently grouped together DN and their matching congenital nevi and showed a divergence of DN miRNA profile from melanoma. Our study suggests that DN have a peculiar and different miRNA expression profile compared to melanomas developed in the same patient, thus supporting the hypothesis that DN are distinct biological entities and not melanoma precursors.

A germline mutation of CDKN2A and a novel RPLP1-C19MC fusion detected in a rare melanotic neuroectodermal tumor of infancy: a case report

Background

Melanotic neuroectodermal tumor of infancy (MNTI) is exceptionally rare and occurs predominantly in the head and neck (92.8 % cases). The patient reported here is only the eighth case of MNTI presenting in an extremity, and the first reported in the fibula.

Case presentation

A 2-month-old female presented with a mass arising in the fibula. Exhaustive genomic, transcriptomic, epigenetic and pathological characterization was performed on the excised primary tumor and a derived cell line. Whole-exome analysis of genomic DNA from both the tumor and blood indicated no somatic, non-synonymous coding mutations within the tumor, but a heterozygous, unique germline, loss of function mutation in CDKN2A (p16^INK4A, D74A). SNP-array CGH on DNA samples revealed the tumor to be euploid, with no detectable gene copy number variants. Multiple chromosomal translocations were identified by RNA-Seq, and fusion genes included RPLP1-C19MC, potentially deregulating the C19MC cluster, an imprinted locus containing microRNA genes reactivated by gene fusion in embryonal tumors with multilayered rosettes. Since the presumed cell of origin of MNTI is from the neural crest, we also compared gene expression with a dataset from human neural crest cells and identified 185 genes with significantly different expression. Consistent with the melanotic phenotype of the tumor, elevated expression of tyrosinase was observed. Other highly expressed genes encoded muscle proteins and modulators of the extracellular matrix. A derived MNTI cell line was sensitive to inhibitors of lysine demethylase, but not to compounds targeting other epigenetic regulators.

Conclusions

In the absence of somatic copy number variations or mutations, the fully transformed phenotype of the MNTI may have arisen in infancy because of the combined effects of a germline CDKN2A mutation, tumor promoting somatic fusion genes and epigenetic deregulation. Very little is known about the etiology of MNTI and this report advances knowledge of these rare tumors by providing the first comprehensive genomic, transcriptomic and epigenetic characterization of a case.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12885-016-2669-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Dysplastic nevus: Fact and fiction

The term "dysplastic nevus" (DN) implies that this nevus exists as a distinct and defined entity of potential detriment to its host. We examine the current data, which suggest that this entity exists as histologically and possibly genetically different from common nevus, with some overlapping features. Studies show that a melanoma associated with a nevus is just as likely to arise in a common nevus as in DN. Furthermore, there is no evidence that a histologically defined DN evolves into a melanoma or that the presence of 1 or more DN on an individual patient confers any increased melanoma risk. We suggest that the term "dysplastic nevus" be abandoned so that the focus can shift to confirmed and relevant indicators of melanoma risk, including high nevus counts and large nevus size.

The dysplastic nevus: from historical perspective to management in the modern era: part II. Molecular aspects and clinical management

The dysplastic nevus is a discreet histologic entity that exhibits some clinical and histologic features overlapping with common nevi and melanoma. These overlapping features present a therapeutic challenge, and with a lack of accepted guidelines, the management of dysplastic nevi remains a controversial subject. Although some differences between dysplastic and common nevi can be detected at the molecular level, there are currently no established markers to predict biologic behavior. In part II of this continuing medical education article, we will review the molecular aspects of dysplastic nevi and their therapeutic implications. Our goal is to provide the clinician with an up-to-date understanding of this entity to facilitate clinical management of patients with nevi that have histologic dysplasia.

Dysplastic nevi

Dysplastic nevi have been a subject of much debate since their original description in 1978. Although some question the biological potential of dysplastic nevi themselves, several studies have shown that their presence confers substantial risk for melanoma. In addition to predisposing patients to melanoma, dysplastic nevi have been shown to harbor genetic mutations, indicating their position on a continuum between banal nevi and melanomas. Dysplastic nevi are also clinically relevant as mimickers of melanoma, and can be challenging diagnostically. This article reviews the history, epidemiology, biology and genetics, clinical features, histopathologic features, and management guidelines for patients with these lesions.

Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) as an ancillary diagnostic tool in the diagnosis of melanoma

Although the clinical and pathologic diagnosis of some melanomas is clear-cut, there are many histopathologic simulators of melanoma that pose problems. Over-diagnosis of melanoma can lead to inappropriate therapy and psychologic burdens, whereas under-diagnosis can lead to inadequate treatment of a deadly cancer. We used existing data on DNA copy number alterations in melanoma to assemble panels of fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) probes suitable for the analysis of paraffin-embedded tissue. Using FISH data from a training set of 301 tumors, we established a discriminatory algorithm and validated it on an independent set of 169 unequivocal nevi and melanomas as well as 27 cases with ambiguous pathology, for which we had long-term follow-up data. An algorithm-using signal counts from a combination of 4 probes targeting chromosome 6p25, 6 centromere, 6q23, and 11q13 provided the highest diagnostic discrimination. This algorithm correctly classified melanoma with 86.7% sensitivity and 95.4% specificity in the validation cohort. The test also correctly identified as melanoma all 6 of 6 cases with ambiguous pathology that later metastasized. There was a significant difference in the metastasis free survival between test-positive and negative cases with ambiguous pathology (P=0.003). Sufficient chromosomal alterations are present in melanoma that a limited panel of FISH probes can distinguish most melanomas from most nevi, providing useful diagnostic information in cases that cannot be classified reliably by current methods. As a diagnostic aid to traditional histologic evaluation, this assay can have significant clinical impact and improve classification of melanocytic neoplasms with conflicting morphologic criteria.

Allelotyping, microsatellite instability, and BRAF mutation analyses in common and atypical melanocytic nevi and primary cutaneous melanomas

Loss of heterozygosity (LOH) in several chromosomal regions is found in melanoma, and it has been partially studied in nevi. BRAF mutations are found in melanoma and nevi and in colorectal cancer are linked to mismatch repair deficiency. We studied early genetic events involved in melanomagenesis through analysis of allelic loss, microsatellite instability (MSI), and BRAF mutations. DNA extracted from microdissected cells of 22 common nevi, 23 atypical nevi, and 25 primary cutaneous melanomas were examined for LOH and MSI by polymerase chain reaction-based analysis of 24 microsatellite markers and BRAF mutation. Allelic loss index was higher in atypical nevi (0.20) and melanomas (0.27) than common nevi (0.07). LOH was frequent at 9p21, 17q21, 6q23, and 5q35 in melanoma. LOH at any of this loci occurred in 27% of common nevi, 57% of atypical nevi, and 68% of melanomas. BRAF mutations were not related to MSI presence and MSI index was not related with BRAF mutational status. Similar genetic alterations in atypical nevi and melanomas support the concept of atypical nevus as melanoma precursor. Novel deletion loci at 5q35 and 17q21 (BRCA1) in atypical nevi and melanomas were identified. Mismatch repair deficiency is not a crucial event for BRAF mutation in melanocytic tumors.

The "dysplastic" nevus

Dysplastic nevi have become an increasing focus clinically, with evidence that they are associated with a higher risk of developing melanoma. However, there still is contention regarding the significance of dysplastic nevi. This contribution provides an overview of the history, epidemiology, genetics, clinical and histologic features, and procedures for clinical management of dysplastic nevi. Since dysplastic nevi were described originally in 1978, a great deal of research has examined the epidemiology of these lesions and the genetic factors related to the development of dysplastic nevi. However, there is disagreement regarding the clinical management of dysplastic nevi and the histologic definition of dysplastic nevi. Current recommendations include preventative measures, such as sun protection and careful surveillance and biopsies of suspicious lesions as needed. The advent of new technologies, such as computer-vision systems, have the potential to significantly change treatment of dysplastic nevi in the future.

The molecular basis of melanomagenesis and the metastatic phenotype

The last two decades have seen spectacular advances in our understanding of the biology of melanoma and, in particular, have elucidated the mechanisms operative in disease initiation and progression. With respect to the former, the genetics of melanoma and in particular the impact of genetic defects on dysregulation of the cell cycle are key issues in malignant transformation and are a major focus of this review. With respect to the latter, consideration also is given to the acquisition of growth factor autonomy and the capacity for invasion and metastasis from the standpoint of cell adhesion, motility, and matrix digestion. These events have specific morphologic correlates that will be briefly addressed. Where relevant, we will address certain of the modern pharmacogenetic strategies that flow from these novel observations concerning melanoma biology.

The role of cell cycle regulatory proteins in the pathogenesis of melanoma

The transformation of melanocytes to melanoma cells is characterised by abnormal proliferation resulting from alterations in cell cycle regulatory mechanisms. This occurs through alterations in the two major cell cycle regulatory pathways, the retinoblastoma (Rb) and p53 tumour suppressor pathways. This review summarises the current knowledge of alterations in these two pathways at G1/S transition and specifically the role of the key cell cycle regulatory proteins pRb, p16INK4a (p16), cyclin D1, p27Kip1 (p27), p53 and p21Waf1/Cip1 (p21) in the pathogenesis of melanoma. It also considers their prognostic significance. Current data indicate that alterations of cyclin kinase inhibitor (cdki) levels are implicated in the pathogenesis of melanoma and may be useful prognostic markers. However, large validation studies linked to comprehensive clinical follow up data are necessary to clarify the prognostic significance of cell cycle regulatory proteins in individual patients.

De novo intraepidermal epithelioid melanocytic dysplasia as a marker of the atypical mole phenotype - a clinical and pathological study of 75 patients

BACKGROUND

We encountered a distinctive pattern of dysplastic intraepidermal melanocytic proliferation, which defies classification as a dysplastic melanocytic nevus, but in which the morphologic features fall short of a diagnosis of melanoma in situ. We designate such lesions as de novo intraepidermal epithelioid melanocytic dysplasia.

METHODS

From 75 patients, 82 skin biopsies were encountered that showed this distinctive morphology. Hematoxylin- and eosin-stained histologic sections were studied and the features were correlated with personal and family histories of dysplastic nevi and melanoma.

RESULTS

The diagnosis of de novo melanocytic dysplasia was made in 27 male patients and 48 female patients (mean age: 44 years). The histologic hallmark was a pagetoid (single-cell) array of moderately to severely atypical epithelioid melanocytes within the epidermis. Seventy-three lesions were located on sun-exposed skin and nine on sun-protected skin. In 41 patients, there was an atypical mole phenotype, whereas 20 patients had a prior or subsequent diagnosis of melanoma with five of 16 patients questioned revealing a family history of melanoma.

CONCLUSIONS

De novo intraepidermal epithelioid melanocytic dysplasia is a distinct entity associated with an atypical mole phenotype and a personal and/or family history of melanoma.

Cutaneous melanoma: pathogenesis and rationale for chemoprevention

OBJECTIVE

To critically review aspects of melanoma pathogenesis that lend themselves to a chemoprevention strategy. To discuss potential candidate chemoprevention agents with an emphasis on the lipid lowering drugs, the statins, currently, the most promising agents.

DATA SOURCES

A retrospective review of the literature.

STUDY SELECTION

Studies included those relevant to melanoma pathogenesis, to the scientific rationale of chemoprevention, and pertinent epidemiologic, pre-clinical, and clinical studies. The referenced study designs and methodologies varied.

DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS

Data were extracted by two reviewers, and the main results are presented in a quantitative descriptive manner.

CONCLUSION

Melanoma is a preventable disease by altering behavior (sun exposure) among at-risk individuals. There is also considerable evidence to suggest that melanoma development may be prevented or delayed by drugs of sufficiently low toxicity to make clinical trials of chemoprevention feasible and potentially successful. Among potential candidate agents, statins have compelling data for long-term safety and sufficient pre-clinical and clinical evidence for efficacy to justify their evaluation in well-designed trials in high-risk individuals, incorporating intermediate biologic endpoints.

Melanocytic dysplastic naevi occupy the middle ground between benign melanocytic naevi and cutaneous malignant melanomas: emerging clues

Although several studies have confirmed the aetiological importance of melanocytic dysplastic naevi (MDN) in the development of cutaneous malignant melanoma (CMM), the analysis of these lesions was directed mostly towards the study of melanomas. The underlying reasons include the relatively large size of CMMs, their direct lethal outcome, and the feasibility of establishing melanoma cell lines. In contrast, because of their relatively small size, questionable malignant potential, and the difficulty in establishing in vitro cultures, MDN have been studied less extensively. Hypothetically, transformed melanocytes can give rise to any lesion in the hierarchy of melanocytic tumours. Based on this hypothetical perspective, and on the epidemiological, morphological, immunohistochemical, and genetic characteristics of MDN, it is not surprising that these lesions occupy an intermediate position in the hierarchy of melanocytic lesions, and may be precursors of CMM. Although this argument appears to be straightforward, it is still controversial. This review explores the components of this argument and provides supporting evidence for this hypothesis.

Agminated acquired melanocytic nevi of the common and dysplastic type

We previously reported a single case of agminated acquired melanocytic nevi, consisting of a localized clustering of banal and atypical moles. We now report 4 more cases, confirming that the initial case was not an isolated finding. We examined the lesions clinically, with a dermoscope, with a Wood's light, and in 3 cases with UV photography so as to exclude nevus spilus from the differential diagnosis. The presence of an underlying dysplastic nevus syndrome phenotype in 4 of the 5 cases raises the possibility that agminated nevi arise as a consequence of postzygotic loss of heterozygosity and, thus, may represent a type 2 segmental manifestation of the atypical mole syndrome phenotype. Further studies of similar cases using microdissection techniques for analysis of loss of heterozygosity pattern are warranted.

Genetic pathways to melanoma tumorigenesis

The incidence of cutaneous malignant melanomas is growing faster than that of any other cancer and therefore posing a major heath threat worldwide. In melanocytic skin tumours, the feasibility of correlating a specific pathological stage with a corresponding genetic alteration provides a remarkable opportunity to study the multistep tumorigenesis model. This multistep melanoma tumorigenesis is best described as a continuum of transformation of the melanocytes, melanocytic dysplasia, and melanoma formation. These steps involve genotypic alterations including loss of tumour suppressor genes, microsatellite instability, and alterations of the mismatch repair system. This review seeks to examine melanoma tumorigenesis based on these genetic changes.

The TP53 Tumor Suppressor Gene and Melanoma Tumorigenesis: Is There a Relationship?

Mutations in the TP53 gene are found in about 11% of melanomas. Although nearly 600 papers have been published with varying degrees of consensus, there does not appear to be any comparable analysis that facilitates more than a glimpse into the role of p53 in melanomagenesis. This article reviews p53 alterations (at the gene and protein levels) in melanocytic skin lesions and discusses the following points: (i) p53 alterations commence as early as at the stage of benign and dysplastic nevi; (ii) these alterations are frequent in melanomas, and gradually increase with their progression; (iii) there is no concordance between the frequent p53 protein expression and the rarity of both TP53 gene mutations in melanomas, and (iv) the entire p53 pathway is a more critical determinant of the fate of the melanocytic skin lesions than the status of the p53 protein or the gene itself.

Mutation of B-Raf in human choroidal melanoma cells mediates cell proliferation and transformation through the MEK/ERK pathway

The BRAF gene, encoding a mitogen-activated protein kinase kinase kinase, is mutated in several human cancers, with the highest incidence occurring in cutaneous melanoma. The activating V599E mutation accounted for 80% of all mutations detected in cutaneous melanoma cell lines. Reconstitution experiments have shown that this mutation increases ectopically expressed B-Raf kinase activity and induces NIH3T3 cell transformation. Here we used tumor-derived cell lines to characterize the activity of endogenous mutated B-Raf protein and assess its specific role in transformation. We show that three cell lines (OCM-1, MKT-BR, and SP-6.5) derived from human choroidal melanoma, the most frequent primary ocular neoplasm in humans, express B-Raf containing the V599E mutation. These melanoma cells showed a 10-fold increase in endogenous B-RafV599E kinase activity and a constitutive activation of the MEK/ERK pathway that is independent of Ras. This, as well as melanoma cell proliferation, was strongly diminished by siRNA-mediated depletion of the mutant B-Raf protein. Moreover, blocking B-RafV599E-induced ERK activation by different experimental approaches significantly reduced cell proliferation and anchorage-independent growth of melanoma cells. Finally, quantitative immunoblot analysis allowed us to identify signaling and cell cycle proteins that are differentially expressed between normal melanocytes and melanoma cells. Although the expression of signaling molecules was not sensitive to U0126 in melanoma cells, the expression of a cluster of cell cycle proteins remained regulated by the B-RafV599E/MEK/ERK pathway. Our results pinpoint this pathway as an important component in choroidal melanoma cell lines.

Raf proteins and cancer: B-Raf is identified as a mutational target

A recent report has shown that activating mutations in the BRAF gene are present in a large percentage of human malignant melanomas and in a proportion of colon cancers. The vast majority of these mutations represent a single nucleotide change of T-A at nucleotide 1796 resulting in a valine to glutamic acid change at residue 599 within the activation segment of B-Raf. This exciting new discovery is the first time that a direct association between any RAF gene and human cancer has been reported. Raf proteins are also indirectly associated with cancer as effectors of activated Ras proteins, oncogenic forms of which are present in approximately one-third of all human cancers. BRAF and RAS mutations are rarely both present in the same cancers but the cancer types with BRAF mutations are similar to those with RAS mutations. This has been taken as evidence that the inappropriate regulation of the downstream ERKs (the p42/p44 MAP kinases) is a major contributing factor in the development of these cancers. Recent studies in mice with targeted mutations of the raf genes have confirmed that B-Raf is a far stronger activator of ERKs than its better studied Raf-1 homologue, even in cell types in which the protein is barely expressed. The explanation for this lies in a number of key differences in the regulation of B-Raf and Raf-1 activity. Constitutive phosphorylation of serine 445 of B-Raf leads to this protein having a higher basal kinase activity than Raf-1. Phosphorylation of threonine 598 and serine 601 within the activation loop of B-Raf at the plasma membrane also regulates its activity. The V599E mutation is thought to mimic these phosphorylations, resulting in a protein with high activity, leading to constitutive ERK activation. B-Raf now provides a critical new target to which drugs for treating malignant melanoma can be developed and, with this in mind, it is now important to gain clear insight into the biochemical properties of this relatively little characterised protein.

Assessment of genetic instability in melanocytic skin lesions through microsatellite analysis of benign naevi, dysplastic naevi, and primary melanomas and their metastases

Microsatellite instability (MSI) is caused by replication errors due to deficient DNA mismatch repair and has been associated with tumour progression in various types of cancer. Controversial results have been reported concerning the frequency and significance of MSI in malignant melanoma. In this study, the time of onset and relative incidence of MSI were determined during the progression of melanocytic tumours, starting with benign melanocytic naevi. MSI was studied at 13 loci containing single, di- or trinucleotide repeat sequences and mapping to five different chromosomal locations. Tumours were classified as being low frequency MSI (L-MSI+) or high frequency MSI (H-MSI+) when either one or at least two marker loci, respectively, displayed mutant alleles in tumour DNA compared with the corresponding normal tissue DNA. None of the eight melanocytic naevi studied showed MSI, whereas a moderate frequency of H-MSI was detected in dysplastic naevi (one out of 11; 9%) and primary melanomas (six out of 56; 11%). The incidence of H-MSI was increased in melanoma metastases from the same patients (nine out of 42; 21%). In contrast to previously reported data showing higher rates of MSI in melanoma, genetic instability seems to be present in a minority of malignant melanoma lesions. However, our findings are consistent with the hypothesis that MSI may be sequentially induced during malignant evolution, contributing to the progression of a subset of melanocytic tumours.

p53-related pathways and the molecular pathogenesis of melanoma

Cutaneous malignant melanoma (CMM) is a life-threatening cancer that can have a poor prognosis with high metastatic potential. Its incidence is rapidly increasing worldwide. Its molecular alterations involve multiple pathways, including those related to p53. Since 1981, more than 380 papers containing the terms 'p53 and melanoma' as key words in the Abstract have been published in the literature. However, in spite of these extensive investigations, a review of p53 and associated genes in CMM is still lacking. To remedy this issue, this review seeks to provide a brief overview of p53 and discuss the genes targeted along its related pathways.

Loss of heterozygosity and microsatellite instability in acquired melanocytic nevi: towards a molecular definition of the dysplastic nevus

Acquired melanocytic nevi may show signs of histological dysplasia, and epidemiological studies have demonstrated that dysplastic melanocytic nevi (DMN) are associated with an elevated melanoma risk. Nevertheless, the concept of DMN as precursors of melanoma has remained a concept, in view of the difficulty of establishing unambiguous cytological and histological criteria for DMN. Recent molecular data suggest that genetic instability is more frequent in DMN than in benign acquired melanocytic nevi. We have analyzed 54 benign melanocytic nevi and 6 DMN for loss of heterozygosity (LOH) at microsatellite markers D9S171, IFNA, D9S270, D9S265. LOH at one or more loci was detected in 17 out of 54 benign nevi and in 4 out of 6 DMN. LOH was demonstrated at 26 out of 103 amplified and informative microsatellites in benign nevi and at 6 out of 11 microsatellites in DMN. In addition, 6 benign nevi and 6 DMN were microdissected in 4-15 regions per lesion and analyzed for LOH and microsatellite instability (MSI) at D9S162 and D14S53. Both LOH and MSI were detected more frequently in dysplastic nevi (LOH frequency 0.61 vs 0.18; MSI frequency 0.27 vs 0.05). These results confirm that genetic instability is more prevalent in DMN than in benign acquired melanocytic nevi. Therefore, DMN might be defined as a monoclonal and genetically unstable, but limited, melanocytic proliferation that distinguishes this entity from the benign nevus and from malignant melanoma.

p53 alone or in combination with antisense cyclin D1 induces apoptosis and reduces tumor size in human melanoma

Melanoma incidence is growing at a faster rate than any other human malignancy. Wild-type (wt) p53 is important in both G(1) and G(2) cell cycle arrest, and cyclin D1 (CD1) is necessary for G(1)-->S progression in melanoma cells. We reported that an adenoviral vector containing wt p53 significantly reduced [(3)H]thymidine uptake in melanoma cells containing mutant but not wt p53. Subsequently we showed that CD1 decreased melanoma proliferation and increased apoptosis. We now extend these findings by evaluating the effect on preformed melanomas of (1) intratumoral therapy with wt p53 alone, (2) wt p53 in combination with antisense (AS) CD1, both short (< or =14 days) and longer term, and (3) doubling the dose or repeat doses of wt p53 or AS CD1. Two melanoma cells lines that metastasize in SCID mice (451 and 1205) were used, one containing a p53 mutation (451) and the other a normal p53 gene sequence (1205). Compared to injection with a control adenoviral vector containing beta-galactosidase (LacZ), intratumoral injection of wt p53 slowed the growth of tumors formed from 451 cells. Using 5 x 10(8) plaque forming units as our standard intratumoral dose, neither doubling the dose of LacZ, p53 or AS CD1, nor repeat doses of the vectors, was as effective as combined therapy with wt p53+AS CD1, which resulted in the shrinkage of all tumors treated and 4/7 (57%) tumors vanished. No tumors treated with wt p53 or AS CD1 alone vanished. Wt p53+AS CD1 treatment resulted in significantly more cells undergoing apoptosis compared to either therapy alone. In summary, combining the separately effective treatment vectors p53 and AS CD1 led to an enhanced growth-suppressive and apoptotic effect, supporting a role for combination gene therapy to treat human malignant melanoma.

Molecular aspects of melanocytic dysplastic nevi

Melanocytic dysplastic nevi were first described in both patients and their relatives who had one or several cutaneous malignant melanomas. Most of these dysplastic lesions are biologically stable, but some of them have severe histological atypia and can progress further to melanomas. Although several studies have suggested the etiological importance of dysplastic nevi in the development of melanomas, comprehensive reviews of the molecular changes in these dysplastic lesions are still scarce. To remedy this issue, this article analyzes the available molecular information about dysplastic nevi and provides the current state of knowledge regarding the karyotypic abnormalities of the melanoma/dysplastic nevus trait and the involvement of allelic loss, tumor suppressor genes, mismatch repair proteins, microsatellite instability, oncogenes, extracellular matrix proteins, and growth factors in the genesis of these lesions. These studies suggest that although some of these lesions represent "genetic dead-ends," others represent intermediate lesional steps in the melanoma tumorigenesis pathway.

Loss of heterozygosity analysis of cutaneous melanoma and benign melanocytic nevi: laser capture microdissection demonstrates clonal genetic changes in acquired nevocellular nevi

The molecular pathology of the common nevocellular nevus (NCN) and its relationship to the genetic model of malignant melanoma (MM) progression has not been fully characterized. We used laser capture microdissection of archival formalin-fixed material to study 34 melanocytic lesions (19 MM and 15 NCN). Twelve of the 15 NCN were acquired, 3 of which were congenital; none had dysplastic features. Ten polymorphic markers on five chromosomal regions (1p36, 6q22-23.3, 8p22-24, 10q23, and 11q23) were selected for loss of heterozygosity (LOH) analysis, based on previous studies demonstrating involvement in MM pathogenesis and progression. Loss of heterozygosity at any allelic locus was observed in 18 of 19 (95%) MM and in 9 of 15 (60%) NCN. Of the three congenital nevi analyzed, none showed LOH at any informative locus. The frequency of allelic loss was highest in the MM at 6q22-23.3 (64%), followed by 10q23 (62%), 8p22-24 (43%), 11q23 (43%), and 1p36 (13%). In the 15 NCN, the most frequent allelic losses were detected at 6q22-23.3 (29%), 1p36 (27%), and 10q23 (25%), with lower frequencies of LOH at 11q23 (10%) and 8p22-24 (7%). LOH at a single polymorphic marker, D6S1038, was detected in 70% of the MM and in 36% of the NCN, suggesting the presence of putative tumor-suppressor genes (TSGs) critical in melanocytic neoplasia at 6q22-23.3. The presence of clonal genetic alterations in acquired NCN justifies their classification as a benign neoplasm. The pattern of LOH in NCN is not random; rather, the relative frequencies of LOH at the chromosomal regions examined are consistent with a multistep model of MM progression that begins with NCN. Molecular analysis of NCN reiterates established epidemiologic and morphologic notions that NCN are precursor lesions for MM.

Analysis of N- and K-ras mutations in the distinctive tumor progression phases of melanoma

Mutations in the ras genes are key events in the process of carcinogenesis; in particular, point mutations in codon 61 of exon 2 of the N-ras gene occur frequently in cutaneous melanoma. To investigate whether these mutations occur in early or late tumor progression phases, we searched for point mutations in the N- and K-ras genes in 69 primary cutaneous melanoma, 35 metastases, and seven nevocellular nevi in association with cutaneous melanoma. Lesions were microdissected in order to procure pure tumor samples from the distinctive growth phases of the cutaneous melanoma; the very sensitive denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis technique was used to visualize the mutations, and was followed by sequencing. Point mutations in the N-ras gene but not in the K-ras gene were detected on denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis. Twenty-three primary (33%) and nine metastatic (26%) melanomas showed bandshifts for N-ras. In the majority of cases, mutations occurring in early growth phases (i.e., the "intraepidermal" radial growth phase), were preserved in later growth phases (i.e., the invasive radial growth phase, vertical growth phase, and metastatic phase), which proves the clonal relationship between the successive growth phases. In three cases, however, the mutations differed between the distinctive growth phases within the same cutaneous melanoma, due to the occurrence of an additional mutation (especially in codon 61) in a later tumor progression phase. Our approach also permitted us to analyze the mutational status of nevi, associated with cutaneous melanoma. Six out of seven associated nevi carried the same sequence (mutated or wild-type) as the primary cutaneous melanoma, whereas in one case the sequence for N-ras differed between the primary melanoma and the associated nevus. In conclusion, this approach allowed us to demonstrate the clonal relationship between subsequent growth phases of melanoma and associated nevi; our results suggest that N-ras exon 1 mutations preferentially occur during early stages of tumor progression and hence may be involved in melanoma initiation, whereas those in N-ras exon 2 are found preferentially during later stages and hence are more probably involved in metastatic spread of cutaneous melanoma.

UV-induced DNA damage, repair, mutations and oncogenic pathways in skin cancer

Repair of UV induced DNA damage is of key importance to UV-induced skin carcinogenesis. Specific signal transduction pathways that regulate cell cycling, differentiation and apoptosis are found to be corrupted in skin cancers, e.g., the epidermal growth-stimulating Hedgehog pathway in basal cell carcinomas (BCCs). Mutations in genes coding for proteins in these pathways lead to persistent disturbances that are passed along to daughter cells, e.g., mutations in the gene for the Patched (PTCH) protein in the Hedgehog pathway. Thus far only the point mutations in the P53 gene from squamous cell carcinomas and BCCs, and in PTCH gene from BCC of xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) patients appear to be unambiguously attributable to solar UV radiation. Solar UVB radiation is most effective in causing these point mutations. Other forms of UV-induced genetic changes (e.g., deletions) may, however, contribute to skin carcinogenesis with different wavelength dependencies.

Make PEEC, not war: does evasive transdifferentiation protect from carcinogenesis?

DNA repair and immune surveillance are established mechanisms that secure a programmed escape from the evolution of cancer (PEEC) by healing and elimination, respectively. Evasive transdifferentiation, i.e. silencing of carcinogenic events, is an emerging concept with potentially broad applicability that paradigmatically includes the claim that common acquired melanocytic nevi represent a programmed rescue from malignity for initiated melanocytes. This hypothesis is difficult to test. Research into the molecular mechanisms that govern the development of acquired melanocytic nevi, however, should result in the identification of a molecular master switch and an associated set of genes that - beyond the processes involved in apoptosis - may help bypass carcinogenesis and may be of therapeutic benefit in the future.

Recent advances in melanoma research

Recent advancement in the research of malignant melanoma is reviewed. Among many gene alterations detected in human melanoma, defect of CDKN2A located at chromosome 9p21 seems to be most important in the earlier developmental phase, though significance of this gene in the evolution of melanoma in situ has not been confirmed yet. Deletions of PTEN/MMAC1 on 10q23.3 and AIM1 on 6q21 as well as mutations of ras gene are involved in the later progression stages of melanoma. Adhesion molecules relevant to development and progression of melanoma have been intensely investigated in recent years, revealing crucial roles of cadherins and alpha(v)beta(3) integrin in the biologic behaviors of melanoma cells. Melanoma is characterized by extremely high potential of developing metastases. Dynamic changes of matrix metalloproteinase activity during invasion and movement of melanoma cells may be a major concern in this field. Fragility of blood vessels in melanoma lesions is another important point related to hematogeneous metastases. Acral lentiginous melanoma is a unique subtype of melanoma, because, in contrast to other subtypes, ultraviolet irradiation is not a major factor in its development. Investigation of pathogenesis of acral lentiginous melanoma surely provides us with new information about mechanism of melanocyte transformation. Recent advances in the management of malignant melanoma are also briefly reviewed, such as biochemotherapy, immunotherapy, and gene therapy. Finally, the concept of molecular classification of melanoma by gene expression profile is introduced, which possibly enables us to give the tailor-made therapy for each melanoma patient in the near future.

Cyclin D1 expression in dysplastic nevi: an immunohistochemical study

OBJECTIVE

We previously surveyed cyclin D1 expression in common acquired nevi, Spitz nevi, and malignant melanomas and reported that benign nevi maintain a zonal pattern of cyclin D1 expression, in contrast with malignant melanomas. Our aim was to extend those observations by examining cyclin D1 expression in dysplastic nevi.

METHODS

Cyclin D1 overexpression in 23 dysplastic nevi was detected by an immunohistochemical technique. The extent of atypia of the nevi was graded as mild, moderate, or severe, using previously established criteria.

RESULTS

Cyclin D1 overexpression in dysplastic nevi maintained a zonal pattern, similar to Spitz nevi. Cyclin D1 overexpression was greatest in the region of the epidermal-dermal junction and was significantly less prominent in the papillary and reticular dermis, suggesting that cyclin D1 expression is under cell control and correlates with maturation of nevus cells. Cyclin D1 overexpression also correlated with cytologic atypia, as dysplastic nevi with moderate or severe cytologic atypia contained a greater percentage of cyclin D1-positive cells than did nevi with mild atypia. Six dysplastic nevi with many cyclin D1--positive cells were assessed by fluorescence in situ hybridization studies using cyclin D1--specific and chromosome 11 centromeric probes. In all cases, there was no evidence of 11q13 translocation, amplification, or trisomy of chromosome 11.

CONCLUSIONS

Cyclin D1 may be involved in the pathogenesis of dysplastic nevi. Cyclin D1 overexpression does not appear to be explained by cyclin D1 locus amplification or translocation in most cases, and it may be a result of other cell abnormalities that up-regulate the protein level of cyclin D1.

Definition of the role of chromosome 9p21 in sporadic melanoma through genetic analysis of primary tumours and their metastases. The Melanoma Cooperative Group

Malignant melanoma (MM) is thought to arise by sequential accumulation of genetic alterations in normal melanocytes. Previous cytogenetic and molecular studies indicated the 9p21 as the chromosomal region involved in MM pathogenesis. In addition to the CDKN genes (p16/CDKN2A, p15/CDKN2B and p19(ARF), frequently inactivated in familial MM), widely reported data suggested the presence within this region of other melanoma susceptibility gene(s). To clearly assess the role of the 9p21 region in sporadic melanoma, we evaluated the presence of microsatellite instability (MSI) and loss of heterozygosity (LOH) in primary tumours as well as in synchronous or asynchronous metastases obtained from the same MM patients, using 9 polymorphic markers from a 17-cM region at 9p21. LOH and MSI were found in 27 (41%) and 11 (17%), respectively, out of 66 primary tumours analysed. In corresponding 58 metastases, MSI was found at higher rate (22; 38%), whereas a quite identical pattern of allelic deletions with 27 (47%) LOH+ cases were observed. Although the CDKN locus was mostly affected by LOH, an additional region of common allelic deletion corresponding to marker D9S171 was also identified. No significant statistical correlation between any 9p21 genetic alteration (LOH, MSI or both) and clinicopathological parameters was observed.

Analysis of G(1)/S checkpoint regulators in metastatic melanoma

We have analyzed the expression of the CDKN1A (p21(CIP1)), CDKN1B (p27(Kip1)), TP53, RB1 and MDM2 proteins and tumor cell proliferation by immunohistochemical staining in 59 cases of metastatic melanoma. The genomic status of the CDKN2A (INK4-ARF, p16/p14(ARF)), CDKN2B (p15) and CDKN2C (p18) genes was determined by PCR-SSCP (single-strand conformation polymorphism) in 46 of these cases. These results were correlated with various clinico-pathological parameters, including the outcome of combined chemoimmunotherapy. We found positive correlations between the expression of CDKN1A and MDM2 (r = 0.5063, P = 0.001), between the expression of CDKN1B and RB1 (r = 0.5026, P = 0.001), and between RB1 expression and tumor cell proliferation (0.5564, P<0.001). Two mutations in the CDKN2A (p16) gene were detected, including a novel base change AAC-->ATC (Asn to Ile) at codon 71, that also changes the codon 85 of the alternative reading frame gene p14(ARF) from CAA to CAT (Gln to His). Homozygous deletion at exon 2 of the CDKN2A (INK4-ARF) gene was detected in six cases. In seven cases, the 540C-->G polymorphism in the 3'UTR of the CDKN2A (p16) gene was found in linkage disequilibrium with the 74C-->A polymorphism in intron 1 of the CDKN2B gene (P < 0.0001). These cases had significantly lower expression of the TP53 protein (P = 0.0032). Both 540C-->G and 580C-->T polymorphisms in the 3'UTR of the CDKN2A (p16) gene were associated with significantly shorter progression time from primary to metastatic disease (P = 0.0071). We conclude, that although none of the analyzed cell cycle regulators could be singled out as a major prognostic factor, G(1)/S checkpoint abnormalities remain one of the most significant factors in the development of malignant melanoma.

Two arginine rich domains in the p14ARF tumour suppressor mediate nucleolar localization

The INK4a/ARF locus encodes two distinct tumour suppressors, p16INK4a and p14ARF, that regulate cell cycle progression via the pRB and p53 pathways, respectively. The ARF protein inhibits hdm2 activity, leading to the stabilization of the p53 tumour suppressor and cell cycle inhibition. The amino-terminal domain of human p14ARF and of the mouse homologue, p19ARF, is sufficient for these effects. This domain is also sufficient for the nucleolar localization of the mouse ARF protein. In contrast, we show that the human ARF protein requires two arginine rich domains, one in the amino- and the other in the carboxy-terminus, for nucleolar targeting. The amino-terminal nucleolar-targeting domain of p14ARF is also important for ARF-hdm2 binding and cell cycle inhibition. The carboxy-terminal p14ARF nucleolar localization domain lies within the shared INK4a/ARF exon 2, and is mutated in a small number of melanoma-prone kindreds. The INK4a/ARF exon2-mutations could affect the function of both the p16INK4a and p14ARF tumour suppressors. Oncogene (2000).

Melanoma genetics: an update with focus on the CDKN2A(p16)/ARF tumor suppressors

Investigative interest in atypical nevi and familial melanoma has contributed to the identification of several candidate melanoma loci within the human genome. Molecular defects in both tumor suppressor genes and oncogenes have been pathogenically linked to melanoma in recent studies. Of the loci currently characterized, the major gene resides on chromosome 9p and encodes a tumor suppressor designated p16. This gene, which is also known as CDKN2A, is either mutated or deleted in a large majority of melanoma cell lines, as well as in many uncultured melanoma cells and in the germline of melanoma kindreds. A novel aspect of the p16 locus is that it encodes not just one but two separate gene products that are transcribed in alternative reading frames. Both products function as negative regulators of cell cycle progression. The p16 protein itself executes its effects by competitively inhibiting cyclin-dependent kinase 4, which is a factor necessary for cellular progression through a major regulatory transition of the cell division cycle. Inherited and acquired deletions or point mutations in the p16 gene increase the likelihood that potentially mutagenic DNA damage will escape repair before cell division. Notably, the second product of the locus, ARF (for alternative reading frame), regulates cell growth through independent effects on the p53 pathway. Although there is little evidence that ARF by itself is involved in the pathogenesis of melanoma, deletions at the p16 locus disable two separate pathways that control cell growth. These recent advances open up the possibility of genetic testing for melanoma susceptibility in the setting of familial melanoma and suggest novel therapeutic strategies for melanoma based on gene therapy or small molecule mimicry targeted to the correction of defects in the p16 regulatory pathway. (J Am Acad Dermatol 2000;42:705-22.)

LEARNING OBJECTIVE

At the conclusion of this learning activity, participants should be familiar with the historical aspects of melanoma genetics and should have a greater understanding of the CDKN2A(p16)/ARF tumor suppressor genes.

Detection of microsatellite alterations in the spectrum of melanocytic nevi in patients with or without individual or family history of melanoma

We studied a group of patients with or without individual or family history of melanoma for the occurrence of genetic alterations at microsatellite DNA sequences, usually referred to as microsatellite instability (MSI), and loss of heterozygosity (LOH). Microsatellite analysis of 3 markers located on chromosome 9p21-22 was performed for 88 melanocytic lesions, including 27 melanomas and 35 dysplastic and 26 common nevi, from 48 patients. Three additional markers, on 11q23, 17q21 and 5q22, were investigated in 16 melanomas. Overall, microsatellite alterations of the type usually considered low-level instability at 9p21-22 were observed in 22% of melanomas and 31% of dysplastic and 23% of common nevi. LOH at the same loci was found in 15% of melanomas and 8% of dysplastic nevi but never in common nevi. Cases with a positive family history of melanoma compared to those with a negative family history showed a higher microsatellite alteration frequency (43% vs. 20%), and the same was observed in melanoma compared to non-melanoma carriers (31% vs. 16%). Our results show that (i) MSI is common in all melanocytic lesions, though with differences in the group of patients which could have clinical relevance if confirmed, whereas LOH is restricted to melanomas and dysplastic nevi; (ii) various melanocytic lesions from the same patient represent clonally distinct tumors; (iii) the phenotype suggestive of DNA repair deficiency is influenced by a family or an individual history of melanoma; (iv) the microsatellite alteration frequency correlates with patient groups ordered according to increasing melanoma risk.

Analysis of tumor cell evolution in a melanoma: evidence of mutational and selective pressure for loss of p16ink4 and for microsatellite instability

Tumorigenesis and tumor progression can be considered an evolutionary process. In order to deduce information on the mutational and selective pressures during melanoma progression we performed microsatellite analysis at 42 autosomal and two X-linked loci in a microdissected primary melanoma and its nine metastases. Loss of heterozygosity at locus D9S259 was the only genetic change observed in all metastases. The pattern of loss of heterozygosity at loci D9S162 and D9S171 within the region of common loss on chromosome 9p21 which encompasses the tumor suppressor gene p16ink4 enabled the distinction of four genetically different tumor cell populations. Three cell lineages showed homozygous loss of the p16ink4 gene, which evolved independently in each tumor cell population within the primary tumor. Additional allele losses could be demonstrated at markers D14S53 and DXS998. The fourth lineage did not demonstrate loss of heterozygosity at loci D9S162 and D9S171 and contained the wild type p16ink4 gene but was characterized by abundant microsatellite instability. The evolutionary approach towards tumorigenesis and tumor progression used in this study thus confirms the role of p16ink4 inactivation for melanoma progression but not for melanoma initiation; it suggests the existence of additional putative tumor suppressor genes located on 9p as well as on the long arm of chromosome 14 and shows that microsatellite instability may represent an alternative pathway of tumor cell evolution in malignant melanoma.

Chromosome loss is the most frequent mechanism contributing to HLA haplotype loss in human tumors

Loss of heterozygosity (LOH) in the short arm of chromosome 6 (6p) was detected in samples obtained from colon (13.8%), larynx (17.6%) and melanoma (15.3%) tumors. The parallel study of HLA-antigen expression in tumor tissues using locus- and polymorphic-specific antibodies in combination with LOH microsatellite analysis on 6p allowed us to establish that LOH in chromosome 6 is a representative phenomenon in most tumor cells present in a given tumor tissue. In most cases, specific HLA alleles had been lost in a predominant population of tumor cells, indicating that LOH is a non-irrelevant mutation that probably confers a selective advantage for survival of the mutant cell. We also demonstrate that LOH frequently occurred through chromosome loss rather than somatic recombination. LOH at all loci studied on the p and q arms of chromosome 6 was observed in at least 56.2% (9/17) cases. This HLA-associated microsatellite analysis was a useful tool for classifying tumors as LOH-positive or -negative, and therefore to consider a patient as a potential non-responder or responder in a vaccination trial.

Detection of p16 gene alteration in cervical cancer using tissue microdissection and LOH study

The p16 gene was identified as cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor (CDKI) and this may negatively regulate the cell cycle by acting as a tumor suppressor. Using tissue microdissection, the molecular changes at p16 and Rb genes were analysed in the spectrum of disease from dysplasia to invasive cancer of the uterine cervix. Six of 27 (22%) cases informative for D9S171 and IFNA of 9p21-22 marker (p16INK4a) showed loss of one or both alleles in at least one of these loci. LOH of pRb was detected in 29% (5/17). Gene alterations at p16 and pRb loci were only detectable in some cases of HPV-16/18 DNA positive cervical cancer. Three cases demonstrated mutational changes of p16INK4a, and the alterations were determined to be G to T shift, suggesting transitional missense mutation. In summary, the inactivation of the p16/cdk-cyclin/Rb cascade may play an additional role during the malignant progression in HPV-16/18 positive cervical cancers.