Brain malformations in the sheep model of myelomeningocele are similar to those found in human disease: preliminary report

State of the art in translating experimental myelomeningocele research to the bedside

Myelomeningocele (MMC), the commonest type of spina bifida (SB), occurs due to abnormal development of the neural tube and manifest as failure of the complete fusion of posterior arches of the spinal column, leading to dysplastic growth of the spinal cord and meninges. It is associated with several degrees of motor and sensory deficits below the level of the lesion, as well as skeletal deformities, bladder and bowel incontinence, and sexual dysfunction. These children might develop varying degrees of neuropsychomotor delay, partly due to the severity of the injuries that affect the nervous system before birth, partly due to the related cerebral malformations (notably hydrocephalus-which may also lead to an increase in intracranial pressure-and Chiari II deformity). Traditionally, MMC was repaired surgically just after birth; however, intrauterine correction of MMC has been shown to have several potential benefits, including better sensorimotor outcomes (since exposure to amniotic fluid and its consequent deleterious effects is shortened) and reduced rates of hydrocephalus, among others. Fetal surgery for myelomeningocele, nevertheless, would not have been made possible without the development of experimental models of this pathological condition. Hence, the aim of the current article is to provide an overview of the animal models of MMC that were used over the years and describe how this knowledge has been translated into the fetal treatment of MMC in humans.

A Novel Model of Fetal Spinal Cord Exposure Allowing for Long-Term Postnatal Survival

BACKGROUND

The inherent morbidity associated with fetal ovine models of myelomeningocele (MMC) has created challenges for long-term survival of lambs. We aimed to develop a fetal ovine surgical spinal exposure model which could be used to evaluate long-term safety after direct spinal cord application of novel therapeutics for augmentation of in utero MMC repair.

METHODS

At gestational age (GA) 100-106, fetal lambs underwent surgical intervention. Laminectomy of L5-L6 was performed, dura was removed, and an experimental product was directly applied to the spinal cord. Paraspinal muscles and skin were closed and the fetus was returned to the uterus. Lambs were delivered via cesarean section at GA 140-142. Lambs were survived for 3 months with regular evaluation of motor function by the sheep locomotor rating scale. Spinal angulation was evaluated by magnetic resonance imaging at 2 weeks and 3 months.

RESULTS

Five fetal surgical intervention lambs and 6 control lambs who did not undergo surgical intervention were included. All lambs survived to the study endpoint of 3 months. No lambs had motor function abnormalities or increased spinal angulation.

CONCLUSION

This model allows for long-term survival after fetal spinal cord exposure with product application directly onto the spinal cord.

Fetal therapy for congenital hydrocephalus-where we came from and where we are going

Despite unfavorable outcomes during the early experience with in utero intervention for congenital hydrocephalus, improvements in prenatal diagnosis, patient selection, and fetal surgery techniques have led to a renewed interest in fetal intervention for congenital hydrocephalus. Research studies and clinical evidence shows that postnatal cerebrospinal fluid diversion to release intraventricular pressure and cerebral mantle compression usually arrives late to avoid irreversible brain damage. Make sense to decompress those lateral ventricles as soon as possible during the intrauterine life when hydrocephalus is antenatally detected. We present a historical review of research in animal models as well as clinical experience in the last decades, traveling until the last years when some research fetal therapy groups have made significant progress in recapitulating the prenatal intervention for fetuses with congenital obstructive hydrocephalus.

A Decade of Experience with the Ovine Model of Myelomeningocele: Risk Factors for Fetal Loss

INTRODUCTION

The ovine model is the gold standard large animal model of myelomeningocele (MMC); however, it has a high rate of fetal loss. We reviewed our experience with the model to determine risk factors for fetal loss.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective review from 2009 to 2018 to identify operative factors associated with fetal loss (early fetal demise, abortion, or stillbirth). Operative risk factors included gestational age at operation, operative time, reduction of multiple gestations, amount of replaced amniotic fluid, ambient temperature, and method of delivery.

RESULTS

MMC defects were created in 232 lambs with an overall survival rate of 43%. Of the 128 fetuses that died, 53 (42%) had demise prior to repair, 61 (48%) aborted, and 14 (11%) were stillborn. Selective reduction of multiple gestations in the same uterine horn was associated with increased fetal demise (OR 3.03 [95% CI 1.29-7.05], p = 0.01). Later gestational age at MMC repair and Cesarean delivery were associated with decreased abortion/stillbirth (OR 0.90 [95% CI 0.83-0.90], p = 0.03, and OR 0.37 [95% CI 0.16-0.31], p = 0.02), respectively.

CONCLUSION

Avoiding selective reduction, repairing MMC later in gestation, and performing Cesarean delivery decreases the rate of fetal loss in the ovine MMC model.

Two Hundred Thirty-Six Children With Developmental Hydrocephalus: Causes and Clinical Consequences

Few systematic assessments of developmental forms of hydrocephalus exist. We reviewed magnetic resonance images (MRIs) and clinical records of patients with infancy-onset hydrocephalus. Among 411 infants, 236 had hydrocephalus with no recognizable extrinsic cause. These children were assigned to 1 of 5 subtypes and compared on the basis of clinical characteristics and developmental and surgical outcomes. At an average age of 5.3 years, 72% of children were walking independently and 87% could eat by mouth; in addition, 18% had epilepsy. Distinct patterns of associated malformations and syndromes were observed within each subtype. On average, children with aqueductal obstruction, cysts, and encephaloceles had worse clinical outcomes than those with other forms of developmental hydrocephalus. Overall, 53% of surgically treated patients experienced at least 1 shunt failure, but hydrocephalus associated with posterior fossa crowding required fewer shunt revisions. We conclude that each subtype of developmental hydrocephalus is associated with distinct clinical characteristics, syndromology, and outcomes, suggesting differences in underlying mechanisms.

Limits of the surgically induced model of myelomeningocele in the fetal sheep

PURPOSE

The prevention of Chiari type II malformation (CM) is commonly used as a primary outcome for the evaluation of techniques of fetal myelomeningocele (MMC) surgery in the fetal lamb. The aim of our study was to investigate the frequency of the associated CM in the MMC fetal sheep model and to investigate the contribution of prenatal ultrasound evaluation of CM at the time of prenatal repair.

METHODS

A MMC-like lesion was surgically created at 75 days of gestation in 21 fetuses performing a L1-L5 laminectomy followed by an excision of the exposed dura and a midline myelotomy. At a 90-day gestation, among the 19 alived fetuses, a conventional repair of the MMC-like lesion was performed in seven, four of whom underwent cerebral ultrasound (US) examination before the repair. Twelve fetuses remained untreated (control group). All fetuses underwent post-mortem examination (PM) at 138 days.

RESULTS

At a 90-day gestation, CM was demonstrated by US examination in all four evaluated fetuses. At birth, CM was found in 3/6 control whether CM was absent in all alived fetuses in the prenatal repair group (n = 4).

CONCLUSIONS

Creation of a MMC-like lesion with an additional myelotomy does not always lead to hindbrain herniation. Our study suggests that CM should be assessed by ultrasound examination at the time of the prenatal repair to demonstrate the effectiveness of new techniques for the prenatal repair of MMC.

Bladder changes after several coverage modalities in the surgically induced model of myelomeningocele in lambs

OBJECTIVE

To assess the presence of early bladder abnormalities in a prenatally corrected and uncorrected animal model of Myelomeningocele (MMC).

METHOD

A MMC-like lesion was surgically created in 18 fetal lambs between the 60th and the 80th day of gestation. Eight of them did not undergo fetal repair (group A), three were repaired with an open two-layer closure (group B), three using BioGlue® (groupC) and four fetoscopically (group D). At term, bladders were examined macroscopically and histopathological changes were assessed using H-E and Masson Trichrome.

RESULTS

Five animals in group A (5/8, 62%), two in group B (2/3, 66%), one in group C (1/3, 33%) and one in group D (1/4, 25%) survived. Macroscopically bladders in group A were severely dilated and showed thinner walls. Microscopically they showed a thin layer of colagenous tissue (Blue layer. BL) lying immediately subjacent to the urothelium. The muscular layers were thinner. Non compliant pattern with thick wall and low capacity was also found in the non corrected model. Group B and the control showed preservation of muscular layers and absence of BL. Groups C and D presented BL but also preservation of muscular layers.

CONCLUSION

Bladder changes in a surgically-induced model of MMC can be described using histopathological data. Both extremes of bladder changes can be observed in the model. These changes were completely prevented with open fetal surgery and partially with other coverage modalities.

Experimental models of spinal open neural tube defect and Chiari type II malformation

INTRODUCTION

Experimental animal models are essential for investigation of the pathoembryogenesis, pathophysiology, and management strategy of spinal open neural tube defect (ONTD) and its associated anomalies including Chiari type II malformation. Genetic, chemical/nutrient, and surgical models have been widely used for a variety of purposes. The aim of this article is to review the representative animal models of spinal ONTD and associated Chiari type II malformation with respect to their advantages and disadvantages.

DISCUSSION

Among them, the surgical model was described in detail because it is familiar to neurosurgeons and it is used for evaluations of prenatal repair of spinal ONTDs. The surgical model also has advantages because it allows quantitative analysis of the lesions. A description of our previous studies on spinal ONTDs using a chick surgical model is presented as an example.

Neurogenic bowel dysfunction in patients with spinal cord injury, myelomeningocele, multiple sclerosis and Parkinson’s disease

Exciting new features have been described concerning neurogenic bowel dysfunction, including interactions between the central nervous system, the enteric nervous system, axonal injury, neuronal loss, neurotransmission of noxious and non-noxious stimuli, and the fields of gastroenterology and neurology. Patients with spinal cord injury, myelomeningocele, multiple sclerosis and Parkinson’s disease present with serious upper and lower bowel dysfunctions characterized by constipation, incontinence, gastrointestinal motor dysfunction and altered visceral sensitivity. Spinal cord injury is associated with severe autonomic dysfunction, and bowel dysfunction is a major physical and psychological burden for these patients. An adult myelomeningocele patient commonly has multiple problems reflecting the multisystemic nature of the disease. Multiple sclerosis is a neurodegenerative disorder in which axonal injury, neuronal loss, and atrophy of the central nervous system can lead to permanent neurological damage and clinical disability. Parkinson's disease is a multisystem disorder involving dopaminergic, noradrenergic, serotoninergic and cholinergic systems, characterized by motor and non-motor symptoms. Parkinson's disease affects several neuronal structures outside the substantia nigra, among which is the enteric nervous system. Recent reports have shown that the lesions in the enteric nervous system occur in very early stages of the disease, even before the involvement of the central nervous system. This has led to the postulation that the enteric nervous system could be critical in the pathophysiology of Parkinson's disease, as it could represent the point of entry for a putative environmental factor to initiate the pathological process. This review covers the data related to the etiology, epidemiology, clinical expression, pathophysiology, genetic aspects, gastrointestinal motor dysfunction, visceral sensitivity, management, prevention and prognosis of neurogenic bowel dysfunction patients with these neurological diseases. Embryological, morphological and experimental studies on animal models and humans are also taken into account.

Maldevelopment of the cerebral cortex in the surgically induced model of myelomeningocele: implications for fetal neurosurgery

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study is to describe the malformations of cortical development detected in a model of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leakage and the influence of surgical closure technique on developmental outcome.

METHODS

Using a surgically induced model of myelomeningocele (MMC) in sheep, we studied the effects of different repair methods upon the development of hydrocephalus, the presence of the Arnold-Chiari II (AC-II) hindbrain malformation, and cerebral cortex developmental anomalies using gross and histologic (hematoxylin and eosin and Nissl staining) study techniques.

RESULTS

A malformed cerebral cortex, including 2 anomalous cortical folding patterns, and lower brain weights were observed in the untreated animals. Hydrocephalus and AC-II malformations were also found in this group. These malformations were mostly prevented with prenatal 2-layer closure.

CONCLUSIONS

Cerebral cortical malformations and hydrocephalus, in addition to the AC-II hindbrain malformation, are disorders caused by fetal CSF leakage. These malformations were prevented with the technique of MMC closure currently used in humans. Both observations magnify the importance of the second hit associated with chronic CSF leakage, in addition to the primary defect causing the MMC, in the development of the malformation complex.

Effects of birth advancement in Chiari malformation in a surgical myelomeningocele model in rabbits

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

In myelomeningocele (MMC), Chiari II malformation progresses during gestation because of the continuous loss of cerebrospinal fluid at the site of the defect. Our purpose was to assess the impact of birth advancement (BA) and prenatal corticosteroid treatment (PCT) on Chiari malformation in a surgical MMC model in rabbits.

METHODS

A surgical MMC-like defect was created in 75 fetal rabbits. Animals were distributed into 4 groups depending on the treatment received: not treated and those undergoing BA + PCT, BA, or PCT. The degree of Chiari malformation in newborn rabbits was defined as the percentage of downward protrusion of the hindbrain between the end of the occipital bone and the beginning of the first vertebral arch.

RESULTS

The degree of hindbrain herniation was 80% (8.15) in the not treated group, 36.8% (10.57) in BA + PCT, 41.8% (8.27) in BA, and 44.4% (8.32) in PCT. The BA + PCT, BA, and PCT groups showed less severe hindbrain herniation than not treated animals (mean decrease, 39.86%; SD, 10.57; P = .000). There were no significant differences between the BA + PCT, BA, and PCT groups (P = .311).

CONCLUSIONS

Birth advancement and prenatal administration of corticosteroids decrease the severity of the hindbrain herniation component of Chiari II malformation in surgical MMC in fetal rabbits.