Immunoglobulin light chain class multiplicity and alternative organizational forms in early vertebrate phylogeny

Systematic characterization of immunoglobulin loci and deep sequencing of the expressed repertoire in the Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua)

BACKGROUND

The Atlantic cod is a prolific species in the Atlantic, despite its inconsistent specific antibody response. It presents a peculiar case within vertebrate immunology due to its distinct immune system, characterized by the absence of MHCII antigen presentation pathway, required for T cell-dependent antibody responses. Thorough characterisation of immunoglobulin loci and analysis of the antibody repertoire is necessary to further our understanding of the Atlantic cod's immune response on a molecular level.

RESULTS

A comprehensive search of the cod genome (gadmor3.0) identified the complete set of IgH genes organized into three sequential translocons on chromosome 2, while IgL genes were located on chromosomes 2 and 5. The Atlantic cod displayed a moderate germline V gene diversity, comprising four V gene families for both IgH and IgL, each with distinct chromosomal locations and organizational structures. 5'RACE sequencing revealed a diverse range of heavy chain CDR3 sequences and relatively limited CDR3 diversity in light chains. The analysis highlighted a differential impact of V-gene germline CDR3 length on receptor CDR3 length between heavy and light chains, underlining different recombination processes.

CONCLUSIONS

This study reveals that the Atlantic cod, despite its inconsistent antibody response, maintains a level of immunoglobulin diversity comparable to other fish species. The findings suggest that the extensive recent duplications of kappa light chain genes do not result in increased repertoire diversity. This research provides a comprehensive view of the Atlantic cod's immunoglobulin gene organization and repertoire, necessary for future studies of antibody responses at the molecular level.

On the relationship between extant innate immune receptors and the evolutionary origins of jawed vertebrate adaptive immunity

For over half a century, deciphering the origins of the genomic loci that form the jawed vertebrate adaptive immune response has been a major topic in comparative immunogenetics. Vertebrate adaptive immunity relies on an extensive and highly diverse repertoire of tandem arrays of variable (V), diversity (D), and joining (J) gene segments that recombine to produce different immunoglobulin (Ig) and T cell receptor (TCR) genes. The current consensus is that a recombination-activating gene (RAG)-like transposon invaded an exon of an ancient innate immune VJ-bearing receptor, giving rise to the extant diversity of Ig and TCR loci across jawed vertebrates. However, a model for the evolutionary relationships between extant non-recombining innate immune receptors and the V(D)J receptors of the jawed vertebrate adaptive immune system has only recently begun to come into focus. In this review, we provide an overview of non-recombining VJ genes, including CD8β, CD79b, natural cytotoxicity receptor 3 (NCR3/NKp30), putative remnants of an antigen receptor precursor (PRARPs), and the multigene family of signal-regulatory proteins (SIRPs), that play a wide range of roles in immune function. We then focus in detail on the VJ-containing novel immune-type receptors (NITRs) from ray-finned fishes, as recent work has indicated that these genes are at least 50 million years older than originally thought. We conclude by providing a conceptual model of the evolutionary origins and phylogenetic distribution of known VJ-containing innate immune receptors, highlighting opportunities for future comparative research that are empowered by this emerging evolutionary perspective.

The immunoglobulins of cartilaginous fishes

Cartilaginous fishes, comprising the chimeras, sharks, skates, and rays, split from the common ancestor with other jawed vertebrates approx. 450 million years ago. Being the oldest extant taxonomic group to possess an immunoglobulin (Ig)-based adaptive immune system, examination of this group has taught us much about the evolution of adaptive immunity, as well as the conserved and taxon-specific characteristics of Igs. Significant progress has been made analyzing sequences from numerous genomic and transcriptomic data sets. These findings have been supported by additional functional studies characterizing the Igs and humoral response of sharks and their relatives. This review will summarize what we have learned about the genomic organization, protein structure, and in vivo function of these Ig isotypes in cartilaginous fishes and highlight the areas where our knowledge is still lacking.

A comprehensive analysis of the genomic organization, expression and phylogeny of immunoglobulin light chain genes in pigeon (Columba livia)

Previous studies on immunoglobulin light chain (IgL) genes in avian species are limited to Galloanseres, and few studies have investigated IgL genes in Neoaves, which includes most living birds. Based on published genome data, we demonstrate that the pigeon (Columba livia) IgL locus spans approximately 24 kb of DNA and contains twenty Vλ segments located upstream of a single pair of Jλ-Cλ. Among the identified Vλ gene segments, four segments are structurally intact and all four segments are able to recombine with Jλ. Moreover, the four functional Vλ segments are preferentially utilized in VλJλ recombination. Phylogenetic analysis suggests that the presence of the four functional Vλ segments in pigeon was likely generated by gene duplication that occurred after the divergence of pigeon and other birds. Our study provides insight into IgL gene evolution and evolutionary diversity of Ig genes in birds.

A cold-blooded view of adaptive immunity

The adaptive immune system arose 500 million years ago in ectothermic (cold-blooded) vertebrates. Classically, the adaptive immune system has been defined by the presence of lymphocytes expressing recombination-activating gene (RAG)-dependent antigen receptors and the MHC. These features are found in all jawed vertebrates, including cartilaginous and bony fish, amphibians and reptiles and are most likely also found in the oldest class of jawed vertebrates, the extinct placoderms. However, with the discovery of an adaptive immune system in jawless fish based on an entirely different set of antigen receptors - the variable lymphocyte receptors - the divergence of T and B cells, and perhaps innate-like lymphocytes, goes back to the origin of all vertebrates. This Review explores how recent developments in comparative immunology have furthered our understanding of the origins and function of the adaptive immune system.

Diversity of Immunoglobulin Light Chain Genes in Non-Teleost Ray-Finned Fish Uncovers IgL Subdivision into Five Ancient Isotypes

The aim of this study was to fill important gaps in the evolutionary history of immunoglobulins by examining the structure and diversity of IgL genes in non-teleost ray-finned fish. First, based on the bioinformatic analysis of recent transcriptomic and genomic resources, we experimentally characterized the IgL genes in the chondrostean fish, Acipenser ruthenus (sterlet). We show that this species has three loci encoding IgL kappa-like chains with a translocon-type gene organization and a single VJC cluster, encoding homogeneous lambda-like light chain. In addition, sterlet possesses sigma-like VL and J-CL genes, which are transcribed separately and both encode protein products with cleavable leader peptides. The Acipenseriformes IgL dataset was extended by the sequences mined in the databases of species belonging to other non-teleost lineages of ray-finned fish: Holostei and Polypteriformes. Inclusion of these new data into phylogenetic analysis showed a clear subdivision of IgL chains into five groups. The isotype described previously as the teleostean IgL lambda turned out to be a kappa and lambda chain paralog that emerged before the radiation of ray-finned fish. We designate this isotype as lambda-2. The phylogeny also showed that sigma-2 IgL chains initially regarded as specific for cartilaginous fish are present in holosteans, polypterids, and even in turtles. We conclude that there were five ancient IgL isotypes, which evolved differentially in various lineages of jawed vertebrates.

Evolutionary history of the T cell receptor complex as revealed by small-spotted catshark (Scyliorhinus canicula)

In every jawed vertebrate species studied so far, the T cell receptor (TCR) complex is composed of two different TCR chains (α/β or γ/δ) and a number of CD3 subunits responsible for transmitting signals into the T cell. In this study, we characterised all of the TCR and CD3 genes of small-spotted catshark (Scyliorhinus canicula) and analysed their expression in a broad range of tissues. While the TCR complex is highly conserved across jawed vertebrates, we identified a number of differences in catshark, most notably the presence of two copies of both TCRβ and CD3γδ, and the absence of a functionally-important proline rich region from CD3ε. We also demonstrate that TCRβ has duplicated independently multiple times in jawed vertebrate evolution, bringing additional diversity to the TCR complex. This study reveals new insights about the evolutionary history of the TCR complex and raises new avenues for future exploration.

Evidence for Ig Light Chain Isotype Exclusion in Shark B Lymphocytes Suggests Ordered Mechanisms

Unlike most vertebrates, the shark IgL gene organization precludes secondary rearrangements that delete self-reactive VJ rearranged genes. Nurse sharks express four L chain isotypes, κ, λ, σ, and σ-2, encoded by 35 functional minigenes or clusters. The sequence of gene activation/expression and receptor editing of these isotypes have not been studied. We therefore investigated the extent of isotypic exclusion in separated B cell subpopulations. Surface Ig (sIg)κ-expressing cells, isolated with mAb LK14 that recognizes Cκ, carry predominantly nonproductive rearrangements of other L chain isotypes. Conversely, after depletion with LK14, sIgM⁺ cells contained largely nonproductive κ and enrichment for in-frame VJ of the others. Because some isotypic inclusion was observed at the mRNA level, expression in the BCR was examined. Functional λ mRNA was obtained, as expected, from the LK14-depleted population, but was also in sIgκ⁺ splenocytes. Whereas λ somatic mutants from the depleted sample displayed evidence of positive selection, the λ genes in sIgκ⁺ cells accumulated bystander mutations indicating a failure to express their products at the cell surface in association with the BCR H chain. In conclusion, a shark B cell expresses one L chain isotype at the surface and other isotypes as nonproductive VJ, sterile transcripts, or in-frame VJ whose products may not associate with the H chain. Based on the mRNA content found in the B cell subpopulations, an order of L chain gene activation is suggested as: σ-2 followed by κ, then σ and λ.

Immunoglobulin light chain (IGL) genes in torafugu: Genomic organization and identification of a third teleost IGL isotype

Here, we report a genome-wide survey of immunoglobulin light chain (IGL) genes of torafugu (Takifugu rubripes) revealing multi-clusters spanning three separate chromosomes (v5 assembly) and 45 scaffolds (v4 assembly). Conventional sequence similarity searches and motif scanning approaches based on recombination signal sequence (RSS) motifs were used. We found that three IGL isotypes (L1, L2, and L3) exist in torafugu and that several loci for each isotype are present. The transcriptional orientations of the variable IGL (V_L) segments were found to be either the same (in the L2 isotype) or opposite (in the L1 and L3 isotypes) to the IGL joining (J_L) and constant (C_L) segments, suggesting they can undergo rearrangement by deletion or inversion when expressed. Alignments of expressed sequence tags (ESTs) to corresponding germline gene segments revealed expression of the three IGL isotypes in torafugu. Taken together, our findings provide a genomic framework for torafugu IGL genes and show that the IG diversity of this species could be attributed to at least three distinct chromosomal regions.

Fish Immunoglobulins

The B cell receptor and secreted antibody are at the nexus of humoral adaptive immunity. In this review, we summarize what is known of the immunoglobulin genes of jawed cartilaginous and bony fishes. We focus on what has been learned from genomic or cDNA sequence data, but where appropriate draw upon protein, immunization, affinity and structural studies. Work from major aquatic model organisms and less studied comparative species are both included to define what is the rule for an immunoglobulin isotype or taxonomic group and what exemplifies an exception.

Antibody Repertoires in Fish

As in mammals, cartilaginous and teleost fishes possess adaptive immune systems based on antigen recognition by immunoglobulins (Ig), T cell receptors (TCR), and major histocompatibility complex molecules (MHC) I and MHC II molecules. Also it is well established that fish B cells and mammalian B cells share many similarities, including Ig gene rearrangements, and production of membrane Ig and secreted Ig forms. This chapter provides an overview of the IgH and IgL chains in cartilaginous and bony fish, including their gene organizations, expression, diversity of their isotypes, and development of the primary repertoire. Furthermore, when possible, we have included summaries of key studies on immune mechanisms such as allelic exclusion, somatic hypermutation, affinity maturation, class switching, and mucosal immune responses.

What the shark immune system can and cannot provide for the expanding design landscape of immunotherapy

INTRODUCTION

Sharks have successfully lived in marine ecosystems, often atop food chains as apex predators, for nearly one and a half billion years. Throughout this period they have benefitted from an immune system with the same fundamental components found in terrestrial vertebrates like man. Additionally, sharks have some rather extraordinary immune mechanisms which mammals lack.

AREAS COVERED

In this review the author briefly orients the reader to sharks, their adaptive immunity, and their important phylogenetic position in comparative immunology. The author also differentiates some of the myths from facts concerning these animals, their cartilage, and cancer. From thereon, the author explores some of the more remarkable capabilities and products of shark lymphocytes. Sharks have an isotype of light chain-less antibodies that are useful tools in molecular biology and are moving towards translational use in the clinic. These special antibodies are just one of the several tricks of shark lymphocyte antigen receptor systems.

EXPERT OPINION

While shark cartilage has not helped oncology patients, shark immunoglobulins and T cell receptors do offer exciting novel possibilities for immunotherapeutics. Much of the clinical immunology developmental pipeline has turned from traditional vaccines to passively delivered monoclonal antibody-based drugs for targeted depletion, activation, blocking and immunomodulation. The immunogenetic tools of shark lymphocytes, battle-tested since the dawn of our adaptive immune system, are well poised to expand the design landscape for the next generation of immunotherapy products.

The immunoglobulin light chain locus of the turkey, Meleagris gallopavo

To date, most jawed vertebrate species encode more than one immunoglobulin light (IgL) chain isotypes. It has been shown that several bird species (chickens, white Pekin or domestic duck, and zebra finches) exclusively express lambda isotype. We analyze here the genomic organization of another bird species turkey IgL genes based on the recently released genome data. The turkey IgL locus located on chromosome 17 spans approximately 75.2kb and contains a single functional V(λ) gene, twenty V(λ) pseudogenes, and a single functional J(λ)-C(λ) block. These data suggest that the genomic organization of bird IgL chain genes seems to be conserved. Ten cDNA clones from turkey Igλ chain containing almost full-length V(λ), J(λ) and C(λ) segments were acquired. The comparison of V(λ) cDNA sequences to all the germline V(λ) segments suggests that turkey species may be generating IgL chain diversity by gene conversion and somatic hypermutation like the chicken. This study provides insights into the immunoglobulin light chain genes in another bird species.

Characterization of the immunoglobulin repertoire of the spiny dogfish (Squalus acanthias)

The cartilaginous fish (chimeras, sharks, skates and rays) are the oldest group relative to mammals in which an adaptive immune system founded upon immunoglobulins has been found. In this manuscript we characterize the immunoglobulins of the spiny dogfish (Squalus acanthias) at both the molecular and expressed protein levels. Despite the presence of hundreds of IgM clusters in this species the serum levels of this isotype are comparatively low. However, analysis of cDNA sequences and serum protein suggests microheterogeneity in the IgM heavy chains and supports the proposal that different clusters are preferentially used in the two forms (monomer or pentamer) of this isotype. We also found that the IgNAR isotype in this species exists in a previously unknown multimeric format in serum. Finally, we identified a new form of the IgW isotype (the shark IgD orthologue), in which the leader is spliced directly to the first constant domain, resulting in a molecule lacking an antigen-binding domain.

Characterisation and expression analysis of B-cell activating factor (BAFF) in spiny dogfish (Squalus acanthias): cartilaginous fish BAFF has a unique extra exon that may impact receptor binding

B-cell activating factor (BAFF), also known as tumour necrosis factor (TNF) ligand superfamily member 13B, is an important immune regulator with critical roles in B-cell survival, proliferation, differentiation and immunoglobulin secretion. A BAFF gene has been cloned from spiny dogfish (Squalus acanthias) and its expression studied. The dogfish BAFF encodes for an anchored type-II transmembrane protein of 288 aa with a putative furin protease cleavage site and TNF family signature as seen in BAFFs from other species. The identity of dogfish BAFF has also been confirmed by conserved cysteine residues, and phylogenetic tree analysis. The dogfish BAFF gene has an extra exon not seen in teleost fish, birds and mammals that encodes for 29 aa and may impact on receptor binding. The dogfish BAFF is highly expressed in immune tissues, such as spleen, and is up-regulated by PWM in peripheral blood leucocytes, suggesting a potentially important role in the immune system.

Immunoglobulin light (IgL) chains in ectothermic vertebrates

Four major ancesteral IgL isotypes have been identified κ, λ, σ and σ-cart. However, depending on the vertebrate class the genomic representation of these isotypes differs in regards to what is encoded in the germline and how these genes are organized. Also, the relative contribution of each isotype in immune responses varies. This review focuses on the IgL chains of ectothermic vertebrates, specifically the number of different isotypes, their phylogenetic relationship, genomic organizations and expression.

Three isotypes of immunoglobulin light chains in large yellow croaker, Pseudosciaena crocea: Molecular cloning, characterization, and expression analysis

Both cDNA library mining and transcriptome analysis were used to obtain 21 immunoglobulin light chain (IgL) sequences for the large yellow croaker, Pseudosciaena crocea. Full-length cDNA sequences are available for 10 of these, and they were identified as belonging to the three IgL isotypes of LycIgL1, LycIgL2, and LycIgL3. The LycIgL1 isotype is most abundant in the large yellow croaker IgL repertoire, as in the other teleosts. Tissue expression profile analysis revealed that the three LycIgL isotypes were constitutively expressed at different abundances in the kidney, spleen, liver, gill, heart, intestine, and muscle, although the heart did not express LycIgL3. Real-time polymerase chain reaction revealed that expression of the three LycIgL isotypes in the kidney and spleen tissues was up-regulated during 72 h of inductions with poly(I:C) or bacterial vaccine at different intensities and in different manners. The LycIgL1 isotype responded to stimulations most intensely in the spleen, while the LycIgL3 isotype responded most quickly in the kidney. Compared to the LycIgL1 and LycIgL3 isotypes, the LycIgL2 isotype responded more slowly and weakly in both tissues. These results indicate different isotypes of LycIgL respond to immune stimuli in the spleen and kidney in an isotypic-specific manner.

Evolutionarily conserved TCR binding sites, identification of T cells in primary lymphoid tissues, and surprising trans-rearrangements in nurse shark

Cartilaginous fish are the oldest animals that generate RAG-based Ag receptor diversity. We have analyzed the genes and expressed transcripts of the four TCR chains for the first time in a cartilaginous fish, the nurse shark (Ginglymostoma cirratum). Northern blotting found TCR mRNA expression predominantly in lymphoid and mucosal tissues. Southern blotting suggested translocon-type loci encoding all four chains. Based on diversity of V and J segments, the expressed combinatorial diversity for gamma is similar to that of human, alpha and beta may be slightly lower, and delta diversity is the highest of any organism studied to date. Nurse shark TCRdelta have long CDR3 loops compared with the other three chains, creating binding site topologies comparable to those of mammalian TCR in basic paratope structure; additionally, nurse shark TCRdelta CDR3 are more similar to IgH CDR3 in length and heterogeneity than to other TCR chains. Most interestingly, several cDNAs were isolated that contained IgM or IgW V segments rearranged to other gene segments of TCRdelta and alpha. Finally, in situ hybridization experiments demonstrate a conservation of both alpha/beta and gamma/delta T cell localization in the thymus across 450 million years of vertebrate evolution, with gamma/delta TCR expression especially high in the subcapsular region. Collectively, these data make the first cellular identification of TCR-expressing lymphocytes in a cartilaginous fish.

Characterization of arrangement and expression of the beta-2 microglobulin locus in the sandbar and nurse shark

Beta 2 microglobulin (beta2m) is an essential subunit of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) type I molecules. In this report, beta2m cDNAs were identified and sequenced from sandbar shark spleen cDNA library. Sandbar shark beta2m gene encodes one amino acid less than most teleost beta2m genes, and 3 amino acids less than mammal beta2m genes. Although sandbar shark beta2m protein contains one beta sheet less than that of human in the predicted protein structure, the overall structure of beta2m proteins is conserved during evolution. Germline gene for the beta2m in sandbar and nurse shark is present as a single locus. It contains three exons and two introns. CpG sites are evenly distributed in the shark beta2m loci. Several DNA repeat elements were also identified in the shark beta2m loci. Sequence analysis suggests that the beta2m locus is not linked to the MHC I loci in the shark genome.

Origin and evolution of the adaptive immune system: genetic events and selective pressures

The adaptive immune system (AIS) in mammals, which is centred on lymphocytes bearing antigen receptors that are generated by somatic recombination, arose approximately 500 million years ago in jawed fish. This intricate defence system consists of many molecules, mechanisms and tissues that are not present in jawless vertebrates. Two macroevolutionary events are believed to have contributed to the genesis of the AIS: the emergence of the recombination-activating gene (RAG) transposon, and two rounds of whole-genome duplication. It has recently been discovered that a non-RAG-based AIS with similarities to the jawed vertebrate AIS - including two lymphoid cell lineages - arose in jawless fish by convergent evolution. We offer insights into the latest advances in this field and speculate on the selective pressures that led to the emergence and maintenance of the AIS.

Characterization of arrangement and expression of the T cell receptor gamma locus in the sandbar shark

Ig and T cell receptor (TCR) genes consist of separate genomic elements, which must undergo rearrangement and joining before a functional protein can be expressed. Considerable plasticity in the genomic arrangement of these elements has occurred during the evolution of the immune system. In tetrapods, all Ig and TCR chain elements are arranged as translocons. In teleosts, the Ig heavy and TCR chains are translocons, but light chain genes may occur as clusters. However, in chondrichthyes, all of the Ig light and heavy chain genes are arranged as clusters. These clusters vary in number from <10 to several hundred, depending on isotype and species. Here, we report that the germ-line gene for the TCR gamma chain in a chondrichthyan, the sandbar shark (Carcharhinus plumbeus), is present as a single locus arranged in a classic translocon pattern. Thus, the shark utilizes 2 types of genomic arrangements, the unique cluster organization for Ig genes and the "conventional" translocon organization for TCR genes. The TCR gamma translocon contains at least 5 V region genes, 3 J segment genes, and 1 C segment. As expected, the third hypervariable segment (CDR3), formed by the rearrangement of the Vgamma and Jgamma segments, contributed the major variability in the intact V region structure. Our data also suggest that diversity may be generated by mutation in the V regions.

Four primordial immunoglobulin light chain isotypes, including lambda and kappa, identified in the most primitive living jawed vertebrates

The discovery of a fourth immunoglobulin (Ig) light (L) chain isotype in sharks has revealed the origins and natural history of all vertebrate L chains. Phylogenetic comparisons have established orthology between this new shark L chain and the unique Xenopus L chain isotype sigma. More importantly, inclusion of this new L chain family in phylogenetic analyses showed that all vertebrate L chains can be categorized into four ancestral clans originating prior to the emergence of cartilaginous fish: one restricted to elasmobranchs (sigma-cart/type I), one found in all cold-blooded vertebrates (sigma/teleost type 2/elasmobranch type IV), one in all groups except bony fish (lambda/elasmobranch type II), and one in all groups except birds (kappa/elasmobranch type III/teleost type 1 and 3). All four of these primordial L chain isotypes (sigma, sigma-cart, lambda and kappa) have maintained separate V region identities since their emergence at least 450 million years ago, suggestive of an ancient physiological distinction of the L chains. We suggest that, based upon unique, discrete sizes of complementarity determining regions 1 and 2 and other features of the V region sequences, the different L chain isotypes arose to provide different functional conformations in the Ig binding site when they pair with heavy chains.

The antibody repertoire in evolution: chance, selection, and continuity

All jawed vertebrates contain the genetic elements essential for the function of the adaptive/combinatorial immune response, have diverse sets of natural antibodies resulting from segmental gene recombination, express comparable functional repertoires and can produce specific antibodies following appropriate immunization. Profound variability occurs in the third hypervariable (CDR3) segments of light and heavy chains even within antibodies of the same ostensible specificity. Germline VH and VL elements, as well as the joining (J) segments are highly conserved among the distinct vertebrate species. Conservation is particularly noted among the VH3-like sequences of all jawed vertebrates in the FR2 and FR3 segments, as well as in the FGXGT(R or K)L J-segment characteristic of light chains and TCRs and the WGXGT(uncharged)VT JH segments. Human VH3-53 and Vlambda6 family orthologs may be present over the entire range of vertebrates. Models of the three-dimensional structures of shark VH/VL combining sites indicate similarity in framework structure and comparable CDR usage to those of man. Although carcharhine shark VH regions show greater than 50% identity to the human VH germline prototype, searches of lower deuterostome and invertebrate databases fail to detect molecules with significant relatedness. Overall, antibodies of jawed vertebrates show tremendous individual diversity, but are constructed incorporating design features that arose with the evolutionary emergence of the jawed vertebrates and have been conserved through at least 450 million years of evolutionary time.

Antibody repertoire development in cartilaginous fish

There are 3 H chain and 3 L chain isotypes in the cartilaginous fish, all encoded by genes in the so-called cluster (VDDJ, VJ) organization. The H chain isotypes IgM and IgNAR, are readily detected at the protein level in most species. The third is readily identified at the protein level in skates (IgR) but only via immunoprecipitation or at the transcript level in sharks (IgW). High levels of diversity in CDR3 and up to 200 germline genes have been detected for IgM depending upon the species examined. IgNAR displays very high levels of CDR3 diversity but almost none in the germline. At least IgNAR and L chain genes have been shown to hypermutate to very high levels, apparently in response to antigen. The mutation footprints are similar to those in mammals except that the shark genes uniquely mutate nucleotide residues in tandem. A conspicuous feature of cartilaginous fish Ig genes is the presence of germline-joined genes, which are a result of RAG activity in germ cells. Such genes are expressed early in ontogeny and then extinguished or expressed at lower levels. 19S IgM and IgW expression precede that of 7S IgM and IgNAR during ontogeny. The 'switch' from 19S to 7S IgM, the regulation of expression of the Ig clusters, and the microenvironments for mutation/selection of cartilaginous fish B cells are all areas of ongoing research.

The CDR1 of the human λVI light chains adopts a new canonical structure

We performed a comparative analysis of the conformation of the CDR1 of the human lambdaVI variable domains JTO and WIL and the equivalent loop of the lambdaI light chains RHE and KOL, which are representative of the type I canonical structure for lambda light chains. On the basis of the differences found in the main chain conformation, as well as the identity of the residues at key positions, we showed that the L1 of some lambdaVI light chains adopts a conformation that represents a new type of canonical structure. The conformation of the L1 of those lambdaVI light chains, is primarily determined by the presence of an Arg residue at position 25. The analysis of the lambdaVI light chain sequences so far reported, showed that near 25% of those proteins have Gly at position 25 instead of Arg, which represents an allotypic variant of the lambdaVI variable locus. The presence of Gly at position 25 in the L1 of lambdaVI light chains would imply a different conformation for this loop. Additionally, the position 68 in lambdaVI light chains, which is at the top of the FR3 loop, showed such spatial orientation and variability that suggested its participation in the conformation of the antigen recognition surface in this subgroup of lambda chains.

Antigen receptor genes and the evolution of a recombinase

Antigen receptor genes exist in the germline in a "split" configuration and are assembled in developing B and T lymphocytes by V(D)J recombination. This site-specific recombination reaction is initiated by a complex containing the RAG1 and RAG2 proteins and completed by general DNA repair factors. RAG1 and RAG2, like the adaptive immune system itself, are found exclusively in jawed vertebrates, and are thought to have entered the vertebrate genome by horizontal transmission as components of a transposable element. This review discusses the structure of antigen receptor genes and the mechanisms by which they are assembled and diversified, and then goes on to consider the evolutionary implications of the arrival of the hypothetical "RAG transposon".

Characterization and expression of the immunoglobulin light chain in the fugu: evidence of a solitaire type

In this study, we characterized the immunoglobulin light (IgL) chain gene and examined its expression in the fugu (Takifugu rubripes). The cDNA fragment that partially encodes the IgL chain was isolated by RACE and used as a probe for screening for IgL in a fugu splenic cDNA library. The IgL cDNA sequence that we found consisted of a variable (V(L)) and a constant (C(L)) segment. Its structural features were similar to the IgL isotype commonly found in teleosts. Genomic sequence analysis revealed that the IgL gene was organized as two V(L) gene segments (designed V(L1) and V(L2)) followed by single joining (J(L)) and C(L) segment. In addition, an unusual duplicate V(L1) gene segment was found downstream of the C(L) segment. The transcriptional orientation of the V(L) exons was found to be opposite to that of the J(L) and C(L) segments. Genomic blot hybridizations with V(L) and C(L) probes gave multibands, supporting the contention that the teleost IgL forms a multicluster. Both genomic and cDNA sequences analyses showed that all of the constant segments found in the fugu are identical, suggesting that no other isotypes could be found in this species. Comparison of the deduced amino acid sequence of the fugu C(L) domain with those of other species showed a high degree of identity (from 40 to 77%). IgL mRNAs were found to be expressed primarily in the lymphoid tissues. In situ hybridization revealed the presence of IgL-positive cells widely distributed throughout the spleen, head kidney, kidney, and thymus. These results support the contention that the lymphoid tissues are the major sites of antibody production in fish. Since IgL mRNA was also expressed in the skin and gill that are exposed to external antigens, it is likely that mucosal Ig plays an important role in immune protection.

Characterisation of a fourth immunoglobulin light chain isotype in the common carp

Three isotypes of immunoglobulin (Ig) light (L) chain, designated L1A, L1B, and L3, have been characterised in the common carp (Cyprinus carpio L.) to date. In this paper the molecular cloning of a fourth IgL isotype in carp, designated L2, is described. A reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) method including 5'- and 3'-RACE was used to isolate carp L2 cDNA clones. The VL sequences could be divided into two distinct VL families, designated VL2-1 and VL2-2, most similar to rainbow trout (68% similarity) and zebrafish (78%) VL2 amino acid sequences, respectively. The CL amino acid sequences showed the highest similarity to zebrafish L2 (80%), and contained the characteristic cysteines necessary for intradomain or interchain disulphide bridges as did the VL sequences. Neither the VL nor CL sequences demonstrated such a high similarity to the other carp IgL isotypes, L1A, L1B, and L3. For JL segments, sequence variations appeared to be confined to a few positions. In the course of 5'- and 3'-RACE, cDNA clones containing recombination signal sequence (RSS), representatives of IgL sterile transcripts, were obtained. Southern blot analyses suggested that the locus of carp L2 has a cluster-like organisation. Phylogenetic analyses showed that both carp VL2 and CL2 amino acid sequences highly clustered with other teleost L2 sequences.

Lineage-restricted retention of a primitive immunoglobulin heavy chain isotype within the Dipnoi reveals an evolutionary paradox

The lineage leading to lungfishes is one of the few major jawed vertebrate groups in which Ig heavy chain isotype structure has not been investigated at the genetic level. In this study, we have characterized three different Ig heavy chain isotypes of the African lungfish, Protopterus aethiopicus, including an IgM-type heavy chain and short and long forms of non-IgM heavy chains. Northern blot analysis as well as patterns of V(H) utilization suggest that the IgM and non-IgM isotypes are likely encoded in separate loci. The two non-IgM isotypes identified in Protopterus share structural features with the short and long forms of IgX/W/NARC (referred to hereafter as IgW), which were previously considered to be restricted to the cartilaginous fish. It seems that the IgW isotype has a far broader phylogenetic distribution than considered originally and raises questions with regard to the origin and evolutionary divergence of IgM and IgW. Moreover, its absence in other gnathostome lineages implies paradoxically that the IgW-type genes were lost from teleost and tetrapod lineages.

Cloning of shark RAG2 and characterization of the RAG1/RAG2 gene locus

The recombination-activating genes (RAG) encode a site-specific recombinase that is centrally responsible for the rearrangement of genomic V(D)J exons necessary to form functional immunoglobulin and T-cell receptor genes. To help elucidate the origins of the RAG genes, we have cloned the RAG2 gene from the sandbar shark (Carcharhinus plumbeus) and characterized the entire RAG1/RAG2 gene locus. The shark RAG2 protein consists of 520 amino acids, is approximately 50% identical with RAG2 proteins from other vertebrates, and contains the same three domains identified in mammalian RAG2. Residues critical for RAG2 function are conserved in the shark sequence. In common with other vertebrate species, the shark RAG2 coding region lacks introns and is closely linked in opposite orientation to the RAG1 gene. The intergenic region is 9.4 kb, which is considerably larger than of teleosts (2-3 kb) and is comparable to that of tetrapods. This length is partially explained by the presence of several SINE and LINE fragments. The ancestors of the sharks were apparently the first vertebrates in phylogeny to have RAG genes, and our results confirm that the RAG genes have been highly conserved during evolution both in terms of sequence and gene organization.

Cloning, sequence and variability analysis of expressed immunoglobulin light chain genes from yellowtail Seriola quinqueradiata

The cDNA clones encoding immunoglobulin (Ig) light (L) chain variable (V) region associated with constant (C) region were isolated from yellowtail (Seriola quinqueradiata) kidney by expressed sequence tag analysis (accession numbers: AB062619-AB062668, AB064322). The sequences of both VL and CL region contain well-conserved cysteine residues important for intra- and inter-domain interaction in mammals. Comparisons of the amino acid sequence of the CL domain with those of other species showed a high degree of similarity, with 88.3%, 59.8%, and 60.6% to those of wolf fish (Anarhichas lupus), rainbow trout IgL I isotype (Oncorhynchus mykiss) and channel catfish G isotype (Ictalurus punctatus), respectively. Multiple sequence alignments of the CL domain with those of higher vertebrates, however, did not readily allow it to be classified as kappa or lambda isotypes. Furthermore, the pI, hydrophobicity and variability of yellowtail VL regions were studied in 65 cDNA clones and the diversity was observed in CDR1, CDR2 and CDR3 regions.

Light chain promoter regions in rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss: function of a classical and an atypical Ig promoter

Three rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) light chain isotypes (L1, L2 and L3) have been identified at the cDNA level. Genomic clones have previously been obtained for L1 and L2, revealing different structures of the V/J/C clusters and divergent putative promoter regions. While the L1 putative promoter has a classical Ig promoter structure with TATA, E-box, and octamer, the L2 putative promoter lacks typical features of the Ig promoter. The L2 putative promoter region contains a kappa-Y motif, an E-box and two putative non-consensus TATA boxes. In this study the isolation of a genomic clone that encompassed a VJC cluster of the recently described L3 isotype is described. The structure of the L3 putative promoter region is very similar to that of the L1 promoter. The transcriptional activities of the promoters of the trout L1 and L2 isotypes were compared. The promoter region of the L1 isotype showed a strong and predictable B cell-specific activity. Despite the unusual structure of the L2 V gene promoter, the transcriptional activity of it was much stronger in B-cells as compared to non B-cells. Deletion analyses of L2 promoter constructs showed that the region containing the kappa-Y element is critical for the transcriptional activity of the L2 promoter. Both L1 and L2 promoters can cooperate with a B cell-specific enhancer from Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua).

Haplotype exclusion: the unique case presented by multiple immunoglobulin gene loci in cartilaginous fish

Cartilaginous fish represent the most phylogenetically distant species from man in which immunoglobulin and T cell antigen receptor genes have been identified. Immunoglobulin genes in cartilaginous fish are organized in hundreds of clusters, located on different chromosomes and presumably are under independent regulation; large numbers of immunoglobulin gene clusters are germline-joined and thus their expression is not directly dependent on somatic rearrangement. Despite the unusual nature of immunoglobulin gene genetics in these species, preliminary characterization of the transcription products of immunoglobulin loci in single cell isolates is consistent with haplotype exclusion. Certain features of immunoglobulin gene organization and expression in cartilaginous fish are remarkably similar to that of odorant receptors and suggest that at the level of transcriptional regulation, at least two different mechanisms could exist that relate to haplotype exclusion.

Hypermutation in shark immunoglobulin light chain genes results in contiguous substitutions

Among 631 substitutions present in 90 nurse shark immunoglobulin light chain somatic mutants, 338 constitute 2-4 bp stretches of adjacent changes. An absence of mutations in perinatal sequences and the bias for one mutating V gene in adults suggest that the diversification is antigen dependent. The substitutions shared no patterns, and the absence of donor sequences, including from family members, supports the idea that most changes arose from nontemplated mutation. The tandem mutations as a group are distinguished by consistently fewer transition changes and an A bias. We suggest this is one of several pathways of hypermutation diversifying shark antigen-receptor genes--point mutations, tandem mutations, and mutations with a G-C preference--that coevolved with or preceded gene rearrangement.

Evolutionary dynamics of the T-cell receptor VB gene family as inferred from the human and mouse genomic sequences

The diversity of T-cell receptors is generated primarily by the variable-region gene families, each of which is composed of a large number of member genes. The entire genomic sequence of the variable region (VB) of the T- cell receptor beta chain from humans and mice has become available. To understand the evolutionary dynamics of the VB gene family, we conducted a phylogenetic analysis of all VB genes from humans and mice, as well as a detailed analysis of internal DNA duplications in the human genomic VB region. The phylogenetic tree obtained shows that human and mouse VB genes intermingle extensively rather than forming two separate clusters and that many gene duplications occurred both before and after the divergence between primates and rodents. Analyzing the genomic maps of transposable elements (e.g., LINEs and SINEs) and relic VB genes in the VB gene region, we present evidence that a 20-kb VB region duplicated tandemly four times in the human lineage during the last 32 Myr, and 6 out of the 15 VB genes in this region have become nonfunctional during this period. Our results show that the VB gene family is subject to evolution by a birth-and-death process rather than to concerted evolution.

Complex expression patterns of lymphocyte-specific genes during the development of cartilaginous fish implicate unique lymphoid tissues in generating an immune repertoire

Cartilaginous fish express canonical B and T cell recognition genes, but their lymphoid organs and lymphocyte development have been poorly defined. Here, the expression of Ig, TCR, recombination-activating gene (Rag)-1 and terminal deoxynucleosidase (TdT) genes has been used to identify roles of various lymphoid tissues throughout development in the cartilaginous fish, Raja eglanteria (clearnose skate). In embryogenesis, Ig and TCR genes are sharply up-regulated at 8 weeks of development. At this stage TCR and TdT expression is limited to the thymus; later, TCR gene expression appears in peripheral sites in hatchlings and adults, suggesting that the thymus is a source of T cells as in mammals. B cell gene expression indicates more complex roles for the spleen and two special organs of cartilaginous fish-the Leydig and epigonal (gonad-associated) organs. In the adult, the Leydig organ is the site of the highest IgM and IgX expression. However, the spleen is the first site of IgM expression, while IgX is expressed first in gonad, liver, Leydig and even thymus. Distinctive spatiotemporal patterns of Ig light chain gene expression also are seen. A subset of Ig genes is pre-rearranged in the germline of the cartilaginous fish, making expression possible without rearrangement. To assess whether this allows differential developmental regulation, IgM and IgX heavy chain cDNA sequences from specific tissues and developmental stages have been compared with known germline-joined genomic sequences. Both non-productively rearranged genes and germline-joined genes are transcribed in the embryo and hatchling, but not in the adult.

Characterisation of the kappa light chain of the brushtail possum (Trichosurus vulpecula)

Two full length cDNA sequences encoding the kappa light chain of the Australian marsupial, Trichosurus vulpecula, the brushtail possum, were isolated from a mesenteric lymph node cDNA library. The constant regions (Ckappa) of the two light chains were identical, but the variable (Vkappa) and joining (Jkappa) regions were different. At the amino acid level, possum Ckappa was most similar to Ckappa of an American marsupial, Monodelphis domestica (75%), with similarity to eutherian Ckappa ranging from 47 to 63%. The availability of molecular data will enable the development of immunological reagents for studying immune responses and disease in marsupials, thereby aiding conservation strategies and veterinary medicine.

Immune-type diversity in the absence of somatic rearrangement

Immunoglobulin gene diversity has been characterized to varying degrees in modern representatives of all of the major radiations of cartilaginous fish. A pattern of overall chromosomal relationships of the various types of joined and unjoined Ig gene clusters is suggested in which the essential features are: (a) both Ig heavy and light-chain gene clusters occur on multiple chromosomes, (b) various classes of Ig are interspersed, (c) not all individual gene loci appear to be closely linked (Fig. 2). The cluster-type Ig gene system appears to be a series of (potentially) individually regulated loci analogous in part to the olfactory receptor gene system (BUCK and AXEL 1991) and markedly distinct from Ig loci in other vertebrate groups and TCR genes. Such a system would be ideal for the creation of variation in both form and function in a large number of clusters while preserving or partially preserving specificity in a number of other gene clusters. The full range of joined genes and the relative number of joined genes (as relates to unjoined genes), have yet to be determined. Nevertheless, a number of conclusions can be drawn: (a) four distinct forms of heavy-chain joining have been identified (VDD-J, VD-DJ, V-D-DJ, and VDJ; Fig. 1); (b) light-chain genes, which possess only two recombining elements, can be found in either unjoined (V-J) or joined (VJ) forms (Fig. 1); (c) physical linkage between individual joined and unjoined genes has not been established, although such investigations have not been pursued in a significantly rigorous manner as to rule out this possibility; (d) joined light-chain genes are expressed and can be somatically mutated. Can germline joining be viewed as an ancestral character? The answer to this needs to be considered in the context of an overall system in which the level of structural and functional redundancy is extremely high. Joining is an adaptation that is unique to multicluster gene families. The phenomenon overcomes the possibility of not generating a specific form of a receptor, a major shortcoming of conventional rearranging Ig and TCR gene systems. The limitation of encoding specific receptors is compensated through large numbers of additional gene clusters that retain the capacity to rearrange and generate new specificities. Commitment of a V region to diverse, fixed specificity also is a property of the NITR genes, which although not related closely to Ig in a structural sense, may reflect an analogous phenomena. The possibility that immune-type diversity is achieved in the absence of somatic rearrangement and that remnants of such systems could be operative in immune recognition in contemporary vertebrates is of extraordinary significance in terms of our overall understanding of the relationships between adaptive and innate immune recognition.

Evolution of vertebrate immunoglobulin variable gene segments

Evolution of Ig V gene segments are generally characterized by (a) evolution by "the birth and death process" and (b) diversifying selection. However, the detailed evolutionary pattern of V gene segments varies among species due to the fact that the humoral immune system itself has changed during vertebrate evolution. The change in somatic diversification system coupled with the change in lymphocyte development has imposed a significant impact on the evolution of Ig genes. In order to understand the evolution of immunological genes it is important to view it in the context of the evolution of the entire immune system itself.

Rearrangement of immunoglobulin genes in shark germ cells

The variable (V), (diversity [D]), and joining (J) region recombinases (recombination activating genes [RAGs]) can perform like transposases and are thought to have initiated development of the adaptive immune system in early vertebrates by splitting archaic V genes with transposable elements. In cartilaginous fishes, the immunoglobulin (Ig) light chain genes are organized as multiple VJ-constant (C) clusters; some loci are capable of rearrangement while others contain fused VJ. The latter may be key to understanding the evolutionary role of RAG. Are they relics of the archaic genes, or are they results of rearrangement in germ cells? Our data suggest that some fused VJ genes are not only recently rearranged, but also resulted from RAG-like activity involving hairpin intermediates. Expression studies show that these, like some other germline-joined Ig sequences, are expressed at significant levels only early in ontogeny. We suggest that a rejoined Ig gene may not merely be a sequence restricting antibody diversity, but is potentially a novel receptor no longer tied to somatic RAG expression and rearrangement. From the combined data, we arrived at the unexpected conclusion that, in some vertebrates, RAG is still an active force in changing the genome.

The evolution of vertebrate antigen receptors: a phylogenetic approach

Classical T cells, those with alpha beta T-cell receptors (TCRs), are an important component of the dominant paradigm for self-nonself immune recognition in vertebrates. alpha beta T cells recognize foreign peptide antigens when they are bound to MHC molecules on the surfaces of antigen-presenting cells. gamma delta T cells bear a similar receptor, and it is often assumed that these T cells also require specialized antigen-presenting molecules for immune recognition, which we term "indirect antigen recognition." B-cell receptors, or immunoglobulins, bind directly to antigens without the help of a specialized antigen-presenting molecule. Phylogenetically, it has been assumed that T-cell receptors and the genes that encode them are a monophyletic group, and that "indirect" antigen recognition evolved before the split into two types of TCR. Recently, however, it has been proposed that gamma delta-TCRs bind directly to antigens, as do immunoglobulins (Ig's). This calls into question the null hypothesis that indirect antigen recognition is a common characteristic of TCRs and, by extension, the hypothesis that all TCR gene sequences form a monophyletic group. To determine whether alternative explanations for antigen recognition and other historical relationships among TCR genes might be possible, we performed phylogenetic analyses on amino acid sequences of the constant and variable regions which encode the basic subunits of TCR and Ig molecules. We used both maximum-parsimony and genetic distance-based methods and could find no strong support for the hypothesis of TCR monophyly. Analyses of the constant region suggest that TCR gamma or delta sequences are the most ancient, implying that the ancestral immune cell was like a modern gamma delta T cell. From this gamma delta-like ancestor arose alpha beta T cells and B cells, implying that indirect antigen recognition is indeed a derived property of alpha beta-TCRs. Analyses of the variable regions are complicated by strong selection on antigen-binding sequences, but imply that direct antigen binding is the ancestral condition.

Junctional diversity in Xenopus immunoglobulin light chains

Xenopus cDNA sequences encoding the homolog of mammalian kappa (kappa) light (L) chains were isolated from isogenic tadpole and adult individuals to investigate whether there existed stage-specific immunoglobulin L chain expression and somatic diversification. In the course of these studies rearrangements to a sixth J(L) gene segment and a pseudogene (J(L)psi) were found, and it is suggested that the order of these gene segments with respect to the L chain constant (C) region exon is: J(L)6-J(L)1-J(L)2-J(L)3-J(L)4-J(L)5-J(L)psi-C(L). The cDNA junctional diversity was analyzed; few N and P regions were found and almost all the CDR3 were 9 codons in length. There were restricted patterns of recombination site resolution, and this is attributed to some constraint in JL coding end processing.

Allelic exclusion in anamniotic vertebrates

Clonal selection, a central principle in immunology, is predicated on one lymphocyte making one kind of antibody or T cell receptor. At loci encoding antigen receptors only one allele is used, and this has been shown in normal lymphocytes from frogs to humans. Fish antibody chains, however, are encoded by multiple loci, and at some of these loci the gene segments are already rearranged in the germline. The differences in germline organization and the uncoupling of rearrangement and expression raise questions as to whether some of the early vertebrates might be an exception to the clonal selection theory.

Evolution of antigen binding receptors

This review addresses issues related to the evolution of the complex multigene families of antigen binding receptors that function in adaptive immunity. Advances in molecular genetic technology now permit the study of immunoglobulin (Ig) and T cell receptor (TCR) genes in many species that are not commonly studied yet represent critical branch points in vertebrate phylogeny. Both Ig and TCR genes have been defined in most of the major lineages of jawed vertebrates, including the cartilaginous fishes, which represent the most phylogenetically divergent jawed vertebrate group relative to the mammals. Ig genes in cartilaginous fish are encoded by multiple individual loci that each contain rearranging segmental elements and constant regions. In some loci, segmental elements are joined in the germline, i.e. they do not undergo genetic rearrangement. Other major differences in Ig gene organization and the mechanisms of somatic diversification have occurred throughout vertebrate evolution. However, relating these changes to adaptive immune function in lower vertebrates is challenging. TCR genes exhibit greater sequence diversity in individual segmental elements than is found in Ig genes but have undergone fewer changes in gene organization, isotype diversity, and mechanisms of diversification. As of yet, homologous forms of antigen binding receptors have not been identified in jawless vertebrates; however, acquisition of large amounts of structural data for the antigen binding receptors that are found in a variety of jawed vertebrates has defined shared characteristics that provide unique insight into the distant origins of the rearranging gene systems and their relationships to both adaptive and innate recognition processes.

Light chain variable region diversity in Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua L.)

This study was undertaken to determine if a lack of V(L) domain variability could explain, in part, the failure of Atlantic cod to respond to immunization with the production of specific antibodies. The variability of cod V(L) regions was studied in 33 cDNA and two genomic clones. The variability of the CDRs was estimated by the Shannon entropy method and compared with that in other species. It was found to be lowest in the little skate (Raja erinacea), higher in cod, and highest in Xenopus and mouse. While the variability of the CDRs is slightly lower in cod than in Xenopus and mouse, it is spread over broader areas of the amino acid sequence. The length of CDR1 and CDR3 in cod is equal to or exceeds that found in skate, Xenopus, chicken and mammals. Isoelectric points and hydrophobicity vary substantially among the studied Ig light chain domains. Thus, neither the length, nor the variability, nor the physicochemical properties (pI and hydrophobicity) of the L chain CDRs can explain the absence of antibody response to immunization in cod.