Fluorescence displacement method for the determination of receptor-ligand binding constants

Structural basis for tunable affinity and specificity of LxCxE-dependent protein interactions with the retinoblastoma protein family

The retinoblastoma protein (Rb) and its homologs p107 and p130 are critical regulators of gene expression during the cell cycle and are commonly inactivated in cancer. Rb proteins use their "pocket domain" to bind an LxCxE sequence motif in other proteins, many of which function with Rb proteins to co-regulate transcription. Here, we present binding data and crystal structures of the p107 pocket domain in complex with LxCxE peptides from the transcriptional co-repressor proteins HDAC1, ARID4A, and EID1. Our results explain why Rb and p107 have weaker affinity for cellular LxCxE proteins compared with the E7 protein from human papillomavirus, which has been used as the primary model for understanding LxCxE motif interactions. Our structural and mutagenesis data also identify and explain differences in Rb and p107 affinities for some LxCxE-containing sequences. Our study provides new insights into how Rb proteins bind their cell partners with varying affinity and specificity.

Conformational buffering underlies functional selection in intrinsically disordered protein regions

Many disordered proteins conserve essential functions in the face of extensive sequence variation, making it challenging to identify the mechanisms responsible for functional selection. Here we identify the molecular mechanism of functional selection for the disordered adenovirus early gene 1A (E1A) protein. E1A competes with host factors to bind the retinoblastoma (Rb) protein, subverting cell cycle regulation. We show that two binding motifs tethered by a hypervariable disordered linker drive picomolar affinity Rb binding and host factor displacement. Compensatory changes in amino acid sequence composition and sequence length lead to conservation of optimal tethering across a large family of E1A linkers. We refer to this compensatory mechanism as conformational buffering. We also detect coevolution of the motifs and linker, which can preserve or eliminate the tethering mechanism. Conformational buffering and motif-linker coevolution explain robust functional encoding within hypervariable disordered linkers and could underlie functional selection of many disordered protein regions.

The S. pombe mRNA decapping complex recruits cofactors and an Edc1-like activator through a single dynamic surface

The removal of the 5' 7-methylguanosine mRNA cap structure (decapping) is a central step in the 5'-3' mRNA degradation pathway and is performed by the Dcp1:Dcp2 decapping complex. The activity of this complex is tightly regulated to prevent premature degradation of the transcript. Here, we establish that the aromatic groove of the EVH1 domain of Schizosaccharomyces pombe Dcp1 can interact with proline-rich sequences in the exonuclease Xrn1, the scaffolding protein Pat1, the helicase Dhh1, and the C-terminal disordered region of Dcp2. We show that this region of Dcp1 can also recruit a previously unidentified enhancer of decapping protein (Edc1) and solved the crystal structure of the complex. NMR relaxation dispersion experiments reveal that the Dcp1 binding site can adopt multiple conformations, thus providing the plasticity that is required to accommodate different ligands. We show that the activator Edc1 makes additional contacts with the regulatory domain of Dcp2 and that an activation motif in Edc1 increases the RNA affinity of Dcp1:Dcp2. Our data support a model where Edc1 stabilizes the RNA in the active site, which results in enhanced decapping rates. In summary, we show that multiple decapping factors, including the Dcp2 C-terminal region, compete with Edc1 for Dcp1 binding. Our data thus reveal a network of interactions that can fine-tune the catalytic activity of the decapping complex.

Targeting autocrine HB-EGF signaling with specific ADAM12 inhibition using recombinant ADAM12 prodomain

Dysregulation of ErbB-family signaling underlies numerous pathologies and has been therapeutically targeted through inhibiting ErbB-receptors themselves or their cognate ligands. For the latter, “decoy” antibodies have been developed to sequester ligands including heparin-binding epidermal growth factor (HB-EGF); however, demonstrating sufficient efficacy has been difficult. Here, we hypothesized that this strategy depends on properties such as ligand-receptor binding affinity, which varies widely across the known ErbB-family ligands. Guided by computational modeling, we found that high-affinity ligands such as HB-EGF are more difficult to target with decoy antibodies compared to low-affinity ligands such as amphiregulin (AREG). To address this issue, we developed an alternative method for inhibiting HB-EGF activity by targeting its cleavage from the cell surface. In a model of the invasive disease endometriosis, we identified A Disintegrin and Metalloproteinase 12 (ADAM12) as a protease implicated in HB-EGF shedding. We designed a specific inhibitor of ADAM12 based on its recombinant prodomain (PA12), which selectively inhibits ADAM12 but not ADAM10 or ADAM17. In endometriotic cells, PA12 significantly reduced HB-EGF shedding and resultant cellular migration. Overall, specific inhibition of ligand shedding represents a possible alternative to decoy antibodies, especially for ligands such as HB-EGF that exhibit high binding affinity and localized signaling.

Semi-synthesis of cyclosporins

BACKGROUND

Since its isolation in 1970, and discovery of its potent inhibitory activity on T-cell proliferation, cyclosporin A (CsA) has been shown to play a significant role in diverse fields of biology. Furthermore, chemical modification of CsA has led to analogs with distinct biological activities associated with its protein receptor family, cyclophilins.

SCOPE OF REVIEW

This review systematically collates the synthetic chemistry performed at each of the eleven amino acids, and provides examples of the utility of such transformations. The various modifications of CsA are traced from early, modest chemistry performed at the unique Bmt residue, through the remarkable use of a polyanion enolate that can be stereoselectively manipulated, and onto application of more recently developed olefin metathesis chemistry to prepare new CsA derivatives with unexpected biological activity.

MAJOR CONCLUSIONS

The myriad biological activities of CsA and its synthetic derivatives have inspired the development of new approaches to modify the CsA ring. In turn, these new CsA derivatives have served as tools in the discovery of new roles for cyclophilins.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

This review provides information on the types of cyclosporin derivatives that are available to the many biologists working in this field, and should be of value to the medicinal chemist trying to discover drugs based on CsA. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Proline-directed foldases: Cell signaling catalysts and drug targets.

An investigation of the affinities, specificity and kinetics involved in the interaction between the Yin Yang 1 transcription factor and DNA

Human transcription factor Yin Yang 1 (YY1) is a four zinc-finger protein that regulates a large number of genes with various biological functions in processes such as development, carcinogenesis and B-cell maturation. The natural binding sites of YY1 are relatively unconserved and have a short core sequence (CCAT). We were interested in determining how YY1 recognizes its binding sites and achieves the necessary sequence selectivity in the cell. Using fluorescence anisotropy, we determined the equilibrium dissociation constants for selected naturally occurring YY1 binding sites that have various levels of similarity to the consensus sequence. We found that recombinant YY1 interacts with its specific binding sites with relatively low affinities from the high nanomolar to the low micromolar range. Using a fluorescence anisotropy competition assay, we determined the affinity of YY1 for non-specific DNA to be between 30 and 40 μm, which results in low specificity ratios of between 3 and 220. Additionally, surface plasmon resonance measurements showed rapid association and dissociation rates, suggesting that the binding strength is regulated through changes in both k(a) and k(d). In conclusion, we propose that, in the cell, YY1 may achieve higher specificity by associating with co-regulators or as a part of multi-subunit complexes.

Cooperation of the prolyl isomerase and chaperone activities of the protein folding catalyst SlyD

The SlyD (sensitive to lysis D) protein of Escherichia coli is a folding enzyme with a chaperone domain and a prolyl isomerase domain of the FK506 binding protein type. Here we investigated how the two domains and their interplay are optimized for function in protein folding. Unfolded protein molecules initially form a highly dynamic complex with the chaperone domain of SlyD, and they are then transferred to the prolyl isomerase domain. The turnover number of the prolyl isomerase site is very high and guarantees that, after transfer, prolyl peptide bonds in substrate proteins are isomerized very rapidly. The Michaelis constant of catalyzed folding reflects the substrate affinity of the chaperone domain, and the turnover number is presumably determined by the rate of productive substrate transfer from the chaperone to the prolyl isomerase site and by the intrinsic propensity of the refolding protein chain to leave the active site with the native prolyl isomer. The efficiency of substrate transfer is high because dissociation from the chaperone site is very fast and because the two sites are close to each other. Protein molecules that left the prolyl isomerase site with an incorrect prolyl isomer can rapidly be re-bound by the chaperone domain because the association rate is very high as well.

Coumarin-suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid as a fluorescent probe for determining binding affinities and off-rates of histone deacetylase inhibitors

Histone deacetylases (HDACs) are intimately involved in epigenetic regulation and, thus, are one of the key therapeutic targets for cancer, and two HDAC inhibitors, namely suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid (SAHA) and romidepsin, have been recently approved for cancer treatment. Because the screening and detailed characterization of HDAC inhibitors has been time-consuming, we synthesized coumarin-SAHA (c-SAHA) as a fluorescent probe for determining the binding affinities (K(d)) and the dissociation off-rates (k(off)) of the enzyme-inhibitor complexes. The determination of the above parameters relies on the changes in the fluorescence emission intensity (λ(ex)=325 nm, λ(em)=400 nm) of c-SAHA due to its competitive binding against other HDAC inhibitors, and such determination neither requires employment of polarization accessories nor is dependent on the fluorescence energy transfer from the enzyme's tryptophan residues to the probe. Our highly sensitive and robust analytical protocol presented here is applicable to most of the HDAC isozymes, and it can be easily adopted in a high-throughput mode for screening the HDAC inhibitors as well as for quantitatively determining their K(d) and k(off) values.

Targeting mechanism of the retinoblastoma tumor suppressor by a prototypical viral oncoprotein. Structural modularity, intrinsic disorder and phosphorylation of human papillomavirus E7

DNA tumor viruses ensure genome amplification by hijacking the cellular replication machinery and forcing infected cells to enter the S phase. The retinoblastoma (Rb) protein controls the G1/S checkpoint, and is targeted by several viral oncoproteins, among these the E7 protein from human papillomaviruses (HPVs). A quantitative investigation of the interaction mechanism between the HPV16 E7 protein and the RbAB domain in solution revealed that 90% of the binding energy is determined by the LxCxE motif, with an additional binding determinant (1.0 kcal.mol(-1)) located in the C-terminal domain of E7, establishing a dual-contact mode. The stoichiometry and subnanomolar affinity of E7 indicated that it can bind RbAB as a monomer. The low-risk HPV11 E7 protein bound 2.0 kcal.mol(-1) more weakly than the high-risk HPV16 and HPV18 type counterparts, but the modularity and binding mode were conserved. Phosphorylation at a conserved casein kinase II site in the natively unfolded N-terminal domain of E7 affected the local conformation by increasing the polyproline II content and stabilizing an extended conformation, which allowed for a tighter interaction with the Rb protein. Thus, the E7-RbAB interaction involves multiple motifs within the N-terminal domain of E7 and at least two conserved interaction surfaces in RbAB. We discussed a mechanistic model of the interaction of the Rb protein with a viral target in solution, integrated with structural data and the analysis of other cellular and viral proteins, which provided information about the balance of interactions involving the Rb protein and how these determine the progression into either the normal cell cycle or transformation.

Bis[μ-2-(2-pyridylmethyl-amino-meth-yl)phenolato]-κN,N',O:O;κO:N,N',O-bis-[(thio-cyanato-κN)copper(II)]

The centrosymmetric binuclear complex, [Cu₂(C₁₃H₁₃N₂O)₂(NCS)₂], formed via phenolate oxygen bridges, involves the Cu^II atoms in a distorted square-pyramidal coordination [τ = 0.197 (1)]. A Cu⋯Cu separation of 3.2281 (3) Å is observed. The in-plane Cu—O_phenolate distance [1.9342 (8) Å] is shorter than the axial distance [2.252 (8) Å]. The Cu—N_amine and Cu—N_py distances are similar [2.0095 (10) and 2.0192 (10) Å, respectively]. The Cu—N_{thio­cyanate} distance [1.9678 (11) Å] is in the range found for Cu—N distances in previously determined structures containing coordinated thio­cyanate anions. There is an inter­molecular hydrogen bond between the amine H atom and the S atom of a coordinated thio­cyanate anion.

Staurosporine-based binding assay for testing the affinity of compounds to protein kinases

Staurosporine is a broad-spectrum inhibitor of both tyrosine and serine/threonine protein kinases. Excitation of staurosporine and its analogues at 296 nm results in major emission bands centered at 378 and 396 nm. The intensity of the emission bands is enhanced on binding to the adenosine triphosphate (ATP) site of many protein kinases. This property was used to develop a competitive displacement assay for evaluating the binding affinity of small molecules to protein kinases. The assay was validated in both cuvette and plate formats for several phosphorylated and non-phosphorylated protein kinases. The throughput of the assay is high enough to be used in drug discovery for screening as well as lead optimization.

A fluorescence polarization-based assay for peptidyl prolyl cis/trans isomerase cyclophilin A

Peptidyl prolyl cis/trans isomerase cyclophilin A (CypA) serves as a cellular receptor for the important immunosuppressant drug, cyclosporin A. In addition, CypA and its enzyme family have been found to play critical roles in a variety of biological processes, including protein trafficking, HIV and HCV infection/replication, and Ca(2+)-mediated intracellular signaling. For these reasons, cyclophilins have emerged as potential drug targets for several diseases. Therefore, it is extremely important to screen for novel small molecule cyclophilin inhibitors. Unfortunately, the biochemical assays reported so far are not adaptable to a high-throughput screening format. Here, we report a fluorescence polarization-based assay for human CypA that can be adapted to high-throughput screening for drug discovery. The technique is based on competition and uses a fluorescein-labeled cyclosporin A analog and purified human CypA to quantitatively measure the binding capacity of unlabeled inhibitors. Detection by fluorescence polarization allows real-time measurement of binding ratios without separation steps. The results obtained demonstrated significant correlation among assay procedures, suggesting that the application of fluorescence polarization in combination with CypA is highly advantageous for the accurate assessment of inhibitor binding.

Interaction of the adenovirus proteinase with protein cofactors with high negative charge densities

The interactions of the human adenovirus proteinase (AVP) with polymers with high negative charge densities were characterized. AVP utilizes two viral cofactors for maximal enzyme activity (k(cat)/K(m)), the 11-amino acid peptide from the C-terminus of virion precursor protein pVI (pVIc) and the viral DNA. The viral DNA stimulates covalent AVP-pVIc complexes (AVP-pVIc) as a polyanion with a high negative charge density. Here, the interactions of AVP-pVIc with different polymers with high negative charge densities, polymers of glutamic acid (polyE), were characterized. The rate of substrate hydrolysis by AVP-pVIc increased with increasing concentrations of polyE. At higher concentrations of polyE, the increase in the rate of substrate hydrolysis approached saturation. Although glutamic acid did not stimulate enzyme activity, glutamic acid and NaCl could displace DNA from AVP-pVIc.(DNA) complexes; the K(i) values were 230 and 329 nM, respectively. PolyE binds to the DNA binding site on AVP-pVIc as polyE and DNA compete for binding to AVP-pVIc. The equilibrium dissociation constant for 1.3 kDa polyE binding to AVP-pVIc was 56 nM. On average, one molecule of AVP-pVIc binds to 12 residues in polyE. Comparison of polyE and 12-mer single-stranded DNA interacting with AVP-pVIc revealed the binding constants are similar, as are the Michaelis-Menten constants for substrate hydrolysis. The number of ion pairs formed upon the binding of 1.3 kDa polyE to AVP-pVIc was 2, and the nonelectrostatic change in free energy upon binding was -6.5 kcal. These observations may be physiologically relevant as they infer that AVP may bind to proteins that have regions of negative charge density. This would restrict activation of the enzyme to the locus of the cofactor within the cell.

Polymorphisms A387P in thrombospondin-4 and N700S in thrombospondin-1 perturb calcium binding sites

Recent genetic studies have associated members of the thrombospondin (TSP) gene family with premature cardiovascular disease. The disease-associated polymorphisms lead to single amino acid changes in TSP-4 (A387P) and TSP-1 (N700S). These substitutions reside in adjacent domains of these highly homologous proteins. Secondary structural predictive programs and the homology of the domains harboring these amino acid substitutions to those in other proteins pointed to potential alterations of putative Ca2+ binding sites that reside in close proximity to the polymorphic amino acids. Since Ca2+ binding is critical for the structure and function of TSP family members, direct evidence for differences in Ca2+ binding by the polymorphic forms was sought. Using synthetic peptides and purified recombinant variant fragments bearing the amino acid substitutions, we measured differences in Tb3+ luminescence as an index of Ca2+ binding. The Tb3+ binding constants placed the TSP-1 region affected by N700S polymorphism among other high-affinity Ca2+ binding sites. The affinity of Ca2+ binding was lower for peptides (3.5-fold) and recombinant fragments (10-fold) containing the S700 vs. the N700 form. In TSP-4, the P387 form acquired an additional Ca2+ binding site absent in the A387 form. The results of our study suggest that both substitutions (A387P in TSP-4 and N700S in TSP-1) alter Ca2+ binding properties. Since these substitutions exert the opposite effects on Ca2+ binding, a decrease in TSP-1 and an increase in TSP-4, the two TSP variants are likely to influence cardiovascular functions in distinct but yet pathogenic ways.

Thermodynamic characterization of the interaction of human cyclophilin 18 with cyclosporin A

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) was used to investigate thermodynamic parameters of the cyclosporin A (CsA)-cyclophilin 18 (hCyp18) association reaction. We have calculated the thermodynamic parameters (enthalpy, entropy, heat capacity, and free energy of binding) of the CsA/hCyp18 complexation. All but two methods described in the literature underestimate the affinity to hCyp18 of CsA. We found that the association constant (1.1.10(8) M(-1) at 10 degrees C) of CsA to hCyp18 is in close agreement with the reciprocal of the reported inhibitory constant of the peptidylprolyl cis/trans isomerase activity of hCyp18. Interpretation of the thermodynamic parameters in buffered solution of water, 30% glycerol and D(2)O leads to the conclusion that the highly specific binding of CsA to hCyp18 is mainly mediated through hydrogen bonding and to a lesser degree through hydrophobic interaction. Furthermore, the pH dependence of the association constant was determined and analyzed according to a single proton linkage model, resulting in a pK(a) value of 5.7 in free hCyp18 and below 4.5 in the CsA complexed form. Titration experiments using different single component buffers possessing different heats of ionization allowed us to estimate that statistically half a proton is transferred upon CsA binding from the binding interface of hCyp18 to the buffer at pH 5.5. No proton transfer was detected at pH 7.5. The thermodynamic results are discussed in relation to the published X-ray and NMR structure of the free and CsA complexed hCyp18.

General numerical treatment of competitive binding kinetics: application to thrombin-dehydrothrombin-hirudin

This paper describes a general numerical method for the determination of rate constants that characterize the binding of a ligand L simultaneously and competitively to two different receptor molecules, R1 and R2. The experimental data consist of changes in the concentration of one receptor (e.g., R1) monitored over time. An example problem is represented by hirudin (L) binding to thrombin (R1) and to a chemical mutant of thrombin (R2). The published experimental data [Wedemeyer et al. (1997) Anal. Biochem. 248, 130-140], previously analyzed by using an appropriate algebraic method, were reanalyzed here by numerical integration [Kuzmic (1996) Anal. Biochem. 237, 260-273]. This general numerical method offers the following advantages. (1) It provides an estimate for the lower limit on feasible values of association rate constants. (2) It is many orders of magnitude more accurate. (3) It is easily extensible to more complicated reaction mechanisms. (4) It uses a simpler formalism and it is thus more accessible to nonmathematicians. (5) A suitable computer program for the analysis of competitive binding kinetics can be obtained via the Internet (http://www.biokin.com).

Fixed-point methods for computing the equilibrium composition of complex biochemical mixtures

The fixed-point algebraic method [Storer and Cornish-Bowden (1976) Biochem. J. 159, 1-5] for computing the concentrations at equilibrium of complex biochemical mixtures fails for many binding stoichiometries, especially those that include molecular self-association. A typical example is the monomer-dimer-tetramer equilibrium. This paper reports two main results. First, the above algorithm is analysed theoretically to predict for which binding stoichiometries it succeeds and for which it will fail. Secondly, an alternative algorithm is described for self-associating biochemical systems. Illustrative examples are based on the dimeric proteinase from HIV.

The cytoplasmic domain of alphaIIb beta3. A ternary complex of the integrin alpha and beta subunits and a divalent cation

Peptides corresponding to the cytoplasmic tails of the alphaIIb (alphaIIb (985-1008)) and beta3 (beta3 (713-762)) subunits of the integrin receptor alphaIIb beta3 (glycoprotein IIb-IIIa) were synthesized and used to characterize their interaction with cations and with one another. alphaIIb (985-1008) was found to contain a functional cation binding site as assessed by both terbium luminescence and electrospray ionization mass spectroscopy. The binding of Tb3+ to alphaIIb (985-1008) was of high affinity (Kd = 8.8 +/- 5.2 nM), occurred with a 1:1 stoichiometry, and was mediated by its acidic carboxy] terminus (alphaIIb (999-1008), PLEEDDEEGE). The affinity of this site for divalent cations was in the micromolar range, suggesting that this site would be constitutively occupied in the intracellular environment. Incubation of alphaIIb (999-1008) with beta3 (713-762) resulted in the formation of a complex, both in the presence and absence of cations. The interactive site for alphaIIb (999-1008) in beta3 was mapped to beta3 (721-740), and complex formation was associated with a stabilization of secondary structure as assessed by circular dichroism. Both a binary (alphaIIb (985-1008).beta3 (721-740)) and a ternary (Tb3+.alphaIIIb (999-1008).beta3 (721-740)) complex were detected by mass spectroscopy, but the distribution and intensity of the mass/charge peaks were distinct. These difference may reflect the involvement of distinct cation coordination sites and the formation of salt bridges in stabilizing the ternary complex. These data demonstrate the formation of a novel entity composed of the cytoplasmic tails of alphaIIb and beta3 and a cation which may constitute a functional intracellular domain.

An exact mathematical expression for describing competitive binding of two different ligands to a protein molecule

The dissociation constant for the binding of a spectroscopically invisible or non-radioactive ligand to its protein receptor can be determined in a competition experiment by using a structural analog that contains a reporter group. Many plotting and numerical analysis methods have been developed to calculate the binding constant of unlabeled ligand from the displacement experiments. However, a common problem with these plotting methods is that the equation transformations inevitably result in non-standard error distribution, and thus simple linear regression can not be used to extract correct values for the parameters. In the case of the numerical analysis methods, one would be faced with the possible existence of multiple solutions. In this paper, the exact mathematical expression for describing competitive binding of two different ligands to a protein molecule is presented in terms of the total concentrations of species in the system. Thus, using a commercially available non-linear regression program, all unknown parameters for describing this system can be determined by fitting the experimental data to the algebraically explicit equation without any data transformations. The distribution curves of all the species in the system can also be constructed with this equation. It is particularly useful for the cases in which the concentrations of all the species in the system are comparable to each other.