Gene expression by atypical recombinant ovine adenovirus vectors during abortive infection of human and animal cells in vitro

Development of Novel Adenoviral Vectors to Overcome Challenges Observed With HAdV-5-based Constructs

Recombinant vectors based on human adenovirus serotype 5 (HAdV-5) have been extensively studied in preclinical models and clinical trials over the past two decades. However, the thorough understanding of the HAdV-5 interaction with human subjects has uncovered major concerns about its product applicability. High vector-associated toxicity and widespread preexisting immunity have been shown to significantly impede the effectiveness of HAdV-5–mediated gene transfer. It is therefore that the in-depth knowledge attained working on HAdV-5 is currently being used to develop alternative vectors. Here, we provide a comprehensive overview of data obtained in recent years disqualifying the HAdV-5 vector for systemic gene delivery as well as novel strategies being pursued to overcome the limitations observed with particular emphasis on the ongoing vectorization efforts to obtain vectors based on alternative serotypes.

Circumventing antivector immunity: potential use of nonhuman adenoviral vectors

Adenoviruses are efficient gene delivery vectors based on their ability to transduce a wide variety of cell types and drive high-level transient transgene expression. While there have been advances in modifying human adenoviral (HAdV) vectors to increase their safety profile, there are still pitfalls that need to be further addressed. Preexisting humoral and cellular immunity against common HAdV serotypes limits the efficacy of gene transfer and duration of transgene expression. As an alternative, nonhuman AdV (NHAdV) vectors can circumvent neutralizing antibodies against HAdVs in immunized mice and monkeys and in human sera, suggesting that NHAdV vectors could circumvent preexisting humoral immunity against HAdVs in a clinical setting. Consequently, there has been an increased interest in developing NHAdV vectors for gene delivery in humans. In this review, we outline the recent advances and limitations of HAdV vectors for gene therapy and describe examples of NHAdV vectors focusing on their immunogenicity, tropism, and potential as effective gene therapy vehicles.

Comparative analysis of ovine adenovirus 287 and human adenovirus 2 and 5 based on their codon usage

Ovine adenovirus 287 (OAdV287) emerges as one of the most promising gene vectors resulting from its unique biological characteristics. To obtain a more detailed knowledge about the codon usage of OAdV287, a comparative study based on the codon usage of OAdV287 and the prototypes of human adenovirus serotypes 2 and 5 (HAdV2/5) was carried out. Some commonly used indices measuring the codon usage patterns, including effective number of codons, relative synonymous codon usage, and statistical methods, were adopted. Overall, OAdV287 had a more biased and conservative codon usage pattern than that of HAdV2/5. Both mutation pressure and natural selection played important roles in shaping the codon usage patterns of these three adenoviruses. All the preference codons of OAdV287 had A/U ends and were totally different from those of sheep and humans; however, the preference codons of HAdV2/5 mostly had G/C ends and were mostly coincident with those of sheep and humans. The codon usage analysis in this study supplies some clues for further comprehending the unique biological characteristics of OAdV287 as gene vectors.

Induction of both cellular and humoral immunity following a rational prime-boost immunization regimen that incorporates recombinant ovine atadenovirus and fowlpox virus

Recombinant fowlpox viruses (rFPV) and ovine atadenoviruses (rOAdV) are being developed as safe, nonpathogenic, prophylactic and therapeutic vaccine vectors. There is scope, however, to improve the limited immune responses elicited by each of these vaccine vectors. Using previously determined and optimized routes of administration and viral doses, we characterized the primary adaptive immune responses elicited by recombinant variants of each virus. We demonstrate the contrasting nature of the response elicited by each recombinant virus. Whereas rFPV generates predominately cell-mediated immunity to our nominal target antigen, ovalbumin (OVA), rOAdV drives strong humoral responses. By defining the time taken to achieve maximal cytotoxic T cell responses and by studying the different patterns and kinetics of major histocompatibility complex class I-restricted OVA antigen expression postimmunization, we proposed a heterologous prime-boost regimen of immunization with rOAdV followed by rFPV. The subsequent experimental results showed that this approach produced robust cell-mediated and humoral immune responses against OVA that, importantly, were accompanied by weak anti-viral vector antibody responses. These results, therefore, represent a novel and potentially clinically applicable way to achieve broadly based and effective immunity to the antigens encoded by vectored vaccines.

Ovine atadenovirus, a novel and highly immunogenic vector in prime-boost studies of a candidate HIV-1 vaccine

Ovine adenovirus type 7 (OAdV) is the prototype member of the genus Atadenovirus. No immunity to the virus has so far been detected in human sera. We describe the construction and evaluation of a candidate HIV-1 vaccine based on OAdV and its utilisation alone and in combination with plasmid-, human adenovirus type 5 (HAdV5; a Mastadenovirus)-, and modified vaccinia Ankara (MVA)-vectored vaccines. All vectors expressed HIVA, an immunogen consisting of HIV-1 clade A consensus Gag-derived protein coupled to a T cell polyepitope. OAdV.HIVA was genetically stable, grew well and expressed high levels of protein from the Rous sarcoma virus promoter. OAdV.HIVA was highly immunogenic in mice and efficiently primed and boosted HIV-1-specific T cell responses together with heterologous HIVA-expressing vectors. There were significant differences between OAdV and HAdV5 vectors in priming of naïve CD8(+) T cell responses to HIVA and in the persistence of MHC class I-restricted epitope presentation in the local draining lymph nodes. OAdV.HIVA primed T cells more rapidly but was less persistent than AdV5.HIVA and thus induced a qualitatively distinct T cell response. Nevertheless, both vectors primed a response in mice that reduced viral titres in a surrogate challenge model by three to four orders of magnitude. Thus, OAdV is a novel, underexplored vaccine vector with potential for further development for HIV-1 and other vaccines. The data are discussed in the context of the latest HIV-1 vaccine developments.

Cryoelectron microscopy map of Atadenovirus reveals cross-genus structural differences from human adenovirus

A three-dimensional (3D) cryoelectron microscopy reconstruction of the prototype Atadenovirus (OAdV [an ovine adenovirus isolate]) showing information at a 10.6-A resolution (0.5 Fourier shell correlation) was derived by single-particle analysis. This is the first 3D structure solved for any adenovirus that is not a Mastadenovirus, allowing cross-genus comparisons between structures and the assignment of genus-specific capsid proteins. Viable OAdV mutants that lacked the genus-specific LH3 and p32k proteins in purified virions were also generated. Negatively stained 3D reconstructions of these mutants were used to identify the location of protein LH3 and infer that of p32k within the capsid. The key finding was that LH3 is a critical protein that holds the outer capsid of the virus together. In its absence, the outer viral capsid is unstable. LH3 is located in the same position among the hexon subunits as its protein IX equivalent from mastadenoviruses but sits on top of the hexon trimers, forming prominent "knobs" on the virion surface that visually distinguish OAdV from other known AdVs. Electron density was also assigned to hexon and penton subunits and to proteins IIIa and VIII. There was good correspondence between OAdV density and human AdV hexon structures, which also validated the significant differences that were observed between the penton base protein structures.

Completion of the genome analysis of snake adenovirus type 1, a representative of the reptilian lineage within the novel genus Atadenovirus

Genome sequencing and analysis of snake adenovirus type 1 (SnAdV-1), originating from corn snake, were completed. This is the first full genomic sequence of an adenovirus from reptilian hosts. The presence of characteristic genus-common genes and transcription units, showed that SnAdV-1 shares similar genome organisation with members of the recently established genus Atadenovirus. Three novel open reading frames of yet unknown functions were found. One of these seemed to be related to a putative gene, the so-called 105R that has recently been described from the genome of the tree shrew adenovirus. The other two putative genes were found to be unique for SnAdV-1. On phylogenetic trees, SnAdV-1 clustered within the atadenovirus clade. Thereby the hypothesis on the reptilian origin of atadenoviruses was further strengthened. Interestingly, however, one of the most striking features of atadenoviruses, namely the base content heavily biased towards A+T, is not characteristic for SnAdV-1 having a genome of balanced composition with a G+C value of 50.21%.

Increased complexity of wild-type adeno-associated virus–chromosomal junctions as determined by analysis of unselected cellular genomes

Adeno-associated virus (AAV) undergoes preferential Rep-mediated integration into the AAVS1 region of human chromosome 19 during latent infection, at least in highly-selected cell cultures. However, integration at the level of the whole eukaryotic genome in unselected cells has not yet been monitored for AAV as it has been for retro- and lentiviruses. Here we have used ligation-mediated PCR (LMPCR) to monitor the formation of AAV–chromosome junctions within unselected genomic DNA after infection. Our analyses show that, in the absence of selection, the complexity of junction formation is much greater than for selected cells. Sequencing of more than 50 authentic LMPCR clones showed that AAV formed junctions with many different chromosomal sites via DNA micro-homologies that frequently involved GGTC motifs located within the AAV p5 element. One site at position 280 was preferred. Even greater complexity was found when unselected junctions identified by LMPCR were analysed by direct PCR amplification and cloning of genomic DNA. No clones containing AAV–AAVS1 chromosome 19 junctions were identified among the LMPCR clones, although they were readily obtained using chromosomal PCR primers, suggesting that junctions with AAVS1 constituted only a small portion of the total. Thus, we have identified an additional means by which AAV sequences may join to human chromosomes, although the detailed molecular mechanisms remain to be elucidated. These data may have implications for the design of new-generation AAV vectors.

An adenovirus serotype 5 vector with fibers derived from ovine atadenovirus demonstrates CAR-independent tropism and unique biodistribution in mice

Many clinically important tissues are refractory to adenovirus (Ad) infection due to negligible levels of the primary Ad5 receptor the coxsackie and adenovirus receptor CAR. Thus, development of novel CAR-independent Ad vectors should lead to therapeutic gain. Ovine atadenovirus type 7, the prototype member of genus Atadenovirus, efficiently transduces CAR-deficient human cells in vitro, and systemic administration of OAdV is not associated with liver sequestration in mice. The penton base of OAdV7 does not contain an RGD motif, implicating the long-shafted fiber molecule as a major structural dictate of OAdV tropism. We hypothesized that replacement of the Ad5 fiber with the OAdV7 fiber would result in an Ad5 vector with CAR-independent tropism in vitro and liver "detargeting" in vivo. An Ad5 vector displaying the OAdV7 fiber was constructed (Ad5Luc1-OvF) and displayed CAR-independent, enhanced transduction of CAR-deficient human cells. When administered systemically to C57BL/6 mice, Ad5Luc1-OvF reporter gene expression was reduced by 80% in the liver compared to Ad5 and exhibited 50-fold higher gene expression in the kidney than the control vector. To our knowledge, this is the first report of a fiber-pseudotyped Ad vector that simultaneously displays decreased liver uptake and a distinct organ tropism in vivo. This vector may have future utility in murine models of renal disease.

Development of nonhuman adenoviruses as vaccine vectors

Human adenoviral (HAd) vectors have demonstrated great potential as vaccine vectors. Preclinical and clinical studies have demonstrated the feasibility of vector design, robust antigen expression and protective immunity using this system. However, clinical use of adenoviral vectors for vaccine purposes is anticipated to be limited by vector immunity that is either preexisting or develops rapidly following the first inoculation with adenoviral vectors. Vector immunity inactivates the vector particles and rapidly removes the transduced cells, thereby limiting the duration of transgene expression. Due to strong vector immunity, subsequent use of the same vector is usually less efficient. In order to circumvent this limitation, nonhuman adenoviral vectors have been proposed as alternative vectors. In addition to eluding HAd immunity, these vectors possess most of the attractive features of HAd vectors. Several replication-competent or replication-defective nonhuman adenoviral vectors have been developed and investigated for their potential as vaccine-delivery vectors. Here, we review recent advances in the design and characterization of various nonhuman adenoviral vectors, and discuss their potential applications for human and animal vaccination.

Preclinical evaluation of a prostate-targeted gene-directed enzyme prodrug therapy delivered by ovine atadenovirus

Gene-directed enzyme prodrug therapy (GDEPT) based on the Escherichia coli enzyme, purine nucleoside phosphorylase (PNP), provides a novel strategy for treating slowly growing tumors like prostate cancer (CaP). PNP converts systemically administered prodrug, fludarabine phosphate, to a toxic metabolite, 2-fluoroadenine, that kills PNP-expressing and nearby cells by inhibiting DNA, RNA and protein synthesis. Reporter gene expression directed by a hybrid prostate-directed promoter and enhancer, PSMEPb, was assayed after plasmid transfection or viral transduction of prostate and non-CaP cell lines. Androgen-sensitive (AS) LNCaP-LN3 and androgen-independent (AI) PC3 human CaP xenografts in nude mice were injected intratumorally with an ovine atadenovirus vector, OAdV623, that carries the PNP gene under PSMEPb, formulated with cationic lipid for enhanced infectivity. Fludarabine phosphate was then given intraperitoneally for 5 days at 75 mg/m2/day. PNP expression was evaluated by enzymic conversion of its substrate using reverse phase HPLC. OAdV623 showed excellent in vitro transcriptional specificity for CaP cells. In vivo, expression of PNP persisted for > 6 days after OAdV623 injection and a single treatment provided 100% increase in tumor doubling time and > 50% inhibition of tumor growth for both LNCaP-LN3 and PC3 lines, with increased tumor necrosis and apoptosis and decreased tumor cell proliferation. OAdV623 significantly suppressed the growth of AS and AI human CaP xenografts in mice.

Recombinant ovine atadenovirus induces a strong and sustained T cell response against the hepatitis C virus NS3 antigen in mice

Ovine atadenovirus (OAdV) is a novel gene transfer vector with excellent in vivo gene transfer characteristics. In the present study, we have investigated the ability of an OAdV vector to mediate a T cell response to an antigen of the hepatitis C virus (HCV) in mice. Specifically, an expression cassette coding for non-structural protein 3 (NS3) of hepatitis C virus was inserted into the OAdV genome and the resulting recombinant virus (OAdV-ns3) was shown to propagate stably and to express the ns3 gene at a high level in vitro. A single injection of this non-replicating vector into BALB/c mice resulted in a strong induction of NS3-specific, IFN-gamma secreting T-lymphocytes as measured by direct ex vivo ELISpot assay. The number of IFN-gamma secreting lymphocytes remained nearly unaltered for a period of at least 10 weeks. The immune response was shown to depend on virus dose but a single intramuscular injection of less than 10(8) infectious particles of OAdV-ns3 was sufficient to induce a significant NS3-specific T cell response. Moreover, this response was not affected by prior immunisation of animals with human adenovirus type 5 (HAdV-5). The results of our study provide proof for the concept that OAdV vectors may be valuable tools for vaccination and immunotherapy even in the face of natural immunity to human adenoviruses.

Antibody response and virus tissue distribution in chickens inoculated with wild-type and recombinant fowl adenoviruses

We demonstrated that the long tandemly repeated region (TR-2) is dispensable for in vitro replication of fowl adenovirus 9 (FAdV-9). The TR-2-deleted recombinant FAdV-9 expressing the enhanced green fluorescence protein was further characterized for in vivo effects. Groups of chickens were exposed to recombinant or wild-type FAdV-9 by intramuscular injection, through the feed or drinking water and one group served as a negative control. The antibody (Ab) response, evaluated by ELISA and a plaque reduction test depended on the virus, dosage and the route of inoculation. Although the highest levels of anti-viral Ab were detected in chickens inoculated intramuscularly (i.m.) with wild-type FAdV-9, the deletion of TR-2 did not have a significant effect on the immune response. The tissue distribution of the virus was examined by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and was similar for both wild-type and recombinant viruses. Based on these results the TR-2 was dispensable for viral replication in vivo and did not influence virus distribution, and the recombinant FAdV-9 induced the same immune response as the wild-type virus.

Ovine atadenovirus: a review of its biology, biosafety profile and application as a gene delivery vector

The ovine adenovirus isolate OAdV287 is the prototype of the newly recognized genus of atadenoviruses. Although not as well studied as human mastadenoviruses, a substantial amount of work has now been carried out with this virus and an understanding of its interesting and unique properties is beginning to emerge. In this article the biology and biosafety profile of the virus is reviewed. This knowledge underpins the exploitation of the virus as a gene delivery vector. Its potential as a vaccine vector and its application to the treatment of prostate cancer is summarized and discussed.

Identification of an ovine atadenovirus gene whose product activates the viral E2 promoter: possible involvement of E2F-1

Activation of the adenoviral E2 promoter is an early step in adenovirus gene expression. For members of the mast- and aviadenoviruses, this requires induction of the cellular transcription factor E2F by virally encoded gene products such as E1A, E4orf6/7 and orf22/GAM-1. The newly recognized genus atadenovirus, of which the ovine isolate OAdV is the prototype, lacks any sequence homology to those genes. To find a possible link between E2 promoter activation and OAdV gene expression, we utilized a screening method to search for genes within the OAdV genome that were capable of stimulating the viral E2 promoter. One such gene, E43, was identified within the proposed E4 region toward the right-hand end of the OAdV genome. The E43 gene product was also found to be capable of stimulating E2F-1-dependent gene expression. A closer inspection of the E2 promoter revealed the presence of a non-palindromic E2F binding site within the OAdV E2 promoter. Mutation of this site markedly reduced both E2F-1- and E43-dependent promoter activation. Moreover, a direct protein-protein interaction of the E43 gene product with E2F, but not with the retinoblastoma protein pRb, suggested a possible cooperation between these two proteins in activating the E2 promoter. The importance of the E43 gene product for virus replication is also underlined by the finding that an OAdV recombinant with a functionally inactivated E43 gene showed severely inhibited virus growth.

Construction, rescue, and characterization of vectors derived from ovine atadenovirus

Gene transfer vectors derived from ovine atadenovirus type 7 (OAdV) can efficiently infect a variety of mammalian cells in vitro and in vivo to deliver and express transgenes. However, early OAdV vectors were designed on human mastadenovirus principles prior to the complete characterization of OAdV genes and transcripts. The distinctive arrangement of the OAdV genome has suggested ways to improve OAdV vector design and utility. We therefore developed a cosmid-based approach that allows efficient construction of recombinant ovine atadenovirus genomes in which the transgene is inserted at one of three sites. Viruses were rescued by transfection of viral DNA into a new ovine fetal skin fibroblast producer cell line, HVO156. The suitability of the three insertion sites was compared with respect to virus rescue efficiency, gene expression levels, and genetic stability of the vectors. We found that one vector with a transgene inserted at site 1, between the pVIII and fiber genes, was unstable. Only one vector that carried a transgene at site 2, near the right end of the genome, together with a nearby deletion was rescued. In contrast, several vectors with different transgenes inserted in site 3, between the E4 and RH transcription units, were repeatedly rescued, and these vectors were stable over at least four passages. Transgene orientation in site 3 had only little effect on expression. Finally, a vector carrying a human factor IX cDNA at site 3, when administered intravenously, produced nearly physiological levels of human factor IX in mice. The availability of an efficient method for vector construction and the identification of a new insertion site for virus rescue and gene expression substantially enhance the utility of the OAdV vector system.

Molecular evolution of adenoviruses

New advances in the field of genetic characterization of adenoviruses originating from different animal species are summarized. Variations seen in the host range and specificity, pathogenicity, genomic arrangement or gene complement are much wider than expected based on previous studies of human adenoviruses. Several exceptional adenoviruses from the two traditional conventional genera are now removed, and proposed to form at least two new genera. The eventual host origin of the new genera, however, is not clarified. Novel results from the genomic and phylogenetic analyses of adenoviruses originating from lower vertebrate species (including reptiles, amphibians and fish) seem to imply that probably five major clusters of adenoviruses exist corresponding to the five major classes of Vertebrata. Adenoviruses, which are now suspected to have common origin with enterobacterium phages from the family Tectiviridae, are perhaps very ancient indeed, and may have undergone a co-evolution with vertebrate hosts.

Biology of ovine adenovirus infection of nonpermissive cells

Nonhuman adenoviruses, including those of the genus Atadenovirus, have the potential to serve as vectors for vaccine and gene therapy applications in humans, since they are resistant to preexisting immunity induced by human adenoviruses in the majority of the population. In this study, we elucidate the outcome of infection by ovine adenovirus type 7 isolate 287 (OAdV) of several nonovine cell types. We show here that OAdV infects a wide range of nonovine cells but is unable to complete its replication cycle in any of them. In nonovine, nonfibroblast cells, viral replication is blocked at an early stage before the onset of, or early in, DNA replication. Some fibroblasts, on the other hand, allow viral DNA replication but block virus production at a later stage during or after the translation of late viral proteins. Late viral proteins are expressed in cells where viral DNA replication takes place, albeit at a reduced level. Significantly, late proteins are not properly processed, and their cellular distribution differs from that observed in infected ovine cells. Thus, our results clearly show that OAdV infection of all nonovine cells tested is abortive even if significant viral DNA replication occurs. These findings have significant positive implications with respect to the safety of the vector system and its future use in humans.

Gene therapy for prostate cancer delivered by ovine adenovirus and mediated by purine nucleoside phosphorylase and fludarabine in mouse models

A gene-directed enzyme pro-drug therapy (GDEPT) based on purine nucleoside phosphorylase (PNP), that converts the prodrug, fludarabine to 2-fluoroadenine, has been described, but studies are limited compared with other GDEPTs. We investigated the in vitro and in vivo efficacies of PNP-GDEPT for treating androgen-independent (AI) prostate cancer. The PNP gene controlled by Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) constitutive promoter was delivered using a recombinant ovine adenovirus vector (OAdV220) that uses a different receptor from human adenovirus type 5. In vitro, OAdV220 provided increased transgene expression over a comparable human Ad5 vector in infected AI, murine RM1 prostate cancer cells. Subsequent in vivo testing was therefore confined to OAdV220. Transduction of RM1 cells with OAdV220 before implantation in immunocompetent mice dramatically inhibited subcutaneous (s.c.) tumor growth when fludarabine phosphate was administered systemically and increased mouse survival in a dose-dependent manner. In tumor-bearing C57BL/6 mice, a single intratumoral injection of OAdV220 produced detectable PNP activity for at least 6 days and with prodrug, retarded the growth of aggressive RM1 s.c. tumors by 35% at day 14. There was a consistent trend to reduction of pre-established intraprostatic RM1 tumors. A similar regimen induced significant therapeutic efficacy in human PC3 xenografts. Thus, ovine adenovirus-mediated GDEPT using the PNP system was effective in vivo against AI prostate cancers, the aggressive murine RM1, and the human PC3 lines. Methods that improve viral dissemination and stimulate the immune system in vivo may further improve efficacy.

Complementation of a defective human adenovirus by an otherwise incompatible ovine adenovirus recombinant carrying a functional E1A gene

All known human adenoviruses are classified as mastadenoviruses, while the ovine adenovirus (OAdV) serotype 7 is the prototype of the atadenoviruses, a proposed new genus. OAdV replicates abortively in human cell types and has potential as a gene transfer vector. However, the function of OAdV nonstructural genes is poorly understood and it is unclear whether OAdV replication might be complemented by a replicating human AdV in coinfected cells. To investigate possible interactions three human cell lines were singly infected with OAdV or human AdV5 or doubly infected. The development of a cytopathic effect and genome replication was monitored over three passages in each cell type. No significant OAdV replication occurred in any of the cell types examined either in the presence or in the absence of replicating AdV5. No aberrant AdV5 genome products were detected in coinfected cells. In contrast, in coinfected cells an OAdV recombinant that expressed the AdV5 E1A gene was able to promote the replication of an AdV5 E1A-deficient mutant, demonstrating trans-complementation between appropriate viruses. These findings have implications for the biosafety of OAdV vectors and their possible utility for enhancing gene delivery.

Analysis of early region 1 of porcine adenovirus type 3

To identify the proteins encoded by the porcine adenovirus 3 (PAV-3) E1 region, rabbit antisera were prepared using a bacterial fusion protein encoding E1A, E1B(small), or E1B(large) protein. Sera against E1A, E1B(small), and E1B(large) immunoprecipitated a protein of 35, 23, and 53 kDa, respectively, in in vitro translated and transcribed mRNA and PAV-3 infected cells. To determine the role of E1 proteins in PAV-3 replication, we constructed vectors with a deletion(s) in the E1 region. Mutant PAV211, containing deletions in E1A and E3, grew to titers similar to wild-type in VIDO R1 cells (E1A complementing) but not in swine testicular (ST) cells. No early protein (E1B(small), DNA binding protein) expression could be detected in PAV211 infected ST cells by Western blots. Mutant PAV212, containing deletions in E1B(small) and E3, grew to wild-type titers in VIDO R1 or ST cells. These deletions were successfully rescued, resulting in recombinant PAV214, containing deletions in E1A, E1B(small), and E3. However, mutant PAV-3, containing a triple stop codon inserted in the E1B(large) coding sequence, could not be isolated. Next, we constructed a recombinant PAV216 by inserting the green fluorescent protein gene flanked by a promoter and a poly(A) in the E1A region of the PAV214 genome. Both PAV214 and PAV216 replicate as efficiently as wild-type in VIDO R1 cells. These results suggested that (a) E1A is essential for virus replication and is required for the activation of other PAV-3 early genes, (b) E1B(small) is not essential for replication of PAV-3, and (c) E1B(large) is essential for virus replication. Moreover, the PAV216 vector can be used for the expression of a transgene.

An ovine adenovirus vector lacks transforming ability in cells that are transformed by AD5 E1A/B sequences

Adenoviruses of the Mastadenovirus and Aviadenovirus genera are able to transform certain cell types and induce tumor formation in susceptible animals. For the mastadenoviruses the E1A/B sequences are largely responsible for these properties but E4 sequences may also be involved. The transforming sequences of the aviadenoviruses, which lack E1A/B and E4 homologues, have not yet been fully identified. The recent proposal for a third genus of adenoviruses, which apparently lack an E1A homologue and have weak E1B homology, prompted an examination of the transforming properties of ovine adenovirus OAV287 (OAV), the prototype member of the new group. When OAV and human adenovirus type 5 (Ad5) were used to infect primary rat embryo cells, transformed foci developed in Ad5- but not in OAV-infected cultures. Similarly, after plasmid transfection, baby rat kidney cells were transformed by Ad5 E1A/B but not by OAV sequences. When CSL503 cells, an ovine cell line that is permissive for OAV, were transfected with Ad5 E1A/B sequences, transformed foci again appeared. However, plasmids or fragments containing complete or partial OAV genome sequences did not detectably transform CSL503 cells under the same conditions. When Ad5 E1A/B sequences were incorporated into the complete OAV genome and transfected, transformed clones were again obtained, showing that the gene dosage and transfection conditions were not limiting for transformation. The provision of Ad5 E1A and OAV sequences in combination marginally increased the number of morphologically altered foci in baby rat kidney cells but failed to induce multilayered focus formation. The data suggest that OAV lacks transforming functions in the cell types examined. Additional information suggesting that OAV may have a fundamentally distinct strategy for replication compared with other Ads is discussed.

Novel human gene transfer vectors: evaluation of wild-type and recombinant animal adenoviruses in human-derived cells

Major disadvantages of human adenovirus (hAd) vectors in gene therapy include preexisting or induced immune responses, and possible coreplication of recombinant hAd in the presence of wild-type hAds. These disadvantages may be overcome by using nonhuman, animal adenoviruses (aAds). We evaluated four different aAds for their potential use as viral vectors. The canine adenovirus type 2 (CAV2) and bovine adenovirus type 3 (BAV3) appeared to be suitable systems, as they infect human cells. CAV2, but not BAV3, caused cytotoxicity, and only limited (CAV2) or no (BAV3) production of infectious virus particles was observed after infection of human cell lines. CAV2 showed higher expression of endogenous genes than did BAV3 in the tested human cells. No interference between hAd and CAV2 or BAV3, such as recombination of DNA or cross-activation of virus replication, was observed in up to five passages in double-infected human cells. Transfection of cloned genomic CAV2 or BAV3 DNA into appropriate permissive cell lines rescued infectious virus. Furthermore, we produced a recombinant E1-deleted BAV3, and showed that it could infect and express a reporter gene in various human cell types. The goal was to construct and evaluate recombinant (E1-deleted) animal adenoviruses (aAds) as new vector systems for human gene therapy. The rationale for developing aAds for human use is the potential higher safety and efficiency, as compared with human adenoviruses (hAds). Coreplication and recombination with preexisting hAds should not be possible owing to lack of homology, and preexisting immunity in the general population should be limited. Of the four aAds we evaluated, BAV3 appeared to be the best candidate. It infects human cells without showing growth or cytotoxic effects, viral gene expression was barely detectable, and no trans-activation of either virus was detected in coinfections with hAd5. Rescue of virus in permissive cells, from plasmids containing the CAV2 or BAV3 genome, confirmed our approach. Furthermore, an E1-deleted recombinant BAV3 was constructed and shown to transduce and express the lacZ reporter gene in human cells.

Porcine adenovirus-3 as a helper-dependent expression vector

Porcine adenovirus has been proposed as a potential vector for generating novel and effective vaccines for pigs. As a prerequisite for the generation of helper-dependent porcine adenovirus-3 (PAV-3) vectors, two E1-complementing porcine cell lines expressing E1 proteins of human adenovirus-5 (HAV-5) were made. These cell lines could be efficiently transfected with DNA and allowed the rescue and propagation of a PAV-3 recombinant, PAV201, containing a 0.597 kb E3 deletion and a 0.803 kb E1A deletion. Our data demonstrate that E1A proteins of HAV-5 have the capacity to transform foetal porcine retina cells and complement for the E1A proteins of PAV-3. The green fluorescent protein (GFP) gene placed under the control of a cytomegalovirus immediate early promoter was inserted into the E1A region of the PAV201 genome. Using these cell lines, a helper-dependent PAV-3 recombinant expressing GFP, PAV202, was constructed and characterized. The wild-type PAV-3 and the recombinant PAV202 expressing GFP were used to determine the ability of the virus to enter and replicate in cells of human and animal origin under cell culture conditions. Our results suggest that PAV-3 enters but does not replicate in dog, sheep, bovine and human cells.

Ovine adenovirus vectors overcome preexisting humoral immunity against human adenoviruses in vivo

Recombinant human adenoviruses (hAd) have become widely used as tools to achieve efficient gene transfer. However, successful application of hAd-derived vectors in clinical trials is limited due to immunological and potential safety problems inherent in their human origin. In this study, we describe a recombinant ovine adenovirus (OAV) as an alternative vector for gene transfer in vivo. In contrast to an hAd vector, the OAV vector was not neutralized by human sera. An OAV vector which contained the cDNA of the human alpha1-antitrypsin (hAAT) gene linked to the Rous sarcoma virus promoter was generated and administered systemically to mice. The level and duration of hAAT gene expression was similar to that achieved with an hAd counterpart in both immunocompetent and immunodeficient mice. However, the tissue distribution of the OAV vector differed from that observed for hAd vectors in that the liver was not the dominant target. Significantly, we demonstrated efficient gene transfer with the OAV vector into mice immunized with hAd vectors and vice versa. We also confirm that the immune response to a transgene product can prevent its functional expression following sequential application of a vector. Our results suggest a possible solution to endemic humoral immunity against currently used hAd vectors and should therefore have an impact on the design of improved gene therapy protocols utilizing adenovirus vectors.

Mutational analysis of the avian adenovirus CELO, which provides a basis for gene delivery vectors

The avian adenovirus CELO is being developed as a gene transfer tool. Using homologous recombination in Escherichia coli, the CELO genome was screened for regions that could be deleted and would tolerate the insertion of a marker gene (luciferase or enhanced green fluorescent protein). For each mutant genome, the production of viable virus able to deliver the transgene to target cells was monitored. A series of mutants in the genome identified a set of open reading frames that could be deleted but which must be supplied in trans for virus replication. A region of the genome which is dispensable for viral replication and allows the insertion of an expression cassette was identified and a vector based on this mutation was evaluated as a gene delivery reagent. Transduction of avian cells occurs at 10- to 100-fold greater efficiency (per virus particle) than with an adenovirus type 5 (Ad5)-based vector carrying the same expression cassette. Most important for gene transfer applications, the CELO vector transduced mammalian cells as efficiently as an Ad5 vector. The CELO vector is exceptionally stable, can be grown inexpensively in chicken embryos, and provides a useful alternative to Ad5-based vectors.

Altered tropism of an ovine adenovirus carrying the fiber protein cell binding domain of human adenovirus type 5

Ovine adenovirus OAV287 (OAV) is phylogenetically and serotypically distinct from human Ad5. OAV grows productively in CSL503 foetal ovine lung cells and abortively infects several human cell lines. OAV has a unique fiber and a penton protein that lacks a recognisable integrin-binding motif. It is not known whether a secondary receptor is required for infection. A hybrid virus was constructed in which the cell binding domain on the OAV fiber protein was exchanged for the equivalent region from human adenovirus type 5. The hybrid OAV grew to titres that were 1 to 2 log10 lower than wild-type OAV in permissive ovine cells. Human Ad5 also infected CSL503 cells but failed to compete with OAV for receptor binding sites on those cells. However, the hybrid virus did compete with Ad5, consistent with its use of the Ad primary receptor. The hybrid virus was also neutralised by Ad5 antiserum whereas OAV was not. Human 293 kidney and LNCaP prostate cell lines that were not detectably infected by OAV were infected by the hybrid virus and other human prostate and breast cancer cell lines showed greatly enhanced infectivity. Thus, modification of the fiber cell binding domain was sufficient to profoundly alter the tropism of OAV, suggesting that the interaction between the primary receptor and the virus particle is the major factor controlling virus entry during infection.

Identification of transcripts and promoter regions of ovine adenovirus OAV287

The ovine adenovirus isolated OAV287 represents a new group of adenoviruses that are distinct from the Mast- and Aviadenoviruses by several criteria, including genome arrangement. The OAV major late promoter and some late transcripts were previously mapped. To better define the probable coding sequences and to identify the approximate location of early promoters a partial transcription map of the genome was elucidated using a PCR-based approach. This was possible because the complete nucleotide sequence of the genome was known. The strategy permitted the identification of transcription start sites and RNA splice junctions and allowed the approximate location of promoters in the lefthand end, IVa2, E2, P32K, and E4 regions to be deduced. The data showed that lefthand end and E4 regions are controlled by three and two temporally distinct promoters, respectively. The E2 region is controlled by a single promoter, in contrast to Mastadenoviruses, where E2 expression is controlled by the E2A and E2B promoters. The p32kDa structural protein at the lefthand end and the IVa2 protein are also expressed from their own promoters. These data contribute to the first overview of transcription from a non-Mastadenovirus genome.