Respiratory gas exchange and inert gas retention during partial liquid ventilation

Pulmonary applications of perfluorochemical liquids: ventilation and beyond

In this review of liquid ventilation, concepts and applications are presented that summarise the pulmonary applications of perfluorochemical liquids. Beginning with the question of whether this alternative form of respiratory support is needed and ending with lessons learned from clinical trials, the various methods of liquid assisted ventilation are compared and contrasted, evidence for mechanoprotective and cytoprotective attributes of intrapulmonary perfluorochemical liquid are presented and alternative intrapulmonary applications, including their use as vehicles for drugs, for thermal control and as imaging agents are presented.

Continuous tracheal gas insufflation during partial liquid ventilation in juvenile rabbits with acute lung injury

To examine the hypothesis that combined treatment with tracheal gas insufflation (TGI) and partial liquid ventilation (PLV) may improve pulmonary outcome relative to either treatment alone in acute lung injury (ALI), saline lavage lung injury was induced in 24 anesthetized, ventilated juvenile rabbits that were then randomly assigned to receive ( n = 6/group) 1) conventional mechanical ventilation (CMV) alone, 2) continuous TGI at 0.5 l/min, 3) PLV with perfluorochemical liquid, and 4) combined TGI and PLV (TGI + PLV), and subsequently ventilated with minimized pressures and tidal volume (Vt) to keep arterial Po2 (PaO2) >100 Torr and arterial Pco2 (PaCO2) at 45-60 Torr for 4 h. Gas exchange, lung mechanics, myeloperoxidase, IL-8, and histomorphometry [including expansion index (EI)] were assessed. The CMV group showed no improvement in lung mechanics and gas exchange; all treated groups had significant increases in compliance, PaO2, ventilation efficacy index (VEI), and EI, and decreases in PaCO2, oxygenation index, physiological dead space-to-Vt ratio (Vd/Vt), myeloperoxidase, and IL-8, relative to the CMV group. TGI resulted in lower peak inspiratory pressure, Vt, Vd/Vt, and greater VEI vs. PLV group; PLV resulted in greater compliance, PaO2, and EI vs. TGI. TGI + PLV resulted in decreased peak inspiratory pressure, Vt, Vd/Vt, and increased VEI compared with TGI, improved compliance and EI compared with PLV, and a further increase in PaO2 and oxygenation index and a decrease in PaCO2 vs. either treatment alone. These results indicate that combined treatment of TGI and PLV results in improved pulmonary outcome than either treatment alone in this animal model of ALI.

Distribution dynamics of perfluorocarbon delivery to the lungs: an intact rabbit model

Motivated by the goal of understanding how to most homogeneously fill the lungs with perfluorocarbon for liquid ventilation, we investigate the transport of liquid instilled into the lungs using an intact rabbit model. Perfluorocarbon is instilled into the trachea of the ventilated animal. Radiographic images of the perfluorocarbon distribution are obtained at a rate of 30 frames/s during the filling process. Image analysis is used to quantify the liquid distribution (center of mass, spatial standard deviation, skewness, kurtosis, and indicators of homogeneity) as time progresses. We compare the distribution dynamics in supine animals to those in upright animals for three constant infusion rates of perfluorocarbon: 15, 40, and 60 ml/min. It is found that formation of liquid plugs in large airways, which is affected by posture and infusion rate, can result in a more homogeneous liquid distribution than gravity drainage alone. The supine posture resulted in more homogeneous filling of the lungs than did upright posture, in which the lungs tend to fill in the inferior regions first. Faster instillation of perfluorocarbon results in liquid plugs forming in large airways and, consequently, more uniform distribution of perfluorocarbon than slower instillation rates in the upright animals.

Steady-state pleural fluid flow and pressure and the effects of lung buoyancy

Both theoretical and experimental studies of pleural fluid dynamics and lung buoyancy during steady-state, apneic conditions are presented. The theory shows that steady-state, top-to-bottom pleural-liquid flow creates a pressure distribution that opposes lung buoyancy. These two forces may balance, permitting dynamic lung floating, but when they do not, pleural-pleural contact is required. The animal experiments examine pleural-liquid pressure distributions in response to simulated reduced gravity, achieved by lung inflation with perfluorocarbon liquid as compared to air. The resulting decrease in lung buoyancy modifies the force balance in the pleural fluid, which is reflected in its vertical pressure gradient. The data and model show that the decrease in buoyancy with perfluorocarbon inflation causes the vertical pressure gradient to approach hydrostatic. In the microgravity analogue, the pleural pressures would be toward a more uniform distribution, consistent with ventilation studies during space flight. The pleural liquid turnover predicted by the model is computed and found to be comparable to experimental values from the literature. The model provides the flow field, which can be used to develop a full transport theory for molecular and cellular constituents that are found in pleural fluid.

Partial liquid ventilation in severely surfactant-depleted, spontaneously breathing rabbits supported by proportional assist ventilation

OBJECTIVE

We hypothesized that partial liquid ventilation (PLV) would improve oxygenation in nonparalyzed, surfactant-deficient rabbits breathing spontaneously while supported by proportional assist ventilation (PAV). This ventilation mode compensates for low pulmonary compliance and high resistance and thereby facilitates spontaneous breathing.

DESIGN

Randomized trial.

SETTING

University animal research facility.

SUBJECTS

Twenty-six anesthetized New Zealand white rabbits weighing 2592 +/- 237g (mean +/- sd).

INTERVENTIONS

After pulmonary lavage (target Pao2 <100 mm Hg on mechanical ventilation with 6 cm H2O of positive end-expiratory pressure [PEEP] and an Fio2 of 1.0), rabbits were randomized to PAV (PEEP of 8 cm H2O) with or without PLV. PLV rabbits received 25 mL/kg of perfluorocarbon by intratracheal infusion (1 mL/kg/min). Pao2, Paco2, tidal volume, respiratory rate, minute ventilation, mean airway pressure, arterial blood pressure, heart rate, pulmonary compliance, and airway resistance were measured. Evaporated perfluorocarbon was refilled every 30 mins in PLV animals. After 5 hrs, animals were killed and lungs were removed. Lung injury was evaluated using a histologic score.

MAIN RESULTS

Pao2 and compliance were significantly higher in PLV rabbits compared with controls (p <.05, analysis of variance for repeated measures). All other parameters were similar in both groups.

CONCLUSIONS

PLV improved oxygenation and pulmonary compliance in spontaneously breathing, severely surfactant-depleted rabbits supported by PAV. The severity of lung injury by histology was unaffected.

Modeling diffusion limitation of gas exchange in lungs containing perfluorocarbon

We reported changes in alveolar-arterial PO2 gradient, ventilation-perfusion heterogeneity, and arterial-alveolar PCO2 gradient during partial liquid ventilation (PLV) in healthy piglets (E. A. Mates, P. Tarczy-Hornoch, J. Hildebrandt, J. C. Jackson, and M. P. Hlastala. In: Oxygen Transport to Tissue XVII, edited by C. Ince. New York: Plenum, 1996, vol. 388, p. 585-597). Here we develop two mathematical models to predict transient and steady-state (SS) gas exchange conditions during PLV and to estimate the contribution of diffusion limitation to SS arterial-alveolar differences. In the simplest model, perfluorocarbon is represented as a uniform flat stirred layer and, in a more complex model, as an unstirred spherical layer in a ventilated terminal alveolar sac. Time-dependent solutions of both models show that SS is established for various inert and respiratory gases within 5-150 s. In fluid-filled unventilated terminal units, all times to SS increased sometimes by hours, e.g., SF6 exceeded 4 h. SS solutions for the ventilated spherical model predicted minor end-capillary disequilibrium of inert gases and significant disequilibrium of respiratory gases, which could explain a large portion of the arterial-alveolar PCO2 gradient measured during PLV (14). We conclude that, during PLV, diffusion gradients for gases are generally small, except for CO2.

Non-conventional respiratory support modalities applicable in the older child. High frequency ventilation and liquid ventilation

HFV, LV, and several other novel therapies offer promise to adults and children that the mortality associated with respiratory failure may be affected. Although there are several forms of HFV, HFOV is presently gaining favor in the treatment of severe respiratory failure and has generally supplanted HFJV in pediatric critical care. HFOV has the advantage of having an active expiratory phase, which helps to minimize air trapping and better modulate mean lung volume. Ventilators with sufficient power to perform HFOV in adults are currently under investigation, although there is a growing experience in using current ventilators in larger patients. To date, however, demonstration of lowered mortality with HFOV is lacking although intermediate outcome indicators are improved. PLV also offers promise in the treatment of ARF through its drastic ability to improve oxygenation, ventilation, and compliance in many lung injury models. Human trials are presently underway, but the optimal delivery of this novel therapy still necessitates extensive investigation. TLV is likely even more removed from general clinical application given the necessity of developing a new generation of ventilators for the delivery of liquid tidal volumes. How these and other modalities may piece together to improve the condition of our patients who have respiratory failure remains to be seen, but certainly, present and future investigation will be intriguing for years to come.

Surfactant replacement increases compliance in premature lamb lungs during partial liquid ventilation in situ

Treatments available to improve compliance in surfactant-deficient states include exogenous surfactant (ES) and either partial (PLV) or total liquid ventilation (TLV) with perfluorochemical (PFC). Because of the additional air-lung and air-PFC interfaces introduced during PLV compared with TLV, we hypothesized that compliance would be worse during PLV than during TLV. Because surfactant is able to reduce interfacial tension between air and lung as well as between PFC and lung, we further hypothesized that compliance would improve with surfactant treatment before PLV. In excised preterm lamb lungs, we used Survanta for surfactant replacement and perflubron as the PFC. Compliance during PLV was intermediate between TLV and gas inflation, both with and without surfactant. Surfactant improved compliance during PLV, compared with PLV alone. Because of the force-balance equation governing the behavior of immiscible droplets on liquid surfaces, we predict that PFC droplets spread during PLV to cover the alveolar surface in surfactant-deficient lungs during most of lung inflation and deflation but that the PFC would retract into droplets in surfactant-sufficient lungs, except at end inspiration.

Perfluorochemical rescue after surfactant treatment: effect of perflubron dose and ventilatory frequency

To test the hypotheses that perfluorochemical (PFC) liquid rescue after natural surfactant (SF) treatment would improve pulmonary function and histology and that this profile would be influenced by PFC dose or ventilator strategy, anesthetized preterm lambs (n = 31) with respiratory distress were studied using nonpreoxygenated perflubron. All animals received SF at 1 h and were randomized at 2 h as follows and studied to 4 h postnatal age: 1) conventional mechanical gas ventilation (n = 8), 2) 30 ml/kg perflubron with gas ventilation [partial liquid ventilation (PLV)] at 60 breaths/min (n = 8), 3) 10 ml/kg perflubron with PLV at 60 breaths/min (n = 7), and 4) 10 ml/kg perflubron with PLV at 30 breaths/min (n = 8). All animals tolerated instillation without additional cardiopulmonary instability. All perflubron-rescued groups demonstrated sustained improvement in gas exchange, respiratory compliance, and reduction in pressure requirements relative to animals receiving SF alone. Improvement was directly related to perflubron dose and breathing frequency; peak inspiratory pressure required to achieve physiological gas exchange was lower in the higher-dose and -frequency groups, and mean airway pressure was lower in the lower-frequency group. Lung expansion was greater and evidence of barotrauma was less in the higher-dose and -frequency group; regional differences in expansion were not different as a function of dose but were greater in the lower-frequency group. Regional differences in lung perflubron content were reduced in the higher-dose and -frequency groups and greatest in the lower-dose and -frequency group. The results suggest that, whereas PLV of the SF-treated lung improves gas exchange and lung mechanics, the protective benefits of perflubron in the lung may depend on dose and ventilator strategy to optimize PFC distribution and minimize exposure of the alveolar-capillary membrane to a gas-liquid interface.

Shunt and ventilation-perfusion distribution during partial liquid ventilation in healthy piglets

Replacing gas in the lung with perfluorocarbon fluids (PFC) and periodically ventilating with a gas [partial liquid ventilation (PLV)] has been shown to improve oxygenation in models of respiratory distress syndrome. We hypothesized that the addition of PFC to healthy lungs would result in shunt, diffusion impairment, and increased ventilation-perfusion (VA/Q) heterogeneity. Previously, Mates et al. showed that O2 shunt and arterial-alveolar CO2 difference increased linearly with dose in piglets given graded intratracheal doses of PFC (10, 20, and 30 ml/kg followed by mechanical ventilation with 100% O2) (E.A. Mates, J. C. Jackson, J. Hildebrandt, W. E. Truog, T. A. Standaert, and M. P. Hlastala. In: Oxygen Transport to Tissue XVI, 1994, p. 427-435). Here we report VA/Q distribution in the same animals, showing a 50% increase in VA/Q heterogeneity during PLV independent of PFC dose. Ventilation heterogeneity was the major factor in this increase, and there was no significant change in dead space ventilation. We also report on five animals given a single 20 ml/kg dose of PFC and followed for 3 h. They showed an increase in shunt during PLV but no change in arterial-alveolar CO2 difference.

Gas Exchange during Gas and Liquid Ventilation

Liquid Ventilation with perfluorochemicals (PFC) violates many of our long-held assumptions about how the lung functions. However, the technique has been so successful in animal models of lung disease that it is currently being tested in clinical trials for the treatment of infant and acute (“adult”) respiratory distress syndrome in newborns, children, and adults. A common feature of both infant and acute respiratory distress syndromes is an inability of the lung's surfactant system to adequately lower surface tension, leading to regions of atelectasis. Liquid ventilation with PFC appears to ameliorate the disease process by lowering interfacial tension in the lung, opening regions of atelectasis, and improving gas exchange. To understand how gas exchange is successful during liquid ventilation requires careful re-evaluation of the assumptions underlying our current models of gas exchange physiology during normal gas ventilation. These assumptions must then be examined in light of the alterations in pulmonary physiology during liquid ventilation.