Introduction to polymer-based solid-contact ion-selective electrodes—basic concepts, practical considerations, and current research topics

Flexible ammonium ion-selective electrode based on inkjet-printed graphene solid contact

Miniaturization and mass-production of potentiometric sensor systems is paving the way towards distributed environmental sensing, on-body measurements and industrial process monitoring. Inkjet printing is gaining popularity as a highly adaptable and scalable production technique. Presented here is a scalable and low-cost route for flexible solid-contact ammonium ion-selective electrode fabrication by inkjet printing. Utilization of inkjet-printed melamine-intercalated graphene nanosheets as the solid-contact material significantly improved charge transport, while evading the detrimental water-layer formation. External polarization was investigated as a means of improving the inter-electrode reproducibility: the standard deviations of E0 values were reduced after electrode polarization, the linear region of the response was extended to the range 10-1-10-6 M of NH4Cl and LODs reduced to 0.88 ± 0.17 μM. Finally, we have shown that the electrodes are adequate for measurements in a complex real sample: ammonium concentration was determined in landfill leachate water, with less than 4 % deviation from the reference method.

A smartphone-based sensor for detection of iron and potassium in food and beverage samples

A novel approach for simultaneous detection of iron and potassium via a smartphone-based potentiometric method is proposed in this study. The screen printed electrodes were modified with carbon black nanomaterial and ion selective membrane including zinc (II) phtalocyanine as the ionophore. The developed Fe3+-selective electrode and K+-selective electrode exhibited detection limits of 1.0 × 10-6 M and 1.0 × 10-5 M for Fe3+ and K+ ions, respectively. The electrodes were used to simultaneously detect Fe3+ and K+ ions in apple juice, skim milk, soybean and coconut water samples with recovery values between 90%-100.5%, and validated against inductively coupled plasma-optical emission spectrometry. Due to the advantageous characteristics of the sensors and the portability of Near Field Communication potentiometer supported with a smartphone application, the proposed method offers sensitive and selective detection of iron and potassium ions in food and beverage samples at the point of need.

Cu1.4Mn1.6O4 as a bifunctional transducer for potentiometric Cu2+ solid-contact ion-selective electrode

Current potentiometric Cu2+ sensors mostly rely on polymer-membrane-based solid-contact ion-selective electrodes (SC-ISEs) that constitute ion-selective membranes (ISM) and solid contact (SC) for respective ion recognition and ion-to-electron transduction. Herein, we report an ISM-free Cu2+-SC-ISE based on Cu-Mn oxide (Cu1.4Mn1.6O4) as a bifunctional SC layer. The starting point is simplifying complex multi-interfaces for Cu2+-SC-ISEs. Specifically, ion recognition and signal transduction have been achieved synchronously by an ion-coupled-electron transfer of crystal ion transport and electron transfer of Mn4+/3+ in Cu1.4Mn1.6O4. The proposed Cu1.4Mn1.6O4 electrode discloses comparable sensitivity, response time, high selectivity and stability compared with present ISM-based potentiometric Cu2+ sensors. In addition, the Cu1.4Mn1.6O4 electrode also exhibits near Nernstian responses toward Cu2+ in natural water background. This work emphasizes an ISM-free concept and presents a scheme for the development of potentiometric Cu2+ sensors.

Ion-Selective Electrodes with Solid Contact Based on Composite Materials: A Review

Potentiometric sensors are the largest and most commonly used group of electrochemical sensors. Among them, ion-selective electrodes hold a prominent place. Since the end of the last century, their re-development has been observed, which is a consequence of the introduction of solid contact constructions, i.e., electrodes without an internal electrolyte solution. Research carried out in the field of potentiometric sensors primarily focuses on developing new variants of solid contact in order to obtain devices with better analytical parameters, and at the same time cheaper and easier to use, which has been made possible thanks to the achievements of material engineering. This paper presents an overview of new materials used as a solid contact in ion-selective electrodes over the past several years. These are primarily composite and hybrid materials that are a combination of carbon nanomaterials and polymers, as well as those obtained from carbon and polymer nanomaterials in combination with others, such as metal nanoparticles, metal oxides, ionic liquids and many others. Composite materials often have better mechanical, thermal, electrical, optical and chemical properties than the original components. With regard to their use in the construction of ion-selective electrodes, it is particularly important to increase the capacitance and surface area of the material, which makes them more effective in the process of charge transfer between the polymer membrane and the substrate material. This allows to obtain sensors with better analytical and operational parameters. Brief characteristics of electrodes with solid contact, their advantages and disadvantages, as well as research methods used to assess their parameters and analytical usefulness were presented. The work was divided into chapters according to the type of composite material, while the data in the table were arranged according to the type of ion. Selected basic analytical parameters of the obtained electrodes have been collected and summarized in order to better illustrate and compare the achievements that have been described till now in this field of analytical chemistry, which is potentiometry. This comprehensive review is a compendium of knowledge in the research area of functional composite materials and state-of-the-art SC-ISE construction technologies.

An Accessible Yarn-Based Sensor for In-Field Detection of Succinylcholine Poisoning

Succinylcholine (SUX) is a clinical anesthetic that induces temporary paralysis and is degraded by endogenous enzymes within the body. In high doses and without respiratory support, it results in rapid and untraceable death by asphyxiation. A potentiometric thread-based method was developed for the in-field and rapid detection of SUX for forensic use. We fabricated the first solid-contact SUX ion-selective electrodes from cotton yarn, a carbon black ink, and a polymeric ion-selective membrane. The electrodes could selectively measure SUX in a linear range of 1 mM to 4.3 μM in urine, with a Nernstian slope of 27.6 mV/decade. Our compact and portable yarn-based SUX sensors achieved 94.1% recovery at low concentrations, demonstrating feasibility in real-world applications. While other challenges remain, the development of a thread-based ion-selective electrode for SUX detection shows that it is possible to detect this poison in urine and paves the way for other low-cost, rapid forensic diagnostic devices.

Micro- and nano-devices for electrochemical sensing

Electrode miniaturization has profoundly revolutionized the field of electrochemical sensing, opening up unprecedented opportunities for probing biological events with a high spatial and temporal resolution, integrating electrochemical systems with microfluidics, and designing arrays for multiplexed sensing. Several technological issues posed by the desire for downsizing have been addressed so far, leading to micrometric and nanometric sensing systems with different degrees of maturity. However, there is still an endless margin for researchers to improve current strategies and cope with demanding sensing fields, such as lab-on-a-chip devices and multi-array sensors, brain chemistry, and cell monitoring. In this review, we present current trends in the design of micro-/nano-electrochemical sensors and cutting-edge applications reported in the last 10 years. Micro- and nanosensors are divided into four categories depending on the transduction mechanism, e.g., amperometric, impedimetric, potentiometric, and transistor-based, to best guide the reader through the different detection strategies and highlight major advancements as well as still unaddressed demands in electrochemical sensing.

Graphical Abstract

Chloride Ion-Selective Electrode with Solid-Contact Based on Polyaniline Nanofibers and Multiwalled Carbon Nanotubes Nanocomposite

Use of the nanocomposite of chloride-doped polyaniline nanofibers and multiwalled carbon nanotubes (PANINFs-Cl:MWCNTs) for construction of ion-selective electrodes with solid-contact sensitive to chloride ions has been described. Many types of electrodes were tested, differing in the quantitative and qualitative composition of the layer placed between the electrode material and the ion-selective membrane. Initial tests were carried out, including tests of electrical properties of intermediate solid-contact layers. The obtained ion-selective electrodes had a theoretical slope of the electrode characteristic curve (-61.3 mV dec^-1), a wide range of linearity (5 × 10^-6-1 × 10^-1 mol L^-1) and good potential stability resistant to changing measurement conditions (redox potential, light, oxygen). The chloride contents in the tap, mineral and river water samples were successfully determined using the electrodes.

Microfluidic-based ion-selective thermoplastic electrode array for point-of-care detection of potassium and sodium ions

A microfluidic paper-based thermoplastic electrode (TPE) array has been developed for point-of-care detection of Na⁺ and K⁺ ions using a custom-made portable potentiometer. TPEs were fabricated using polystyrene as the binder and two different types of graphite to compare the electrode performance. The newly designed TPE array embedded in a polymethyl methacrylate chip consists of two working electrodes modified with carbon black nanomaterial and an ion-selective membrane, and an all-solid-state reference electrode modified with Ag/AgCl ink and poly(butyl methacrylate-co-methyl methacrylate) membrane via drop-casting. Ion-selective membrane compositions and conditioning steps were optimized. Under optimized conditions, ion-selective TPEs demonstrated fast response time (4 s) and good stability. The TPE array demonstrated a Nernstian behavior for K⁺ with a sensitivity of 59.2 ± 0.2 mV decade^-1 and near-Nernstian response for Na⁺ with a sensitivity of 54.0 ± 1.1 mV decade^-1 in the range 10^-1 - 10^-4 M and 1 -  10^-3 M, respectively. The detection limits were 1 × 10^-5 M and 1 × 10^-4 M for K⁺ and Na⁺, respectively. In addition, a K⁺ and Na⁺ selective microfluidic paper-based analytical device (µPAD) was applied to artificial serum analysis and found in good agreement with average recoveries of 101.3% and 99.7%, respectively, suggesting that the developed ISE array is suitable for detection of sodium and potassium in complex matrix.

Application of polyaniline nanofibers for the construction of nitrate all-solid-state ion-selective electrodes

The application of polyaniline nanofibers doped with chloride and nitrate ions (PANINFs-Cl and PANINFs-NO3) in potentiometry was described. Both kinds of nanofibers were used as an ion-to-electron transducer in ion-selective electrodes with solid contact (SCISEs). Extensive research on the properties of the nanofibers themselves (SEM, UV–Vis spectroscopy, FTIR) and the constructed electrodes (potentiometric methods, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy) has been carried out. Basic analytical parameters of electrodes containing various nanofibers contents in the ion-selective membrane and with nanofibers as an intermediate layer were determined. It was found that application of PANI nanofibers resulted in improvement of electrode performance (among others, better stability and reversibility of the electrode potential). The obtained sensors were characterized by a high slope of the calibration curve, a wide measuring range and a fast response time. Moreover, they were insensitive to change of redox potential, as well as light and the presence of oxygen in the solution, what is important from a practical point of view. They were also successfully used for nitrate determination in real environmental samples.

Solid-Contact Electrode with Composite PVC-Based 3D-Printed Membrane. Optimization of Fabrication and Performance

Intense interest in reference electrode design and fabrication has recently been enriched with the application of 3D printing of electrodes with salt-loaded PVC membranes. This type of material is attractive in sensor technology and is challenging to implement in 3D. In this report, several improvements and simplifications in the technology were focused on and supported by a fundamental electrochemical characterization.

Identification of Mint Scents Using a QCM Based E-Nose

Mints emit diverse scents that exert specific biological functions and are relevance for applications. The current work strives to develop electronic noses that can electronically discriminate the scents emitted by different species of Mint as alternative to conventional profiling by gas chromatography. Here, 12 different sensing materials including 4 different metal oxide nanoparticle dispersions (AZO, ZnO, SnO2, ITO), one Metal Organic Frame as Cu(BPDC), and 7 different polymer films, including PVA, PEDOT:PSS, PFO, SB, SW, SG, and PB were used for functionalizing of Quartz Crystal Microbalance (QCM) sensors. The purpose was to discriminate six economically relevant Mint species (Mentha x piperita, Mentha spicata, Mentha spicata ssp. crispa, Mentha longifolia, Agastache rugosa, and Nepeta cataria). The adsorption and desorption datasets obtained from each modified QCM sensor were processed by three different classification models, including Principal Component Analysis (PCA), Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA), and k-Nearest Neighbor Analysis (k-NN). This allowed discriminating the different Mints with classification accuracies of 97.2% (PCA), 100% (LDA), and 99.9% (k-NN), respectively. Prediction accuracies with a repeating test measurement reached up to 90.6% for LDA, and 85.6% for k-NN. These data demonstrate that this electronic nose can discriminate different Mint scents in a reliable and efficient manner.

Microfabricated Ion-Selective Transistors with Fast and Super-Nernstian Response

Transistor-based ion sensors have evolved significantly, but the best-performing ones rely on a liquid electrolyte as an internal ion reservoir between the ion-selective membrane and the channel. This liquid reservoir makes sensor miniaturization difficult and leads to devices that are bulky and have limited mechanical flexibility, which is holding back the development of high-performance wearable/implantable ion sensors. This work demonstrates microfabricated ion-selective organic electrochemical transistors (OECTs) with a transconductance of 4 mS, in which a thin polyelectrolyte film with mobile sodium ions replaces the liquid reservoir. These devices are capable of selective detection of various ions with a fast response time (≈1 s), a super-Nernstian sensitivity (85 mV dec^-1 ), and a high current sensitivity (224 µA dec^-1 ), comparing favorably to other ion sensors based on traditional and emerging materials. Furthermore, the ion-selective OECTs are stable with highly reproducible sensitivity even after 5 months. These characteristics pave the way for new applications in implantable and wearable electronics.

Boronate ester bond-based potentiometric aptasensor for screening carcinoembryonic antigen-glycoprotein using nanometer-sized CaCO3 with ion-selective electrode

Phenylboronic acid-functionalized nanometer-sized CaCO₃ particles (PBA-CaCO₃) were designed to determine the carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) glycoprotein with a portable Ca²⁺ ion-selective electrode (Ca-ISE) through a typical boronate ester bond. CaCO₃ nanospheres were conjugated to 3-aminophenylboronic acid by amine-epoxy reaction, whereas target CEA was captured into the aptasensing interface by the immobilized thiolated aptamer on gold substrate. Upon PBA-CaCO₃ introduction, 3-aminophenylboronic acid labeled to CaCO₃ microsphere specifically recognized with CEA glycoprotein based on sugar-boronic acid interaction to form a sandwiched complex. The carried CaCO₃ was dissolved under acidic conditions to release Ca²⁺ ion with a portable Ca-ISE readout. Thanks to the specific boronate ester bond between PBA and 1,2-diols, the synthesized PBA-CaCO₃ exhibited good conjugation properties for CEA glycoprotein. Under optimum conditions, Ca-ISE-based aptasensing platform exhibited good electrode potential response for evaluation of target CEA, and allowed detection of CEA at a concentration as low as 7.3 pg mL^-1. Importantly, Ca-ISE-based aptasensing system is readily extended to detect other disease-related glycoproteins by controlling the corresponding aptamer.

One-step electrochemical sensor based on an integrated probe toward sub-ppt level Pb2+ detection by fast scan voltammetry

Herein, a one-step electrochemical sensor for selective and sensitive detection of lead ion Pb²⁺ was developed based on an integrated probe meso-tetra(4-carboxyphenyl) porphine (TCPP)-multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs)@Fe₃O₄, which is TCPP-modified magnetic multi-walled carbon nanotubes. In the integrated probe, TCPP is a porphyrin with a specific cavity structure which could selectively chelate with Pb²⁺, MWCNTs with good electric conductivity provide a place to load TCPP and form a specific adsorption state of Pb²⁺ on the electrode surface, and Fe₃O₄ enables the rapid separation and one-step fabrication of the electrochemical sensor. Based on it, the sample pre-enrichment, separation and determination can be integrated, making the whole process very fast and simple. In addition, fast scan voltammetry (FSV) with a scan rate up to 200 V/s could be used to improve the detection sensitivity greatly, benefitting from the specific adsorption state formed. Under the optimal conditions obtained through orthogonal experiments including adsorption time, integrated probe dosage and solution pH, there was a good linear relationship between the peak current and Pb²⁺ concentration ranging from 2.0 × 10^-4 μg L^-1 to 2.0 × 10^-3 μg L^-1, with the limit of detection (LOD) being 6.7 × 10^-5 μg L^-1 (S/N = 3) i.e. 0.067 ppt. Analysis of actual water samples was successful. Therefore, being simple, fast, selective and sensitive, the one-step electrochemical sensor proposed has a good potential in practical applications.

A wearable sensor for the detection of sodium and potassium in human sweat during exercise

The SwEatch platform, a wearable sensor for sampling and measuring the concentration of electrolytes in human sweat in real time, has been improved in order to allow the sensing of two analytes. The solid contact ion-sensitive electrodes (ISEs) for the detection of Na⁺ and K⁺ have been developed in two alternative formulations, containing either poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene) (PEDOT) or poly(3-octylthiophene-2,5-diyl) (POT) as a conductive polymer transducing component. The solution-processable POT formulation simplifies the fabrication process, and sensor to sensor reproducibility has been improved via partial automation using an Opentron® automated pipetting robot. The resulting electrodes showed good sensitivity (52.4 ± 6.3 mV/decade (PEDOT) and 56.4 ± 2.2 mV/decade (POT) for Na⁺ ISEs, and 45.7 ± 7.4 mV/decade (PEDOT) and 54.3 ± 1.5 mV/decade (POT) for K⁺) and excellent selectivity towards potential interferents present in human sweat (H⁺, Na⁺, K⁺, Mg²⁺, Ca²⁺). The 3D printed SwEatch platform has been redesigned to incorporate a double, mirrored fluidic unit which is capable of drawing sweat from the skin through passive capillary action and bring it in contact with two independent electrodes. The potentiometric signal generated by the electrodes is measured by an integrated electronics board, digitised and transmitted via Bluetooth to a laptop. The results obtained from on-body trials on athletes during cycling show a relatively small increase in sodium (1.89 mM-2.97 mM) and potassium (3.31 mM-7.25 mM) concentrations during the exercise period of up to 90 min.

Recent advances in solid-contact ion-selective electrodes: functional materials, transduction mechanisms, and development trends

This article presents a comprehensive overview of recent progress in the design and applications of solid-contact ion-selective electrodes (SC-ISEs).

Thiol-functionalized reduced graphene oxide as self-assembled ion-to-electron transducer for durable solid-contact ion-selective electrodes

Thiol-functionalized reduced graphene oxide (TRGO) as a novel ion-to-electron transducing layer is firstly employed to develop durable solid-contact ion-selective electrodes (SC-ISEs) in this work. The performance of the sensors is evaluated by determining K⁺ and NO₃^- as an example of cation and anion. The covalent linkage of TRGO at golden electrode surface generates a stable transducing layer. No water films are observed in the proposed TRGO-based potassium (K⁺-TRGO-ISEs) and nitrate (NO₃^--TRGO-ISEs) selective SC-ISEs. The resultant electrodes exhibit Nernstian responses (60.0 ± 0.4 mV/decade for K⁺-TRGO-ISEs and -60.0 ± 0.5 mV/decade for NO₃^--TRGO-ISEs), low detection limits (2.5 × 10^-6 M for K⁺-TRGO-ISEs and 4.0 × 10^-6 M for NO₃^--TRGO-ISEs) and good selectivity behavior. More importantly, the TRGO-based SC-ISEs display a much longer lifetime of 2 weeks than that of reduced graphene oxide-based SC-ISEs in continuous flowing solutions using a longer peristaltic pump. These improvements push TRGO a general and reliable transducer for the development of durable SC-ISEs.

Screen-printed Microsensors Using Polyoctyl-thiophene (POT) Conducting Polymer As Solid Transducer for Ultratrace Determination of Azides

Two novel all-solid-state potentiometric sensors for the determination of azide ion are prepared and described here for the first time. The sensors are based on the use of iron II-phthalocyanine (Fe-PC) neutral carrier complex and nitron-azide ion-pair complex (Nit-N₃⁻) as active recognition selective receptors, tetradodecylammonium tetrakis(4-chlorophenyl) borate (ETH 500) as lipophilic cationic additives and poly(octylthiophene) (POT) as the solid contact material on carbon screen-printed devices made from a ceramic substrate. The solid-contact material (POT) is placed on a carbon substrate (2 mm diameter) by drop-casting, followed, after drying, by coating with a plasticized PVC membrane containing the recognition sensing complexes. Over the pH range 6-9, the sensors display fast (< 10 s), linear potentiometric response for 1.0 × 10⁻²–1.0 × 10⁻⁷ M azide with low detection limit of 1.0 × 10⁻⁷ and 7.7 × 10⁻⁸ M (i.e., 6.2–4.8 ng/ml) for Fe-PC/POT/and Nit-N₃⁻/POT based sensors, respectively. The high potential stability and sensitivity of the proposed sensors are confirmed by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) and constant-current chronopotentiometry measurement techniques. Strong membrane adhesion and absence of delamination of the membrane, due to possible formation of a water film between the recognition membranes and the electron conductor are also verified. The proposed sensors are successfully applied for azide quantification in synthetic primer mixture samples. Advantages offered by these sensors are the robustness, ease of fabrication, simple operation, stable potential response, high selectivity, good sensitivity and low cost.

Phytic acid-based copper(ii) ion-selective electrode on graphene oxide for potentiometric immunoassay of breast cancer antigen 15-3

A potentiometric immunoassay based on a copper(ii) ion-selective electrode (Cu-ISE) was designed for the quantitative determination of carbohydrate antigen 15-3 (CA 15-3; a tumor marker associated with breast cancer).

Solid-contact Ca2+-selective electrodes based on two-dimensional black phosphorus as ion-to-electron transducers

A solid-contact Ca²⁺-selective electrode with two-dimensional black phosphorus as the solid contact was developed for the first time.