Hybrid central odontogenic fibroma with giant cell granuloma-like component: case report and review of literature

Hybrid odontogenic lesions: A systematic review of 203 cases reported in the literature

BACKGROUND

Hybrid odontogenic lesions combine histopathological characteristics of two or more odontogenic cysts and/or tumours. The aim of this study was to evaluate the available data on hybrid odontogenic lesions (HOL) and to analyse their epidemiological/clinical features and biological behaviour.

METHODS

An electronic search was done in January 2021 using multiple databases. Eligibility criteria encompassed publications with sufficient clinical and histological information to confirm the tumours' diagnoses.

RESULTS

A total of 147 articles were included in this study, comprising 203 cases. Calcifying odontogenic cyst associated with odontoma (COC/OD) (37/18.2%) was the most common HOL. Females were more affected with a mean age of 24.9 years. Lesions presented as asymptomatic swellings, with a mean evolution time of 8.2 months (0.3-96), and mean tumour size of 4.8 cm (0.3-7). Radiographic aspects frequently showed radiolucent (139/68.4%) and unilocular (52/25.6%) images with well-defined limits (48/23.6%). The lesions mostly affected mandibular pre-molars (69/34%) and mandibular molars (69/34%) regions. Enucleation (89/43.8%) and surgical excision (59/29%) were the most common treatment modalities. The mean follow-up time was 33.8 months (0.5-216 months) and recurrences were observed in four cases (1.9%), all of which were central odontogenic fibroma associated with central giant cell granuloma (COF/CGCG).

CONCLUSION

COC/OD is the most common HOL and recurrence is a rare event, being usually associated with the diagnosis of COF/CGCG.

Central odontogenic fibroma in association with brown tumor of hyperparathyroidism in a patient with neurofibromatosis type 1

We present a patient with bone abnormalities and a myriad of lesions secondary to his redeveloping renal failure and neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1). A 21-year-old male renal transplant recipient with NF1 presented with painless masses and large, irregular radiolucent lesions in the maxilla and mandible. After histologic examination, the lesion was diagnosed as a central odontogenic fibroma (COdF) in association with a central giant cell lesion, most consistent with brown tumor of hyperparathyroidism. The bone changes were interpreted to be highly suggestive of renal osteodystrophy. Around 30 cases of hybrid central giant cell granuloma-like lesion in association with central odontogenic fibroma have been reported. This, to our knowledge, is the first reported case of brown tumor in association with COdF. Our case provides further evidence of the giant cell component as the initiating entity in these hybrid lesions.

A systematic review of the clinical and radiographic features of hybrid central giant cell granuloma lesions of the jaws

OBJECTIVE

Central giant cell granuloma (CGCG) can coexist with other benign lesions of the jaw. These hybrid lesions are diagnostically challenging to both oral pathologists and radiologists. This work systematically reviews the clinical and radiographic features of hybrid-CGCG lesions in the jaws.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Three reviewers conducted an electronic search of five databases for histologically diagnosed hybrid-CGCG lesions in human jaws.

RESULTS

Thirty-four of 1224 articles met the inclusion criteria. Of 39 hybrid-CGCG lesions, 14 (35.9%) were central odontogenic fibroma, 11 (28.2%) were central ossifying fibroma, seven (17.9%) were fibrous dysplasia, and seven (17.9%) were other bone conditions. There were 22 females and 17 males with a mean age of 30.5 ± 19.9 years. 89.5% of hybrid-CGCG lesions were well defined, 57.9% were non-corticated, 60.5% were radiolucent, and 66.7% were in the posterior mandible. Most hybrid lesions affected the cortical plates by thinning, expansion, or perforation (93.1%), displaced, or resorbed teeth (60%).

CONCLUSION

The radiographic features of hybrid-CGCG lesions vary according to the concurrent bony lesion. Hybrid-CGCG lesions altered the radiographic appearance with the following entities: fibrous dysplasia, melorheostosis, and Paget's disease. Optimal imaging modalities are crucial to detail radiographic features and direct representative biopsy of suspicious sites that may host a CGCG hybridisation.

Central Odontogenic Fibroma with Giant Cell Granuloma-Like Lesion: A Report of an Additional Case and Review of Literature

Central odontogenic fibroma is a rare benign odontogenic tumor that relies on clinical-radiographic-histological correlation to reach its diagnosis, especially its rare variants. Of these rare types is the coexistence of giant cell granuloma-like lesion, with the characteristic odontogenic epithelial rests. The presented case is a 33 years old female complaining of asymptomatic mandibular bony swelling. Radiographically, the lesion is unilocular radiolucent, without root resorption. Histological examination revealed the presence of multinucleated giant cells within the diagnosed central odontogenic fibroma. Immunohistochemical staining highlighted the presence of both components.

Hybrid Central Odontogenic Fibroma with Giant Cell Granuloma like Lesion: A Report of Three Additional Cases and Review of the Literature

Central odontogenic fibroma (COF) is an uncommon intraosseous neoplasm of the gnathic bones which is composed of fibrous connective tissue, with or without calcifications, and variable amounts of inactive odontogenic epithelium. It makes up less than 5% of odontogenic tumors and is more commonly seen in females. Central giant cell granuloma (CGCG) is a locally destructive but benign lesion of the jaws containing osteoclast-like multinucleated giant cells in a fibrovascular stroma. CGCG makes up approximately 10% of all benign jaw tumors and typically occurs in females younger than 30 years of age. A hybrid lesion with histologic features of both COF and CGCG is very rare and was first described in 1992. To date, fewer than 50 cases of this lesion have been reported. In this study, we present three additional cases of COF developing in conjunction with giant cell granuloma-like lesion, as well as provide a comprehensive literature review. Two of the lesions presented in our study were located in the posterior mandible and one occurred in the anterior mandible. Buccal and/or lingual expansion was noted in two patients and no recurrence was reported. Histologically, all three lesions demonstrated a blend of odontogenic epithelial islands with numerous multinucleated giant cells in a highly cellular connective tissue stroma. Immunohistochemical staining with CK19 and CD68 highlighted the odontogenic epithelium and multinucleated giant cells respectively. The precise nature of these hybrid lesions remains obscure and additional molecular studies may be of help in understanding their pathogenesis.

Clinicopathologic and Molecular Characteristics of Familial Cherubism with Associated Odontogenic Tumorous Proliferations

Cherubism is a rare autosomal dominant condition affecting the jaws and caused by mutations in the gene encoding for the adapter protein SH3BP2 that maps to chromosome 4p16.3. Cherubism is characterized by symmetrically developing bone lesions in the maxilla and mandible. The lesions have been radiographically and histopathologically well-described. Here, we present a family with cherubism with two of its members featuring odontogenic tumorous proliferations in association with persistent central giant cell lesions (CGCL). Specifically, the proband, a 25-year-old male, developed a radiolucent lesion characterized histologically by central odontogenic fibroma-like proliferation in association with a CGCL component, while his mother, at age 57, was diagnosed with primary intraosseous odontogenic carcinoma with areas of benign fibro-osseous lesions. In both patients the lesions occurred in the anterior mandible and presented with clinical enlargement. The son underwent incisional biopsy and did not have additional treatment. His mother underwent extensive mandibulectomy due to widespread tumor. The son has two affected children with classic cherubism while a third child at age 5, had not shown any features of the disease. Mutation analysis of three affected members resulted in the identification of a heterozygous mutation in SH3BP2 (c.1244G>C; p.Arg415Pro). To the best of our knowledge, association of cherubism with odontogenic neoplastic lesions has hitherto not been reported in the literature, thus suggesting a relationship between cherubism with disturbed odontogenesis.

Collision lesion of mandible--coexistence of keratocystic odontogenic tumor with central giant cell granuloma: a rare case report

AIM AND BACKGROUND

An odontogenic keratocyst (OKC) or keratocystic odontogenic tumor (KCOT) and giant cell granuloma (GCG) in the jaws are common lesions which have been studied extensively in detail over the years. However, a lesion showing features of both is exceptionally rare and is reported only twice in the literature till date.

CASE DESCRIPTION

A rare case of OKC in mandible showing foci of GCG like areas is reported in a 29 years old male patient.

CONCLUSION

It seems to be a collision lesion, though the possibility of KCOT showing a reactive response to form giant cells or it being a rare variant cannot be totally ruled out.

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE

This entity requires aggressive treatment since biological behavior of this unique lesion is difficult to predict unless more of such lesions are reported and followed up in future.