Antigenic competition between minor (non-H-2) histocompatibility antigens

SCNT-derived ESCs with mismatched mitochondria trigger an immune response in allogeneic hosts

The generation of pluripotent stem cells by somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) has recently been achieved in human cells and sparked new interest in this technology. The authors reporting this methodical breakthrough speculated that SCNT would allow the creation of patient-matched embryonic stem cells, even in patients with hereditary mitochondrial diseases. However, herein we show that mismatched mitochondria in nuclear-transfer-derived embryonic stem cells (NT-ESCs) possess alloantigenicity and are subject to immune rejection. In a murine transplantation setup, we demonstrate that allogeneic mitochondria in NT-ESCs, which are nucleus-identical to the recipient, may trigger an adaptive alloimmune response that impairs the survival of NT-ESC grafts. The immune response is adaptive, directed against mitochondrial content, and amenable for tolerance induction. Mitochondrial alloantigenicity should therefore be considered when developing therapeutic SCNT-based strategies.

Human minor histocompatibility antigens: new concepts for marrow transplantation and adoptive immunotherapy

Bone marrow transplantation (BMT) is the present treatment for hematological malignancies. Two major drawbacks of allogeneic BMT are graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) and leukemia relapse. The use of HLA-matched siblings as marrow donors results in the best transplant outcome. Nonetheless, the results of clinical BMT reveal that the selection of MHC-identical donors' bone marrow (BM) is no guarantee for avoiding GVHD or ensuring disease-free survival even when donor and recipient are closely related. It is believed that non-MHC-encoded so-called minor histocompatibility antigens (mHag) are involved in both graft-versus-host and graft-versus-leukemia activities. The recent new insights into the chemical nature of mHag not only reveal their physiological function but, more importantly, provide insights into their role in BMT. Together with the information on the human mHag genetics and tissue distribution gathered in the past, we may now apply this knowledge to the benefit of human BMT. Directly relevant is the utility of mHag molecular typing for diagnostics in BM donor selection. Most promising is the use of mHag-specific cytotoxic T cells for adoptive immunotherapy of leukemia.

Variable capacity of L3T4+ T cells to cause lethal graft-versus-host disease across minor histocompatibility barriers in mice

Highly purified populations of L3T4+ and Lyt-2+ T cell subsets were compared for their capacity to cause lethal GVHD in six different H-2-compatible, multiple minor histocompatibility antigen-different murine strain combinations. In four of these combinations (C3H.SW----B6, DBA/2----B10.D2, B10.BR----CBA, and B10.S----SJL), lethal GVHD appeared to be caused almost entirely by Lyt-2+ cells; the injection of L3T4+ cells resulted in low mortality even when these cells were presensitized to the recipient antigens. In the remaining two combinations (B10.D2----DBA/2 and B10.D2----BALB/c), L3T4+ T cells were able to cause a high incidence of GVHD and were more potent than the Lyt-2+ cells. The implications of these findings are discussed.

Sex-dependent effects of non-H-2 loci on lethal GVH reaction induced across an H-2 barrier

We have studied the influence of DBA/2 non-H-2 antigens on the lethal graft-versus-host reaction (GVHR) developed across an H-2 barrier. (DBA/2 X B10.D2)F1 X B10.D2 (H-2d) backcross (BC) mice were typed for their allelic constitution at nine genetically independent chromosome markers and used as individual cell donors simultaneously for two to three (DBA/2 X B10.D2)F1 recipients incompatible for DBA/2 non-H-2 antigens alone and two to three (DBA/2 X B10.BR)F1 recipients incompatible for DBA/2 non-H-2 antigens and H-2k. The results showed that, when compared with that developed in a control group incompatible for H-2k alone [B10.D2----(B10.D2 X B10.BR)F1]; the GVHR mortality seen in the presence of an additional incompatibility for DBA/2 non-H-2 antigens [(DBA/2 X B10.BR)F1 recipients] is significantly delayed but only in female mice. An analysis of individual BC donors indicated that this protective effect of DBA/2 non-H-2 antigens correlates with incompatibility for gene(s) linked to the Pgm-1 chromosome marker. In contrast, incompatibility for gene(s) linked to Mod-1 and Es-3 markers accelerates GVHR mortality, but only in male mice. Finally, the results obtained with (DBA/2 X B10.D2)F1 and (DBA/2 X B10.BR)F1 recipients were compared; they showed that the intensity of the GVHR developed by cells from individual BC donors against a given set of DBA/2 non-H-2 antigens correlates well with that developed by the same BC donor against the same set of non-H-2 antigens plus H-2k. We conclude that certain non-H-2 genes (and antigens) can modulate the intensity of the GVHR developed across an H-2 barrier. The number of such genes is probably great; their effects are strong and complex, and can be sex-dependent.

Immunodominance in the T-cell response to multiple non-H-2 histocompatibility antigens. II. Observation of a hierarchy among dominant antigens

Immunization of C57BL/6 mice with BALB.B spleen cells in vivo and subsequent boosting in mixed lymphocyte culture result in the generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTLs) which are specific for a limited number of immunodominant antigens. Experiments are described which suggest the existence of a hierarchy of immunodominance in this donor: host combination. Two antigens, CTT-1.3 and CTT-2.3, are dominant in the C57BL/6 anti-BALB.B CTL response. The distribution of these antigens among CXB recombinant inbred (RI) strains suggests that they segregate as single gene traits. Elimination of the CTT-1.3 and CTT-2.3 antigens by complementation in the responder, or elimination from the priming and boosting stages by the selection of CXB RI strain mice as responders or stimulators, reveals a second level of immunodominant antigens which include CTT-3.3 and CTT-4.3. CXB mice which express one of the CTT-1.3 or CTT-2.3 antigens will produce CTLs specific for the other antigen upon priming and boosting with BALB.B cells. Expression of both antigens in responders results in the generation of CTLs specific for the second level, dominant antigens. Immunodominance is not confined to the C57BL/6 anti-BALB.B system but can also be observed in the BALB.B anti-C57BL/6 and B10.D2 anti-DBA/2 systems. Finally, generation of CTLs following priming and boosting with dominant and dominated antigens presented on different cells confirmed that immunodominance can only be observed when the dominant and dominated antigens are presented on the same cells. These observations suggest that immunodominance is revealed at the level of antigen-presenting cells primarily involved in vivo priming.

Parameters involved in the induction and abrogation of the lethal graft-versus-host reaction directed against non-H-2 antigens

The grafting of cells from donors incompatible for non-H-2 antigens alone can lead to GvHR mortality in up to 100% of lethally irradiated adult recipients. GvHR severity correlates with the number of mature immunocompetent cells present in the bone marrow inoculum. Histologic and clinical manifestations of GvHR observed in these mice differ from those seen when GvHR is induced across an H-2 barrier. The number of non-H-2 genes capable of influencing GvHR mortality is probably great, and their effects may vary as a function of sex. The non-H-2 genes influence GvHR mortality mainly via their interactions, the consequences of which are complex and can result in either cumulative or suppressive effects. GvHR mortality is considerably reduced by donor immunization, shortly before grafting, against host-specific non-H-2 antigens; and it is virtually abrogated by an additional immunization of the donors against nonspecific (foreign) H-2 antigens. Three weeks after grafting, these "protected" mice are easily distinguishable from those undergoing lethal GvHR, as assessed by both clinical appearance and histologic examination; in contrast, they are nearly indistinguishable from control mice grafted with syngeneic cells. However, depending upon the conditions used for the immunization, an additional immunization against nonspecific H-2 antigens can lead to acceleration rather than suppression of GvHR mortality; this phenomenon is not seen, under the same experimental conditions, after immunization against specific non-H-2 antigens alone. It is therefore suggested that a "second signal" provided by an additional nonspecific stimulus can potentiate either the establishment of specific suppression or the activation of a secondary ("positive") response. Suppressive effects of the specific and nonspecific immunizations are cumulative, and both treatments activate suppressor cells. The intensity of suppression induced by both specific and nonspecific immunizations is antigen dose-dependent. At equivalent antigen doses the specific immunization is considerably more effective than the nonspecific immunization, and is detectable after injection of as few as 2.5 X 10(5) cells. In both cases, irradiation of the immunizing cells abolishes the suppression induced by the lower cell doses tested, while it merely decreases the intensity of the suppression induced by the higher cell doses tested. The impairment of suppression after irradiation of the immunizing cells is not attributable to a modification of their homing pattern, but to the fact that proliferation of the immunizing cells, which leads to an augmentation of the antigen dose, is abolished by irradiation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Strong histocompatibility and cell-mediated cytotoxic effects of a single Mls difference demonstrated using a new congenic mouse strain

In vivo and in vitro effects of incompatibility at the Mls locus have been studied utilizing a recently created congenic mouse strain. Results obtained with skin grafts were compared to those obtained in the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) and cell-mediated cytotoxicity assays. The in vitro responsiveness of cells from skin-grafted mice was compared to that of cells from corresponding ungrafted mice. The results showed that: (a) Mlsa, strongly stimulatory in primary MLR, has a weak effect on skin graft rejection; specific in vivo preimmunization against Mlsa increases and accelerates the rejection of skin grafts, but abrogates the responsiveness in MLR; and (b) incompatibility for Mlsb, nonstimulatory in primary MLR, induces relatively rapid rejection of 100% of skin grafts; this rejection is dramatically accelerated by specific in vivo preimmunization and is followed by activation of helper and cytotoxic cells. Results obtained in the cell-mediated cytotoxicity assay suggest that the recognition of Mlsb determinants is H-2-restricted. Finally, the rejection of skin grafts incompatible for numerous non-H-2 loci is delayed by an additional incompatibility for Mlsb, suggesting that Mlsb decreases the response to other non-H-2 antigens, thus acting as a suppressor and/or competitor antigen. We conclude that, in contrast with previous findings, Mls incompatibility may have a strong effect on skin graft rejection, depending on the allelic combination involved, and, after in vivo immunization, Mlsb activates cell-mediated proliferative and cytotoxic responses and definitely is not "silent". The importance of the histocompatibility effects of Mls determinants and the variety of its biological functions are much in favor of the existence of a polymorphic and complex system capable of activating different cell subsets.

Immunodominance in the immune response to "multiple" histocompatibility antigens

Cytotoxic effector T cells putatively specific for multiple non-H-2 histocompatibility (H) antigens were generated by immunizing and boosting C57BL/6 and B6.C-H-2d mice with BALB.B and BALB/c stimulator cells, respectively. The generated effectors were tested for cell-mediated lympholysis on a panel of targets whose BALB/c-derived non-H-2 H antigens were donated by CXB recombinant inbred mice. The spectrum of reactivity of cytotoxic effector T cells with CXB targets demonstrated that the effectors did not recognize multiple H antigens but rather preferentially recognized a single immunodominant non-H 2 antigen. The identity of the immunodominant H antigen was determined by the H-2 genotype of the stimulator cells when (B6 x B6.C-H-2d)F1 cytotoxic effectors were tested. These observations indicate that despite the fact that responders were challenged with more than 40 individual non-H-2 H antigens, they preferentially responded to single immunodominant antigen.