Hope is No Plan: Uncovering Actively Missing Transition-Aged Youth with Congenital Heart Disease

Trends in Gaps of Care for Patients With Congenital Heart Disease: Implications for Social Determinants of Health and Child Opportunity Index

BACKGROUND

Lifelong continuity of care is essential for patients with congenital heart disease (CHD) to maximize health outcomes; unfortunately, gaps in care (GIC) are common. Trends in GIC and of social determinants of health factors contributing to GIC are poorly understood.

METHODS AND RESULTS

This retrospective cohort study included patients with CHD, aged 0 to 34 years, who underwent surgery between January 2003 and May 2020, followed up at a pediatric subspeciality hospital. Patients were categorized as having simple, moderate, and complex CHD based on 2018 American Heart Association and American College of Cardiology guidelines. Social determinants of health, such as race, ethnicity, language, insurance status, and Child Opportunity Index, based on home address zip code, were analyzed. Of 2012 patients with CHD, a GIC of ≥3 years was identified in 56% (n=1119). The proportion of patients with GIC per year increased by 0.51% (P<0.001). Multivariable longitudinal models showed that the odds of GIC were higher for patients who were ≥10.5 years old, had simple CHD, lived out of state, lived farther from care site, received public insurance, had less protection with additional insurance plans, and with low Child Opportunity Index. A separate model for patients with only moderate/complex CHD showed similar findings. Race and ethnicity were not associated with the odds of experiencing GIC over time.

CONCLUSIONS

GIC have increased over time for patients with CHD. Social determinants of health, like insurance, access, and neighborhood opportunity, are key risk factors for increasing GIC. Efforts to reduce GIC in patients with CHD should focus on addressing the impact of specific social determinants of health.

Patient factors and geographic barriers influencing excess time between paediatric and adult CHD care

INTRODUCTION

Over 90% of children with CHD survive into adulthood and require lifelong cardiology care. Delays in care predispose patients to cardiac complications. We sought to determine the time interval to accessing adult CHD care beyond what was recommended by the referring paediatric cardiologist (excess time) and determine risk factors for prolonged excess time.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Retrospective cohort study including all patients in the province of Alberta, Canada, age 16-18 years at their last paediatric cardiology visit, with moderate or complex lesions. Excess time between paediatric and adult care was defined as the interval (months) between the final paediatric visit and the first adult visit, minus the recommended interval between these appointments. Patients whose first adult CHD appointment occurred earlier than the recommended interval were assigned an excess time of zero.

RESULTS

We included 286 patients (66% male, mean age 17.6 years). Mean excess time was 7.9 ± 15.9 months. Twenty-nine (10%) had an excess time > 24 months. Not having a pacemaker (p = 0.03) and not needing cardiac medications at transfer (p = 0.02) were risk factors for excess time >3 months. Excess time was not influenced by CHD complexity.

DISCUSSION

The mean delay to first adult CHD appointment was almost 8 months longer than recommended by referring paediatric cardiologists. Not having a pacemaker and not needing cardiac medication(s) were risk factors for excess time > 3 months. Greater outpatient resources are required to accommodate the growing number of adult CHD survivors.

The Impact of Social Determinants of Health on Transition From Pediatric to Adult Cardiology Care

Social determinants of health (SDoH) are the economic, social, environmental, and psychosocial factors that influence health. Adolescents and young adults with congenital heart disease (CHD) require lifelong cardiology follow-up and therefore coordinated transition from pediatric to adult healthcare systems. However, gaps in care are common during transition, and they are driven in part by pervasive disparities in SDoH, including race, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, access to insurance, and remote location of residence. These disparities often coexist and compound the challenges faced by patients and families. For example, Black and Indigenous individuals are more likely to be subject to systemic racism and implicit bias within healthcare and other settings, to be unemployed and poor, to have limited access to insurance, and to have a lower likelihood of transfer of care to adult CHD specialists. SDoH also are associated with acquired cardiovascular disease, a comorbidity that adults with CHD face. This review summarizes existing evidence regarding the impact of SDoH on the transition to adult care and proposes strategies at the individual, institutional, and population and/or system levels. to reduce inequities faced by transition-age youth. These strategies include routinely screening for SDoH in clinical settings with referral to appropriate services, providing formal transition education for all transition-age youth, including training on navigating complex medical systems, creating satellite cardiology clinics to facilitate access to care for those who live remote from tertiary centres, advocating for lifelong insurance coverage where applicable, mandating cultural-sensitivity training for providers, and increasing the diversity of healthcare providers in pediatric and adult CHD care.

Quality Improvement Identifies Healthcare Transition Disparities in Adolescents with Congenital Heart Disease and Disabilities

Introduction

We aim to implement healthcare transition (HCT) education for youth with congenital heart disease (CHD) and assess HCT preparedness for cardiac self-care.

Methods

An HCT clinic was implemented at an academic pediatric cardiology clinic for CHD youth 17 years of age and older. An educator used transition readiness assessment questionnaires and discussed HCT material. The percentage of eligible youth who received HCT education and the cause for missed occurrences were tracked. Plan-do-study-act cycles began in August 2020 to improve the number of youths reached. Secondary analyses assessed improvement differences among those without cardiac procedures or disabilities.

Results

HCT education provision improved from a mean of 38% to 73% in the 17-year and older age group by December 2022. Communication failure was the leading cause of missed visits in 2021 (30%), reduced to 0 by 2022 following plan-do-study-act cycles. Other missed HCT visits included clinic add-ons after screening, limited staff availability, and unidentified eligibility. Readiness assessments were similar for youth with and without prior cardiac procedures, for example, confidence in taking charge of their health care (P = 0.47) and moving to adult care (P = 0.22). Adolescents with disabilities were significantly less confident than those without disabilities in taking charge of their heart health care (6.3 versus 7.5, P = 0.04) and moving to adult care (4.9 versus 7.4, P < 0.001).

Conclusions

Implementation of a CHD HCT clinic improved successful education delivery. Provider engagement and clinic staffing are important for sustainability. HCT knowledge gaps exist for all adolescents, yet those with disabilities had the greatest deficits.

Transition of care in CHD: a single-centre experience: an enigma remains

Transition of care refers to the continuity of health care during the movement from one healthcare setting to another as care needs change during a chronic illness. We sought to describe social, demographic, and clinical factors related to successful transition in a tertiary urban care facility in patients with CHD. Patients were identified utilising the electronic medical record. Inclusion criteria were patients with CHDs aged ≥15 years seen in the paediatric cardiology clinic between 2013 and 2014. Deceased patients were excluded. Clinical and demographic variables were collected. Patient charts were reviewed in 2015-2021 to determine if included patients were a) still in paediatric cardiology care, b) transitioned to adult cardiology/adult CHD, or were c) lost to follow-up. A total of 322 patients, 53% male (N:172), 46% female (N:149) were included. Majority had moderately complex lesions (N:132, 41%). Most patients had public insurance (N:172, 53%), followed by private insurance (N:67, 21%), while 15% of patients (N:47) were uninsured. Only 49% (N = 159) had successful transition, while 22% (N = 70) continued in care with paediatric cardiology, and 29% (N = 93) were lost to follow-up. Severity of CHD (p = 0.0002), having healthcare insurance (p < .0001), presence of a defibrillator (p = 0.0028), and frequency of paediatric cardiology visits (p = 0.0005) were significantly associated with successful transition. Most patients lost to follow-up (N:42,62%) were either uninsured or had public insurance. Lack of successful transition is multifactorial, and further efforts are needed to improve the process in patients with CHD.

Social Determinants of Health Including Child Opportunity Index Leading to Gaps in Care for Patients With Significant Congenital Heart Disease

BACKGROUND

Gaps in care (GIC) are common for patients with congenital heart disease (CHD) and can lead to worsening clinical status, unplanned hospitalization, and mortality. Understanding of how social determinants of health (SDOH) contribute to GIC in CHD is incomplete. We hypothesize that SDOH, including Child Opportunity Index (COI), are associated with GIC in patients with significant CHD.

METHODS AND RESULTS

A total of 8554 patients followed at a regional specialty pediatric hospital with moderate to severe CHD seen in cardiology clinic between January 2013 and December 2015 were retrospectively reviewed. SDOH factors including race, ethnicity, language, and COI calculated based on home address and zip code were analyzed. GIC of >3.25 years were identified in 32% (2709) of patients. GIC were associated with ages 14 to 29 years (P<0.001), Black race or Hispanic ethnicity (P<0.001), living ≥150 miles from the hospital (P=0.017), public health insurance (P<0.001), a maternal education level of high school or less (P<0.001), and a low COI (P<0.001). Multivariable analysis showed that GIC were associated with age ≥14 years, Black race or Hispanic ethnicity, documenting <3 caregivers as contacts, mother's education level being high school or less, a very low/low COI, and insurance status (C statistic 0.66).

CONCLUSIONS

One-third of patients followed in a regional referral center with significant CHD experienced a substantial GIC (>3.25 years). Several SDOH, including a low COI, were associated with GIC. Hospitals should adopt formal GIC improvement programs focusing on SDOH to improve continuity of care and ultimately overall outcomes for patients with CHD.

Health System Encounters after Loss to Cardiology Follow-Up among Patients with Congenital Heart Disease

OBJECTIVE

To analyze receipt of care at other locations within a single rural academic health system after loss to follow-up in a cardiology clinic.

STUDY DESIGN

Patients with congenital heart defects seen in the clinic during 2018 and subsequently lost to cardiology follow-up were included in the study. We defined loss to follow-up as not being seen in the clinic for at least 6 months past the most recently recommended follow-up visit. Subsequent visits to other locations, including other subspecialty clinics, primary care clinics, the emergency department, and the hospital, were tracked through 2020.

RESULTS

Of 235 patients (median age 7 years, 136/99 female/male), 96 (41%) were seen elsewhere in the health system. Of 96 patients with any follow-up, 40 were seen by a primary care provider and 46 by another specialist; 44 were seen in the emergency department and 12 more were hospitalized. Patients with medical comorbidities or Medicaid insurance and those living closer to the clinic were more likely to continue receiving care within the same health system.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with congenital heart defect are frequently lost to cardiology follow-up. Our study supports collaboration across specialties and between cardiology clinics and affiliated emergency departments to identify patients with congenital heart defect who have been lost to cardiology follow-up but remain within the health system. A combination of in-person and remote outreach to these patients may help them continue cardiology care.

Evaluation of a nurse-led multi-component transition program for adolescents with congenital heart disease

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the effectiveness of the transition program for adolescents with congenital heart disease (CHD) 'Transition With a Heart' (TWAH) on disease-related knowledge, quality of life (QoL), transition experiences, and gaps in follow-up.

METHODS

A study with pre-posttest and control group (post-test) using consecutive sampling, including adolescents with moderate to severely complex CHD, without intellectual disability, aged≥ 12 y, and parents. After weighting, t-tests were performed. A multivariable regression analysis explored the outcomes' determinants.

RESULTS

In the intervention group, 28 adolescents and 25 parents were included, and 53 adolescents and 18 parents as controls. Adolescents' knowledge significantly increased after completing TWAH (from 59.8% to 75.7%;p < 0.01). Their knowledge was positively correlated with TWAH (β = +13.3;p < 0.01). Adolescents' transition experiences were also positively related to TWAH (general experience: β = +5.5;p < 0.01; transfer satisfaction: β = +0.8; p < 0.01). Adolescents' QoL was mainly determined by CHD complexity and not by TWAH. No one showed gaps in follow-up. TWAH was not associated with parents' transition experiences.

CONCLUSION

Implementing TWAH substantially improved adolescents' disease-related knowledge and transition experiences.

PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS

The results regarding transition experiences need to be confirmed by further research. The TWAH design with the person-tailored educational program, skills training, and the transition coordinator can be used in settings with other chronic diseases.

The Transition of Children Living With Congenital Heart Disease to Adult Care

The article explores the significance of the timely transition of a child living with congenital heart disease (CHD) to adult care and the role played by multidisciplinary care. Due to recent healthcare advances, more children with CHD survive to adulthood without surgical intervention. This survival is mainly due to the lesion being compatible with life and its management being done medically. However, further management requires meeting the child's needs and helping him transition to become a healthy, independent adult with almost equal life expectancy as his counterparts. The article reviews the comprehensive framework of transition through multidisciplinary care. Highlighting the necessity of training physicians to acquire expertise in the management of CHD is a foundational aspect of this review article. Introduction to transition requires assessment of the child's needs through all phases of life and informative counseling of both parents and child. It highlights the approach to educating patients and families with the knowledge to safeguard compliance. Multidisciplinary collaboration from various fields such as cardiology, pediatric physiatrist, nursing, and psychology has been stressed. Patients also need to cultivate skills in self-management and independence and be educated to comprehend their condition, including the potential health issues. This collaborative and multidisciplinary process necessitates the cooperation of patients, families, and the adult congenital heart disease (ACHD) team. Emphasis has been given to individualized counseling for girls to address their sexual health. The article also highlights the possible obstacles and how to tackle them to improve healthcare adherence. Timely transition and follow-up can be measured using various tools or through indices measuring the quality of life and average life expectancy. The global patterns of transition to ACHD care have also been emphasized, as well as the need for research studies to develop reliable indicators for assessing transition success.

Access to Specialized Care Across the Lifespan in Tetralogy of Fallot

Individuals living with tetralogy of Fallot require lifelong specialized congenital heart disease care to monitor for and manage potential late complications. However, access to cardiology care remains a challenge for many patients, as does access to mental health services, dental care, obstetrical care, and other specialties required by this population. Inequities in health care access were highlighted by the COVID-19 pandemic and continue to exist. Paradoxically, many social factors influence an individual's need for care, yet inadvertently restrict access to it. These include sex and gender, being a member of a racial or ethnic historically excluded group, lower educational attainment, lower socioeconomic status, living remotely from tertiary care centres, transportation difficulties, inadequate health insurance, occupational instability, and prior experiences with discrimination in the health care setting. These factors may coexist and have compounding effects. In addition, many patients believe that they are cured and unaware of the need for specialized follow-up. For these reasons, lapses in care are common, particularly around the time of transfer from paediatric to adult care. The lack of trained health care professionals for adults with congenital heart disease presents an additional barrier, even in higher income countries. This review summarizes challenges regarding access to multiple domains of specialized care for individuals with tetralogy of Fallot, with a focus on the impact of social determinants of health. Specific recommendations to improve access to care within Canadian and American systems are offered.