Does the paraxial mesoderm of the avian embryo have hemangioblastic capacity?

How the avian model has pioneered the field of hematopoietic development

The chicken embryo has a long history as a key model in developmental biology. Because of its distinctive developmental characteristics, it has contributed to major breakthroughs in the field of hematopoiesis. Among these, the discovery of B lymphocytes and the three rounds of thymus colonization; the embryonic origin of hematopoietic stem cells and the traffic between different hematopoietic organs; and the existence of two distinct endothelial cell lineages one angioblastic, restricted to endothelial cell production, and another, hemangioblastic, able to produce both endothelial and hematopoietic cells, should be cited. The avian model has also contributed to substantiate the endothelial-to-hematopoietic transition associated with aortic hematopoiesis and the existence of the allantois as a hematopoietic organ. Because the immune system develops relatively late in aves, the avian embryo is used to probe the tissue-forming potential of mouse tissues through mouse-into-chicken chimeras, providing insights into early mouse development by circumventing the lethality associated with some genetic strains. Finally, the avian embryo can be used to investigate the differentiation potential of human ES cells in the context of a whole organism. The combinations of classic approaches with the development of powerful genetic tools make the avian embryo a great and versatile model.

Hemogenic endothelium: origins, regulation, and implications for vascular biology

The study of endothelial development has been intertwined with hematopoiesis since the early 20th century when a bi-potential cell (hemangioblast) was noted to produce both endothelial and hematopoietic cells. Since then, ideas regarding the nature of connection between the vascular and hematopoietic systems have ranged from a tenuous association to direct lineage origination. In this review, historical data that spans hematopoietic development is examined within the context of hemogenic endothelium. Hemogenic endothelium, a specialized endothelial population capable of hematopoiesis, is an emerging theory that has recently gained momentum. Evidence across species and decades are reviewed, as are the possible modulators of the phenomenon, which include pathways that specify definitive hematopoiesis (Runx1), arterial identity (Notch1), as well as physiological and developmental factors.

Endothelial progenitor cells: their potential in the placental vasculature and related complications

Endothelial progenitor cells (EPCs) have received significant attention in recent times. A role for EPCs has been suggested in a range of pathologies and some recent studies of EPCs in pregnancy have been published. This review provides a guide to the confusing field of EPCs. Attention is paid to their phenotyping, as although elementary this remains a highly debated topic. The current understanding of different subtypes and physiological role of EPCs in the placenta, fetus and adult are also considered. An overview is given as to role of EPC's in the pathophysiology of different disease states and the possible therapeutic and diagnostic applications expected from EPC-related research in obstetrics.

Somite-derived cells replace ventral aortic hemangioblasts and provide aortic smooth muscle cells of the trunk

We have previously shown that endothelial cells of the aortic floor give rise to hematopoietic cells, revealing the existence of an aortic hemangioblast. It has been proposed that the restriction of hematopoiesis to the aortic floor is based on the existence of two different and complementary endothelial lineages that form the vessel: one originating from the somite would contribute to the roof and sides, another from the splanchnopleura would contribute to the floor. Using quail/chick orthotopic transplantations of paraxial mesoderm, we have traced the distribution of somite-derived endothelial cells during aortic hematopoiesis. We show that the aortic endothelium undergoes two successive waves of remodeling by somitic cells: one when the aortae are still paired, during which the initial roof and sides of the vessels are renewed; and a second, associated to aortic hematopoiesis, in which the hemogenic floor is replaced by somite endothelial cells. This floor thus appears as a temporary structure, spent out and replaced. In addition,the somite contributes to smooth muscle cells of the aorta. In vivo lineage tracing experiments with non-replicative retroviral vectors showed that endothelial cells do not give rise to smooth muscle cells. However, in vitro,purified endothelial cells acquire smooth muscle cells characteristics. Taken together, these data point to the crucial role of the somite in shaping the aorta and also give an explanation for the short life of aortic hematopoiesis.

Blood Vessel Patterning at the Embryonic Midline

The reproducible pattern of blood vessels formed in vertebrate embryos has been described extensively, but only recently have we obtained the genetic and molecular tools to address the mechanisms underlying these processes. This review describes our current knowledge regarding vascular patterning around the vertebrate midline and presents data derived from frogs, zebrafish, avians, and mice. The embryonic structures implicated in midline vascular patterning, the hypochord, endoderm, notochord, and neural tube, are discussed. Moreover, several molecular signaling pathways implicated in vascular patterning, VEGF, Tie/tek, Notch, Eph/ephrin, and Semaphorin, are described. Data showing that VEGF is critical to patterning the dorsal aorta in frogs and zebrafish, and to patterning the vascular plexus that forms around the neural tube in amniotes, is presented. A more complete knowledge of vascular patterning is likely to come from the next generation of experiments using ever more sophisticated tools, and these results promise to directly impact on clinically important issues such as forming new vessels in the human body and/or in bioreactors.

Microvascular assembly and cell invasion in chick mesonephros grafted onto chorioallantoic membrane

Embryonic tissues, in common with other tissues, including tumours, tend to develop a substantial vasculature when transplanted onto the chorioallantoic membrane (CAM). Studies conducted to date have not examined in any detail the identity of vessels that supply these grafts, although it is known that the survival of transplanted tissues depends on their ability to connect with CAM vessels supplying oxygen and nutrients. We grafted the mesonephros, a challenging model for studies in vascular development, when it was fully developed (HH35). We used reciprocal chick-quail transplantations in order to study the arterial and venous connections and to analyse the cell invasion from the CAM to the organ, whose degeneration in normal conditions is rapid. The revascularization of the grafted mesonephros was produced by the formation of peripheral anastomoses between the graft and previous host vasculatures. The assembly of graft and CAM blood vessels occurred between relatively large arteries or veins, resulting in chimeric vessels of varying morphology depending on their arterial or venous status. Grafts showed an increased angiogenesis from their original vasculature, suggesting that the normal vascular degeneration of the mesonephros was partially inhibited. Three types of isolated host haemangioblast were identified in the mesonephros: migrating angioblast-like cells, indicating vasculogenesis, undifferentiated haematopoietic cells and macrophages, which might have been involved in the angiogenesis. Tomato lectin was found to bind activated macrophages in avian embryos.

Hematopoietic stem cells and their precursors: developmental diversity and lineage relationships

Within the context of the developing embryo, restrictions in cell lineage potential occur through cell-cell interactions and signaling molecules, leading to changes in genetic programs and to the emergence of disparate tissues containing functionally distinct cell types including somatic stem cells. Tissue maintenance in the adult is thought to occur through specific stem cells, and in the case of the hematopoietic system, through hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs). These cells arise in midgestation within the region of the embryo containing the dorsal aorta, gonads, and mesonephros (AGM) and are thought to maintain a distinct hematopoietic lineage-restricted fate. However, recent transplantation experiments suggest that within the adult, HSCs previously thought to be restricted can, under certain circumstances, display unexpected lineage potentials. With these surprising and controversial results, it is becoming apparent that a better understanding of the developmental processes, molecular programs and lineage relationships leading to the emergence of adult stem cells will provide insight into the incremental steps involved in lineage determination, and perhaps possibilities for the manipulated differentiation of stem cells. The most widely studied, accessible stem cell and cellular differentiation hierarchy is that of the hematopoietic system. With the issue of stem cell potential in the forefront, the focus of this review is on the development of the hematopoietic system: how HSCs arise in the embryo, the lineage relationships of hematopoietic cells as they are generated, and the identification of precursor cells fated to the hematopoietic lineage throughout ontogeny.

EphA4/ephrin-A5 interactions in muscle precursor cell migration in the avian forelimb

Limb muscles derive from muscle precursor cells that lie initially in the lateral portion of the somitic dermomyotome and subsequently migrate to their target limb regions, where muscle-specific gene transcription is initiated. Although several molecules that control the generation and delamination of muscle precursor cells have been identified, little is known about the mechanisms that guide muscle precursor cell migration in the limb. We have examined the distribution of members of the Eph family during muscle precursor cell development. The EphA4 receptor tyrosine kinase and its ligand, ephrin-A5, are expressed by muscle precursor cells and forelimb mesoderm in unique spatiotemporal patterns during the period when muscle precursors delaminate from the dermomyotome and migrate into the limb. To test the function of EphA4/ephrin-A5 interactions in muscle precursor migration, we used targeted in ovo electroporation to express ephrin-A5 ectopically specifically in the presumptive limb mesoderm. In the presence of ectopic ephrin-A5, Pax7-positive muscle precursor cells are significantly reduced in number in the proximal limb, compared with controls, and congregate abnormally near the lateral dermomyotome. In stripe assays, isolated muscle precursor cells avoid substrate-bound ephrin-A5 and this avoidance is abolished by addition of soluble ephrin-A5. These data suggest that ephrin-A5 normally restricts migrating, EphA4-positive muscle precursor cells to their appropriate territories in the forelimb, disallowing entry into abnormal embryonic regions.

Ontogeny of the endothelial system in the avian model

The avian model provides an experimental approach for dissecting the origin, migrations and differentiation of cell lineages in early embryos. In this model, the endothelial network was shown to take place through two processes depending on the origin of endothelial precursors: vasculogenesis when angioblasts emerge in situ, angiogenesis when angioblasts are extrinsic. Two different mesodermal territories produce angioblasts, the somite which only gives rise to endothelial cells and the splanchnopleural mesoderm which also produces hemopoietic stem cells. Potentialities of the mesoderm are determined by a positive influence from the endoderm and a negative control from the ectoderm. The presence of circulating endothelial precursors in the embryonic blood stream is also detected.

The role of FGF and VEGF in angioblast induction and migration during vascular development

The embryonic vasculature forms by the processes of vasculogenesis and angiogenesis. Angioblasts (endothelial cell precursors) appear to be induced by fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF-2). The angioblasts contributing to the dorsal aortae arise by an epithelial to mesenchymal transformation of cells originating from the splanchnic mesoderm. QH-l and vascular endothelial growth factor receptor 2 (VEGFR-2) both appear to label these cells as they adopt a mesenchymal morphology. Since VEGFR-2 is the earliest known VEGF receptor this suggests that VEGF is not involved in angioblast induction. VEGF does appear to be critical, however, for growth and morphogenesis of angioblasts into the initial vascular pattern. Controlled delivery of FGF-2 from beads and aggregates of cells transfected with quail VEGF have been used in our laboratory to study the role of these growth factors in angioblast induction and migration. We have induced cells from the epithelial quail somite to differentiate into angioblasts with FGF-2 both in the embryo and in culture. This is a useful model system to study the origins of endothelial cells that are normally more diffusely induced during gastrulation by an obscure process probably involving signals from the embryonic endoderm. The origins of arterial versus venous endothelial cells is also poorly understood but recent findings on the distribution of ephrins and Eph receptors suggest that molecular differences exist prior to the onset of circulation. Finally, studies on the role of growth factors in such diverse phenomena as stem cell biology, angiogenesis, and molecular medicine in addition to vascular development suggest multiple roles for FGF-2 and VEGF in vascular development.

Fate restriction in limb muscle precursor cells precedes high-level expression of MyoD family member genes

The mechanisms by which pluripotent embryonic cells generate unipotent tissue progenitor cells during development are unknown. Molecular/genetic experiments in cultured cells have led to the hypothesis that the product of a single member of the MyoD gene family (MDF) is necessary and sufficient to establish the positive aspects of the determined state of myogenic precursor cells: i.e., the ability to initiate and maintain the differentiated state (Weintraub, H., Davis, R., Tapscott, S., Thayer, M., Krause, M., Benezra, R., Blackwell, T. K., Turner, D., Rupp, R., Hollenberg, S. et al. (1991) Science 251, 761–766). Embryonic cell type determination also involves negative regulation, such as the restriction of developmental potential for alternative cell types, that is not directly addressed by the MDF model. In the experiments reported here, phenotypic restriction in myogenic precursor cells is assayed by an in vivo ‘notochord challenge’ to evaluate their potential to ‘choose’ between two alternative cell fate endpoints: cartilage and muscle (Williams, B. A. and Ordahl, C. P. (1997) Development 124, 4983–4997). Two separate myogenic precursor cell populations were found to be phenotypically restricted while expressing the Pax3 gene and prior to MDF gene activation. Therefore, while MDF family members act positively during myogenic differentiation, phenotypic restriction, the negative aspect of cell specification, requires cellular and molecular events and interactions that precede MDF expression in myogenic precursor cells. The qualities of muscle formed by the determined myogenic precursor cells in these experiments further indicate that their developmental potential is intermediate between that of myoblastic stem cells taken from fetal or adult tissue (which lack mitotic and morphogenetic potential when tested in vivo) and embryonic stem cells (which are multipotent). We hypothesize that such embryonic myogenic progenitor cells represent a distinct class of determined embryonic cell, one that is responsible for both tissue growth and tissue morphogenesis.

Insights into early vasculogenesis revealed by expression of the ETS-domain transcription factor Fli-1 in wild-type and mutant zebrafish embryos

Fli-1 is an ETS-domain transcription factor whose locus is disrupted in Ewing's Sarcoma and F-MuLV induced erythroleukaemia. To gain a better understanding of its normal function, we have isolated the zebrafish homologue. Similarities with other vertebrates, in the amino acid sequence and DNA binding properties of Fli-1 from zebrafish, suggest that its function has been conserved during vertebrate evolution. The initial expression of zebrafish fli-1 in the posterior lateral mesoderm overlaps with that of gata2 in a potential haemangioblast population which likely contains precursors of blood and endothelium. Subsequently, fli-1 and gata2 expression patterns diverge, with separate fli-1 and gata2 expression domains arising in the developing vasculature and in sites of blood formation respectively. Elsewhere in the embryo, fli-1 is expressed in sites of vasculogenesis. The expression of fli-1 was investigated in a number of zebrafish mutants, which affect the circulatory system. In cloche, endothelium is absent and blood is drastically reduced. In contrast to the blood and endothelial markers that have been studied previously, fli-1 expression was initiated normally in cloche embryos, indicating that induction of fli-1 is one of the earliest indicators of haemangioblast formation. Furthermore, although fli-1 expression in the trunk was not maintained, the normal expression pattern in the anterior half of the embryo was retained. These anterior cells did not, however, condense to form blood vessels. These data indicate that cloche has previously unsuspected roles at multiple stages in the formation of the vasculature. Analysis of fli-1 expression in midline patterning mutants floating head and squint, confirms a requirement for the notochord in the formation of the dorsal-aorta. The formation of endothelium in one-eyed pinhead, cyclops and squint embryos indicates a novel role for the endoderm in the formation of the axial vein. The phenotype of sonic-you mutants implies a likely role for Sonic Hedgehog in mediating these processes.

Elucidating the origins of the vascular system: a fate map of the vascular endothelial and red blood cell lineages in Xenopus laevis

Required to supply nutrients and oxygen to the growing embryo, the vascular system is the first functional organ system to develop during vertebrate embryogenesis. Although there has been substantial progress in identifying the genetic cascade regulating vascular development, the initial stages of vasculogenesis, namely, the origin of vascular endothelial cells within the early embryo, remain unclear. To address this issue we constructed a fate map for specific vascular structures, including the aortic arches, endocardium, dorsal aorta, cardinal veins, and lateral abdominal veins, as well as for the red blood cells at the 16-cell stage and the 32-cell stage of Xenopus laevis. Using genetic markers to identify these cell types, our results suggest that vascular endothelial cells can arise from virtually every blastomere of the 16-cell-stage and the 32-cell-stage embryo, with different blastomeres preferentially, though not exclusively, giving rise to specific vascular structures. Similarly, but more surprisingly, every blastomere in the 16-cell-stage embryo and all but those in the most animal tier of the 32-cell-stage embryo serve as progenitors for red blood cells. Taken together, our results suggest that during normal development, both dorsal and ventral blastomeres contribute significantly to the vascular endothelial and red blood cell lineages.

Manipulation of the angiopoietic/hemangiopoietic commitment in the avian embryo

The hypothesis that the endothelial and hemopoietic lineages have a common ontogenic origin is currently being revived. We have shown previously by means of quail/chick transplantations that two subsets of the mesoderm give rise to endothelial precursors: a dorsal one, the somite, produces pure angioblasts (angiopoietic potential), while a ventral one, the splanchnopleural mesoderm, gives rise to progenitors with a dual endothelial and hemopoietic potential (hemangiopoietic potential). To investigate the cellular and molecular controls of the angiopoietic/hemangiopoietic potential, we devised an in vivo assay based on the polarized homing of hemopoietic cell precursors to the floor of the aorta detectable in the quail/chick model. In the present work, quail mesoderm was grafted, after various pretreatments, onto the splanchnopleure of a chick host; the homing pattern and nature of graft-derived QH1(+) cells were analyzed thereafter. We report that transient contact with endoderm or ectoderm could change the behavior of cells derived from treated mesoderm, and that the effect of these germ layers could be mimicked by treatment with several growth factors VEGF, bFGF, TGFbeta1, EGF and TGF(α), known to be involved in endothelial commitment and proliferation, and/or hemopoietic processes. The endoderm induced a hemangiopoietic potential in the associated mesoderm. Indeed, the association of somatopleural mesoderm with endoderm promoted the ‘ventral homing’ and the production of hemopoietic cells from mesoderm not normally endowed with this potential. The hemangiopoietic induction by endoderm could be mimicked by VEGF, bFGF and TGFbeta1. In contrast, contact with ectoderm or EGF/TGF(α) treatments totally abrogated the hemangiopoietic capacity of the splanchnopleural mesoderm, which produced pure angioblasts with no ‘ventral homing’ behaviour. We postulate that two gradients, one positive and one negative, modulate the angiopoietic/hemangiopoietic potential of the mesoderm.

Avian models in developmental biology

The avian embryo is uniquely amenable to experimental manipulation. The most widely used models are chimeras resulting from heterotopic or orthotopic exchanges of rudiments between chick and quail embryos, according to Le Douarin's technique (1969). Cell migrations and fates are traced in these chimeras either through the identification of quail cell nuclei stained for DNA or by means of monoclonal antibodies that recognize a particular lineage in only one of the two species. The ontogeny of the hemopoietic and endothelial lineages, as enlightened through appropriately designed chimeras, is reviewed in the present article. Homologies recently disclosed in mouse and human embryo are emphasized. Finally, the possibilities afforded by retroviral somatic transgenesis in the avian embryo will be envisaged.

Two distinct endothelial lineages in ontogeny, one of them related to hemopoiesis

We have shown previously by means of quail/chick transplantations that external and visceral organs, i.e., somatopleural and splanchnopleural derivatives, acquire their endothelial network through different mechanisms, namely immigration (termed angiogenesis) versus in situ emergence of precursors (or vasculogenesis). We have traced the distribution of QH1-positive cells in chick hosts after replacement of the last somites by quail somites (orthotopic grafts) or lateral plate mesoderm (heterotopic grafts). The results lead to the conclusion that the embryo becomes vascularized by endothelial precursors from two distinct regions, splanchnopleural mesoderm and paraxial mesoderm. The territories respectively vascularized are complementary, precursors from the paraxial mesoderm occupy the body wall and kidney, i.e., they settle along with the other paraxial mesoderm derivatives and colonize the somatopleure. The precursors from the two origins have distinct recognition and potentialities properties: endothelial precursors of paraxial origin are barred from vascularizing visceral organs and from integrating into the floor of the aorta, and are never associated with hemopoiesis; splanchnopleural mesoderm grafted in the place of somites, gives off endothelial cells to body wall and kidney but also visceral organs. It gives rise to hemopoietic precursors in addition to endothelial cells.