The Difficulties in Comparing In Vivo Oxygen Measurements

Contribution of Harold M. Swartz to In Vivo EPR and EPR Dosimetry

In 2015, we are celebrating half a century of research in the application of Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (EPR) as a biodosimetry tool to evaluate the dose received by irradiated people. During the EPR Biodose 2015 meeting, a special session was organized to acknowledge the pioneering contribution of Harold M. (Hal) Swartz in the field. The article summarizes his main contribution in physiology and medicine. Four emerging themes have been pursued continuously along his career since its beginning: (1) radiation biology; (2) oxygen and oxidation; (3) measuring physiology in vivo; and (4) application of these measurements in clinical medicine. The common feature among all these different subjects has been the use of magnetic resonance techniques, especially EPR. In this article, you will find an impressionist portrait of Hal Swartz with the description of the 'making of' this pioneer, a time-line perspective on his career with the creation of three National Institutes of Health-funded EPR centers, a topic-oriented perspective on his career with a description of his major contributions to Science, his role as a mentor and his influence on his academic children, his active role as founder of scientific societies and organizer of scientific meetings, and the well-deserved international recognition received so far.

Microvascular and mitochondrial PO(2) simultaneously measured by oxygen-dependent delayed luminescence

Measurement of tissue oxygenation is a complex task and various techniques have led to a wide range of tissue PO(2) values and contradictory results. Tissue is compartmentalized in microcirculation, interstitium and intracellular space and current techniques are biased towards a certain compartment. Simultaneous oxygen measurements in various compartments might be of great benefit for our understanding of determinants of tissue oxygenation. Here we report simultaneous measurement of microvascular PO(2) (μPO(2) ) and mitochondrial PO(2) (mitoPO(2) ) in rats. The μPO(2) measurements are based on oxygen-dependent quenching of phosphorescence of the near-infrared phosphor Oxyphor G2. The mitoPO(2) measurements are based on oxygen-dependent quenching of delayed fluorescence of protoporphyrin IX (PpIX). Favorable spectral properties of these porphyrins allow simultaneous measurement of the delayed luminescence lifetimes. A dedicated fiber-based time-domain setup consisting of a tunable pulsed laser, 2 red-sensitive gated photomultiplier tubes and a simultaneous sampling data-acquisition system is described in detail. The absence of cross talk between the channels is shown and the feasibility of simultaneous μPO(2) and mitoPO(2) measurements is demonstrated in rat liver in vivo. It is anticipated that this novel approach will greatly contribute to our understanding of tissue oxygenation in physiological and pathological circumstances.

Detection and characterization of tumor hypoxia using pO2 histography

Data from 125 studies describing the pretreatment oxygenation status as measured in the clinical setting using the computerized Eppendorf pO2 histography system have been compiled in this article. Tumor oxygenation is heterogeneous and severely compromised as compared to normal tissue. Hypoxia results from inadequate perfusion and diffusion within tumors and from a reduced O2 transport capacity in anemic patients. The development of tumor hypoxia is independent of a series of relevant tumor characteristics (e.g., clinical size, stage, histology, and grade) and various patient demographics. Overall median pO2 in cancers of the uterine cervix, head and neck, and breast is 10 mm Hg with the overall hypoxic fraction (pO2 <or= 2.5 mm Hg) being approx. 25%. Metastatic lesions do not substantially deviate from the oxygenation status of (their) primary tumors. Whereas normal tissue oxygenation is independent of the hemoglobin level over the range of 8-15 g/dL, hypoxia is more pronounced in anemic patients and above this range in some cancers. Identification of tumor hypoxia may allow an assessment of a tumor's potential to develop an aggressive phenotype or acquired treatment resistance, both of which lead to poor prognosis. Detection of hypoxia in the clinical setting may therefore be helpful in selecting high-risk patients for individual and/or more intensive treatment schedules.

Hypoxia: importance in tumor biology, noninvasive measurement by imaging, and value of its measurement in the management of cancer therapy

PURPOSE

The Cancer Imaging Program of the National Cancer Institute convened a workshop to assess the current status of hypoxia imaging, to assess what is known about the biology of hypoxia as it relates to cancer and cancer therapy, and to define clinical scenarios in which in vivo hypoxia imaging could prove valuable.

RESULTS

Hypoxia, or low oxygenation, has emerged as an important factor in tumor biology and response to cancer treatment. It has been correlated with angiogenesis, tumor aggressiveness, local recurrence, and metastasis, and it appears to be a prognostic factor for several cancers, including those of the cervix, head and neck, prostate, pancreas, and brain. The relationship between tumor oxygenation and response to radiation therapy has been well established, but hypoxia also affects and is affected by some chemotherapeutic agents. Although hypoxia is an important aspect of tumor physiology and response to treatment, the lack of simple and efficient methods to measure and image oxygenation hampers further understanding and limits their prognostic usefulness. There is no gold standard for measuring hypoxia; Eppendorf measurement of pO(2) has been used, but this method is invasive. Recent studies have focused on molecular markers of hypoxia, such as hypoxia inducible factor 1 (HIF-1) and carbonic anhydrase isozyme IX (CA-IX), and on developing noninvasive imaging techniques.

CONCLUSIONS

This workshop yielded recommendations on using hypoxia measurement to identify patients who would respond best to radiation therapy, which would improve treatment planning. This represents a narrow focus, as hypoxia measurement might also prove useful in drug development and in increasing our understanding of tumor biology.

Past, present, and future of oxygen in cancer research

The first pathologists, oncologists, and medical physicists were aware that tumors were populated by an aberrant vasculature. The classic observations of Thomlinson and Gray in the 1950's established that O2 diffusion distances caused tumor to grow in cords. Tumor necrosis was observed surrounding a Krogh cylinder of viable tumor. That work helped explain earlier work by Warburg, who demonstrated a predisposition for tumors to favor anaerobic respiration, and it became the basis for 5 decades of subsequent research aimed at improving tumor oxygenation at the time of radiation. The role of O2 in modifying radiation response was attributed exclusively to the reactive free radicals that can be formed when O2 is present. These radicals produce approximately three-fold more irreparable double strand breaks in DNA. Subsequently it became clear that tumor had nutritional insufficiencies in addition to hypoxia. Ischemic regions are hypoglycemic, acidotic, have poor penetration of drugs, increased interstitial pressure, and altered immunological states. Ischemic regions can have intermittent reflow and associated redox stress. The relative impact of O2 compared to these associated phenomenon, and the degree to which hypoxia causes or follows these associated physiologic stresses, have been studied in detail. ISOTT scientists are responsible for much of the elucidation of the specific effects of O2, ADP/ATP ratios, hypoglycemia, and acidosis on tumor responses to radiation and hyperthermia. Many questions still remain.