Antiandrogenic properties of spironolactone. Clinical trial in the management of female hirsutism

Inhibitors of Brassinosteroid Biosynthesis and Signal Transduction

Chemical inhibitors are invaluable tools for investigating protein function in reverse genetic approaches. Their application bears many advantages over mutant generation and characterization. Inhibitors can overcome functional redundancy, their application is not limited to species for which tools of molecular genetics are available and they can be applied to specific tissues or developmental stages, making them highly convenient for addressing biological questions. The use of inhibitors has helped to elucidate hormone biosynthesis and signaling pathways and here we review compounds that were developed for the plant hormones brassinosteroids (BRs). BRs are steroids that have strong growth-promoting capacities, are crucial for all stages of plant development and participate in adaptive growth processes and stress response reactions. In the last two decades, impressive progress has been made in BR inhibitor development and application, which has been instrumental for studying BR modes of activity and identifying and characterizing key players. Both, inhibitors that target biosynthesis, such as brassinazole, and inhibitors that target signaling, such as bikinin, exist and in a comprehensive overview we summarize knowledge and methodology that enabled their design and key findings of their use. In addition, the potential of BR inhibitors for commercial application in plant production is discussed.

Oral Spironolactone for Acne Vulgaris in Adult Females: A Hybrid Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

The management of acne in adult females is problematic, with many having a history of treatment failure and some having a predisposition to androgen excess. Alternatives to oral antibiotics and combined oral contraceptives (COCs) are required.

OBJECTIVE

Our aim was to conduct a hybrid systematic review of the evidence for benefits and potential harms of oral spironolactone in the management of acne in adult females.

METHODS

The review was conducted according to a previously published protocol. Three reviewers independently selected relevant studies from the search results, extracted data, assessed the risk of bias, and rated the quality of the evidence using the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) approach.

RESULTS

Ten randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and 21 case series were retrieved. All trials were assessed as being at a 'high risk' of bias, and the quality of evidence was rated as low or very low for all outcomes. Apart from one crossover trial that demonstrated statistical superiority of a 200 mg daily dose versus inflamed lesions compared with placebo, data from the remaining trials were unhelpful in establishing the degree of efficacy of lower doses versus active comparators or placebo. Menstrual side effects were significantly more common with the 200 mg dose; frequency could be significantly reduced by concomitant use of a COC. Pooling of results for serum potassium supported the recent recommendation that routine monitoring is not required in this patient population.

CONCLUSION

This systematic review of RCTs and case series identified evidence of limited quality to underpin the expert endorsement of spironolactone at the doses typically used (≤100 mg/day) in everyday clinical practice.

Spironolactone and intermenstrual bleeding in polycystic ovary syndrome with normal BMI

PURPOSE

Spironolactone (SP) is an effective treatment for polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), but it is often associated with menstrual abnormalities whose mechanism is still under investigation. In this study, we investigated the serum sex steroids and endometrial thickness in 30 PCOS patients, before and after one-month 100 mg SP treatment.

METHODS

Serum FSH, LH, estradiol, progesterone and endometrial thickness were evaluated at the 14th and 16th day of the menstrual cycle, before and during short-term SP treatment. According to the presence (15 cases) or absence (15 cases) of menstrual bleeding at the 14th day during SP, the patients were divided into two groups, which were then compared using a two-tailed Student's t test.

RESULTS

Serum estradiol and endometrial thickness were lower than pretreatment at both determinations in all patients, but patients with bleeding had significantly lower estradiol values than non-bleeding ones, both before and after therapy. Endometrial thickness was significantly lower in the bleeding group compared with non-bleeding group only at the 16th day of the cycle. These differences were significant, even though the values of estradiol and endometrial thickness remained in the normal range.

CONCLUSIONS

SP therapy can reduce the values of estradiol and the endometrial thickness in patients with PCOS compared with pretreatment, but PCOS patients with bleeding had pretreatment estradiol values lower than the patients who did not complain of this side effect. Intermenstrual abnormalities may represent the low estrogen impregnation of endometrium due to SP, whose mechanism is complex, involving several factors, such as the effects of some metabolites of SP on estradiol and progesterone production, on their receptors, and the individual metabolism of SP in vivo.

Effects of flutamide on pituitary and adrenal responsiveness to corticotrophin releasing factor (CRF)

OBJECTIVE

Flutamide is a non-steroid antiandrogen that specifically blocks the androgen receptor. We have investigated the effect of flutamide treatment on the adrenal androgen response to corticotrophin releasing factor (CRF) in eight patients with polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS).

PATIENTS

Eight women with moderate to severe hirsutism, ranging in age from 19 to 23 years were enrolled in the study. Basal hormonal pattern showed anovulatory cycles, increased concentrations of LH, androstenedione and testosterone and increased LH/ FSH ratio. A baseline ultrasound scan revealed polycystic ovaries in all patients. Each received 250 mg of Flutamide twice a day for 6 months.

MEASUREMENTS

Before treatment and at the end of the sixth month, women were evaluated for hirsutism score and a CRF test was performed to evaluate ACTH, cortisol and adrenal androgen responses.

RESULTS

Androstenedione (delta 4), DHEA-S, 17-hydroxy-progesterone, testosterone and free-testosterone showed significantly reduced responses after six months of flutamide therapy whereas ACTH and cortisol response were similar to those before treatment. Clinical improvement in the degree of hirsutism was observed in all patients. The Ferriman-Gallwey scores decreased from a mean of 22 +/- 2 to 8 +/- 1.5.

CONCLUSION

Flutamide induces a significant reduction in adrenal androgen response to the CRF test but not in the response of ACTH and cortisol. The finding that flutamide does not alter the pituitary-adrenal axis shows that flutamide acts by reducing adrenal androgens. These results demonstrate that flutamide is not only effective in the treatment of hirsutism but also reduces adrenal androgen secretion.

Comparison of spironolactone-oral contraceptive versus cyproterone acetate-estrogen regimens in the treatment of hirsutism

OBJECTIVE

To compare the efficacy of two antiandrogens, cyproterone acetate (CPA) and spironolactone, in the treatment of hirsutism.

DESIGN

Prospective randomized single-blinded study.

SETTING

A tertiary hirsutism clinic.

PATIENTS

Forty-two premenopausal patients with hirsutism were selected.

INTERVENTIONS

Subjects were randomized to receive either 100 mg spironolactone and an oral contraceptive (OC) containing 150 microg desogestrel and 30 microg ethinyl E2 or 50 mg CPA daily on days 1 to 10 of the menstrual cycle, which was administered with 35 microg ethinyl E2 daily on days 1 to 21.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Hirsutism scores were measured according to Ferriman-Gallwey scoring system and side effects were monitored for 9 months of treatment. Blood samples were taken at each visit for assessment of endocrine, biochemical, and hematologic parameters.

RESULTS

Hirsutism scores were decreaded significantly in both groups at the end of 9 months. The percent of change in hirsutism scores in CPA and spironolactone group were as follows: 19.23% +/- 14.77% and 24.48% +/- 14.27% at 3 months; 39.01% +/- 19.77% and 37.46% +/- 16.90% at 6 months; and 51.89% +/- 20.87% and 46.39% +/- 16.10% at 9 months, respectively. There was a trend toward a better response with CPA treatment, which did not achieve significance. None of the patients stopped treatment because of side effects.

CONCLUSION

The present data suggest that both spironolactone and CPA were similarly effective in treatment of hirsutism.

Comparison of flutamide and spironolactone in the treatment of hirsutism: a randomized controlled trial

OBJECTIVE

To compare the clinical efficacy and safety of the pure antiandrogen flutamide and the steroidal derivative spironolactone in the treatment of hirsutism in women.

DESIGN

Fifty-three premenopausal women suffering from moderate to severe hirsutism were randomized into two groups and received either flutamide or spironolactone in association with a triphasic oral contraceptive (OC) pill. Hirsutism, acne, seborrhea, alopecia, and side effects were monitored monthly for a treatment period of 9 months and a follow-up after treatment period of 6 months. Blood samples were taken at each visit for assessment of endocrine, biochemical, and hematologic parameters.

RESULTS

After only 6 months of therapy, flutamide caused a maximal reduction in the hirsutism score to a value within almost normal range; during the same period, spironolactone caused only a 30% reduction of the hirsutism score. Whereas flutamide caused a dramatic (80%) decrease in total acne, seborrhea, and hair loss score after only 3 months of therapy, spironolactone caused only a 50% reduction in acne and seborrhea, with no significant effect on the hair loss score. Four patients in the spironolactone group but only one in the flutamide group stopped the medication because of adverse side effects.

CONCLUSION

The present data obtained in a randomized prospective study clearly demonstrate that the pure antiandrogen flutamide is superior to spironolactone in the treatment of female hirsutism and its related androgen-dependent symptoms and signs in women.

Topical canrenoic acid. Quantification of the antiandrogenic activity in the hamster flank organ

The topical antiandrogenic activity of potassium canrenoate (CAK), compared with that of spironolactone (SP), was assayed in vivo in female golden Syrian hamsters whose flank organs were stimulated by subcutaneous administration of testosterone propionate. Sebaceous glands and hair were measured by a computerized image analyzer. Pigmented spots, sebaceous gland areas, and the diameter of hairs of the treated flank organs were smaller in the groups that received CAK (1.6 mg/day) and SP (0.4 mg/day). The authors' results showed that CAK may act as a topical antiandrogen on the hamster flank organ when applied in concentrations four times greater than the minimal active dosage of SP. Potassium canrenoate may be a useful weak topical antiandrogen, and it could be used in androgen-related skin disorders involving both sebaceous glands and hair, especially in men. These concentrations could be verified by additional clinical investigations.

Predictors of clinical response in hirsute women treated with spironolactone

OBJECTIVE

To examine the clinical efficacy of low dose spironolactone in hirsute women.

DESIGN

Retrospective.

SETTING

Outpatient endocrinology clinic.

PATIENTS

One hundred nine consecutive women prescribed 75 to 100 mg/d spironolactone for at least 4 months in whom adequate follow-up data were available.

RESULTS

Hirsutism improved in 72% of the women. Women with regular menses, whether or not they used oral contraceptives (OCs), had the highest response rate to spironolactone (78%), whereas women with irregular menses who did not use an OC had the lowest response rate (55%). Favorable responses were associated with increased severity of hirsutism (P = 0.04) and lower serum dehydroepiandrosterone sulfate levels (P = 0.05). Responders and nonresponders did not differ significantly in age (P = 0.10), duration of hirsutism (P = 0.14), pretreatment serum testosterone (T) (P = 0.48), or body mass index (P = 0.11). However, when each parameter was divided into subsets, trends toward decreasing response were observed with increasing age, duration of hirsutism over 15 years, and increasing serum T level.

CONCLUSION

Low-dose spironolactone improves hirsutism in a majority of hirsute women, irrespective of age, severity or duration of hirsutism, menstrual status, or serum hormone levels.

Antiandrogens: clinical applications

Antiandrogens, preventing androgen action at target tissue level, are used in the treatment of various androgen-dependent diseases. Pharmacologically these substances have either a steroidal structure, like cyproterone acetate (CPA) and spironolactone (SPL), or a non-steroidal structure, like flutamide (FLU). In women with hyperandrogenism (PCO syndrome, idiopathic hirsutism, acne), clinical benefit may be obtained with CPA, which also displays a progestational activity and an antigonadotropic effect. CPA (25-50 mg/day) is used in combination with ethinyl-estradiol (EE) (20-30 micrograms/day) in reversed sequential regimen. SPL, less effective than CPA may be employed in moderate hirsutism and acne at dosages of 100-200 mg/day. During SPL treatment menstrual irregularities are frequent: in this case an association with oral contraceptives is indicated. SPL + bromocriptine (2.5-5 mg/day) has been experienced with success in PCO syndrome. The pure antiandrogen FLU, inducing progressive increase in LH and testosterone secretion, may be used only in combination with oral contraceptives. In men antiandrogens have been tested in BPH and prostatic carcinoma. In BPH the decrease in nuclear receptors and DHT nuclear content during CPA or FLU may represent the rational base of the medical treatment. An improvement in urinary obstructive manifestation has been observed with CPA alone or associated with tamoxifen (100 mg + 100 mg day). In advanced prostatic carcinoma antiandrogens represent a good alternative to estrogen therapy with less side effects and in combination with surgical or medical castration (LH-RH analogues) achieve a complete androgen blockade. An increase in the percentage of remissions and survival has been reported.

Dexamethasone and spironolactone in the treatment of non-tumorous hyperandrogenism

To test the hypothesis that a combination therapy with dexamethasone and spironolactone in hirsute women with menstrual disorders due to non-tumorous hyperandrogenism might yield better results than monotherapy with spironolactone, we evaluated 25 women randomly assigned to dexamethasone-spironolactone (n = 15) and spironolactone (n = 10) groups. The Ferriman-Gallwey score and hormonal levels (LH, FSH, PRL, serum testosterone, androstenedione, dehydroepiandrosterone sulfate, estradiol, estrone and salivary testosterone) were determined before and after 6 months of therapy. There were comparable results, with a significant drop in the Ferriman-Gallwey score, in serum androstenedione and estrone concentrations and in salivary testosterone levels in both groups. The only difference between the two groups after therapy was a significant fall in serum dehydroepiandrosterone levels in patients treated with the combination therapy. The results indicate that the combination therapy with spironolactone and dexamethasone presents no real advantage over therapy with spironolactone alone, for the initial treatment of non-tumorous hyperandrogenism.

Lack of effect of spironolactone on hair shaft diameter in hirsute females

Because of its anti-androgenic activity spironolactone 50-200 mg daily is advocated widely for the management of female hirsutism but this practice lacks adequately controlled experimental support. In a double-blind placebo controlled study of the efficacy of spironolactone 100 mg daily in idiopathic hirsutism we were unable to demonstrate objective benefit from spironolactone treatment. The mean effect of spironolactone given over a 9 month period was to increase hair shaft diameter by +15% with 95% CI (-0.4% to +29%). In addition there were no changes in circulating serum androgen concentrations.

Topical antiandrogens in the treatment of male-pattern baldness

Antiandrogen therapy for androgen-induced baldness is in its infancy. In men, because of side effects, topical antiandrogens appear to hold the most promise. Assessing changes in scalp hair growth may be difficult, however, and hirsutism provides a useful model for testing the efficacy of topical antiandrogens. Systemic administration of 5 alpha-reductase inhibitors may also eventually prove to be helpful in the treatment of male-pattern baldness, but side effects and long-term risks are unknown. In women, systemic antiandrogens appear to be a reasonable option for therapy and produce a good subjective response. Further research is needed, however, to document the long-term risks and efficacy of systemic antiandrogen therapy in women.

Clinical applications of antiandrogens

Antiandrogens, substances that prevent androgens from expressing their activity at target cells, play an important role in the treatment of prostate cancer. The most frequently used substances have either a steroidal structure (cyproterone acetate) or a non-steroidal structure (Flutamide or Anandron). Antiandrogens have been tested both alone and in combination with treatments aimed at inhibiting testicular secretion (castration, LH-RH analogs), thereby producing complete blockade of androgen secretion and action. Patients treated by such combination protocols have often shown an improvement in the percentage of remissions and, less often, improvement in survival. Administration of antiandrogens improves the clinical symptoms of patients with benign prostatic hypertrophy, but the exact mechanism of their action requires further investigation. Cutaneous manifestations due to hyperandrogenicity (hirsutism, alopecia, acne) have also been improved by cyproterone acetate, which is often given together with estrogens (reversed sequential regime), by spironolactone or topically applied products. Finally, antiandrogens have been successfully used to treat breast cancer in men, early puberty, hypersexuality and sexual deviations.

A comparative study of Aldactone and Diane in the treatment of hirsutism

A comparative study has been performed in order to evaluate the relative potency of Diane and Aldactone in reducing hair growth as well as the effect on blood hormone concentrations. Thirty-six women participated in the study and depending on the desire for contraception, 22 were treated with Diane and 14 with Aldactone. The results show that Aldactone (50 mg per day) had little effect on hormone concentrations, only LH was significantly reduced after 12 months of treatment. Despite the lack of effect on hormone levels, all 14 women reported reduced hair growth and after 5 months of treatment, 58% also reported a decrease in the formation in new hair growth. In contrast to the Aldactone treated group, the women on Diane medication demonstrated a marked decrease in circulating hormone levels with a subsequent effect on the hair parameters. The clinical effects were, however, not quite of the same degree as those seen with Aldactone treatment. Approximately 20% exhibited no response for any of the 3 hair-parameters (reduced hair growth, formation of new hair and a change to softer hair). The response time before any effect was observed was also longer than that seen with the Aldactone group. The data suggest that, at the dosages employed, Aldactone has a better clinical effect on the hair parameters despite a lack of effect on circulating hormone levels. One should, however, be aware that Diane contains only 2 mg cyproterone acetate (CPA) and a better effect would most probably have been obtained using a higher dosage of CPA.

The endocrine effects of spironolactone used as an antiandrogen

Eight castrate, estrogen-replaced women were given 200 mg spironolactone daily for 4 weeks. The response of plasma dehydroepiandrosterone sulfate (DHEAS), testosterone (T), and androstenedione (delta 4A), all indicators of adrenal C19-steroid production, varied greatly among individuals. Sixteen women with idiopathic hirsutism were given night-time dexamethasone (DEX) and then superimposed spironolactone for 4 weeks, followed by DEX without spironolactone for an additional 4 weeks. As expected, DHEAS, T, and delta 4A declined on DEX treatment. On addition of spironolactone, there was little further change in DHEAS, while plasma T declined in 7 of 16 women, including all those whose T level had remained elevated despite DEX treatment; most values rebounded when spironolactone was discontinued. The authors conclude from intact DEX-suppressed women that ovarian T, especially when increased, is frequently lowered by spironolactone. Thus, both adrenal and ovarian androgen production (as measured by prevailing plasma levels) may be diminished by this agent. These highly variable effects on androgen production are unlikely to account for the consistent antiandrogenic effects reported clinically.

Spironolactone in the treatment of idiopathic hirsutism and the polycystic ovary syndrome

Forty-eight hirsute women were treated with spironolactone 100 mg twice daily for 3 to 12 months. Both facial and body hirsuties improved by 30-40%, and there was a threefold reduction in frequency of local treatments such as waxing or shaving. Plasma testosterone fell by 30%, though the improvement in hirsuties grading did not correlate with the fall in plasma testosterone. Six subjects discontinued treatment because of lack of effect, and 4 because of menstrual disturbance. Spironolactone was equally effective in the treatment of idiopathic hirsutism and of the polycystic ovary syndrome.

Oral spironolactone: an effective treatment for acne vulgaris in women

The effect of oral spironolactone (200 mg daily) on acne vulgaris has been studied in 21 women in a randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind crossover study using 3 month treatment periods. Compared with placebo, spironolactone produced significant improvement as assessed by subjective benefit (P less than 0. 001), number of inflamed lesions (P less than 0 . 001) and by an independently evaluated photographic method (P less than 0 .02). There was a fall in sex hormone binding globulin but no significant changes in plasma testosterone and derived free testosterone. Initial plasma androgen levels were no higher in responders than in non-responders, nor did oral contraceptive use appear to affect clinical response. Spironolactone is a useful alternative therapy for women with acne vulgaris.

The effect of spironolactone on hirsutism and female androgen metabolism

An objective evaluation of the anti-androgen effects of spironolactone was performed in a consecutive series of 12 hirsute patients receiving a daily dose of 150 mg; nine completed the study. Using a computer assisted image analyser, hair diameter on two weekly shavings decreased significantly over a 12 month period in three of the patients, although growth rate and mean diameter did not change in the group as a whole. Plasma testosterone fell significantly to a mean of 53% of basal levels. The mean free testosterone (derived) fell significantly to 64% of basal by the sixth month (P = less than 0.005) and remained significantly depressed the remainder of the study. There was subjective benefit in hair growth and greasiness and a significant reduction in the semi-objective Ferriman-Gallwey index in nine of 10 subjects assessed for at least 9 months. We conclude that although spironolactone was not consistently successful, it may represent effective therapy for a sub group of patients with hirsutism.