Perspectives of children, family caregivers, and health professionals about pediatric oncology symptoms: a systematic review

Acceptability of a Serious Game About Proton Radiotherapy Designed for Children Aged 5 to 14 Years and Its Potential Impact on Perceived Anxiety: Feasibility and Randomized Controlled Pilot Trial

Background

Children who are going to undergo radiotherapy have displayed fear and anxiety. Therefore, a web-based serious game was developed as a psychological preparation to investigate if it could affect anxiety levels. In an earlier stage, children with experience of radiotherapy had been part of the developmental process.

Objective

The study aimed to investigate the feasibility in terms of reach, usability, and acceptability of a serious game about proton radiotherapy and to pilot that it did not increase anxiety levels in children aged 5 to 14 years undergoing radiotherapy.

Methods

The design was a randomized controlled pilot trial with predefined feasibility criteria. In total, 28 children were assessed for eligibility, and 23 met the inclusion criteria. They were consecutively randomized into 1 of 2 study arms. One child was excluded after randomization. If randomized into arm 1, the children received the intervention before treatment started. Children in arm 2 were treated as controls. Questionnaires with fixed answers were used to assess anxiety levels (an adapted version of the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory for Children) and experiences of gameplay (an adapted version of Player Experience of Need Satisfaction [PENS]). The children were asked to answer questionnaires at 5 different measurement occasions during their radiotherapy treatment.

Results

In arm 1, age ranged from 5 to 13 (mean 8.4, SD 2.4) years. In arm 2, age ranged from 5 to 11 (mean 7.6, SD 2.3) years. The sample consisted of 15 girls and 7 boys. The feasibility criterion that the children should play the game for 20 minutes or more was not met. Mean playtime for children in arm 1 was 32.1 (SD 23.8) minutes, where 18 children had played for at least 15 minutes. The criterion that 70% (n=16) or more of the participants should return all of the questionnaires was not met; however, more than 73% (n=16) returned the PENS questionnaires. The State-Trait Anxiety Inventory for Children was returned by 73% (n=16) on day 0, 77% (n=17) on day 1, 82% (n=18) on day 3, 82% (n=18) on day 6, and 86% (n=19) on day 15.

Conclusions

All feasibility criteria set for the study were not met, suggesting that adaptions need to be made if a future study is to be undertaken. Further, the analysis revealed that there was no indication that playing increased the children's self-reported anxiety. The PENS questionnaire adapted for children showed promising results regarding player satisfaction when using the serious game. When studying children with severe conditions and young age, 5 measurement occasions seemed to be too many. Measuring both player satisfaction or experience and knowledge transfer would be preferable in future studies.

A qualitative exploration of nurses' views on technology-based interventions in pediatric oncology care

OBJECTIVES

Recent technological advancements offer tools for pediatric oncology care, but their integration into clnical practice is still under research. This study aimed to explore pediatric oncology nurses' perspectives on integrating technology-based interventions into care.

METHODS

A descriptive phenomenological qualitative study was conducted with 13 pediatric oncology nurses. The focus groups were led by the research members, and each group included four to five participants. Nurses were asked to discuss their perceptions of the technology-based intervention, the type of technology used in the clinic, and the advantages and disadvantages of the technology. The focus groups were audio-recorded and professionally transcribed. The transcripts were analyzed thematically by two study team members using MAXQDA. The Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research were followed.

RESULTS

The mean age of nurses was 38.46 ± 5.23 years and 92.3 % had more than 10 years of professional experience. As a result of the focus group interviews, three main themes and seven sub-themes were identified. These main themes included: (i) Need for competence and training for technology-based interventions, (ii) Effectiveness of technology-based interventions in pediatric patient care, and (iii) Challenges in integrating technology-based interventions into care.

CONCLUSION

The study found that from the perspective of pediatric oncology nurses, technology-based interventions have multifaceted benefits and are effective in improving patient outcomes and care; however, nurses' limited ability to use technology-based interventions restricts them from integrating their care.

IMPLICATIONS TO PRACTICE

It is recommended that nurses should be trained on technology-based interventions and the safe use of these interventions.

Developing and validating a 2D digital version of the Brazilian Children's anxiety questionnaire

PURPOSE

This study aims to transpose the printed Brazilian Children's Anxiety Questionnaire (CAQ BR) into a 2D digital format, validate it with nurses and hospitalized children, and analyze the association between the printed and 2D digital format versions.

DESIGN AND METHOD

This is a descriptive and multicentric study, conducted from 2021 to 2022 on working in pediatric care at two hospitals in Brazil. The nurses analyzed the printed and digital instruments and subsequently applied them to a child and proposed suggestions. A cutoff score of 0.80 on the content validity index was used; items that scored an average lower than the CVI in the study were adequate. Eighty children responded to the questionnaires sequentially according to the randomization table. A 90% agreement rate was used.

RESULTS

The digital instrument was validated in content by 51 experts, with a CVI of 0.95. Face validation data for 80 children (mean age = 7.9 years) shows a 90% agreement rate. The intraclass correlation index for the general score was 0.87 and 95% CI (0.79-0.91), which shows good stability of the children's responses in both questionnaires. In addition, 59% (n = 47) of the children reported a preference for the digital questionnaire.

CONCLUSIONS

The digital CAQ BR can be used as an audiovisual instrument by nurses when implementing the systematization of nursing care in pediatrics.

PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS

The digital 2D version was successfully applied and can be used in hospitals to measure children's self-reported anxiety.

Health-related quality of life in Chinese children and adolescents with cancer

AIM

Cancer diagnosis and related treatment can have multiple impacts on children's health-related quality of life (HRQoL). This study aimed to determine profiles of HRQoL in Chinese children and adolescents with cancer based on patient-reported outcomes.

METHODS

This cross-sectional study recruited 310 pediatric patients with cancer (in treatment and survivorship) aged 8-17 years old and their family caregivers from four hospitals in China. The participants were asked to complete the PROMIS Pediatric-25 Profile 2.0, along with a demographic and clinical characteristics questionnaire, fatigue screening item, and an item assessing the family caregiver's coping style. Latent profile analysis was used to identify profiles.

RESULTS

Two profiles were identified: Profile 1, "low symptom and high function" (n = 147, 47.4%); and Profile 2, "high symptom and low function" (n = 163, 52.5%). Children reporting ≥3 on the five-point Symptom Distress Scale fatigue screening item were more likely to be in Profile 2 (OR = 1.961; 95% CI: 1.098-3.501). Participants were less likely to be in Profile 2 if they were in survivorship (OR = 0.494; 95% CI: 0.271-0.903), or their caregiver's coping style was identified as facing positively (OR = 0.439; 95% CI: 0.274-0.703).

CONCLUSION

The identified profiles demonstrate the heterogeneity in HRQoL among pediatric patients with cancer, and the importance of supporting caregivers' coping as a means of supporting the child. Knowledge of these profiles can assist clinicians in better identifying and targeting interventions for children with cancer.

Patient-Reported Outcome Benefits for Children with Advanced Cancer and Parents: A Qualitative Study

CONTEXT

Electronic patient-reported outcomes (e-PROs) in pediatric oncology may be useful to track patients' symptoms and quality of life (QoL). However, implementation in the clinical setting is limited and few studies have examined child and parent perspectives on e-PRO usage.

OBJECTIVES

This brief report aims to explore child and parent perspectives on the benefits of using e-PROs to routinely report on symptoms and QoL.

METHODS

We analyzed qualitative data embedded within the PediQUEST Response trial, a randomized controlled trial aimed at early palliative care integration for children with advanced cancer and their parents. Study dyads, made up of a child and their parent, completed weekly surveys assessing symptoms and QoL for 18 weeks, and were invited to participate in an audio-recorded exit interview to share study feedback. Interview transcripts were analyzed with a thematic analysis approach, with emergent themes centered on the benefits of e-PRO usage reported here.

RESULTS

Of 154 total randomized participants, we collected 147 exit interviews representing 105 child participants. Interviewed children (n=47) and parents (n=104) were mostly White and non-Hispanic. Two predominant themes emerged regarding e-PRO benefits:1) raised reflection and awareness of self and others' experiences, and 2) increased communication and connection between parents and children or between study dyads and care teams through survey prompted discussion.

CONCLUSION

Advanced pediatric cancer patients and their parents found benefit in completing routine e-PROs as they promoted greater reflection and awareness and increased communication. These results may inform further integration of e-PROs in routine pediatric oncology care.

Disagreement between mothers' and fathers' rating of health-related quality of life in children with cancer

PURPOSE

Serial assessment of health condition based on self-report made by children and their proxies has consistently shown a lack of congruence. The study explored the discrepancies between mother's, father's, and children's reports on health-related quality of life (HRQOL) during the first two months of pediatric cancer treatment.

METHODS

In this cohort study, children and parents completed the generic and cancer-specific Pediatric Quality-of-Life Inventory (PedsQL) questionnaires at initial diagnosis and in the subsequent months. Evaluation of discrepancies included intraclass correlations between mother-child and father-child dyads at different domain levels.

RESULTS

Thirty-six children with a diagnosis of cancer between May 2020 and November 2021 and their parents were included in this study. At diagnosis, mother-child dyads showed better agreement on more domains of the PedsQL Generic Core Scale than father-child dyads; moderate agreement persisted for both parents at subsequent time points on the physical domain. The disease-specific PedsQL Cancer Module revealed moderate and better agreement for mother-child dyads during active cancer therapy. In particular, agreement of mother-child dyads was pronounced for domains such as worry (0.77 [95% CI 0.52-0.89, P < 0.001]), whereas fathers tended to overestimate the child's symptom burden for most of the remaining domains of the PedsQL Cancer Module.

CONCLUSION

This cohort study shows that both parent proxy reports can provide valid information on child's HRQOL, but that fathers tend to overestimate, particularly for non-observable domains. Proxy reports derived from mothers more closely agreed with children's HRQOL and might be more weighted, if there is uncertainty between parents.

"I Didn't Want My Baby to Pass, But I Didn't Want Him Suffering Either": Comparing Bereaved Parents' Narratives With Nursing End-of-Life Assessments in the Pediatric Intensive Care Unit

Little is known about how nursing care at the end of a child's life impacts long-term parental bereavement. We aimed to explain, contextualize, and examine comparisons between quantitative trends in children's end-of-life care and parents' qualitative perceptions. We used a mixed methods design, combining quantitative data from the RESTORE clinical trial with qualitative interviews with bereaved parents. Patients who died during RESTORE were included in quantitative analyses. A subset of their parents was interviewed 7 to 11 years later. The quantitative analyses included 104 children. Eight parents were interviewed; 4 had a child die after cancer, and 4 had a child die after a complex chronic illness. Quantitatively, patients' pain and sedation scores were generally comfortable. Children died with multiple invasive devices in place. Parents' descriptions of their child's comfort and critical care requirements differed by illness trajectory (cancer, complex chronic illness). Parents' memories of their child's suffering aligned with peaks in clinical scores, rather than averages. Invasive devices and equipment altered parents' ability to make meaningful final memories with the dying child. Pediatric intensive care clinicians may need to broaden how they attend to dying children's pain and corresponding parental distress, as parents' memories of their dying child's suffering persist for years.

Lived experiences with unmet supportive care needs in pediatric cancer: Perspective of Chinese children and their parents

Objective

Unmet supportive care needs(SCNs) impact pediatric cancer patients and their parents. This study aimed to explore the unmet SCNs from the perspective of Chinese children with cancer and their parents through lived experiences.

Methods

The data of this study was collected using face-to-face semi-structured interviews. The participants were recruited from the oncology units of three children’s hospitals in China’s cities (Shanghai, Guangzhou, and Hefei) from October 2020 to December 2021. Data were analyzed using Colaizzi’s seven-step phenomenological analysis method.

Results

Eight pediatric cancer patients and twenty-four parents were enrolled in the study. Four main themes and eight subthemes (both children’s and parent’s perspectives) were generated: 1) meeting the ongoing needs along the cancer trajectory (can you tell me what comes next; our needs are growing); 2) communicating with a family focus (they only talk to my parents; let each family member have a voice); 3) providing care beyond the treatment (I am bigger than my body [the children’s needs for emotional consolidation and information about their prognosis]; there are things beyond treatment); 4) getting support from the community (I am not a monster [the children were unhappy about being treated differently]; we want to connect with the resources near us).

Conclusion

This study revealed multiple unmet SCNs from the perspective of Chinese children with cancer and their parents. The findings call for comprehensive and in-depth supportive care beyond treatment, integration of the family member voice in pediatric cancer care, and a coordinated pediatric cancer support mechanism in the Chinese healthcare system.

Nursing Care at End of Life in Pediatric Intensive Care Unit Patients Requiring Mechanical Ventilation

BACKGROUND

Parents' perceptions of critical care during the final days of their child's life shape their grief for decades. Little is known about nursing care needs of children actively dying in the pediatric intensive care unit (PICU).

OBJECTIVES

To examine associations between patient characteristics, circumstances of death, and nursing care requirements for children who died in the PICU.

METHODS

A secondary analysis of the data set from the Randomized Evaluation of Sedation Titration for Respiratory Failure trial was conducted.

RESULTS

This analysis included 104 children; 67 died after withdrawal of life-sustaining treatments; 21, after failed resuscitation; and 16, after brain death. Patients had a median age of 7.5 years, were cognitively appropriate, and were intubated for acute respiratory failure. Daily pain and sedation scores indicated patients' comfort was well managed (mean pain scores: modal, 0; peak, 2; mean sedation scores: modal, -2; peak, -1). Patients with longer PICU stays more often experienced pain and agitation on the day of death. Illness trajectory (acute, complex chronic condition, or cancer) was associated with pain scores (P = .04). Specifically, children with cancer had higher pain scores than children with acute illness trajectories (P = .01). Many patients (62%) had no change in critical care devices in their last days of life (median, 5 devices). Patterns of pain, sedation, comfort medications, and nursing care requirements did not differ by circumstances of death.

CONCLUSION

Children with cancer and longer PICU stays may need comprehensive comfort management. Invasive devices left in place during withdrawal of life support may have inhibited parents' ability to connect with their child. Future research should incorporate parents' perspectives.

[Needs of Children with Oncological Diseases: Psychometric Review of the Survey Instrument "KiWuF-PädOnk" and First Results]

In der vorliegenden Querschnittstudie wurde ein neu konzipierter Bedürfnisfragebogen für 8- bis 13-jährige Krebspatienten psychometrisch überprüft (N=117). Auf der Grundlage einer explorativen Faktorenanalyse wurden 4 Skalen mit insgesamt 19 Items gebildet. Die interne Konsistenz des Fragebogens ist zufriedenstellend. Die Teilnehmenden äußerten ein starkes Bedürfnis nach sozialer Teilhabe, Sicherheit und Kontrollerleben sowie nach Normalität. Der KiWuF-PädOnk liefert Informationen zu Bedürfnissen aus Patientensicht und fördert somit eine individuumszentrierte psychosoziale Versorgung. In the present cross-sectional study, a newly designed needs questionnaire for 8- to 13-year-old cancer patients was psychometrically tested (N=117). Based on an exploratory factor analysis, 4 scales with a total of 19 items were formed. The internal consistency of the questionnaire is satisfactory. Participants expressed a strong need for social participation, safety and experience of control, and normality. The KiWuF-PädOnk provides information on needs from the patient's perspective and thus promotes individual-centered psychosocial care.

The predictive trifecta? Fatigue, pain, and anxiety severity forecast the suffering profile of children with cancer

BACKGROUND

Fatigue, pain, and anxiety, symptoms commonly experienced by children with cancer, may predict pediatric symptom suffering profile membership that is amenable to treatment.

METHODS

Three latent profiles (Low, Medium, and High symptom suffering) from 436 pediatric patients undergoing cancer care were assessed for association with three single-item symptoms and socio-demographic variables.

RESULTS

Pediatric-PRO-CTCAE fatigue, pain, and anxiety severity scores at baseline were highly and significantly associated with the Medium and High Suffering profiles comprised of PROMIS pediatric symptom and function measures. The likelihood of membership in the Medium Suffering group was 11.37 times higher for patients who experienced fatigue severity than those with did not, while experience of pain severity increased the likelihood of the child's membership in the Medium Suffering profile by 2.59 times and anxiety by 3.67 times. The severity of fatigue increased the likelihood of presence in the High Suffering group by 2.99 times while pain severity increased the likelihood of the child's membership in the High Suffering profile by 6.36 times and anxiety by 16.75 times. Controlling for experience of symptom severity, older patients were more likely to be in the Higher or Medium Suffering profile than in the Low Suffering profile; no other socio-demographic or clinical variables had a significant effect on the latent profile classification.

CONCLUSION

Clinician knowledge of the strong association between fatigue, pain, and anxiety severity and suffering profiles may help focus supportive care to improve the cancer experience for children most at risk from time of diagnosis through treatment.

The Symptom Experience in Pediatric Cancer: Current Conceptualizations and Future Directions

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

We aimed to review the recent research on the childhood cancer symptom experience pertaining to socioeconomic factors, biology and genetics, growth and development, family psychosocial dynamics, and social and treating environments to begin to formulate recommendations for a personalized approach to symptom management.

RECENT FINDINGS

Cancer symptoms are common and distressing in children and negatively impact child and family quality of life. Many interacting factors influence children's cancer symptoms experiences, including the assessment and management of such symptoms. This paper highlights several gaps in the research related to the cancer symptom experience including routine symptom assessment, the impact of socioeconomic, biological, and genetic factors on symptoms, and the establishment of effective symptom management partnerships with families. Based on our findings, we provide recommendations related to that research which is ready to be implemented into clinical practice and areas for needed future efforts.

The Pediatric Cancer Survivors' User Experiences With Digital Health Interventions: A Systematic Review of Qualitative Data

BACKGROUND

Evidence suggests that digital health interventions are feasible and acceptable in pediatric cancer survivors. Efforts to synthesize user experiences, however, are limited.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to systematically identify, appraise, and synthesize qualitative evidence on the user experiences of pediatric cancer survivors participating in digital health interventions.

METHODS

We searched 4 databases to identify studies with qualitative data of the digital health intervention user experiences from childhood, adolescent, and young adult pediatric cancer survivors, published from the databases' inception to January 31, 2020. Studies that met inclusion criteria were selected and reviewed for quality. The extracted data were analyzed by thematic synthesis.

RESULTS

Sixteen articles met the inclusion criteria. Two analytic themes emerged, each with 3 descriptive themes: (1) the favorable experience of using digital health interventions, including "knowing about oneself and one's cancer," "connecting with others in a trustworthy and safe way," and "getting empowered and rewarded"; and (2) the challenges of using digital health interventions, including "challenges from the content of the program," "technology challenges," and "user challenges."

CONCLUSIONS

This systematic review supports the value of digital health interventions as an acceptable and convenient approach for delivering care to pediatric cancer survivors. It is essential to understand the users' positive experiences and challenges to customize interventions and achieve positive health outcomes.

IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE

Nurses can contribute to the development and implementation of digital health interventions for pediatric cancer survivors through advocacy, navigation, feedback, and multidisciplinary collaboration. We recommended system-level support in modifying and developing relevant workflows or practice guidelines for implementation.

Palliative home-based care to pediatric cancer patients: characteristics and healthcare delivered

OBJECTIVES

Cancer patients constitute an important group in pediatric palliative care. Though the patients' home is the preferred place of care, little is known about the characteristics of patients attended by units that provide home assistance. Our objective is to describe the characteristics of cancer patients and healthcare delivered by a pediatric palliative care unit with a home hospitalization program.

METHODS

Retrospective study based on clinical records of deceased patients attended by the pediatric palliative care unit of Madrid over 10 years. Data collected included general characteristics, type of cancer, whether they received home assistance, place of death, healthcare delivered (hospitalizations, devices, oncological treatments…), and symptom prevalence.

RESULTS

After excluding 47 patients, the clinical records of 144 patients were analyzed. The median age at referral was 9.4 years (IQR: 5.6-14.1), 61.2% were males; 44.2% had solid non-CNS tumors, 35.4% CNS tumors, and 20.4% hematological malignancies; 137 received home care with 89 not requiring further hospital admissions and 70.1% dying at home. The median follow-up time was 1.6 months (IQR: 0.5-2.9). The most used devices were venous ports (71.4%) and oxygen (49.4%); 53.5% of the patients received oncological support therapies. The most common symptoms were pain (91.8%) dyspnea (49.0%) and fatigue (46.9%).

CONCLUSIONS

Home assistance was provided in a high number of patients, with a large proportion needing one or no hospital admissions and 70.1% of them dying at home. Further studies characterizing these patients and the factors which promote early access to palliative care are needed.

Pain Reported by Chinese Children During Cancer Treatment: Prevalence, Intensity, Interference, and Management

BACKGROUND

Pain is a frequently reported and distressing symptoms during cancer treatment. However, there is limited evidence on pain reported by Chinese children with cancer.

OBJECTIVES

This study aimed to investigate the prevalence, intensity, interference, and management of pain reported by Chinese children during cancer treatment and explore the predictors of pain interference.

METHODS

We conducted a cross-sectional survey to investigate the pain intensity, pain interference, co-occurring symptoms (anger, anxiety, depression, fatigue), and pain management strategies reported by children 8 years and older undergoing active cancer treatment in 4 Chinese hospitals.

RESULTS

Data were analyzed for 187 children. The prevalence of moderate to severe pain (≥4/10) was 38.50%, with an average pain interference score of 52.97 out of 100. Approximately 24% of children were prescribed pain medicine. Pain interference and pain intensity were marginally correlated (r = 0.047, P < .01) and were both positively correlated with pain duration and co-occurring symptoms and negatively correlated with perceived pain alleviation (all P < .01). Multiple regression analyses suggested that severe pain intensity (B = 2.028, P = .003) and fatigue (B = 0.440, P < .001) significantly predicted higher levels of pain interference (R2 = 0.547, F = 23.102, P < .001).

CONCLUSION

Chinese children with cancer reported a low pain intensity score but a relatively high level of pain interference. According to the children's reports, pain has not been sufficiently addressed through Chinese pediatric oncology supportive care.

IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE

There is an urgent requirement for comprehensive pain assessment and standardized, targeted interventions in Chinese pediatric oncology pain management.

A Systematic Review of Self-Report Instruments for the Measurement of Anxiety in Hospitalized Children with Cancer

Anxiety has been identified as one of the most severe and long-lasting symptoms experienced by hospitalized children with cancer. Self-reports are especially important for documenting emotional and abstract concepts, such as anxiety. Children may not always be able to communicate their symptoms due to language difficulties, a lack of developmental language skills, or the severity of their illness. Instruments with sufficient psychometric quality and pictorial support may address this communication challenge. The purpose of this review was to systematically search the published literature and identify validated and reliable self-report instruments available for children aged 5–18 years to use in the assessment of their anxiety to ensure they receive appropriate anxiety-relief intervention in hospital. What validated self-report instruments can children with cancer use to self-report anxiety in the hospital setting? Which of these instruments offer pictorial support? Eight instruments were identified, but most of the instruments lacked pictorial support. The Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) and Pediatric Quality of Life (PedsQL™) 3.0 Brain Tumor Module and Cancer Module proved to be useful in hospitalized children with cancer, as they provide pictorial support. It is recommended that faces or symbols be used along with the VAS, as pictures are easily understood by younger children. Future studies could include the adaptation of existing instruments in digital e-health tools.

The effect of digital health technologies on managing symptoms across pediatric cancer continuum: A systematic review

Objective

Pediatric cancer patients endure multiple symptoms during treatment and also in survivorship. Digital health technologies provide an innovative way to support their symptom management. This review aimed to examine the effect of digital health technologies on managing symptoms among across pediatric cancer continuum.

Methods

A systematic literature search of six English and three Chinese electronic databases was combined with hand searching, to identify eligible research studies from database establishment to November 30, 2019. Two reviewers carried out data selection, data extraction, and quality appraisal independently. A narrative approach was taken to summarize data.

Results

Four randomized control trials, two quasi-experiments, and five one group pre-posttest designed studies, were included in the review with a total of 425 participants. The methodological quality of the studies was generally fair. Seven symptoms (anxiety, depression, pain, anger, fatigue, fear, distress) and seven digital health technologies (visual reality, website, humanoid robot, app, wearable devices, short messages and videoconference) were reported in the included studies.

Conclusions

Current evidence supports the effect of digital health technologies is generally mixed and inconclusive. There is a trend of positive effects found in the interventions that feature digital health technologies' interactive function. This review highlights the need for further investigation with rigorous research designs and the consideration of influencing factors from the symptoms, participants, and context levels to inform a better digital health implementation.

Reasons for disagreement between proxy-report and self-report rating of symptoms in children receiving cancer therapies

PURPOSE

To qualitatively describe reasons for disagreement in ratings of bothersome symptoms between child self-report and parent proxy-report.

METHODS

We enrolled child and parent dyads, who understood English and where children (4-18 years of age) were diagnosed with cancer or were hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) recipients. Each child and parent separately reported symptoms using self-report or proxy-report Symptom Screening in Pediatrics Tool (SSPedi). We then used semi-structured interviews to elicit reasons for discrepancies in symptom reporting.

RESULTS

We enrolled 12 dyads in each of four age cohorts, resulting in 48 dyads. Forty-one dyads (85.4%) had disagreement in rating the presence or absence of at least one symptom. Themes identified as reasons for disagreement included (1) perception, differing perception of symptom or availability or palatability of intervention; (2) understanding, difficulty orienting to time frame or concept of bother; (3) lack of communication, including child not acknowledging or talking about experiences; (4) projection, of how the parent felt or how they assumed the child would feel; and (5) discrepancy, in how the amount of symptom bother that was initially reported on SSPedi, by either child or parent, did not align with what was reported during the dyad discussion.

CONCLUSION

We identified themes that explained disagreement in ratings of bothersome symptoms between child self-report and parent proxy-report. Some disagreement may be reduced by enhancing communication about symptom reporting between child and parent. Future research should focus on methods of symptom screening that encourage communication between children with cancer and their caregivers.

Determining the Effectiveness of Using Patient-Reported Outcomes in Pediatric Clinical Practices

PROBLEM

Patient-reported outcomes (PROs) are increasingly recognized in pediatric clinical care as adding essential information relevant to actual care. However, the effectiveness of using PROs in pediatric clinical settings has not been fully explored with synthesized evidence. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of using patient-reported outcomes in pediatric clinical practices.

ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA

We searched four English and three Chinese databases to identify studies that examine the effectiveness of using PROs in pediatric clinical practices published from the inception date of each database to January 2020.

SAMPLE

Ten articles met the inclusion criteria.

RESULTS

There was wide a variation in the ten studies' designs, samples, PROs administered (type, length, timing, mode), and type of outcomes evaluated. The effect sizes of using PROs on three categories of outcomes (patient, process of care and health service) were assessed. Of 70 measured outcomes, 32 were positive, 5 were negative, and 33 were mixed.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, there is a weak but trending positive impact of using PROs in pediatric clinical practice.

IMPLICATIONS

More rigorous study designs with sources of bias controlled are needed to more directly assess the impact of using PROs in pediatric care. If findings continue to be positive, then an implementation model addressing the numerous influencing factors is recommended to integrate PROs into pediatric care.

Discordance between pediatric self-report and parent proxy-report symptom scores and creation of a dyad symptom screening tool (co-SSPedi)

Symptom Screening in Pediatrics Tool (SSPedi) (age 8-18 years) and mini-SSPedi (age 4-7 years) can be used to self-report and proxy-report bothersome symptoms in pediatric patients receiving cancer treatments. There are limitations of sole child self-report or proxy-report. An approach in which children and parents complete symptom reports together may be useful. The aim of our study was to describe discordance between child self-report and parent proxy-report symptom scores, and to determine how these scores compare to an approach in which reporting is performed together (co-SSPedi). Children and parents completed SSPedi or mini-SSPedi separately. Discordant symptoms were shared with respondents and discussed. Next, the dyad completed co-SSPedi together and were asked which approach they preferred. Discordance was evaluated for each symptom and was defined as a difference of at least 2 points on an ordinal scale ranging from 0 (not at all bothered) to 4 (extremely bothered). Of the 48 enrolled dyads (children, median age, 10.8 years; 54.2% male), 41 (85.4%) had discordance in at least one symptom. There was no clear pattern in discordance by age group. When a dyad approach was used, more co-SSPedi scores agreed with the original child self-report scores (59 dyads, 56.2%) compared to original parent proxy-report scores (15 dyads, 14.3%) for discordant symptoms. Forty-three (89.6%) dyads preferred to complete SSPedi together. Future work should evaluate the psychometric properties of co-SSPedi.