Cold air challenge for measuring airway reactivity in children: lack of a late asthmatic reaction

'Indirect' challenges from science to clinical practice

Indirect challenges act to provoke bronchoconstriction by causing the release of endogenous mediators and are used to identify airway hyper-responsiveness. This paper reviews the historical development of challenges, with exercise, eucapnic voluntary hyperpnoea (EVH) of dry air, wet hypertonic saline, and with dry powder mannitol, that preceded their use in clinical practice. The first challenge developed for clinical use was exercise. Physicians were keen for a standardized test to identify exercise-induced asthma (EIA) and to assess the effect of drugs such as disodium cromoglycate. EVH with dry air became a surrogate for exercise to increase ventilation to very high levels. A simple test was developed with EVH and used to identify EIA in defence force recruits and later in elite athletes. The research findings with different conditions of inspired air led to the conclusion that loss of water by evaporation from the airway surface was the stimulus to EIA. The proposal that water loss caused a transient increase in osmolarity led to the development of the hypertonic saline challenge. The wet aerosol challenge with 4.5% saline, provided a known osmotic stimulus, to which most asthmatics were sensitive. To simplify the osmotic challenge, a dry powder of mannitol was specially prepared and encapsulated. The test pack with different doses and an inhaler provided a common operating procedure that could be used at the point of care. All these challenge tests have a high specificity to identify currently active asthma. All have been used to assess the benefit of treatment with inhaled corticosteroids. Over the 50 years, the methods for testing became safer, less complex, and less expensive and all used forced expiratory volume in 1 sec to measure the response. Thus, they became practical to use routinely and were recommended in guidelines for use in clinical practice.

Modeling the acute- and late-phase responses to peripheral airway cooling and desiccation

Acute bronchoconstriction after isocapnic hyperpnea can be produced in most asthmatic individuals. However, the existence of a late-phase response is less certain. We used a canine model of isocapnic hyperpnea to test the hypothesis that this discrepancy is due to differences in the challenge threshold for the responses. Acute-phase and late-phase bronchoconstriction was measured in nine dogs after peripheral airway exposure to unconditioned air. Additionally, bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF) was obtained during the late-phase response. The acute-phase response was a polynomial function with a decreasing slope at higher challenges, whereas the late-phase response suggested that a minimum threshold of challenge severity was needed to produce late-phase bronchoconstriction. BALF leukocyte and eicosanoid concentrations had linear relationships with challenge severity. Our data support the hypothesis that acute- and late-phase posthyperpnea responses have different dose-response relationships, a fact that may explain the frequent lack of a late-phase response. However, our data suggest that mild inflammation can be induced with relatively lower challenge severity.

A comparison of a single-step cold-dry air challenge and a routine histamine provocation for the assessment of bronchial responsiveness in children and adolescents

BACKGROUND

It has remained unclear whether bronchial responsiveness as measured by a single-step cold-dry air challenge (CACh) correlates closely to the responsiveness that is assessed by a routine pharmacologic challenge.

METHODS

On 2 consecutive days, we performed a CACh and a histamine challenge in 128 symptom- and medication-free pediatric and adolescent asthma patients. The CACh consisted of 4 min of isocapnic hyperventilation of -10 degrees C, absolutely dry air; responsiveness was expressed by the induced change in FEV1 (delta FEV1). The histamine challenge consisted of sequential inhalations of incremental increases in concentrations of histamine; responsiveness was expressed by the concentration which caused a 20% fall of FEV1 (PC20).

RESULTS

Five children did not bronchoconstrict sufficiently in the histamine challenge for measuring a PC20 and were excluded from analysis. In the remaining 123, delta FEV1 (CACh) ranged from +5 to -73%, PC20 (histamine) from 0.05 to 7.2 mg/mL. There was a statistically significant correlation between delta FEV1 and PC20 (r = 0.54, p < 0.001), but also a considerable scatter of individual data points around the regression line. Fifty-two subjects were hyperresponsive by CACh and 114 by histamine criteria.

CONCLUSIONS

There is a relatively weak correlation between the results of these two challenges; thus, one cannot be substituted one for the other. Histamine appears as more sensitive in detecting airway hyperresponsiveness than CACh. The poor correlation between the responses to these two challenges can be explained by differences between the challenge protocols, or, alternatively, by differences between applied stimuli and activated mechanisms.

Evaluation of cold air challenge data in a population sample using a model of bronchial hyperreactivity and disposition to bronchial obstruction

To explore the role of bronchial hyperreactivity and obstruction after cold air challenge, data from a cross-sectional study of more than 7,000 10-year-old children were used. Current knowledge of hyperreactivity is primarily based on pharmacological provocation tests with variable prechallenge flow rates and their decrease relative to baseline. Using forced expiratory volume (FEV) in 1 sec values before and after cold air challenge, however, it is possible to define a subsample of children with predominant hyperreactivity and a subsample with predominant obstruction after challenge. The prevalence of respiratory symptoms and the diagnoses in the two subsamples were compared. The analysis showed that children with bronchial obstruction have nearly the same frequency of respiratory symptoms as those with bronchial hyperreactivity. A combined model of bronchial obstruction and hyperreactivity was, therefore, more predictive of symptoms than a model of hyperreactivity alone.

Reactivity to cold-air hyperventilation in normal and in asthmatic children in a survey of 5,697 schoolchildren in southern Bavaria

The measurement of bronchial hyperreactivity (BHR) may give additional information to questionnaire-based studies of asthma prevalence. It is desirable to have a provocation method with high specificity that avoids the use of pharmacologic provocations in large numbers of healthy children. It was the aim of this study to establish a range of values for responsiveness to cold-air challenge in normal children, to describe its specificity and sensitivity for a diagnosis of asthma in a large unselected sample of schoolchildren in a field study, and to measure factors associated with hyperresponsiveness. All fourth-grade schoolchildren (9 to 11 yr of age) in Munich and several southern Bavarian communities (n = 9,403) were surveyed with a questionnaire (response rate, 87%), baseline lung function, and cold-air hyperventilation challenge (n = 5,697). A diagnosis of asthma was reported in 7.9% of children. In the reference group, the ninety-fifth percentile (%ile) for the change of FEV1 (DFEV1) was -9.0%; the 90%ile was -7.3%. Asymptomatic children fulfilling all criteria for the reference group showed a significantly increased reactivity if they had a family history of asthma (p = 0.038). With a cutoff for DFEV1 of -9.0% or -7.3% the respective sensitivities to "detect" a diagnosis of asthma were 21.6 and 30.7%, and for asthma with symptoms during the previous 12 months it was 26.2 and 35.1%. Reactivity to cold air increased with the number of episodes of asthma in the previous 12 months. In a multiple linear regression model, factors associated with increased reactivity to cold air were diagnosed asthma, hay fever, male sex, younger age, and a positive skin test.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Cold air challenge of airway reactivity in children: a correlation of transcutaneously measured oxygen tension and conventional lung functions

For pharmacological challenges, a correlation between the induced changes of the transcutaneously measured oxygen tension (PtcO2) and of conventional pulmonary function tests (PFTs) has been documented. We performed a 4-minute cold air challenge (CACh) in 17 children with bronchial asthma under continuous monitoring of PtcO2, and correlated observed changes with CACh-induced alterations of conventional PFTs. PtcO2 decreased significantly with CACh (from 86 +/- 10 mmHg to 66 +/- 14 mmHg, P less than 0.001), but returned to near-baseline within the next 30 minutes. PFTs changed with a similar pattern; the closest correlation was found between the CACh-induced fall of PtcO2 and Delta-FEV1 (r = 0.833, P less than 0.001). Changes of FVC, PEF, and Vmax50 correlated significantly as well. PtcO2 can complement or substitute for conventional PFTs in assessing the response to CACh in children.