Homologous interactions of lambda repressor and lambda Cro with the lambda operator

Chromatin Conformation in Development and Disease

Chromatin domains and loops are important elements of chromatin structure and dynamics, but much remains to be learned about their exact biological role and nature. Topological associated domains and functional loops are key to gene expression and hold the answer to many questions regarding developmental decisions and diseases. Here, we discuss new findings, which have linked chromatin conformation with development, differentiation and diseases and hypothesized on various models while integrating all recent findings on how chromatin architecture affects gene expression during development, evolution and disease.

A bacterial three-hybrid assay detects Escherichia coli Hfq-sRNA interactions in vivo

The interaction of RNA molecules with proteins is a critical aspect of gene regulation across all domains of life. Here, we report the development of a bacterial three-hybrid (B3H) assay to genetically detect RNA-protein interactions. The basis for this three-hybrid assay is a transcription-based bacterial two-hybrid assay that has been used widely to detect and dissect protein-protein interactions. In the three-hybrid assay, a DNA-bound protein with a fused RNA-binding moiety (the coat protein of bacteriophage MS2 (MS2CP)) is used to recruit a hybrid RNA upstream of a test promoter. The hybrid RNA consists of a constant region that binds the tethered MS2CP and a variable region. Interaction between the variable region of the hybrid RNA and a target RNA-binding protein that is fused to a subunit of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP) stabilizes the binding of RNAP to the test promoter, thereby activating transcription of a reporter gene. We demonstrate that this three-hybrid assay detects interaction between non-coding small RNAs (sRNAs) and the hexameric RNA chaperone Hfq from E. coli and enables the identification of Hfq mutants with sRNA-binding defects. Our findings suggest that this B3H assay will be broadly applicable for the study of RNA-protein interactions.

Dissection of recognition determinants of Escherichia coli sigma32 suggests a composite -10 region with an 'extended -10' motif and a core -10 element

Sigma32 controls expression of heat shock genes in Escherichia coli and is widely distributed in proteobacteria. The distinguishing feature of sigma32 promoters is a long -10 region (CCCCATNT) whose tetra-C motif is important for promoter activity. Using alanine-scanning mutagenesis of sigma32 and in vivo and in vitro assays, we identified promoter recognition determinants of this motif. The most downstream C (-13) is part of the -10 motif; our work confirms and extends recognition determinants of -13C. Most importantly, our work suggests that the two upstream Cs (-16, -15) constitute an 'extended -10' recognition motif that is recognized by K130, a residue universally conserved in beta- and gamma-proteobacteria. This residue is located in the alpha-helix of sigmaDomain 3 that mediates recognition of the extended -10 promoter motif in other sigmas. K130 is not conserved in alpha- and delta-/epsilon-proteobacteria and we found that sigma32 from the alpha-proteobacterium Caulobacter crescentus does not need the extended -10 motif for high promoter activity. This result supports the idea that K130 mediates extended -10 recognition. Sigma32 is the first Group 3 sigma shown to use the 'extended -10' recognition motif.

Mutational analysis of Escherichia coli sigma28 and its target promoters reveals recognition of a composite -10 region, comprised of an 'extended -10' motif and a core -10 element

Sigma28 controls the expression of flagella-related genes and is the most widely distributed alternative sigma factor, present in motile Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria. The distinguishing feature of sigma28 promoters is a long -10 region (GCCGATAA). Despite the fact that the upstream GC is highly conserved, previous studies have not indicated a functional role for this motif. Here we examine the functional relevance of the GCCG motif and determine which residues in sigma28 participate in its recognition. We find that the GCCG motif is a functionally important composite element. The upstream GC constitutes an extended -10 motif and is recognized by R91, a residue in Domain 3 of sigma28. The downstream CG is the upstream edge of -10 region of the promoter; two residues in Region 2.4, D81 and R84, participate in its recognition. Consistent with their role in base-specific recognition of the promoter, R91, D81 and D84 are universally conserved in sigma28 orthologues. Sigma28 is the second Group 3 sigma shown to use an extended -10 region in promoter recognition, raising the possibility that other Group 3 sigmas will do so as well.

Crystal structure of the DNA-binding domain of BldD, a central regulator of aerial mycelium formation in Streptomyces coelicolor A3(2)

BldD is a central regulator of the developmental process in Streptomyces coelicolor. The 1.8 angstroms resolution structure of the DNA-binding domain of BldD (BldDN) reveals that BldDN forms a compact globular domain composed of four helices (alpha1-alpha4) containing a helix-turn-helix motif (alpha2-alpha3) resembling that of the DNA-binding domain of lambda repressor. The BldDN/DNA complex model led us to design a series of mutants, which revealed the important role of alpha3 and the 'turn' region between alpha2 and alpha3 for DNA recognition. Based on the fact that BldD occupies two operator sites of bldN and whiG and shows significant disparity in the affinity toward the two operator sites when they are disconnected, we propose a model of cooperative binding, which means that the binding of one BldD dimer to the high affinity site facilitates that of the second BldD dimer to the low affinity site. In addition, structural and mutational investigation reveals that the Tyr62Cys mutation, found in the first-identified bldD mutant, can destabilize BldD structure by disrupting the hydrophobic core.

Effect of supercoiling on formation of protein-mediated DNA loops

DNA loop formation is one of several mechanisms used by organisms to regulate genes. The free energy of forming a loop is an important factor in determining whether the associated gene is switched on or off. In this paper we use an elastic rod model of DNA to determine the free energy of forming short (50-100 basepair), protein mediated DNA loops. Superhelical stress in the DNA of living cells is a critical factor determining the energetics of loop formation, and we explicitly account for it in our calculations. The repressor protein itself is regarded as a rigid coupler; its geometry enters the problem through the boundary conditions it applies on the DNA. We show that a theory with these ingredients is sufficient to explain certain features observed in modulation of in vivo gene activity as a function of the distance between operator sites for the lac repressor. We also use our theory to make quantitative predictions for the dependence of looping on superhelical stress, which may be testable both in vivo and in single-molecule experiments such as the tethered particle assay and the magnetic bead assay.

Investigating the basis of substrate recognition in the pC221 relaxosome

The nicking of the origin of transfer (oriT) is an essential initial step in the conjugative mobilization of plasmid DNA. In the case of staphylococcal plasmid pC221, nicking by the plasmid-specific MobA relaxase is facilitated by the DNA-binding accessory protein MobC; however, the role of MobC in this process is currently unknown. In this study, the site of MobC binding was determined by DNase I footprinting. MobC interacts with oriT DNA at two directly repeated 9 bp sequences, mcb1 and mcb2, upstream of the oriT nic site, and additionally at a third, degenerate repeat within the mobC gene, mcb3. The binding activity of the conserved sequences was confirmed indirectly by competitive electrophoretic mobility shift assays and directly by Surface Plasmon Resonance studies. Mutation at mcb2 abolished detectable nicking activity, suggesting that binding of this site by MobC is a prerequisite for nicking by MobA. Sequential site-directed mutagenesis of each binding site in pC221 has demonstrated that all three are required for mobilization. The MobA relaxase, while unable to bind to oriT DNA alone, was found to associate with a MobC-oriT complex and alter the MobC binding profile in a region between mcb2 and the nic site. Mutagenesis of oriT in this region defines a 7 bp sequence, sra, which was essential for nicking by MobA. Exchange of four divergent bases between the sra of pC221 and the related plasmid pC223 was sufficient to swap their substrate identity in a MobA-specific nicking assay. Based on these observations we propose a model of layered specificity in the assembly of pC221-family relaxosomes, whereby a common MobC:mcb complex presents the oriT substrate, which is then nicked only by the cognate MobA.

Regulation of sexual dimorphism: mutational and chemogenetic analysis of the doublesex DM domain

Doublesex (dsx) is a transcription factor in Drosophila that regulates somatic sexual differentiation. Male- and female-specific splicing isoforms of DSX share a novel DNA-binding domain, designated the DM motif. Broadly conserved among metazoan sex-determining factors, the DM domain contains a nonclassical zinc module and binds in the DNA minor groove. Here, we characterize the DM motif by site-directed and random mutagenesis using a yeast one-hybrid (Y1H) system and extend this analysis by chemogenetic complementation in vitro. The Y1H system is based on a sex-specific Drosophila enhancer element and validated through studies of intersexual dsx mutations. We demonstrate that the eight motif-specific histidines and cysteines engaged in zinc coordination are each critical and cannot be interchanged; folding also requires conserved aliphatic side chains in the hydrophobic core. Mutations that impair DNA binding tend to occur at conserved positions, whereas neutral substitutions occur at nonconserved sites. Evidence for a specific salt bridge between a conserved lysine and the DNA backbone is obtained through the synthesis of nonstandard protein and DNA analogs. Together, these results provide molecular links between the structure of the DM domain and its function in the regulation of sexual dimorphism.

A chimeric activator of transcription that uses two DNA-binding domains to make simultaneous contact with pairs of recognition sites

Many well-known transcriptional regulatory proteins are composed of at least two independently folding domains and, typically, only one of these is a DNA-binding domain. However, some transcriptional regulators have been described that have more than one DNA-binding domain. Regulators with a single DNA-binding domain often bind co-operatively to the DNA in homotypic or heterotypic combinations, and two or more DNA-binding domains of a single regulatory protein can also bind co-operatively to suitably positioned recognition sequences. Here, we examine the behaviour of a chimeric activator of transcription with two different DNA-binding domains, that of the bacteriophage lambda cI protein and that of the Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein. We show that these two DNA-binding moieties, when present in the same molecule, can bind co-operatively to a pair of cognate recognition sites located upstream of a test promoter, thereby permitting the chimera to function as a particularly strong activator of transcription from this promoter. Our results show how such a bivalent DNA-binding protein can be used to regulate transcription differentially from promoters that bear either one or both recognition sites.

Intermolecular contacts between the lambda-Cro repressor and the operator DNA characterized by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy

The specific interaction between lambda phage Cro repressor and the DNA fragment bearing the consensus sequence of operators has been studied using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). Using both 15N- and 13C/15N- labeled lambda-Cro in complex with unlabeled DNA, chemical shift assignments of the lambda-Cro-DNA complex were obtained using heteronuclear NMR experiments. Inter-molecular contacts between the protein and DNA were identified using heteronuclear filtered NOESY experiments. The inter-molecular contacts were supplemented with intra-protein and intra-DNA NOE constraints to dock lambda-Cro to the bent B-form DNA using restrained molecular dynamics. The structure of one of the subunits of lambda-Cro in the complex is essentially the same as that of the unbound form. In the complex, inter-molecular NOEs were observed between the "helix-turn-helix" region comprising the alpha2 and alpha3 helices of the lambda-Cro protein and the major groove of the DNA. The methyl group of Thr17 forms a hydrophobic contact with the methyl group of the thymine at base pair 1 in the DNA, and Val25 and Ala29 make hydrophobic contacts with the methyl group of the thymine at base pair 5. The presence and the absence of these contacts can explain the difference in the affinity of lambda-Cro to several variants of the operator sequence.

Probing site-specific interactions in protein-DNA complexes using heteronuclear NMR spectroscopy and molecular modeling: binding of Cro repressor to OR3

In this paper, a general method is developed to study site-specific interactions in DNA-protein complexes using heteronuclear NMR spectroscopy and molecular modeling. This method involves two steps: (a) homonuclear 1H NMR and molecular modeling are used to develop a low resolution model and (b) 15N7-guanosine containing oligonucleotides are employed to probe the specific intermolecular interactions predicted in (a). This method is applied to Cro-operator complex due to its small size and extensive prior characterization. Non-exchangeable and exchangeable base protons have been assigned by nuclear Overhauser effect spectroscopy (NOESY) and chemical shift correlation spectroscopy. Extensive line-broadening has been observed in the 1H NMR spectra of the operator DNA in the presence of protein. Differential line-broadening observed in the imino proton region and the comparison of NOESY spectra in the presence and absence of Cro protein show that guanosine-12 and guanosine-14 are involved in the Cro-DNA interaction, while the three A.T base-pairs at the 3'- and 5'-termini play only a minor role in the binding. A model of the Cro-operator DNA complex has been constructed by docking helix-3 of the Cro protein in the major groove and it predicted specific hydrogen bonds between N7 of guanosines-12 and -14 and the side-chain of Lys-32 and Ser-28, respectively. The appearance of a new resonance in the temperature dependent proton detected heteronuclear multiple quantum coherence (HMQC) spectra of the Cro-DNA complex also demonstrates a specific interaction of Cro with guanosine-14 of the operator DNA.

Crystal structure of lambda-Cro bound to a consensus operator at 3.0 A resolution

The structure of the Cro protein from bacteriophage lambda in complex with a 19 base-pair DNA duplex that includes the 17 base-pair consensus operator has been determined at 3.0 A resolution. The structure confirms the large changes in the protein and DNA seen previously in a crystallographically distinct low-resolution structure of the complex and, for the first time, reveals the detailed interactions between the side-chains of the protein and the base-pairs of the operator. Relative to the crystal structure of the free protein, the subunits of Cro rotate 53 degrees with respect to each other on binding DNA. At the same time the DNA is bent by 40 degrees through the 19 base-pairs. The intersubunit connection includes a region within the protein core that is structurally reminiscent of the "ball and socket" motif seen in the immunoglobulins and T-cell receptors. The crystal structure of the Cro complex is consistent with virtually all available biochemical and related data. Some of the interactions between Cro and DNA proposed on the basis of model-building are now seen to be correct, but many are different. Tests of the original model by mutagenesis and biochemical analysis corrected some but not all of the errors. Within the limitations of the crystallographic resolution it appears that operator recognition is achieved almost entirely by direct hydrogen-bonding and van der Waals contacts between the protein and the exposed bases within the major groove of the DNA. The discrimination of Cro between the operators OR3 and OR1, which differ in sequence at just three positions, is inferred to result from a combination of small differences, both favorable and unfavorable. A van der Waals contact at one of the positions is of primary importance, while the other two provide smaller, indirect effects. Direct hydrogen bonding is not utilized in this distinction.

How Cro and lambda-repressor distinguish between operators: the structural basis underlying a genetic switch

Knowledge of the three-dimensional structures of the lambda-Cro and lambda-repressor proteins in complex with DNA has made it possible to evaluate how these proteins discriminate between different operators in phage lambda. As anticipated in previous studies, the helix-turn-helix units of the respective proteins bind in very different alignments. In Cro the recognition helices are 29 A apart and are tilted by 55 degrees with respect to each other, but bind parallel to the major groove of the DNA. In lambda-repressor [Beamer, L. J. & Pabo, C. O. (1992) J. Mol. Biol. 227, 177-196] the helices are 34 A apart and are essentially parallel to each other, but are inclined to the major grooves. The DNA is much more bent when bound by Cro than in the case with lambda-repressor. The first two amino acids of the recognition helices of the two proteins, Gln-27 and Ser-28 in Cro, and Gln-44 and Ser-45 in lambda-repressor, make very similar interactions with the invariant bps 2 and 4. There are also analogous contacts between the thymine of bp 5 and, respectively, the backbone of Ala-29 of Cro and the backbone of Gly-46 of lambda-repressor. Otherwise, however, unrelated parts of the two proteins are used in sequence-specific recognition. It appears that similar contacts to the invariant or almost invariant bps (especially 2 and 4) are used by both Cro and lambda-repressor to differentiate the operator sites as a group from other sites on the DNA. The discrimination of Cro and lambda-repressor between their different operators is more subtle and seems to be achieved primarily through differences in van der Waals contacts at bp 3', together with weaker, less direct effects at bps 5' and 8', all in the nonconsensus half of the operators. The results provide further support for the idea that there is no simple code for DNA-protein recognition.

Conversion of the omega subunit of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase into a transcriptional activator or an activation target

Evidence obtained in both eukaryotes and prokaryotes indicates that arbitrary contacts between DNA-bound proteins and components of the transcriptional machinery can activate transcription. Here we demonstrate that the Escherichia coli omega protein, which copurifies with RNA polymerase, can function as a transcriptional activator when linked covalently to a DNA-binding protein. We show further that omega can function as an activation target when this covalent linkage is replaced by a pair of interacting polypeptides fused to the DNA-binding protein and to omega, respectively. Our findings imply that the omega protein is associated with RNA polymerase holoenzyme in vivo, and provide support for the hypothesis that contact between a DNA-bound protein and any component of E. coli RNA polymerase can activate transcription.

CRP interacts with promoter-bound sigma54 RNA polymerase and blocks transcriptional activation of the dctA promoter

The cAMP receptor protein (CRP) is an activator of sigma70-dependent transcription. Analysis of the sigma54-dependent dctA promoter reveals a novel negative regulatory function for CRP. CRP can bind to two distant sites of the dctA promoter, sites which overlap the upstream activator sequences for the DctD activator. CRP interacts with Esigma54 bound at the dctA promoter via DNA loop formation. When the CRP-binding sites are deleted, CRP still interacts in a cAMP-dependent manner with the stable Esigma54 closed complex via protein-protein contacts. CRP is able to repress activation of the dctA promoter, even in the absence of specific CRP-binding sites. CRP affects both the final level and the kinetics of activation. The establishment of the repression and its release by the NtrC activator proceed via slow processes. The kinetics suggest that CRP favours a new form of closed complex which interconverts slowly with the classical closed intermediate. Only the latter is capable of interacting with an activator to form an open promoter complex. Thus, Esigma54 promoters are responsive to CRP, a protein unrelated to sigma54 activators, and the repression exerted is the direct result of an interaction between Esigma54 and the CRP-cAMP complex.

Mutation of the Oct-1 POU-specific recognition helix leads to altered DNA binding and influences enhancement of adenovirus DNA replication

To assess which residues of Oct-1 POU-specific (POUs) are important for DNA recognition and stimulation of adenovirus DNA replication we have mutated 10 residues of the POUs helix-turn-helix motif implicated in DNA contact. Seven of these turned out to have reduced DNA binding affinity. Of these, three alanine substituted proteins were found to have a changed specificity using a binding site selection procedure. Mutation of the first residue in the recognition helix, Gln44, to alanine led to a loss of specificity for the first two bases, TA, of the wild-type recognition site TATGC(A/T)AAT. Instead of the A, a T was selected, suggesting a new contact and a novel specificity. A change in specificity was also observed for the T45A mutant, which could bind to TATAC(A/T)AAT, a site hardly recognized by the wild-type protein. Mutation of residue Arg49 led to a relaxed specificity for three consecutive bases, TGC. This residue, which is critical for high affinity binding, is absent from the structurally homologous lambdoid helix-turn-helix motifs. Employing a reconstituted system all but two mutants could stimulate adenovirus DNA replication upon saturation. Mutation of residues Gln27 and Arg49 impairs the ability of the Oct-1 POU domain protein to enhance replication, with a concomitant loss of DNA contacts. Since the POU domain binds the precursor terminal protein-DNA polymerase complex and guides it to the origin, lack of stimulation may be caused by incorrect targetting of the DNA polymerase due to loss of specificity.

Cloning of the early promoters of Pseudomonas aeruginosa bacteriophage D3: sequence of the immunity region of D3

The early promoters of bacteriophage D3 of Pseudomonas aeruginosa were cloned and physically mapped to the right 25% of the phage genome. The promoters were cloned into promoter selection vector pQF26, and their relative strengths, the direction of transcription, and whether they were directly regulated by repressor were determined. A 3.3-kb fragment of the genome containing the immunity region was sequenced and analyzed (GenBank accession number: L22692). The promoter activity associated with this region was determined to be bidirectional and repressible, indicating that this region contains operator-promoter complexes. Sequence and functional analyses suggest that this region is analogous to the immunity region of coliphage lambda. Two strong promoters, one of which was repressible, were found to be located adjacent to the immunity region. Clear-plaque mutant phage D3c contains insertion element IS222, which causes it to behave as a repressor-negative (c1) variant. The site of insertion of IS222 was sequenced and determined to lie within the c1 gene open reading frame. This phage shows remarkable similarity in genomic organization to coliphage lambda and its relatives.

An invariant asparagine in the POU-specific homeodomain regulates the specificity of the Oct-2 POU motif

The homeodomain defines a family of transcription factors broadly involved in the regulation of gene expression. DNA recognition, as observed in three representative complexes (Engrailed, Antennapedia, and MAT alpha 2), is mediated in the major groove by a helix-turn-helix (HTH) element and in the minor groove by an N-terminal arm. The three complexes share similar overall features, but they also exhibit significant differences in DNA interactions. Because these differences may distinguish the biological activities of different classes of homeodomains, we have investigated the contribution of the Oct-2 POU-specific homeodomain (POUHD) to the specificity of the bipartite POU motif. Comparative studies of variant protein-DNA complexes demonstrate the following. (i) Mutations in an invariant residue in the POUHD HTH (N347; residue 10 of the putative recognition alpha-helix) reduce octamer binding with the relaxation of specificity at one position (5'-ATGCAAAT). The inferred HTH side chain-base interaction, although not observed in the solution structure of the Antennapedia complex, is in accord with homologous contacts in the Engrailed and MAT alpha 2 cocrystal structures. (ii) Comparison of the DNA-binding properties of POU and POUHD demonstrates that POUs and POUHD independently regulate specificity at opposite ends of the DNA site (5'-TATGCAAAT). Both domains contact the two central bases (5'-TATGCAAAT) where coordinate binding of POUS in the major groove overrides the intrinsic specificity of POUHD in the minor groove. (iii) The differential sensitivity of POU and POUHD to 2'-deoxyinosine substitutions (a minor-groove modification) suggests that POUS binding repositions the POUHD N-terminal "arm".(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Mapping critical residues in eukaryotic DNA-binding proteins: a plasmid-based genetic selection strategy with application to the Oct-2 POU motif

Discrimination between allowed and disallowed amino acid substitutions provides a powerful method for analysis of protein structure and function. Site-directed mutagenesis allows specific hypotheses to be tested, but its systematic application to entire structural motifs is inefficient. This limitation may be overcome by genetic selection, which allows rapid scoring of thousands of randomly (or pseudorandomly) generated mutants. To facilitate structural dissection of DNA-binding proteins, we have designed two generally applicable bacterial selection systems: pPLUS selects for the ability of a protein to bind to a user-defined DNA sequence, whereas pMINUS selects against such binding. Complementary positive and negative selections allow rapid mapping of critical residues. To test and calibrate the systems, we have investigated the bipartite POU domain of the human B-cell-specific transcription factor Oct-2. (i) An invariant residue (Asn347) in the DNA-recognition helix of the POU-specific homeodomain (POUHD) was substituted by each of the 19 other possible amino acids. The mutant proteins each exhibited decreased specific DNA binding as defined in vivo by genetic selection and in vitro by gel retardation; relative affinities correlate with phenotypes in the positive and negative selection systems. An essential role for Asn347 in wild-type POUHD-DNA recognition is consistent with homologous Asn-adenine interactions in cocrystal structures of canonical homeodomains. (ii) Extension of pPLUS/pMINUS selection to the POU-specific subdomain (POUs) is demonstrated by analysis of mutations in its putative helix-turn-helix (HTH) element.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

An altered-specificity mutation in a human POU domain demonstrates functional analogy between the POU-specific subdomain and phage lambda repressor

The POU motif, conserved among a family of eukaryotic transcription factors, contains two DNA-binding domains: an N-terminal POU-specific domain (POUS) and a C-terminal homeodomain (POUHD). Surprisingly, POUS is similar in structure to the helix-turn-helix domains of bacteriophage repressor and Cro proteins. Such similarity predicts a common mechanism of DNA recognition. To test this prediction, we have studied the DNA-binding properties of the human Oct-2 POU domain by combined application of chemical synthesis and site-directed mutagenesis. The POUS footprint of DNA contacts, identified by use of modified bases, is analogous to those of bacteriophage repressor-operator complexes. Moreover, a loss-of-contact substitution in the putative POUS recognition alpha-helix leads to relaxed specificity at one position in the DNA target site. The implied side chain-base contact is identical to that of bacteriophage repressor and Cro proteins. These results establish a functional analogy between the POUS and prokaryotic helix-turn-helix elements and suggest that their DNA specificities may be governed by a shared set of rules.

Additivity of mutant effects assessed by binomial mutagenesis

Eleven amino acid positions in the helix-turn-helix of lambda repressor have been mutagenized by using a combinatorial method in which alanine is substituted at each position with a probability of 0.5. Approximately 25% of the 2048 proteins in the resulting binomial library are active, including some variants with as many as seven alanine substitutions. The frequency of alanine substitutions in the set of active variants is a measure of the importance of the wild-type residue at each mutagenized position, and comparison of the frequencies of pairwise mutations with those expected based upon the single-position frequencies allows the additivity of mutant effects to be tested. For the positions examined here, we find that the effects of multiple substitutions are largely additive and are able to predict the activity class of the binomial mutants with 90% accuracy by using a model that simply sums penalty scores derived from the alanine substitution frequencies. We also find, however, that several residue pairs, including some that are distant in the three-dimensional structure, do display nonadditive effects that appear to be statistically significant.

CA runs increase DNA flexibility in the complex of lambda Cro protein with the OR3 site

The alternating pyrimidine-purine elements CA, CAC, and CACA are anisotropically flexible, as deduced from gel circularization assays on point mutations and single-base mismatches in the OR3 site of lambda phage alone and in the specific complex with the Cro protein. These sequences evidently promote DNA bending in the specific binding region of the complex and may also facilitate overwinding in the central nonbinding region. Effects for CACA are exceptionally large and suggest that an alternative DNA structure may occur in this element.

Functional roles of amino acid residues involved in forming the alpha-helix-turn-alpha-helix operator DNA binding motif of Tet repressor from Tn10

The Tn10 derived Tet repressor contains an amino acid segment with high homology to the alpha-helix-turn-alpha-helix motif (HTH) of other DNA binding proteins. The five most conserved amino acids in HTH are probably involved in structural formation of the motif. Their functional role was probed by saturation mutagenesis yielding 95 single amino acid replacement mutants of Tet repressor. Their binding efficiencies to tet operator were quantitatively determined in vivo. All functional mutants contain amino acid substitutions consistent with their proposed role in a HTH. In particular, only the two smallest amino acids (serine, glycine) can substitute a conserved alanine in the proposed first alpha-helix without loss of activity. The last position of the first alpha-helix, the second position in the turn, and the fourth position in the second alpha-helix require mostly hydrophobic residues. The proposed C-terminus of the first alpha-helix is supported by a more active asparagine compared to glutamine replacement mutant of the wt leucine residue. The turn is located close to the protein surface as indicated by functional lysine and arginine replacements for valine. A glycine residue at the first position in the turn can be replaced by any amino acid yielding mutants with at least residual tet operator affinity. A structural model of the HTH of Tet repressor is presented.

Refined 1.8 A crystal structure of the lambda repressor-operator complex

The crystal structure of the lambda repressor-operator complex has been refined to an R-factor of 18.9% at 1.8 A resolution. This refinement, using data collected at low temperature, has revealed the structure of the N-terminal arm and shows that the interactions of repressor with the two halves of the pseudo-symmetric operator site are significantly different. The two halves of the complex are most similar near the outer edge of the operator site (in a region where the lambda and 434 repressors make similar contacts), but they become increasingly different toward the center of the operator. There are striking differences near the center of the site where it appears that the arm makes significant contacts to only one half of the DNA site. This suggested a new way of aligning the operator sites in phage lambda. The high resolution structure confirms many of the previously noted features of the complex, but also reveals a number of new protein-DNA contacts. It also gives a better view of the extensive H-bonding networks that couple contacts made by different residues and different regions of the protein, and reveals important new details about the helix-turn-helix (HTH) region, and the positions of many water molecules in the complex.

Contacts between Tet repressor and tet operator revealed by new recognition specificities of single amino acid replacement mutants

We have analyzed the DNA binding properties of Tet-repressor mutants with single amino acid residue replacements at eight positions within the alpha-helix-turn-alpha-helix DNA-binding motif. A saturation mutagenesis of Gln38, Pro39, Thr40, Tyr42, Trp43 and His44 in the second alpha-helix was performed; in addition, several substitutions of Thr27 and Arg28 in the first alpha-helix were constructed. The abilities of these mutant repressors to bind a set of 16 operator variants were determined and revealed 23 new binding specificities. All repressor mutants with DNA-binding activity were inducible by tetracycline, while mutants lacking binding activity were trans-dominant over the wild-type. All mutant proteins were present at the same intracellular steady-state concentrations as the wild-type. These results suggest the structural integrity of the mutant repressors. On the basis of the new recognition specificities, five contacts between a repressor monomer and each operator half-site and the chemical nature of these repressor-operator interactions are proposed. We suggest that Arg28 contacts guanine of the G.C base-pair at operator position 2 with two H-bonds, Gln38 binds adenine of the A.T base-pair at position 3 with two H-bonds, and the methyl group of Thr40 participates in a van der Waals' contact with cytosine of the G.C base-pair at position 6 of tet operator. A previously unrecognized type of interaction is proposed for Pro39, which inserts its side-chain between the methyl groups of the thymines of T.A and A.T base-pairs at positions 4 and 5. Computer modeling of these proposed contacts reveals that they are possible using the canonical structures of the helix-turn-helix motif and B-DNA. These contacts suggest an inverse orientation of the Tet repressor helix-turn-helix with respect to the operator center as compared with non-inducible repressor-operator complexes, and are supported by similar contacts of other repressor-operator complexes.

Genetic identification of the DNA binding domain of Escherichia coli LexA protein

Two genetic approaches were taken to define the DNA binding domain of LexA protein, the repressor of the Escherichia coli SOS regulon. First, several dominant negative lexA mutants defective in DNA binding were isolated. The mutations altered amino acids in a region similar to the helix-turn-helix, a DNA binding domain of other repressors and DNA binding proteins. Second, the region encoding the predicted DNA recognition helix was subjected to oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis and mutant LexA proteins with altered or relaxed specificity for several recA operator positions were isolated. By examining the effects of a series of amino acid substitutions on repressor specificity, it was shown that a glutamic acid residue at position 45 in LexA protein is important for recognition of the first base pair (G.C) in the recA operator.

Mutations in the bZIP domain of yeast GCN4 that alter DNA-binding specificity

The bZIP class of eukaryotic transcriptional regulators utilize a distinct structural motif that consists of a leucine zipper that mediates dimerization and an adjacent basic region that directly contacts DNA. Although models of the protein-DNA complex have been proposed, the basis of DNA-binding specificity is essentially unknown. By genetically selecting for derivatives of yeast GCN4 that activate transcription from promoters containing mutant binding sites, we isolate an altered-specificity mutant in which the invariant asparagine in the basic region of bZIP proteins (Asn-235) has been changed to tryptophan. Wild-type GCN4 binds the optimal site (ATGACTCAT) with much higher affinity than the mutant site (TTGACTCAA), whereas the Trp-235 protein binds these sites with similar affinity. Moreover, the Trp-235, Ala-235, and Gln-235 derivatives differ from GCN4 in their strong discrimination against GTGACTCAC. These results suggest a direct interaction between Asn-235 and the +/- 4 position of the DNA target site and are discussed in terms of the scissors-grip and induced-fork models of bZIP proteins.

DNA-binding by the glucocorticoid receptor: a structural and functional analysis

The glucocorticoid receptor belongs to a family of ligand activated nuclear receptors. This family includes, in addition to the receptors for steroid hormones, receptors for thyroid hormone, retinoic acid and 1,25-dihydroxy vitamin D3 as well as some receptors with as yet unknown ligands. The glucocorticoid receptor DNA-binding domain has been expressed in E. coli. The purified protein binds to the same DNA sequences as the native receptor and is therefore suitable for biochemical and structural studies of the DNA-binding function of the receptor protein. This protein has been shown to bind as a dimer to its DNA-binding site. Protein-protein interactions facilitate DNA-binding and a segment responsible for these interactions has been identified close to the C-terminal zinc-binding site. The family of nuclear receptors, with their related DNA-binding sites, provides an opportunity to study determinants for DNA sequence recognition. A segment close to the N-terminal zinc ion has been shown to be responsible for the target specificity of glucocorticoid and estrogen receptors. DNA-binding domains of nuclear receptors include nine conserved cysteine residues which have been shown to coordinate two zinc ions and zinc has been shown to be required for the structural integrity and DNA-binding ability of the glucocorticoid receptor DNA-binding domain. A motif for DNA recognition, based around zinc ions, was first described for transcription factor IIIA and nuclear receptors were believed to recognize DNA via a similar motif. However, the three-dimensional structure determination of the glucocorticoid receptor DNA-binding domain shows that its structure is clearly different from that of the TFIIIA type zinc-binding domains.

The phage 434 Cro/OR1 complex at 2.5 A resolution

The crystal structure of phage 434 Cro protein in complex with a 20 base-pair DNA fragment has been determined to 2.5 A resolution. The DNA fragment contains the sequence of the OR1 operator site. The structure shows a bent conformation for the DNA, straighter at the center and more bent at the ends. The central base-pairs adopt conformations with significant deviations from coplanarity. The two molecules interact extensively along their common interface, both through hydrogen bonds and van der Waals interactions. The significance of these interactions for operator binding and recognition is discussed.

A genetic model for interaction of the homeodomain recognition helix with DNA

The Bicoid homeodomain protein controls anterior development in the Drosophila embryo by binding to DNA and regulating gene expression. With the use of genetic assays in yeast, the interaction between the Bicoid homeodomain and a series of mutated DNA sites was studied. These experiments defined important features of homeodomain binding sites, identified specific amino acid-base pair contacts, and suggested a model for interaction of the recognition alpha-helices of Bicoid and Antennapedia-class homeodomain proteins with DNA. The model is in general agreement with results of crystallographic and magnetic resonance studies, but differs in important details. It is likely that genetic studies of protein-DNA interaction will continue to complement conventional structural approaches.

Protein-DNA conformational changes in the crystal structure of a lambda Cro-operator complex

The structure of a complex of bacteriophage lambda Cro protein with a 17-base-pair operator has been determined at 3.9-A resolution. Isomorphous derivatives obtained by the synthesis of site-specific iodinated DNA oligomers were of critical importance in solving the structure. The crystal structure contains three independent Cro-operator complexes that have very similar, although not necessarily identical, conformations. In the complex, the protein dimer undergoes a large conformational change relative to the crystal structure of the free protein. One monomer rotates by about 40 degrees relative to the other, this being accomplished primarily by a twisting of the two beta-sheet strands that connect one monomer with the other. In the complex, the DNA is bent by about 40 degrees into the shape of a boomerang but maintains essentially Watson-Crick B-form. In contrast to other known protein-DNA complexes, the DNA is not stacked end-to-end. The structure confirms the general features of the model previously proposed for the interaction of Cro with DNA.

Two amino acids in an RNA polymerase sigma factor involved in the recognition of adjacent base pairs in the -10 region of a cognate promoter

The recognition of promoter region -10 nucleotide sequences in prokaryotes is believed to be mediated by a segment of alpha-helix in a region of RNA polymerase sigma factors called 2.4. Earlier genetic studies implicated Thr-100 in region 2.4 of the Bacillus subtilis sigma factor sigma H in the recognition of the G.C base pair at position -13 in the -10 region (GAAT) of a cognate promoter. In confirmation of this assignment, we now show that a change-of-specificity mutant of sigma H in which Thr-100 was replaced with isoleucine suppresses a G.C----A.T nucleotide substitution at position -13 but not other "promoter down mutations" (causing impaired promoter activity) at positions -13, -12, and -11. We also show that a loss-of-contact mutant created by the replacement of Thr-100 with alanine (having a short side chain) enables sigma H to tolerate three different promoter down mutations at position -13 but not down mutations at other positions. Finally, we suggest the identification of an additional amino acid involved in base-pair recognition by the demonstration that the replacement of Arg-96 with alanine specifically suppresses an A.T----G.C promoter down mutation at position -12. The identification of amino acids that are four residues apart that are involved in the recognition of adjacent base pairs may fix the orientation of region 2.4 (its NH2 terminus being proximal to the promoter transcription start site) and is consistent with a model in which the recognition of promoter region -10 nucleotide sequences is mediated by an alpha-helix in which residues involved in base-pair contact are separated by one turn and clustered on one face of the helix.

Structural studies of protein-nucleic acid interaction: the sources of sequence-specific binding

Structural studies of DNA-binding proteins and their complexes with DNA have proceeded at an accelerating pace in recent years due to important technical advances in molecular genetics, DNA synthesis, protein crystallography and nuclear magnetic resonance. The last major review on this subject by Pabo & Sauer (1984) summarized the structural and functional studies of the three sequence-specific DNA-binding proteins whose crystal structures were then known, theE. colicatabolite gene activator protein (CAP) (McKay & Steitz, 1981; McKayet al.1982; Weber & Steitz, 1987), acrorepressor from phage λ (Andersonet al.1981), and the DNA-binding proteolytic fragment ofλcIrepressor protein (Pabo & Lewis, 1982) Although crystallographic studies of theE. coli lacrepressor protein were initiated as early as 1971 when it was the only regulatory protein available in sufficient quantities for structural studies (Steitzet al.1974), little was established about the structural aspects of DNA-binding proteins until the structure of CAP was determined in 1980 followed shortly thereafter by the structure ofλcrorepressor and subsequently that of the λ repressor fragment. There are now determined at high resolution the crystal structures of seven prokaryotic gene regulatory proteins or fragments [CAP,λcro,λcIrepressor fragment, 434 repressor fragment (Andersonet al.1987), 434crorepressor (Wolbergeret al.1988),E. coli trprepressor (Schevitzet al.1985),E. coli metrepressor (Raffertyet al.1989)],EcoRI restriction endonuclease (McClarinet al.1986), DNAse I (Suck & Ofner, 1986), the catalytic domain of γδ resolvase (Hatfullet al.1989) and two sequence-independent double-stranded DNA-binding proteins [the Klenow fragment ofE. coliDNA polymerase I (Olliset al.1985) and theE. coliHu protein (Tanakaet al., 1984)].

Identification of a contact between arginine-180 of the catabolite gene activator protein (CAP) and base pair 5 of the DNA site in the CAP-DNA complex

We have used site-directed mutagenesis to replace amino acid 1 of the recognition alpha-helix of the catabolite gene activator protein (CAP), Arg-180, with glycine and with alanine. Substitution of Arg-180 of CAP eliminated specificity between G.C, A.T, C.G, and T.A at base pair 5 of the DNA half-site. The effect was position-specific: substitution of Arg-180 did not eliminate specificity between G.C, A.T, C.G, and T.A at base pair 7 of the DNA half-site. We conclude, in agreement with the model for the structure of the CAP-DNA complex [Weber, I. & Steitz, T. (1984) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 81, 3973-3977; and Ebright, R., Cossart, P., Gicquel-Sanzey, B. & Beckwith, J. (1984) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 81, 7274-7278], that Arg-180 of CAP makes a specificity-determining contact with base pair 5 of the DNA half-site in the CAP-DNA complex. The identification of the contact by Arg-180 in this report, in conjunction with the identification of the contact by Glu-181 in a previous report [Ebright, R., Cossart, P., Gicquel-Sanzey, B. & Beckwith, J. (1984) Nature (London) 311, 232-235], provides information sufficient to define the orientation of the helix-turn-helix motif of CAP with respect to DNA in the CAP-DNA complex.

Lysine 188 of the catabolite gene activator protein (CAP) plays no role in specificity at base pair 7 of the DNA half site

Two similar, but not identical, models have been proposed for the amino acid-base pair contacts in the CAP-DNA complex ('model I,' Weber, I. and Steitz, T., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 81, 3973-3977, 1984; 'model II,' Ebright, et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 81, 7274-7278, 1984). The most important difference between the two models involves Lys188 of CAP. Model I predicts that Lys188 of CAP makes a specificity determining contact with base pair 7 of the DNA half site. In contrast, model II predicts that Lys188 makes no contact with base pair 7 of the DNA half site. In the present work, we have used site-directed mutagenesis to replace Lys188 of CAP by Asn, an amino acid unable to make the putative contact. We have assessed the specificities of the following proteins, both in vitro and in vivo: wild-type CAP, [Asn188]CAP, [Val181]CAP, and [Val181;Asn188]CAP. The results indicate that Lys188 makes no contribution to specificity at base pair 7 of the DNA half site. We propose, contrary to model I, that Lys188 makes no contact with base pair 7 of the DNA half site.

Sequence signals in eukaryotic upstream regions

Two DNA sequence elements are known to recur frequently upstream of eukaryotic polymerase II-transcribed genes. The TATAAA, at position -40, specifies the transcription initiation site. The GGCCAATCT is less frequent around -80. Sequence analysis of upstream regions reveals that the underlined yeast UAS2 consensus sequence, TGATTGGT, is also very frequent at -80 in higher polymerase II-transcribed animal sequences. The underlined CCAAT box and yeast UAS sequences are complementary. Structural analysis suggests some symmetry in their DNA structures. Upstream of the TATAAT-rich region there is an abundance of GC sequences. Analysis of nucleotide tracts indicates that these are preferentially flanked by their complementary nucleotides with a pyrimidine-purine junction, i.e., TTAN, CCGn, CnGG, TnAA. Here, I discuss DNA structural consideration in upstream regions along with protein readout of the major and minor groove information content. These sequence-structure aspects are put in the general context of protein (factors)-DNA (elements) recognition and regulation.

A single amino acid can determine the DNA binding specificity of homeodomain proteins

Many Drosophila developmental genes contain a DNA binding domain encoded by the homeobox. This homeodomain contains a region distantly homologous to the helix-turn-helix motif present in several prokaryotic DNA binding proteins. We investigated the nature of homeodomain-DNA interactions by making a series of mutations in the helix-turn-helix motif of the Drosophila homeodomain protein Paired (Prd). This protein does not recognize sequences bound by the homeodomain proteins Fushi tarazu (Ftz) or Bicoid (Bcd). We show that changing a single amino acid at the C-terminus of the recognition helix is both necessary and sufficient to confer the DNA binding specificity of either Ftz or Bcd on Prd. This simple rule indicates that the amino acids that determine the specificity of homeodomains are different from those mediating protein-DNA contacts in prokaryotic proteins. We further show that Prd contains two DNA binding activities. The Prd homeodomain is responsible for one of them while the other is not dependent on the recognition helix.

Determining residue-base interactions between AraC protein and araI DNA

Depurination/depyrimidation binding-interference experiments (missing contact probing) identified specific candidate residue-base interactions lost by mutants of Escherichia coli L-arabinose operon regulatory protein, AraC, to one of its binding sites, araI. These candidates were then checked more rigorously by comparing the affinities of wild-type and alanine-substituted AraC protein to variants of araI with alterations in the candidate contacted positions. Residues 208 and 212 apparently contact DNA and support, but do not prove the existence of a helix-turn-helix structure in this region of AraC protein whereas contacts by mutants with alterations at positions 256, 257 and 261 which are within another potential helix-turn-helix region do not support the existence of such a structure there. The missing contacts displayed by three AraC mutants are found within two major groove regions of the DNA and are spaced 21 base-pairs apart in a pattern indicating a direct repeat orientation for the subunits of AraC.

Genetic analysis of transcriptional activation and repression in the Tn21 mer operon

Transcription of the Tn21 mercury resistance operon (mer) is controlled by the toxic metal cation Hg(II). This control is mediated by the product of the merR gene, a 144-amino-acid protein which represses transcription of the structural genes (merTPCAD) in the absence of Hg(II) and activates transcription in the presence of Hg(II). We have used a mer-lac transcriptional fusion to obtain regulatory mutants in this metal-responsive system. Some mutants were defective in Hg(II)-induced activation while retaining repression function (a- r+), others were defective in repression but not activation (a+ r-), and some had lost both functions (a- r-). Mutations in three of the four cysteine residues of merR resulted in complete loss of Hg(II)-inducible activation but retention of the repressor function, suggesting that these residues serve as ligands for Hg(II) in the activation process. Other lesions adjacent to or very near these cysteines exhibited severely reduced activation and also retained repressor function. There were two putative helix-turn-helix (HTH) domains in merR, and mutants in each had very different phenotypes. A partially dominant mutation in the more amino-terminal region of the two putative HTH regions resulted in loss of both activation and repression (a- r-), consistent with a role for this region in DNA binding. Mutations in the more centrally located HTH region resulted only in loss of Hg(II)-induced activation (a- r+). Lesions in the central and in the carboxy-terminal regions of merR exhibited both Hg(II)-independent and Hg(II)-dependent transcriptional activation, suggesting that elements important in the activation mechanism may be widely distributed in this relatively small protein. The sole cis-acting mutant obtained with this operon fusion strategy, a down-promoter mutation, lies in a highly conserved base in the -35 region of the merTPCAD promoter.

DNA specificity of the bicoid activator protein is determined by homeodomain recognition helix residue 9

Formation of anterior structures in the Drosophila embryo requires the product of the gene bicoid. The bicoid protein contains a homeodomain and may exert its effects in early development by regulating transcription of the gap gene, hunchback (hb). Consistent with this view, we have demonstrated that DNA-bound Bicoid fusion proteins stimulate gene expression. We used the gene activation phenotype in yeast to study DNA recognition by the Bicoid homeodomain. We found that a single amino acid replacement at position 9 of the recognition helix was sufficient to switch the DNA specificity of the Bicoid protein. The altered specificity Bicoid mutants recognized DNA sites bound by Ultrabithorax, fushi tarazu, and other related homeo-domain proteins. Our results suggest that DNA specificity in Bicoid and Antennapedia class proteins is determined by recognition helix residue 9.

Altered promoter recognition by mutant forms of the sigma 70 subunit of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

We have systematically assayed the in vivo promoter recognition properties of 13 mutations in rpoD, the gene that encodes the sigma 70 subunit of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase holoenzyme, using transcriptional fusions to 37 mutant and wild-type promoters. We found three classes of rpoD mutations: (1) mutations that suggest contacts between amino acid side-chains of sigma 70 and specific bases in the promoter; (2) mutations that appear to affect either sequence independent contacts to promoter DNA or isomerization of the polymerase; and (3) mutations that have little or no effect on promoter recognition. Our results lead us to suggest that a sequence near the C terminus of sigma 70, which is similar to the helix-turn-helix DNA binding motif of phage and bacterial DNA binding proteins, is responsible for recognition of the -35 region, and that a sequence internal to sigma 70, in a region which is highly conserved among sigma factors, recognizes the -10 region of the promoter. rpoD mutations that lie in the recognition helix of the proposed helix-turn-helix motif affect interactions with specific bases in the -35 region, while mutations in the upstream helix, which is thought to contact the phosphate backbone, have sequence-independent effect on promoter recognition.

Mutation changing the specificity of an RNA polymerase sigma factor

We describe a mutation that changes the fine specificity of promoter selection by a secondary form of RNA polymerase holoenzyme in Bacillus subtilis. The product of regulatory gene spo0H is an RNA polymerase sigma factor called sigma H, which directs transcription of a sporulation gene known as spoVG. We show that the spo0H mutation spo0H81, which blocks transcription from the wild-type spoVG promoter, enhances transcription from a mutant form of the spoVG promoter (spoVG249) bearing a severe down-mutation (a G.C to A.T transition) at position -13 in the "-10 region." Suppression of the spoVG249 mutation is specific in the sense that the transcription from several other spoVG mutant promoters was not restored by the mutant sigma. Evidently, spo0H81 is a change-of-specificity mutation that alters sigma H-RNA polymerase in a way that decreases its capacity to use the wild-type spoVG promoter, while increasing its capacity to use the mutant promoter. Transcription experiments in vitro using RNA polymerase containing the wild-type or mutant sigma support this interpretation. The spo0H81 mutation causes a threonine (Thr100) to isoleucine substitution in a region of sigma H that is highly homologous among sigma factors of diverse origins. We discuss the possibility that Thr100 is an amino acid-base-pair contact site and that sigma factors contact the -10 region of their cognate promoters by means of amino acid residues in this highly conserved region.

Peptide and protein synthesis by segment synthesis-condensation

The chemical synthesis of biologically active peptides and polypeptides can be achieved by using a convergent strategy of condensing protected peptide segments to form the desired molecule. An oxime support increases the ease with which intermediate protected peptides can be synthesized and makes this approach useful for the synthesis of peptides in which secondary structural elements have been redesigned. The extension of these methods to large peptides and proteins, for which folding of secondary structures into functional tertiary structures is critical, is discussed. Models of apolipoproteins, the homeo domain from the developmental protein encoded by the Antennapedia gene of Drosophila, a part of the Cro repressor, and the enzyme ribonuclease T1 and a structural analog have been synthesized with this method.