Effects of ferrous sulfate amendment and water management on rice growth and metal(loid) accumulation in arsenic and lead co-contaminated soil

How Fe-bearing materials affect soil arsenic bioavailability to rice: A meta-analysis

Arsenic (As) contamination is widespread in soil and poses a threat to agricultural products and human health due to its high susceptibility to absorption by rice. Fe-bearing materials (Fe-Mat) display significant potential for reducing As bioavailability in soil and bioaccumulation in rice. However, the remediation effect of various Fe-Mat is often inconsistent, and the response to diverse environmental factors is ambiguous. Here, we conducted a meta-analysis to quantitatively assess the effects of As in soils, rice roots, and grains based on 673, 321, and 305 individual observations from 67 peer-reviewed articles, respectively. On average, Fe-Mat reduced As bioavailability in soils, rice roots, and grains by 28.74 %, 33.48 %, and 44.61 %, respectively. According to the analysis of influencing factors, the remediation efficiency of Fe-Mat on As-contaminated soil was significantly enhanced with increasing Fe content in the material, in which the industry byproduct was the most effective in soils (-42.31 %) and rice roots (-44.57 %), while Fe-biochar was superior in rice grains (-54.62 %). The efficiency of Fe-Mat in minimizing soil As mobility was negatively correlated with soil Fe content, CEC, and pH. In addition, applying Fe-Mat in alkaline soils with higher silt, lower clay and available P was more effective in reducing As in rice grains. A higher efficiency of applying Fe-Mat under continuous flooding conditions (27.39 %) compared with alternate wetting and drying conditions (23.66 %) was also identified. Our results offer an important reference for the development of remediation strategies and methods for various As-contaminated paddy soils.

Silica sources for arsenic mitigation in rice: machine learning-based predictive modeling and risk assessment

Arsenic (As) is a well-known human carcinogen, and the consumption of rice is the main pathway for the South Asian people. The study evaluated the impact of the amendments involving CaSiO3, SiO2 nanoparticles, silica solubilizing bacteria (SSB), and rice straw compost (RSC) on mitigation of As toxicity in rice. The translocation of As from soil to cooked rice was tracked, and the results showed that RSC and its combination with SSB were the most effective in reducing As loading in rice grain by 53.2%. To determine the risk of dietary exposure to As, the average daily intake (ADI), hazard quotient (HQ), and incremental lifetime cancer risk (ILCR) were computed. The study observed that the ADI was reduced to one-third (0.24 μg kg-1bw) under RSC+SSB treatments compared to the control. An effective prediction model was established using random forest model and described the accumulation of As by rice grains depend on bioavailable As, P, and Fe which explained 48.5, 5.07%, and 2.6% of the variation in the grain As, respectively. The model anticipates that to produce As benign rice grain, soil should have P and Fe concentration more than 30 mg kg-1 and 12 mg kg-1, respectively if soil As surpasses 2.5 mg kg-1.

Microbial communities in paddy soils: differences in abundance and functionality between rhizosphere and pore water, the influence of different soil organic carbon, sulfate fertilization and cultivation time, and contribution to arsenic mobility and speciation

Abiotic factors and rhizosphere microbial populations influence arsenic accumulation in rice grains. Although mineral and organic surfaces are keystones in element cycling, localization of specific microbial reactions in the root/soil/pore water system is still unclear. Here, we tested if original unplanted soil, rhizosphere soil and pore water represented distinct ecological microniches for arsenic-, sulfur- and iron-cycling microorganisms and compared the influence of relevant factors such as soil type, sulfate fertilization and cultivation time. In rice open-air-mesocosms with two paddy soils (2.0% and 4.7% organic carbon), Illumina 16S rRNA gene sequencing demonstrated minor effects of cultivation time and sulfate fertilization that decreased Archaea-driven microbial networks and incremented sulfate-reducing and sulfur-oxidizing bacteria. Different compartments, characterized by different bacterial and archaeal compositions, had the strongest effect, with higher microbial abundances, bacterial biodiversity and interconnections in the rhizosphere vs pore water. Within each compartment, a significant soil type effect was observed. Higher percentage contributions of rhizosphere dissimilatory arsenate- and iron-reducing, arsenite-oxidizing, and, surprisingly, dissimilatory sulfate-reducing bacteria, as well as pore water iron-oxidizing bacteria in the lower organic carbon soil, supported previous chemistry-based interpretations of a more active S-cycling, a higher percentage of thioarsenates and lower arsenic mobility by sorption to mixed Fe(II)Fe(III)-minerals in this soil.

Microwave-enhanced simultaneous immobilization of lead and arsenic in a field soil using ferrous sulfate

Remediation of soil contaminated by mixed heavy metals and metalloids has been a major challenge in the global environmental field. To address this critical issue, we tested a new technology for simultaneous immobilization of lead (Pb) and arsenic (As) in a field contaminated soil using a microwave-assisted FeSO₄·7H₂O treatment process. The process was able to rapidly reduce the TCLP-based leachability of Pb from 12.74 to 0.1 mg L^-1 and As from 2.704 to 0.002 mg L^-1 (MW power = 800 W, Irradiation time = 20 min, and FeSO₄·7H₂O = 4 wt%). The effects of FeSO₄·7H₂O dosage, microwave power, and irradiation time were determined and optimized. After 365 days of curing under atmospheric conditions, the TCLP-leached concentration of Pb and As in the treated soil remained below the regulatory limits of 0.1 and 0.002 mg L^-1, respectively. The microwave irradiation promoted the formation of insoluble PbSO₄(s) and Fe₃(AsO₄)₂·8H₂O(s), resulting in the long-term stability of Pb and As in the soil. The technology offers an effective alternative for remediation of Pb- and/or As-contaminated soil and groundwater.

An insight into the act of iron to impede arsenic toxicity in paddy agro-system

Surplus research on the widespread arsenic (As) revealed its disturbing role in obstructing the metabolic function of plants. Also, the predilection of As towards rice has been an interesting topic. Contrary to As, iron (Fe) is an essential micronutrient for all life forms. Past findings propound about the enhanced As-resistance in rice plants during Fe supplementation. Thus, considering the severity of As contamination and resulting exposure through rice crops, as well as the studied cross-talks between As and Fe, we found this topic of relevance. Keeping these in view, we bring this review discussing the presence of As-Fe in the paddy environment, the criticality of Fe plaque in As sequestration, and the effectiveness of various Fe forms to overcome As toxicity in rice. This type of interactive analysis for As and Fe is also crucial in the context of the involvement of Fe in cellular redox activities such as oxidative stress. Also, this piece of work highlights Fe biofortification approaches for better rice varieties with optimum intrinsic Fe and limited As. Though elaborated by others, we lastly present the acquisition and transport mechanisms of both As and Fe in rice tissues. Altogether we suggest that Fe supply and Fe plaque might be a prospective agronomical tool against As poisoning and for phytostabilization, respectively.

The risks of sulfur addition on cadmium accumulation in paddy rice under different water-management conditions

Recently, the application of sulfur (S) has been recommended to control the accumulation of cadmium (Cd) in rice in contaminated paddy soil. However, the effects of exogenous S on Cd transfer in paddy rice systems under different water-management practices have not been systematically investigated. Pot experiments were performed to monitor the composition of soil pore water and the Cd accumulation in iron plaque and rice tissue were compared under different S (0 and 200 mg/kg Na₂SO₄) and water (continuous and discontinuous flooding) treatments. Sulfur application significantly increased Cd concentrations in soil pore water under discontinuous flooding conditions, but slightly reduced them under continuous flooding. Moreover, the oxidation/reduction potential (Eh) was the most critical factor that affected the Cd levels. When the Eh exceeded -42.5 mV, S became the second critical factor, and excessive S application promoted Cd dissolution. In addition, S addition elevated the Cd levels in iron plaque and reduced the Cd transfer from the iron plaque to rice roots. In rice, S addition inhibited Cd transfer from the rice roots to the straw; thus, more Cd was stored in the rice roots. Nevertheless, additional S application increased the Cd content in the rice grains by 72% under discontinuous flooding, although this effect was mitigated by continued flooding. Under simulated practical water management conditions, S addition increased the risk of Cd contamination in rice, suggesting that S application should be reconsidered as a paddy fertilization strategy.

Effect of sulfate application on inhibition of arsenic bioaccumulation in rice (Oryza sativa L.) with consequent health risk assessment of cooked rice arsenic on human: A pot to plate study

Arsenic (As) in rice is posing a serious threat worldwide and consumption of As contaminated rice by human is causing health risks. A pot experiment with different levels of sulfate dosage (0, 20, 40, 60 and 80 mg/kg) was set up in this study to explore the influence of sulfate fertilizer on rice plant growth, yield, and As accumulation in rice grain. Apart from As bioaccumulation in rice grains, the As fraction of cooked rice was quantified, and the health risks associated with cooked rice consumption were also investigated. The sulfate application significantly (p ≤ 0.05) enhanced the chlorophyll, tiller number, grains per panicle, grain and biomass yield under As stressed condition. The sulfate application also reduced the oxidative stress and antioxidant activity in rice plants. Sulfate fertigation improved the accumulation of total sulfur (S) and reduced the uptake and translocation of As in rice plants. Arsenic concentration in rice grain was reduced by 50.1% in S80 treatment (80 mg of sulfate/kg of soil) as compared to S0 set. The reduction percentage of As in cooked parboiled and sunned rice with correspond to raw rice ranged from 55.9 to 74% and 40.3-60.7%, respectively. However, the sulfate application and cooking of parboiled rice reduced the potential non-cancer and cancer risk as compared to sunned rice. The S80 treatment and cooking of parboiled rice reduce the As exposure for both children and adults by 51% as compared to cooked sunned rice under S80 treatment and this trend was similar for all treatments. Therefore, sulfate application in soil can be recommended to produce safer rice grains and subsequent cooking of parboiled rice grain with low-As contaminated water need to be done to avoid any potential health risk in As endemic areas.

Novel agricultural waste-based materials decrease the uptake and accumulation of cadmium by rice (Oryza sativa L.) in contaminated paddy soils

Heavy metal pollution in paddy fields has caused widespread concerns due to the threat to food safety. The present study used low-cost sugarcane bagasse (SB) and two sugarcane bagasse materials modified with citric-acid (SSB) and citric-acid/Fe₃O₄ (MSB) to investigate their effects on the bioavailability of Cd in soil and Cd accumulations in rice in a pot experiment. The three organic amendments significantly decreased the Cd accumulation in plants by limiting its mobilization in soil. The MSB and SSB but not SB increased the soil pH and immobilized the Cd in soil significantly during the 120-day experiment. The amendments decreased Cd bioavailability through transforming to the stable fraction throughout the whole growth stage. The functional groups in the amendments (-OH, -COOH, C-O, -COO^- and Fe-O) and precipitates [Cd(NO₂)₂K(NO₂)₂, Cd(OH)₂ and Cd₇₅Zn₂₅Fe₂O₄] played active roles in Cd immobilization. Moreover, the three organic materials increased the content of Fe-Mn plaque on rice roots, which prevented its transport from soil to rice roots further. We also found that Fe competed with Cd for transporters and reduced potential Cd uptake and translocation in rice tissues. The addition of MSB and SB but not SSB inhibited the rice growth compared to the unamended control, indicating the potential of SSB in situ remediation. These results provide valuable information to use organic amendments for Cd passivation in soil and food safety.

Water management of alternate wetting and drying combined with phosphate application reduced lead and arsenic accumulation in rice

Lead (Pb) and arsenic (As) exist in soil with different ionic forms, and it is difficult to immobilize simultaneously Pb and As in soil. The objective of this study is to determine the effects of water management including flooding (FL), alternate wetting and drying (AWD) and dry farming (DF) combined with addition of phosphate (P) on the accumulation of Pb and As in rice. Our results showed that Pb accumulated in root during vegetative stage, and most of As in root was transported to the above ground parts during the reproductive stage. Pb was evenly distributed in grains, and As was mostly accumulated in bran and aleurone layer. Water management had a reverse effect on the accumulation of Pb and As in rice. However, the effects of P on arid soil environment and Pb, As accumulation in rice were stronger than that in flooded soil. Application of P under AWD treatment could maintain a similar quantity of Fe plaque with flooding, decrease the availability of Pb in rhizosphere soil, reduce Pb and As accumulation in root, and result in the reduction of Pb and As accumulation in grains by 86% and 66% respectively. Besides, our study also found that flooding or AWD during vegetative stage facilitated the formation of iron plaque. In conclusion, AWD combined with P application could maintain a relatively lower concentrations of Pb and As in grains.

Arsenic transfer and accumulation in the soil-rice system with sulfur application and different water managements

Rice (Oryza sativa L.) can readily accumulate arsenic (As), owing to its high capacity to take up As and special flooding cultivation, which poses a potential risk to human health. Although sulfur (S) can influence As accumulation in rice, its behavior in the rice-soil system is not clear under practical water management conditions. In this study, the transfer and soil solution dynamics of As in the whole soil-rice system was investigated under continuous flooding or intermittent drainage, either with S addition or not. The results showed that intermittent drainage effectively reduced As concentration in soil solution regardless of S conditions, and it only reduced As content in rice without S addition. Exogenous S decreased As concentration in soil solution and rice, except in the roots of mature rice, under continuous flooding. Sulfur addition significantly decreased the total As and As(III) contents in rice grains, by 62% and 79% under continuous flooding and by 50% and 76% under intermittent drainage, respectively. Moreover, the addition of S resulted in impaired iron plaque and inhibited binding of As. Sulfur also reduced As translocation from rice roots to shoots. Therefore, S could alleviate the crisis of excessive accumulation of As in rice grains caused by flooded environment through various adjustments to the soil-rice system.

Effects of carbide slag, lodestone and biochar on the immobilization, plant uptake and translocation of As and Cd in a contaminated paddy soil

The contamination of arsenic (As) and cadmium (Cd) in paddy soils is widely reported and these two metals are difficult to be co-remediated due to the contrasting chemical behaviors. This poses a challenge to simultaneously decrease their availability in soil and accumulation in rice via immobilization by amendments, especially in in-situ fields. This study compared the effects of carbide slag, lodestone and biochar on the bioavailability of As and Cd in soil and their accumulation in rice tissues and root Fe-Mn plaque at tillering and mature stages in a paddy field. The addition of three amendments significantly limited the mobilization of As and Cd in soil and decreased their accumulations in brown rice by 30-52% and 9-21%, respectively. Carbide slag was most whereas lodestone least effective in As and Cd immobilization in the tested contaminated soils. Community Bureau of Reference (BCR) sequential extraction analysis showed that the amendments changed the forms of As and Cd to less-available. Activated functional groups of the amendments (e.g. -OH, C-O, OC-O, OH^- and CO₃^2-) sequestered metals by precipitation, adsorption, ion exchange or electrostatic attributes contributed greatly to the As and Cd immobilization in soil. Furthermore, the amendments promoted the formation of Fe-Mn plaque in rice roots, which further limited the mobility of As and Cd in soil and prevented their transport from soil to rice roots. The application of carbide slag and biochar but not lodestone increased rice yield compared to the unamended control, indicating their applicability in situ remediation. Our study gives a strong reference to select immobilizing amendments for food safe production in co-contaminated paddy soils.

The response of arsenic bioavailability and microbial community in paddy soil with the application of sulfur fertilizers

Arsenic (As) has been recognized as one of the most toxic metalloids present in the surface soil contaminating food chain and posing threat to human life. Sulfur (S) fertilizer is often supplied in paddy soil for rice growth, but its impact on As mobility and related bacteria remains poorly understood. In this study, a pot experiment was set up with two different types of sulfur treatments (element sulfur and Na₂SO₄) to evaluate the effect of sulfur fertilizers on As speciation in porewater, As fractions in soil, As accumulation in rice plants. Besides, rhizosphere bacterial composition and functional genes that might influence As mobility were also studied. The results revealed that the addition of 150 mg/kg Na₂SO₄ decreased As(III) and As(V) concentrations in soil porewater at maturation stage by 77% and 64%, respectively. With the same sulfur content, Na₂SO₄ was more effective than element sulfur. The addition of sulfur fertilizers promoted rice growth and reduced As accumulation in shoots, further reduced As translocation from root to above-ground parts by 39-59%. The addition of sulfur fertilizers had little effect on genes involved in As metabolism. However, the relative abundance of Fe(III) and sulfate reduction related genera increased with the addition of 150 mg/kg Na₂SO₄, consistent with the increase of Fe(III) reducing bacteria Geobacteraceae and sulfate reducing gene dsrA. The phenomenon likely influenced the decrease of As concentrations in soil porewater and rice uptake. The outcomes indicate that promoting Fe- and S- reducing bacteria in the rhizosphere by sulfur fertilizers may be one way to reduce As risk in the soil-rice system.

Simultaneous immobilization of the cadmium, lead and arsenic in paddy soils amended with titanium gypsum

In situ immobilization of heavy metals in contaminated soils using industrial by-products is an attractive remediation technique. In this work, titanium gypsum (TG) was applied at two levels (TG-L: 0.15% and TG-H: 0.30%) to simultaneously reduce the uptake of cadmium (Cd), lead (Pb) and arsenic (As) in rice grown in heavy metal contaminated paddy soils. The results showed that the addition of TG significantly decreased the pH and dissolved organic carbon (DOC) in the bulk soil. TG addition significantly improved the rice plants growth and reduced the bioavailability of Cd, Pb and As. Particularly, bioavailable Cd, Pb and As decreased by 35.2%, 38.1% and 38.0% in TG-H treatment during the tillering stage, respectively. Moreover, TG application significantly reduced the accumulation of Cd, Pb and As in brown rice. Real-time PCR analysis demonstrated that the relative abundance of sulfate-reducing bacteria increased with the TG application, but not for the iron-reducing bacteria. In addition, 16S rRNA sequencing analysis revealed that the relative abundances of heavy metal-resistant bacteria such as Bacillus, Sulfuritalea, Clostridium, Sulfuricella, Geobacter, Nocardioides and Sulfuricurvum at the genus level significantly increased with the TG addition. In conclusion, the present study implied that TG is a potential and effective amendment to immobilize metal(loid)s in soil and thereby reduce the exposure risk of metal(loid)s associated with rice consumption.

The bioavailability and contribution of the newly deposited heavy metals (copper and lead) from atmosphere to rice (Oryza sativa L.)

Despite the global importance of atmospheric heavy metal input into agricultural soils, research has primarily focused on the amount of the depositions with limited attention given to the risk of the newly deposited heavy metals. To understand the remobilization of the newly deposited copper (Cu) and lead (Pb) from the atmosphere and explore the metals' mobility and bioavailability to rice (Oryza sativa L.), a soil transplant experiment was conducted in three areas along a gradient of atmospheric depositions. Approximately 61% of the Cu and 76% of the Pb depositions tended to be present in potentially mobile fractions. The soil retention of newly deposited Cu and Pb presented as higher mobile fractions than these in the original soil. The newly deposited Cu and Pb in soils only accounted for 0.34-8.7% and 0.07-0.29% of the total soil Cu and Pb pools, but they contributed 30-84% and 6-41% in rice tissues, respectively. A major implication of these findings is that once the heavy metal is deposited, it may be reactivated in soils and transported to aerial parts or foliar uptake into plant tissues, emphasizing the important role of the newly deposited Cu and Pb in contributing to the edible parts of crops.

Combined Effect of Ferrous Ion and Biochar on Cadmium and Arsenic Accumulation in Rice

Excessive accumulation of cadmium (Cd) and arsenic (As) in rice (Oryza sativa L.) poses a potential health risk to populations. Cd and As exhibit opposite geochemical behavior in paddy soil, using appropriate remediation materials to reduce their migration and inhibit their uptake by rice is a great challenge. A pot culture experiment was conducted to investigate the effects of application of silkworm excrement biochar (BC) and ferrous sulfate (Fe(II)) on available Cd and As in paddy soils and their uptake by rice. Results showed that the application of BC + Fe significantly accelerated the tillering of rice plants, and the addition of BC alone to soil did not have a significant effect on the pH of soil, while applied 1% (w/w) BC and 1% (w/w) Fe(II) (1BC-1 Fe(II)) treatment could markedly reduce the soil pH. BC+Fe(II) could reduce the content of available Cd (reduced by 10%–23%) and As (reduced by 6%–33%) in soil. BC+Fe(II) has a distinct decreasing effect on the available As, thus inhibiting As uptake in rice tissues, and the effect was more obvious with an increasing mass ratio of Fe in BC+Fe(II) treatment. BC+Fe(II) decreased bioaccumulation factors (BF) of As compared to control and BC alone treatments. Compared with As, Cd was more readily transferred from the root to the shoot and accumulated in rice eventually. These findings provide a safe and reliable remediation strategy though application of BC+Fe(II) in Cd and As co-contaminated soil. However, the improvement effect of amendments should be paid a special attention on soil pH.

Facets of iron in arsenic exposed Oryza sativa varieties: A manifestation of plant's adjustment at morpho-biochemical and enzymatic levels☆

Rice consumption is one of the primary sources of arsenic (As) exposure as the grains contain relatively higher concentration of inorganic As. Abundant studies on the ability of iron (Fe) plaque in hampering As uptake by plants has been reported earlier. However, little is known about its role in the mitigation of As mediated oxidative damage in rice plants. The present study highlights the effect of As and Fe co-supplementation on growth response, oxidative stress, Fe uptake related enzymes and nutrient status in rice varieties. Eight different Indica rice varieties were screened and finally four varieties (Varsha, Jaya, PB-1 and IR-64) were selected for detailed investigations. Improved germination and chlorophyll/protein levels during As+Fe co-exposure indicate healthier plants than As(III) treated ones. Interestingly Fe was found act both as an antagonist and also as a synergist of As treatments. It acted by reducing As translocation and improving the nutritional levels and enhancing the oxidative stress. Fe uptake related enzymes (nitrite reductase and ferric chelate reductase) and phytosiderophores analysis revealed that Fe supplementation can reduce its deficiency in rice plants. Morpho-biochemical, oxidative stress and nutrient analysis symbolizes higher tolerance of PB-1 towards As, while Varsha being most sensitive, efficiently combated the As(III) stress in the presence of Fe.

Lead toxicity in plants: Impacts and remediation

Lead (Pb) is the second most toxic heavy metal after arsenic (As), which has no role in biological systems. Pb toxicity causes a range of damages to plants from germination to yield formation; however, its toxicity is both time and concentration dependent. Its exposure at higher rates disturbs the plant water and nutritional relations and causes oxidative damages to plants. Reduced rate of seed germination and plant growth under stress is mainly due to Pb interference with enzymatic activities, membrane damage and stomatal closure because of induction of absicic acid and negative correlation of Pb with potassium in plants. Pb induced structural changes in photosynthetic apparatus and reduced biosynthesis of chlorophyll pigments cause retardation of carbon metabolism. In this review, the noxious effects of Pb on germination, stand establishment, growth, water relations, nutrient uptake and assimilation, ultra-structural and oxidative damages, carbon metabolism and enzymatic activities in plants are reported. The Pb dynamics in soil rhizosphere and role of remediation strategies i.e. physical, chemical and biological to decontaminate the Pb polluted soils has also been described. Among them, biological strategies, including phytoremediation, microbe-assisted remediation and remediation by organic amendments, are cost effective and environmentally sound remedies for cleaning Pb contaminated soils. Use of organic manures and some agricultural practices have the potential to harvest better crops yield of good quality form Pb contaminated soils.

The stability of Fe(III)-As(V) co-precipitate in the presence of ascorbic acid: Effect of pH and Fe/As molar ratio

The potential hazards of Fe(III)-As(V) co-precipitate under reducing conditions are incompletely known. This work investigated the effect of Fe(III) reduction by ascorbic acid (AH₂) on the stability of Fe(III)-As(V) co-precipitate at different pHs and Fe/As molar ratios. The results showed that As (14-98.9%) and Fe (27.9-99.3%) were significantly released into solution by 79.9-97.5% Fe(III) reduction of the co-precipitate (Fe/As molar ratios of 3 and 5) at pH 5-9. More As release was observed with the increase of pH (6-9) or decrease in Fe/As molar ratio (from 5 to 3). This could be attributed by oxalate, the final product of AH₂ decomposition, which strongly competed with As(V) for Fe(II) at higher pH or lower Fe/As molar ratio, inhibiting parasymplesite accumulation and then causing more As mobilization. The stability of Fe(III)-As(V) co-precipitate with AH₂ upon Fe(III) reduction was lower than that in oxic environment. Compared with produced Fe(II,III) (hydr)oxides in the presence of hydroquinone (QH₂), humboldtine was formed during the long-term reactions of Fe(III)-As(V) co-precipitate with AH₂. The findings of this study implied that parasymplesite and humboldtine as secondary solid products were environmental relevant and mainly responsible for As(V) and Fe(II) immobilization.