Germinal centres and the B-cell system. V. Presence of germinal centre-precursor cells among lymphocytes of the thoracic duct in the rat

Histophysiology of follicular structures and germinal centres in relation to B cell differentiation

A historical review of germinal centres since their original description in 1885 by Flemming is given, followed by a description of the germinal centre reaction. Microenvironmental aspects are discussed, special attention being paid to the role of antigen in the induction and further regulation of germinal centre activity. Germinal centres give rise to a new population of lymphocytes (germinal centre-derived cells). Their immune capacities were studied using the rabbit appendix as an experimental model. The possible properties of the cell from which a germinal centre develops (germinal centre precursor cell) were investigated using germinal centre cell suspensions from the rabbit appendix and bone marrow and thoracic duct lymphocytes in the rat in adoptive transfer systems. From these experiments a working hypothesis was formulated for the possible role of germinal centres in B cell differentiation. Essentially, germinal centres are thought not only to be sites of selective amplification of antigen-reactive but still immature B cells, resulting in the generation of memory cells, but also to contribute to the overall pool of B cells by polyclonal amplification of B cells of specificities unrelated to the antigen inducing the germinal centre.

The humoral response in TCR alpha-/- mice. Can gammadelta-T cells support the humoral immune response?

An optimal humoral response requires T-cell help; however, it has been questioned if this help comes exclusively from alphabeta-T cells or whether gammadelta-T cells also contribute. We have attempted to answer this question by studying the humoral response in T-cell receptor alpha-chain knockout (alpha-/-) mice, which lack the alphabetaT cell subset. Two model antigens were used to characterize the response: the thymus-independent (TI) antigen native dextran B512 (Dx), and the thymus-dependent (TD) antigen heat shock protein (HSP65) from Mycobacterium tuberculosis. When challenged with Dx, the alpha-/- mice elicited a strong antibody response and formed rudimentary germinal centres (GCs), a T-cell dependent reaction. In contrast, the humoral response to HSP65 was poor. However, alpha-/- mice became primed when challenged with HSP65, because when supplemented with wild-type thymocytes, the antigen-primed animals were able to mount a stronger response than the nonprimed ones when challenged with HSP65. A crucial step seems to be the collaboration between gammadeltaT cells and antigen presenting cells (APCs), as splenocytes from alpha-/- mice were able to respond to HSP65 in an environment containing primed-APCs. Based on these results, we propose a model for B-cell activation in the alpha-/- mice.

Immunoglobulin gene hypermutation in germinal centers is independent of the RAG-1 V(D)J recombinase

Antigen-driven somatic hypermutation in immunoglobulin genes coupled with stringent selection leads to affinity maturation in the B-lymphocyte populations present in germinal centers. To date, no gene(s) has been identified that drives the hypermutation process. The site-specific recombination of antigen-receptor gene segments in T and B lymphocytes is dependent on the expression of two recombination activating genes, RAG-1 and RAG-2. The RAG-1 and RAG-2 proteins are essential for the cleavage of DNA at highly conserved recombination signals to make double-strand breaks and their expression is sufficient to confer V(D)J recombination activity to non-lymphoid cells. Until very recently, expression of the V(D)J recombinase in adults was believed to be restricted to sites of primary lymphogenesis. However, several laboratories have now demonstrated expression of RAG-1 and RAG-2 and active V-to-(D)J recombination in germinal center B cells. This observation of active recombinase in germinal centers raises the issue of RAG-mediated nuclease activity as a component of V(D)J hypermutation. Here, we show that a transgenic kappa-light chain gene in a RAG-1-/- genetic background can acquire high frequencies of mutations. Thus, the RAG-1 protein is not essential for the machinery of immunoglobulin hypermutation. The genetic approaches to identifying the genes necessary for somatic hypermutation will require further studies on DNA-repair and immunodeficient models.

Immunosenescence and germinal center reaction

Dysfunction of the immune system in aged individuals includes at least two important factors: accumulation of immunocytes with reduced function and accumulation of lymphocyte clones with self-reactive potential. Coincidently, there is a profound reduction of the germinal center reaction in the aged. While this reduction is likely the result of age-associated impairment in lymphocyte function (e.g. diminished response to costimulus, altered lymphokine production etc.), the reduction of germinal centers may itself make an important contribution to further immunological dysfunction.

Relative contribution of T and B cells to hypermutation and selection of the antibody repertoire in germinal centers of aged mice

The immune system of aged individuals often produces antibodies that have lower affinity and are less protective than antibodies from young individuals. Recent studies in mice suggested that antibodies produced by old individuals may be encoded by distinct immunoglobulin (Ig) genes and that the somatic hypermutation process in these individuals is compromised. The present study employed Ighb scid mice reconstituted with normal lymphocytes from young (2-3-mo-old) and aged (20-25-mo-old) donors and immunized with a protein conjugate of the hapten (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP) to determine whether the molecular changes in antibody repertoire reflect senescence in the B cells or whether they are mediated by the aging helper T lymphocytes. The NP-reactive B cells from splenic germinal centers (GC) were recovered by microdissection of frozen tissue sections and their rearranged Ig heavy chain variable region (VH) genes of the V186.2/V3 families were sequenced. It was found that the VH gene repertoire of the GC B cells was strongly influenced by the source of the CD4+ T cells. When T cells were donated by young mice, the anti-NP response in GC was dominated by the canonical V186.2 gene, even if the responder B cells came from aged donors. However, when the mice were reconstituted with T cells from aged donors, the expression of the V186.2 gene by young B cells was diminished and the response was dominated by the C1H4 gene, another member of the V186.2/V3 family. In contrast, the somatic hypermutation process in the GC B cells followed a different pattern. The mutation frequencies in the animals that were reconstituted with both B and T cells from young donors (1/50 to 1/150 bp) were comparable to the frequencies previously reported for NP-immunized intact young/adult mice. However, when either lymphocyte subset was donated by the aged mice, the mutation frequencies declined. Thus, mice reconstituted with T cells from the aged and B cells from the young had severely compromised mutational mechanism. Likewise, the recipients of aged B and young T cells had diminished mutations even though the repertoire of their anti-NP response was dominated by the canonical V186.2 gene. It appears that the change in germine-encoded repertoire and the decrease of somatic hypermutation represent distinct mechanisms of immunosenescence and that the aging of helper T cells plays a pivotal role in both of these processes.

Facultative role of germinal centers and T cells in the somatic diversification of IgVH genes

The development of memory B cells takes place in germinal centers (GC) of lymphoid follicles where antigen-driven lymphocytes undergo somatic hypermutation and affinity selection, presumably under the influence of helper T cells. However, the mechanisms that drive this complex response are not well understood. We explored the relationship between GC formation and the onset of hypermutation in response to the hapten phosphorylcholine (PC) coupled to antigenic proteins in mice bearing different frequencies of CD4+ T cells. PC-reactive GC were identified by staining frozen splenic sections with peanut agglutinin (PNA) and with monoclonal Abs against AB1-2, a dominant idiotope of T15+ anti-PC antibody. The nucleotide sequences of rearranged T15 VH1 genes were determined from polymerase chain reaction amplifications of genomic DNA from microdissected GC B cells. T15+ GC became fully developed by day 6-7 after primary immunization of euthymic mice with either PC-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) or PC-chicken gamma globulin (CGG). Yet the VH1 gene segments recovered from the primary GC as late as day 10-14 had low numbers of mutations, in contrast to responses to the haptens nitrophenyl or oxazolone that sustain high levels of hypermutation after GC formation. PC-reactive B cells proliferate in histologically typical GC for considerable periods with no or little somatic hypermutation; the signals for GC formation are independent of those for the activation of hypermutation. We then examined GC 7 d after secondary immunization with PC-KLH in euthymic mice, in nu/nu mice reconstituted with limited numbers of normal CD4+ cells before priming (CD4(+)-nu/nu) and in nu/nu mice. All of these animals develop T15+ GC after antigen priming, however, the patterns of V gene mutations in the secondary GC reflected the levels of CD4+ cells present during the primary response. VDJ sequences from secondary GC of euthymic mice were heavily mutated, but most of these mutations were shared among all related (identical VDJ joints) sequences suggesting the proliferation of mutated, memory B cells, with little de novo somatic hypermutation. In contrast, the patterns of V gene diversity in secondary GC from CD4(+)-nu/nu mice suggested that there was ongoing mutation and clonal diversification during the first week after rechallenge. The secondary GC from T cell-deficient, nu/nu mice showed little evidence for mutational and/or recombinational diversity of T15+ B cells. We conclude that the participation of CD4+ helper cells is required for full activation of the mutator in GC and takes place in a dose-dependent fashion.

Immune events in lymphoid tissues during experimental glomerulonephritis

To investigate immune events within lymphoid tissues and their role in relation to glomerular disease, systemic lymphoid tissues from rats with accelerated experimental anti-GBM glomerulonephritis or with primed serum sickness glomerulopathy were studied. Following disease induction, changes in leukocytic populations within lymphoid tissues were analysed over a 28 day time course by immunoperoxidase labelling with monoclonal antibodies. In anti-GBM glomerulonephritis there was rapid and severe renal injury and pulmonary hemorrhage (Good-pasture's syndrome). In these rats, antigen (rabbit IgG) was deposited on the GBM and within germinal centres of lymphoid tissues. From day 3 onwards, there was a significant increase in the number of T cells, presumably CD4+ T helper cells, present within enlarged germinal centres of kidney draining lymph nodes, axillary lymph nodes and spleen (p < 0.05) which peaked at day 14 (up to 28% of total cells) when there was intense deposition of rat IgG and C3 on the GBM. Similarly, increased numbers of ED1+ macrophages were evident in both germinal centres and T cell areas (paracortex and periarteriolar lymphoid sheath). Notably, the appearance of IL-2R expression in germinal centres and T cell areas was apparent from day 7 onwards. This was the time when widespread renal interstitial infiltration, cellular immune activation and severe renal functional and histological injury developed. In addition, antigen deposited in germinal centres was found to be associated with CD4+, CD5-, ED1- cells, most probably antigen presenting dendritic cells. In contrast, in acute serum sickness there was no antigen deposited in germinal centres and only mild renal injury and minor changes within lymphoid tissues.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Signals involved in germinal center reactions

Many of the features observed in the in vitro cultures discussed in this review coincide with characteristics described for an in vivo germinal center response. FDC and T cells are required to maintain B-cell proliferation which is confined to a finite amount of time (i.e. less than 2 wk). Large cellular aggregated form which contain many blasting cells undergoing DNA synthesis. In addition to proliferation, apoptosis is also occurring in the cultures but appears to be limited to the population which is not in contact with the FDC. The system can be driven by specific antigen, suggesting that clonal expansion is occurring. As in other immunological systems, there is an important role for adhesion molecules both for cluster formation and DNA synthesis. Antigen processing and presentation is a major event since blocking this through several mechanisms ends the stimulation. The role of T cells is essential both in vivo and in vitro; however, their exact contribution is still not well understood. It is interesting that blocking IL4 usage either by neutralizing the molecule or its receptor by monoclonal antibodies has no effect on the system. Which interleukins are important for germinal centers remains on open question. Evidence continues to accumulate on the important role of FDC and the molecules they express. Not only are the immune complexes an essential part, but it seems that molecules yet to be defined have an effect. For many practical reasons these have remained a mystery, but using our various systems we are attempting to reveal them. Two intriguing questions which remain include: 1. the molecular nature of the signalling between the FDC and B cell; and 2. how does the FDC retain the antigen in a native form for such long periods of time? An understanding of both mechanisms will provide us with a better appreciation for the events leading to a germinal center response and the immunological phenomenon referred to as memory.

Immigration of thoracic duct B lymphocytes into established germinal centers in the rat

Immigration of B lymphocytes into established germinal centers in the rat was studied by transferring genetically marked thoracic duct B cells to non-irradiated congenic hosts at various times between 3 days before and 6 days after host immunization. Seven days after host immunization, the distribution of donor B cells to lymph node germinal centers (relative to their distribution to non-germinal center lymph node areas) was measured by two-color flow cytometry in which (a) donor and host B cells were distinguished by their Ig kappa chain allotypes, and (b) germinal center B cells were distinguished by their lack of labeling with the monoclonal antibody HIS22. Thoracic duct B cells from long-term antigen-primed rats were found to immigrate into host germinal centers much better than B cells from unprimed donors. This effect was antigen specific: primed B cells only immigrated well into host germinal centers induced by the priming antigen. Although B cells localized in germinal centers most efficiently when injected before immunization, specifically primed donor B cells injected after immunization were still found to be at least as evenly distributed to germinal centers as to other lymph node areas, whereas unprimed B cells transferred after immunization localized poorly in host germinal centers. These findings are discussed in light of recent suggestions that memory B cell clones are maintained by continued antigenic stimulation within secondary lymphoid follicles.

Germinal centers develop oligoclonally

As part of our studies into the role of germinal centers, we investigated whether each de novo generated germinal center (GC) develops from one single GC precursor cell (GCPC, monoclonal development), a few GCPC (oligoclonal development) or from many GCPC (polyclonal development). Thus, lethally (9 Gy) X-irradiated AO (RT1u) rats were reconstituted with 10(8) thoracic duct lymphocytes (TDL) containing mixtures of AO and AO X BN cells in various ratios. The AO TDL were tolerant for AO X BN cells by using TDL from AO----(AO X BN)F1 (RT1u/n) X-irradiation bone marrow chimeras. To induce GC formation in the spleen of TDL-reconstituted rats, animals were i.v. injected with 10(9) sheep red blood cells. Five days after reconstitution and antigenic challenge spleens were taken for analysis of cellular make up of de novo generated GC. Spleen sections were immunohistochemically stained with monoclonal antibody F17-23-2, recognizing major histocompatibility complex class II antigens of the RT1n haplotype but not the RT1u haplotype, to discriminate between B cells of AO and AO X BN origin. Analysis of the GC in spleens of rats reconstituted with a mixture of AO and AO X BN TDL revealed three types of GC: GC entirely composed of AO cells, GC entirely composed of AO X BN cells and GC containing a mixture of both. The relative frequencies of these three types of GC indicated that in our experimental system, de novo GC developed oligoclonally from one to three GCPC. These data strongly suggest that GC are sites of antigen-driven expansion of peripheral B cells to very large clones.

The early postnatal development of the primary immune response in TNP-KLH-stimulated popliteal lymph node in the rat

The popliteal lymph nodes were removed from young rats of various ages five days after a single immunization with TNP-KLH in the hind footpads. Cryostat sections of the lymph nodes were investigated by means of enzyme- and immunohistochemical techniques at the light-microscopical level. The presence and localization of anti-TNP antibody-containing cells were examined using a new technique to visualize specific antibodies. Moreover, the development of the lymph nodes following exogenous antigenic stimulation was compared with that of unstimulated lymph nodes. Specific antibody-containing cells could not be found before day 15 after birth, in rats immunized at day 10. From that time these lymphoid cells were located primarily at the border between cortex and medulla. Younger popliteal lymph nodes showed only aspecific immunoglobulin-containing lymphoid cells. With age, the number of specific antibody-containing cells tended to increase. These cells were more mature, according to morphological criteria and were located nearer the medulla. The first primary follicles were seen at day 19, as was the case in unstimulated animals. The first secondary follicles, containing germinal centers, were detected at day 23, whereas in unstimulated popliteal lymph nodes they were never found. Trapping of immune complexes could not be demonstrated before day 33 after birth. The later appearance of this phenomenon might be a consequence of the techniques applied to demonstrate specific antibody-containing cells.

Functional anatomy of germinal centers

This year we celebrate the first centennial of the discovery of germinal centers by Flemming in 1884. The present paper reviews and adds new data to the functional anatomy of a germinal center. Emphasizing its reactive nature, we first describe a germinal center reaction and then deal with its infrastructural aspects and constituent cell populations, both lymphoid and nonlymphoid. Elements involved in the de novo formation of a germinal center, like antigen, T cells, and the mysterious germinal-center-precursor cell, are discussed. Next, attention is paid to the requirements for lymphoid cells to migrate into germinal centers, and novel features of germinal-center-seeking cells are presented. Subsequently, we discuss kinetic aspects of the high proliferative activity in a germinal center; and finally a description of the functional capacities of germinal-center-derived cells, such as B memory cells and IgM-antibody-forming cell precursors, completes this picture of present-day knowledge of the germinal center, a structure which has yet to reveal its last secrets.

Plasma cells and their precursors. II. Kinetics of B-memory cell production in rabbits

Rabbits were irradiated with 4.5 Gy in order to eliminate completely preexisting antibody-forming cell precursors. Sheep red blood cells were administered 24 h or 8 days after irradiation in order to induce the production of IgG B-memory AFCP. Resulting B-memory cells were triggered into antibody synthesis by a second dose of SRBC given 8 days after the challenge; the resulting IgG antibody clones were analyzed by isoelectric focusing. Memory IgG antibody clones were detectable from the third day after secondary immunization onward. It is concluded that antigen administered as early as 24 h after the irradiation induces B-memory cell production equally well as primary immunization 8 days after the irradiation. This B-memory cell production proceeds in the absence of detectable primary IgG antibody formation. Irradiated non-immunized rabbits showed spontaneous reappearance of IgG-AFCP with specificities to SRBC. In sharp contrast to the specifically induced production of B-memory IgG-AFCP mentioned above, this process took more than two months to reach potentialities comparable to those of "preexistent" AFCP present in normal, control rabbits.