The kinetics of adenovirus recombination in homotypic and heterotypic genetic crosses

Genomic foundations of evolution and ocular pathogenesis in human adenovirus species D

Human adenovirus commonly causes infections of respiratory, gastrointestinal, genitourinary, and ocular surface mucosae. Although most adenovirus eye infections are mild and self-limited, specific viruses within human adenovirus species D are associated with epidemic keratoconjunctivitis (EKC), a severe and highly contagious ocular surface infection, which can lead to chronic and/or recurrent, visually disabling keratitis. In this review, we discuss the links between adenovirus ontogeny, genomics, immune responses, and corneal pathogenesis, for those viruses that cause EKC.

Bacterial RecA Protein Promotes Adenoviral Recombination during In Vitro Infection

Adenoviruses are common human mucosal pathogens of the gastrointestinal, respiratory, and genitourinary tracts and ocular surface. Here, we report finding Chi-like sequences in adenovirus recombination hot spots. Adenovirus coinfection in the presence of bacterial RecA protein facilitated homologous recombination between viruses. Genetic recombination led to evolution of an important external feature on the adenoviral capsid, namely, the penton base protein hypervariable loop 2, which contains the arginine-glycine-aspartic acid motif critical to viral internalization. We speculate that free Rec proteins present in gastrointestinal secretions upon bacterial cell death facilitate the evolution of human adenoviruses through homologous recombination, an example of viral commensalism and the complexity of virus-host interactions, including regional microbiota.

Adenovirus infections in humans are common and sometimes lethal. Adenovirus-derived vectors are also commonly chosen for gene therapy in human clinical trials. We have shown in previous work that homologous recombination between adenoviral genomes of human adenovirus species D (HAdV-D), the largest and fastest growing HAdV species, is responsible for the rapid evolution of this species. Because adenovirus infection initiates in mucosal epithelia, particularly at the gastrointestinal, respiratory, genitourinary, and ocular surfaces, we sought to determine a possible role for mucosal microbiota in adenovirus genome diversity. By analysis of known recombination hot spots across 38 human adenovirus genomes in species D (HAdV-D), we identified nucleotide sequence motifs similar to bacterial Chi sequences, which facilitate homologous recombination in the presence of bacterial Rec enzymes. These motifs, referred to here as Chi_AD, were identified immediately 5′ to the sequence encoding penton base hypervariable loop 2, which expresses the arginine-glycine-aspartate moiety critical to adenoviral cellular entry. Coinfection with two HAdV-Ds in the presence of an Escherichia coli lysate increased recombination; this was blocked in a RecA mutant strain, E. coli DH5α, or upon RecA depletion. Recombination increased in the presence of E. coli lysate despite a general reduction in viral replication. RecA colocalized with viral DNA in HAdV-D-infected cell nuclei and was shown to bind specifically to Chi_AD sequences. These results indicate that adenoviruses may repurpose bacterial recombination machinery, a sharing of evolutionary mechanisms across a diverse microbiota, and unique example of viral commensalism.

IMPORTANCE Adenoviruses are common human mucosal pathogens of the gastrointestinal, respiratory, and genitourinary tracts and ocular surface. Here, we report finding Chi-like sequences in adenovirus recombination hot spots. Adenovirus coinfection in the presence of bacterial RecA protein facilitated homologous recombination between viruses. Genetic recombination led to evolution of an important external feature on the adenoviral capsid, namely, the penton base protein hypervariable loop 2, which contains the arginine-glycine-aspartic acid motif critical to viral internalization. We speculate that free Rec proteins present in gastrointestinal secretions upon bacterial cell death facilitate the evolution of human adenoviruses through homologous recombination, an example of viral commensalism and the complexity of virus-host interactions, including regional microbiota.

Genomic characterization of a novel human adenovirus type 31 recombinant in the hexon gene

A novel human recombinant adenovirus of species A (HAdV-A31 MZ) was isolated from a patient with acute gastroenteritis in Japan. The complete genome of HAdV-A31 strain MZ contains 33 776 bp. Analysis of the hexon gene of HAdV-A31 MZ indicated that its hexon sequence is the result of a genetic recombination between those of HAdV-A31 and a close relative to HAdV-A12. The recombination sites were found around the border of hypervariable loops 1 and 2 in the hexon gene, which are the most important determinants for virus neutralization. Loops 1 and 2 of this virus were genetically related to HAdV-A12, whereas all other parts of the genome were highly similar to HAdV-A31. In order to understand the evolution of adenoviruses correctly and to avoid misidentification of HAdV types, we recommend characterizing not only the hexon gene, but also the penton base and fiber genes.

Molecular evolution of human species D adenoviruses

Adenoviruses are medium-sized double stranded DNA viruses that infect vertebrates. Human adenoviruses cause an array of diseases. Currently there are 56 human adenovirus types recognized and characterized within seven species (A-G). Of those types, a majority belongs to species D. In this review, the genomic conservation and diversity are examined among human adenoviruses within species D, particularly in contrast to other human adenovirus species. Specifically, homologous recombination is presented as a driving force for the molecular evolution of human adenoviruses and the emergence of new adenovirus pathogens.

The FANC pathway is activated by adenovirus infection and promotes viral replication-dependent recombination

Deciphering the crosstalk between a host cell and a virus during infection is important not only to better define viral biology but also to improve our understanding of cellular processes. We identified the FANC pathway as a helper of viral replication and recombination by searching for cellular targets that are modified by adenovirus (Ad) infection and are involved in its outcome. This pathway, which is involved in the DNA damage response and checkpoint control, is altered in Fanconi anaemia, a rare cancer predisposition syndrome. We show here that Ad5 infection activates the FANC pathway independent of the classical DNA damage response. Infection with a non-replicating Ad shows that the presence of viral DNA is not sufficient to induce the monoubiquitination of FANCD2 but still activates the DNA damage response coordinated by phospho-NBS1 and phospho-CHK1. E1A expression alone fails to induce FANCD2 monoubiquitination, indicating that a productive viral infection and/or replication is required for FANC pathway activation. Our data indicate that Ad5 infection induces FANCD2 activation to promote its own replication. Specifically, we show that FANCD2 is involved in the recombination process that accompanies viral DNA replication. This study provides evidence of a DNA damage-independent function of the FANC pathway and identifies a cellular system involved in Ad5 recombination.

Computational analysis of human adenovirus type 22 provides evidence for recombination among species D human adenoviruses in the penton base gene

Recombination in human adenoviruses (HAdV) may confer virulence upon an otherwise nonvirulent strain. The genome sequence of species D HAdV type 22 (HAdV-D22) revealed evidence for recombination with HAdV-D19 and HAdV-D37 within the capsid penton base gene. Bootscan analysis demonstrated that recombination sites within the penton base gene frame the coding sequences for the two external hypervariable loops in the protein. A similar pattern of recombination was evident within other HAdV-D types but not other HAdV species. Further study of recombination among HAdVs is needed to better predict possible recombination events among wild-type viruses and adenoviral gene therapy vectors.

Coinfection with two closely related alphaherpesviruses results in a highly diversified recombination mosaic displaying negative genetic interference

Phylogenetic studies of the emergence and spread of natural recombinants in herpesviruses infecting humans and animals have been reported recently. However, despite an ever-increasing amount of evidence of recombination in herpesvirus history, the recombination process and the consequences on the genetic diversity of the progeny remain poorly characterized. We addressed this issue by using multiple single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) differentiating the two subtypes of an alphaherpesvirus, bovine herpesvirus 1 (BoHV-1). Analysis of a large sample of progeny virions obtained in a single growth cycle of coinfected BoHV-1 strains provided a prospective investigation of the recombination dynamics by using SNPs as recombination markers. We found that the simultaneous infection with two closely related herpesviruses results in a highly diversified recombination mosaic. From the analysis of multiple recombinants arising in the progeny, we provide the first evidence of genetic interference influencing the recombination process in herpesviruses. In addition, we report striking differences in the levels of recombination frequency observed along the BoHV-1 genome. With particular emphasis on the genetic structure of a progeny virus population rising in vitro, our data show to which extent recombination participates to the genetic diversification of herpesviruses.

Replication-competent adenovirus formation in 293 cells: the recombination-based rate is influenced by structure and location of the transgene cassette and not increased by overproduction of HsRad51, Rad51-interacting, or E2F family proteins

Propagation of E1 region replacement adenovirus vectors in 293 cells results in the rare appearance of replication-competent adenovirus (RCA). The RCA genome contains E1 DNA acquired from the 293 cellular genome. The Luria-Delbruck fluctuation test was adapted to measure RCA formation rates. To test if structure affected rate, we measured rates during the production of adenovirus vectors with genomes containing three different expression cassette arrangements. The vectors had different extents of sequence identity with integrated Ad5 DNA of 293 cells and had different distributions of identity flanking the expression cassettes. Empty cassette vector RCA rates ranged from 2.5 x 10(-8) to 5.6 x 10(-10). The extent of sequence identity was not an accurate RCA rate predictor. The vector with the highest RCA rate also had the least overall sequence identity. To define factors controlling RCA generation, adenovirus vectors expressing E2F family proteins, known to modulate recombination gene expression, and overexpressing the human Rad51 recombination protein were analyzed. Compared to their corresponding empty vectors, RCA rates were not increased but were slightly decreased. Initial results suggested expression cassette orientation and/or transcription direction as potential RCA rate modifiers. Testing adenovirus vectors with identical transgene cassettes oriented in opposite directions suggested that transcription direction was not the basis of these rate differences. Thus, the overall structure and location of the transgene cassette had the largest effect on RCA rate. The RCA fluctuation test should be useful for investigators who require accurate measurements of targeted recombination and the probability of RCA formation during stock production.

Sequence conversion during postreplicative adenovirus overlap recombination

Sequence conversion efficiently transfers genetic information in high yield during postreplicative adenovirus overlap recombination. This process is intrinsically nonreciprocal, depends on adenovirus-specific strand-displacement replication by both partner molecules, and requires that complementary sequences on displaced strands must exceed a minimal length to form a heteroduplex intermediate.

Homologous recombination of adenovirus DNA in mammalian cells: enhanced recombination following UV-irradiation of the virus

We have used adenovirus as a molecular probe to examine the recombination of viral DNA following infection of mammalian cells. The technique gives a quantitative measure of homologous recombination between adenovirus type 2 (Ad2) and Ad5PyMTR3. Ad5PyMTR3 is an insertion mutant of Ad5 containing polyoma virus (Py) DNA inserted into a deleted E1 region of the Ad5 genome. Cells were coinfected with Ad2 and Ad5PyMTR3 and at an appropriate time after infection, viral DNA was extracted from the infected cells, digested with restriction endonuclease and electrophoresed through an agarose gel. Although Ad2 and Ad5 have more than 99% DNA homology, they differ sufficiently in their restriction endonuclease patterns, such that recombinant viral DNA molecules containing the Py insert could be detected and quantified by Southern blotting and hybridization to a radioactive Py DNA probe. Using this method we are able to detect and quantitate recombinant viral DNA molecules containing the Py insert which are present at frequencies down to at least 1 in 100. Recombination was detected in Chinese hamster ovary cells, monkey kidney cells, human HeLa cells, normal human fibroblasts and SV40 transformed human fibroblasts. In experiments using HeLa cells, the frequency of recombination between the Py insert on Ad5PyMTR3 and a number of unique restriction enzyme sites on Ad2 increased with the distance from the Py insert to the restriction site. Also in HeLa cells, recombination increased with increasing amounts of viral DNA synthesis and with increasing UV dose to the virus. UV-irradiation of both coinfecting viruses with 1500 J/m2 resulted in a more than 100-fold reduction in the amount of viral DNA synthesized and about a 3-fold increase in the frequency of recombination.

Adenovirus homologous recombination does not require expression of the immediate-early E1a gene

To investigate whether early genes other than those involved directly in DNA replication are required for efficient adenovirus recombination, pairs of viruses with deletions in E1a, E1b 496R, E1b 196R, or E4 and containing differing restriction site markers were used to infect both permissive and non- or semipermissive cells. Recombination was assayed among intracellular and extracellular genomes by restriction digestion and blot hybridization. Recombination was delayed in infections of nonpermissive cells with E1a- viruses until a time consistent with the late onset of DNA replication characteristic of the cell type. This shows that E1a expression is not absolutely required for adenovirus recombination. Similar tests with deletion mutations in E1b and E4 also show that these genes are not required for efficient recombination. Taken together with earlier results showing that recombination depends on DNA replication, it is likely that adenovirus recombination is a consequence of cellular repair functions acting on the substrates produced by replication.

A genetic investigation of the mechanism of adenovirus marker rescue

We have developed quantitative and segregational methods for investigating the mechanism of genetic exchange in adenovirus marker rescue. Estimates of "marker rescue frequency" (m.r.f.) were used to show that marker rescue increases linearly with increasing dose of fragment up to equimolarity with the full-length genome. The m.r.f. is also affected by the size of the rescuing fragment and the position of the wild-type allele within it, regardless of whether the fragment is terminal or internal. This is compatible with marker rescue being based on homologous exchange between the recombining partners. Examination of individually transfected cells showed that there is very wide variability in the values of the m.r.f.'s. This suggests that marker transfer can occur after replication of the full-length genome has begun, and can occur late into the infectious cycle. Unselected markers on the rescuing fragment were shown to be co-inherited frequently. This suggests that physical linkage is accompanied by genetic linkage. To examine this more closely, a multifactorial marker rescue was performed. The data show unequivocally that markers resident on the same fragment as the selected allele are inherited at high frequency, with a gradient of transfer in which markers closest to the selected marker are transferred most frequently. Markers up to 13 and perhaps as many as 17 kb apart can be inherited together. There are very few examples of the inheritance of distal markers in the absence of proximal ones. These data suggest that large pieces of DNA are transferred in a concerted reaction during marker rescue.

Analysis of recombination in mammalian cells using SV40 and SV40-derived vectors

Viruses and viral vectors have played a crucial role in our understanding of the pathways of homologous and non-homologous recombination in mitotically dividing mammalian cells. In particular, they have allowed the confirmation of the preponderance of non-homologous over homologous recombination events and led to schemes for the selection and isolation of homologous recombination products. These studies have allowed an examination of the properties of reciprocal and non-reciprocal homologous recombination events extrachromosomally, in the chromosome and between plasmids and chromosomes. They suggest that it is feasible now to direct DNA segments to predetermined chromosomal locations by homologous recombination.

Cre-stimulated recombination at loxP-containing DNA sequences placed into the mammalian genome

The cre gene of coliphage P1 encodes a 38 kDa protein which efficiently promotes both intra- and intermolecular recombination at specific 34 bp sites called loxP. To demonstrate that the Cre protein can promote DNA recombination at loxP sites resident on a mammalian chromosome, a mouse cell line was constructed containing two directly repeated loxP sites flanking a 2.5 kb yeast DNA fragment and inserted between the SV40 promoter and the neo structural gene to disrupt expression of the neo gene. Expression of the cre gene in this cell line results in excision of the intervening yeast DNA and thus permits sufficient expression of the neo gene to allow cell growth in high concentrations of G418. Southern analysis indicated that Cre-mediated excision occurred at the loxP sites. In the absence of the cre gene such excisive events are quite rare. Cre-mediated recombination should thus be quite useful in effecting a variety of genomic rearrangements in eukaryotic cells.

Homologous recombination between human immunodeficiency viral DNAs in cultured human cells: analysis of the factors influencing recombination

Recombination between HIV DNAs was analyzed using DNA transfection in cell cultures and the optimal conditions for efficient recombination were determined. Recombinant plasmid DNA substrates were constructed from HIV proviral DNAs and the success of recombination was measured by the production of viable hybrid virus. The process of recombination between HIV DNAs was shown to be i) dependent on homology between the truncated HIV DNAs and ii) maximum with concentrations of the truncated DNAs 3ug and above. HIV isolates with heterogeneity in their primary sequence, thus offer an ideal system for the analysis of the requirement of homologous recombination. In addition, recombination methodology would be useful for generating hybrid HIVs for the analysis of specific viral gene functions.

The creation of adenovirus genomes with viable, stable, internal redundancies centered about the E2b region

During the course of constructing new adenoviral strains by overlap recombination, we have discovered that internally redundant viable genomes can be created by end-to-end joining of the input DNA molecules. The cellular functions responsible for the end-joining activity frequently ligated the overhanging single strands of the complementary ends to form a novel restriction site at the junction. In 2 of the 17 cases analyzed in detail by restriction digestion, and some sequence determinations, the cellular functions had repaired the ends, presumably prior to end-joining. Four of the isolates had suffered deletions at the junction ranging in size from 13 to 532 bp. The isolate with the largest deletion also had an insertion of 14 bp of unknown origin at the site of the deletion. All of the redundant isolates replicated as efficiently as isogenic unit length strains, and plaque dilution titrations obeyed one-hit kinetics, showing that the redundant genomes were nondefective. Nevertheless unit-length genomes were observed at a low level (some 5 to 10% of the total) in stocks of each isolate before and after plaque purification. They presumably arose by recombination between the redundant sequences either intra- or intermolecularly. Evidence from Southern blot analysis showed that molecules with three copies of the redundant sequences also arose and could be detected both in intracellular and in capsid viral DNA. These species would arise by unequal crossing-over between redundant genomes. The efficient replication of the redundant species demonstrates that the precise spatial relationships between splice donors and acceptors on either strand, in this region of the genome, do not have to be rigidly maintained. These data suggest that it may be possible to place other genetic information between the DNA polymerase and terminal protein precursor genes and have it expressed from the major late promoter in its normal location.

Recombination in mouse L cells between DNA introduced into cells and homologous chromosomal sequences

In this paper, we show that DNA added to mouse L cells by the calcium phosphate method can be inserted into the genome of those cells by homologous recombination. The insertion event is detected because it reconstructs a functional thymidine kinase (tk) gene from two defective genes that share 320 base pairs of homology. One of the genes is missing its 5' portion (tk delta 5') and is in the cell's chromosome, and the other is missing its 3' portion (tk delta 3') and is in the introduced DNA. Gene reconstruction by homologous insertion is relatively inefficient; approximately one Tk+ transformant is produced per 10(6) cells per 4 micrograms of added tk DNA, a frequency of about 10(-5) that of normal tk gene transformation. The Tk+ transformants produced by homologous recombination contain Sma I and Pvu II fragments that are diagnostic of the intact tk gene, contain a herpesvirus-specific thymidine kinase activity, and can transfer the Tk+ phenotype to Tk- cells by DNA-mediated gene transfer. Two surprising observations made in the course of these studies were that only 1 of 10 Tk- cell lines containing defective tk genes could be transformed to Tk+ by homologous insertion of the complementary defective tk gene and that relatively little illegitimate insertion of introduced tk DNA into cellular DNA was detected in those cells that were transformed to Tk+ by homologous recombination.

The minimum amount of homology required for homologous recombination in mammalian cells

Although DNA sequence homology is believed to be a prerequisite for homologous recombination events in procaryotes and eucaryotes, no systematic study has been done on the minimum amount of homology required for homologous recombination in mammalian cells. We have used simian virus 40-pBR322 hybrid plasmids constructed in vitro as substrates to quantitate intramolecular homologous recombination in cultured monkey cells. Excision of wild-type simian virus 40 DNA by homologous recombination was scored by the viral plaque assay. Using a series of plasmids containing 0 to 243 base pairs of homology, we have shown that the recombination frequency decreases as the homology is reduced, with the sharpest drop in recombination frequency occurring when the homology was reduced from 214 to 163 base pairs. However, low recombination frequencies were also observed with as little as 14 base pairs of homology.

The minimum amount of homology required for homologous recombination in mammalian cells

Although DNA sequence homology is believed to be a prerequisite for homologous recombination events in procaryotes and eucaryotes, no systematic study has been done on the minimum amount of homology required for homologous recombination in mammalian cells. We have used simian virus 40-pBR322 hybrid plasmids constructed in vitro as substrates to quantitate intramolecular homologous recombination in cultured monkey cells. Excision of wild-type simian virus 40 DNA by homologous recombination was scored by the viral plaque assay. Using a series of plasmids containing 0 to 243 base pairs of homology, we have shown that the recombination frequency decreases as the homology is reduced, with the sharpest drop in recombination frequency occurring when the homology was reduced from 214 to 163 base pairs. However, low recombination frequencies were also observed with as little as 14 base pairs of homology.

Rescue of silent integrated polyoma genomes suggests homologous recombination between resident and transfected DNA fragments

Two defective polyoma virus genomes, deleted in the nucleotide sequences coding the N-termini of the tumor antigens, were introduced into Fisher 3T3 rat cells by DNA-mediated gene transfer (transfection). The resulting integrated genomes were incapable of conferring a transformed phenotype to the cells. However, after transfection of these lines with small polyoma fragments overlapping the deleted sequences, transformed clones were isolated. These clones were analyzed by Southern genomic blot hybridization and by isolation in E. coli of plasmids containing viral sequences excised following fusion with mouse polyoma growth-permissive cells. In all cases at least one intact copy of the early region of the polyoma genome was found. Furthermore, restriction sites adjacent to the initial inactive insertion remained unchanged in many of the transformed lines. These results show that functional restoration of the defective polyoma early region involves homologous recombination between the deleted viral genomes integrated in the cellular DNA and the transfecting viral fragments.

Replication and recombination in adenovirus-infected cells are temporally and functionally related

We have studied the temporal and functional relationships between DNA replication and recombination in adenovirus-infected cells by using Southern blot hybridization to detect recombinant products among intracellular viral genomes. The data show that recombination can be detected soon after DNA replication has commenced and that the proportion of recombinant products increases thereafter. To determine the functional relationship between DNA replication and recombination, replication was blocked with the protein synthesis inhibitor anisomycin, the replication inhibitor cytosine arabinoside, and conditionally lethal mutations in either the virus-specified DNA-binding protein or the DNA polymerase. All treatments that directly or indirectly blocked DNA replication caused a delay in the appearance of recombinant products and a marked decline in their abundance relative to products of parental genotype. These data strongly suggest that DNA replication and recombination are interrelated, either because both processes share functions or because DNA structures produced by replication are suitable substrates for recombination. In addition, we have shown that some recombination function(s) is intrinsically thermolabile at 40.9 degrees C, even in wild-type crosses, since the appearance of recombinant products is delayed and their extent is reduced compared with that from crosses performed at 39.9 degrees C.

Model for homologous recombination during transfer of DNA into mouse L cells: role for DNA ends in the recombination process

We have constructed phage lambda and plasmid DNA substrates (lambda tk2 and ptk2) that contain two defective herpesvirus thymidine kinase (tk) genes that can be used to detect homologous recombination during the transfer of DNA into mouse L cells deficient in thymidine kinase activity. The recombination event reconstructs a wild-type tk gene and is scored because it converts Tk- cells to Tk+. Using this system, we have shown that (i) both intramolecular and intermolecular homologous recombination can be detected after gene transfer; (ii) the degree of recombination decreases with decreasing tk gene homology; and (iii) the efficiency of recombination can be stimulated 10- to 100-fold by cutting the tk2 DNA with restriction enzymes at appropriate sites relative to the recombining sequences. Based on the substrate requirements for these recombination events, we propose a model to explain how recombination might occur in mammalian cells. The essential features of the model are that the cut restriction site ends are substrates for cellular exonucleases that degrade DNA strands. This process exposes complementary strands of the two defective tk genes, which then pair. Removal of unpaired DNA at the junction between the paired and unpaired regions permits a gap repair process to reconstruct an intact gene.

Homologous recombination between overlapping thymidine kinase gene fragments stably inserted into a mouse cell genome

We have constructed a substrate to study homologous recombination between adjacent segments of chromosomal DNA. This substrate, designated lambda tk2 , consists of one completely defective and one partially defective herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (tk) gene cloned in bacteriophage lambda DNA. The two genes have homologous 984-base-pair sequences and are separated by 3 kilobases of largely vector DNA. When lambda tk2 DNA was transferred into mouse LMtk- cells by the calcium phosphate method, rare TK+ transformants were obtained that contained many (greater than 40) copies of the unrecombined DNA. Tk- revertants, which had lost most of the copies of unrecombined DNA, were isolated from these TK+-transformed lines. Two of these Tk- lines were further studied by analysis of their reversion back to the Tk+ phenotype. They generated ca. 200 Tk+ revertants per 10(8) cells after growth in nonselecting medium for 5 days. All of these Tk+ revertants have an intact tk gene reconstructed by homologous recombination; they also retain various amounts of unrecombined lambda tk2 DNA. Southern blot analysis suggested that at least some of the recombination events involve unequal sister chromatid exchanges. We also tested three agents, mitomycin C, 12-O-tetradecanoyl-phorbol-13-acetate, and mezerein, that are thought to stimulate recombination to determine whether they affect the reversion from Tk- to Tk+. Only mitomycin C increased the number of Tk+ revertants.

Model for homologous recombination during transfer of DNA into mouse L cells: role for DNA ends in the recombination process

We have constructed phage lambda and plasmid DNA substrates (lambda tk2 and ptk2) that contain two defective herpesvirus thymidine kinase (tk) genes that can be used to detect homologous recombination during the transfer of DNA into mouse L cells deficient in thymidine kinase activity. The recombination event reconstructs a wild-type tk gene and is scored because it converts Tk- cells to Tk+. Using this system, we have shown that (i) both intramolecular and intermolecular homologous recombination can be detected after gene transfer; (ii) the degree of recombination decreases with decreasing tk gene homology; and (iii) the efficiency of recombination can be stimulated 10- to 100-fold by cutting the tk2 DNA with restriction enzymes at appropriate sites relative to the recombining sequences. Based on the substrate requirements for these recombination events, we propose a model to explain how recombination might occur in mammalian cells. The essential features of the model are that the cut restriction site ends are substrates for cellular exonucleases that degrade DNA strands. This process exposes complementary strands of the two defective tk genes, which then pair. Removal of unpaired DNA at the junction between the paired and unpaired regions permits a gap repair process to reconstruct an intact gene.

Polarity in adenovirus recombination

The distributions of the crossovers necessary to generate ts+ genomes have been examined in a collection of clonally unrelated ts+ recombinants from a set of ts X ts adenovirus crosses. In a cross between two parents that are grossly heterologous between map units 80.2 and 91.5, the distribution of crossovers was significantly skewed toward the left-hand end of the genome, with a declining frequency proceeding rightward. This gradient of recombination was modified by the removal of the right-hand heterology and by the presence of another region of heterology between map units 3.67 and 10.11. In a cross where the ts markers were flanked by both heterologies, no gradient was observed and ts+ recombinants were characterized by a higher rate of supernumerary crossovers. In a cross designed so that one ts marker was internal to two heterologies, crossovers were found disproportionately between the second ts marker and the nearby heterology. In addition, ts+ recombinants formed by crossing over internal to the heterologies again were accompanied by a high frequency of supernumerary crossovers. Finally, ts+ recombinant frequencies in crosses identical except for the presence of either one or two flanking heterologies were markedly lower in the latter case. These data, taken together, suggest that a major pathway of adenovirus recombination initiates at, or near, the molecular termini and is perhaps driven by the displaced single strands produced during DNA replication. Internal initiation, on the other hand, may employ these single strands to form genetic "patches."

Homologous recombination between overlapping thymidine kinase gene fragments stably inserted into a mouse cell genome

We have constructed a substrate to study homologous recombination between adjacent segments of chromosomal DNA. This substrate, designated lambda tk2 , consists of one completely defective and one partially defective herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (tk) gene cloned in bacteriophage lambda DNA. The two genes have homologous 984-base-pair sequences and are separated by 3 kilobases of largely vector DNA. When lambda tk2 DNA was transferred into mouse LMtk- cells by the calcium phosphate method, rare TK+ transformants were obtained that contained many (greater than 40) copies of the unrecombined DNA. Tk- revertants, which had lost most of the copies of unrecombined DNA, were isolated from these TK+-transformed lines. Two of these Tk- lines were further studied by analysis of their reversion back to the Tk+ phenotype. They generated ca. 200 Tk+ revertants per 10(8) cells after growth in nonselecting medium for 5 days. All of these Tk+ revertants have an intact tk gene reconstructed by homologous recombination; they also retain various amounts of unrecombined lambda tk2 DNA. Southern blot analysis suggested that at least some of the recombination events involve unequal sister chromatid exchanges. We also tested three agents, mitomycin C, 12-O-tetradecanoyl-phorbol-13-acetate, and mezerein, that are thought to stimulate recombination to determine whether they affect the reversion from Tk- to Tk+. Only mitomycin C increased the number of Tk+ revertants.

Detection of herpes simplex virus intertypic recombinant genomes in infected cell DNA

Intertypic recombination between herpes simplex virus types 1 and 2 (HSV-1 and HSV-2) was detected using DNA from mixedly infected cells. Because HSV-1 and HSV-2 share a 50% base sequence homology along the genome but have markedly different DNA restriction enzyme cleavage patterns, recombination events can be detected and quantified by analysis of restriction endonuclease digests for the presence of novel DNA fragments. We have used this technique to quantify the degree of interference by HSV-2 on HSV-1 replication as well as the effect of limiting the availability of one genome on the frequency of intertypic recombination. Because this technique does not require production of viable progeny virions, it should also be useful for studying early recombination events.

Recombination in adenovirus: DNA sequence analysis of crossover sites in intertypic recombinants

The nucleotide sequence of the adenovirus type 5 genome has been determined for a 620-bp region that spans the C terminus of the pVI gene and the N terminus of the hexon gene, and compared to the adenovirus type 2 DNA sequence: 25 base changes have been identified, most of which do not lead to alterations in the amino acid sequence and regulatory signals in the region. Crossover sites in three intertypic recombinants have been previously located in this region of the genome by fine restriction mapping. A sequence determination for the three recombinants, and the four ts mutants used in generating the ts+ recombinants, was carried out. The crossovers were in each case located in a small region of complete sequence homology (from 45 to 156 nucleotides long) flanked on either side by sequences derived from each parent. These structures are compatible with a reciprocal crossing over model of generalised recombination, where a recombinant joint has resolved in a region of high DNA homology. For the recombinants considered here, this region abutts onto a neighbouring region of much lower sequence homology, and it is possible that the position of the crossover is determined at least in part by the termination of branch migration at a heterologous boundary.

Homologous and nonhomologous recombination in monkey cells

Though recombinational events are important for the proper functioning of most cells, little is known about the frequency and mechanisms of recombination in mammalian cells. We have used simian virus 40 (SV40)-pBR322 hybrid plasmids constructed in vitro as substrates to detect and quantitate intramolecular homologous and nonhomologous recombination events in cultured monkey cells. Excision of wild-type or defective SV40 DNAs by recombination from these plasmids was scored by the viral plaque assay, in either the absence or the presence of DNA from a temperature-sensitive helper virus. Several independent products of homologous and nonhomologous recombination have been isolated and characterized at the DNA sequence level. We find that neither DNA replication of the recombination substrate nor SV40 large T antigen is essential for either homologous or nonhomologous recombination involving viral or pBR322 sequences.

Homologous and nonhomologous recombination in monkey cells

Though recombinational events are important for the proper functioning of most cells, little is known about the frequency and mechanisms of recombination in mammalian cells. We have used simian virus 40 (SV40)-pBR322 hybrid plasmids constructed in vitro as substrates to detect and quantitate intramolecular homologous and nonhomologous recombination events in cultured monkey cells. Excision of wild-type or defective SV40 DNAs by recombination from these plasmids was scored by the viral plaque assay, in either the absence or the presence of DNA from a temperature-sensitive helper virus. Several independent products of homologous and nonhomologous recombination have been isolated and characterized at the DNA sequence level. We find that neither DNA replication of the recombination substrate nor SV40 large T antigen is essential for either homologous or nonhomologous recombination involving viral or pBR322 sequences.

The genetic analysis of adenovirus recombination in triparental and superinfection crosses

Previous genetic and molecular data suggest that adenovirus genomes can undergo several rounds of recombination before being encapsidated (C. S. H. Young and S. J. Silverstein, Virology 101, 503-515). Two predictions of this hypothesis have been tested. The first is that infection with three differentially marked parental viruses should lead to the appearance of recombinants with genetic contributions from all three parents. In a triparental cross, involving two strains with different ts mutations in chimeric Ad5/Ad2+ND1 backgrounds, and a third strain containing both ts mutations in an Ad5 background, it was demonstrated that multiple recombinations, involving distinguishable restriction endonuclease sites and host range markers from all three parents, were common. The second prediction, from previous kinetic data, is that cells are recombinationally proficient from the eclipse period well into the exponential rise period. This has been tested by superinfecting singly infected cultures, both during eclipse and in early exponential phase. Recombinant viruses were produced in these superinfections, demonstrating that the early to late switch in the replicative cycle does not inhibit recombination. From the temporal appearance of recombinants moreover, it seems likely that recombination functions, and the DNA structures necessary to initiate recombination, are present well into the late phase of replication.

Somatic cells efficiently join unrelated DNA segments end-to-end

Molecular substrates for probing nonhomologous recombination in somatic cells were constructed by inserting pBR322 sequences at selected sites on the simian virus 40 (SV40) genome. The chimeric products are too large to be packaged into an SV40 capsid. Therefore, production of viable progeny requires that most of the pBR322 sequences be deleted without altering any SV40 sequences that are essential for lytic infection. As judged by plaque assay, these recombination events occur at readily detectable frequencies after transfection into CV1 monkey kidney cells. Depending on the site of pBR322 insertion, the infectivities of the full-length circular or linear chimeras ranged from 0.02 to 2% of the infectivity of linear wild-type SV40 DNA. Nucleotide sequence analysis of several recombinant progeny revealed three distinct classes of recombination junction and indicated that the causative recombination events were minimally dependent on sequence homology. Potential mechanisms involving recombination at internal sites or at ends were distinguished by measuring the infectivity of chimeric molecules from which various lengths of pBR322 had been removed. These data support end-to-end joining as the primary mechanism by which DNA segments recombine nonhomologously in somatic cells. This end joining appears to be very efficient, since SV40 genomes with complementary single-stranded tails or with short non-complementary pBR322 tails were comparably infectious. Overall, this study indicates that mammalian somatic cells are quite efficient at the willy-nilly end-to-end joining of unrelated DNA segments.

The genetic analysis of recombination using adenovirus overlapping terminal DNA fragments

We have studied the consequences of genetic recombination between overlapping terminal fragments of adenovirus genomes with respect to markers in the overlapping sequence. The findings are consistent with general recombination occurring approximately isotonically within the interval. In particular, single markers within the overlap, scored nonselectively, showed frequencies of recovery dependent on the position of their locus in relation to the ends of the overlap. Pairs of ts markers recombined to form ts+ progeny in proportion to their distance apart, provided the markers were oriented so that a single crossover between them would produce a full-length genome bearing both ts+ alleles. In the opposite orientation, where such a single crossover would be expected to produce ts/ts recombinants, the ts+ frequency was much lower, indicating that multiple recombination events are rare in this system. These findings rule out site-specific recombination, recombination occurring exclusively at the cleaved ends of the overlap, and recombination by means of mismatch repair of a heteroduplex the length of the overlap. They also indicate either that any heteroduplex junction region formed in the course of this reaction is quite short or that it is not subject to heteroduplex repair. Finally, our results demonstrate the efficacy of overlap recombination as a genetic and physical mapping tool and as a method of strain construction, and they suggest other applications, such as using overlap recombination to demonstrate that closely spaced pairs of markers (e.g., putative second-site reversions and their accompanying ts lesions) can be segregated.

Somatic cells efficiently join unrelated DNA segments end-to-end

Molecular substrates for probing nonhomologous recombination in somatic cells were constructed by inserting pBR322 sequences at selected sites on the simian virus 40 (SV40) genome. The chimeric products are too large to be packaged into an SV40 capsid. Therefore, production of viable progeny requires that most of the pBR322 sequences be deleted without altering any SV40 sequences that are essential for lytic infection. As judged by plaque assay, these recombination events occur at readily detectable frequencies after transfection into CV1 monkey kidney cells. Depending on the site of pBR322 insertion, the infectivities of the full-length circular or linear chimeras ranged from 0.02 to 2% of the infectivity of linear wild-type SV40 DNA. Nucleotide sequence analysis of several recombinant progeny revealed three distinct classes of recombination junction and indicated that the causative recombination events were minimally dependent on sequence homology. Potential mechanisms involving recombination at internal sites or at ends were distinguished by measuring the infectivity of chimeric molecules from which various lengths of pBR322 had been removed. These data support end-to-end joining as the primary mechanism by which DNA segments recombine nonhomologously in somatic cells. This end joining appears to be very efficient, since SV40 genomes with complementary single-stranded tails or with short non-complementary pBR322 tails were comparably infectious. Overall, this study indicates that mammalian somatic cells are quite efficient at the willy-nilly end-to-end joining of unrelated DNA segments.

DNA replication-mediated recombination of molecules of adenovirus 2 DNA

Molecules of adenovirus 2 DNA were isolated as nucleoprotein complexes late in infection of HeLa cells and examined by electron microscopy. Some were interpreted as representing intermediates in recombination events. The structures observed were consistent with predicted intermediates according to the model for genetic recombination proposed by Meselson and Radding [Meselson, M. S. & Radding, C. M. (1975) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 72, 358-361] and constitute physical evidence from animal cells in support of this model.

Visualization of genetic recombination intermediates of human adenovirus type 2 DNA from infected HeLa cells

The study of recombination in prokaryotes has been facilitated by the availability of recombinational mutants and simple genetic elements such as phages and plasmids. These small but defined molecules of DNA have been especially useful for electron microscopic analysis of structural detail of molecules undergoing recombination both in vivo and in vitro. A limitation in the structural analysis of plasmid recombination is the absolute number of recombining molecules which can be identified and analysed amidst a background of nonrecombining molecules. This limitation would be of even greater consequence in studies of genetic recombination in animal cells. We therefore chose virus-infected animal cells as a model system for the study of the molecular mechanism of genetic recombination in higher organisms. HeLa cells infected with adenovirus serotype 2 (Ad-2) offer several advantages for studying recombination: (1) the virus contains a small and well characterized genome of about 35 kilobases; (2) a large amount of Ad-2 DNA is accumulated during lytic infection and host DNA synthesis is suppressed; (3) Ad-2 recombines at a very high frequency; and (4) similar to phages, animal viruses and Ad-2 in particular are believed to use many of the host cell's enzymes in necessary metabolic processes, presumably including recombination. In this study we used electron microscopic techniques to visualize the structures of in vivo Ad-2 DNA recombination intermediates. Molecules were observed with structures at putative cross-over points which were consistent with the molecular mechanism of recombination proposed by Holliday. In addition, we observed Ad-2 DNA molecules engaged in recombination which were simultaneously serving as templates for replication and/or transcription. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first visualization of in vivo recombination intermediates of discrete DNA molecules isolated from eukaryotic cells.