Evidence for non-cysteinyl coordination of the [2Fe-2S] cluster in Escherichia coli succinate dehydrogenase

Synergy of native mass spectrometry and other biophysical techniques in studies of iron‑sulfur cluster proteins and their assembly

The application of mass spectrometric methodologies has revolutionised biological chemistry, from identification through to structural and conformational studies of proteins and other macromolecules. Native mass spectrometry (MS), in which proteins retain their native structure, is a rapidly growing field. This is particularly the case for studies of metalloproteins, where non-covalently bound cofactors remain bound following ionisation. Such metalloproteins include those that contain an iron‑sulfur (FeS) cluster and, despite their fragility and O2 sensitivity, they have been a particular focus for applications of native MS because of its capacity to accurately monitor mass changes that reveal chemical changes at the cluster. Here we review recent advances in these applications of native MS, which, together with data from more traditionally applied biophysical methods, have yielded a remarkable breadth of information about the FeS species present, and provided key mechanistic insight not only for FeS cluster proteins themselves, but also their assembly.

Defining a direction: electron transfer and catalysis in Escherichia coli complex II enzymes

There are two homologous membrane-bound enzymes in Escherichia coli that catalyze reversible conversion between succinate/fumarate and quinone/quinol. Succinate:ubiquinone reductase (SQR) is a component of aerobic respiratory chains, whereas quinol:fumarate reductase (QFR) utilizes menaquinol to reduce fumarate in a final step of anaerobic respiration. Although, both protein complexes are capable of supporting bacterial growth on either minimal succinate or fumarate media, the enzymes are more proficient in their physiological directions. Here we evaluate factors that may underlie this catalytic bias. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Respiratory complex II: Role in cellular physiology and disease.

A Model Study on the Possible Effects of an External Electrical Field on Enzymes Having Dinuclear Iron Cluster [2Fe-2S]

Hydrogenases which catalyze the H₂↔ 2H⁺ + 2e⁻ reaction are metalloenzymes that can be divided into two classes, the NiFe and Fe enzymes, on the basis of their metal content. Iron-sulfur clusters [2Fe-2S] and [4Fe-4S] are common in ironhydrogenases. In the present model study, [2Fe-2S] cluster has been considered to visualize the effect of external electric field on various quantum chemical properties of it. In the model, all the cysteinyl residues are in the amide form. The PM3 type semiempirical calculations have been performed for the geometry optimization of the model structure in the absence and presence of the external field. Then, single point DFT calculations (B3LYP/6-31+G(d)) have been carried out. Depending on the direction of the field, the chemical reactivity of the model enzyme varies which suggests that an external electric field could, under proper conditions, improve the enzymatic hydrogen production.

Histidine 103 in Fra2 is an iron-sulfur cluster ligand in the [2Fe-2S] Fra2-Grx3 complex and is required for in vivo iron signaling in yeast

The BolA homologue Fra2 and the cytosolic monothiol glutaredoxins Grx3 and Grx4 together play a key role in regulating iron homeostasis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Genetic studies indicate that Grx3/4 and Fra2 regulate activity of the iron-responsive transcription factors Aft1 and Aft2 in response to mitochondrial Fe-S cluster biosynthesis. We have previously shown that Fra2 and Grx3/4 form a [2Fe-2S](2+)-bridged heterodimeric complex with iron ligands provided by the active site cysteine of Grx3/4, glutathione, and a histidine residue. To further characterize this unusual Fe-S-binding complex, site-directed mutagenesis was used to identify specific residues in Fra2 that influence Fe-S cluster binding and regulation of Aft1 activity in vivo. Here, we present spectroscopic evidence that His-103 in Fra2 is an Fe-S cluster ligand in the Fra2-Grx3 complex. Replacement of this residue does not abolish Fe-S cluster binding, but it does lead to a change in cluster coordination and destabilization of the [2Fe-2S] cluster. In vivo genetic studies further confirm that Fra2 His-103 is critical for control of Aft1 activity in response to the cellular iron status. Using CD spectroscopy, we find that ∼1 mol eq of apo-Fra2 binds tightly to the [2Fe-2S] Grx3 homodimer to form the [2Fe-2S] Fra2-Grx3 heterodimer, suggesting a mechanism for formation of the [2Fe-2S] Fra2-Grx3 heterodimer in vivo. Taken together, these results demonstrate that the histidine coordination and stability of the [2Fe-2S] cluster in the Fra2-Grx3 complex are essential for iron regulation in yeast.

Electron paramagnetic resonance and Mössbauer spectroscopy of intact mitochondria from respiring Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Mitochondria from respiring cells were isolated under anaerobic conditions. Microscopic images were largely devoid of contaminants, and samples consumed O(2) in an NADH-dependent manner. Protein and metal concentrations of packed mitochondria were determined, as was the percentage of external void volume. Samples were similarly packed into electron paramagnetic resonance tubes, either in the as-isolated state or after exposure to various reagents. Analyses revealed two signals originating from species that could be removed by chelation, including rhombic Fe(3+) (g = 4.3) and aqueous Mn(2+) ions (g = 2.00 with Mn-based hyperfine). Three S = 5/2 signals from Fe(3+) hemes were observed, probably arising from cytochrome c peroxidase and the a(3):Cu(b) site of cytochrome c oxidase. Three Fe/S-based signals were observed, with averaged g values of 1.94, 1.90 and 2.01. These probably arise, respectively, from the [Fe(2)S(2)](+) cluster of succinate dehydrogenase, the [Fe(2)S(2)](+) cluster of the Rieske protein of cytochrome bc (1), and the [Fe(3)S(4)](+) cluster of aconitase, homoaconitase or succinate dehydrogenase. Also observed was a low-intensity isotropic g = 2.00 signal arising from organic-based radicals, and a broad signal with g (ave) = 2.02. Mössbauer spectra of intact mitochondria were dominated by signals from Fe(4)S(4) clusters (60-85% of Fe). The major feature in as-isolated samples, and in samples treated with ethylenebis(oxyethylenenitrilo)tetraacetic acid, dithionite or O(2), was a quadrupole doublet with DeltaE (Q) = 1.15 mm/s and delta = 0.45 mm/s, assigned to [Fe(4)S(4)](2+) clusters. Substantial high-spin non-heme Fe(2+) (up to 20%) and Fe(3+) (up to 15%) species were observed. The distribution of Fe was qualitatively similar to that suggested by the mitochondrial proteome.

Succinate as Donor; Fumarate as Acceptor

Succinate and fumarate are four-carbon dicarboxylates that differ in the identity of their central bond (single or double). The oxidoreduction of these small molecules plays a central role in both aerobic and anaerobic respiration. During aerobic respiration, succinate is oxidized, donating two reducing equivalents, while in anaerobic respiration, fumarate is reduced, accepting two reducing equivalents. Two related integral membrane Complex II superfamily members catalyze these reactions, succinate:ubiquinone oxidoreductase (SQR) and fumarate:menaquinol oxidoreductase (QFR). The structure, function, and regulation of these integral-membrane enzymes are summarized here. The overall architecture of these Complex II enzymes has been found to consist of four subunits: two integral membrane subunits, and a soluble domain consisting of an iron-sulfur protein subunit, and a flavoprotein subunit. This architecture provides a scaffold that houses one active site in the membrane and another in the soluble milieu, making a linear electron transfer chain that facilities shuttling of reducing equivalents between the two active sites. A combination of kinetic measurements, mutagenesis, electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy, UV/Vis spectroscopy, and x-ray crystallography have suggested mechanisms for succinate:fumarate interconversion, electron transfer, and quinone:quinol interconversion. Of particular interest are the structural details that control directionality and make SQR and QFR primed for preferential catalysis each in different favored directions.

Function and structure of complex II of the respiratory chain

Complex II is the only membrane-bound component of the Krebs cycle and in addition functions as a member of the electron transport chain in mitochondria and in many bacteria. A recent X-ray structural solution of members of the complex II family of proteins has provided important insights into their function. One feature of the complex II structures is a linear electron transport chain that extends from the flavin and iron-sulfur redox cofactors in the membrane extrinsic domain to the quinone and b heme cofactors in the membrane domain. Exciting recent developments in relation to disease in humans and the formation of reactive oxygen species by complex II point to its overall importance in cellular physiology.

Complex II from phototrophic purple bacterium Rhodoferax fermentans displays rhodoquinol-fumarate reductase activity

It has long been accepted that bacterial quinol-fumarate reductase (QFR) generally uses a low-redox-potential naphthoquinone, menaquinone (MK), as the electron donor, whereas mitochondrial QFR from facultative and anaerobic eukaryotes uses a low-redox-potential benzoquinone, rhodoquinone (RQ), as the substrate. In the present study, we purified novel complex II from the RQ-containing phototrophic purple bacterium, Rhodoferax fermentans that exhibited high rhodoquinol-fumarate reductase activity in addition to succinate-ubiquinone reductase activity. SDS/PAGE indicated that the purified R. fermentans complex II comprises four subunits of 64.0, 28.6, 18.7 and 17.5 kDa and contains 1.3 nmol heme per mg protein. Phylogenetic analysis and comparison of the deduced amino acid sequences of R. fermentans complex II with pro/eukaryotic complex II indicate that the structure and the evolutional origins of R. fermentans complex II are closer to bacterial SQR than to mitochondrial rhodoquinol-fumarate reductase. The results strongly indicate that R. fermentans complex II and mitochondrial QFR might have evolved independently, although they both utilize RQ for fumarate reduction.

Architecture of succinate dehydrogenase and reactive oxygen species generation

The structure of Escherichia coli succinate dehydrogenase (SQR), analogous to the mitochondrial respiratory complex II, has been determined, revealing the electron transport pathway from the electron donor, succinate, to the terminal electron acceptor, ubiquinone. It was found that the SQR redox centers are arranged in a manner that aids the prevention of reactive oxygen species (ROS) formation at the flavin adenine dinucleotide. This is likely to be the main reason SQR is expressed during aerobic respiration rather than the related enzyme fumarate reductase, which produces high levels of ROS. Furthermore, symptoms of genetic disorders associated with mitochondrial SQR mutations may be a result of ROS formation resulting from impaired electron transport in the enzyme.

Quinol:fumarate oxidoreductases and succinate:quinone oxidoreductases: phylogenetic relationships, metal centres and membrane attachment

A comprehensive phylogenetic analysis of the core subunits of succinate:quinone oxidoreductases and quinol:fumarate oxidoreductases is performed, showing that the classification of the enzymes as type A to E based on the type of the membrane anchor fully correlates with the specific characteristics of the two core subunits. A special emphasis is given to the type E enzymes, which have an atypical association to the membrane, possibly involving anchor subunits with amphipathic helices. Furthermore, the redox properties of the SQR/QFR proteins are also reviewed, stressing out the recent observation of redox-Bohr effect upon haem reduction, observed for the Desulfovibrio gigas and Rhodothermus marinus enzymes, which indicates a direct protonation event at the haems or at a nearby residue. Finally, the possible contribution of these enzymes to the formation/dissipation of a transmembrane proton gradient is discussed, considering recent experimental and structural data.

Succinate dehydrogenase and fumarate reductase from Escherichia coli

Succinate-ubiquinone oxidoreductase (SQR) as part of the trichloroacetic acid cycle and menaquinol-fumarate oxidoreductase (QFR) used for anaerobic respiration by Escherichia coli are structurally and functionally related membrane-bound enzyme complexes. Each enzyme complex is composed of four distinct subunits. The recent solution of the X-ray structure of QFR has provided new insights into the function of these enzymes. Both enzyme complexes contain a catalytic domain composed of a subunit with a covalently bound flavin cofactor, the dicarboxylate binding site, and an iron-sulfur subunit which contains three distinct iron-sulfur clusters. The catalytic domain is bound to the cytoplasmic membrane by two hydrophobic membrane anchor subunits that also form the site(s) for interaction with quinones. The membrane domain of E. coli SQR is also the site where the heme b556 is located. The structure and function of SQR and QFR are briefly summarized in this communication and the similarities and differences in the membrane domain of the two enzymes are discussed.

Structure-function studies of iron-sulfur clusters and semiquinones in the NADH-Q oxidoreductase segment of the respiratory chain

Our recent experimental data on iron-sulfur clusters and semiquinones in the complex I segment of the respiratory chain is presented, focusing on the Paracoccus (P.) denitrificans and bovine heart studies. The iron-sulfur cluster N2 has attracted the attention of investigators in the research field of complex I, since the mid-point redox potential of this cluster is the highest among all clusters in complex I, and is pH dependent (60 mV/pH). It is known that this cluster is located either in the NQO6 (NuoB in E. coli/PSST in bovine heart nomenclature) or in the NQO9 (NuoI/TYKY) subunit in the amphipathic domain of complex I. Our preliminary data indicate that the cluster N2 is located in the NuoB rather than the long-advocated NuoI subunit, and may have a unique ligand structure. We previously reported spin-spin interactions between cluster N2 and two distinct species of semiquinone (designated SQNf and SQNs) associated with complex I. A parallel intensity change was observed between the SQNf (g = 2.00) signal and the N2 split g parallel signal, further supporting our proposed interaction between SQNf and N2 spins.

Iron-sulfur cluster cysteine-to-serine mutants of Anabaena -2Fe-2S- ferredoxin exhibit unexpected redox properties and are competent in electron transfer to ferredoxin:NADP+ reductase

The reduction potentials and the rate constants for electron transfer (et) to ferredoxin:NADP+ reductase (FNR) are reported for site-directed mutants of the [2Fe-2S] vegetative cell ferredoxin (Fd) from Anabaena PCC 7120, each of which has a cluster ligating cysteine residue mutated to serine (C41S, C46S, and C49S). The X-ray crystal structure of the C49S mutant has also been determined. The UV-visible optical and CD spectra of the mutants differ from each other and from wild-type (wt) Fd. This is a consequence of oxygen replacing one of the ligating cysteine sulfur atoms, thus altering the ligand --> Fe charge transfer transition energies and the chiro-optical properties of the chromophore. Each mutant is able to rapidly accept an electron from deazariboflavin semiquinone (dRfH.) and to transfer an electron from its reduced form to oxidized FNR although all are somewhat less reactive (30-50%) toward FNR and are appreciably less stable in solution than is wt Fd. Whereas the reduction potential of C46S (-381 mV) is not significantly altered from that of wt Fd (-384 mV), the potential of the C49S mutant (-329 mV) is shifted positively by 55 mV, demonstrating that the cluster potential is sensitive to mutations made at the ferric iron in reduced [2Fe-2S] Fds with localized valences. Despite the decrease in thermodynamic driving force for et from C49S to FNR, the et rate constant is similar to that measured for C46S. Thus, the et reactivity of the mutants does not correlate with altered reduction potentials. The et rate constants of the mutants also do not correlate with the apparent binding constants of the intermediate (Fdred:FNRox) complexes or with the ability of the prosthetic group to be reduced by dRfH.. Furthermore, the X-ray crystal structure of the C49S mutant is virtually identical to that of wt Fd. We conclude from these data that cysteine sulfur d-orbitals are not essential for et into or out of the iron atoms of the cluster and that the decreased et reactivity of these Fd mutants toward FNR may be due to small changes in the mutual orientation of the proteins within the intermediate complex and/or alterations in the electronic structure of the [2Fe-2S] cluster.

Site-directed mutagenesis and spectroscopic characterization of human ferrochelatase: identification of residues coordinating the [2Fe-2S] cluster

The five cysteines closest to the carboxyl terminus of human ferrochelatase have been individually mutated to serine, histidine, or aspartate residues in an attempt to identify the protein ligands to the [2Fe-2S] cluster. Mutations of cysteines at positions 403, 406, and 411 (C403D, C403H, C406D, C406H, C406S, C411H, and C411S mutants) all resulted in inactive enzyme that failed to assemble the [2Fe-2S] cluster as judged by whole-cell EPR studies. In contrast, mutation of the cysteines at positions 360 and 395 to serines (C360S and C395S mutants) did not affect the enzymatic activity, and the resulting enzyme assembled a [2Fe-2S] cluster that was spectroscopically indistinguishable from the wild-type enzyme. The results indicate that three of the conserved cysteines in the 30-residue C-terminal extension of mammalian ferrochelatase are involved in ligating the [2Fe-2S] cluster. Resonance Raman and variable-temperature magnetic circular dichroism studies of heme-free preparations of human ferrochelatase are reported, and the spectra are best interpreted in terms of one non-cysteinyl, oxygenic ligand for the [2Fe-2S] cluster. Such anomalous coordination could account for the cluster lability compared to similar clusters with complete cysteinyl ligation and hence may be intrinsic to the proposed regulatory role for this cluster in mammalian ferrochelatases.

Human ferredoxin: overproduction in Escherichia coli, reconstitution in vitro, and spectroscopic studies of iron-sulfur cluster ligand cysteine-to-serine mutants

Human ferredoxin, the human equivalent of bovine adrenodoxin, is a small iron-sulfur protein with one [2Fe-2S] cluster. It functions, as do other vertebrate ferredoxins, to transfer electrons during the processes of steroid hormone synthesis. A DNA fragment encoding the mature form of human ferredoxin was cloned into an expression vector under control of the T7 RNA polymerase/promoter system. The protein was overproduced in Escherichia coli, and the [2Fe-2S] cluster was incorporated into the protein by in vitro reconstitution. The overall yield was approximately 30 mg of purified, reconstituted ferredoxin per liter of culture. Four of the five cysteines in human ferredoxin are coordinated to the iron-sulfur cluster. First, the non-ligand cysteine (cysteine-95) was mutated to alanine, and then double mutants were created in which each of the other four cysteines (at positions 46, 52, 55, and 92) were mutated individually to serine. The wild-type ferredoxin and each of the five mutant proteins were studied by UV-visible spectroscopy and electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy. The EPR gav values of all five mutants were very similar to that of wild-type human ferredoxin. In the reduced state, three of the cysteine-to-serine mutants exhibited axial EPR spectra similar to that of wild-type, but one of the double mutants (C52S/C95A) exhibited a rhombic EPR spectrum. The UV-visible spectroscopic properties of the wild-type and the C95A mutant ferredoxins were identical, but those of the other cysteine-to-serine mutant proteins of human ferredoxin were quite different from those of the wild-type protein and each other. These results, along with those from cysteine-to-serine mutations in other ferredoxins, provide the basis for a more comprehensive theoretical and practical understanding of the features important to the ligation of [2Fe-2S] clusters, although they do not yet permit determination of which two cysteines ligate Fe(II) and which ligate Fe(III) in the reduced protein.

The role of threonine 54 in adrenodoxin for the properties of its iron-sulfur cluster and its electron transfer function

The amino acid in position 54 of adrenodoxin is strongly conserved among ferredoxins, consisting of a threonine or serine. Its role was studied by analyzing mutants T54S and T54A of bovine adrenodoxin. Absorption, circular dichroism, fluorescence, and electron paramagnetic resonance spectra of mutant T54S show that this substitution has no influence on the formation and stability of the ferredoxin. The redox potential of this mutant, however, was lowered by 55 mV as compared with native adrenodoxin, indicating a role for this residue in redox potential modulation. Incorporation of the iron-sulfur cluster was not impaired in the T54A mutant, although structural features of the oxidized protein were considerably changed. The decreased stability of the T54A mutant as compared with the wild type and mutant T54S indicates that a hydrogen bond donor at this position stabilizes the protein. Both mutants have been shown to be functionally active. Replacement of threonine 54 by serine or alanine, however, leads to rearrangements at the recognition sites for its redox partners. This is reflected by decreased Km and Kd values of both mutants for the cytochromes P450, whereas only T54A displayed a decreased Km value in cytochrome c reduction. Substrate conversion was accelerated (2.2- and 2.4-fold for mutants T54A and T54S, respectively) in the CYP11B1-, but not in the CYP11A1-dependent reaction.

Site-directed mutagenesis of Azotobacter vinelandii ferredoxin I: cysteine ligation of the [4Fe-4S] cluster with protein rearrangement is preferred over serine ligation

The [4Fe-4S] cluster of Azotobacter vinelandii ferredoxin I receives three of its four ligands from a Cys-Xaa-Xaa-Cys-Xaa-Xaa-Cys sequence at positions 39-45 while the fourth ligand, Cys20, is provided by a distal portion of the sequence. Previously we reported that the site-directed mutation of Cys20 to Ala (C20A protein) resulted in the formation of a new [4Fe-4S] cluster that obtained its fourth ligand from Cys24, a free cysteine in the native structure. That ligand exchange required significant protein rearrangement. Here we report the conversion of Cys20 to Ser (C20S protein), which gives the protein the opportunity either to retain the native structure and use the Ser20 O gamma as a ligand or to rearrange and use Cys24. X-ray crystallography demonstrates that the cluster does not use the Ser20 O gamma as a ligand; rather it rearranges to use Cys24. In the C20S protein the [4Fe-4S] cluster has altered stability and redox properties relative to either C20A or the native protein.

Overproduction and physical characterization of SoxR, a [2Fe-2S] protein that governs an oxidative response regulon in Escherichia coli

SoxR protein governs the soxRS (superoxide response) regulon of Escherichia coli by becoming a transcriptional activator when the cells are exposed to compounds that mediate univalent redox reactions, many of which produce superoxide as a by-product. SoxR was overproduced and purified to near homogeneity from a strain bearing an expression vector. It could bind specifically to the soxS operator even in the absence of RNA polymerase. The aerobically purified protein, which is readily autooxidized, could activate the transcription of soxS DNA even without exposure to known inducing agents. SoxR is a globular homodimer. It contains one [2Fe-2S] cluster per polypeptide chain, as demonstrated by optical and EPR spectroscopy combined with stoichiometric analysis of iron content, unpaired-electron-spin density, and reduction by dithionite. The protein is active in its oxidized ([2Fe-2S]2+) state. The presence of a prosthetic group capable of univalent redox reactions may help to explain the activation of the regulon in vivo by compounds that can mediate such reactions.

Expression and functional properties of fumarate reductase

Images

ESEEM studies of the iron-sulphur clusters of succinate dehydrogenase in Arum maculatum spadix mitochondrial membranes

We have performed ESEEM spectroscopy in order to obtain structural information about the environment of the [2Fe-2S] cluster and the [3Fe-4S] cluster of succinate dehydrogenase (Centres 1 and 3, respectively) in intact Arum maculatum mitochondrial membranes. Both iron-sulphur clusters showed modulations indicative of 14N in the three-pulse echo decay envelopes. We have estimated the hyperfine couplings for the reduced [2Fe-2S] cluster (A approximately 1.1 MHz) and the oxidised [3Fe-4S] cluster (A approximately 0.8 MHz). Our results are compared with ESEEM data obtained for purified [2Fe-2S] cluster-containing proteins, namely Spirulina platensis ferredoxin, a protein for which the three-dimensional structure is known, and Escherichia coli fumarate reductase. The hyperfine and quadrupolar coupling parameters determined are consistent with a weak interaction of Centre 1 and Centre 3 with peptide 14N, rather than 14N of imidazole rings.