Thermodynamics of 5-HT3 receptor binding discriminates agonistic from antagonistic behaviour

Fluorescent Nanozeolite Receptors for the Highly Selective and Sensitive Detection of Neurotransmitters in Water and Biofluids

The design and preparation of synthetic binders (SBs) applicable for small biomolecule sensing in aqueous media remains very challenging. SBs designed by the lock-and-key principle can be selective for their target analyte but usually show an insufficient binding strength in water. In contrast, SBs based on symmetric macrocycles with a hydrophobic cavity can display high binding affinities but generally suffer from indiscriminate binding of many analytes. Herein, a completely new and modular receptor design strategy based on microporous hybrid materials is presented yielding zeolite-based artificial receptors (ZARs) which reversibly bind the neurotransmitters serotonin and dopamine with unprecedented affinity and selectivity even in saline biofluids. ZARs are thought to uniquely exploit both the non-classical hydrophobic effect and direct non-covalent recognition motifs, which is supported by in-depth photophysical, and calorimetric experiments combined with full atomistic modeling. ZARs are thermally and chemically robust and can be readily prepared at gram scales. Their applicability for the label-free monitoring of important enzymatic reactions, for (two-photon) fluorescence imaging, and for high-throughput diagnostics in biofluids is demonstrated. This study showcases that artificial receptor based on microporous hybrid materials can overcome standing limitations of synthetic chemosensors, paving the way towards personalized diagnostics and metabolomics.

Differential thermodynamic driving force of first- and second-generation antihistamines to determine their binding affinity for human H1 receptors

Differential binding sites for first- and second-generation antihistamines were indicated on the basis of the crystal structure of human histamine H1 receptors. In this study, we evaluated differences between the thermodynamic driving forces of first- and second-generation antihistamines for human H1 receptors and their structural determinants. The binding enthalpy and entropy of 20 antihistamines were estimated with the van't Hoff equation using their dissociation constants obtained from their displacement curves against the binding of [(3)H]mepyramine to membrane preparations of Chinese hamster ovary cells expressing human H1 receptors at various temperatures from 4°C to 37°C. Structural determinants of antihistamines for their thermodynamic binding properties were assessed by quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) analyses. We found that entropy-dependent binding was more evident in second- than first-generation antihistamines, resulting in enthalpy-entropy compensation between the binding forces of first- and second-generation antihistamines. QSAR analyses indicated that enthalpy-entropy compensation was determined by the sum of degrees, maximal electrostatic potentials, water-accessible surface area and hydrogen binding acceptor count of antihistamines to regulate their affinity for receptors. In conclusion, it was revealed that entropy-dependent hydrophobic interaction was more important in the binding of second-generation antihistamines, even though the hydrophilicity of second-generation antihistamines is generally increased. Furthermore, their structural determinants responsible for enthalpy-entropy compensation were explored by QSAR analyses. These findings may contribute to understanding the fundamental mechanisms of how the affinity of ligands for their receptors is regulated.

The kinetics of competitive antagonism of nicotinic acetylcholine receptors at physiological temperature

Detailed information about the ligand-binding site of nicotinic acetylcholine receptors has emerged from structural and mutagenesis experiments. However, these approaches provide only static images of ligand-receptor interactions. Kinetic measurements of changes in protein function are needed to develop a more dynamic picture. Previously, we measured association and dissociation rate constants for competitive inhibition of current through embryonic muscle acetylcholine receptor channels at 25 degrees C. Little is known about competitive antagonism at physiological temperatures. Here, we performed measurements at 37 degrees C and used thermodynamics to estimate the energetics of antagonism. We used rapid solution exchange protocols to determine equilibrium and kinetics of inhibition of acetylcholine-activated currents in outside-out patches by (+)-tubocurarine, pancuronium and cisatracurium. Kinetic rates as high as 600 s(-1) were resolved by this technique. Binding was primarily enthalpy driven. The 12 degrees C increase in temperature decreased equilibrium antagonist binding by 1.7- to 1.9-fold. In contrast, association and dissociation rate constants increased 1.9- to 6.0-fold. Activation energies for dissociation were 90 +/- 6, 106 +/- 8 and 116 +/- 10 kJ mol(-1) for cisatracurium, (+)-tubocurarine and pancuronium, respectively. The corresponding apparent activation energies for association were 38 +/- 6, 85 +/- 6 and 107 +/- 13 kJ mol(-1). The higher activation energy for association of (+)-tubocurarine and pancuronium compared with cisatracurium is notable. This may arise from either a more superficial binding site for the large antagonist cisatracurium compared to the other ligands, or from a change in receptor conformation upon binding of (+)-tubocurarine and pancuronium but not cisatracurium. Differences in ligand desolvation and ligand conformation are not likely to be important.

Thermodynamics of A2B adenosine receptor binding discriminates agonistic from antagonistic behaviour

Thermodynamic parameters DeltaG degrees , DeltaH degrees and DeltaS degrees of the binding equilibrium of 12 ligands (six agonists and six antagonists) to the A(2B) adenosine receptor subtype have been determined by affinity measurements carried out on HEK 293 cells stably transfected with human A(2B) adenosine receptors at six different temperatures (4, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30 degrees C) and van't Hoff plot analysis have been performed. Affinity constants were obtained from saturation experiments of [(3)H]MRE 2029-F20 or by its displacement in inhibition assays for the other compounds. van't Hoff plots were essentially linear in the temperature range investigated, showing that the DeltaC(p) degrees of the binding equilibrium is nearly zero. Thermodynamic parameters are in the range 7< or =DeltaH degrees < or =23 kJ mol(-1)and 123< or =DeltaS degrees < or =219 JK(-1)mol(-1) for agonists and -40 < or =DeltaH degrees < or =-20 kJ mol(-1) and 10< or =DeltaS degrees < or =91 JK(-1)mol(-1) for antagonists indicating that agonistic binding is always totally entropy-driven while antagonistic binding is enthalpy and entropy-driven. In the -TDeltaS degrees versus DeltaH degrees plot the thermodynamic data are clearly arranged in separate clusters for agonists and antagonists, which, therefore, turn out to be thermodynamically discriminated.

Thermodynamic analysis of ligands at cholecystokinin CCK2 receptors in rat cerebral cortex

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Several studies using radioligand binding assays, have shown that measurement of thermodynamic parameters can allow discrimination of agonists and antagonists (Weiland et al., 1979; Borea et al., 1996a). Here we investigate whether agonists and antagonists can be thermodynamically discriminated at CCK(2) receptors in rat cerebral cortex.

EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH

The pK(L) of [(3)H]-JB93182 in rat cerebral cortex membranes was determined at 4, 12, 21 and 37 degrees C in 50 mM Tris-HCl buffer (buffer B pH 6.96; containing 0.089 mM bacitracin). pK(I) values of ligands of diverse chemical structure and with differing intrinsic activity (alpha), as defined by the lumen-perfused rat and mouse stomach bioassays, were determined in buffer B at 4, 12, 21 and 37 degrees C.

KEY RESULTS

[(3)H]-JB93182 labelled a homogeneous population of receptors in rat cerebral cortex at 4, 12, 21 and 37 degrees C and the pK(L) and B(max) were not altered by incubation temperature. [(3)H]-JB93182 binding reached equilibrium after 10, 50, 90 and 220 min at 37, 21, 12 and 4 degrees C, respectively. pK(I) values for R-L-365,260, R-L-740,093, YM220, PD134,308 and JB95008 were higher at 4 degrees C than at 37 degrees C. There was no effect of temperature on pK(I) values for pentagastrin, CCK-8S, S-L-365,260, YM022, PD140,376 and JB93242.

CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS

CCK(2) receptor agonists and antagonists at rat CCK(2) receptors cannot be discriminated by thermodynamic analysis using [(3)H]-JB93182 as the radioligand.

Cell autonomy, receptor autonomy, and thermodynamics in nicotine receptor up-regulation

Chronic nicotine exposure, in smokers or in experimental rodents administered nicotine, produces elevated levels of nicotinic acetylcholine receptors in several brain regions. However, there are few data on up-regulation of receptors in specific neuronal subtypes. We tested whether functional up-regulation of nicotinic responses occurs in cultured GABAergic neurons of the ventral midbrain. Fura-2 measurements of nicotinic responses were made on ventral midbrain neurons from knock-in mice heterozygous for the alpha4-M2 domain Leu9'Ala mutation, which confers nicotine hypersensitivity. Chronic nicotine exposure at a concentration (10 nM for 3 days) that activates only the hypersensitive alpha4* (Leu9'Ala) receptors, but not wild-type receptors, resulted in significant potentiation of ACh (100 microM)-elicited responses. Experiments were also performed on midbrain neuronal cultures heterozygous for the alpha4* (Leu9'Ala) mutation as well as for a GFP protein fused to a GABA transporter that reliably reveals GABAergic neurons. In cultures chronically treated with 10nM nicotine, there was significantly increased alpha4* nicotinic-induced Ca(2+) influx elicited by low concentration of ACh (3 microM). Furthermore, chronic exposure to the competitive antagonist dihydro-beta-erythroidine, but not to the noncompetitive antagonist mecamylamine, induced up-regulation of ACh elicited nicotinic responses. These results suggest that occupation of alpha4* nicotinic receptor binding site(s), at the interface between two subunits, is sufficient to promote assembly and/or up-regulation of functional receptors in GABAergic neurons. Up-regulation in neurons is both "cell-autonomous", occurring at the cell itself, and "receptor autonomous", occurring at the receptor itself, and may be a thermodynamic necessity of ligand-protein interactions.

Histamine H3-receptor agonists and imidazole-based H3-receptor antagonists can be thermodynamically discriminated

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Studies suggest that measurement of thermodynamic parameters can allow discrimination of agonists and antagonists. Here we investigate whether agonists and antagonists can be thermodynamically discriminated at histamine H(3) receptors.

EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH

The pK(L) of the antagonist radioligand, [(3)H]-clobenpropit, in guinea-pig cortex membranes was estimated at 4, 12, 21 and 30 degrees C in 20 mM HEPES-NaOH buffer (buffer A), or buffer A containing 300 mM CaCl(2), (buffer A(Ca)). pK(I)' values for ligands with varying intrinsic activity were determined in buffer A and A(Ca) at 4, 12, 21 and 30 degrees C.

KEY RESULTS

In buffer A, the pK(L) of [(3)H]-clobenpropit increased with decreasing temperature while it did not change in buffer A(Ca). The Bmax was not affected by temperature or buffer and n (H) values were not different from unity. In buffer A, pK(I)' values for agonists remained unchanged or decreased with decreasing temperature, while antagonist pK(I) values increased with decreasing temperature; agonist binding was entropy-driven while antagonist binding was enthalpy and entropy-driven. In buffer A(Ca), temperature had no effect on antagonist and agonist pK(I) values; both agonist and antagonist binding were enthalpy and entropy-driven.

CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS

The binding of H(3)-receptor agonists and antagonists can be thermodynamically discriminated under conditions where agonist pK(I)' values are over-estimated (pK(I)' not = pK(app)). However, under conditions when agonist pK(I) approximately pK(app), the thermodynamics underlying the binding of agonists are not different to those of antagonists.

Binding Thermodynamics as a Tool To Investigate the Mechanisms of Drug−Receptor Interactions: Thermodynamics of Cytoplasmic Steroid/Nuclear Receptors in Comparison with Membrane Receptors

Drug-receptor binding thermodynamics has proved to be a valid tool for pharmacological and pharmaceutical characterization of molecular mechanisms of receptor-recognition phenomena. The large number of membrane receptors so far studied has led to the discovery of enthalpy-entropy compensation effects in drug-receptor binding and discrimination between agonists and antagonists by thermodynamic methods. Since a single thermodynamic study on cytoplasmic receptors was known, this paper reports on binding thermodynamics of estradiol, ORG2058, and R1881 bound to estrogen, progesterone, and androgen steroid/nuclear receptors, respectively, as determined by variable-temperature binding constant measurements. The binding at 25 degrees C appears enthalpy/entropy-driven (-53.0 </= DeltaG degrees </= -48.6, -34.5 </= DeltaH degrees </= -19.9 kJ/mol, 0.057 </= DeltaS degrees </= 0.111, and -2.4 </= DeltaC(p) degrees </= -1.7 kJ mol(-1) K(-1)) and is interpreted in terms of hydrophobic and hydrogen-bonded specific interactions. Results obtained for cytoplasmic receptors are extensively compared with those known for typical membrane receptors, in particular the adenosine A(1) receptor, to investigate the thermodynamic bases of drug-receptor binding from the most general point of view.

Hyperekplexia mutation of glycine receptors: decreased gating efficacy with altered binding thermodynamics

[(3)H]Strychnine binding was studied to recombinant human alpha(1) and the hyperekplexia mutant alpha(1)R271L glycine receptors (GlyRs) transiently expressed in human embryonic kidney (HEK)-293 cell cultures at 0, 18 and 37 degrees. The alpha(1)R271L mutation did not affect the linear van't Hoff plots of the exothermic binding of the antagonist [3H]strychnine while it turned taurine into an antagonist with exothermic binding. The inhibition constants of the agonist glycine showed opposite temperature dependence on alpha(1) GlyRs, corresponding to endothermic binding driven by large entropic increases. The temperature dependence of displacement by the partial agonists taurine on alpha(1) GlyRs and glycine on alpha(1)R271L GlyRs was biphasic reflecting negative heat capacity changes, dehydration changes and/or a complex binding mechanism. The thermodynamic discrimination of efficacy is valid for native rat spinal and recombinant human GlyRs. The alpha(1)R271L mutation impairs the transduction mechanism and distorts gating of GlyRs. Thereby it reduces the potency and efficacy of agonists and affects their thermodynamic parameters of binding. The hyperekplexia mutation offers a model system to demonstrate the correlation among pathophysiology, gating efficacy and binding thermodynamics of GlyRs.

Entropy as the predominant driving force of binding to human recombinant alpha(x)beta(3)gamma(2) GABA(A) receptors

In order to study the correlation of the thermodynamic driving forces of binding with the efficacies of displacing ligands, the specific binding of [3H]SR 95531 [2-(3-carboxypropyl)3-amino-6-p-methoxyphenylpyridazinium bromide], a GABA(A) receptor antagonist, was studied in cell lines stably expressing human alpha(1)beta(3)gamma(2) and alpha(2)beta(3)gamma(2) GABA(A) receptors. Displacing potencies for the agonists with different efficacies (muscimol, 4,5,6,7-tetrahydroisoxazolo[5,4-c]pyridin-3-ol (THIP) and piperidine-4-sulfonic acid) and for antagonists (SR 95531 and 5-(4-piperidyl)isothiazol-3-ol) were determined at 0 degrees C, 20 degrees C and 37 degrees C. Displacing potencies were temperature-nearly independent for alpha(1)beta(3)gamma(2) receptors. At alpha(2)beta(3)gamma(2), receptor binding of the antagonists was exothermic, endothermic for the agonists THIP and piperidine-4-sulfonic acid and isothermic for muscimol. The free energy increments of displacement for the binding of the antagonist [3H]SR 95531 versus the agonist [3H]muscimol approach saturation as a function of the efficacies of the displacers only for alpha(1)beta(3)gamma(2) receptors. This suggests that, for binding to alpha(1)beta(3)gamma(2) GABA(A) receptors, displacement is an efficacy-dependent interaction predominantly driven by entropic increases.

Can thermodynamic measurements of receptor binding yield information on drug affinity and efficacy?

The present commentary surveys the methods for obtaining the thermodynamic parameters of the drug-receptor binding equilibrium, DeltaG degrees, DeltaH degrees, DeltaS degrees, and DeltaC degrees (p) (standard free energy, enthalpy, entropy, and heat capacity, respectively). Moreover, it reviews the available thermodynamic data for the binding of agonists and antagonists to several G-protein coupled receptors (GPCRs) and ligand-gated ion channel receptors (LGICRs). In particular, thermodynamic data for five GPCRs (beta-adrenergic, adenosine A(1), adenosine A(2A), dopamine D(2), and 5-HT(1A)) and four LGICRs (glycine, GABA(A), 5-HT(3), and nicotinic) have been collected and analyzed. Among these receptor systems, seven (three GPCRs and all LGICRs) show "thermodynamic agonist-antagonist discrimination": when the agonist binding to a given receptor is entropy-driven, the binding of its antagonist is enthalpy-driven, or vice versa. A scatter plot of all entropy versus enthalpy values of the database gives a regression line with the equation TDeltaS degrees (kJ mol(-1); T = 298.15 K) = 40.3 (+/- 0.7) + 1.00 (+/-0.01) DeltaH degrees (kJ mol(-1)); N = 184; r = 0.981; P < 0.0001 - which is of the form DeltaH degrees = beta. DeltaS degrees, revealing the presence of the "enthalpy-entropy compensation" phenomenon. This means that any decrease of binding enthalpy is compensated for by a parallel decrease of binding entropy, and vice versa, in such a manner that affinity constant values (K(A)) of drug-receptor equilibrium (DeltaG degrees = -RT ln K(A) = DeltaH degrees - TDeltaS degrees ) cannot be greater than 10(11) M(-1). According to the most recent hypotheses concerning drug-receptor interaction mechanisms, these thermodynamic phenomena appear to be a consequence of the rearrangement of solvent molecules that occurs during the binding.

Thermodynamically distinct high and low affinity states of the A(1) adenosine receptor induced by G protein coupling and guanine nucleotide ligation states of G proteins

The influence of the receptor-G protein coupling state and the guanine nucleotide ligation state of the G protein on the binding mechanism of A(1) adenosine receptor ligands has been investigated in [(3)H]-1,3-dipropyl-8-cyclopentylxanthine ([(3)H]-DPCPX) binding studies in rat brain membranes. Thermodynamic parameters of binding of A(1) adenosine receptor ligands of different intrinsic activities were determined in the absence or presence of GDP and compared to the binding mechanism after receptor-G protein uncoupling. In agreement with previous studies, it was found that xanthine and non-xanthine antagonists showed an enthalpy- or enthalpy- and entropy-driven binding mechanism under all conditions. In contrast to antagonists, the binding mechanism of agonists was strongly affected by the G protein coupling state or the absence or presence of guanine nucleotides. Binding of full and partial agonists to the high-affinity state of the A(1) receptor was entropy-driven in the absence of GDP, and a good correlation between intrinsic activities and the contribution of entropy was observed. In the absence of GDP, binding of full and partial agonists and antagonists to the high affinity state of the receptor was thermodynamically discriminated. In contrast, no such discrimination was found in the presence of GDP. The binding mechanism of agonists to the low-affinity state of the receptor was identical to that of antagonists only after uncoupling of the receptor from G proteins by pretreatment with N-ethylmaleimide or guanosine-5'-(gamma-thio)-triphosphate (GTPgammaS). These results indicate the existence of two thermodynamically distinct high- and low-affinity states of the A(1) adenosine receptor.

Evidence that histamine homologues discriminate between H3-receptors in guinea-pig cerebral cortex and ileum longitudinal muscle myenteric plexus

1. The binding of the selective histamine H3-receptor agonist ([3H]-R-alpha-methylhistamine) to sites in guinea-pig cerebral cortex and ileum longitudinal muscle myenteric plexus has been characterized and a comparison made of the apparent affinities of a series of H3-receptor ligands. 2. Saturation analysis suggested that [3H]-R-alpha-methylhistamine labelled a homogeneous population of histamine H3-receptors in guinea-pig cerebral cortex (pKD=9.91+/-0. 07; nH=1.07+/-0.03; n=5) and ileum longitudinal muscle myenteric plexus (pKD=9.75+/-0.21; nH=0.97+/-0.02; n=5). There was no significant difference in the estimated affinity of [3H]-R-alpha-methylhistamine in the two tissues. The cerebral cortex had a significantly higher receptor density (3.91+/-0.37 fmol mg-1 tissue) than the ileum longitudinal muscle myenteric plexus (0. 39+/-0.11 fmol mg-1). 3. Overall, the apparent affinities of compounds, classified as H3-receptor ligands, in cerebral cortex and ileum longitudinal muscle myenteric plexus were well correlated (r=0. 91, P<0.0001) and consistent with the cerebral cortex and ileum longitudinal muscle myenteric plexus expressing histamine H3-receptor population(s) that are pharmacologically indistinguishable by the majority of histamine H3-receptor ligands. However, it was evident that the homologues of histamine within this group of compounds could discriminate between the receptor populations in the two tissues. Thus, the estimated affinity of five imidazole unbranched alkylamines (histamine, homohistamine, VUF4701, VUF4732 and impentamine) were significantly higher in the guinea-pig cerebral cortex than in the ileum longitudinal muscle myenteric plexus assay.

Temperature dependence and GABA modulation of beta-carboline binding to rat cerebellum benzodiazepine receptors

The temperature dependence of the binding of beta-carboline derivatives to the central benzodiazepine receptors was determined using [3H]-Ro 15-1788, as a selective radioligand. The compounds chosen display a wide spectrum of efficacies ranging from inverse agonists to agonists through antagonists. Assays were performed at 0, 10, 20, 25, 30, 35 degrees C in the absence and in the presence of 10 microM GABA. The temperature dependence of the affinity constants K(A)=1/K(D) or 1/Ki is shown in the van't Hoff plots (In K(A) versus 1/T) for each compound. Thermodynamic parameters deltaG degrees, deltaH degrees and deltaS degrees were determined by regression analysis of the plots which were linear in the range of temperatures investigated. Moreover, their slopes were systematically positive indicating that the binding of the compounds analyzed to benzodiazepine receptors is essentially enthalpy-driven both in the presence and in the absence of GABA. We verified that the ratio of affinity constant values in the presence and absence of GABA 10 microM (GABA ratio) (<1 for inverse agonists, =1 for antagonists, >1 for agonists), strongly correlates with the corresponding differences of deltaH degrees and deltaS degrees values obtained for each compound in the absence and in the presence of GABA. These results suggest that binding thermodynamic analysis of BDZ receptor ligands, in the presence and in the absence of GABA, permits to discriminate inverse agonists from antagonists, and agonists.

Thermodynamics of full agonist, partial agonist, and antagonist binding to wild-type and mutant adenosine A1 receptors

A thermodynamic analysis of the binding of a full agonist (N6-cyclopentyladenosine), a partial agonist (8-butylamino-N6-cyclopentyladenosine) and an antagonist (8-cyclopentyltheophylline) to human wild-type and mutant (mutation of a threonine (Thr) to an alanine (Ala) residue at position 277) adenosine A1 receptors expressed on Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells, and to rat brain adenosine A1 receptors was undertaken. The thermodynamic parameters deltaGo (standard free energy), deltaHo (standard enthalpy) and deltaSo (standard entropy) of the binding equilibrium to rat brain receptors were determined by means of affinity measurements carried out at four different temperatures (0, 10, 20 and 25 degrees) and van't Hoff plots. Two temperatures (0 and 25 degrees) were considered for human receptors. Affinity constants were obtained from inhibition assays on membrane preparations of rat brain and CHO cells by use of the antagonist [3H]1,3-dipropyl-8-cyclopentylxanthine ([3H]DPCPX) as selective adenosine A1 receptor radioligand. As for rat brain receptors, full agonist binding was totally entropy driven, whereas antagonist binding was essentially enthalpy driven. Partial agonist binding appeared both enthalpy and entropy driven. As for human receptors, full agonist affinity was highly dependent on the presence of Thr277. Moreover, affinity to both wild-type and mutant receptors was enhanced by temperature increase, suggesting a totally entropy-driven binding. Antagonist binding did not depend on the presence of Thr277. Antagonist affinity decreased with an increase in temperature, suggesting a mainly enthalpy-driven binding. Partial agonist binding was significantly dependent on the presence of Thr277 at 25 degrees, whereas such a dependence was not evident at 0 degrees. It is concluded that Thr277 contributes only to the binding of adenosine derivatives and that its role changes drastically with the receptor conformation and with the type of agonist (full or partial) interacting with the adenosine A1 receptors.

Ligand binding to the serotonin 5HT3 receptor studied with a novel fluorescent ligand

The thermodynamics and kinetics of ligand binding to the purified serotonin 5HT3 receptor and the local environment of the bound ligand were studied by fluorescence spectroscopy using a novel fluorescein-labeled ligand GR-flu [1,2,3, 9-tetrahydro-3-[(5-methyl-1H-imidazol-4-yl)methyl]-9-(3-amino-(N-fluo rescien-thiocarbamoyl)-propyl)-4H-carbazol-4-one]. Electrophysiological investigations demonstrated GR-flu to be an antagonist, and radioligand competition assays delivered a dissociation constant of 0.32 nM. Changes in the fluorescence intensity and anisotropy upon specific binding to the receptor yielded dissociation constants of approximately 0.2 nM. Fluorescence measurements showed that selective 5HT3 receptor ligands competed for GR-flu binding with a rank order of potency identical to that established with the radioligand [3H]-GR65630. The kinetics of GR-flu binding to the 5HT3 receptor revealed a bimolecular association process with an on-rate constant of 1.17 x 10(6) s-1 M-1 and a biphasic dissociation reaction with off-rate constants of 275 x 10(-)6 and 43 x 10(-)6 s-1. The temperature dependence of the dissociation constant yielded an enthalpic term of -26 kJ mol-1 and an entropic term of 94 J K-1 mol-1 for the binding of GR-flu to the receptor, indicating that both quantities contribute equally to the reaction. An activation enthalpy DeltaH#on and entropy DeltaS#on of binding of 50 kJ mol-1 and 43 J mol-1 K-1 were obtained, indicating that the entropy facilitates the initial steps of GR-flu binding to the 5HT3 receptor. The fluorescence anisotropy of receptor-bound GR-flu and the environmental sensitivity of the fluorescent probe suggest that the binding site has a wide entrance and that it is 0.8 pH unit more acidic than the bulk solution.

Binding thermodynamics at the human neuronal nicotine receptor

The thermodynamic parameters deltaGo (standard free energy), deltaHo (standard enthalpy) and deltaSo (standard entropy) of the binding equilibrium of eleven ligands (six agonists and five antagonists) to the neuronal nicotinic receptor were determined by affinity measurements carried out on human thalamus membranes at six different temperatures (0, 10, 20, 25, 30, 35 degrees) and deltaG vs. T plot analysis. Affinity constants were obtained by saturation experiments for [3H]-cytisine, a ganglionic nicotinic agonist, or its displacement in inhibition assays for the other compounds. The deltaG vs T plots appeared to be reasonably linear in the full temperature range for most of the compounds investigated (equilibrium heat capacity change,deltaCo(p) approximately 0), with the exception of the three agonists cytisine, nicotine and methylcarbachol (deltaCo(p) of the order of -720 / -1610 J mol(-1) K(-1)). Thermodynamic parameters were in the range -53.3 < or =deltaHo < or = -28.9 kJ mol(-1) and -41 < or = deltaSo < or = 69 J mol(-1) K(-1) for agonists, and 8.7 < or = deltaHo < or = 68.2 kJ mol(-1) and 99 < or = deltaSo < or = 311 J mol(-1) K(-1) for antagonists, indicating that agonistic binding was both enthalpy- and entropy-driven, while antagonistic binding was totally entropy-driven. Agonists and antagonists were, therefore, thermodynamically discriminated. Experimental results were discussed with particular regard to the following points: 1) reasons why membrane receptors displayed unusually low values of deltaCo(p); 2) possible reasons for the phenomenon of thermodynamic discrimination between agonists and antagonists particularly in connection with ligand-gated ion channel receptors; and 3) the origin of the recurrent phenomenon of enthalpy-entropy compensation which has been observed for neuronal nicotinic receptor ligands as well as for all membrane receptors studied thus far.

Receptor binding thermodynamics as a tool for linking drug efficacy and affinity

Determination of drug-receptor binding constants (association, KA, or dissociation, KD = l/KA) by radiochemical specific binding assays has proved to be an invaluable tool for screening of potential active drugs. Simple determination of KA (or KD) values makes it possible, however, to calculate the standard free energy delta G degree = -RTln KA = RTln KD (T = 298.15 K) of the binding equilibrium but not that of its two components as defined by the Gibbs equation delta G degree = delta H degree - T delta S degree, where delta H degree and delta S degree are the equilibrium standard enthalpy and entropy, respectively. This incomplete knowledge is highly inconvenient from a pure thermodynamic point of view as delta H degree and delta S degree carry much information on the details of the drug-receptor interaction and the interplay of both reaction partners with the solvent. In recent times it has been shown that the relative delta H degree and delta S degree magnitudes can often give a simple 'in vitro' way for discriminating 'the effect', that is the manner in which the drug interferes with the signal transduction pathways. This particular effect, called 'thermodynamic discrimination', results from the fact that binding of antagonists may be enthalpy-driven and that of agonists entropy-driven, or vice versa. The first case of thermodynamic discrimination was reported for the beta-adrenergic G-protein coupled receptor (GPCR) and only recently has it been confirmed for adenosine A1 and A2a receptors. Only very recently has the binding thermodynamics of ligand-gated ion channel receptors (LGICR) been investigated and data for four receptors have been reported showing that all of them are thermodynamically discriminated. While it seems difficult at present to find a reasonable explanation for the thermodynamic discrimination phenomenon in GPCR, some hypotheses can be suggested for LGICR. Since global delta H degree and delta S degree values of the binding process are expected to be heavily affected by rearrangements occurring in the solvent, thermodynamic discrimination in LGICR is at least logically understandable admitting that the observed delta H degree (and then delta S degree) values are determined by both specific binding and abrupt variation of water-accessible receptor surfaces consequent to the setting up of the channel opening.

Binding thermodynamics of 5-HT1A receptor ligands

The thermodynamic parameters delta G degree, delta H degree and delta S degree of the binding equilibrium of 15 ligands (eight agonists and seven antagonists) to the 5-HT1A receptor subtype have been determined by affinity measurements carried out on rat cortex membranes (minus striatum) at six different temperatures (0, 10, 20, 25, 30, 35 degrees C), and by van't Hoff plots. Most of the compounds studied are tryptamine, phenylpiperazine and tetralin derivatives. Affinity constants were measured by saturation experiments for the selective 5-HT1A receptor agonist [3H]8-hydroxy-N,N-dipropyl-2-aminotetralin ([3H]8-OH-DPAT) and by inhibition assays of [3H]8-OH-DPAT binding for the other compounds. Scatchard plots were monophasic in the full range of temperatures, indicating a single class of high affinity binding sites. Van't Hoff plots of all ligands were linear in the temperature range investigated (0-30 degrees C or 0-35 degrees C). 5-Hydroxytryptamine (serotonin) and 5-methoxy-tryptamine (mexamine) displayed a positive slope. Experimental data indicate that for 5-HT1A receptor subtype agonists and antagonists are not thermodynamically discriminated. The results are discussed from a quantitative point of view with the aim of obtaining new details on the nature of the forces driving the 5-HT1A binding at a molecular level.