Reversible interconversion of the functional state of the gene regulator FNR from Escherichia coli in vivo by O2 and iron availability

Phenazines Regulate Nap-Dependent Denitrification in Pseudomonas aeruginosa Biofilms

Microbes in biofilms face the challenge of substrate limitation. In particular, oxygen often becomes limited for cells in Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilms growing in the laboratory or during host colonization. Previously we found that phenazines, antibiotics produced by P. aeruginosa, balance the intracellular redox state of cells in biofilms. Here, we show that genes involved in denitrification are induced in phenazine-null (Δphz) mutant biofilms grown under an aerobic atmosphere, even in the absence of nitrate. This finding suggests that resident cells employ a bet-hedging strategy to anticipate the potential availability of nitrate and counterbalance their highly reduced redox state. Consistent with our previous characterization of aerobically grown colonies supplemented with nitrate, we found that the pathway that is induced in Δphz mutant colonies combines the nitrate reductase activity of the periplasmic enzyme Nap with the downstream reduction of nitrite to nitrogen gas catalyzed by the enzymes Nir, Nor, and Nos. This regulatory relationship differs from the denitrification pathway that functions under anaerobic growth, with nitrate as the terminal electron acceptor, which depends on the membrane-associated nitrate reductase Nar. We identified the sequences in the promoter regions of the nap and nir operons that are required for the effects of phenazines on expression. We also show that specific phenazines have differential effects on nap gene expression. Finally, we provide evidence that individual steps of the denitrification pathway are catalyzed at different depths within aerobically grown biofilms, suggesting metabolic cross-feeding between community subpopulations.IMPORTANCE An understanding of the unique physiology of cells in biofilms is critical to our ability to treat fungal and bacterial infections. Colony biofilms of the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa grown under an aerobic atmosphere but without nitrate express a denitrification pathway that differs from that used for anaerobic growth. We report that the components of this pathway are induced by electron acceptor limitation and that they are differentially expressed over the biofilm depth. These observations suggest that (i) P. aeruginosa exhibits "bet hedging," in that it expends energy and resources to prepare for nitrate availability when other electron acceptors are absent, and (ii) cells in distinct biofilm microniches may be able to exchange substrates to catalyze full denitrification.

Links between Anr and Quorum Sensing in Pseudomonas aeruginosa Biofilms

In Pseudomonas aeruginosa, the transcription factor Anr controls the cellular response to low oxygen or anoxia. Anr activity is high in oxygen-limited environments, including biofilms and populations associated with chronic infections, and Anr is necessary for persistence in a model of pulmonary infection. In this study, we characterized the Anr regulon in biofilm-grown cells at 1% oxygen in the laboratory strain PAO1 and in a quorum sensing (QS)-deficient clinical isolate, J215. As expected, transcripts related to denitrification, arginine fermentation, high-affinity cytochrome oxidases, and CupA fimbriae were lower in the Δanr derivatives. In addition, we observed that transcripts associated with quorum sensing regulation, iron acquisition and storage, type VI secretion, and the catabolism of aromatic compounds were also differentially expressed in the Δanr strains. Prior reports have shown that quorum sensing-defective mutants have higher levels of denitrification, and we found that multiple Anr-regulated processes, including denitrification, were strongly inversely proportional to quorum sensing in both transcriptional and protein-based assays. We also found that in LasR-defective strains but not their LasR-intact counterparts, Anr regulated the production of the 4-hydroxy-2-alkylquinolines, which play roles in quorum sensing and interspecies interactions. These data show that Anr was required for the expression of important metabolic pathways in low-oxygen biofilms, and they reveal an expanded and compensatory role for Anr in the regulation of virulence-related genes in quorum sensing mutants, such as those commonly isolated from infections.

IMPORTANCE

Pseudomonas aeruginosa causes acute ocular, soft tissue, and pulmonary infections, as well as chronic infections in the airways of cystic fibrosis patients. P. aeruginosa uses quorum sensing (QS) to regulate virulence, but mutations in the gene encoding the master regulator of QS, lasR, are frequently observed in clinical isolates. We demonstrated that the regulon attributed to Anr, an oxygen-sensitive transcription factor, was more highly expressed in lasR mutants. Furthermore, we show that Anr regulates the production of several different secreted factors in lasR mutants. These data demonstrate the importance of Anr in naturally occurring quorum sensing mutants in the context of chronic infections.

Three Pseudomonas putida FNR Family Proteins with Different Sensitivities to O2

The Escherichia coli fumarate-nitrate reduction regulator (FNR) protein is the paradigm for bacterial O₂-sensing transcription factors. However, unlike E. coli, some bacterial species possess multiple FNR proteins that presumably have evolved to fulfill distinct roles. Here, three FNR proteins (ANR, PP_3233, and PP_3287) from a single bacterial species, Pseudomonas putida KT2440, have been analyzed. Under anaerobic conditions, all three proteins had spectral properties resembling those of [4Fe-4S] proteins. The reactivity of the ANR [4Fe-4S] cluster with O₂ was similar to that of E. coli FNR, and during conversion to the apo-protein, via a [2Fe-2S] intermediate, cluster sulfur was retained. Like ANR, reconstituted PP_3233 and PP_3287 were converted to [2Fe-2S] forms when exposed to O₂, but their [4Fe-4S] clusters reacted more slowly. Transcription from an FNR-dependent promoter with a consensus FNR-binding site in P. putida and E. coli strains expressing only one FNR protein was consistent with the in vitro responses to O₂. Taken together, the experimental results suggest that the local environments of the iron-sulfur clusters in the different P. putida FNR proteins influence their reactivity with O₂, such that ANR resembles E. coli FNR and is highly responsive to low concentrations of O₂, whereas PP_3233 and PP_3287 have evolved to be less sensitive to O₂.

Transcriptional regulation of bacterial virulence gene expression by molecular oxygen and nitric oxide

Molecular oxygen (O₂) and nitric oxide (NO) are diatomic gases that play major roles in infection. The host innate immune system generates reactive oxygen species and NO as bacteriocidal agents and both require O₂ for their production. Furthermore, the ability to adapt to changes in O₂ availability is crucial for many bacterial pathogens, as many niches within a host are hypoxic. Pathogenic bacteria have evolved transcriptional regulatory systems that perceive these gases and respond by reprogramming gene expression. Direct sensors possess iron-containing co-factors (iron–sulfur clusters, mononuclear iron, heme) or reactive cysteine thiols that react with O₂ and/or NO. Indirect sensors perceive the physiological effects of O₂ starvation. Thus, O₂ and NO act as environmental cues that trigger the coordinated expression of virulence genes and metabolic adaptations necessary for survival within a host. Here, the mechanisms of signal perception by key O₂- and NO-responsive bacterial transcription factors and the effects on virulence gene expression are reviewed, followed by consideration of these aspects of gene regulation in two major pathogens, Staphylococcus aureus and Mycobacterium tuberculosis.

Bacterial iron-sulfur regulatory proteins as biological sensor-switches

SIGNIFICANCE

In recent years, bacterial iron-sulfur cluster proteins that function as regulators of gene transcription have emerged as a major new group. In all cases, the cluster acts as a sensor of the environment and enables the organism to adapt to the prevailing conditions. This can range from mounting a response to oxidative or nitrosative stress to switching between anaerobic and aerobic respiratory pathways. The sensitivity of these ancient cofactors to small molecule reactive oxygen and nitrogen species, in particular, makes them ideally suited to function as sensors.

RECENT ADVANCES

An important challenge is to obtain mechanistic and structural information about how these regulators function and, in particular, how the chemistry occurring at the cluster drives the subsequent regulatory response. For several regulators, including FNR, SoxR, NsrR, IscR, and Wbl proteins, major advances in understanding have been gained recently and these are reviewed here.

CRITICAL ISSUES

A common theme emerging from these studies is that the sensitivity and specificity of the cluster of each regulatory protein must be exquisitely controlled by the protein environment of the cluster.

FUTURE DIRECTIONS

A major future challenge is to determine, for a range of regulators, the key factors for achieving control of sensitivity/specificity. Such information will lead, eventually, to a system understanding of stress response, which often involves more than one regulator.

Reduced apo-fumarate nitrate reductase regulator (apoFNR) as the major form of FNR in aerobically growing Escherichia coli

Under anoxic conditions, the Escherichia coli oxygen sensor FNR (fumarate nitrate reductase regulator) is in the active state and contains a [4Fe-4S] cluster. Oxygen converts [4Fe-4S]FNR to inactive [2Fe-2S]FNR. After prolonged exposure to air in vitro, apoFNR lacking a Fe-S cluster is formed. ApoFNR can be differentiated from Fe-S-containing forms by the accessibility of the five Cys thiol residues, four of which serve as ligands for the Fe-S cluster. The presence of apoFNR in aerobically and anaerobically grown E. coli was analyzed in situ using thiol reagents. In anaerobically and aerobically grown cells, the membrane-permeable monobromobimane labeled one to two and four Cys residues, respectively; the same labeling pattern was found with impermeable thiol reagents after cell permeabilization. Alkylation of FNR in aerobic bacteria and counting the labeled residues by mass spectrometry showed a form of FNR with five accessible Cys residues, corresponding to apoFNR with all Cys residues in the thiol state. Therefore, aerobically growing cells contain apoFNR, whereas a significant amount of Fe-S-containing FNR was not detected under these conditions. Exposure of anaerobic bacteria to oxygen caused conversion of Fe-S-containing FNR to apoFNR within 6 min. ApoFNR from aerobic bacteria contained no disulfide, in contrast to apoFNR formed in vitro by air inactivation, and all Cys residues were in the thiol form.

In vivo cycling of the Escherichia coli transcription factor FNR between active and inactive states

FNR proteins are transcription regulators that sense changes in oxygen availability via assembly-disassembly of [4Fe-4S] clusters. The Escherichia coli FNR protein is present in bacteria grown under aerobic and anaerobic conditions. Under aerobic conditions, FNR is isolated as an inactive monomeric apoprotein, whereas under anaerobic conditions, FNR is present as an active dimeric holoprotein containing one [4Fe-4S] cluster per subunit. It has been suggested that the active and inactive forms of FNR are interconverted in vivo, or that iron-sulphur clusters are mostly incorporated into newly synthesized FNR. Here, experiments using a thermo-inducible fnr expression plasmid showed that a model FNR-dependent promoter is activated under anaerobic conditions by FNR that was synthesized under aerobic conditions. Immunoblots suggested that FNR was more prone to degradation under aerobic compared with anaerobic conditions, and that the ClpXP protease contributes to this degradation. Nevertheless, FNR was sufficiently long lived (half-life under aerobic conditions, approximately 45 min) to allow cycling between active and inactive forms. Measuring the abundance of the FNR-activated dms transcript when chloramphenicol-treated cultures were switched between aerobic and anaerobic conditions showed that it increased when cultures were switched to anaerobic conditions, and decreased when aerobic conditions were restored. In contrast, measurement of the abundance of the FNR-repressed ndh transcript under the same conditions showed that it decreased upon switching to anaerobic conditions, and then increased when aerobic conditions were restored. The abundance of the FNR- and oxygen-independent tatE transcript was unaffected by changes in oxygen availability. Thus, the simplest explanation for the observations reported here is that the FNR protein can be switched between inactive and active forms in vivo in the absence of de novo protein synthesis.

ClpXP-dependent Proteolysis of FNR upon Loss of its O2-sensing [4Fe–4S] Cluster

The global regulator FNR from Escherichia coli controls the transcription of genes required for an anaerobic lifestyle. While previous studies have demonstrated that FNR activity is regulated by O2 through loss of dimerization upon destruction of its [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster, the present study reveals that monomeric FNR protein is also a target of proteolysis. We have found that turnover of FNR protein is increased selectively under aerobic growth conditions, when FNR is not active as a transcription factor and is primarily a metal-free, monomeric form (apo-FNR). This degradation of monomeric FNR was dependent on the ClpXP protease and required the presence of two amino acid sequences within FNR that resemble known ClpX recognition motifs. By measuring the turnover rates of various FNR mutants that have unique properties with respect to dimerization and Fe-S cluster stability, we have shown that loss of dimerization upon [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster destruction by O2 targets FNR for degradation by the ClpXP protease. In addition, by measuring the differential rate of FNR degradation upon switching aerobic cultures to anaerobic growth conditions, we provide evidence that pre-existing FNR apo-protein can be converted to [4Fe-4S]2+ -FNR. Finally, we address the physiological significance of FNR proteolysis by demonstrating that varying FNR protein levels over a small range under aerobic growth conditions has a direct effect on the function of FNR in O2 sensing.

Kinetic analysis of the oxidative conversion of the [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster of FNR to a [2Fe-2S]2+ Cluster

The ability of FNR to sense and respond to cellular O(2) levels depends on its [4Fe-4S](2+) cluster. In the presence of O(2), the [4Fe-4S](2+) cluster is converted to a [2Fe-2S](2+) cluster, which inactivates FNR as a transcriptional regulator. In this study, we demonstrate that approximately 2 Fe(2+) ions are released from the reaction of O(2) with the [4Fe-4S](2+) cluster. Fe(2+) release was then used as an assay of reaction progress to investigate the rate of [4Fe-4S](2+) to [2Fe-2S](2+) cluster conversion in vitro. We also found that there was no detectable difference in the rate of O(2)-induced cluster conversion for FNR free in solution compared to its DNA-bound form. In addition, the rate of FNR inactivation was monitored in vivo by measuring the rate at which transcriptional regulation by FNR is lost upon the exposure of cells to O(2); a comparison of the in vitro and in vivo rates of conversion suggests that O(2)-induced cluster conversion is sufficient to explain FNR inactivation in cells. FNR protein levels were also compared for cells grown under aerobic and anaerobic conditions.

Functional versatility in the CRP-FNR superfamily of transcription factors: FNR and FLP

The cAMP receptor protein (CRP; sometimes known as CAP, the catabolite gene activator protein) and the fumarate and nitrate reduction regulator (FNR) of Escherichia coli are founder members of an expanding superfamily of structurally related transcription factors. The archetypal CRP structural fold provides a very versatile mechanism for transducing environmental and metabolic signals to the transcription machinery. It allows different functional specificities at the sensory, DNA-recognition and RNA-polymerase-interaction levels to be 'mixed and matched' in order to create a diverse range of transcription factors tailored to respond to particular physiological conditions. This versatility is clearly illustrated by comparing the properties of the CRP, FNR and FLP (FNR-like protein) regulators. At the sensory level, the basic structural fold has been adapted in FNR and FLP by the acquisition in the N-terminal region of different combinations of cysteine or other residues; which bestow oxygen/redox sensing mechanisms that are poised according to the oxidative stress thresholds affecting the metabolism of specific bacteria. At the DNA-recognition level, discrimination between distinct but related DNA targets is mediated by amino acid sequence modifications in the conserved core contact between the DNA-recognition helix and target DNA. And, at the level of RNA-polymerase-interaction, different combinations of three discrete regions contacting the polymerase (the activating regions) are used for polymerase recruitment and promoting transcription.

Role of glutathione in the formation of the active form of the oxygen sensor FNR ([4Fe-4S].FNR) and in the control of FNR function

The oxygen sensor regulator FNR (fumarate nitrate reductase regulator) of Escherichia coli is known to be inactivated by O2 as the result of conversion of a [4Fe-4S] cluster of the protein into a [2Fe-2S] cluster. Further incubation with O2 causes loss of the [2Fe-2S] cluster and production of apoFNR. The reactions involved in cluster assembly and reductive activation of apoFNR isolated under anaerobic or aerobic conditions were studied in vivo and in vitro. In a gshA mutant of E. coli that was completely devoid of glutathione, the O2 tension for the regulatory switch for FNR-dependent gene regulation was decreased by a factor of 4-5 compared with the wild-type, suggesting a role for glutathione in FNR function. In isolated apoFNR, glutathione could be used as the reducing agent for HS- formation required for [4Fe-4S] assembly by cysteine desulfurase (NifS), and for the reduction of cysteine ligands of the FeS cluster in FNR. Air-inactivated FNR (apoFNR without FeS) could be reconstituted to [4Fe-4S].FNR by the same reaction as used for apoFNR isolated under anaerobic conditions. The in vivo effects of glutathione on FNR function and the role of glutathione in the formation of active [4Fe-4S].FNR in vitro suggest an important role for glutathione in the de novo assembly of FNR and in the reductive activation of air-oxidized FNR under anaerobic conditions.

Oxygen sensing by the global regulator, FNR: the role of the iron-sulfur cluster

FNR is a global regulator that controls transcription of genes whose functions facilitate adaptation to growth under O2 limiting conditions. It has long been appreciated that the activity of FNR must be regulated by O2 availability, since FNR dependent gene expression is observed in vivo only under anaerobic conditions, while similar levels of this protein are present in both aerobic and anaerobic grown cells. Recent progress in this field has shown that anaerobically purified FNR contains a [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster and that this [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster is sufficiently unstable toward O2 to make it suitable as an O2 sensor. The presence of the [4Fe-4S] cluster increases dimerization of FNR which is correlated with an increase in site-specific DNA binding of FNR, a property expected of transcription factors of the FNR/CRP family. According to Mössbauer spectroscopy on purified FNR and cells containing overexpressed FNR, the [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster of FNR is converted by O2 to a [2Fe-2S]2+ in high yield. The [2Fe-2S]2+ cluster can be reconverted to the [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster on reduction with dithionite in vitro raising the possibility that the [2Fe-2S]2+ cluster is a biologically inactive intermediate which may be more readily available for reconstitution into the [4Fe-4S]2+ form than the Fe-free apoform. The ability to observe, by Mössbauer spectroscopy, the Fe-S clusters of FNR in cells containing high levels of FNR should be of value in further unraveling how FNR functions in vivo. Attempts to reduce the [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster of FNR with dithionite indicated that the redox potential of the +1/+2 couple is < or = -650 mV and that the [4Fe-4S]+ cluster form is, therefore, not likely to occur in vivo.

Mössbauer spectroscopy as a tool for the study of activation/inactivation of the transcription regulator FNR in whole cells of Escherichia coli

The global regulator FNR (for fumarate nitrate reduction) controls the transcription of >100 genes whose products facilitate adaptation of Escherichia coli to growth under O2-limiting conditions. Previous Mössbauer studies have shown that anaerobically purified FNR contains a [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster that, on exposure to oxygen, is converted into a [2Fe-2S]2+ cluster, a process that decreases DNA binding by FNR. Using 57Fe Mössbauer spectroscopy of E. coli cells containing overexpressed FNR, we show here that the same cluster conversion also occurs in vivo on exposure to O2. Furthermore, the data show that a significant amount of the [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster is regenerated when the cells are shifted back to an anaerobic environment. The present study also demonstrates that 57Fe Mössbauer spectroscopy can be employed to study the in vivo behavior of (overexpressed) proteins. The use of this technique to study other iron-containing cell components is discussed.

Mechanism of regulation of 8-hydroxyguanine endonuclease by oxidative stress: roles of FNR, ArcA, and Fur

We found previously that 8-hydroxyguanine (oh8Gua) endonuclease in E. coli is induced in response to oxidative stress in a fashion similar to the oxidative response of the Mn-superoxide dismutase (MnSOD). In this study, attempts were made to identify the genes involved in the co-regulation of E. coli endonuclease and MnSOD (sodA). oh8Gua nuclease is induced by molecular oxygen and a superoxide radical generator (paraquat) but not by H2O2, suggesting that the regulation of this endonuclease is dependent on SoxRS but independent of OxyR. This enzyme was induced by paraquat in all of the soxRS mutant strains used (soxR-, soxS- and soxRc), whereas glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (a member of the soxRS regulon) showed the expected responses; therefore, this possibility was excluded. The presence of metal chelators in the growth medium caused the induction of this enzyme, and this induction was suppressed by the addition of Fe++. Consistent with this finding, this enzyme was expressed under anaerobiosis in all of the mutant strains of fnr in particular, as well as fur, arcA, and combinations thereof. These findings suggest that the oxidative regulation of oh8Gua endonuclease is under control of fnr, fur, and arcA, where fnr plays a predominant role. The multiple involvement of regulatory genes as well as co-regulation with antioxidant enzyme will enhance the efficiency of cellular growth and survival in the aerobic environment.

Regulation of fumarase (fumB) gene expression in Escherichia coli in response to oxygen, iron and heme availability: role of the arcA, fur, and hemA gene products

Three distinct fumarases, FumA, FumB and FumC, have been reported in Escherichia coli. While the fumA and fumC gene products are expressed under aerobic cell growth conditions, the FumB fumarase appears to be more abundant during anaerobic growth. To study the transcriptional regulation of the fumB gene, a fumB-lacZ operon fusion was constructed and analyzed in a single copy under a variety of cell culture conditions. Expression of fumB-lacZ was fourfold higher under anaerobic than aerobic growth conditions. This anaerobic response is modulated by the ArcA and Fnr proteins, which function independently as anaerobic activators of fumB gene expression. Cellular iron limitation in a fur mutant caused fumB-lacZ expression to decrease sevenfold while cellular heme limitation decreased fumB gene expression twofold. In addition, fumB-lacZ expression was shown to vary depending on the DNA superhelicity. This study further delineates the regulation of the fumB gene in cell growth.

FNR is a direct oxygen sensor having a biphasic response curve

FNR is a transcription regulator that controls the expression of target genes in response to anoxia. Anaerobiosis is accompanied by the acquisition of two [4Fe-4S]2+ clusters per FNR dimer and the ability to bind DNA site-specifically. Oxidation of the [4Fe-4S]2+ form of FNR by O2 produced a non-DNA-binding, transcriptionally inactive form which also contains an iron-sulfur cluster, recently identified by Mossbauer spectroscopy as a [2Fe-2S] cluster (Khoroshilova et al., 1997, PNAS. 94, 6078). Complete conversion needed at least 2.5-3.0 molecules of O2 per [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster. Using sub-stoicheiometric amounts of air-saturated buffer, stable equilibria were established in which the [4Fe-4S]2+ and [2Fe-2S]2+ forms co-exist and no EPR detectable free ferric ions were released. In contrast, a 20-fold molar excess K3Fe(CN)6 was required to oxidise the [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster and in this case, ferric ions were released. FNR is therefore a sensitive O2 sensor.

Alternative respiratory pathways of Escherichia coli: energetics and transcriptional regulation in response to electron acceptors

The electron-transport chains of Escherichia coli are composed of many different dehydrogenases and terminal reductases (or oxidases) which are linked by quinones (ubiquinone, menaquinone and demethylmenaquinone). Quinol:cytochrome c oxido-reductase ('bc1 complex') is not present. For various electron acceptors (O2, nitrate) and donors (formate, H2, NADH, glycerol-3-P) isoenzymes are present. The enzymes show great variability in membrane topology and energy conservation. Energy is conserved by conformational proton pumps, or by arrangement of substrate sites on opposite sides of the membrane resulting in charge separation. Depending on the enzymes and isoenzymes used, the H+/e- ratios are between 0 and 4 H+/e- for the overall chain. The expression of the terminal reductases is regulated by electron acceptors. O2 is the preferred electron acceptor and represses the terminal reductases of anaerobic respiration. In anaerobic respiration, nitrate represses other terminal reductases, such as fumarate or DMSO reductases. Energy conservation is maximal with O2 and lowest with fumarate. By this regulation pathways with high ATP or growth yields are favoured. The expression of the dehydrogenases is regulated by the electron acceptors, too. In aerobic growth, non-coupling dehydrogenases are expressed and used preferentially, whereas in fumarate or DMSO respiration coupling dehydrogenases are essential. Coupling and non-coupling isoenzymes are expressed correspondingly. Thus the rationale for expression of the dehydrogenases is not maximal energy yield, but could be maximal flux or growth rates. Nitrate regulation is effected by two-component signal transfer systems with membraneous nitrate/nitrite sensors (NarX, NarQ) and cytoplasmic response regulators (NarL, NarP) which communicate by protein phosphorylation. O2 regulates by a two-component regulatory system consisting of a membraneous sensor (ArcB) and a response regulator (ArcA). ArcA is the major regulator of aerobic metabolism and represses the genes of aerobic metabolism under anaerobic conditions. FNR is a cytoplasmic O2 responsive regulator with a sensory and a regulatory DNA-binding domain. FNR is the regulator of genes required for anaerobic respiration and related pathways. The binding sites of NarL, NarP, ArcA and FNR are characterized for various promoters. Most of the genes are regulated by more than one of the regulators, which can act in any combination and in a positive or negative mode. By this the hierarchical expression of the genes in response to the electron acceptors is achieved. FNR is located in the cytoplasm and contains a 4Fe4S cluster in the sensory domain. The regulatory concentrations of O2 are 1-5 mbar. Under these conditions O2 diffuses to the cytoplasm and is able to react directly with FNR without involvement of other specific enzymes or protein mediators. By oxidation of the FeS cluster, FNR is converted to the inactive state in a reversible process. Reductive activation could be achieved by cellular reductants in the absence of O2. In addition, O2 may cause destruction and loss of the FeS cluster. It is not known whether this process is required for regulation of FNR function.

O2 as the regulatory signal for FNR-dependent gene regulation in Escherichia coli

With an oxystat, changes in the pattern of expression of FNR-dependent genes from Escherichia coli were studied as a function of the O2 tension (pO2) in the medium. Expression of all four tested genes was decreased by increasing O2. However, the pO2 values that gave rise to half-maximal repression (pO(0.5)) were dependent on the particular promoter and varied between 1 and 5 millibars (1 bar = 10(5) Pa). The pO(0.5) value for the ArcA-regulated succinate dehydrogenase genes was in the same range (pO(0.5) = 4.6 millibars). At these pO2 values, the cytoplasm can be calculated to be well supplied with O2 by diffusion. Therefore, intracellular O2 could provide the signal to FNR, suggesting that there is no need for a signal transfer chain. Genetic inactivation of the enzymes and coenzymes of aerobic respiration had no or limited effects on the pO(0.5) of FNR-regulated genes. Thus, neither the components of aerobic respiration nor their redox state are the primary sites for O2 sensing, supporting the significance of intracellular O2. Non-redox-active, structural O2 analogs like CO, CN-, and N3-, could not mimic the effect of O2 on FNR-regulated genes under anaerobic conditions and did not decrease the inhibitory effect of O2 under aerobic conditions.

Reactivity of the N-terminal cysteine residues in active and inactive forms of FNR, and O2-responsive, Fe containing transcriptional regulator of Escherichia coli

FNR, the O2-responsive gene regulator of anaerobic respiratory genes in Escherichia coli, contains an N-terminal cluster of four cysteine residues (Cys16-X3-Cys20-X2-Cys23-X5-Cys29), three of which are thought to be involved in the binding of an iron cofactor. The accessibility of the cysteine residues for iodoacetate is known to increase upon switch from the active (anaerobic) to the inactive (aerobic or metal depleted) state. It was analyzed which residues become accessible under either condition. Up to four modified forms, FNR-I, FNR-II, FNR-III, and FNR-IV, containing approximately 1, 2, 3.5, and 5 carboxymethyl groups, were obtained either by reaction in vivo and in vitro under conditions of aerobiosis, anaerobiosis, or iron limitation. By N-terminal sequencing, the carboxymethylated cysteine residues were identified. The amount of label in each of the four cysteine residues increased rather uniformly and gradually from FNR-I to FNR-IV irrespective of the condition of labeling; only Cys16 was preferentially labeled to some extent. It is concluded that the four essential cysteine residues change their accessibility in a similar way in the switch from active to inactive (aerobic or metal depleted) FNR, without specific differences in their reaction or function. Potential modes of Fe-binding by the cysteine residues are discussed. In addition, a different type of interaction of Fe(II) with FNR is described. The interaction occurred also in FNR carboxymethylated at approximately three cysteine residues.

Association of a polynuclear iron-sulfur center with a mutant FNR protein enhances DNA binding

In the facultative anaerobe Escherichia coli, the transcription factor FNR (fumarate nitrate reduction) regulates gene expression in response to oxygen deprivation. To investigate how the activity of FNR is regulated by oxygen availability, two mutant proteins, DA154 and LH28-DA154, which have enhanced in vivo activity in the presence of oxygen, were purified and compared. Unlike other previously examined FNR preparations, the absorption spectrum of LH28-DA154 had two maxima at 324 nm and 419 nm, typical of iron-sulfur (Fe-S)-containing proteins. Consistent with these data, metal analysis showed that only the LH28-DA154 protein contained a significant amount of iron and acid-labile sulfide, and, by low temperature EPR spectroscopy, a signal typical of a [3Fe-4S]+ cluster was detected. The LH28-DA154 protein that contained the Fe-S cluster also contained a higher proportion of dimers and had a 3- to 4-fold higher apparent affinity for the target DNA than the DA154 protein. In agreement with this, we found that when the LH28-DA154 protein was treated with an iron chelator (alpha,alpha'-dipyridyl), it lost its characteristic absorption and the apparent affinity for DNA was reduced 6-fold. However, increased DNA binding and the characteristic absorption spectrum could be restored by in vitro reconstitution of the Fe-S center. DNA binding of the LH28-DA154 protein was also affected by the redox state of the Fe-S center, since protein exposed to oxygen bound 1/10th as much DNA as the protein reduced anaerobically with dithionite. The observation that DNA binding is enhanced when the Fe-S center is reduced indicates that the redox state of the Fe-S center affects the DNA-binding activity of this protein and suggests a possible mechanism for regulation of the wild-type protein.

Aerobic-anaerobic gene regulation in Escherichia coli: control by the ArcAB and Fnr regulons

A variety of pathways for carbon and electron flow in the bacterium Escherichia coli and in other enteric bacteria are differentially expressed depending on whether molecular oxygen is present in the cell environment. This review briefly summarizes the metabolic pathways operative during aerobic versus anaerobic cell growth, and provides a regulatory overview for how the cell controls expression of the many genes involved in these processes. The cell has two distinctly different transcriptional regulators, consisting of the Fnr and the ArcA/ArcB regulatory proteins to accomplish this task. Together, they coordinate gene expression to adjust carbon flow with electron flow and energy generation so that cells can balance growth in an efficiently coupled manner.

Regulation of transcription at the ndh promoter of Escherichia coli by FNR and novel factors

FNR is a transcriptional regulator that controls gene expression in response to oxygen limitation in Escherichia coli. The NADH dehydrogenase II gene (ndh) is repressed by FNR under anaerobic conditions. Repression is not simply due to occlusion of the promoter (-35 and -10) region by FNR because adjacent pairs of FNR monomers were found to bind at two sites centred at -50.5 and -94.5 in the ndh promoter region without preventing RNA polymerase binding. However, contact between RNA polymerase and the -132 to -62 region of the non-coding strand of ndh DNA, and RNA polymerase-mediated open complex formation, were prevented by bound FNR. The upstream FNR-binding site (-94.5) was needed for efficient FNR-dependent repression of ndh transcription in vitro, and also for repression of an ndh-lacZ fusion in vivo. Anaerobic ndh repression may thus involve the binding of two pairs of FNR monomers upstream of the -35 region, which prevents essential RNA polymerase-DNA contacts in the upstream region as well as inhibiting RNA polymerase function by direct FNR interaction. Expression of the ndh-lacZ fusion in an fnr deletion strain was enhanced by anaerobic growth in rich medium or minimal medium supplemented with amino acids. Furthermore, two proteins (M(r) 12,000 and 35,000) which interact with and may activate transcription from the ndh promoter under these conditions were detected by gel retardation analysis. These putative amino acid-responsive activators may thus offset FNR-mediated repression and maintain a low level of anaerobic ndh expression for regulating the NAD+/NADH ratio during growth in rich media.

Oxygen regulated gene expression in facultatively anaerobic bacteria

In facultatively anaerobic bacteria such as Escherichia coli, oxygen and other electron acceptors fundamentally influence catabolic and anabolic pathways. E. coli is able to grow aerobically by respiration and in the absence of O2 by anaerobic respiration with nitrate, nitrite, fumarate, dimethylsulfoxide and trimethylamine N-oxide as acceptors or by fermentation. The expression of the various catabolic pathways occurs according to a hierarchy with 3 or 4 levels. Aerobic respiration at the highest level is followed by nitrate respiration (level 2), anaerobic respiration with the other acceptors (level 3) and fermentation. In other bacteria, different regulatory cascades with other underlying principles can be observed. Regulation of anabolism in response to O2 availability is important, too. It is caused by different requirements of cofactors or coenzymes in aerobic and anaerobic metabolism and by the requirement for different O2-independent biosynthetic routes under anoxia. The regulation mainly occurs at the transcriptional level. In E. coli, 4 global regulatory systems are known to be essential for the aerobic/anaerobic switch and the described hierarchy. A two-component sensor/regulator system comprising ArcB (sensor) and ArcA (transcriptional regulator) is responsible for regulation of aerobic metabolism. The FNR protein is a transcriptional sensor-regulator protein which regulates anaerobic respiratory genes in response to O2 availability. The gene activator FhlA regulates fermentative formate and hydrogen metabolism with formate as the inductor. ArcA/B and FNR directly respond to O2, FhlA indirectly by decreased levels of formate in the presence of O2. Regulation of nitrate/nitrite catabolism is effected by two 2-component sensor/regulator systems NarX(Q)/NarL(P) in response to nitrate/nitrite. Co-operation of the different regulatory systems at the target promoters which are in part under dual (or manifold) transcriptional control causes the expression according to the hierarchy. The sensing of the environmental signals by the sensor proteins or domains is not well understood so far. FNR, which acts presumably as a cytoplasmic 'one component' sensor-regulator, is suggested to sense directly cytoplasmic O2-levels corresponding to the environmental O2-levels.

Activation of FNR-dependent transcription by iron: an in vitro switch for FNR

FNR is an iron-binding transcriptional regulator of Escherichia coli which controls the expression of target genes in response to anaerobiosis. The mechanism used by FNR to sense and respond to anaerobiosis is unknown but it is thought to involve iron. In vitro transcription analyses have shown that iron-deficient FNR is unable to activate transcription from the FF-melR promoter, but activity could be restored by preincubation with Fe2+ and beta-mercaptoethanol. The reactivation of FNR was prevented and reversed by chelating agents, and this reactivation thus provides an artificial in vitro switch for FNR-dependent transcriptional activation.

A role for iron in transcriptional activation by FNR

FNR is a transcriptional regulator which controls the expression of target genes in response to anoxia in Escherichia coli. The mechanism by which FNR senses and responds to anaerobiosis is unknown but indirect evidence suggests that an iron cofactor is involved. Using KMnO4 as a probe for DNA melting at active promoters, footprinting studies have now shown that the ferrous iron chelator, ferrozine, inhibits open complex formation in vivo, and that FNR with a high iron-content is essential for open complex formation in vitro. Since open complex formation is an essential pre-requisite for transcription, it is concluded that transcriptional activation by FNR is mediated by a ferrous iron cofactor.

Properties of FNR proteins substituted at each of the five cysteine residues

FNR is a transcriptional regulator controlling the expression of a number of Escherichia coli genes in response to anoxia. It is structurally-related to CRP (the cyclic AMP receptor protein) except for the presence of a cysteine-rich N-terminal extension, which may form part of an iron-binding, redox-sensing domain in FNR. Site-directed substitution has previously shown that four of the cysteine residues (C20, C23, C29 and C122) are essential for FNR function, whereas the fifth (C16) is not. The FNR protein exists in two forms separable by non-reducing SDS-PAGE, and in studies with altered FNR proteins containing single substitutions at each of the five cysteine residues it was concluded that the faster-migrating form (FNR(27)), possesses an intramolecular disulphide bond linking C122 to one of the cysteines near the N-terminus. FNR(27) was more abundant in aerobic cells but the physiological significance of this was not established. Footprint studies indicated that FNR proteins lacking essential cysteine residues are impaired in their ability to protect FNR sites in the ndh promoter. The non-essential cysteine residue (C16) was identified as the source of the most reactive sulphydryl group and all of the inactive proteins exhibited different sulphydryl reactivities. The iron content of the C122A-substituted protein was much reduced but those of the other proteins were less affected. Electrospray mass spectrometry confirmed the accuracy of the gene-derived amino acid composition of FNR with a mutant protein and it showed that a fraction of the wild-type protein may carry a 78 Da substituent which could not be removed with dithiothreitol or beta-mercaptoethanol.

Induction of manganese-containing superoxide dismutase in anaerobic Escherichia coli by diamide and 1,10-phenanthroline: sites of transcriptional regulation

Transcriptional regulation of the sodA gene, a member of the soxRS regulon encoding the manganese-containing superoxide dismutase (MnSOD; superoxide:superoxide oxidoreductase, EC 1.15.1.1) of Escherichia coli, was examined in a variety of regulatory mutants. Diamide, an oxidant that causes the anaerobic biosynthesis of the MnSOD polypeptide and also facilitates insertion of manganese at the active site, was found to anaerobically induce MnSOD in both soxRS and fur arcA fnr strains. Metal chelating agents also caused anaerobic induction of MnSOD in a fur arcA fnr triple mutant; however, this induction of MnSOD and of glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) by 1,10-phenanthroline was dependent on an intact soxRS locus. A strain of E. coli bearing a fusion of the soxS promoter to lacZ was used to demonstrate that both diamide and 1,10-phenanthroline caused anaerobic activation of soxS transcription. These results indicate that (i) both diamide and 1,10-phenanthroline induce the soxRS regulon anaerobically by stimulation of soxS transcription; (ii) diamide, but not metal chelators, also induces MnSOD biosynthesis by a soxRS-independent mechanism, perhaps mediated by effects on fur, arcA, or fnr-mediated repression of sodA; and (iii) the soxRS locus contains a metal-binding component and is responsive to the redox status of the cell.

The effect of iron limitation on expression of the aerobic and anaerobic electron transport pathway genes in Escherichia coli

To determine whether the aerobic and anaerobic respiratory pathways of Escherichia coli are regulated in response to iron availability, strains containing lacZ reporter fusions to the cydAB, cyoABCDE, narGHJI, dmsABC and frdABCD operons were grown in medium limited for iron by use of the chelator, 2,2'-dipyridyl. Under anaerobic conditions, expression of the anaerobic respiratory pathway operons, narG-lacZ, dmsA-lacZ and frdA-lacZ, was reduced 14-16 fold when iron was limited. In contrast, expression of the aerobic pathway operons, cyoA-lacZ and cydA-lacZ, was elevated modestly. Iron-dependent transcriptional control of these operons was independent of the fur gene which encodes an iron-and-DNA-binding regulatory protein. The expression of fnr-lacZ was relatively unaffected by iron limitation suggesting that Fnr levels in the cell do not change in response to iron. The above findings suggest that in addition to Fur, some other cellular protein may bind iron for reporting and regulating iron-dependent cell functions.

The Rhizobium leguminosarum FnrN protein is functionally similar to Escherichia coli Fnr and promotes heterologous oxygen-dependent activation of transcription

An open reading frame from Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae strain VF39, previously identified and found to be similar to Escherichia coli fnr and Rhizobium meliloti fixK (orf240, thereafter called fnrN), was further analysed. Analysis of the expression of an fnrN-lacZ transcriptional fusion revealed that fnrN is preferentially expressed under oxygen limitation. Using R. meliloti fixN-lacZ fusions it was shown that the fnrN gene product only mediates transcriptional activation under microaerobiosis, indicating that the FnrN protein responds, directly or indirectly, to oxygen. Plasmids which expressed fnrN under the control of an E. coli promoter were able to complement an E. coli fnr mutant with respect to anaerobic growth on nitrate but not fumarate, and to promote anaerobic but not aerobic activation of the Fnr-dependent E. coli genes narGHJI, nirB and fdnGHI coding for nitrate reductase, NADH-dependent nitrite reductase and formate dehydrogenase-N, respectively. Fumarate and DMSO reductase activities were not induced by FnrN. The E. coli fnr gene substituted for fnrN in oxygen-regulated transcription of nirB- and fixN-lacZ fusions in R. leguminosarum. The results indicate that Fnr and FnrN are functionally very similar and share a common mode of oxygen-dependent transcriptional activation. From hybridization studies, it appeared that fnrN-like genes are present in a number of different R. leguminosarum strains.

Anaerobic fumarate transport in Escherichia coli by an fnr-dependent dicarboxylate uptake system which is different from the aerobic dicarboxylate uptake system

Escherichia coli grown anaerobically with fumarate as electron acceptor is able to take up C4-dicarboxylates by a specific transport system. The system differs in all tested parameters from the known aerobic C4-dicarboxylate transporter. The anaerobic transport system shows higher transport rates (95 mumol/g [dry weight] per min versus 30 mumol/g/min) and higher Kms (400 versus 30 microM) for fumarate than for the aerobic system. Mutants lacking the aerobic dicarboxylate uptake system are able to grow anaerobically at the expense of fumarate respiration and transport dicarboxylates with wild-type rates after anaerobic but not after aerobic growth. Transport by the anaerobic system is stimulated by preloading the bacteria with dicarboxylates. The anaerobic transport system catalyzes homologous and heterologous antiport of dicarboxylates, whereas the aerobic system operates only in the unidirectional mode. The anaerobic antiport is measurable only in anaerobically grown bacteria with fnr+ backgrounds. Additionally, the system is inhibited by incubation of resting bacteria with physiological electron acceptors such as O2, nitrate, dimethyl sulfoxide, and fumarate. The inhibition is reversed by the presence of reducing agents. It is suggested that the physiological role of the system is a fumarate/succinate antiport under conditions of fumarate respiration.