New reactions of the ribosomal RNA precursor of Tetrahymena and the mechanism of self-splicing

Biogenesis and Regulatory Roles of Circular RNAs

Covalently closed, single-stranded circular RNAs can be produced from viral RNA genomes as well as from the processing of cellular housekeeping noncoding RNAs and precursor messenger RNAs. Recent transcriptomic studies have surprisingly uncovered that many protein-coding genes can be subjected to backsplicing, leading to widespread expression of a specific type of circular RNAs (circRNAs) in eukaryotic cells. Here, we discuss experimental strategies used to discover and characterize diverse circRNAs at both the genome and individual gene scales. We further highlight the current understanding of how circRNAs are generated and how the mature transcripts function. Some circRNAs act as noncoding RNAs to impact gene regulation by serving as decoys or competitors for microRNAs and proteins. Others form extensive networks of ribonucleoprotein complexes or encode functional peptides that are translated in response to certain cellular stresses. Overall, circRNAs have emerged as an important class of RNAmolecules in gene expression regulation that impact many physiological processes, including early development, immune responses, neurogenesis, and tumorigenesis.

Sub-3-Å cryo-EM structure of RNA enabled by engineered homomeric self-assembly

High-resolution structural studies are essential for understanding the folding and function of diverse RNAs. Herein, we present a nanoarchitectural engineering strategy for efficient structural determination of RNA-only structures using single-particle cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM). This strategy-ROCK (RNA oligomerization-enabled cryo-EM via installing kissing loops)-involves installing kissing-loop sequences onto the functionally nonessential stems of RNAs for homomeric self-assembly into closed rings with multiplied molecular weights and mitigated structural flexibility. ROCK enables cryo-EM reconstruction of the Tetrahymena group I intron at 2.98-Å resolution overall (2.85 Å for the core), allowing de novo model building of the complete RNA, including the previously unknown peripheral domains. ROCK is further applied to two smaller RNAs-the Azoarcus group I intron and the FMN riboswitch, revealing the conformational change of the former and the bound ligand in the latter. ROCK holds promise to greatly facilitate the use of cryo-EM in RNA structural studies.

How to Kinetically Dissect an RNA Machine

RNA-based machines are ubiquitous in Nature and increasingly important for medicines. They fold into complex, dynamic structures that process information and catalyze reactions, including reactions that generate new RNAs and proteins across biology. What are the experimental strategies and steps that are necessary to understand how these complex machines work? Two 1990 papers from Herschlag and Cech on "Catalysis of RNA Cleavage by the Tetrahymena thermophila Ribozyme" provide a master class in dissecting an RNA machine through kinetics approaches. By showing how to propose a kinetic framework, fill in the numbers, do cross-checks, and make comparisons across mutants and different RNA systems, the papers illustrate how to take a mechanistic approach and distill the results into general insights that are difficult to attain through other means.

Multi-metal-dependent nucleic acid enzymes

Nucleic acid enzymes require metal ions for activity, and many recently discovered enzymes can use multiple metals, either binding to the scissile phosphate or also playing an allosteric role.

Accumulation of Stable Full-Length Circular Group I Intron RNAs during Heat-Shock

Group I introns in nuclear ribosomal RNA of eukaryotic microorganisms are processed by splicing or circularization. The latter results in formation of full-length circular introns without ligation of the exons and has been proposed to be active in intron mobility. We applied qRT-PCR to estimate the copy number of circular intron RNA from the myxomycete Didymium iridis. In exponentially growing amoebae, the circular introns are nuclear and found in 70 copies per cell. During heat-shock, the circular form is up-regulated to more than 500 copies per cell. The intron harbours two ribozymes that have the potential to linearize the circle. To understand the structural features that maintain circle integrity, we performed chemical and enzymatic probing of the splicing ribozyme combined with molecular modeling to arrive at models of the inactive circular form and its active linear counterpart. We show that the two forms have the same overall structure but differ in key parts, including the catalytic core element P7 and the junctions at which reactions take place. These differences explain the relative stability of the circular species, demonstrate how it is prone to react with a target molecule for circle integration and thus supports the notion that the circular form is a biologically significant molecule possibly with a role in intron mobility.

RNA circularization strategies in vivo and in vitro

In the plenitude of naturally occurring RNAs, circular RNAs (circRNAs) and their biological role were underestimated for years. However, circRNAs are ubiquitous in all domains of life, including eukaryotes, archaea, bacteria and viruses, where they can fulfill diverse biological functions. Some of those functions, as for example playing a role in the life cycle of viral and viroid genomes or in the maturation of tRNA genes, have been elucidated; other putative functions still remain elusive. Due to the resistance to exonucleases, circRNAs are promising tools for in vivo application as aptamers, trans-cleaving ribozymes or siRNAs. How are circRNAs generated in vivo and what approaches do exist to produce ring-shaped RNAs in vitro? In this review we illustrate the occurrence and mechanisms of RNA circularization in vivo, survey methods for the generation of circRNA in vitro and provide appropriate protocols.

Evolution of RNA-protein interactions: non-specific binding led to RNA splicing activity of fungal mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetases

Studies of tRNA synthetases that adapted to assist the splicing of group I introns provide insight into how proteins can evolve new RNA-binding functions.

The Neurospora crassa mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (mtTyrRS; CYT-18 protein) evolved a new function as a group I intron splicing factor by acquiring the ability to bind group I intron RNAs and stabilize their catalytically active RNA structure. Previous studies showed: (i) CYT-18 binds group I introns by using both its N-terminal catalytic domain and flexibly attached C-terminal anticodon-binding domain (CTD); and (ii) the catalytic domain binds group I introns specifically via multiple structural adaptations that occurred during or after the divergence of Peziomycotina and Saccharomycotina. However, the function of the CTD and how it contributed to the evolution of splicing activity have been unclear. Here, small angle X-ray scattering analysis of CYT-18 shows that both CTDs of the homodimeric protein extend outward from the catalytic domain, but move inward to bind opposite ends of a group I intron RNA. Biochemical assays show that the isolated CTD of CYT-18 binds RNAs non-specifically, possibly contributing to its interaction with the structurally different ends of the intron RNA. Finally, we find that the yeast mtTyrRS, which diverged from Pezizomycotina fungal mtTyrRSs prior to the evolution of splicing activity, binds group I intron and other RNAs non-specifically via its CTD, but lacks further adaptations needed for group I intron splicing. Our results suggest a scenario of constructive neutral (i.e., pre-adaptive) evolution in which an initial non-specific interaction between the CTD of an ancestral fungal mtTyrRS and a self-splicing group I intron was “fixed” by an intron RNA mutation that resulted in protein-dependent splicing. Once fixed, this interaction could be elaborated by further adaptive mutations in both the catalytic domain and CTD that enabled specific binding of group I introns. Our results highlight a role for non-specific RNA binding in the evolution of RNA-binding proteins.

The acquisition of new modes of post-transcriptional gene regulation played an important role in the evolution of eukaryotes and was achieved by an increase in the number of RNA-binding proteins with new functions. RNA-binding proteins bind directly to double- or single-stranded RNA and regulate many cellular processes. Here, we address how proteins evolve new RNA-binding functions by using as a model system a fungal mitochondrial tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase that evolved to acquire a novel function in splicing group I introns. Group I introns are RNA enzymes (or “ribozymes”) that catalyze their own removal from transcripts, but can become dependent upon proteins to stabilize their active structure. We show that the C-terminal domain of the synthetase is flexibly attached and has high non-specific RNA-binding activity that likely pre-dated the evolution of splicing activity. Our findings suggest an evolutionary scenario in which an initial non-specific interaction between an ancestral synthetase and a self-splicing group I intron was fixed by an intron RNA mutation, thereby making it dependent upon the protein for structural stabilization. The interaction then evolved by the acquisition of adaptive mutations throughout the protein and RNA that increased both the splicing efficiency and its protein-dependence. Our results suggest a general mechanism by which non-specific binding interactions can lead to the evolution of new RNA-binding functions and provide novel insights into splicing and synthetase mechanisms.

Computational prediction of efficient splice sites for trans-splicing ribozymes

Group I introns have been engineered into trans-splicing ribozymes capable of replacing the 3'-terminal portion of an external mRNA with their own 3'-exon. Although this design makes trans-splicing ribozymes potentially useful for therapeutic application, their trans-splicing efficiency is usually too low for medical use. One factor that strongly influences trans-splicing efficiency is the position of the target splice site on the mRNA substrate. Viable splice sites are currently determined using a biochemical trans-tagging assay. Here, we propose a rapid and inexpensive alternative approach to identify efficient splice sites. This approach involves the computation of the binding free energies between ribozyme and mRNA substrate. We found that the computed binding free energies correlate well with the trans-splicing efficiency experimentally determined at 18 different splice sites on the mRNA of chloramphenicol acetyl transferase. In contrast, our results from the trans-tagging assay correlate less well with measured trans-splicing efficiency. The computed free energy components suggest that splice site efficiency depends on the following secondary structure rearrangements: hybridization of the ribozyme's internal guide sequence (IGS) with mRNA substrate (most important), unfolding of substrate proximal to the splice site, and release of the IGS from the 3'-exon (least important). The proposed computational approach can also be extended to fulfill additional design requirements of efficient trans-splicing ribozymes, such as the optimization of 3'-exon and extended guide sequences.

RNA reprogramming and repair based on trans-splicing group I ribozymes

While many traditional gene therapy strategies attempt to deliver new copies of wild-type genes back to cells harboring the defective genes, RNA-directed strategies offer a range of novel therapeutic applications. Revision or reprogramming of mRNA is a form of gene therapy that modifies mRNA without directly changing the transcriptional regulation or the genomic gene sequence. Group I ribozymes can be engineered to act in trans by recognizing a separate RNA molecule in a sequence-specific manner, and to covalently link a new RNA sequence to this separate RNA molecule. Group I ribozymes have been shown to repair defective transcripts that cause human genetic or malignant diseases, as well as to replace transcript sequences by foreign RNA resulting in new cellular functions. This review provides an overview of current strategies using trans-splicing group I ribozymes in RNA repair and reprogramming.

Mechanistic insights from reversible splicing catalysis

Recent work demonstrating the ability of spliceosomes purified after the second catalytic step of splicing to efficiently reverse both steps of the reaction provides answers to several unresolved questions regarding the splicing reaction, and raises many more.

Toward predicting self-splicing and protein-facilitated splicing of group I introns

In the current era of massive discoveries of noncoding RNAs within genomes, being able to infer a function from a nucleotide sequence is of paramount interest. Although studies of individual group I introns have identified self-splicing and nonself-splicing examples, there is no overall understanding of the prevalence of self-splicing or the factors that determine it among the >2300 group I introns sequenced to date. Here, the self-splicing activities of 12 group I introns from various organisms were assayed under six reaction conditions that had been shown previously to promote RNA catalysis for different RNAs. Besides revealing that assessing self-splicing under only one condition can be misleading, this survey emphasizes that in vitro self-splicing efficiency is correlated with the GC content of the intron (>35% GC was generally conductive to self-splicing), and with the ability of the introns to form particular tertiary interactions. Addition of the Neurospora crassa CYT-18 protein activated splicing of two nonself-splicing introns, but inhibited the second step of self-splicing for two others. Together, correlations between sequence, predicted structure and splicing begin to establish rules that should facilitate our ability to predict the self-splicing activity of any group I intron from its sequence.

Tetrahymena thermophila and Candida albicans group I intron-derived ribozymes can catalyze the trans-excision-splicing reaction

Group I intron-derived ribozymes can catalyze a variety of non-native reactions. For the trans-excision-splicing (TES) reaction, an intron-derived ribozyme from the opportunistic pathogen Pneumocystis carinii catalyzes the excision of a predefined region from within an RNA substrate with subsequent ligation of the flanking regions. To establish TES as a general ribozyme-mediated reaction, intron-derived ribozymes from Tetrahymena thermophila and Candida albicans, which are similar to but not the same as that from Pneumocystis, were investigated for their propensity to catalyze the TES reaction. We now report that the Tetrahymena and Candida ribozymes can catalyze the excision of a single nucleotide from within their ribozyme-specific substrates. Under the conditions studied, the Tetrahymena and Candida ribozymes, however, catalyze the TES reaction with lower yields and rates [Tetrahymena (k(obs)) = 0.14/min and Candida (k(obs)) = 0.34/min] than the Pneumocystis ribozyme (k(obs) = 3.2/min). The lower yields are likely partially due to the fact that the Tetrahymena and Candida catalyze additional reactions, separate from TES. The differences in rates are likely partially due to the individual ribozymes ability to effectively bind their 3' terminal guanosines as intramolecular nucleophiles. Nevertheless, our results demonstrate that group I intron-derived ribozymes are inherently able to catalyze the TES reaction.

Kinetic characterization of the first step of the ribozyme-catalyzed trans excision-splicing reaction

Group I introns catalyze the self-splicing reaction, and their derived ribozymes are frequently used as model systems for the study of RNA folding and catalysis, as well as for the development of non-native catalytic reactions. Utilizing a group I intron-derived ribozyme from Pneumocystis carinii, we previously reported a non-native reaction termed trans excision-splicing (TES). In this reaction, an internal segment of RNA is excised from an RNA substrate, resulting in the covalent reattachment of the flanking regions. TES proceeds through two consecutive phosphotransesterification reactions, which are similar to the reaction steps of self-splicing. One key difference is that TES utilizes the 3'-terminal guanosine of the ribozyme as the first-step nucleophile, whereas self-splicing utilizes an exogenous guanosine. To further aid in our understanding of ribozyme reactions, a kinetic framework for the first reaction step (substrate cleavage) was established. The results demonstrate that the substrate binds to the ribozyme at a rate expected for simple helix formation. In addition, the rate constant for the first step of the TES reaction is more than one order of magnitude lower than the analogous step in self-splicing. Results also suggest that a conformational change, likely similar to that in self-splicing, exists between the two reaction steps of TES. Finally, multiple turnover is curtailed because dissociation of the cleavage product is slower than the rate of chemistry.

A Pneumocystis carinii group I intron-derived ribozyme utilizes an endogenous guanosine as the first reaction step nucleophile in the trans excision-splicing reaction

In the trans excision-splicing reaction, a Pneumocystis carinii group I intron-derived ribozyme binds an RNA substrate, excises a specific internal segment, and ligates the flanking regions back together. This reaction can occur both in vitro and in vivo. In this report, the first of the two reaction steps was analyzed to distinguish between two reaction mechanisms: ribozyme-mediated hydrolysis and nucleotide-dependent intramolecular transesterification. We found that the 3'-terminal nucleotide of the ribozyme is the first-reaction step nucleophile. In addition, the 3'-half of the RNA substrate becomes covalently attached to the 3'-terminal nucleotide of the ribozyme during the reaction, both in vitro and in vivo. Results also show that the identity of the 3'-terminal nucleotide influences the rate of the intramolecular transesterification reaction, with guanosine being more effective than adenosine. Finally, expected products of the hydrolysis mechanism do not form during the reaction. These results are consistent with only the intramolecular transesterification mechanism. Unexpectedly, we also found that ribozyme constructs become truncated in vivo, probably through intramolecular 3'-hydrolysis (self-activation), to create functional 3'-terminal nucleotides.

The paradoxical behavior of a highly structured misfolded intermediate in RNA folding

Like many structured RNAs, the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme is prone to misfolding. Here we probe a long-lived misfolded species, referred to as M, and uncover paradoxical aspects of its structure and folding. Previous work indicated that a non-native local secondary structure, termed alt P3, led to formation of M during folding in vitro. Surprisingly, hydroxyl radical footprinting, fluorescence measurements with site-specifically incorporated 2-aminopurine, and functional assays indicate that the native P3, not alt P3, is present in the M state. The paradoxical behavior of alt P3 presumably arises because alt P3 biases folding toward M, but, after commitment to this folding pathway and before formation of M, alt P3 is replaced by P3. Further, structural and functional probes demonstrate that the misfolded ribozyme contains extensive native structure, with only local differences between the two states, and the misfolded structure even possesses partial catalytic activity. Despite the similarity of these structures, re-folding of M to the native state is very slow and is strongly accelerated by urea, Na+, and increased temperature and strongly impeded by Mg2+ and the presence of native peripheral contacts. The paradoxical observations of extensive native structure within the misfolded species but slow conversion of this species to the native state are readily reconciled by a model in which the misfolded state is a topological isomer of the native state, and computational results support the feasibility of this model. We speculate that the complex topology of RNA secondary structures and the inherent rigidity of RNA helices render kinetic traps due to topological isomers considerably more common for RNA than for proteins.

A peripheral element assembles the compact core structure essential for group I intron self-splicing

The presence of non-conserved peripheral elements in all naturally occurring group I introns underline their importance in ensuring the natural intron function. Recently, we reported that some peripheral elements are conserved in group I introns of IE subgroup. Using self-splicing activity as a readout, our initial screening revealed that one such conserved peripheral elements, P2.1, is mainly required to fold the catalytically active structure of the Candida ribozyme, an IE intron. Unexpectedly, the essential function of P2.1 resides in a sequence-conserved short stem of P2.1 but not in a long-range interaction associated with the loop of P2.1 that stabilizes the ribozyme structure. The P2.1 stem is indispensable in folding the compact ribozyme core, most probably by forming a triple helical interaction with two core helices, P3 and P6. Surprisingly, although the ribozyme lacking the P2.1 stem renders a loosely folded core and the loss of self-splicing activity requires two consecutive transesterifications, the mutant ribozyme efficiently catalyzes the first transesterification reaction. These results suggest that the intron self-splicing demands much more ordered structure than does one independent transesterification, highlighting that the universally present peripheral elements achieve their functional importance by enabling the highly ordered structure through diverse tertiary interactions.

Long-term evolution of the S788 fungal nuclear small subunit rRNA group I introns

More than 1000 group I introns have been identified in fungal rDNA. Little is known, however, of the splicing and secondary structure evolution of these ribozymes. Here, we use a combination of comparative and biochemical methods to address the evolution and splicing of a vertically inherited group I intron found at position 788 in the fungal small subunit (S) rRNA. The ancestral state of the S788 intron contains a highly conserved core and an extended P5 domain typical of IC1 introns. In contrast, the more derived introns have lost most of P5, and have an accelerated divergence rate within the core region with three functionally important substitutions that unambiguously separate them from the ancestral pool. Of 14 S788 group I introns that were tested for splicing, five, all of the ancestral type, were able to self-splice and produced intron RNA circles in vitro. The more derived S788 introns did not self-splice, and potentially rely on fungal-specific factors to facilitate splicing. In summary, we demonstrate one possible fate of vertically inherited group I introns, the loss of secondary structure elements, lessened selective constraints in the intron core, and ultimately, dependence on host-mediated splicing.

Single-Cell Detection of Trans-Splicing Ribozyme In Vivo Activity

The Tetrahymena trans-splicing ribozyme can edit RNA in a sequence-specific manner, but its efficiency needs to be improved for any functional rescues. This communication describes a simple method that uses a bacterial enzyme beta-lactamase to report trans-splicing activity of Tetrahymena ribozyme in single living mammalian cells by fluorescence microscopy and flow cytometry. This enzyme-based single-cell detection method is highly sensitive and compatible with living cell flow cytometry, and should allow a cell-based systematic screening of a vast library of ribozymes for better trans-spliced ribozyme variants.

The ability to form full-length intron RNA circles is a general property of nuclear group I introns

In addition to splicing, group I intron RNA is capable of an alternative two-step processing pathway that results in the formation of full-length intron circular RNA. The circularization pathway is initiated by hydrolytic cleavage at the 3' splice site and followed by a transesterification reaction in which the intron terminal guanosine attacks the 5' splice site presented in a structure analogous to that of the first step of splicing. The products of the reactions are full-length circular intron and unligated exons. For this reason, the circularization reaction is to the benefit of the intron at the expense of the host. The circularization pathway has distinct structural requirements that differ from those of splicing and appears to be specifically suppressed in vivo. The ability to form full-length circles is found in all types of nuclear group I introns, including those from the Tetrahymena ribosomal DNA. The biological function of the full-length circles is not known, but the fact that the circles contain the entire genetic information of the intron suggests a role in intron mobility.

Functional repair of a mutant chloride channel using a trans-splicing ribozyme

RNA repair has been proposed as a novel gene-based therapeutic strategy. Modified Tetrahymena group I intron ribozymes have been used to mediate trans-splicing of therapeutically relevant RNA transcripts, but the efficiency of the ribozyme-mediated RNA repair process has not been determined precisely and subsequent restoration of protein function has been demonstrated only by indirect means. We engineered a ribozyme that targets the mRNA of a mutant canine skeletal muscle chloride channel (cClC-1) (mutation T268M in ClC-1 causing myotonia congenita) and replaces the mutant-containing 3' portion by trans-splicing the corresponding 4-kb wild-type sequence. Repair efficiency assessed by quantitative RT-PCR was 1.2% +/- 0.1% in a population of treated cells. However, when chloride channel function was examined in single cells, a wide range of electrophysiological activity was observed, with 18% of cells exhibiting significant functional restoration and some cells exhibiting complete rescue of the biophysical phenotype. These results indicate that RNA repair can restore wild-type protein activity and reveal considerable cell-to-cell variability in ribozyme-mediated trans-splicing reaction efficiency.

Functional repair of a mutant chloride channel using a trans-splicing ribozyme

RNA repair has been proposed as a novel gene-based therapeutic strategy. Modified Tetrahymena group I intron ribozymes have been used to mediate trans-splicing of therapeutically relevant RNA transcripts, but the efficiency of the ribozyme-mediated RNA repair process has not been determined precisely and subsequent restoration of protein function has been demonstrated only by indirect means. We engineered a ribozyme that targets the mRNA of a mutant canine skeletal muscle chloride channel (cClC-1) (mutation T268M in ClC-1 causing myotonia congenita) and replaces the mutant-containing 3' portion by trans-splicing the corresponding 4-kb wild-type sequence. Repair efficiency assessed by quantitative RT-PCR was 1.2% +/- 0.1% in a population of treated cells. However, when chloride channel function was examined in single cells, a wide range of electrophysiological activity was observed, with 18% of cells exhibiting significant functional restoration and some cells exhibiting complete rescue of the biophysical phenotype. These results indicate that RNA repair can restore wild-type protein activity and reveal considerable cell-to-cell variability in ribozyme-mediated trans-splicing reaction efficiency.

Excision of group II introns as circles

Group II introns are usually removed from precursor RNAs as lariats comprised of a circular component and a short 3' tail. We find that group II introns can also be excised as complete circles. Circle formation requires release of the 3' exon of a splicing substrate, apparently by a trans splicing mechanism. After 3' exon release, the terminal uridine of the intron attacks the 5' splice site, releasing the 5' exon and joining the first and last intron residues by a 2'-5' phosphodiester bond. RNA isolated from yeast mitochondria also contains circles, indicating that at least one group II intron (aI2) forms circles in vivo. Furthermore, analysis of RNA and DNA from certain mutant yeast strains shows that circular DNA introns exist and are produced by reverse transcription of RNA, rather than by ectopic homing.

Recent advances in the elucidation of the mechanisms of action of ribozymes

The cleavage of RNA can be accelerated by a number of factors. These factors include an acidic group (Lewis acid) or a basic group that aids in the deprotonation of the attacking nucleophile, in effect enhancing the nucleophilicity of the nucleophile; an acidic group that can neutralize and stabilize the leaving group; and any environment that can stabilize the pentavalent species that is either a transition state or a short-lived intermediate. The catalytic properties of ribozymes are due to factors that are derived from the complicated and specific structure of the ribozyme-substrate complex. It was postulated initially that nature had adopted a rather narrowly defined mechanism for the cleavage of RNA. However, recent findings have clearly demonstrated the diversity of the mechanisms of ribozyme-catalyzed reactions. Such mechanisms include the metal-independent cleavage that occurs in reactions catalyzed by hairpin ribozymes and the general double-metal-ion mechanism of catalysis in reactions catalyzed by the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme. Furthermore, the architecture of the complex between the substrate and the hepatitis delta virus ribozyme allows perturbation of the pK(a) of ring nitrogens of cytosine and adenine. The resultant perturbed ring nitrogens appear to be directly involved in acid/base catalysis. Moreover, while high concentrations of monovalent metal ions or polyamines can facilitate cleavage by hammerhead ribozymes, divalent metal ions are the most effective acid/base catalysts under physiological conditions.

Recognition of nucleoside triphosphates during RNA-catalyzed primer extension

In support of the idea that certain RNA molecules might be able to catalyze RNA replication, a ribozyme was previously generated that synthesizes short segments of RNA in a reaction modeled after that of proteinaceous RNA polymerases. Here, we describe substrate recognition by this polymerase ribozyme. Altering base or sugar moieties of the nucleoside triphosphate only moderately affects its utilization, provided that the alterations do not disrupt Watson-Crick pairing to the template. Correctly paired nucleotides have both a lower K(m) and a higher k(cat), suggesting that differential binding and orientation each play roles in discriminating matched from mismatched nucleotides. Binding of the pyrophosphate leaving group appears weak, as evidenced by a very inefficient pyrophosphate-exchange reaction, the reverse of the primer-extension reaction. Indeed, substitutions at the gamma-phosphate can be tolerated, although poorly. Thio substitutions of oxygen atoms at the reactive phosphate exert effects similar to those seen with cellular polymerases, leaving open the possibility of an active site analogous to those of protein enzymes. The polymerase ribozyme, derived from an efficient RNA ligase ribozyme, can achieve the very fast k(cat) of the parent ribozyme when the substrate of the polymerase (GTP) is replaced by an extended substrate (pppGGA), in which the GA dinucleotide extension corresponds to the second and third nucleotides of the ligase. This suggests that the GA dinucleotide, which had been deleted when converting the ligase into a polymerase, plays an important role in orienting the 5'-terminal nucleoside. Polymerase constructs that restore this missing orientation function should achieve much more efficient and perhaps more accurate RNA polymerization.

A small structural element, Pc-J5/5a, plays dual roles in a group IC1 intron RNA

The P4-P6 domain of group IC1 intron ribozymes such as that of the Tetrahymena autonomously folds into a hairpin-shaped structure in which the J5/5a region serves as a hinge. Phylogenetic comparisons of these IC1 introns suggested that the J5/5a region (termed Pc-J5/5a motif) in a subclass of IC1 introns such as the one from Pneumocystis carinii functions not only as a hinge but also as a receptor for a GAAA-tetraloop. We investigated the role of this motif by transplanting the structural unit, Pc-J5/5a motif, of Pneumocystis carinii into the P4-P6 domain of the Tetrahymena intron. The results showed that the Pc-J5/5a motif binds to a GAAA loop with high affinity and also facilitates the bending of the Tetrahymena P4-P6 domain more positively than the original J5/5a region.

Characterization of P8 and J8/7 elements in the conserved core of the tetrahymena group I intron ribozyme

The universally conserved core region in the group I intron ribozymes is responsible for its catalytic activity. The structural elements in this region have been known to organize the active site of this class of ribozymes. However, it has been unclear whether all elements are requisite or some elements are dispensable for conducting the catalysis. To investigate the necessity of these elements in the catalysis, we prepared and examined a series of mutants having a nick or deletion in these elements. In this report, we show that two elements, P8 and 5' portion of J8/7, are nonessential for activity.

A conserved motif in group IC3 introns is a new class of GNRA receptor

Terminal tetraloops consisting of GNRA sequences are often found in biologically active large RNAs. The loops appear to contribute towards the organization of higher order RNA structures by forming specific tertiary interactions with their receptors. Group IC3 introns which possess a GAAA loop in the L2 region often have a phylogenetically conserved motif in their P8 domains. In this report, we show that this conserved motif stands as a new class of receptor that distinguishes the sequences of GNRA loops less stringently than previously known receptors. The motif can functionally substitute an 11 nt motif receptor in the Tetrahymena ribozyme. Its structural and functional similarity to one class of synthetic receptors obtained from in vitro selection is observed.

Folding intermediates of a self-splicing RNA: mispairing of the catalytic core

The Tetrahymena thermophila self-splicing RNA is trapped in an inactive conformation during folding reactions at physiological temperatures. The structure of this metastable intermediate was probed by chemical modification interference and site-directed mutagenesis. In the inactive structure, an incorrect base-pairing, which we call Alt P3, displaces the P3 helix in the catalytic core of the intron. Mutations that stabilize Alt P3 increase the fraction of pre-rRNA that becomes trapped in the inactive structure, whereas mutations that destabilize Alt P3 reduce accumulation of this conformer. At high concentrations of Mg2+, the yield of correctly folded mutant pre-rRNAs is similar to wild-type RNA. Under these conditions, the rate of folding for mutant RNAs is slower than for the wild-type, but is increased by addition of urea. The results show that slow folding of the Tetrahymena pre-rRNA is a consequence of non-native secondary structure in the catalytic core of the intron, which is linked to an alternative hairpin in the 5' exon. This illustrates how kinetically stable, long-range interactions shape RNA folding pathways.

Visualizing metal-ion-binding sites in group I introns by iron(II)-mediated Fenton reactions

BACKGROUND

Most catalytic RNAs depend on divalent metal ions for folding and catalysis. A thorough structure-function analysis of catalytic RNA therefore requires the identification of the metal-ion-binding sites. Here, we probed the binding sites using Fenton chemistry, which makes use of the ability of Fe2+ to functionally or structurally replace Mg2+ at ion-binding sites and to generate short-lived and highly reactive hydroxyl radicals that can cleave nucleic acid and protein backbones in spatial proximity of these ion-binding sites.

RESULTS

Incubation of group I intron RNA with Fe2+, sodium ascorbate and hydrogen peroxide yields distinctly cleaved regions that occur only in the correctly folded RNA in the presence of Mg2+ and can be competed by additional Mg2+, suggesting that Fe2+ and Mg2+ interact with the same sites. Cleaved regions in the catalytic core are conserved for three different group I introns, and there is good correlation between metal-ion-binding sites determined using our method and those determined using other techniques. In a model of the T4 phage-derived td intron, cleaved regions separated in the secondary structure come together in three-dimensional space to form several metal-ion-binding pockets.

CONCLUSIONS

In contrast to structural probing with Fe2+/EDTA, cleavage with Fe2+ detects metal-ion-binding sites located primarily in the inside of the RNA. Essentially all metal-ion-binding pockets detected are formed by tertiary structure elements. Using this method, we confirmed proposed metal-ion-binding sites and identified new ones in group I intron RNAs. This approach should allow the localization of metal-ion-binding sites in RNAs of interest.

The Therapeutic Potential of Ribozymes

Ribozymes are catalytic RNA molecules that recognize their target RNA in a highly sequence-specific manner. They can therefore be used to inhibit deleterious gene expression (by cleavage of the target mRNA) or even repair mutant cellular RNAs. Targets such as the mRNAs of oncogenes (resulting from base mutations or chromosome translocations, eg, ras or bcr-abl) and viral genomes and transcripts (human immunodeficiency virus–type 1 [HIV-1]) are ideal targets for such sequence-specific agents. The aim of this review is therefore to introduce the different classes of ribozymes, highlighting some of the chemistry of the reactions they catalyze, to address the specific inhibition of genes by ribozymes, the problems yet to be resolved, and how new developments in the field give hope to the future for ribozymes in the therapeutic field.

The Therapeutic Potential of Ribozymes

Ribozymes are catalytic RNA molecules that recognize their target RNA in a highly sequence-specific manner. They can therefore be used to inhibit deleterious gene expression (by cleavage of the target mRNA) or even repair mutant cellular RNAs. Targets such as the mRNAs of oncogenes (resulting from base mutations or chromosome translocations, eg, ras or bcr-abl) and viral genomes and transcripts (human immunodeficiency virus–type 1 [HIV-1]) are ideal targets for such sequence-specific agents. The aim of this review is therefore to introduce the different classes of ribozymes, highlighting some of the chemistry of the reactions they catalyze, to address the specific inhibition of genes by ribozymes, the problems yet to be resolved, and how new developments in the field give hope to the future for ribozymes in the therapeutic field.

Kinetic and secondary structure analysis of Naegleria andersoni GIR1, a group I ribozyme whose putative biological function is site-specific hydrolysis

NanGIR1 is a catalytic element inserted in the P6 loop of a group I intron (NanGIR2) in the small subunit rRNA precursor of the protist Naegleria andersoni [Einvik, C., Decatur, W. A., Embley, T. M., Vogt, V. M., and Johansen, S. (1997) RNA 3, 710-720]. It catalyzes site-specific hydrolysis at an internal processing site (IPS) after a G residue that immediately follows the P9 stem-loop. Functional and structural analyses were initiated to compare NanGIR1 to group I introns that carry out self-splicing. Chemical modification and site-directed mutagenesis studies showed that NanGIR1 shares many structural elements with other group I introns, but also contains a pseudoknot (P15), which is important for catalytic activity. Deletion analysis revealed the boundaries of the minimum self-cleaving unit (178 nucleotides). The rate of self-cleavage was measured as a function of mono- and divalent ion concentration, temperature, and pH. The reaction at the IPS yields 5'-phosphate and 3'-hydroxyl termini, requires Mg2+or Mn2+ ions, and is first-order in [OH-] between pH 5.0 and 8.5. The latter results suggest that the nucleophile in the reaction is hydroxide or possibly a Mg2+-coordinated hydroxide. With a second-order rate constant of 1 x 10(5) min-1 M-1, the self-cleavage reaction of NanGIR1 is 2 orders of magnitude faster than a similar site-specific hydrolysis reaction of the circular form of the Tetrahymena group I intron.

Isoalloxazine derivatives promote photocleavage of natural RNAs at G.U base pairs embedded within helices

We have recently shown that isoalloxazine derivatives are able to photocleave RNA specifically at G.U base pairs embedded within a helical stack. The reaction involves the selective molecular recognition of G.U base pairs by the isoalloxazine ring and the removal of one nucleoside downstream of the uracil residue. Divalent metal ions are absolutely required for cleavage. Here we extend our studies to complex natural RNA molecules with known secondary and tertiary structures, such as tRNAs and a group I intron (td). G.U pairs were cleaved in accordance with the phylogenetically and experimentally derived secondary and tertiary structures. Tandem G.U pairs or certain G.U pairs located at a helix extremity were not affected. These new cleavage data, together with the RNA crystal structure, allowed us to perform molecular dynamics simulations to provide a structural basis for the observed specificity. We present a stable structural model for the ternary complex of the G. U-containing helical stack, the isoalloxazine molecule and a metal ion. This model provides significant new insight into several aspects of the cleavage phenomenon, mechanism and specificity for G. U pairs. Our study shows that in large natural RNAs a secondary structure motif made of an unusual base pair can be recognized and cleaved with high specificity by a low molecular weight molecule. This photocleavage reaction thus opens up the possibility of probing the accessibility of G.U base pairs, which are endowed with specific structural and functional roles in numerous structured and catalytic RNAs and interactions of RNA with proteins, in folded RNAs.

A second catalytic metal ion in group I ribozyme

Although only a subset of protein enzymes depend on the presence of a metal ion for their catalytic function, all naturally occurring RNA enzymes require metal ions to stabilize their structure and for catalytic competence. In the self-splicing group I intron from Tetrahymena thermophila, several divalent metals can serve structural roles, but only Mg2+ and Mn2+ promote splice-site cleavage and exon ligation. A study of a ribozyme reaction analogous to 5'-splice-site cleavage by guanosine uncovered the first metal ion with a definitive role in catalysis. Substitution of the 3'-oxygen of the leaving group with sulphur resulted in a metal-specificity switch, indicating an interaction between the leaving group and the metal ion. Here we use 3'-(thioinosylyl)-(3'-->5')-uridine, IspU, as a substrate in a reaction that emulates exon ligation. Activity requires the addition of a thiophilic metal ion (Cd2+ or Mn2+), providing evidence for stabilization of the leaving group by a metal ion in that step of splicing. Based on the principle of microscopic reversibility, this metal ion activates the nucleophilic 3'-hydroxyl of guanosine in the first step of splicing, supporting the model of a two-metal-ion active site.

Characterization of the newly constructed domains that replace P5abc within the Tetrahymena ribozyme

The P5abc domain of the Tetrahymena ribozyme has been shown to function as an activator that enhances core catalytic activity of the ribozyme. We reported previously that several new domains in that their primary sequences are different from that of P5abc are also capable of activating the ribozyme. It was unclear whether the mechanism of activation by the new domains is identical to that by P5abc. We have investigated structural and functional properties of the new domains and obtained evidence that strongly indicates that a particular domain activates the ribozyme in a different manner from that by P5abc.

Two mitochondrial group I introns in a metazoan, the sea anemone Metridium senile: one intron contains genes for subunits 1 and 3 of NADH dehydrogenase

Mitochondrial genes for cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI) and NADH dehydrogenase subunit 5 (ND5) of the sea anemone Metridium senile (phylum Cnidaria) each contain a group I intron. This is in contrast to the reported absence of introns in all other metazoan mtDNAs so far examined. The ND5 intron is unusual in that it ends with A and contains two genes (ND1 and ND3) encoding additional subunits of NADH dehydrogenase. Correctly excised ND5 introns are not circularized but are precisely cleaved near their 3' ends and polyadenylylated to provide bicistronic transcripts of ND1 and ND3. COI introns, which encode a putative homing endonuclease, circularize, but in a way that retains the entire genome-encoded intron sequence (other group I introns are circularized with loss of a short segment of the intron 5' end). Introns were detected in the COI and ND5 genes of other sea anemones, but not in the COI and ND5 genes of other cnidarians. This suggests that the sea anemone mitochondrial introns may have been acquired relatively recently.

Mechanistic investigations of a ribozyme derived from the Tetrahymena group I intron: insights into catalysis and the second step of self-splicing

Self-splicing of Tetrahymena pre-rRNA proceeds in two consecutive phosphoryl transesterification steps. One major difference between these steps is that in the first an exogenous guanosine (G) binds to the active site, while in the second the 3'-terminal G414 residue of the intron binds. The first step has been extensively characterized in studies of the L-21ScaI ribozyme, which uses exogenous G as a nucleophile. In this study, mechanistic features involved in the second step are investigated by using the L-21G414 ribozyme. The L-21G414 reaction has been studied in both directions, with G414 acting as a leaving group in the second step and a nucleophile in its reverse. The rate constant of chemical step is the same with exogenous G bound to the L-21ScaI ribozyme and with the intramolecular guanosine residue of the L-21G414 ribozyme. The result supports the previously proposed single G-binding site model and further suggests that the orientation of the bound G and the overall active site structure is the same in both steps of the splicing reaction. An evolutionary rationale for the use of exogenous G in the first step is also presented. The results suggest that the L-21G414 ribozyme exists predominantly with the 3'-terminal G414 docked into the G-binding site. This docking is destabilized by approximately 100-fold when G414 is attached to an electron-withdrawing pA group. The internal equilibrium with K(int) = 0.7 for the ribozyme reaction indicates that bound substrate and product are thermodynamically matched and is consistent with a degree of symmetry within the active site. These observations are consistent with the presence of a second Mg ion in the active site. Finally, the slow dissociation of a 5' exon analog relative to a ligated exon analog from the L-21G414 ribozyme suggests a kinetic mechanism for ensuring efficient ligation of exons and raises new questions about the overall self-splicing reaction.

The chloroplast chlL gene of the green alga Chlorella vulgaris C-27 contains a self-splicing group I intron

The chlL gene product is involved in the light-independent synthesis of chlorophyll in photosynthetic bacteria, green algae and non-flowering plants. The chloroplast genome of Chlorella vulgaris strain C-27 contains the first example of a split chlL gene, which is interrupted by 951 bp group I intron in the coding region. In vitro synthesized pre-mRNA containing the entire intron and parts of the flanking exon sequence is able to efficiently self-splice in vitro in the presence of a divalent and a monovalent cation and GTP, to yield the ligated exons and other splicing intermediates characteristic of self-splicing group I introns. The 5' and 3' splice sites were confirmed by cDNA sequencing and the products of the splicing reaction were characterized by primer extension analysis. The absence of a significant ORF in the long P9 region (522 nt), separating the catalytic core from the 3' splice site, makes this intron different from the other known examples of group I introns. Guanosine-mediated attack at the 3' splice site and the presence of G-exchange reaction sites internal to the intron are some other properties demonstrated for the first time by an intron of a protein-coding plastid gene.

Conformational switches involved in orchestrating the successive steps of group I RNA splicing

Group I introns possess a conserved guanosine residue at their 3' end, termed omegaG, that, in the case of the Tetrahymena pre-rRNA, is a major determinant of the second step of splicing. We examined the role of omegaG in self-splicing of the 249-residue group I intron of the Anabaena PCC7120 tRNAleu precursor. Contrary to observations with the Tetrahymena pre-rRNA intron, a mutation that places an adenosine residue at the omega position did not have a severe effect on the second step of splicing; neither 3' splice-site selection nor the rate of the second step was altered. The first step of splicing, however, was now readily reversed. This unexpected effect also resulted from a mutation that altered the nucleoside specificity of the intronic guanosine-binding site. The theme common to these mutations is that reversal of the first step of splicing results when there is not a strong interaction between the guanosine-binding site and the omega residue. This suggests that a major role of omegaG is to compete with the exogenous guanosine molecule added to the intron in the first step of splicing for the single guanosine-binding site of the intron. From these data, we are able to extend the mechanism for the self-splicing reaction of this intron by proposing two distinct conformational changes between the first and second steps of the splicing. The first of these is the exchange of the exogenous nucleoside for the omega nucleoside. This is the equilibrium that we can perturb by mutations at either the omega position or the guanosine-binding site. An additional conformational change then fully activates the intron for the second step of splicing.

Group II introns: elaborate ribozymes

Group II introns are found in organelle genomes of plants, fungi and algae as well as in some bacteria. Some group II introns have been shown to self-splice in vitro and thus constitute examples of ribozymes. Their splicing pathway is analogous to the splicing pathway of nuclear pre-mRNA introns. They thus constitute simple models to analyze RNA catalysis of this type of splicing reactions. In this review article, I will summarize our current state of understanding of the ribozyme activity of group II introns and show that their large size correlates with their ability to perform complex tasks. After discussing the similarities found between group II and nuclear pre-mRNA introns, I will briefly evoke how the ribozyme activity of group II introns might be involved in their transposition at the DNA level.

Cotranscriptional splicing of a group I intron is facilitated by the Cbp2 protein

The nuclear CBP2 gene encodes a protein essential for the splicing of a mitochondrial group I intron in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. This intron (bI5) is spliced autocatalytically in the presence of high concentrations of magnesium and monovalent salt but requires the Cbp2 protein for splicing under physiological conditions. Addition of Cbp2 during RNA synthesis permitted cotranscriptional splicing. Splicing did not occur in the transcription buffer in the absence of synthesis. The Cbp2 protein appeared to modify the folding of the intron during RNA synthesis: pause sites for RNA polymerase were altered in the presence of the protein, and some mutant transcripts that did not splice after transcription did so during transcription in the presence of Cbp2. Cotranscriptional splicing also reduced hydrolysis at the 3' splice junction. These results suggest that Cbp2 modulates the sequential folding of the ribozyme during its synthesis. In addition, splicing during transcription led to an increase in RNA synthesis with both T7 RNA polymerase and mitochondrial RNA polymerase, implying a functional coupling between transcription and splicing.

Self-incorporation of coenzymes by ribozymes

RNA molecules that are assembled from the four standard nucleotides contain a limited number of chemical functional groups, a characteristic that is generally thought to restrict the potential for catalysis by ribozymes. Although polypeptides carry a wider range of functional groups, many contemporary protein-based enzymes employ coenzymes to augment their capabilities. The coenzymes possess additional chemical moieties that can participate directly in catalysis and thereby enhance catalytic function. In this work, we demonstrate a mechanism by which ribozymes can supplement their limited repertoire of functional groups through RNA-catalyzed incorporation of various coenzymes and coenzyme analogues. The group I ribozyme of Tetrahymena thermophila normally mediates a phosphoester transfer reaction that results in the covalent attachment of guanosine to the ribozyme. Here, a shortened version of the ribozyme is shown to catalyze the self-incorporation of coenzymes and coenzyme analogues, such as NAD+ and dephosphorylated CoA-SH. Similar ribozyme activities may have played an important role in the "RNA world," when RNA enzymes are thought to have maintained a complex metabolism in the absence of proteins and would have benefited from the inclusion of additional functional groups.

Bidirectional effectors of a group I intron ribozyme

The group I self-splicing introns found in many organisms are competitively inhibited by L-arginine. We have found that L-arginine acts stereoselectively on the Pc1. LSU nuclear group I intron of Pneumocystis carinii, competitively inhibiting the first (cleavage) step of the splicing reaction and stimulating the second (ligation) step. Stimulation of the second step is most clearly demonstrated in reactions whose first step is blocked after 15 min by addition of pentamidine. The guanidine moiety of arginine is required for both effects. L-Canavanine is a more potent inhibitor than L-arginine yet it fails to stimulate. L-Arginine derivatized on its carboxyl group as an amide, ester or peptide is more potent than L-arginine as a stimulator and inhibitor, with di-arginine amide and tri-arginine being the most potent effectors tested. The most potent peptides tested are 10,000 times as effective as L-arginine in inhibiting ribozyme activity, and nearly 400 times as effective as stimulators. Arginine and some of its derivatives apparently bind to site(s) on the ribozyme to alter its conformation to one more active in the second step of splicing while competing with guanosine substrate in the first step. This phenomenon indicates that ribozymes, like protein enzymes, can be inhibited or stimulated by non-substrate low molecular weight compounds, which suggests that such compounds may be developed as pharmacological agents acting on RNA targets.

A modified group I intron can function as both a ribozyme and a 5' exon in a trans-exon ligation reaction

Here, we show that a single RNA molecule derived from a group-I intron can provide the catalytic activity, the substrate recognition domain and the attacking nucleophile in a reaction that mimics the exon ligation step of splicing. To accomplish this reaction, we have linked a 5' exon sequence to the 3' end of an attenuated form of the self-splicing Tetrahymena rRNA intron. The ribozyme (I-E1) attacks an oligoribonucleotide analog of the 3' splice site (I'-E2) to generate a product containing ligated exons (I-E1-E2) and a small intron fragment (I'). Two modified introns were constructed and tested for activity. A construct designed to interact with the 3' splice site through intermolecular P9.0 and P10 helices was found to be inactive due to failure to form a stable ribozyme-substrate complex. A second modified intron and substrate combination was engineered, in which the complex was further stabilized by an intermolecular P9.2 helix. In this case, stable complexes and reaction products were identified. The reaction efficiency was low compared to splicing of the unmodified intron-containing precursor, and will be optimized in future experiments. Following optimization, we believe that this system may be exploited to examine the functional consequences of a wide variety of 3' splice-site modifications, and may provide the basis for development of highly selective trans-acting ribozymes.

Selection of novel forms of a functional domain within the Tetrahymena ribozyme

P5abc is an RNA structure within the self-splicing Tetrahymena group I intron that provides an activation function to the remainder of the ribozyme, either when present in cis or when added in trans. This 69-nucleotide activator domain was replaced with randomized sequence of 20 or 40 nt in length, and individuals among these pools with sequences that could functionally replace P5abc were selected. The basis of selection was a reaction in which two separate halves of the ribozyme became joined; selection was completed by reverse transcription and the polymerase chain reaction, using primers with sequence from either side of the ligation junction. Selectant sequences fell into three families that appear unrelated to P5abc; for example they lack the A-rich bulge thought to be a important feature of P5abc. Thus, rather than defining some consensus sequence for activator domains, this result reveals a certain tolerance in the ribozyme in its ability to derive activation function from diverse sequence types. In the context of splicing precursor RNA, the new sequences supported self-splicing, but failed to activate a related reaction, hydrolysis of the 3' splice site, implying that this region of the intron can differentially control two related reactions.