Segmental versus total colectomy for large bowel Crohn's disease

Surgical Treatment of Crohn Colitis Involving More Than 2 Colonic Segments: Long-Term Outcomes From a Single Institution

The incidence of primary Crohn colitis is uncommon and surgical treatment has remained controversial, although most patients with Crohn colitis eventually require surgical intervention. This study aims to compare the operative outcomes of patients who underwent segmental versus either total colectomy or total proctocolectomy for Crohn colitis and to assess potential risk factors associated with clinical and surgical recurrence-free survivals.This is a retrospective study of 116 patients who underwent primary surgery for Crohn colitis between August 1997 and July 2011. Patients were classified based on the type of surgery: segmental colectomy (SC group; n = 71) or either total colectomy or total proctocolectomy (TC group; n = 45).There were no significant differences in postoperative complications or the nutritional state between the SC and TC groups. Patients in TC group had a significantly higher clinical recurrence-free survival (CRFS). Among the 54 patients with multisegmental Crohn colitis, the TC group had a significantly increased CRFS and surgical recurrence-free survival (SRFS), compared with patients in the SC group (5-year CRFS: 82.0% ± 5.8% vs 22.2% ± 13.9%, P = 0.001; 5-year SRFS: 88.1% ± 5.0% vs 44.4% ± 16.6%, P = 0.001). By multivariate analysis of patients with multisegments involved, SC was a risk factor for SRFS and CRFS (hazard ratio [HR] = 4.637, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.387-15.509, P = 0.013 and HR = 32.407, 95% CI = 2.873-365.583, P = 0.005).TC patients have significantly increased CRFS and TC in patients with multisegment involvement may affect improved SRFS and CRFS. Among patients with multisegmental Crohn colitis, SC is an independent risk factor for CRFS and SRFS.

Surgery for Crohn's disease: new developments

BACKGROUND/AIMS

Crohn's disease is a chronic relapsing inflammatory bowel disease requiring surgery in a large number of patients. This review describes new developments in surgical techniques for treating Crohn's disease.

RESULTS

Single-incision laparoscopic surgery decreases abdominal wall trauma by reducing the number of abdominal incisions, possibly improving postoperative results in terms of pain and cosmetics. The resected specimen can be extracted through the single-incision site or the future stoma site. Another option is to use natural orifices for extraction (i.e. transcolonic/transanal), but actual benefits of these procedures have not yet been determined. In patients with extensive perianal disease or rectal involvement, transperineal completion proctectomy is often feasible, thereby avoiding relaparotomy. By using a close rectal intersphincteric resection, damage to the pelvic autonomic nerves is avoided. In addition, the risk of presacral abscess formation is reduced by leaving the mesorectal tissue behind.

CONCLUSION

Minimally invasive surgery and associated techniques have become standard clinical practice in surgical treatment of patients with Crohn's disease. New developments aim at further reducing the hospital stay and morbidity, and improving the cosmetic outcomes.

A comparison of segmental vs subtotal/total colectomy for colonic Crohn's disease: a meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

Using meta-analytical techniques the present study evaluated differences in short-term and long-term outcomes of adult patients with colonic Crohn's disease who underwent either colectomy with ileorectal anastomosis (IRA) or segmental colectomy (SC).

METHODS

Comparative studies published between 1988 and 2002, of subtotal/total colectomy and ileorectal anastomosis vs segmental colectomy, were used. The study end points included were surgical and overall recurrence, time to recurrence, postoperative morbidity and incidence of permanent stoma. Random and fixed-effect meta-analytical models were used to evaluate the study outcomes. Sensitivity analysis, funnel plot and meta-regressive techniques were carried out to explain the heterogeneity and selection bias between the studies.

RESULTS

Six studies, consisting of a total of 488 patients (223 IRA and 265 SC) were included. Analysis of the data suggested that there was no significant difference between IRA and SC in recurrence of Crohn's disease. Time to recurrence was longer in the IRA group by 4.4 years (95% CI: 3.1-5.8), P < 0.001. There was no difference between the incidence of postoperative complications (OR = 1.4., 95% CI 0.16-12.74) or the need for a permanent stoma between the two groups (OR = 2.75, 95% CI 0.78-9.71). Patients with two or more colonic segments involved were associated with lower re-operation rate in the IRA group, a difference which did not reach statistical significance (P = 0.177).

CONCLUSIONS

Both procedures were equally effective as treatment options for colonic Crohn's disease however, patients in the SC group exhibited recurrence earlier than those in the IRA group. The choice of operation is dependent on the extent of colonic disease, with a trend towards better outcomes with IRA for two or more colonic segments involved. Since no prospective randomised study has been undertaken, a clear view about which approach is more suitable for localised colonic Crohn's disease cannot be obtained.

Systematic review: has disease outcome in Crohn's disease changed during the last four decades?

BACKGROUND

Disease outcome in Crohn's disease might have changed during the last four decades. Disease outcome measurement in Crohn's disease has methodological difficulties because of patient selection and lack of proper definition of diagnostic and outcome measurement criteria.

AIM

To assess possible changes in disease outcome in Crohn's disease during the last four decades.

METHODS

A systematic literature search was performed using the MEDLINE search engine and major international conference libraries. Articles and abstracts were selected according to stringent inclusion criteria.

RESULTS

Forty articles and nine abstracts complied with the inclusion criteria. Seven studies with a median follow-up time between 11.1 and 17 years showed standard mortality ratios in Crohn's disease ranging between 2.16 and 0.72 with a tendency of decline during the last four decades. One study with 11.4 years mean follow-up time showed a statistically significant increased relative risk for colorectal cancer that was not confirmed by three others. Sixteen publications applied in the disease recurrence category. Probability of first resective surgery ranged between 38 and 96% during the first 15 years after diagnosis. The overall recurrence and surgical recurrence rates after first resective surgery ranged between 50 and 60, and 28 and 45% respectively during the following 15 years without an apparent time trend.

CONCLUSION

This structured literature review provides no hard evidence for change in disease outcome in Crohn's disease during the last four decades.

Crohn's colitis: experience with segmental resections; results in a series of 84 patients

BACKGROUND

Colonic Crohn's disease can be treated surgically by total colonic resection or by segmental colonic resection. The aim of this study was to analyze the outcomes of patients treated by segmental colectomy for colonic Crohn's disease.

STUDY DESIGN

Among 413 patients undergoing operations for Crohn's disease, 84 had a segmental colectomy (cases of terminal ileitis with limited cecal involvement were not included). Postoperative complications, mortality, recurrence, and functional results were studied.

RESULTS

Eighty-four patients (51 women, 33 men), with a mean age of 34 years, underwent operation (right segmental colectomy: 55%; left segmental colectomy: 40%; associated right and left colectomy: 5%). A stoma was established in 27 patients (32%). Operative mortality was zero. Twelve patients (14%) had postoperative complications (including six cases of anastomotic leakage). The mean and median followup times were 111 and 104 months, respectively (range: 15 to 276 months) for the 82 patients with followup available. Thirty-six patients had to undergo reoperation, and the mean time to reoperation was 4.5 years. Twenty-six of these patients suffered colonic recurrence and were treated by total colectomy (n = 9) or new segmentary resection (n 17). The only factor that correlated with the risk of recurrence was youth. At the end of the study, 13 patients still had a stoma. Seventy-five percent of the patients without stoma had less than three bowel movements per day, and 80% were fully satisfied or satisfied,

CONCLUSIONS

There is no evidence of a higher risk of postoperative complications, surgical recurrence, or the requirement of a permanent stoma in patients suffering from colonic Crohn's disease who are treated according to a "bowel-sparing policy" compared with patients treated with more extensive resections published in the literature. Prospective randomized studies are needed to validate this observation.

Recurrence after colectomy in Crohn's colitis

PURPOSE

Previous studies on recurrence and reoperation after colectomy in Crohn's colitis have been based on heterogeneous groups of patients, and divergent findings may be explained by referral biases and small numbers of patients. The aim of this study was to account for recurrence rates, present risk factors for recurrence after primary colectomy, and account for the ultimate risk of having a stoma after colectomy with ileorectal anastomosis in patients with Crohn's colitis.

METHODS

Data on the primary resection, postoperative recurrence, influence of concomitant risk factors, frequency of stoma operations and proctectomy were evaluated retrospectively using multivariate analysis in a population-based cohort of 833 patients with Crohn's colitis.

RESULTS

The cumulative 10-year risk of a symptomatic recurrence was 58 percent (95 percent confidence interval, 53-63 percent) and 47 percent (95 percent confidence interval, 42-52 percent), respectively, after colectomy with ileorectal anastomosis and segmental colonic resection. In colectomy with ileostomy, lower rates were found with respectively 24 percent (95 percent confidence interval, 18-30 percent) and 37 percent (95 percent confidence interval, 32-43 percent) after subtotal colectomy and proctocolectomy with ileostomy. The multivariate analysis showed that perianal disease, ileorectal anastomosis, and segmental resection were independent risk factors for postoperative recurrence. In 76 percent of patients with ileorectal anastomosis, a stoma-free function could be retained during a median follow-up of 12.5 years.

CONCLUSION

Colectomy with ileorectal anastomosis or segmental resection is a feasible option in the surgical treatment of Crohn's colitis, although anastomoses, in addition to perianal disease, carry an increased risk of recurrent disease.

Long-term outcome of total colectomy and ileostomy for Crohn disease

BACKGROUND

This study was undertaken to review long-term results of total colectomy and end ileostomy for Crohn disease.

METHODS

Sixty-nine patients who underwent total colectomy and end ileostomy with an oversewn rectal stump for Crohn disease between 1962 and 1997 were reviewed. Postoperative complications, fate of the rectum or small-bowel recurrence, factors affecting complications and recurrence rates, and risk of rectal carcinoma are discussed.

RESULTS

Fourteen patients had an emergency colectomy. There were no operative or postoperative deaths. In all except five patients symptoms were rapidly relieved. The commonest postoperative complication was an intra-abdominal sepsis (12%). Only five patients (7%) underwent ileorectal anastomosis, of whom two required proctectomy later. Overall, 37 patients (54%) required proctectomy, with a median duration of 2 years. Sixteen patients (23%) developed small-bowel recurrence requiring surgery, with a median duration of 6.8 years. None of the following factors affected the proctectomy rate: sex, age at operation, duration of symptoms, smoking, perforating disease, coexisting small-bowel disease, preoperative proctitis, perianal disease, emergency operation, postoperative complications, or medical treatment. Youth was the only factor associated with a significantly higher reoperation rate for small-bowel recurrence. One patient developed an adenocarcinoma in a rectovaginal fistula, which was curatively resected at proctectomy.

CONCLUSIONS

Total colectomy and end ileostomy is a safe and effective procedure. However, a few patients underwent ileorectal anastomosis, and half of the patients required proctectomy. The small-bowel recurrence rate is low. Regular surveillance of the retained rectum is advised because of a small cancer risk.

Controversies in Crohn's disease

Despite recent advances in the medical therapy of Crohn's disease, surgery continues to play a central role in the treatment of the disease. The strategy for surgical management of Crohn's disease continues to evolve. This chapter reviews many of the controversies surrounding surgical palliation of complications of Crohn's disease. Included is a discussion of indications for strictureplasty in treatment of intractable intestinal obstruction. Factors influencing long-term outcome with sphincter-saving resection in the treatment of Crohn's colitis are reviewed. Experience with definitive treatment of anal Crohn's disease and repair of rectovaginal fistulas is examined. Finally, recent experience supporting ileocolic resection when acute Crohn's ileitis is identified during laparotomy for right lower quadrant pain is critically evaluated. These controversial aspects of the surgical treatment of Crohn's disease reflect an improved understanding of the natural history of the disease as well as refinement in surgical techniques and better definition of criteria for surgical intervention.

Crohn's disease presenting with acute colonic perforation

Crohn's disease is well known for its multiple intestinal complications. The chronic nature and fibrous inflammation which invariably accompanies this disease explains the relative rarity of free intestinal perforation. The true incidence of free bowel perforation is difficult to assess but 1-2% is the anticipated occurrence during the course of illness. We present a case of Crohn's disease which presented for the first time with acute colonic perforation, an extremely rare entity, and review the current world literature.

Surgical therapy for Crohn's disease of the colon and rectum

Crohn's disease remains incurable by either medical or surgical treatment. Both physician and surgeon must work together with the common objective of restoring health by eliminating or alleviating the complications of Crohn's disease. From the surgeon's viewpoint, operation is performed for complications of the disease or for failure of medical management. Although aggressive surgical excision of affected bowel rids the patient of disease for a period of time, the beneficial effects of operation have to be considered in the context that disease recurrence is always a possibility and that reoperation for such complications may be necessary. The aim of the surgeon is to deal with the current problem as simply as possible and to maintain a long-term, strategic view of the disease process with the understanding that what is done today may affect the patient for life.

Avoiding a stoma: role for segmental or abdominal colectomy in Crohn's colitis

Total proctocolectomy and ileostomy for Crohn's colitis offers a low recurrence rate but commits patients to a permanent ileostomy. In contrast, segmental resection may predispose patients to recurrence and further surgery but may delay or avoid a stoma in select individuals.

AIM

This study was undertaken to determine the risk of recurrence and the need for permanent stoma in patients treated with segmental or abdominal colectomy for Crohn's colitis.

METHODS

Between 1976 and 1985, 699 patients underwent surgery for Crohn's colitis at the Mayo Clinic. Patients who had a total proctocolectomy and end ileostomy or primary ileal or anorectal disease were excluded from further study. Fifty-three patients had a colon resection without a permanent stoma, and 49 were alive and available for follow-up. During a mean follow-up of 14 years, completed questionnaires provided current details on subsequent medical and surgical therapies and/or stomas that were required. In these 49 patients, Crohn's of the colon involved the right, left, and both sides of the colon in 12, 31, and 6 patients, respectively, and involved less than one-third, one to two-thirds, and greater than two-thirds of the colon in 23, 25, and 1 patients, respectively.

RESULTS

Twenty-two of forty-nine patients (45 percent) required no further therapy. In 27 patients (55 percent), further treatment was required, including 11 (22 percent) patients who were managed medically (only 4 >1 year) and 16 (33 percent) patients who were managed surgically. Three recurrences developed in the small bowel; the remaining 24 developed in the colon. For the 16 patients with recurrence requiring surgery, mean time to recurrence was 51 +/- 14 months; in all cases, recurrent disease involved the colon, with four anastomotic recurrences. At first recurrence, ten patients underwent another limited colon resection, and six patients underwent completion proctectomy with permanent ileostomy. Five patients required a third procedure, only one of which resulted in a permanent ileostomy. Therefore, 42 patients (86 percent) remained stoma-free, and 7 (14 percent) ultimately required permanent ileostomy, with a mean stoma-free interval of 23 +/- 4 months.

CONCLUSION

Colon resection without proctectomy in select patients with limited colonic Crohn's disease can delay or avoid the necessity of a permanent stoma.

Crohn's disease in the Hunter Valley region of Australia

Between 1967 and 1991, 130 patients underwent surgery for Crohn's disease at The Royal Newcastle Hospital, New South Wales. There were more patients in recent years, which suggested an increased incidence of the condition (2.1/100 000/per year). The clinical profile and recurrence rate were similar to other studies. However, a greater proportion of patients required surgery for chronic small bowel obstruction and fulminant colitis compared with patients in other countries.

Factors predictive of persistent or recurrent Crohn's disease in excluded rectal segments

The fate of the excluded rectal segment after surgery for Crohn's colitis remains poorly defined. To determine prognostic factors relating to the fate of the rectal segment, records of 47 patients who underwent creation of an excluded rectal segment were studied. Disease developed in 33 patients (70 percent) in the excluded rectal segment by five years; 24 patients (51 percent) had completion proctectomy by 2.4 years; and 9 patients (19 percent) retained a rectum with disease at a median follow-up period of five years (range, 2-13 years). At a median follow-up time of six years (range, 2-21 years), 14 patients were without clinical disease. The three groups were equivalent with respect to sex, duration of preoperative disease, indication for operation, distribution of disease, and histologic involvement of the proximal rectal margin. The median age of patients in the proctectomy group at diagnosis tended to be younger than that of patients with a retained excluded rectal segment (22, 30, and 31 years for patients having proctectomy, patients with a diseased excluded rectal segment, and patients with a normal excluded rectal segment, respectively). Neither initial involvement of the terminal ileum nor endoscopic inflammatory changes seen in the rectum predicted eventual disease of the excluded rectal segment. However, initial perianal disease complicating Crohn's colitis was predictive of persistent excluded rectal segment disease and often required proctectomy. Therefore, because the presence of perianal disease and Crohn's colitis predicts persistent or recurrent excluded rectal segment disease, primary total proctocolectomy or early completion proctectomy may be indicated in this subgroup of patients.

Recurrence of Crohn's disease after resection

Recurrent Crohn's disease develops in most patients after surgical resection if the patient is followed for sufficient time. This review examines various aspects of recurrent Crohn's disease. It is concluded that Crohn's disease is a diffuse condition of the gastrointestinal tract and that radical resection of Crohn's disease does not prevent recurrence. Assorted factors thought to be associated with recurrence are examined and the relevance of these factors to the surgeon treating Crohn's disease is discussed.

Segmental colonic resection is an appropriate operation for short skip lesions due to Crohn's disease in the colon

Thirty-six patients have had a segmental colonic resection for Crohn's colitis between 1948 and 1984. There were 2 deaths caused by intraabdominal abscesses present before operation. There were no cases of anastomotic dehiscence in the 29 patients having segmental resection and immediate anastomosis. The reoperation rate at 10 years was 66% (95% confidence interval, 48-84%), the majority of reresections being for recurrent large bowel Crohn's disease. The 10-year reoperation rates were higher than after subtotal colectomy and ileorectal anastomosis (53%; 95% confidence interval, 37-69%) performed in a comparable group of patients with colonic Crohn's disease. The difference did not achieve statistical significance. These findings suggest that when a patient with Crohn's disease has a short segment of diseased large bowel, a segmental resection is feasible and safe.

Free perforation in Crohn's colitis. A ten-year review

A review of 198 patients with Crohn's disease of the colon who presented over a ten-year period identified six patients with free perforation of the colon (3 percent). Five were females and all were known to have pre-existing Crohn's disease. Four were taking oral corticosteroids at the time of perforation. The sole male presented with acute toxic dilatation of the colon and had not received previous steroids. Pneumoperitoneum was seen in five of the six patients. Subtotal colectomy with ileostomy appears to be the optimum treatment in patients presenting with this complication of Crohn's disease.