Dissimilar immunogenicities of human papillomavirus E7 and adenovirus E1A proteins influence primary tumor development

E1A oncogene induced sensitization to NK cell induced apoptosis requires PIDD and Caspase-2

Expression of the adenovirus E1A oncogene sensitizes tumor cells to innate immune rejection by NK cells. This increased NK sensitivity is only partly explained by an E1A-induced increase in target cell surface expression of NKG2D ligands. The post-recognition mechanisms by which E1A sensitizes cells to the apoptotic cell death response to NK injury remains to be defined. E1A sensitizes cells to apoptotic stimuli through two distinct mechanisms-repression of NF-κB-dependent antiapoptotic responses and enhancement of caspase-2 activation and related mitochondrial injury. The current studies examined the roles of each of these post-NKG2D-recognition pathways in the increased sensitivity of E1A-positive target cells to NK killing. Sensitization to NK-induced apoptosis was independent of E1A-mediated repression of cellular NF-κB responses but was dependent on the expression of both caspase-2 and the upstream, caspase-2 activating molecule, PIDD. Target cells lacking caspase-2 or PIDD expression retained E1A-induced increased expression of the NKG2D ligand, RAE-1. NK cell-induced mitochondrial injury of E1A-expressing cells did not require expression of the mitochondrial molecules, Bak or Bax. These results define a PIDD/caspase-2-dependent pathway, through which E1A sensitizes cells to NK-mediated cytolysis independently of and complementarily to E1A-enhanced NKG2D/RAE-1 ligand expression.

Adenovirus serotype 5 E1A expressing tumor cells elicit a tumor-specific CD8+ T cell response independent of NKG2D

The expression of the Adenovirus serotype 2 or serotype 5 (Ad2/5) E1A gene in tumor cells upregulates ligands that are recognized by the NKG2D activating receptor, which is expressed on NK cells and T cells, and reduces their tumorigenicity, a process dependent on NK cells and T cells. In some model systems, the forced overexpression of NKG2D ligands on tumor cells induced antigen-specific CD8+ T cells that mediated anti-tumor immunity. We wanted to determine if the interaction of NKG2D ligands on tumor cells that express E1A with NKG2D on immune cells contributed to the ability of E1A to induce a CD8+ T cell anti-tumor response or reduce tumorigenicity. To address these questions, we used the MCA-205 tumor cell line or MCA-205 cells that expressed Ad5 E1A (MCA-205-E1A cells), a fusion protein of E1A and ovalbumin (MCA-205-E1A-OVA) or OVA (MCA-205-OVA). We found that the expression of E1A or E1A–OVA, but not OVA, upregulated the expression of the NKG2D ligand RAE-1 on the surface of MCA-205 cells. Additionally, MCA-205-E1A cells and MCA-205-E1A-OVA cells were more sensitive to NK cell lysis than MCA-205 or MCA-205-OVA cells in WT B6 mice, but not NKG2D deficient B6 mice. Next, we adoptively transferred WT or NKG2D deficient OT-1 T cells (CD8 T cells that recognize OVA residues 257–264) into WT B6 mice or B6 mice that were deficient in NKG2D respectively and measured the expansion of OT-1 cells following immunization with MCA-205-E1A-OVA or MCA-205-OVA cells. We found that the expansion of OT-1 cells following immunization of either OVA-expressing MCA-205 cell lines was not affected by the presence or absence of NKG2D in B6 mice. Finally, we found that the capacity of E1A to reduce the tumorigenicity of MCA-205 cells was not impaired in B6-NKG2D deficient mice as compared to WT B6 mice. Our results suggest that the ability of E1A to reduce the tumorigenicity of MCA-205 cells, or induce an antigen-specific CD8+ T cell response, is independent of the interaction of NKG2D ligands with the NKG2D receptor.

A mouse strain defective in both T cells and NK cells has enhanced sensitivity to tumor induction by plasmid DNA expressing both activated H-Ras and c-Myc

As part of safety studies to evaluate the risk of residual cellular DNA in vaccines manufactured in tumorigenic cells, we have been developing in vivo assays to detect and quantify the oncogenic activity of DNA. We generated a plasmid expressing both an activated human H-ras gene and murine c-myc gene and showed that 1 µg of this plasmid, pMSV-T24-H-ras/MSV-c-myc, was capable of inducing tumors in newborn NIH Swiss mice. However, to be able to detect the oncogenicity of dominant activated oncogenes in cellular DNA, a more sensitive system was needed. In this paper, we demonstrate that the newborn CD3 epsilon transgenic mouse, which is defective in both T-cell and NK-cell functions, can detect the oncogenic activity of 25 ng of the circular form of pMSV-T24-H-ras/MSV-c-myc. When this plasmid was inoculated as linear DNA, amounts of DNA as low as 800 pg were capable of inducing tumors. Animals were found that had multiple tumors, and these tumors were independent and likely clonal. These results demonstrate that the newborn CD3 epsilon mouse is highly sensitive for the detection of oncogenic activity of DNA. To determine whether it can detect the oncogenic activity of cellular DNA derived from four human tumor-cell lines (HeLa, A549, HT-1080, and CEM), DNA (100 µg) was inoculated into newborn CD3 epsilon mice both in the presence of 1 µg of linear pMSV-T24-H-ras/MSV-c-myc as positive control and in its absence. While tumors were induced in 100% of mice with the positive-control plasmid, no tumors were induced in mice receiving any of the tumor DNAs alone. These results demonstrate that detection of oncogenes in cellular DNA derived from four human tumor-derived cell lines in this mouse system was not possible; the results also show the importance of including a positive-control plasmid to detect inhibitory effects of the cellular DNA.

Possible role of arginase-1 in concomitant tumor immunity

The expression of Adenovirus serotype 2 or serotype 5 (Ad2/5) E1A in tumor cells reduces their tumorigenicity in vivo by enhancing the NK cell mediated and T cell mediated anti-tumor immune response, an activity that correlates with the ability of E1A to bind p300. We determined if E1A could be used as a molecular adjuvant to enhance antigen-specific T cell responses to a model tumor antigen, ovalbumin (OVA). To achieve this goal, we stably expressed a fusion protein of E1A and OVA (MCA-205-E1A-OVA), OVA (MCA-205-OVA) or a mutant version of E1A unable to bind p300 and OVA (E1A-Δp300-OVA) in the B6-derived, highly tumorigenic MCA-205 tumor cell line. MCA-205-E1A-OVA tumor cells were over 10,000 fold less tumorigenic than MCA-205-OVA, MCA-205-E1A-Δp300-OVA, or MCA-205 in B6 mice. However, immunization of B6 mice with live MCA-205-OVA, MCA-205-E1A-Δp300-OVA and MCA-E1A-OVA tumor cells induced nearly equivalent OVA-specific CD4 T cells and CD8 CTL responses. Further studies revealed that mice with primary, enlarging MCA-205-OVA or MCA-205-E1A-Δp300-OVA tumors on one flank exhibited OVA-specific anti-tumor T cell responses that rejected a tumorigenic dose of MCA-205-OVA cells on the contralateral flank (concomitant tumor immunity). Next we found that tumor associated macrophages (TAMs) in progressive MCA-205-OVA tumors, but not MCA-205-E1A-OVA tumors that expressed high levels of arginase-1, which is known to have local immunosuppressive activities. In summary, immunization of mice with MCA-205 cells expressing OVA, E1A-Δp300-OVA or E1A-OVA induced equivalent OVA-specific CD4 and CD8 anti-tumor responses. TAMs found in MCA-205-OVA, but not MCA-205-E1A-OVA, tumors expressed high levels of arginase-1. We hypothesize that the production of arginase-1 by TAMs in MCA-205-OVA or MCA-205-E1A-Δp300-OVA tumor cells leads to an ineffective anti-tumor immune response in the tumor microenvironment, but does not result in inhibition of a systemic anti-tumor immunity.

Tumorigenic adenovirus 12 cells evade NK cell lysis by reducing the expression of NKG2D ligands

Activation of natural killer (NK) cells depends on a balance between signals received from activation and inhibitory ligands expressed on the surface of target cells. Tumorigenic human adenovirus 12 (Ad12) transformed cells express low levels of the NK cell inhibitory ligand MHC I, but do not exhibit increased sensitivity to NK cell lysis compared to their non-tumorigenic counterparts. Analysis of the expression of activation ligands that bind to the NKG2D receptor revealed that RAE1β and H60 were reduced on the surface of Ad12 mouse cells as well as at the level of transcription. In accord with these results, RAE1 localization to the synapse and sensitivity to NK cell cytotoxicity were also diminished. The reduced transcription of the rat NKG2D ligands, RAEt1L and RRTL, in tumorigenic rat cells compared to non-tumorigenic counterparts implies that both mouse and rat cell lines share a common mechanism of NKG2D ligand activation subverted by Ad12.

Measurement of natural-killer cell lytic activity of adenovirus-infected or adenovirus-transformed cells

Natural-killer (NK) cells are lymphocytes that do not express the CD3 T-cell receptor but do express the CD16 (FcgammaRIII) and CD56 (isoform of NCAM) in humans or NK1.1 antigen in certain strains of mice. NK cells display spontaneous lytic activity but do not exhibit immunological memory. NK cells are important mediators of antiviral and antitumor immunity. Standard NK cytolysis assays measure the ability of NK cells to kill certain target cells (tumor cells, virally infected cells) in short-term (usually 4-6 h) cytolysis assays. This chapter details the use of the NK cell cytolysis assay using polyclonal populations of human or rodent NK cells.

The interaction of adenovirus E1A with p300 family members modulates cellular gene expression to reduce tumorigenicity

The use of adenovirus serotype 2 or 5 (Ad2/5) E1A as therapy for human malignancy requires an understanding of the mechanisms involved in E1A-induced tumor suppression. The prevailing use of E1A in the treatment of human malignancy stresses the non-immunologically mediated, anti-tumorigenic activities of E1A. However, the capacity of E1A to elicit a NK-cell and T-cell anti-tumor immune response and to sensitize tumor cells to lysis by immune effector molecules utilized by NK cells and T cells is also an important component of the anti-tumorigenic activity of E1A. This immune-mediated anti-tumorigenic activity of E1A is not shared by functionally similar viral oncoproteins such as the human papillomavirus type 16 (HPV16) E7 oncoprotein and is dependent on the capacity of E1A to interact with transcriptional coadapter, p300. To further define the molecular mechanisms whereby E1A reduces tumorigenicity, we compared total cellular gene expression in H4 cells, a human fibrosarcoma cell line, to gene expression in H4 cells stably expressing E1A, E7, or mutant forms of E1A that do not bind p300. The expression of E1A, but not E7, in H4 cells modulated the expression of cellular genes that may promote apoptosis, enhance immunogenicity and reduce tumor cell metastasis. The difference in the ability of E1A and E7 to modulate the expression of cellular genes that may influence tumorigenicity was largely attributable to distinct interactions of E1A and E7 with p300. Results of this study will be useful in designing novel strategies to augment the anti-tumorigenic activities of E1A.

Adenovirus serotype 5 E1A sensitizes tumor cells to NKG2D-dependent NK cell lysis and tumor rejection

The expression of the Adenovirus serotype 5 (Ad5) E1A oncogene sensitizes tumor cells to natural killer (NK) cell–mediated killing and tumor rejection in vivo. These effects are dependent on the ability of E1A to bind the transcriptional coadaptor protein p300. To test the hypothesis that E1A up-regulates ligands recognized by the NKG2D-activating receptor, we stably transfected the highly tumorigenic mouse fibrosarcoma cell line MCA-205 with Ad5-E1A or a mutant form of E1A that does not interact with p300 (E1A-Δp300). Ad5-E1A, but not E1A-Δp300, up-regulated the expression of the NKG2D ligand retinoic acid early inducible (RAE)-1, but not murine ULBP-like transcript 1, another NKG2D ligand, in four independently derived MCA-205 transfectants. The up-regulation of RAE-1 by E1A targeted MCA-205 tumor cells to lysis by NK cells, resulting in NKG2D-dependent tumor rejection in vivo. Moreover, the up-regulation of NKG2D ligands by E1A was not limited to mouse tumor cells, as E1A also increased the expression of NKG2D ligands on primary baby mouse kidney cells, human MB435S breast cancer cells, and human H4 fibrosarcoma cells.

Macrophages kill human papillomavirus type 16 E6-expressing tumor cells by tumor necrosis factor alpha- and nitric oxide-dependent mechanisms

The expression of adenovirus serotype 2 or 5 (Ad2/5) E1A sensitizes cells to killing by NK cells and activated macrophages, a property that correlates with the ability of E1A to bind the transcriptional coadaptor proteins p300-CBP. The E6 oncoproteins derived from the high-risk human papillomaviruses (HPV) interact with p300 and can complement mutant forms of E1A that cannot interact with p300 to induce cellular immortalization. Therefore, we determined if HPV type 16 (HPV16) E6 could sensitize cells to killing by macrophages and NK cells. HPV16 E6 expression sensitized human (H4 and C33A) and murine (MCA-102) cell lines to lysis by macrophages but not by NK cells. The lysis of cells that expressed E6 by macrophages was p53 independent but dependent on the production of tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha) or nitric oxide (NO) by macrophages. Unlike cytolysis assays with macrophages, E6 expression did not significantly sensitize cells to lysis by the direct addition of NO or TNF-alpha. Like E1A, E6 has been reported to sensitize cells to lysis by TNF-alpha by inhibiting the TNF-alpha-induced activation of NF-kappaB. We found that E1A, but not E6, blocked the TNF-alpha-induced activation of NF-kappaB, an activity that correlated with E1A-p300 binding. In summary, Ad5 E1A and HPV16 E6 sensitized cells to lysis by macrophages. Unlike E1A, E6 did not block the ability of TNF-alpha to activate NF-kappaB or sensitize cells to lysis by NK cells, TNF-alpha, or NO. Thus, there appears to be a spectrum of common and unique biological activities that result as a consequence of the interaction of E6 or E1A with p300-CBP.

Expression of an E1A/E7 chimeric protein sensitizes tumor cells to killing by activated macrophages but not NK cells

Adenovirus (Ad) E1A and human papillomavirus (HPV) E7 express homologous conserved regions (CRs) that mediate their shared biological functions. Despite their similarities, the expression of E1A sensitizes tumor cells to killing by NK cells and macrophages but the expression of E7 does not, a factor that may contribute to the dissimilar oncogenicities of Ad and HPV. This study was undertaken to define molecular differences between E1A and E7 that are responsible for the ability of E1A and the inability of E7 to sensitize cells to killing by NK cells and macrophages. Genetic mapping studies using human fibrosarcoma cells (H4) that stably expressed mutant forms of E1A showed that only those forms of E1A that interacted with the transcriptional coadaptor protein p300 sensitized cells to killing by NK cells and macrophages. E7 lacks the N-terminal p300-binding region present in E1A. Therefore, a chimeric E1A/E7 gene was constructed that included the N terminus and the CR1 (p300-binding) domain of E1A fused to CR2 and the C-terminal sequences of E7. The E1A/E7 protein interacted with p300 and pRb and immortalized primary mouse embryo fibroblasts (MEF). The expression of E1A/E7 sensitized H4 and MEF cells to killing by activated macrophages but not to killing by NK cells. Therefore, N-terminal differences between E1A and E7 that map to the E1A-p300 binding region accounted for differences in their abilities to sensitize cells to killing by macrophages. However, regions in addition to the E1A-p300 binding region are required to sensitize cells to killing by NK cells.

Adenovirus E1A, not human papillomavirus E7, sensitizes tumor cells to lysis by macrophages through nitric oxide- and TNF-alpha-dependent mechanisms despite up-regulation of 70-kDa heat shock protein

Expression of adenovirus (Ad) serotype 2 or 5 (Ad2/5) E1A or human papillomavirus (HPV)16 E7 reportedly sensitizes cells to lysis by macrophages. Macrophages possess several mechanisms to kill tumor cells including TNF-alpha, NO, reactive oxygen intermediates (ROI), and Fas ligand (FasL). E1A sensitizes cells to apoptosis by TNF-alpha, and macrophages kill E1A-expressing cells, in part through the elaboration of TNF-alpha. However, E1A also up-regulates the expression of 70-kDa heat shock protein, a protein that inhibits killing by TNF-alpha and NO, thereby protecting cells from lysis by macrophages. Unlike E1A, E7 does not sensitize cells to killing by TNF-alpha, and the effector mechanism(s) used by macrophages to kill E7-expressing cells remain undefined. The purpose of this study was to further define the capacity of and the effector mechanisms used by macrophages to kill tumor cells that express Ad5 E1A or HPV16 E7. We found that Ad5 E1A, but not HPV16 E7, sensitized tumor cells to lysis by macrophages. Using macrophages derived from mice unable to make TNF-alpha, NO, ROI, or FasL, we determined that macrophages used NO, and to a lesser extent TNF-alpha, but not FasL or ROI, to kill E1A-expressing cells. Through the use of S-nitroso-N-acetylpenicillamine, which releases NO upon exposure to an aqueous environment, E1A was shown to directly sensitize tumor cells to NO-induced death. E1A sensitized tumor cells to lysis by macrophages despite up-regulating the expression of 70-kDa heat shock protein. In summary, E1A, but not E7, sensitized tumor cells to lysis by macrophages. Macrophages killed E1A-expressing cells through NO- and TNF-alpha-dependent mechanisms.

Evasion of host immunity directed by papillomavirus-encoded proteins

The nature of the interaction between papillomaviruses (PV) and their infected host has led to the identification of ways in which the viral oncoproteins can transform the infected host cells into cancer cells. As viral persistence is required for malignancy, and persistence requires avoidance of immune attack by the host, defining the relationship between PV and the immune system is also paramount in understanding tumorigenesis. It has emerged that PV have evolved several ways in which to prevent clearance by the host immune system. The limitation of the PV replication cycle to the epithelium, together with low level expression of the virus proteins and an absence of inflammation, minimises the exposure of virus to immune cells. In addition, more recently it has been shown that, like many other viruses, PV can directly subvert the immune response, including interference with the interferon pathway, modulation of antigen presentation, inhibition of interleukin-18 activity and down-regulation of major histocompatibility class I on infected cells. Collectively these mechanisms explain how PV lesions are able to persist for long periods of time in immunocompetent hosts.

Role of the E1A Rb-binding domain in repression of the NF-kappa B-dependent defense against tumor necrosis factor-alpha

The adenoviral E1A oncogene sensitizes mammalian cells to tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha), in part by repressing the nuclear factor-kappa B (NF-kappa B)-dependent defense against this cytokine. Other E1A activities involve binding to either p300/cyclic AMP response element-binding protein (CBP) or retinoblastoma (Rb)-family proteins, but the roles of E1A interactions with these transcriptional regulators in sensitizing cells to TNF-alpha are unclear. E1A expression did not block upstream events in TNF-alpha-induced activation of NF-kappa B in NIH 3T3 cells, including degradation of I kappa B-alpha, nuclear translocation of NF-kappa B subunits, and their dimeric binding to kappa B sequences in the nucleus. However, E1A markedly repressed NF-kappa B-dependent transcription and sensitized cells to TNF-alpha induced apoptosis. These E1A effects were selective for kappa B-dependent transcription and for the function of the NF-kappa B p65/RelA subunit. A four amino acid E1A deletion that eliminates binding to Rb-family proteins blocked both repression of TNF-alpha-induced transcription and sensitization to apoptosis. In contrast, mutations that eliminate E1A binding to p300/CBP (coactivators of p65/RelA) did not affect either E1A activity. These data suggest that E1A-Rb-binding blocks the NF-kappa B-dependent activation response to TNF-alpha by altering the function of p65/RelA at a stage after formation of the transcription factor-enhancer complex. These observations also open questions about the general role of Rb-family proteins in modulation of NF-kappa B-dependent transcription.

MHC class I molecules on adenovirus E1A-expressing tumor cells inhibit NK cell killing but not NK cell-mediated tumor rejection

Expression of adenovirus E1A gene products in tumor cells enhances NK cell lysis in vitro and NK-mediated rejection in vivo, despite increasing class I molecules on tumor cells. It is unclear why the increased expression of MHC class I molecules does not appear to confer resistance to killing by NK cells. One possibility is the unique capacity of E1A to sensitize cells to multiple NK cell killing mechanisms including perforin/granzyme, Fas ligand, tumor necrosis factor-alpha and TRAIL. To examine this issue, MCA-102-E1A tumor cells (H-2(b)) that express E1A and are NK sensitive were transfected with H-2D(d), the ligand for the NK inhibitory receptor, Ly49A. Expression of H-2D(d) molecules by MCA-102-E1A cells protected them from lysis by a Ly49A(+) NK cell clone and Ly49A(+) NK cells isolated from C57BL/6 nude mice. In contrast, NK cell-mediated rejection of MCA-102-E1A tumor cells was not inhibited by the expression of H-2D(d) molecules, nor was killing by polyclonal populations of NK cells isolated from C57BL/6-nude mice. H-2D(d) interacts with several inhibitory Ly49 receptors that are non-clonally expressed on NK cells in C57BL/6 mice: Ly49A (20% of NK cells), Ly49G2 (54% of NK cells) and Ly49C/I (47% of NK cells). Our data indicate that while E1A sensitizes cells to NK cell killing, it does not interfere with signal transduction by inhibitory NK receptors. Therefore, a small population of NK cells that do not express Ly49A, Ly49G2 or Ly49C/I inhibitory receptors are likely responsible for the rejection of MCA-102-E1A-D(d) tumor cells in vivo.