State-of-the-art review and bibliometric analysis on electro-Fenton process

Recent progress in electro-Fenton technology for the remediation of pharmaceutical compounds in aqueous environments

The global focus on wastewater treatment has intensified in the contemporary era due to its significant environmental and human health impacts. Pharmaceutical compounds (PCs) have become an emerging concern among various pollutants, as they resist conventional treatment methods and pose a severe environmental threat. Advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) emerge as a potent and environmentally benign approach for treating recalcitrant pharmaceuticals. To address the shortcomings of traditional treatment methods, a technology known as the electro-Fenton (EF) method has been developed more recently as an electrochemical advanced oxidation process (EAOP) that connects electrochemistry to the chemical Fenton process. It has shown effective in treating a variety of pharmaceutically active compounds and actual wastewaters. By producing H2O2 in situ through a two-electron reduction of dissolved O2 on an appropriate cathode, the EF process maximizes the benefits of electrochemistry. Herein, we have critically reviewed the application of the EF process, encompassing diverse reactor types and configurations, the underlying mechanisms involved in the degradation of pharmaceuticals and other emerging contaminants (ECs), and the impact of electrode materials on the process. The review also addresses the factors influencing the efficiency of the EF process, such as (i) pH, (ii) current density, (iii) H2O2 concentration, (iv) and others, while providing insight into the scalability potential of EF technology and its commercialization on a global scale. The review delves into future perspectives and implications concerning the ongoing challenges encountered in the operation of the electro-Fenton process for the treatment of PCs and other ECs.

Recovery capacity of constructed wetlands in response to multiple disturbances: Microbial interaction perspective

Previous studies have predominantly explored the response mechanisms of constructed wetlands (CWs) to singular disturbances. In practical applications, CWs are frequently subject to multiple disturbances, resulting in complex interference mechanisms. Therefore, this study aims to select harmful algal blooms and microalga ZM-5 as disturbances to investigate the response mechanisms of CWs. Results revealed a dynamic pattern in COD removal efficiency of CWs, with fluctuations at 39.0 ± 6.2 % and 80.1 ± 4.7 % during the disturbances, followed by a recovery to approximately 65.7 ± 3.2 %. Additionally, the CWs exhibited a capacity for self-recovery and enhanced stability by selectively promoting specific microbial communities through the regulation of the genes responsible for indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) and vitamin production. Importantly, this study underscored the establishment of a resilient microbial community structure within CWs following multiple disturbances, characterized by a more interconnected microbial network. These findings shed light on the adaptive mechanisms of CWs in the face of complex environmental challenges.

Selective SERS Detection of TATB Explosives Based on Hydroxy-Terminal Nanodiamond-Multilayer Graphene Substrate

Selective surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) detection of target explosives with good reproducibility is very important for monitoring soldiers' health and ecological environment. Here, the specific charge transfer pathway was constructed between a stable nanodiamond-multilayer graphene (MGD) film substrate and the target explosives. Two-step wet chemical oxidation methods of H2O2 (30%) and HNO3 (65%) solutions were used to regulate the terminal structure of MGD films. The experimental results showed that the hydroxyl (-OH) functional groups are successfully modified on the surface of MGD thin films, and the MGD-OH substrates having good selectivity for 1,3,5-triamino-2,4,6-trinitrobenzene (TATB) explosive in mixed solutions of the TATB, 2,2-dinitroethene-1,1-diamine, 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene, and 1,3,5-trinitroperhydro-1,3,5-triazine explosives compared with MGD substrates were demonstrated. Finally, first-principles density functional theory simulations revealed that the SERS enhancement of the MGD-OH substrate is mainly attributed to the transferred electrons between the -NO2 groups of TATB and the -OH groups of the MGD-OH substrate.

Copper-Decorated Titanium Electrodes: Impact of Surface Modifications of Substrate on the Morphology and Electrochemical Performance

This study investigates the effect of surface modifications of the titanium substrate on the growth of electrochemically deposited copper. These materials are intended to serve as cathodes in the electroreduction of nitrates in aqueous solutions. Surface modifications included the use of hydrogen fluoride for titanium etching and anodization to promote the growth of a structured titania nanotube array. The effect of an intermediate calcination step for the nanotubes before deposition was assessed along with a comparison to an untreated substrate electrode. The materials were comprehensively characterized by SEM, XRD, contact angle, potentiodynamic tests, EIS, and cyclic voltammetry. Their electrocatalytic ability was tested in the reduction of aqueous solutions containing nitrates. The results reveal that surface finishing impacted the shape and size of the Cu microparticles, as well as the nucleation mechanism enabling a crystal-facet-controllable synthesis. All the materials exhibited microsized copper particles with a spherical shape with some clusters. On the etched titanium surface, a high number of heterogeneous submicroscopic particles were also present. The thermally treated anodized substrate promoted the development of a combination of sparse microparticles corresponding to defect sites in amorphous titanium and the presence of a diffuse coating of octahedral nanosized particles whose growth was promoted by the tetragonal structure of anatase crystals. Electrochemical tests display reduced charge transfer resistance upon copper deposition on the modified substrates, which is indicative of the enhanced conductivity of the coated materials. Additionally, cyclic voltammetry and electrolysis experiments reveal the electrodes' potential for nitrate reduction, showing a better response for the etched titanium substrate (30% nitrate removal, after 2 h at 25 mA cm-2).

In situ generated iron oxide nanosheet on iron foam electrode for enhanced electro-Fenton performance toward pharmaceutical wastewater treatment

Electro-Fenton (EF) is considered to be an effective technology for the purification of organic wastewater containing antibiotics, but the construction of accessible and efficient heterogeneous EF catalytic materials still faces challenges. In this study, an iron foam-derived electrode (FeOx/if-400) was prepared by a simple method (chemical oxidation combined heat treatment). The fabricated electrode presented great EF degradation efficiency under wide pH range (almost completely removing 50 mg L-1 TNZ within 60 min) and maintained great stability after consecutive operation (>95% removal after six cycles). Also, the FeOx/if-400 electrode showed good purification ability for pharmaceutical wastewater as evaluated by the quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry and the three-dimensional excitation-emission matrix fluorescence spectroscopy. Based on experimental results, characterization analysis, and density functional theory (DFT) calculations, the EF reaction mechanism of FeOx/if-400 electrode and the organics degradation pathways in simulated and real matrices were proposed. Significantly, the biotoxicity assessment of the degradation intermediate products was revealed by ECOSAR software and relative inhibition of E. coli, which fully proved the environmental friendliness of the EF process by the FeOx/if-400 cathode. This work provides a green and effective EF system, showing a promising application potential in the field of organic wastewater treatment containing antibiotic contaminants.

Oxygen-doped carbon nanotubes with dual active cites to enhance •OH formation through three electron oxygen reduction

The electro-Fenton (EF) process generates H2O2 through the 2e- oxygen reduction reaction (ORR), which is subsequently activated to •OH by iron-based catalysts. To alleviate the potential risk of external Fe-based catalysts, along with metal dissolution in acidic or neutral environments, in this study we employed oxygen-doped carbon nanotubes (OCNT) as a bifunctional, metal-free cathode to establish a metal-free EF process for organic pollutant degradation. The results demonstrate that the metal-free electrode has excellent H2O2 accumulation (12 mg L-1 cm-1) and degrades sulfathiazole (STZ) with 97.05 % efficiency in 180 min with an explanation kinetic of 0.0189 min-1. For the first time, this enhancement came from the dual active site centers in OCNT: Ⅰ) -COOH and defects active sites were responsible for H2O2 production, Ⅱ) then -CO triggered H2O2 into •OH, avoiding the introduction of metal-based catalysts. These findings suggest that the EF system with in situ oxygen-doped cathodes have great potential for treating antibiotic wastewater.

Removal of ofloxacin using a porous carbon microfiltration membrane based on in-situ generated •OH

This study investigated the removal performance of ofloxacin (OFL) by a novel electro-Fenton enhanced microfiltration membrane. The membranes used in this study consisted of metal-organic framework derived porous carbon, carbon nanotubes and Fe2+, which were able to produce hydroxyl radicals (•OH) in-situ via reducing O2 to hydrogen peroxide. Herein, membrane filtration with bias not only concentrated the pollutants to the level that could be efficiently treated by electro-Fenton but also confined/retained the toxic intermediates within the membrane to ensure a prolonged contact time with the oxidants. After validated by experiments, the applied bias of -1.0 V, pH of 3 and electrolyte concentration of 0.1 M were the relatively optimum conditions for OFL degradation. Under these conditions, the average OFL removal rate could be reach 75% with merely 5% membrane flux loss after 4 cycles operation by filtrating 1 mg/L OFL. Via decarboxylation reaction, piperazinyl ring opening, dealkylation and ipso substitution reaction, etc., OFL could be gradually and efficiently degraded to intermediate products and even to CO2 by •OH. Moreover, the oxidation reaction was preferred to following first-order reaction kinetics. This research verified a possibility for antibiotic removal by electro-enhanced microfiltration membrane.

Impact of catalyst, chelating agent and light irradiation on electro-Fenton performance under not optimal conditions

Electro-Fenton is a promising game-changer for distributed wastewater treatments for the removal of recalcitrant compounds that it is possible to find in industrial effluent and looking for a water reuse approach. This electrochemical advanced oxidation process (EAOPs) is able to provide fast removal of organic compounds, like dyes, due to the in-situ H2O2 production and its reaction with Fe2+ to form hydroxyl radicals. The literature clearly reports that this reaction reaches its optimum in acid conditions (pH = 3) and low catalyst concentrations [Fe2+<0.5 mM]. This paper wants to investigate the effects of the shifting from optimal conditions on the removal of reactive black 5 (RB5), treating solutions which contain a higher amount of catalyst and a less acid pH. Textile effluents usually contain also other metals able to act as catalyst for Fenton reaction, like copper. Here its activity has been investigated as well as the possible synergistic effect with Fe2+. The results confirm that copper can enhance RB5 removal, especially in those conditions critical for ferrous cation. In the second part, possible process modifications to overcome the issues introduced by unfavourable operating conditions (pH > 3 and Fe2+ > 0.5 mM) are considered, such as the usage of a chelating agent (EDTA) and the application of a light source. The results show the positive impact of these two system modifications highlighting the possibility to enlarge the application window of electro-Fenton systems.

Comprehensive analysis of research trends and prospects in electrochemical advanced oxidation processes (EAOPs) for wastewater treatment

Electrochemical advanced oxidation processes (EAOPs) have emerged as a promising approach for efficient wastewater treatment. However, despite their promising potential, there is a lack of comprehensive analysis regarding the research trends, bibliometric data, and research frontiers of EAOPs. To address this gap, this study conducted a thorough and comprehensive analysis of 2347 related articles in the Web of Science Core Collection Database from 2012 to 2022. The analysis included information on countries, authors, institutions, and more, with a focus on summarizing trends and cutting-edge research hotspots in the field. The University of Barcelona in Spain is the most effective institution. Brillas E. is the most productive author in the world. Research hotspots in EAOPs have evolved from traditional anodic oxidation (AO) to novel electro-Fenton (EF) technology, which focuses on efficient generation of H2O2 and the use of metal-organic frameworks to enhance performance and efficiency. Through systematic research hotspot analysis, the importance of performance comparison of different types of EAOPs, development of new materials, optimization of device parameters, and toxicity assessment of byproducts is highlighted. Concurrently, the rise and mechanisms of emerging EAOPs are predicted and analyzed. Finally, future research on EAOPs technologies should focus on technological coupling, development of new materials, reduction of energy consumption and cost, evaluation and minimization of toxicity, and exploration of green renewable energy sources for larger-scale applications in wastewater treatment pilot plants. In this way, these technologies can contribute to the sustainability of larger industrial wastewater treatment applications and make an important contribution to environmental protection and scientific and technological progress.

A review of electro-Fenton and ultrasound processes: towards a novel integrated technology for wastewater treatment

Nowadays, the presence of persistent dissolved pollutants in water has received increasing attention due to their toxic effects on living organisms. Considering the limitations of conventional wastewater treatment processes for the degradation of these compounds, advanced oxidation processes such as electro-Fenton and sono-chemical process, as well as their combination, appear as potentially effective options for the treatment of wastewater contaminated with bio-recalcitrant pollutants. In view of the importance of the development of processes using real effluents, this review aims to provide a comprehensive perspective of sono-electro-Fenton-related processes applied for real wastewater treatment. In the first section, the fundamentals and effectiveness of both homogeneous and heterogeneous electro-Fenton approaches for the treatment of real wastewater are presented. While the second part of this work describes the fundamentals of ultrasound-based processes, the last section focuses on the coupling of the two methods for real wastewater treatment and on the effect of the main operational parameters of the process. On the basis of the information presented, it is suggested that sono-electro-Fenton processes substantially increase the efficiency of the treatment as well as the biodegradability of the treated wastewater. The combined effect results from mass transfer improvement, electrode cleaning and activation, water electrolysis, and the electro-Fenton-induced production of hydroxyl radicals. The information presented in this work is expected to be useful for closing the gap between laboratory-scale assays and the development of novel wastewater technologies.

Exploring the resilience of constructed wetlands to harmful algal blooms disturbances: A study on microbial response mechanisms

Constructed wetlands (CWs) have emerged as a promising environmentally sustainable technique for wastewater treatment. However, the susceptibility of CWs to disturbances caused by harmful algal blooms (HABs) raises concerns. This study aimed to investigate the impact of HABs on the pollutants' removal performance of CWs and the response of rhizosphere microbial community. Results revealed that CWs possessed an adaptive capacity that enabled them to recover caused by HABs. The rhizosphere was found to stimulate the occurrence of Acinetobacter, which played a critical role to help resist HABs disturbance. This study also observed an increased dissimilatory nitrate reduction metabolic pathway which promoted denitrification and enhanced the nitrogen removal efficiency of CWs. Additionally, the structural equation model further suggested that dissolved oxygen exerted a significant influence on the microbial activities and then affected the pollutants removal performance. Overall, our findings shed light on the mechanism for CW stability maintenance during HABs disturbance.

Highly selective electrosynthesis of H2O2 by N, O co-doped graphite nanosheets for efficient electro-Fenton degradation of p-nitrophenol

The activity and selectivity of the cathode towards electrosynthesis of H₂O₂ are critical for electro-Fenton process. Herein, nickel-foam modified with N, O co-doped graphite nanosheets (NO-GNSs/Ni-F) was developed as a cathode for highly efficient and selective electrosynthesis of H₂O₂. Expectedly, the accumulation of H₂O₂ at pH= 3 reached 494.2 mg L^-1 h^-1, with the selectivity toward H₂O₂ generation reaching 93.0%. The synergistic effect of different oxygen-containing functional groups and N species on the performance and selectivity of H₂O₂ electrosynthesis was investigated by density functional theory calculations, and the combination of epoxy and graphitic N (EP + N) was identified as the most favorable configuration with the lowest theoretical overpotential for H₂O₂ generation. Moreover, NO-GNSs/Ni-F was applied in the electro-Fenton process for p-nitrophenol degradation, resulting in 100% removal within 15 min with the kinetic rate constant of 0.446 min^-1 and 97.6% mineralization within 6 h. The efficient removal was mainly attributed to the generation of bulk ·OH. Furthermore, NO-GNSs/Ni-F exhibited excellent stability. This work provides a workable option for the enhancement of H₂O₂ accumulation and the efficient degradation of pollutants in electro-Fenton system.

Critical Review on the Mechanisms of Fe2+ Regeneration in the Electro-Fenton Process: Fundamentals and Boosting Strategies

This review presents an exhaustive overview on the mechanisms of Fe³⁺ cathodic reduction within the context of the electro-Fenton (EF) process. Different strategies developed to improve the reduction rate are discussed, dividing them into two categories that regard the mechanistic feature that is promoted: electron transfer control and mass transport control. Boosting the Fe³⁺ conversion to Fe²⁺ via electron transfer control includes: (i) the formation of a series of active sites in both carbon- and metal-based materials and (ii) the use of other emerging strategies such as single-atom catalysis or confinement effects. Concerning the enhancement of Fe²⁺ regeneration by mass transport control, the main routes involve the application of magnetic fields, pulse electrolysis, interfacial Joule heating effects, and photoirradiation. Finally, challenges are singled out, and future prospects are described. This review aims to clarify the Fe³⁺/Fe²⁺ cycling process in the EF process, eventually providing essential ideas for smart design of highly effective systems for wastewater treatment and valorization at an industrial scale.

Vertical-scale spatial influence of radial oxygen loss on rhizosphere microbial community in constructed wetland

Complex interactions between plants and microorganisms form the basis of constructed wetlands (CWs) for pollutant removal. In the rhizosphere, radial oxygen loss (ROL) plays a key role in the activity and abundance of functional microorganisms. However, little has been done to explore how ROL would influence the niche differentiation of microbial communities at different vertical spatial scales. We demonstrate that ROL decreases with depth, promoting an oxidation-reduction rhizosphere microecosystem in CWs. The high level of ROL in the upper layer could support the oxygen supply for aerobic bacteria (Haliangium), facilitating the COD (60%) and NH₄⁺-N (50%) removal, whereas the enrichment of denitrifiers (e.g., Hydrogenophaga and Ralstonia) and methanotrophs (Methanobaterium) in the lower layer could stimulate denitrification. The function prediction results further certified that the abundance of genes catalyzing nitrifying and denitrification processes were significantly enhanced in the upper and bottom layers, respectively, which was attributed to the oxygen concentration gradient in the rhizosphere. This study contributes to further unraveling the rhizosphere effect and enables an improved understanding of the decontamination mechanisms of CWs.