The nosologic place of the XO-XY mosaicism

Sex chromosome DSD individuals with mosaic 45,X0 and aberrant Y chromosomes in 46,XY cells: distinct gender phenotypes and germ cell tumour risks§

"Differences of Sexual Development (DSD)," individuals with rearranged Y chromosome breaks in their 46,XY cells are reported with male and female gender phenotypes and differences in germ cell tumour (GCT) risk. This raised the question of whether male or female gender and GCT risk depends on the site of the break and/or rearrangement of the individual´s Y chromosome. In this paper, we report molecular mapping of the breakpoint on the aberrant Y chromosome of 22 DSD individuals with a 45,X/46,XY karyotype reared with a different gender. Their Y chromosome breaks are found at different sites on the long and short Y arms. Our data indicate that gender rearing is, neither dependent on the site of Y breakage, nor on the amount of 45,X0 cells in the individuals' leukocytes. Most prominent are secondary rearrangements of the Y chromosome breaks forming di-centric Y-structures ("dic-Y"). Duplications of the short Y arm and the proximal part of the long Y arm are the results. A putative GCT risk has been analysed with immunohistochemical experiments on some dysgenetic gonadal tissue sections. With specific antibodies for OCT3/4 expression, we marked the pluripotent germ cell fraction being potential tumour precursor cells. With specific antibodies for DDX3Y, TSPY, and UTY we analyzed their putative Gonadoblastoma Y (GBY) tumour susceptibility function in the same specimen. We conclude GBY expression is only diagnostic for GCT development in the aberrant germ cells of these DSD individuals when strong OCT3/4 expression has marked their pluripotency.

Abnormal sexual differentiation and neoplasia

The prevalence of neoplasia is increased in individuals with certain disorders of sexual differentiation. Etiology and frequency of neoplasia vary with the particular disorder. In uncomplicated cryptorchidism, the testis is at least 10 times more likely to undergo neoplastic transformation than a normal scrotal testis. Neoplasia probably is a function of both testicular location (intraabdominal) and underlying dysgenetic structure. If cryptorchidism is unilateral, and if orchiopexy has not been performed prior to age 6-10 years, orchiectomy should be encouraged. In those forms of gonadal dysgenesis not associated with a Y chromosome (e.g., 45,X; 45,X/46,XX; 46,XX) there is no definite increase in neoplasia, suggesting that elevated gonadotropin levels per se are not carcinogenic. Gonadal tumors are found in at least 30% of individuals with XY gonadal dysgenesis and are particularly frequent (55%) in H-Y antigen-positive patients. These tumors are almost always gonadoblastomas or dysgerminomas. Similar tumors are found in 15%-20% of 45,X/46,XY individuals. In either situation the neoplastic transformation could be a) secondary to the existence of XY gonadal tissue in an inhospitable environment, or b) integrally related to that process--genetic or cytogenetic--producing the dysgenetic gonads. The risk of neoplasia is sufficiently high that most of these patients should be offered early gonadal extirpation. The prevalence of gonadal tumors is not increased in Klinefelter's syndrome, further indicating that gonadotropins are not carcinogenic per se. However, Klinefelter patients are 20 times more likely to develop a carcinoma of the breast than are 46,XY males. Extragonadal germ cell tumors also are more common. In female pseudohermaphrodites there is probably no increased risk of neoplasia, whereas, in true hermaphrodites neoplasia is unusual but does occur. Neoplasia occurs in patients with complete testicular feminization (complete androgen insensitivity) but rarely in those with incomplete testicular feminization/Reifenstein's syndrome, 5 alpha-reductase deficiency, anorchia, agonadia, or testosterone biosynthetic defects. In complete testicular feminization the risk of malignant tumors is small prior to age 25. After age 25, it is about 2%-5%. Orchiectomy is recommended after pubertal feminization.