Insulin autoantibodies are associated with islet cell antibodies; their relation to insulin antibodies and B-cell function in diabetic children

Preexisting insulin autoantibodies predict efficacy of otelixizumab in preserving residual β-cell function in recent-onset type 1 diabetes

OBJECTIVE

Immune intervention trials in recent-onset type 1 diabetes would benefit from biomarkers associated with good therapeutic response. In the previously reported randomized placebo-controlled anti-CD3 study (otelixizumab; GlaxoSmithKline), we tested the hypothesis that specific diabetes autoantibodies might serve this purpose.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

In the included patients (n = 40 otelixizumab, n = 40 placebo), β-cell function was assessed as area under the curve (AUC) C-peptide release during a hyperglycemic glucose clamp at baseline (median duration of insulin treatment: 6 days) and every 6 months until 18 months after randomization. (Auto)antibodies against insulin (I[A]A), GAD (GADA), IA-2 (IA-2A), and ZnT8 (ZnT8A) were determined on stored sera by liquid-phase radiobinding assay.

RESULTS

At baseline, only better preserved AUC C-peptide release and higher levels of IAA were associated with better preservation of β-cell function and lower insulin needs under anti-CD3 treatment. In multivariate analysis, IAA (P = 0.022) or the interaction of IAA and C-peptide (P = 0.013) independently predicted outcome together with treatment. During follow-up, good responders to anti-CD3 treatment (i.e., IAA(+) participants with relatively preserved β-cell function [≥ 25% of healthy control subjects]) experienced a less pronounced insulin-induced rise in I(A)A and lower insulin needs. GADA, IA-2A, and ZnT8A levels were not influenced by anti-CD3 treatment, and their changes showed no relation to functional outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

There is important specificity of IAA among other diabetes autoantibodies to predict good therapeutic response of recent-onset type 1 diabetic patients to anti-CD3 treatment. If confirmed, future immune intervention trials in type 1 diabetes should consider both relatively preserved functional β-cell mass and presence of IAA as inclusion criteria.

Etiopathogenesis of insulin autoimmunity

Autoimmunity against pancreatic islet beta cells is strongly associated with proinsulin, insulin, or both. The insulin autoreactivity is particularly pronounced in children with young age at onset of type 1 diabetes. Possible mechanisms for (pro)insulin autoimmunity may involve beta-cell destruction resulting in proinsulin peptide presentation on HLA-DR-DQ Class II molecules in pancreatic draining lymphnodes. Recent data on proinsulin peptide binding to type 1 diabetes-associated HLA-DQ2 and -DQ8 is reviewed and illustrated by molecular modeling. The importance of the cellular immune reaction involving cytotoxic CD8-positive T cells to kill beta cells through Class I MHC is discussed along with speculations of the possible role of B lymphocytes in presenting the proinsulin autoantigen over and over again through insulin-carrying insulin autoantibodies. In contrast to autoantibodies against other islet autoantigens such as GAD65, IA-2, and ZnT8 transporters, it has not been possible yet to standardize the insulin autoantibody test. As islet autoantibodies predict type 1 diabetes, it is imperative to clarify the mechanisms of insulin autoimmunity.

Type 1 diabetes intervention trials: what have we learned? A critical review of selected intervention trials

Developing therapies to stop or slow the immune destruction of islets has been a goal of investigators in type 1 diabetes for several decades. This review of clinical interventions in patients with type 1 diabetes indicates both negative and positive outcomes with a variety of different therapeutic agents. An underlying theme of this article is that differences in study design may impact the outcome more than the therapy being tested. Thus, each of these results need to be considered in the context of important variables in study design. To date, there is no clear answer as to what study design is best to determine if an agent is effective against the diabetes disease process; however, the Immunology of Diabetes Society has recently developed guidelines for the conduct of these trials to facilitate comparisons of therapies in the future.

Photopheresis at onset of type 1 diabetes: a randomised, double blind, placebo controlled trial

BACKGROUND

In recent years photopheresis, an extracorporeal form of photochemotherapy using psoralen and ultraviolet A irradiation of leucocytes, has been claimed to be an effective form of immunomodulation.

AIM

To evaluate its effect in type 1 diabetes we performed a double blind, controlled study using placebo tablets and sham pheresis in the control group.

METHODS

A total of 49 children, aged 10-18 years of age at diagnosis of type 1 diabetes were included; 40 fulfilled the study and were followed for three years (19 received active treatment with photopheresis and 21 placebo treatment).

RESULTS

The actively treated children secreted significantly more C peptide in urine during follow up than control children. C peptide values in serum showed corresponding differences between the two groups. The insulin dose/kg body weight needed to achieve satisfactory HbA1c values was always lower in the photopheresis group; there was no difference between the groups regarding HbA1c values during follow up. The treatment was well accepted except for nausea (n = 3) and urticaria (n = 1) in the actively treated group. There were no differences regarding weight or height, or episodes of infection between the two groups during follow up.

CONCLUSION

Photopheresis does have an effect in addition to its possible placebo effect, shown as a weak but significant effect on the disease process at the onset of type 1 diabetes, an effect still noted after three years of follow up.

An 8-year follow-up of anti-insulin antibodies in diabetic children: relation to insulin autoantibodies, HLA type, beta-cell function, clinical course and type of insulin therapy

In 105 children and adolescents with IDDM, insulin antibodies were detected as a percentage of radiolabelled insulin both at onset of disease and during the first 8 years of treatment. At diagnosis, 29 patients (27%) were insulin autoantibody positive (IAA+). An inverse relationship was found between IAA levels and age at diagnosis. No significant correlation was seen between IAA positivity and HLA antigens, while there was a negative correlation between IAA and C-peptide levels in the second year of the disease. The percentage of insulin antibody (IA) positive patients increased after insulin administration, with a maximum peak between the first and second year of the disease. The IA response to insulin therapy was similar in IAA+ and IAA- patients, while it was greater in younger children. No relationship was found between IA levels and haemoglobin A1c values, daily insulin requirement, HLA and early complications. No difference in either percentage of positivity or IA levels was seen in patients treated continually for the first 5 years of the disease with monocomponent porcine insulin or human insulin. A negative correlation was found between IA and C-peptide levels in the first and second years of the disease. In conclusion, we have shown that, even after many years of disease, neither IAA nor IA, induced in equal measures by current human insulin preparations, have significant effects on the clinical course of the disease.

Islet cell antibodies (ICA), insulin autoantibodies (IAA), islet cell surface antibodies (ICSA) and C-peptide in 1031 school children in a population with a high background incidence of IDDM

Islet cell antibodies (ICA), insulin autoantibodies (IAA) and islet cell surface antibodies (ICSA) together with C-peptide were determined in 1031 healthy schoolchildren to evaluate the frequency of autoimmune reactions towards endocrine pancreas and its relation to insulin secretion in non-diabetic children. The prevalence of ICA (levels > 6 JDF units) was 1.4% (14/1012) while 44 children (4.3%) were ICSA-positive and 40 (4%) had IAA. Girls had higher titres of ICSA than boys. Young children (7-8 years) more often had IAA than 12-13-year-old children who, however, had ICA three times more often than the young children. There were no clear associations between the different antibodies. Of the children, 2.4% had very low post-prandial serum C-peptide values (< or = 0.25 nmol/l). Serum C-peptide was higher in girls than in boys (P < 0.001) and in older children than in younger (P < 0.001). Girls with low levels of ICA had high C-peptide values, while girls with high ICA titers had low C-peptide values, the latter perhaps indicating partial beta cell loss. IAA and ICSA were not related to C-peptide values but both positive ICSA and high C-peptide values were most common in the autumn (P < 0.02 and P < 0.0001, respectively). One of the ICA-positive children developed diabetes in 1991, 4 years after the blood sample was taken. Since after 5 years only one of the children has developed IDDM, it can be concluded autoimmune reactions towards endocrine pancreas and insulin may occur in many children without the development of manifest diabetes. Those with high ICA titers may have lost so many beta cells that their insulin secretion is affected, which in some cases might lead to diabetes many years later.

Comparison of anti-human insulin antibodies detection by commercial enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay kit, displacement enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and radioimmunoassay, in Thai diabetic patients

Antibodies specific to human insulin, in sera of Thai diabetic patients and normal healthy individuals, were detected by a commercial enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) kit, displacement ELISA and radioimmunoassay (RIA). Among 36 insulin-treated patients, the antibodies were detected in 22, 23 and 20 individuals, by RIA, commercial ELISA kit and displacement ELISA, respectively. Among those who had never previously received insulin therapy, RIA showed positive results in 5/11 patients with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) and 1/2 patients with fibrocalculous pancreatic diabetes (FCPD); but were negative in all 26 patients with non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (NIDDM) and 30 normal healthy individuals. The commercial ELISA kit could detect such insulin autoantibodies (IAA) in 4/11 IDDM, 3/26 NIDDM, 2/2 FCPD patients and 4/30 normal controls; while the displacement ELISA showed positive IAA detection in 5/11 IDDM, 2/26 NIDDM, 2/2 FCPD and 2/30 normal controls. By using RIA as the 'gold standard', the commercial ELISA kit had 92.86% sensitivity, 87.01% specificity, 88.57% accuracy, 72.22% positive predictive value and 97.10% negative predictive value; while these indices for the displacement ELISA were 85.71%, 90.01%, 89.52%, 77.42% and 94.59%, respectively.

Prospective evaluation of beta-cell function in insulin autoantibody-positive relatives of insulin-dependent diabetic patients

During the preclinical period of insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM), progression to clinical IDDM is characterized by declining beta-cell function. Although the presence of insulin autoantibodies (IAA) improves the ability of islet cell antibodies (ICA) to predict subsequent clinical IDDM, few studies have examined the risk of developing IDDM in subjects positive for IAA but negative for both ICA and antibodies to glutamic acid decarboxylase (64kA). To investigate this question, detailed beta-cell function tests (acute insulin response to glucose [AIRgluc] and slope of glucose potentiation) were performed on eight IAA-positive first-degree relatives of insulin-dependent diabetics. All eight subjects were negative for ICA, and seven were tested for 64kA and were negative. Five subjects were studied prospectively for 22.4 +/- 9.4 months, while three subjects had only initial studies. Initial beta-cell function tests were normal in each subject. AIRgluc was 122.2% +/- 19.0% of the expected normal response, while slope was 168.6% +/- 20.6% of expected normal response. beta-cell function remained normal and remarkably stable in the five subjects followed prospectively. AIRgluc did not significantly change from an initial value of 147.9% +/- 23.1% of expected to 153.2% +/- 22.4% (NS). The slope of glucose potentiation varied little from 165.5% +/- 39.4% initially to 159.5% +/- 27.3% (NS) at the most recent determination. We conclude that among nondiabetic first-degree relatives of IDDM subjects, the presence of IAA in the absence of ICA and 64kA is not usually associated with and therefore does not reliably predict beta-cell dysfunction or progressive deterioration in beta-cell function.

Autoantibodies to insulin have similar affinity to that of antibodies to exogenous insulin but lower binding capacity

The binding characteristics of insulin autoantibodies (IAA) were compared with those of antibodies to exogenous insulin (IBA) by analyzing the specific binding, binding capacity and affinity for insulin in 11 children (age range 1.5-13.0 years) with insulin-dependent diabetes (IDDM) both at diagnosis and after 1 year of insulin treatment. Maximal specific insulin binding was 7.8 (1.5; SE) pmol l-1 for IAA and 28.1 (6.7) pmol l-1 for IBA (P < 0.01), and the binding capacity of the high affinity class of IAA 0.01 (0.003) nmol l-1, as compared with 0.19 (0.08) nmol l-1 for the corresponding IBA class (P < 0.01). With regard to the low-affinity components the binding capacity was 0.11 (0.05) nmol l-1 for IAA and 1.50 (0.95) nmol l-1 for IBA (P < 0.01). No differences in the affinity constants could be observed between IAA and IBA. There was no correlation between the insulin binding of IAA and quantitative levels of islet cell antibodies (ICA) at the clinical presentation or subsequent IBA values. The specific insulin binding of IBA correlated negatively with serum C-peptide concentrations and positively with HbA1 levels at 1 year. The present observations suggest that IAA developing before the diagnosis of IDDM are characterized by a reduced binding capacity as compared with antibodies to exogenous insulin, whereas they have a similar affinity for insulin. IAA seem to be quantitatively unrelated to ICA and postdiagnostic IBA levels. High IBA levels appear to be associated with reduced endogenous insulin secretion and poor metabolic control during the early clinical course of the disease.

Detection of autoantibodies against islet amyloid polypeptide in human serum. Lack of association with type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus, or with conditions favouring amyloid deposition in islets. The Belgian Diabetes Registry

A radiobinding assay for the detection of autoantibodies against islet amyloid polypeptide was developed, analytically validated, and--in parallel with a similar assay for the detection of autoantibodies against insulin--applied to sera from recent-onset Type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetic patients and from age- and sex-matched control subjects. There was no difference in islet amyloid polypeptide autoantibody titres between patient groups and matched control subjects, nor within subject groups according to age. At onset of Type 1 diabetes, elevated islet amyloid polypeptide-autoantibody levels (> 97th percentile of control subjects) were only detected in 1 of 30 patients aged 0-19 years and in 2 of 35 patients aged 20-39 years. By contrast, insulin autoantibodies were frequently demonstrated, in particular at onset of diabetes under age 20 (0-19 years: 18 of 30 patients; 20-39 years: 10 of 35 patients; p < 0.01 vs matched control subjects). Islet amyloid polypeptide autoantibodies were not detectable in 3 insulinoma patients nor in 37 patients (aged 33-70 years) with Type 2 diabetes (vs 1 of 40 in matched control subjects). In positive serum, adsorption onto protein A-Sepharose removed islet amyloid polypeptide binding activity, hereby confirming its antibody nature. In conclusion, Type 1 diabetes is associated with an age-dependent autoantibody reaction against insulin but not against islet amyloid polypeptide. Conditions associated with amyloid deposition in islets (Type 2 diabetes, insulinoma and ageing) do not favour the formation of autoantibodies against islet amyloid polypeptide.

Immune responses to insulin and lymphocyte subclasses at diagnosis of insulin-dependent diabetes and one year later

Insulin induced proliferation of blood mononuclear cells, numbers of blood B and T cells, of blood lymphocytes bearing interleukin 2 receptors or HLA class II molecules were assayed at diagnosis and one year later in children with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) and in healthy children. Insulin and islet cell antibodies were also studied. The numbers of lymphocytes expressing HLA class II molecules and NK cells were increased at diagnosis. T cells of the helper/inducer (CD4+) phenotype and interleukin 2 receptor positive lymphocytes were increased both at diagnosis and one year later. At diagnosis, insulin induced proliferation of blood mononuclear cells in 65% and one year later in 50% of the patients. Insulin antibodies were detected in 10% and islet cell antibodies in 90% of patients at diagnosis, and in 67% and 78%, respectively, one year later.

The relevance of persistent C-peptide secretion in type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus to glycaemic control and diabetic complications

The effect of residual C-peptide secretion in longer standing IDDM on glycaemic control and the prevalence and evolution of complications over 2 years was evaluated. Thirty-one subjects with IDDM of 15.4 (1.5) years duration (mean SEM)) and residual C-peptide secretion, were matched for age, duration of diabetes and body mass index with 31 subjects without detectable C-peptide secretion. At trial entry and over 2 years, levels of HbA1, fructosamine and mean blood glucose were essentially similar in both groups. Levels of glycated albumin (GSA) were significantly higher in the C-peptide negative group after 3 and 9 months (P less than 0.05). An increased prevalence of proliferative retinopathy in the C-peptide negative group and of peripheral vascular disease in the C-peptide secretor group was apparent at entry to the study (both P less than 0.05), although no significant differences were observed after 1 or 2 years. There was no difference in the prevalence of peripheral or autonomic neuropathy, hypertension, nephropathy or ischaemic heart disease. Subjects with C-peptide concentrations greater than 0.100 pmol/ml at entry to this study had lower daily insulin requirements after 1 and 2 years, but behaved like the larger group with any detectable C-peptide secretion in all other respects. Residual C-peptide secretion was lost after 1 year in 7 patients, in whom glycaemic control during the year had been particularly poor. Insulin antibody titres were no different in the 2 groups at any time point. This study suggests that residual C-peptide secretion in longer standing IDDM confers the potential for limited improvements in glycaemic control. This effect appears to be insufficient to prevent the evolution of microvascular complications over a 2-year period. Residual C-peptide secretion and relative hyperinsulinaemia may be associated with an excess of peripheral vascular disease.

Antibody markers for type 1 diabetes: the issues

The detection of islet-cell-specific autoantibodies before clinical onset may mean that diabetes mellitus can be predicted, with important implications for targeting those to whom preventive treatment might be given. A large number of such markers have been proposed, but only high-titer islet cell antibodies have so far demonstrated the specificity and sensitivity to be of potential clinical value.

Immunological aspects on IDDM in children

Diabetes mellitus in childhood is connected to several immunological phenomena which per se do not prove that immunological mechanisms do cause the beta cell destruction, as such mechanisms could be just secondary. However, there is now evidence which strongly supports the autoimmune hypothesis, like the beta-cell destruction in the transplant given from a healthy twin to the diabetic monozygotic co-twin, the effect in newly-diagnosed diabetes of immunosuppression, the passive transfer in experimental animals of an immune process creating diabetes etc. Several facts such as presence of activated T-cells in the insulitis indicate that the cell-mediated immunity is important, while it is still debatable whether humoral factors, and if so which, alone could be responsible for the beta cell destruction. Recently interleukins and other lymphokines have shown to be of great interest as well as the release of free radicals. This knowledge opens new views on the possibility to put an end to or even prevent the beta cell destruction. Rough immunosuppression with cytostatics or cyclosporin has such severe side-effects that such therapy is contra-indicated at least in children. Until more specific therapies are discovered e.g. vaccination with lymphoblasts or blocking the autoantigens with monoclonal antibodies, supportive measures to protect the beta cells may be one practical way.

Immune responses to insulin in patients with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus

To examine the effect of the major histocompatibility locus (HLA) and the duration of insulin-dependent diabetes (IDDM) on immune responses to insulin we assayed insulin induced proliferation of blood mononuclear cells and measured insulin antibodies in 66 patients with newly diagnosed and in 56 patients with longstanding IDDM matched for the age at onset (less than or equal to 15 years). In up to two thirds of the patients blood mononuclear cells responded to insulins by proliferation, and insulin antibodies were found in two thirds of patients with IDDM of long duration. Insulin proliferation or antibodies were not associated to any particular HLA antigen. The frequency of HLA-DR3 in patients with newly diagnosed IDDM was not increased unlike in patients with IDDM of long duration. In addition, HLA-B8 was associated to HLA-DR3 nearly twice as often in patients with newly diagnosed IDDM as in patients with longstanding IDDM. Thus, patients with IDDM of recent onset and diagnosed within the last three years more frequently responded to insulin by proliferation and less often had HLA-DR3 than patients with IDDM of long duration and diagnosed about 20-25 years earlier.