Allogeneic nerve grafts in the rat, with special reference to the role of Schwann cell basal laminae in nerve regeneration

Beyond the limiting gap length: peripheral nerve regeneration through implantable nerve guidance conduits

Peripheral nerve damage results in the loss of sensorimotor and autonomic functions, which is a significant burden to patients. Furthermore, nerve injuries greater than the limiting gap length require surgical repair. Although autografts are the preferred clinical choice, their usage is impeded by their limited availability, dimensional mismatch, and the sacrifice of another functional donor nerve. Accordingly, nerve guidance conduits, which are tubular scaffolds engineered to provide a biomimetic environment for nerve regeneration, have emerged as alternatives to autografts. Consequently, a few nerve guidance conduits have received clinical approval for the repair of short-mid nerve gaps but failed to regenerate limiting gap damage, which represents the bottleneck of this technology. Thus, it is still necessary to optimize the morphology and constituent materials of conduits. This review summarizes the recent advances in nerve conduit technology. Several manufacturing techniques and conduit designs are discussed, with emphasis on the structural improvement of simple hollow tubes, additive manufacturing techniques, and decellularized grafts. The main objective of this review is to provide a critical overview of nerve guidance conduit technology to support regeneration in long nerve defects, promote future developments, and speed up its clinical translation as a reliable alternative to autografts.

Physical processing for decellularized nerve xenograft in peripheral nerve regeneration

In severe or complex cases of peripheral nerve injuries, autologous nerve grafts are the gold standard yielding promising results, but limited availability and donor site morbidity are some of its disadvantages. Although biological or synthetic substitutes are commonly used, clinical outcomes are inconsistent. Biomimetic alternatives derived from allogenic or xenogenic sources offer an attractive off-the-shelf supply, and the key to successful peripheral nerve regeneration focuses on an effective decellularization process. In addition to chemical and enzymatic decellularization protocols, physical processes might offer identical efficiency. In this comprehensive minireview, we summarize recent advances in the physical methods for decellularized nerve xenograft, focusing on the effects of cellular debris clearance and stability of the native architecture of a xenograft. Furthermore, we compare and summarize the advantages and disadvantages, indicating the future challenges and opportunities in developing multidisciplinary processes for decellularized nerve xenograft.

A Combined Conduit-Bioactive Hydrogel Approach for Regeneration of Transected Sciatic Nerves

Transected peripheral nerve injury (PNI) affects the quality of life of patients, which leads to socioeconomic burden. Despite the existence of autografts and commercially available nerve guidance conduits (NGCs), the complexity of peripheral nerve regeneration requires further research in bioengineered NGCs to improve surgical outcomes. In this work, we introduce multidomain peptide (MDP) hydrogels, as intraluminal fillers, into electrospun poly(ε-caprolactone) (PCL) conduits to bridge 10 mm rat sciatic nerve defects. The efficacy of treatment groups was evaluated by electromyography and gait analysis to determine their electrical and motor recovery. We then studied the samples' histomorphometry with immunofluorescence staining and automatic axon counting/measurement software. Comparison with negative control group shows that PCL conduits filled with an anionic MDP may improve functional recovery 16 weeks postoperation, displaying higher amplitude of compound muscle action potential, greater gastrocnemius muscle weight retention, and earlier occurrence of flexion contracture. In contrast, PCL conduits filled with a cationic MDP showed the least degree of myelination and poor functional recovery. This phenomenon may be attributed to MDPs' difference in degradation time. Electrospun PCL conduits filled with an anionic MDP may become an attractive tissue engineering strategy for treating transected PNI when supplemented with other bioactive modifications.

Decellularized peripheral nerve grafts by a modified protocol for repair of rat sciatic nerve injury

Studies have shown that acellular nerve xenografts do not require immunosuppression and use of acellular nerve xenografts for repair of peripheral nerve injury is safe and effective. However, there is currently no widely accepted standard chemical decellularization method. The purpose of this study is to investigate the efficiency of bovine-derived nerves decellularized by the modified Hudson’s protocol in the repair of rat sciatic nerve injury. In the modified Hudson’s protocol, Triton X-200 was replaced by Triton X-100, and DNase and RNase were used to prepare accelular nerve xenografts. The efficiency of bovine-derived nerves decellularized by the modified Hudson’s protocol was tested in vitro by hematoxylin & eosin, Alcian blue, Masson’s trichrome, and Luxol fast blue staining, immunohistochemistry, and biochemical assays. The decellularization approach excluded cells, myelin, and axons of nerve xenografts, without affecting the organization of nerve xenografts. The decellularized nerve xenograft was used to bridge a 7 mm-long sciatic nerve defect to evaluate its efficiency in the repair of peripheral nerve injury. At 8 weeks after transplantation, sciatic function index in rats subjected to transplantation of acellular nerve xenograft was similar to that in rats undergoing transplantation of nerve allograft. Morphological analysis revealed that there were a large amount of regenerated myelinated axons in acellular nerve xenograft; the number of Schwann cells in the acellular nerve xenograft was similar to that in the nerve allograft. These findings suggest that acellular nerve xenografts prepared by the modified Hudson’s protocol can be used for repair of peripheral nerve injury. This study was approved by the Research Ethics Committee, Research and Technology Chancellor of Guilan University of Medical Sciences, Iran (approval No. IR.GUMS.REC.1395.332) on February 11, 2017.

Evaluation methods as quality control in the generation of decellularized peripheral nerve allografts

Nowadays, the high incidence of peripheral nerve injuries and the low success ratio of surgical treatments are driving research to the generation of novel alternatives to repair critical nerve defects. In this sense, tissue engineering has emerged as a possible alternative with special attention to decellularization techniques. Tissue decellularization offers the possibility to obtain a cell-free, natural extracellular matrix (ECM), characterized by an adequate 3D organization and proper molecular composition to repair different tissues or organs, including peripheral nerves. One major problem, however, is that there are no standard quality control methods to evaluate decellularized tissues. Therefore, in this review, a brief description of current strategies for peripheral nerve repair is given, followed by an overview of different decellularization methods used for peripheral nerves. Furthermore, we extensively discuss the available and currently used methods to demonstrate the success of tissue decellularization in terms of the cell removal, preservation of essential ECM molecules and maintenance or modification of biomechanical properties. Finally, orientative guidelines for the evaluation of decellularized peripheral nerve allografts are proposed.

Therapeutic strategies for peripheral nerve injury: decellularized nerve conduits and Schwann cell transplantation

In recent years, the use of Schwann cell transplantation to repair peripheral nerve injury has attracted much attention. Animal-based studies show that the transplantation of Schwann cells in combination with nerve scaffolds promotes the repair of injured peripheral nerves. Autologous Schwann cell transplantation in humans has been reported recently. This article reviews current methods for removing the extracellular matrix and analyzes its composition and function. The development and secretory products of Schwann cells are also reviewed. The methods for the repair of peripheral nerve injuries that use myelin and Schwann cell transplantation are assessed. This survey of the literature data shows that using a decellularized nerve conduit combined with Schwann cells represents an effective strategy for the treatment of peripheral nerve injury. This analysis provides a comprehensive basis on which to make clinical decisions for the repair of peripheral nerve injury.

Decellularisation and histological characterisation of porcine peripheral nerves

Peripheral nerve injuries affect a large proportion of the global population, often causing significant morbidity and loss of function. Current treatment strategies include the use of implantable nerve guide conduits (NGC's) to direct regenerating axons between the proximal and distal ends of the nerve gap. However, NGC's are limited in their effectiveness at promoting regeneration Current NGCs are not suitable as substrates for supporting either neuronal or Schwann cell growth, as they lack an architecture similar to that of the native extracellular matrix (ECM) of the nerve. The aim of this study was to create an acellular porcine peripheral nerve using a novel decellularisation protocol, in order to eliminate the immunogenic cellular components of the tissue, while preserving the three‐dimensional histoarchitecture and ECM components. Porcine peripheral nerve (sciatic branches were decellularised using a low concentration (0.1%; w/v) sodium dodecyl sulphate in conjunction with hypotonic buffers and protease inhibitors, and then sterilised using 0.1% (v/v) peracetic acid. Quantitative and qualitative analysis revealed a ≥95% (w/w) reduction in DNA content as well as preservation of the nerve fascicles and connective tissue. Acellular nerves were shown to have retained key ECM components such as collagen, laminin and fibronectin. Slow strain rate to failure testing demonstrated the biomechanical properties of acellular nerves to be comparable to fresh controls. In conclusion, we report the production of a biocompatible, biomechanically functional acellular scaffold, which may have use in peripheral nerve repair. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2016;113: 2041–2053. © 2016 The Authors. Biotechnology and Bioengineering published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

An anatomical study of porcine peripheral nerve and its potential use in nerve tissue engineering

Current nerve tissue engineering applications are adopting xenogeneic nerve tissue as potential nerve grafts to help aid nerve regeneration. However, there is little literature that describes the exact location, anatomy and physiology of these nerves to highlight their potential as a donor graft. The aim of this study was to identify and characterise the structural and extracellular matrix (ECM) components of porcine peripheral nerves in the hind leg. Methods included the dissection of porcine nerves, localisation, characterisation and quantification of the ECM components and identification of nerve cells. Results showed a noticeable variance between porcine and rat nerve (a commonly studied species) in terms of fascicle number. The study also revealed that when porcine peripheral nerves branch, a decrease in fascicle number and size was evident. Porcine ECM and nerve fascicles were found to be predominately comprised of collagen together with glycosaminoglycans, laminin and fibronectin. Immunolabelling for nerve growth factor receptor p75 also revealed the localisation of Schwann cells around and inside the fascicles. In conclusion, it is shown that porcine peripheral nerves possess a microstructure similar to that found in rat, and is not dissimilar to human. This finding could extend to the suggestion that due to the similarities in anatomy to human nerve, porcine nerves may have utility as a nerve graft providing guidance and support to regenerating axons.

Chemically extracted acellular allogeneic nerve graft combined with ciliary neurotrophic factor promotes sciatic nerve repair

A chemically extracted acellular allogeneic nerve graft can reduce postoperative immune rejection, similar to an autologous nerve graft, and can guide neural regeneration. However, it remains poorly understood whether a chemically extracted acellular allogeneic nerve graft combined with neurotrophic factors provides a good local environment for neural regeneration. This study investigated the repair of injured rat sciatic nerve using a chemically extracted acellular allogeneic nerve graft combined with ciliary neurotrophic factor. An autologous nerve anastomosis group and a chemical acellular allogeneic nerve bridging group were prepared as controls. At 8 weeks after repair, sciatic functional index, evoked potential amplitude of the soleus muscle, triceps wet weight recovery rate, total number of myelinated nerve fibers and myelin sheath thickness were measured. For these indices, values in the three groups showed the autologous nerve anastomosis group > chemically extracted acellular nerve graft + ciliary neurotrophic factor group > chemical acellular allogeneic nerve bridging group. These results suggest that chemically extracted acellular nerve grafts combined with ciliary neurotrophic factor can repair sciatic nerve defects, and that this repair is inferior to autologous nerve anastomosis, but superior to chemically extracted acellular allogeneic nerve bridging alone.

Tissue engineered constructs for peripheral nerve surgery

BACKGROUND

Tissue engineering has been defined as "an interdisciplinary field that applies the principles of engineering and life sciences toward the development of biological substitutes that restore, maintain, or improve tissue function or a whole organ". Traumatic peripheral nerve injury resulting in significant tissue loss at the zone of injury necessitates the need for a bridge or scaffold for regenerating axons from the proximal stump to reach the distal stump.

METHODS

A review of the literature was used to provide information on the components necessary for the development of a tissue engineered peripheral nerve substitute. Then, a comprehensive review of the literature is presented composed of the studies devoted to this goal.

RESULTS

Extensive research has been directed toward the development of a tissue engineered peripheral nerve substitute to act as a bridge for regenerating axons from the proximal nerve stump seeking the distal nerve. Ideally this nerve substitute would consist of a scaffold component that mimics the extracellular matrix of the peripheral nerve and a cellular component that serves to stimulate and support regenerating peripheral nerve axons.

CONCLUSIONS

The field of tissue engineering should consider its challenge to not only meet the autograft "gold standard" but also to understand what drives and inhibits nerve regeneration in order to surpass the results of an autograft.

Experimental and clinical evidence for use of decellularized nerve allografts in peripheral nerve gap reconstruction

Despite the inherent capability for axonal regeneration, recovery following severe peripheral nerve injury remains unpredictable and often very poor. Surgeons typically use autologous nerve grafts taken from the patient's own body to bridge long nerve gaps. However, the amount of suitable nerve available from a given patient is limited, and using autologous grafts leaves the patient with scars, numbness, and other forms of donor-site morbidity. Therefore, surgeons and engineers have sought off-the-shelf alternatives to the current practice of autologous nerve grafting. Decellularized nerve allografts have recently become available as an alternative to traditional nerve autografting. In this review, we provide a critical analysis comparing the advantages and limitations of the three major experimental models of decellularized nerve allografts: cold preserved, freeze-thawed, and chemical detergent based. Current tissue engineering-based techniques to optimize decellularized nerve allografts are discussed. We also evaluate studies that supplement decellularized nerve grafts with exogenous factors such as Schwann cells, stem cells, and growth factors to both support and enhance axonal regeneration through the decellularized allografts. In examining the advantages and disadvantages of the studies of decellularized allografts, we suggest that experimental methods, including the animal model, graft length, follow-up time, and outcome measures of regenerative progress and success be consolidated. Finally, all clinical studies in which decellularized nerve allografts have been used to bridge nerve gaps in patients are reviewed.

Acellular nerve allografts in peripheral nerve regeneration: a comparative study

INTRODUCTION

Processed nerve allografts offer a promising alternative to nerve autografts in the surgical management of peripheral nerve injuries where short deficits exist.

METHODS

Three established models of acellular nerve allograft (cold-preserved, detergent-processed, and AxoGen-processed nerve allografts) were compared with nerve isografts and silicone nerve guidance conduits in a 14-mm rat sciatic nerve defect.

RESULTS

All acellular nerve grafts were superior to silicone nerve conduits in support of nerve regeneration. Detergent-processed allografts were similar to isografts at 6 weeks postoperatively, whereas AxoGen-processed and cold-preserved allografts supported significantly fewer regenerating nerve fibers. Measurement of muscle force confirmed that detergent-processed allografts promoted isograft-equivalent levels of motor recovery 16 weeks postoperatively. All acellular allografts promoted greater amounts of motor recovery compared with silicone conduits.

CONCLUSION

These findings provide evidence that differential processing for removal of cellular constituents in preparing acellular nerve allografts affects recovery in vivo.

The potentiation of peripheral nerve sheaths in regeneration and repair

Traumatic injury to the nervous system often results in life changing loss of neurological function. Spontaneous neural regeneration occurs rarely and the outcome of therapeutic intervention is most often unacceptable. An intensive effort is underway to improve methods and technologies for nervous system repair. To date, the most success has been attained in the outcomes of peripheral nerve restoration. The importance of the peripheral nerve sheaths in successful nerve regeneration has been long recognized. In particular, Schwann cells and their basal laminae play a central role in axon development, maintenance, physiology, and response to injury. The endoneurial basal lamina is rich in components that promote axonal growth. It is now evident that the bioactivities of these components are counterbalanced by various factors that impede axonal growth. The growth-promoting potential of peripheral nerve is realized in the degenerative processes that occur distal to a lesion. This potentiation involves precise spatiotemporal alterations in the balance of antagonistic regulators of axonal growth. Experimental alteration of nerve sheath composition can also potentiate nerve and improve key features of nerve regeneration. For instance, enzymatic degradation of inhibitory chondroitin sulfate proteoglycan mimics endogenous processes that potentiate degenerated nerve and improves the outcome of direct nerve repair and grafting in animal models. This review provides a perspective of the essential role that peripheral nerve sheaths play in regulating axonal regeneration and focuses on discoveries leading to the inception and development of novel therapies for nerve repair.

Chondroitinase treatment increases the effective length of acellular nerve grafts

Acellular nerve allografts have been explored as an alternative to nerve autografting. It has long been recognized that there is a distinct limit to the effective length of conventional acellular nerve grafts, which must be overcome for many grafting applications. In rodent models nerve regeneration fails in acellular nerve grafts greater than 2 cm in length. In previous studies we found that nerve regeneration is markedly enhanced with acellular nerve grafts in which growth-inhibiting chondroitin sulfate proteoglycan was degraded by pretreatment with chondroitinase ABC (ChABC). Here, we tested if nerve regeneration can be achieved through 4-cm acellular nerve grafts pretreated with ChABC. Adult rats received bilateral sciatic nerve segmental resection and repair with a 4 cm, thermally acellularized, nerve graft treated with ChABC (ChABC graft) or vehicle-treated acellularized graft (Control graft). Nerve regeneration was examined 12 weeks after implantation. Our findings confirm that functional axonal regeneration fails in conventional long acellular grafts. In this condition we found very few axons in the distal host nerve, and there were marginal signs of sciatic nerve reinnervation in few (2/9) rats. This was accompanied by extensive structural disintegration of the distal graft and abundant retrograde axonal regeneration in the proximal nerve. In contrast, most (8/9) animals receiving nerve repair with ChABC grafts showed sciatic nerve reinnervation by direct nerve pinch testing. Histological examination revealed much better structural preservation and axonal growth throughout the ChABC grafts. Numerous axons were found in all but one (8/9) of the host distal nerves and many of these regenerated axons were myelinated. In addition, the amount of aberrant retrograde axonal growth (originating near the proximal suture line) was markedly reduced by repair with ChABC grafts. Based on these results we conclude that ChABC treatment substantially increases the effective length of acellular nerve grafts.

Repair of extended peripheral nerve lesions in rhesus monkeys using acellular allogenic nerve grafts implanted with autologous mesenchymal stem cells

Despite intensive efforts in the field of peripheral nerve injury and regeneration, it remains difficult in humans to achieve full functional recovery following extended peripheral nerve lesions. Optimizing repair of peripheral nerve injuries has been hindered by the lack of viable and reliable biologic or artificial nerve conduits for bridging extended gaps. In this study, we utilized chemically extracted acellular allogenic nerve segments implanted with autologous non-hematopoietic mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) to repair a 40 mm defect in the rhesus monkey ulnar nerve. We found that severely damaged ulnar nerves were structurally and functionally repaired within 6 months following placement of the MSC seeded allografts in all animals studied (6 of 6, 100%). Furthermore, recovery with the MSC seeded allografts was similar to that observed with Schwann cell seeded allografts and autologous nerve grafts. The findings presented here are the first demonstration of the successful use of autologous MSCs, expanded in culture and implanted in a biological conduit, to repair a peripheral nerve gap in primates. Given the difficulty in isolating and purifying sufficient quantities of Schwann cells for peripheral nerve regeneration, the use of MSCs to seed acellular allogenic nerve grafts may prove to be a novel and promising therapeutic approach for repairing severe peripheral nerve injuries in humans.

Tissue engineered nerve constructs: where do we stand?

Driven by enormous clinical need, interest in peripheral nerve regeneration has become a prime focus of research and area of growth within the field of tissue engineering. While using autologous donor nerves for bridging peripheral defects remains today's gold standard, it remains associated with high donor site morbidity and lack of full recovery. This dictates research towards the development of biomimetic constructs as alternatives. Based on current concepts, this review summarizes various approaches including different extracellular matrices, scaffolds, and growth factors that have been shown to promote migration and proliferation of Schwann cells. Since neither of these concepts in isolation is enough, although each is gaining increased interest to promote nerve regeneration, various combinations will need to be identified to strike a harmonious balance. Additional factors that must be incorporated into tissue engineered nerve constructs are also unknown and warrant further research efforts. It seems that future directions may allow us to determine the "missing link".

Possibility of using nerve segments dissected from human cadavers for grafting: preliminary report

An intercostal nerve obtained from a human cadaver 6 h post-mortem was transplanted into the rat sciatic nerve and nerve regeneration was observed 4 and 8 weeks after surgery. Sciatic nerves from deceased rats up to 2 days post-mortem were also transplanted for comparison. Good nerve regeneration was observed through the human cadaver-derived graft to the distal segment at the medial plantal nerve 8 weeks after surgery. The results of the present study indicate the possibility that nerves from human cadavers can be used for nerve grafting in clinical applications.

Optimized acellular nerve graft is immunologically tolerated and supports regeneration

To replace the autologous graft as a clinical treatment of peripheral nerve injuries we developed an optimized acellular (OA) nerve graft that retains the extracellular structure of peripheral nerve tissue via an improved chemical decellularization treatment. The process removes cellular membranes from tissue, thus eliminating the antigens responsible for allograft rejection. In the present study, the immunogenicity and regenerative capacity of the OA grafts were tested. Histological examination of the levels of CD(8+) cells and macrophages that infiltrated the OA grafts suggested that the decellularization process averted cell-mediated rejection of the grafts. In a subsequent experiment, regeneration in OA grafts was compared with that in isografts (comparable to the clinical autograft) and two published acellular graft models. After 84 days, the axon density at the midpoints of OA grafts was statistically indistinguishable from that in isografts, 910% higher than in the thermally decellularized model described by Gulati (J. Neurosurg. 68, 117, 1988), and 401% higher than in the chemically decellularized model described by Sondell et al. (Brain Res. 795, 44, 1998). In summary, the results imply that OA grafts are immunologically tolerated and that the removal of cellular material and preservation of the matrix are beneficial for promoting regeneration through an acellular nerve graft.

Transmigration of donor cells involved in the sciatic nerve graft

INTRODUCTION

Recently, human hand transplantation in Europe has shown that motor function may be recovered in some cases. However, little is known about cell trafficking involved the graft nerve. We have succeeded to use green fluorescent protein transgenic (GFP-Tg) rats with various cells strongly expressing GFP in a model a long-term survival of limb graft. In this model, we found retrograde migration of GFP-positive donor cells through the sclatic nerve anastomosis. It is well known that cellular components in the peripheral nerve graft especially Schwann cells, play an important role in the axonal regeneration promoted by nerve grafting. However, it was difficult to distinguish the cellular component of the nerve graft from recipient cells. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the migration of donor origin cells to the recipient's nerve and to examine the contribution of these cells in axonal regeneration using a simplified model of sciatic grafting.

METHODS

Nerve defects were created in recipient rats, using three experimental combinations: group 1: wild-type rats from GFP Tg rats; group 2: GFP Tg rats from wild-type rats; group 3: wild-type rats from GFP Tg rats whose nerve grafts had been pretreated by freeze-thawing cycles (representing an acellular graft). The sciatic nerve specimens were examined under excitation light at 1, 2, and 3 weeks after transplantation.

RESULTS

GFP-positive area expanded clearly beyond the anastomosis both proximally and distally in group 1 and infiltrated into the middle of the null graft in group 2. On the contrary, freeze-thawing grafts donated GFP Tg rats lost GFP expression completely. Columns of GFP-positive cells were formed in the degenerated graft migrated into the recipient's nerve both ante- and retrograde. The S100-positive GFP-positive cells were considered to be graft-origin Schwann cells. The regenerating axons were accompanied with these double-positive cells in the recipient nerve. In conclusion, we have visualized the contribution of graft cells to axonal regeneration beyond a peripheral nerve anastomosis.

Comparison of continuous and discontinuous FK506 administration on autograft or allograft repair of sciatic nerve resection

An immunosuppressant drug that also possesses neuroregenerative properties, FK506 enhances the rate of axonal regeneration and improves recovery after nerve lesions. Nevertheless, prolonged immunosuppression may not be justified to assure the success of nerve regeneration. In this study, we compare the effects of continuous and discontinuous FK506 treatment on regeneration and reinnervation after sciatic nerve resection repaired with autologous or allogenic grafts in the mouse. For each type of repair, one group received FK506 (5 mg/kg) for 4 months, whereas a second group was treated with FK506 at 5 mg/kg for 5 weeks followed by 3 mg/kg for 4 weeks; a control group received saline only. Functional reinnervation was assessed by noninvasive methods to determine recovery of motor, sensory, and autonomic functions in the hind paw over 4 months after operation. Morphological analysis of the regenerated nerves was performed at the termination of the study. Autografts and allografts treated with sustained FK506 (5 mg/kg) reached high levels of reinnervation and followed a course of recovery faster than controls. The numbers of myelinated fibers also were similar. Allografts without immunosuppression demonstrated a slower rate of regeneration, exhibiting lower final levels of recovery compared with other groups and containing fewer numbers of regenerating myelinated fibers. Withdrawal of immunosuppressant therapy resulted in a decline in the degree of reinnervation in all functions tested during the third month, with stabilization between the third and fourth months. The number of regenerated myelinated fibers in the group was significantly lower than in autografts. Thus, continuous or discontinuous FK506 administration slightly accelerated the rate of reinnervation in autografts. In allograft repair, FK506 significantly enhanced both the rate and degree of regeneration and recovery, but its withdrawal resulted in graft rejection, a marked deterioration in function, and loss of regenerating fibers.

Morphological Variations in Brachial Plexus of Beagle Dogs: Evaluation of Utility as Sources of Allogeneic Nerve Grafts

Basic studies were carried out to apply frozen allogeneic nerve grafts in dogs after wide-ranging defects of the brachial plexus due to surgical resection of tumor. In this study, morphological variations in branching patterns of the brachial plexus were examined in ten beagle dogs, to evaluate whether the brachial plexus might represent a useful source of allogeneic nerve grafts. Spatial relationships between the axillary lymph node, which had the possibility of carcinomatous metastasis, and the musculocutaneous (MC) nerve, which was important for the function of the forelimbs, were also investigated. In all ten cases examined, the brachial plexus received ventral roots from the fifth cervical nerve to the first thoracic nerve. No significant variation in the branching pattern was found in any nerve except the phrenic, MC and dorsal thoracic nerves. Four communicating branches were observed and had some morphological variations which might be negligible for nerve grafting. Considering previous physiological and anatomical reports, the most important nerve to be reunited in graft operations for functional recovery is the radial nerve. The MC nerve and median or ulnar nerve should also be considered as possibilities for reuniting. Distances between the axillary lymph nodes and the MC nerve ranged from 11.2 mm to 21 mm (mean +/- SD: 16.1 +/- 2.3 mm). In conclusion, it was suggested that morphological variations in the brachial plexus were technically acceptable to apply allogeneic nerve grafts at least in beagle dogs.

Approaches to tissue engineered peripheral nerve

The late 1980s and early 1990s brought excitement to the idea that we would be able to replace body tissues and organs through the field of tissue engineering. This enthusiasm was soon replaced by the realization of the limitations in our knowledge for specific tissue types and replication efforts. Such is the case with nerve tissue. We have progressed in this field of knowledge; however, full elucidation to the complex interactions of nerve repair falls short.

Metalloproteinase-dependent predegeneration in vitro enhances axonal regeneration within acellular peripheral nerve grafts

Injury to peripheral nerve initiates a degenerative process that converts the denervated nerve from a suppressive environment to one that promotes axonal regeneration. We investigated the role of matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) in this degenerative process and whether effective predegenerated nerve grafts could be produced in vitro. Rat peripheral nerve explants were cultured for 1-7 d in various media, and their neurite-promoting activity was assessed by cryoculture assay, in which neurons are grown directly on nerve sections. The neurite-promoting activity of cultured nerves increased rapidly and, compared with uncultured nerve, a maximum increase of 72% resulted by 2 d of culture in the presence of serum. Remarkably, the neurite-promoting activity of short-term cultured nerves was also significantly better than nerves degenerated in vivo. We examined whether in vitro degeneration is MMP dependent and found that the MMP inhibitor N-[(2R)-2(hydroxamidocarbonylmethyl)-4-methylpantanoyl]-l-tryptophan methylamide primarily blocked the degenerative increase in neurite-promoting activity. In the absence of hematogenic macrophages, MMP-9 was trivial, whereas elevated MMP-2 expression and activation paralleled the increase in neurite-promoting activity. MMP-2 immunoreactivity localized to Schwann cells and the endoneurium and colocalized with gelatinolytic activity as demonstrated by in situ zymography. Finally, in vitro predegenerated nerves were tested as acellular grafts and, compared with normal acellular nerve grafts, axonal ingress in vivo was approximately doubled. We conclude that Schwann cell expression of MMP-2 plays a principal role in the degenerative process that enhances the regeneration-promoting properties of denervated nerve. Combined with their low immunogenicity, acellular nerve grafts activated by in vitro predegeneration may be a significant advancement for clinical nerve allografting.

Differential response of sensory and motor axons in nerve allografts after withdrawal of immunosuppressive therapy

OBJECT

Rejection of nerve allografts and loss of regenerated host axons after withdrawal of immunosuppressive therapy poses an ongoing challenge in peripheral nerve repair. The present report is of a blinded prospective controlled study in which an established rat model of nerve allotransplantation is used to examine the effect of fiber type on survival and degeneration of nerve allografts after discontinuation of immunosuppression. The authors hypothesized that sensory axons will selectively resist a rejection response, whereas motor axons will degenerate.

METHODS

Four-centimeter nerve segments from ACI rats were grafted into peroneal and sural (mixed) or saphenous (sensory) nerve gaps in Lewis rats. In some rats, L4-6 dorsal root ganglia were ablated before grafting, creating pure motor sural and peroneal nerves. All rats received 12 weeks of immunosuppressive therapy to support nerve regeneration into allografts. Immunosuppression with cyclosporin was then withdrawn. At planned death (12-18 weeks postsurgery), graft tissue was subjected to histomorphometric analysis for evaluation of axon survival and loss. Graft rejection led to loss of all axons in approximately 60% of the allograft segments. The mixed nerve group was most prone to complete rejection, with significantly lowered axon counts at Weeks 16 and 18 compared with the Week 12 baseline. Axons from the sensory nerve were least likely to degenerate. The pure motor nerve group axons demonstrated intermediate sensitivity, with a selective loss of larger axons at Week 16 and a significant decrease in axon counts from the Week 12 baseline at Week 18.

CONCLUSIONS

Whereas the majority of axons are lost after withdrawal of immunosuppressive therapy from nerve allografts, there is a selective survival of axons from cutaneous sensory nerves and smaller-diameter motor fibers. The biological and molecular mechanisms that make some axons impervious to injury remain to be determined.

Schwann cell dependence of regenerating rat sensory neurons is inversely related to the quality of axon growth substratum

It is still controversial to what extent elongation of regenerating sensory axons depends on proliferating Schwann cells (SCs) in an injured peripheral nerve. We hypothesized that such regeneration was independent of SC support early after nerve injury, but later became SC-dependent. The sural nerve in rats was crushed, and freezing destroyed cells but not their basal laminae (BL) in the distal nerve segment. Sensory axon elongation was assessed by the nerve pinch test and their abundance was examined immunohistochemically. Sensory axons regenerated fairly rapidly during the first week even if SC migration was prevented. Thereafter, they ceased to elongate and withdrew until their terminals contacted the SCs migrating from the proximal nerve segment. Intrinsic neuronal capacity for growth without cell support, however, had not been lost. Rather, progressive degradation of the former SC BL and loss of laminin in the acellular segment arrested axon growth. Further elongation occurred only when SC migration was possible, corroborating our hypothesis. Sensory neurons continued to elongate and maintain their axons in spite of deteriorating growth substratum if, prior to injury the axons had been allowed to sprout into the denervated skin. Previous sprouting exposed the sensory neurons to high levels of NGF.

Experimental median nerve repair by fresh or frozen nerve autografts and xenografts

The authors described the reconstruction of a terminal branch of the brachial plexus (the median nerve) by different kinds of peripheral nerve grafts, in rats. Fresh or frozen autografts from Sprague-Dawley rats and fresh or frozen xenografts from Beagle dogs were used. Three, six, nine and twelve months after grafting, rats underwent histological assessment (muscle, nerve and spinal cord) and simple functional assessment by the grasping test. The immune reaction was prevented by the freezing and thawing method that had rendered xenografts acellular. This process allowed a satisfactory reinnervation of the flexor carpi radialis muscle (FCR) and a function recovery about 75% of control value. Nevertheless, the force recovery in rats that received frozen grafts was slower than those received fresh autografts. Probably, the destruction of cellular elements by freezing produced a deficient environment for nerve regeneration. However, this gap was partially compensated at twelve months after surgery by the maturation and the secondary adaptation of regenerated nerve fibers. Theses results showed that the force recovery is directly correlated to the capability of the nerve fibers to reproduce, histologically, a next to normal nerve pattern.

Regeneration across cold preserved peripheral nerve allografts

The feasibility of peripheral nerve allograft pretreatment utilizing cold storage (5 degrees C in the University of Wisconsin Cold Storage Solution) or freeze-thawing to prevent rejection was investigated. Regeneration across cold-stored (3 or 5 weeks) or freeze-thawed (FT), 3.0-cm sciatic nerve allografts were compared to fresh auto- and allografts in an inbred rat model. At 16-week post-engraftment, only FT allografts appeared similar to autografts on gross inspection; FT grafts were neither shrunken nor adherent to the surrounding tissue as seen in the other allograft groups. Qualitatively, the pattern of regeneration in the graft segments of the fresh allograft and to a lesser extent of pretreated allografts was inferior to that of autografts as evidenced by a disruption in the perineurium, more extrafascicular axons, smaller and fewer myelinated axons, increased intrafascicular collagen deposition, and the persistence of perineurial cell compartmentation and perivascular infiltrates. Distal to these grafts, the regeneration became more homogenous between groups, although areas of ongoing Wallerian degeneration, new regeneration as well as compartmentation, were more prevalent in fresh and pretreated allografts. Although the number of myelinated fibres was equivalent to autografts, the fibre diameters, the number of large diameter fibres, and the G-ratio were significantly decreased in the allograft groups, which, in part, accounted for the significant decrease in conduction velocity in the 3-week stored and fresh allograft, and the slight decrease in the 5-week stored and FT allograft groups. There was a small return in the Sciatic Function Index towards normal, but no consistent differences between groups were found. Prolonged cold storage and freeze-thawing of nerve allografts resulted in regeneration that was better than fresh allografts, but inferior to autografts. With the concomitant use of host immunosuppression or other immunotherapies, these storage techniques can provide a means of transporting nerve allografts between medical centres and for converting urgent into elective procedures.

Influence of glial growth factor and Schwann cells in a bioresorbable guidance channel on peripheral nerve regeneration

Using an established rat peripheral nerve regeneration model, we investigated the role of glial growth factor (GGF) in nerve regeneration in combination with a novel bioresorbable poly(lactic-co-glycolic) acid (PLGA) guide in vivo. Schwann cells, established from a 1-cm segment of excised rat sciatic nerve, were isolated and seeded onto nerve guides with or without GGF (n = 24/group). Living nerve guides were re-established in these animals, and nerve regeneration was assessed over a period of 12 weeks. Histological studies revealed a reduction in the total axon count and the number of myelinated axons in the presence of exogenously added Schwann cells compared to saline controls. In contrast, the addition of GGF alone enhanced the total number of axons and significantly increased the number of blood vessels. Although combining GGF with Schwann cells negated the enhanced numbers of axons and blood vessels seen with GGF alone, this combination resulted in the highest myelination index and the fastest conduction velocities recorded. The PLGA guide material did not trigger any histologically detectable host response and was permissive for nerve regeneration in this animal model. The results from this study demonstrate the potential utility of this guide in vivo and establish a promotional role for GGF in nerve regeneration.

Synergistic effect of optic and peripheral nerve grafts on sprouting of axon-like processes of axotomized retinal ganglion cells in adult hamsters

We investigated the sprouting response of retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) following the transplantation of peripheral nerve (PN) and/or optic nerve (ON) into the vitreous of the eye and the intraorbital transection of the optic nerve in hamsters. Our previous results showed that an intravitreal PN graft could induce sprouting of axon-like processes in axotomized RGCS [3] (Cho, E.Y. and So, K.F., Characterization of the sprouting response of axon-like processes from retinal ganglion cells after axotomy in adult hamsters: a model using intravitreal implantation of a peripheral nerve, J. Neurocytol., 21 (1992) 589-603). In this model, we have examined the effect of intravitreal ON graft on the sprouting of RGCs both following a co-transplantation of PN and ON into the vitreous and transplantation of ON alone. The present results show that sprouting is increased by more than two-fold in retinas having PN and ON grafts than a PN graft alone. However, the ON graft by itself rarely induced sprouting in RGCs. These results suggest that the ON graft enhance the number of RGCs to sprout axon-like processes in the presence of PN graft by exerting a synergistic rather than an additive effect, since ON graft alone did not induce sprouting. In addition, no diffusible inhibitory effect of ON graft on PN induced sprouting was observed.

Cold preserved nerve allografts: changes in basement membrane, viability, immunogenicity, and regeneration

Rat sciatic nerve graft segments were harvested and pretreated by either placement in the University of Wisconsin Cold Storage Solution at 5 degrees C and storage from 1 to 26 weeks, or repeatedly freezing (-40 degrees C) and thawing (20 degrees C). Following pretreatment, grafts were transplanted as either syngeneic or allogeneic nerve grafts. Storage and freeze-thawing did not affect the Schwann cell basal lamina or laminin distribution of the peripheral nerve. Graft cell viability decreased with increasing time of storage, with some viable cells detectable even after 3 weeks of storage. Freeze-thawed grafts were not viable. Increasing time of storage led to decreasing immune response and graft rejection, but improved regeneration. Freeze-thawed and 26-week stored allografts were nonimmunogenic and rejection was not seen, but regeneration was delayed compared to autografts. Graft storage may become a useful adjunct to clinical nerve allografting to permit elective scheduling of surgery, provide greater time for preoperative tissue testing, and possibly blunt the immune response.

Long acellular nerve transplants for allogeneic grafting and the effects of basic fibroblast growth factor on the growth of regenerating axons in dogs: a preliminary report

Sciatic nerves were excised from 3 beagle dogs about 5 h after their sacrifice, treated three times by freezing and thawing, and stored in physiological saline for 3 months at -20 degrees C until used. Nerve segments 5 cm in length prepared from these stored nerves were transplanted to the common peroneal nerve in the right hindlimb of beagle dogs. Sixteen beagle dogs in total were used, in four treatment groups of two pairs each studied at 1 and 3 months. Five-hundred microliters basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) of two different concentrations (10 micrograms/300 microliters and 100 micrograms/300 microliters) which were impregnated in 0.5 ml gelatin hydrogels was applied around the sutured allografts. Autografting was also done in 4 beagle dogs, with no bFGF application. One month after the grafting, no regenerating nerves extended beyond the middle of the transplant in any of the allografts, except in the autografts in which a number of regenerated (myelinated) axons were present. Three months after the grafting, an abundance of myelinated axons was found at the middle of the graft: the numbers of axons per 10(4) micron 2 were 22.6 in the autografts and 10.6, 10.4 and 19.2 in the allografts treated with no bFGF, low-dose bFGF, and high-dose bFGF, respectively. Regenerating axons extended into the host nerve: the numbers of myelinated axons at the level 1.5 cm distal to the distal suture were 35.7, 0.9, 3.8, and 12.1 per 10(4) micron 2 in the above respective order. Although it was inferior in quality to the autograft, peripheral nerve regeneration was extensive in the distal nerve using freeze-thawed and bFGF-treated allografts at 3 months. Electromyography showed that the peroneus longus muscle responded to the electrical stimuli given at the site proximal to the transplant in all four groups. These data indicate that a 5-cm acellular nerve segment containing Schwann cell basal laminae can be used successfully as an allograft without any immunosuppressants and that exogenously applied bFGF can improve nerve regeneration by enhancing the growth of regenerating axons.

Peripheral nerve regeneration

Peripheral nerve regeneration comprises the formation of axonal sprouts, their outgrowth as regenerating axons and the reinnervation of original targets. This review focuses on the morphological features of axonal sprouts at the node of Ranvier and their subsequent outgrowth guided by Schwann cells or by Schwann cell basal laminae. Adhesion molecules such as N-CAM, L1 and N-cadherin are involved in the axon-to-axon and axon-to-Schwann cell attachment, and it is suggested that integrins such as alpha 1 beta 1 and alpha 6 beta 1 mediate the attachment between axons and Schwann cell basal laminae. The presence of synaptic vesicle-associated proteins such as synaptophysin, synaptotagmin and synapsin I in the growth cones of regenerating axons indicates the possibility that exocytotic fusion of vesicles with the surface axolemma supplies the membranous components for the extension of regenerating axons. Almost all the subtypes of protein kinase C have been localized in growth cones both in vivo and in vitro. Protein kinase C and GAP-43 are implicated to be involved in at least some part of the adhesion of growth cones to the substrate and their growth activity. The significance of tyrosine kinase in growth cones is emphasized. Tyrosine kinase plays an important role in intracellular signal transduction of the growth of regenerating axons mediated by both nerve trophic factors and adhesion molecules. Growth factors such as NGF, BDNF, CNTF and bFGF are also discussed mainly in terms of the influence of Schwann cells on regenerating axons.

Distribution of protein kinase C (alpha, beta, gamma subtypes) in normal nerve fibers and in regenerating growth cones of the rat peripheral nervous system

The distribution of protein kinase C (alpha, beta, gamma subtypes) was studied using immunocytochemical techniques in normal nerve fibers and in regenerating sprouts (growth cones) from the nodes of Ranvier following crush injuries to the rat peripheral nervous system. In normal nerves, for each protein kinase C subtype, immunoreactivity was present in both myelinated and unmyelinated axons. In myelinated axons, immunoreactivity for all three subtypes was patchy in the axoplasm and diffuse in the subaxolemmal peripheral zones. No immunoreactivity was found in the microtubule and neurofilament (cytoskeletal) domain. In contrast, in unmyelinated axons, immunoreactivity was distributed diffusely in the axoplasm. Schwann cells of myelinated fibers exhibited protein kinase C immunoreactivity, but those of unmyelinated fibers did not. In regenerating nerves, early sprouts and growth cones extending through the crushed site along Schwann cell basal laminae exhibited intense immunoreactivity for all three subtypes. Immunoreactivity was distributed diffusely throughout the axoplasm of the regenerating sprouts (growth cones), in which microtubules and neurofilaments were very rare. Thus, the subcellular localization of the protein kinase C immunoreactivity in growth cones of early regenerating nerves differed from that of normal parent axons. These findings suggest that protein kinase C (alpha, beta and gamma subtypes), whose subcellular distribution becomes more extensive in regenerating axons, may have important functional roles in axonal sprouting and in the regulation of growth cone activity in the peripheral nervous system.

Facilitatory and inhibitory effects of glial cells and extracellular matrix in axonal regeneration

Recent studies have shown that Schwann cells stimulate nerve regeneration by producing nerve growth factor in response to macrophage activation as well as by mediating growth through cell-surface and extracellular matrix adhesion molecules. Neurons sprouting in the central nervous system, however, encounter a hostile environment including mature oligodendrocytes with contact inhibitors of growth cone motility, masses of proliferating astrocytes with surface properties that may block regeneration, and an extracellular environment relatively rich in chondroitin sulfate and tenascin forming a matrix less permissive for regeneration than that found in the peripheral nervous system. In addition, as neurons mature, integrins and cell adhesion molecules are reduced in number (transcriptionally) or in efficacy (post-translationally).

Nerve regeneration through the cryoinjured allogeneic nerve graft in the rabbit

To examine whether the 3-4-cm-long allogeneic basal lamina tubes of Schwann cells serve as conduits for regenerating axons in rabbits, allogeneic saphenous nerve, which had been predenervated and pretreated by freezing, were transplanted from Japanese White rabbits (JW) to New Zealand White rabbits (NW). Animals were killed 1, 2, 6, 8, and 14 weeks after transplantation, and the cytology at the mid-portion of the grafts was examined by electron microscopy. The distal portion of the host saphenous nerves was also examined 14 weeks after grafting. Myelin sheath debris was phagocytosed by macrophages, while the basal lamina of Schwann cells were left intact in the form of tubes. Regenerating axons were first found in such basal lamina tubes 2 weeks after grafting, and gradually increased in number. Host Schwann cells accompanied the regenerating axons behind their growing tips, separating them into individual fibers and forming thin myelin sheaths on thick axons by 6 weeks after grafting. Regenerating nerves were divided into small compartments by new perineurial cells. Newly formed blood vessels were situated outside the compartment 8 weeks after grafting. The percentage of myelinated fibers in the regenerating nerves was roughly 10% at 8 weeks and 30% at 14 weeks after grafting. The diameter of the regenerating axons, both myelinated and unmyelinated, was less than that of normal axons at all the stages examined. Numerous regenerating axons, some of which were fully myelinated, were found at the site 10 mm distal to the distal end of the graft 14 weeks after grafting.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Peripheral nerve regeneration

Schwann cell basal laminae were demonstrated to serve as efficient conduits for the growth of regenerating axons in frozen nerve grafts, and in in situ freezing experiments. Regenerating axonal sprouts usually emanated from the first node of Ranvier proximal to the site of damage, and grew out along the inner surface of the basal lamina. Early growth cones contained numerous clear vesicles of about 50 nm in diameter.