Preferential rod and cone photoreceptor abnormalities in heterozygotes with point mutations in the RDS gene

PRPH2-Related Retinal Dystrophies: Mutational Spectrum in 103 Families from a Spanish Cohort

PRPH2, one of the most frequently inherited retinal dystrophy (IRD)-causing genes, implies a high phenotypic variability. This study aims to analyze the PRPH2 mutational spectrum in one of the largest cohorts worldwide, and to describe novel pathogenic variants and genotype-phenotype correlations. A study of 220 patients from 103 families recruited from a database of 5000 families. A molecular diagnosis was performed using classical molecular approaches and next-generation sequencing. Common haplotypes were ascertained by analyzing single-nucleotide polymorphisms. We identified 56 variants, including 11 novel variants. Most of them were missense variants (64%) and were located in the D2-loop protein domain (77%). The most frequently occurring variants were p.Gly167Ser, p.Gly208Asp and p.Pro221_Cys222del. Haplotype analysis revealed a shared region in families carrying p.Leu41Pro or p.Pro221_Cys222del. Patients with retinitis pigmentosa presented an earlier disease onset. We describe the largest cohort of IRD families associated with PRPH2 from a single center. Most variants were located in the D2-loop domain, highlighting its importance in interacting with other proteins. Our work suggests a likely founder effect for the variants p.Leu41Pro and p.Pro221_Cys222del in our Spanish cohort. Phenotypes with a primary rod alteration presented more severe affectation. Finally, the high phenotypic variability in PRPH2 hinders the possibility of drawing genotype-phenotype correlations.

PRPH2 mutation update: In silico assessment of 245 reported and 7 novel variants in patients with retinal disease

Mutations in PRPH2, encoding peripherin-2, are associated with the development of a wide variety of inherited retinal diseases (IRDs). To determine the causality of the many PRPH2 variants that have been discovered over the last decades, we surveyed all published PRPH2 variants up to July 2020, describing 720 index patients that in total carried 245 unique variants. In addition, we identified seven novel PRPH2 variants in eight additional index patients. The pathogenicity of all variants was determined using the ACMG guidelines. With this, 107 variants were classified as pathogenic, 92 as likely pathogenic, one as benign, and two as likely benign. The remaining 50 variants were classified as variants of uncertain significance. Interestingly, of the total 252 PRPH2 variants, more than half (n = 137) were missense variants. All variants were uploaded into the Leiden Open source Variation and ClinVar databases. Our study underscores the need for experimental assays for variants of unknown significance to improve pathogenicity classification, which would allow us to better understand genotype-phenotype correlations, and in the long-term, hopefully also support the development of therapeutic strategies for patients with PRPH2-associated IRD.

PRPH2-Related Retinal Diseases: Broadening the Clinical Spectrum and Describing a New Mutation

Over 175 pathogenic mutations in the Peripherin-2 (PRPH2) gene are linked to various retinal diseases. We report the phenotype and genotype of eight families (24 patients) with retinal diseases associated with seven distinct PRPH2 gene mutations. We identified a new mutation, c.824_828+3delinsCATTTGGGCTCCTCATTTGG, in a patient with adult-onset vitelliform macular dystrophy (AVMD). One family with the p.Arg46Ter mutation presented with the already described AVMD phenotype, but another family presented with the same mutation and two heterozygous pathogenic mutations (p.Leu2027Phe and p.Gly1977Ser) in the ATP Binding Cassette Subfamily A Member 4 (ABCA4) gene that cause extensive chorioretinal atrophy (ECA), which could be a blended phenotype. The p.Lys154del PRPH2 gene mutation associated with the p.Arg2030Glu mutation in the ABCA4 gene was found in a patient with multifocal pattern dystrophy simulating fundus flavimaculatus (PDsFF), for whom we considered ABCA4 as a possible modifying gene. The mutation p.Gly167Ser was already known to cause pattern dystrophy, but we also found ECA, PDsFF, and autosomal-dominant retinitis pigmentosa (ADRP) as possible phenotypes. Finally, we identified the mutation p.Arg195Leu in a large family with common ancestry, which previously was described to cause central areolar choroidal dystrophy (CACD), but we also found ADRP and observed that it caused ECA more frequently than CACD in this family.

The spectrum of retinal dystrophies caused by mutations in the peripherin/RDS gene

Peripherin/rds is an integral membrane glycoprotein, mainly located in the rod and cone outer segments. The relevance of this protein to photoreceptor outer segment morphology was first demonstrated in retinal degeneration slow (rds) mice. Thus far, over 90 human peripherin/RDS gene mutations have been identified. These mutations have been associated with a variety of retinal dystrophies, in which there is a remarkable inter- and intrafamilial variation of the retinal phenotype. In this paper, we discuss the characteristics of the peripherin/RDS gene and its protein product. An overview is presented of the broad spectrum of clinical phenotypes caused by human peripherin/RDS gene mutations, ranging from various macular dystrophies to widespread forms of retinal dystrophy such as retinitis pigmentosa. Finally, we review the proposed genotype-phenotype correlation and the pathophysiologic mechanisms underlying this group of retinal dystrophies.

Mutations in the peripherin/RDS gene are an important cause of multifocal pattern dystrophy simulating STGD1/fundus flavimaculatus

AIM

To describe the phenotype and to analyse the peripherin/RDS gene in 10 unrelated families with multifocal pattern dystrophy simulating Stargardt disease (STGD1).

METHODS

The probands of 10 families and 20 affected family members underwent an ophthalmic examination including dilated fundus examination, fundus autofluorescence imaging and optical coherence tomography (OCT). In all probands and in selected family members, fluorescein angiography, electrophysiological testing and visual field analysis were performed. Blood samples were obtained from affected and unaffected family members for analysis of the peripherin/RDS gene.

RESULTS

All 10 probands carried mutations in the peripherin/RDS gene. Nine different mutations were identified, including six mutations that were not described previously. All probands showed a pattern dystrophy with yellow-white flecks in the posterior pole that strongly resembled the flecks seen in STGD1, on ophthalmoscopy as well as on autofluorescence and OCT. Clinical findings in the family members carrying the same mutation as the proband were highly variable, ranging from no visible abnormalities to retinitis pigmentosa.

CONCLUSIONS

Mutations in the peripherin/RDS gene are the major cause of multifocal pattern dystrophy simulating STGD1/fundus flavimaculatus. This autosomal dominant disorder should be distinguished from autosomal recessive STGD1, in view of the different inheritance pattern and the overall better visual prognosis.

A NOVEL COMPLEX MUTATION EVENT IN THE PERIPHERIN/RDS GENE IN A FAMILY WITH RETINAL PATTERN DYSTROPHY

PURPOSE

To report a complex mutation in the peripherin/RDS gene found in a family in whom retinal pattern dystrophy is segregating as an autosomal dominant trait.

METHODS

Clinical data were collected from family members of a large Swiss family affected by autosomal dominant retinal pattern dystrophy. Single strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) analysis of the candidate gene peripherin/RDS and subsequent sequencing of the first exon were performed.

RESULTS

Pattern dystrophy of the retina was suspected in 18 family members aged 30 years or older. Assuming a homogeneous phenotype, the candidate locus peripherin/RDS was investigated. SSCP analysis of the first exon of the peripherin/RDS gene showed an aberrant pattern in 18 affected individuals. Direct sequencing of polymerase chain reaction products detected a complex mutation, del265-268GCCA ins AGGGCC, leading to a stop codon at amino acid position 99.

CONCLUSION

To our knowledge, we report the first complex mutation in the peripherin/RDS gene as the cause of a mild macular phenotype, supporting the importance of molecular diagnosis in genetic counseling.

Concentric retinitis pigmentosa: clinicopathologic correlations

Progressive concentric (centripetal) loss of vision is one pattern of visual field loss in retinitis pigmentosa. This study provides the first clinicopathologic correlations for this form of retinitis pigmentosa. A family with autosomal dominant concentric retinitis pigmentosa was examined clinically and with visual function tests. A post-mortem eye of an affected 94 year old family member was processed for histopathology and immunocytochemistry with retinal cell specific antibodies. Unrelated simplex/multiplex patients with concentric retinitis pigmentosa were also examined. Affected family members of the eye donor and patients from the other families had prominent peripheral pigmentary retinopathy with more normal appearing central retina, good visual acuity, concentric field loss, normal or near normal rod and cone sensitivity within the preserved visual field, and reduced rod and cone electroretinograms. The eye donor, at age 90, had good acuity and function in a central island. Grossly, the central region of the donor retina appeared thinned but otherwise normal, while the far periphery contained heavy bone spicule pigment. Microscopically the central retina showed photoreceptor outer segment shortening and some photoreceptor cell loss. The mid periphery had a sharp line of demarcation where more central photoreceptors were near normal except for very short outer segments and peripheral photoreceptors were absent. Rods and cones showed abrupt loss of outer segments and cell death at this interface. It is concluded that concentric retinitis pigmentosa is a rare but recognizable phenotype with slowly progressive photoreceptor death from the far periphery toward the central retina. The disease is retina-wide but shows regional variation in severity of degeneration; photoreceptor death is severe in the peripheral retina with an abrupt edge between viable and degenerate photoreceptors. Peripheral to central gradients of unknown retinal molecule(s) may be defective or modify photoreceptor degeneration in concentric retinitis pigmentosa.

Rod-cone interactions: developmental and clinical significance

During the last decade, numerous research reports have considerably improved our knowledge about the physiopathology of retinal degenerations. Three non-mutually exclusive general areas dealing with therapeutic approaches have been proposed; gene therapy, pharmacology and retinal transplantations. The first approach involving correction of the initial mutation, will need a great deal of time and further development before becoming a therapeutic tool in human clinical practice. The observation that cone photoreceptors, even those seemingly unaffected by any described anomaly, die secondarily to rod disappearance related to mutations expressed specifically in the latter, led us to study the interactions between these two photoreceptor populations to search for possible causal links between rod degeneration and cone death. These in vivo and in vitro studies suggest that paracrine interactions between both cell types exist and that rods are necessary for continued cone survival. Since the role of cones in visual perception is essential, pending the identification of the factors mediating these interactions underway, rod replacement by transplantation and/or neuroprotection by trophic factors or alternative pharmacological means appear as promising approaches for limiting secondary cone loss in currently untreatable blinding conditions.

Diagnosis and classification of macular degenerations: an approach based on retinal function testing

The results from literature concerning some aspects of retinal function in macular degenerations (MDs) were reviewed in order to evaluate whether (a) specific patterns of retinal dysfunction may be linked to different clinical phenotypes, and (b) distinct functional profiles may help in orienting molecular diagnosis of diseases. Examined clinical phenotypes included: Stargardt disease/fundus flavimaculatus (St/FF), age-related maculopathy (ARM) and macular degeneration (AMD), pattern dystrophies (PD), Best vitelliform dystrophy (BVD), Sorsby's fundus dystrophy (SFD), autosomal cone-rod dystrophies (CRD). The following functional tests were evaluated: (1) electroretinogram (ERG) (scotopic and photopic according to ISCEV standards, rod and cone photoresponses, rod and cone b-wave intensity-response function, focal ERGs); (2) dark adaptometry (pre-bleach sensitivity and post-bleach recovery kinetics); (3) fundus reflectometry (pigment density and regeneration kinetics). Specific patterns of retinal dysfunction were identified for St/FF, ARM/AMD, SFD and BVD, whereas partially overlapping profiles were found for PD and CRD. Specific functional patterns were associated with different peripherin/RDS gene mutations, as well as with CRX mutations. Combined analysis of different retinal function tests may help to identify different phenotypes of MD, and to orient molecular diagnosis for selected genotypes.

Genotype-phenotype correlations and differential diagnosis in autosomal dominant macular disease

In the past few years, great progress has been made in the understanding of macular diseases. A number of disease-causing genes have been cloned, and numerous loci for other conditions have been mapped. The purpose of this article is to provide an overview of the current understanding of the genotype-phenotype correlations in autosomal dominant macular diseases with an emphasis on differential diagnostic issues. Whenever possible, the molecular correlates have been reviewed and the implications for age-related macular degeneration have been discussed. The many similarities of these diseases to age-related macular degeneration of the atrophic or exudative type, which can be misleading in elderly subjects, have also been addressed. While some conditions yield disease truly confined to the macula, others show widespread retinal involvement on functional testing. Clear-cut genotype-phenotype correlations are possible only for some forms of macular diseases. To further complicate the diagnostic process, there is a considerable degree of clinical overlap between many of them, making the differential diagnostic process potentially challenging. Functional testing, careful assessment of family history and extensive family work-up are essential in differentiating at the clinical level most, but not all, of these disease entities. Awareness of all of these conditions is required to direct correctly diagnostic investigations, to formulate an accurate prognosis, and for proper genetic counseling.

Expression and characterization of peripherin/rds-rom-1 complexes and mutants implicated in retinal degenerative diseases

Nearly 40 disease-linked mutations have been reported for peripherin/rds to date; heterologous expression in tissue culture cells offers a valuable means of efficiently characterizing the biochemical properties of the various mutants. Peripherin/rds is proposed to act as an essential structural element in outer segment disk morphogenesis, and a present transgenic mice offer the sole tractable system in which recombinant peripherin/rds may be examined functionally in situ. Because the generation and characterization of transgenic animals are both expensive and time consuming, heterologous expression in cultured cells offers an important and complementary means of addressing protein structure and function. The immunopurification and detection of the peripherin/rds-rom-1 complex are performed using specific immunochemical reagents, monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies, that are not commonly available. Several laboratories have developed antibodies to peripherin/rds and rom-1 in rabbits and mice, using a variety of immunogens: purified ROS membranes, purified E. coli fusion proteins, and synthetic peptides coupled to proteins. The C-terminal regions appear to be most highly antigenic, although antibodies have been generated to other regions as well. Regardless of their source, antibodies must be thoroughly characterized; specificity is often a function of solution conditions and must be determined empirically. The approach as described here has provided explanations for several instances of peripherin/rds-associated disease, including digenic RP linked to as L185P mutation, and adRP associated with C118/119del and C214S mutations. In addition, the R172W mutation, linked to macular dystrophy and preferential loss in cone function, is shown to behave normally with respect to biosynthesis and subunit assembly; it likely involves a more subtle functional defect that remains to be described. Finally, the methodology reported here has suggested the existence of a novel (homotetrameric) form of peripherin/rds in individuals lacking rom-1; this hypothesis has been confirmed in rom-1 knockout mice. The information obtained thus far demonstrates the utility of using heterologously expressed peripherin/rds and rom-1 to investigate the consequences of disease-linked mutations in these polypeptides. Heterologous cell expression coupled with transgenic mouse methodologies should continue to provide a more detailed understanding of molecular mechanisms underlying inherited retinal degenerative diseases.

Null mutation in the rhodopsin kinase gene slows recovery kinetics of rod and cone phototransduction in man

Rhodopsin kinase (RK), a specialized G-protein-coupled receptor kinase expressed in retina, is involved in quenching of light-induced signal transduction in photoreceptors. The role of RK in recovery after photoactivation has been explored in vitro and in vivo experimentally but has not been specifically defined in humans. We investigated the effects on human vision of a mutation in the RK gene causing Oguchi disease, a recessively inherited retinopathy. In vitro experiments demonstrated that the mutation, a deletion of exon 5, abolishes the enzymatic activity of RK and is likely a null. Both a homozygote and heterozygote with this RK mutation had recovery phase abnormalities of rod-isolated photoresponses by electroretinography (ERG); photoactivation was normal. Kinetics of rod bleaching adaptation by psychophysics were dramatically slowed in the homozygote but normal final thresholds were attained. Light adaptation was normal at low backgrounds but became abnormal at higher backgrounds. A slight slowing of cone deactivation kinetics in the homozygote was detected by ERG. Cone bleaching adaptation and background adaptation were normal. In this human in vivo condition without a functional RK and probable lack of phosphorylation and arrestin binding to activated rhodopsin, reduction of photolyzed chromophore and regeneration processes with 11-cis-retinal probably constitute the sole pathway for recovery of rod sensitivity. The role of RK in rods would thus be to accelerate inactivation of activated rhodopsin molecules that in concert with regeneration leads to the normal rate of recovery of sensitivity. Cones may rely mainly on regeneration for the inactivation of photolyzed visual pigment, but RK also contributes to cone recovery.