Importance of A-ring substitution of estrogens for the physiology and pharmacology of reproduction

Endocrine Disruptors: A Critical Review of In Vitro and In Vivo Testing Strategies for Assessing Their Toxic Hazard to Humans

Currently, there is much concern that a wide range of both synthetic and naturally occurring environmental chemicals can act as endocrine disruptors (EDs), and can adversely affect humans and wildlife. Many in vivo and in vitro tests have been proposed for screening EDs, and several regulatory agencies, including the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), have recommended tier-testing schemes. Unfortunately, most of the proposed toxicity tests have substantial problems, including non-specificity and lack of reproducibility. There is also uncertainty concerning their relevance for generating useful hazard data for risk assessment purposes, in view of the diversity of the possible ED mechanisms of action (for example, receptor binding, steroidogenesis and modulation of the homeostatic processes which regulate endogenous responses to hormones). Moreover, most of the suggested test methods have yet to be validated according to internationally accepted criteria, although the OECD and the US EPA have defined tests for validation, and an interlaboratory “prevalidation” exercise has been initiated by the OECD. All this is compounded by the lack of information regarding human exposure levels to EDs, and a lack of direct evidence for a causal link between exposure and the development of adverse human health effects. In addition, the regulatory testing of EDs has important negative implications for animal welfare, as some of the proposed in vivo tests require large group sizes of animals and stressful procedures. From a detailed analysis of the available published literature, it is concluded that it is impossible to assess the relative values of currently available in vitro and in vivo toxicity tests for EDs, or to recommend any test or test battery. Any plans for the widespread testing of EDs are therefore premature and might be unnecessary, at least for detecting possible human effects. Several recommendations are made for rectifying this unsatisfactory situation, including the postponement of screening programmes pending: a) more information on human exposure; b) further details of the mechanisms of action of EDs; and c) the development of improved tests, followed by their proper scientific validation.

Changes in the gene expression pattern induced by 2-methoxyestradiol in the mouse uterus

2-Methoxyestradiol (2ME) is an estrogen metabolite with antitumor and antiangiogenic properties, although their effects on the reproductive tissues are not well-determined. Furthermore, it is not very clear whether 2ME is part of the intracellular signaling of estradiol (E2) or it acts through other signaling pathways. The purpose of this study was to determine changes in the gene expression pattern in the mouse female reproductive tract induced by 2ME, under conditions in which this metabolite has no estrogenic activity. Therefore, we first compared the effect of 2ME or E2 on the uterine weight and epithelial cell height, and on the ovarian weight and the number of follicles of immature mice. Then, we examined the gene expression profile in the uterus of immature mice treated with 2ME or E2 and we selected three genes scd2, snx6, and spon1, to confirm differential regulation by E2 and 2ME in the uterine cells using real-time PCR. Finally, in order to explore the physiologic relevance of the 2ME-induced genes we determined the expression and localization of the F-spondin protein encoded by spon1 in the uterus of mature mice treated with E2 or 2ME. Estradiol and 2ME reduced the ovarian weight and decreased the number of follicles ≥ 300 μm, whereas E2 increased the uterine weight and epithelial cell height but not 2ME, indicating that 2ME did not have estrogenic activity in the mouse uterus. Microarray analysis showed that 1.8 % of the uterine genes were regulated by E2 and 0.23 % by 2ME, while 0.04 % was regulated by E2 and 2ME. The mRNA for scd2 was exclusively increased by 2ME, whereas snx6 and spon1 were up-regulated by E2 and 2ME, but the response to 2ME was more intense. F-spondin was mainly expressed in the uterine stroma layer although 2ME or E2 did not change its localization in the uterine cells. We conclude that 2ME regulates a group of genes in the mice uterus, independently of estrogenic activity, suggesting a functional involvement of 2ME in the mammalian uterus.

Estrogen and its metabolites are carcinogenic agents in human breast epithelial cells

Estrogens play a crucial role in the development and evolution of human breast cancer. However, it is still unclear whether estrogens are carcinogenic to the human breast. There are three mechanisms that have been considered to be responsible for the carcinogenicity of estrogens: receptor-mediated hormonal activity, a cytochrome P450 (CYP)-mediated metabolic activation, which elicits direct genotoxic effects by increasing mutation rates, and the induction of aneuploidy by estrogen. To fully demonstrate that estrogens are carcinogenic in the human breast through one or more of the mechanisms explained above it will require an experimental system in which, estrogens by itself or one of the metabolites would induce transformation phenotypes indicative of neoplasia in HBEC in vitro and also induce genomic alterations similar to those observed in spontaneous malignancies. In order to mimic the intermittent exposure of HBEC to endogenous estrogens, MCF-10F cells that are ERalpha negative and ERbeta positive were first treated with 0, 0.007, 70 nM and 1 microM of 17beta-estradiol (E(2)), diethylstilbestrol (DES), benz(a)pyrene (BP), progesterone (P), 2-OH-E(2), 4-hydoxy estradiol (4-OH-E(2)) and 16-alpha-OH-E(2) at 72 h and 120 h post-plating. Treatment of HBEC with physiological doses of E(2), 2-OH-E(2), 4-OH-E(2) induce anchorage independent growth, colony formation in agar methocel, and reduced ductulogenic capacity in collagen gel, all phenotypes whose expression are indicative of neoplastic transformation, and that are induced by BP under the same culture conditions. The presence of ERbeta is the pathway used by E(2) to induce colony formation in agar methocel and loss of ductulogenic in collagen gel. This is supported by the fact that either tamoxifen or the pure antiestrogen ICI-182,780 (ICI) abrogated these phenotypes. However, the invasion phenotype, an important marker of tumorigenesis is not modified when the cells are treated in presence of tamoxifen or ICI, suggesting that other pathways may be involved. Although we cannot rule out the possibility, that 4-OH-E(2) may interact with other receptors still not identified, with the data presently available the direct effect of 4-OH-E(2) support the concept that metabolic activation of estrogens mediated by various cytochrome P450 complexes, generating through this pathway reactive intermediates that elicit direct genotoxic effects leading to transformation. This assumption was confirmed when we found that all the transformation phenotypes induced by 4-OH-E(2) were not abrogated when this compound was used in presence of the pure antiestrogen ICI. The novelty of these observations lies in the role of ERbeta in transformation and that this pathway can successfully bypassed by the estrogen metabolite 4-OH-E(2). Genomic DNA was analyzed for the detection of micro-satellite DNA polymorphism using 64 markers covering chromosomes (chr) 3, 11, 13 and 17. We have detected loss of heterozygosity (LOH) in ch13q12.2-12.3 (D13S893) and in ch17q21.1 (D17S800) in E(2), 2-OH-E(2), 4-OH-E(2), E(2) + ICI, E(2) + tamoxifen and BP-treated cells. LOH in ch17q21.1-21.2 (D17S806) was also observed in E(2), 4-OH-E(2), E(2)+ICI, E(2)+tamoxifen and BP-treated cells. MCF-10F cells treated with P or P+E(2) did not show LOH in the any of the markers studied. LOH was strongly associated with the invasion phenotype. Altogether our data indicate that E(2) and its metabolites induce in HBEC LOH in loci of chromosomes 13 and 17, that has been reported in primary breast cancer, that the changes are similar to those induced by the chemical carcinogen (BP) and that the genomic changes were not abrogated by antiestrogens.

Effect of halogenated substituents on the metabolism and estrogenic effects of the equine estrogen, equilenin

Estrogen replacement therapy has been correlated with an increased risk for developing breast and endometrial cancers. One potential mechanism of estrogen carcinogenesis involves metabolism of estrogens to 2- and 4-hydroxylated catechols, which are further oxidized to electrophilic/redox active o-quinones that have the potential to both initiate and promote the carcinogenic process. Previously, we showed that the equine estrogens, equilin and equilenin, which are major components of the estrogen replacement formulation Premarin (Wyeth-Ayerst), are primarily metabolized to the catechol, 4-hydroxyequilenin. This catechol was found to autoxidize to an o-quinone causing oxidation and alkylation of DNA in vitro and in vivo. To block catechol formation from equilenin, 4-halogenated equilenin derivatives were synthesized. These derivatives were tested for their ability to bind to the estrogen receptor, induce estrogen sensitive genes, and their potential to form catechol metabolites. We found that the 4-fluoro derivatives were more estrogenic than the 4-chloro and 4-bromo derivatives as demonstrated by a higher binding affinity for estrogen receptors alpha and beta, an enhanced induction of alkaline phosphatase activity in Ishikawa cells, pS2 expression in S30 cells, and PR expression in Ishikawa cells. Incubation of these compounds with tyrosinase in the presence of GSH showed that the halogenated equilenin compounds formed less catechol GSH conjugates than the parent compounds, equilenin and 17beta-hydroxyequilenin. In addition, these halogenated compounds showed less cytotoxicity in the presence of tyrosinase than the parent compounds in S30 cells. Also, as stated above, the 4-fluoro derivatives showed similar estrogenic effects as compared with parent compounds; however, they were less toxic in S30 cells as compared to equilenin and 17beta-equilenin. Because 17beta-hydroxy-4-halogenated equilenin derivatives showed higher estrogenic effects than the halogenated equilenin derivatives in vitro, we studied the relative ability of the 17beta-hydroxy-4-halogenated equilenin derivatives to induce estrogenic effects in the ovariectomized rat model. The 4-fluoro derivative showed higher activity than 4-chloro and 4-bromo derivatives as demonstrated by inducing higher vaginal cellular differentiation, uterine growth, and mammary gland branching. However, 17beta-hydroxy-4-fluoroequilenin showed a lower estrogenic activity than 17beta-hydroxyequilenin and estradiol, which could be due to alternative pharmacokinetic properties for these compounds. These data suggest that the 4-fluoroequilenin derivatives have promise as alternatives to traditional estrogen replacement therapy due to their similar estrogenic properties with less overall toxicity.

Urinary excretion pattern of catecholestrogens in preovulatory LH surge during the 4-day estrous cycle of rats

The formation of catecholestrogens represents a major pathway of estrogen metabolism and catecholestrogens are regarded as the main estrogen metabolite in non-pregnant state of various mammalian systems. In the present investigation, level of 2-hydroxyestrone, the major catecholestrogen excreted in rat urine, was measured by radioimmunoassay following acid hydrolysis and column chromatography of the 24-h urine samples of female Sprague Dawley non-pregnant rats during their 4-day estrous cycle. Urinary levels of estrone, estradiol and estriol were measured. Unlike the plasma level, urinary 2-hydroxyestrone showed a marked increase during the pre-ovulatory LH surge suggesting a plausible role of catecholestrogen in the mid-cycle elevation of the gonadotropin level in normal cycling rats.

Developmental, cellular, and molecular basis of human breast cancer

Breast cancer, which is the most common neoplastic disease in females and accounts for up to one third of all new cases of women's cancer in North America, continues to rise in incidence. In addition, the mortality caused by this disease has remained almost unchanged for the past 5 decades, becoming only second to lung cancer as a cause of cancer-related death. The failure in eradicating this disease is largely due to the lack of identification of a specific etiologic agent, the precise time of initiation, and the molecular mechanisms responsible for cancer initiation and progression. Despite the numerous uncertainties surrounding the origin of cancer, there is substantial evidence that breast cancer risk relates to endocrinologic and reproductive factors. The development of breast cancer strongly depends on the ovary and on endocrine conditions modulated by ovarian function, such as early menarche, late menopause, and parity. However, the specific hormone or hormone combinations responsible for cancer initiation have not been identified, and their role as protective or risk factors is still incompletely understood. A highly significant female hormone is estrogen, which is involved in the development of a variety of cancers, but it is still unclear whether estrogens are carcinogenic to the human breast. An understanding of whether estrogens cause mutations, and, if so, whether they act through hormonal effects activated by receptor binding, cytochrome P450-mediated metabolic activation, or compromise the DNA repair system, is essential for determining whether this steroid hormone is involved in the initiation or progression of breast cancer. This knowledge has to be based on a multidisciplinary approach encompassing studies of the development of the breast, influence of hormones on the differentiation of individual structures, and their interrelations in the pathogenesis of breast cancer. The analysis of the mechanisms involved would require confirmation in the adequate in vitro models and determination of the role played by genomic alterations in both cancer initiation and progression.

Structure-metabolism relationships of ring-A halogenated analogues of 17 alpha-ethynyloestradiol

The metabolic fates of 2-chloro-, 2-bromo-, 4-bromo- and 2-iodo-17 alpha-ethynyloestradiol (EE2) in rats were determined. 6,7-3H-labelled analogues (0.1-2.0 mumol/kg) were administered i.v. to anaesthetized animals. The metabolites of all four compounds were rapidly and extensively excreted in bile (79-93% of the dose over 6 h). Unlike EE2 and 2-fluoro-EE2 (2-FEE2), neither 2-chloro(Cl)-(2.0 mumol/kg),2-bromo(Br)-(0.1 mumol/kg), nor 2-iodo(I)-EE2-(0.1 mumol/kg) underwent C-2 hydroxylation in female rats; 2-BrEE2 was similarly refractory in male rats; females, was subject to approx. 2-fold greater C-2 hydroxylation than 2-FEE2 but this equalled only approx. 60% of that undergone by EE2. All three of the C-2 halogenated derivatives were substantially excreted unchanged except for conjugation. 2-ClEE2 alone was C-4 hydroxylated to an appreciable extent. The oxidative metabolism of 2- and 4-BrEE2 in rats was sexually differentiated: 2-BrEE2 yielded an alkyl hydroxylated metabolite and a two-component dihydroxylated fraction in the ratio 1:0.09 and 1:0.76 in males and females, respectively; 4-BrEE2 underwent C-2 and alicyclic (C-15) hydroxylation in the ratio 1:4.8 and 1:0.07 in males and females, respectively. 2-ClEE2 formed much less alkyl monohydroxylated metabolite (C-16 hydroxylated for 2-Cl- and 2-IEE2) than did either 2-BrEE2 or 2-IEE2. The observed structure-metabolism relationships are discussed.

Catecholestrogens are agonists of estrogen receptor dependent gene expression in MCF-7 cells

The catecholestrogens, namely 2-hydroxyestradiol (2-OH-E2) and 4-hydroxyestradiol (4-OH-E2) are important, naturally occurring metabolites of E2. Here we studied their role on estrogen dependent processes. Using the MCF-7 cell line as a model system we analyzed the potency of 2- and 4-OH-E2 on the synthesis of the 160 kDa secreted protein and on the transcription of the pS2 mRNA. Both processes are known to be E2 inducible and are mediated by the estrogen receptor. Control incubations using E2 and antiestrogens were performed to validate the assay procedure and to enable us to comparatively study the effects of the catecholestrogens. Stimulating MCF-7 cells for 2 days with 10(-8) M 2- or 4-OH-E2 resulted in an induction of the synthesis of the 160 kDa protein and in an increase in pS2 mRNA. Following hormonal stimulation with 2- or 4-OH-E2 [35S]methionine labeling of MCF-7 cells increased the level of newly synthesized and secreted 160 kDa protein 54 and 88% compared with the inductive potency of E2 (100%). The pS2 mRNA in MCF-7 cells was increased by a 2 day treatment with 10(-8) M 2- or 4-OH-E2 by 48 and 79%, respectively, compared to E2. Therefore, we conclude that the estrogen receptor is transcriptionally active in MCF-7 cells upon binding of catecholestrogens. The estrogen receptor in vivo may be active if the intracellular concentration of catecholestrogens generated is sufficient to allow occupation of the receptor. The possible action of these hormones in vivo is discussed.

Catecholestrogens are MCF-7 cell estrogen receptor agonists

Catecholestrogens are important metabolites of estradiol and estrone in the human. Considerable interest has focused on the catecholestrogens 2-hydroxy- and 4-hydroxyestradiol since they bind to the estrogen receptor with an affinity in the range of estradiol. Using the MCF-7 cell line, we analysed the capacity of purified catecholestrogens to transform the estrogen receptor into its high affinity nuclear binding form and to affect receptor-dependent processes such as proliferation and expression of the progesterone receptor (PR). Incubations with 2-hydroxy- and 4-hydroxyestradiol at 10(-8) M for 1 h resulted in tight nuclear binding of the estrogen receptor. During treatment of the cells with catecholestrogens we obtained a marked increase in proliferation rate of 36 and 76% for 2-hydroxy- and 4-hydroxyestradiol, respectively, relative to the inductive effect of estradiol (100%). The PR level, was slightly increased by treatment with 2-hydroxyestradiol (10%), whereas treatment with 4-hydroxyestradiol increased the PR level at 28%, compared to estradiol (100%). From these results we conclude that the 2- and 4-hydroxylated derivatives of estradiol are active hormones and are able to initiate estrogen receptor mediated processes in MCF-7 cells.

Oxidative dehalogenation of 2-fluoro-17 alpha-ethynyloestradiol in vivo. A distal structure-metabolism relationship of 17 alpha-ethynylation

Metabolic activation to catechols and their oxidation products is variously considered to contribute to the genotoxic, cytotoxic, transforming and tumour-promoting activities of exogenous steroidal oestrogens. 2-Fluoro-17 alpha-ethynyloestradiol (2-FEE2) was synthesized as a prototype of pharmacologically active derivatives of 17 beta-oestradiol which are resistant to metabolic activation in vivo. It possessed high affinity for the rat uterine oestrogen receptor and was oestrogenic in rats. Biliary metabolites of [6,7-3H]2-FEE2 (0.73 mumol/kg, 157 micrograms/kg, i.v.) in female rats were characterized: 87% of the radiolabel was excreted, principally as 2-FEE2 glucuronide, over 6 hr. Although 2-fluoro-17 beta-oestradiol is not metabolized to C-2 oxygenated products in vivo, 2-FEE2 underwent rapid and appreciable oxidative defluorination. 2-Hydroxy-17 alpha-ethynyloestradiol and 2-methoxy-17 alpha-ethynyloestradiol represented, respectively, 8% and 13% of the dose. Fluorination nevertheless restricted C-2 oxygenation to ca. 28% of that which 17 alpha-ethynyloestradiol undergoes in female rats. C-4 oxygenation of 2-FEE2, resulting in catechol formation, occurred but to a lesser extent (ca. 12% of dose). None of the major and identified minor biliary metabolites was a product of metabolic activation at the ethynyl function. A mechanistic rationalization of the long range enhancement by 17 alpha-ethynylation of oxidative defluorination at C-2 is presented.

Methyl and bromo derivatives of estradiol are agonistic ligands for the estrogen receptor of MCF-7 breast cancer cells

The binding affinity and relative estrogenic potency of 2-bromo-, 4-bromo-, 2-methyl- and 4-methylestradiol was evaluated in MCF-7 breast cancer cells. The relative binding affinities compared to estradiol were 47% for 2-methyl-, 25% for 4-methyl-, 37% for 4-bromo- and 17% for 2-bromoestradiol. However, both 2- and 4-methyl- as well as 2- and 4-bromoestradiol were able (a) to translocate the cytosolic estrogen receptor into the nucleus and (b) to induce the progesterone receptor in a concentration dependent manner. Finally, all ring-A substituted estrogens used in this study induced the pS2 mRNA as demonstrated by Northern-blotting. From these findings we conclude that 2-bromo-, 4-bromo-, 2-methyl- and 4-methylestradiol are agonistic ligands for the estrogen receptor in MCF-7 breast cancer cells.

Metabolism of exogenous 4- and 2-hydroxyestradiol in the human male

The metabolic fate of the isomeric catecholestrogens 4-hydroxyestradiol (4-OHE2) and 2-hydroxyestradiol (2-OHE2) was studied to elucidate possible differences in their metabolism as an explanation for their different bioactivities. Healthy young men (n = 3 each) were infused (90 min) with 4-OHE2 (60 micrograms/h) or 2-OHE2 (100 micrograms/h). The main metabolites were determined in plasma and urine before, during and after infusion. Unconjugated and conjugated steroids, the latter after hot acid hydrolysis, were subjected to chromatography on LH-20 columns and measured by specific RIAs. During the infusion 4-OHE2 reached significant plasma concentrations whereas 2-OHE2 was so rapidly metabolised that its plasma levels remained virtually undetectable in spite of a higher infusion rate. The metabolism of 4-OHE2 was dominated by direct conjugation, that of 2-OHE2 by methyl ether formation. These findings were corroborated by the urinary excretion rates: during the infusion and the first hours afterwards, 4-OHE2 was mainly excreted as 4-OHE2 and 4-hydroxyestrone, while 2-OHE2 was predominantly excreted as 2-hydroxyestradiol 2-methyl ether and 2-hydroxyestrone 2-methyl ether.