Kinetic and structural analysis of a cleaved donor intermediate and a strand transfer intermediate in Tn10 transposition

DNA transposon-based gene vehicles - scenes from an evolutionary drive

DNA transposons are primitive genetic elements which have colonized living organisms from plants to bacteria and mammals. Through evolution such parasitic elements have shaped their host genomes by replicating and relocating between chromosomal loci in processes catalyzed by the transposase proteins encoded by the elements themselves. DNA transposable elements are constantly adapting to life in the genome, and self-suppressive regulation as well as defensive host mechanisms may assist in buffering ‘cut-and-paste’ DNA mobilization until accumulating mutations will eventually restrict events of transposition. With the reconstructed Sleeping Beauty DNA transposon as a powerful engine, a growing list of transposable elements with activity in human cells have moved into biomedical experimentation and preclinical therapy as versatile vehicles for delivery and genomic insertion of transgenes. In this review, we aim to link the mechanisms that drive transposon evolution with the realities and potential challenges we are facing when adapting DNA transposons for gene transfer. We argue that DNA transposon-derived vectors may carry inherent, and potentially limiting, traits of their mother elements. By understanding in detail the evolutionary journey of transposons, from host colonization to element multiplication and inactivation, we may better exploit the potential of distinct transposable elements. Hence, parallel efforts to investigate and develop distinct, but potent, transposon-based vector systems will benefit the broad applications of gene transfer. Insight and clever optimization have shaped new DNA transposon vectors, which recently debuted in the first DNA transposon-based clinical trial. Learning from an evolutionary drive may help us create gene vehicles that are safer, more efficient, and less prone for suppression and inactivation.

Identification of basepairs within Tn5 termini that are critical sfor H-NS binding to the transpososome and regulation of Tn5 transposition

Background

The H-NS protein is a global regulator of gene expression in bacteria and can also bind transposition complexes (transpososomes). In Tn5 transposition H-NS promotes transpososome assembly in vitro and disruption of the hns gene causes a modest decrease in Tn5 transposition (three- to five-fold). This is consistent with H-NS acting as a positive regulator of Tn5 transposition. Molecular determinants for H-NS binding to the Tn5 transpososome have not been determined, nor has the strength of the interaction been established. There is also uncertainty as to whether H-NS regulates Tn5 transposition in vivo through an interaction with the transposition machinery as disruption of the hns gene has pleiotropic effects on Escherichia coli, the organism used in this study.

Results

In the current work we have further examined determinants for H-NS binding to the Tn5 transpososome through both mutational studies on Tn5 termini (or 'transposon ends') and protein-protein cross-linking analysis. We identify mutations in two different segments of the transposon ends that abrogate H-NS binding and characterize the affinity of H-NS for wild type transposon ends in the context of the transpososome. We also show that H-NS forms cross-links with the Tn5 transposase protein specifically in the transpososome, an observation consistent with the two proteins occupying overlapping binding sites in the transposon ends. Finally, we make use of the end mutations to test the idea that H-NS exerts its impact on Tn5 transposition in vivo by binding directly to the transpososome. Consistent with this possibility, we show that two different end mutations reduce the sensitivity of the Tn5 system to H-NS regulation.

Conclusions

H-NS typically regulates cellular functions through its potent transcriptional repressor function. Work presented here provides support for an alternative mechanism of H-NS-based regulation, and adds to our understanding of how bacterial transposition can be regulated.

Reconstitution of a functional IS608 single-strand transpososome: role of non-canonical base pairing

Single-stranded (ss) transposition, a recently identified mechanism adopted by members of the widespread IS200/IS605 family of insertion sequences (IS), is catalysed by the transposase, TnpA. The transposase of IS608, recognizes subterminal imperfect palindromes (IP) at both IS ends and cleaves at sites located at some distance. The cleavage sites, C, are not recognized directly by the protein but by short sequences 5′ to the foot of each IP, guide (G) sequences, using a network of canonical (‘Watson–Crick’) base interactions. In addition a set of non-canonical base interactions similar to those found in RNA structures are also involved. We have reconstituted a biologically relevant complex, the transpososome, including both left and right ends and TnpA, which catalyses excision of a ss DNA circle intermediate. We provide a detailed picture of the way in which the IS608 transpososome is assembled and demonstrate that both C and G sequences are essential for forming a robust transpososome detectable by EMSA. We also address several questions central to the organization and function of the ss transpososome and demonstrate the essential role of non-canonical base interactions in the IS608 ends for its stability by using point mutations which destroy individual non-canonical base interactions.

H-NS binds with high affinity to the Tn10 transpososome and promotes transpososome stabilization

H-NS is a bacterial DNA-binding protein that regulates gene expression and DNA transposition. In the case of Tn10, H-NS binds directly to the transposition machinery (i.e. the transpososome) to influence the outcome of the reaction. In the current work we evaluated the binding affinity of H-NS for two forms of the Tn10 transpososome, including the initial folded form and a pre-unfolded form. These two forms differ in that IHF is bound to the former but not the latter. IHF binding induces a bend (or fold) in the transposon end that facilitates transpososome formation. However, the continued presence of IHF in the transpososome inhibits intermolecular transposition events. We show that H-NS binds particularly strongly to the pre-unfolded transpososome with an apparent K(d) of approximately 0.3 nM. This represents the highest affinity interaction between H-NS and a binding partner documented to date. We also show that binding of H-NS to the transpososome stabilizes this structure and propose that both high-affinity binding and stabilization result from the combined interaction between H-NS and DNA and H-NS and transposase within the transpososome. Mechanistic implications for tight binding of H-NS to the transpososome and transpososome stabilization are considered.

The nucleoid binding protein H-NS acts as an anti-channeling factor to favor intermolecular Tn10 transposition and dissemination

Dissemination of the bacterial transposon Tn10 is limited by target site channeling, a process wherein the transposon ends are forced to interact with and insert into a target site located within the transposon. Integration host factor (IHF) promotes this self-destructive event by binding to the transpososome and forming a DNA loop close to one or both transposon ends; this loop imposes geometric and topological constraints that are responsible for channeling. We demonstrate that a second 'host' protein, histone-like nucleoid structuring protein (H-NS), acts as an anti-channeling factor to limit self-destructive intramolecular transposition events in vitro. Evidence that H-NS competes with IHF for binding to the Tn10 transpososome to block channeling and that this event is relatively insensitive to the level of DNA supercoiling present in the Tn10-containing substrate plasmid are presented. This latter observation is atypical for H-NS, as H-NS binding to other DNA sequences, such as promoters, is generally affected by subtle changes in DNA structure.

Transpososome dynamics and regulation in Tn10 transposition

Tn10 is a bacterial transposon that transposes through a non-replicative mechanism. This mode of DNA transposition is widely used in bacteria and is also used by "DNA-based" transposons in eukaryotes. Tn10 has served as a paradigm for this mode of transposition and continues to provide novel insights into how steps in transposition reactions occur and how these steps are regulated. A common feature of transposition reactions is that they require the formation of a higher order protein-DNA complex called a transpososome. A major objective in the last few years has been to better understand the dynamics of transpososome assembly and progression through the course of transposition reactions. This problem is particularly interesting in the Tn10 system because two important host proteins, IHF and H-NS, have been implicated in regulating transpososome assembly and/or function. Interestingly, H-NS is an integral part of stress response pathways in bacteria, and its function is known to be sensitive to changes in environmental conditions. Consequently, H-NS may provide a means of allowing Tn10 to responed to changing environmental conditions. The current review focuses on the roles of both IHF and H-NS on Tn10 transposition.

The global regulator H-NS acts directly on the transpososome to promote Tn10 transposition

The histone-like nucleoid structuring (H-NS) protein is a global transcriptional regulator that is known to regulate stress response pathways and virulence genes in bacteria. It has also been implicated in the regulation of bacterial transposition systems, including Tn10. We demonstrate here that H-NS promotes Tn10 transposition by binding directly to the transposition complex (or transpososome). We present evidence that, upon binding, H-NS induces the unfolding of the Tn10 transpososome and helps to maintain the transpososome in an unfolded state. This ensures that intermolecular (as opposed to self-destructive intramolecular) transposition events are favored. We present evidence that H-NS binding to the flanking donor DNA of the transpososome is the initiating event in the unfolding process. We propose that by recruiting H-NS as a modulator of transposition, Tn10 has evolved a means of sensing changes in host physiology, as the amount of H-NS in the cell, as well its activity, are responsive to changes in environmental conditions. Sensing of environmental changes through H-NS would allow transposition to occur when it is most opportune for both the transposon and the host.

Tn10 Transposase Mutants with Altered Transpososome Unfolding Properties are Defective in Hairpin Formation

Transposition reactions take place in the context of higher-order protein-DNA complexes called transpososomes. In the Tn10 transpososome, IHF binding to an "outside end" creates a bend in the DNA that allows the transposase protein to contact the end at two different sites, the terminal and subterminal binding sites. Presumably this helps to stabilize the transposase-end interaction. However, the DNA loop that is formed must be unfolded at a later stage in order for the transposon to integrate into other DNA molecules. It has been proposed that transpososome unfolding also plays a role in transposon excision. To investigate this possibility further, we have isolated and characterized transposase mutants with altered transpososome unfolding properties. Two such mutants were identified, R182A and R184A. Both mutants fail to carry out hairpin formation, an intermediate step in transposon excision, specifically with outside end-containing substrates. These results support the idea that transpososome unfolding and excision are linked. Also, based on the importance of residues R182 and R184 in transpososome unfolding, we propose a new model for the Tn10 transpososome, wherein both DNA ends of the transpososome make subterminal contacts with transposase.

The effect of host-encoded nucleoid proteins on transposition: H-NS influences targeting of both IS903 and Tn10

Nucleoid proteins are small, abundant, DNA-binding proteins that profoundly affect the local and global structure of the chromosome, and play a major role in gene regulation. Although several of these proteins have been shown to enhance assembly of transpososomes before initiating transposition, no systematic survey has been carried out examining the in vivo role(s) of these proteins in transposition. We have examined the requirement of the six most abundant nucleoid proteins in transposition for three different transposons, IS903, Tn10 and Tn552. Most notably, H-NS was required for efficient transposition of all three elements in a papillation assay, suggesting a general role for H-NS in bacterial transposition. Further studies indicated that H-NS was exerting its effect on target capture. Targeting preferences for IS903 into the Escherichia coli chromosome were dramatically altered in the absence of H-NS. In addition, the alterations observed in the IS903 target profile emphasized the important role that H-NS plays in chromosome organization. A defect in target capture was also inferred for Tn10, as an excised transposon fragment, a precursor to target capture, accumulated in in vivo induction assays. Furthermore, a transposase mutant that is known to increase target DNA bending and to relax target specificity eliminated this block to target capture. Together, these results imply a role for H-NS in target capture, either by providing regions of DNA more accessible to transposition or by stabilizing transpososome binding to captured targets immediately before strand transfer.

Target DNA bending is an important specificity determinant in target site selection in Tn10 transposition

The bacterial transposon Tn10 inserts preferentially into specific DNA sequences. DNA footprinting and interference studies have revealed that the Tn10-encoded transposase protein contacts a large stretch of target DNA ( approximately 24 bp) and that the target DNA structure is deformed upon incorporation into the transpososome. Target DNA deformation might contribute significantly to target site selection and thus it is of interest to further define the nature of this deformation. Circular permutation analysis was used to demonstrate that the target DNA is bent upon its incorporation into the transpososome. Two lines of evidence are presented that target DNA bending is an important event in target site selection. First, we demonstrate a correlation between increased target site usage and an increased level of target DNA bending. Second, transposase mutants with relaxed target specificity are shown to cause increased target DNA bending relative to wild-type transposase. This latter observation provides new insight into how relaxed specificity may be achieved. We also show that Ca(2+) facilitates target capture by stabilizing transposase interactions with sequences immediately flanking the insertion site. Ca(2+) could, in theory, exert this effect by stabilizing bends in the target DNA.

IHF-independent assembly of the Tn10 strand transfer transpososome: implications for inhibition of disintegration

The frequency of DNA transposition in transposition systems that employ a strand transfer step may be significantly affected by the occurrence of a disintegration reaction, a reaction that reverses the strand transfer event. We have asked whether disintegration occurs in the Tn10 transposition system. We show that disintegration substrates (substrates constituting one half of the strand transfer product) are assembled into a transpososome that mimics the strand transfer intermediate. This strand transfer transpososome (STT) does appear to support an intermolecular disintegration reaction, but only at a very low level. Strikingly, assembly of the STT is not dependent on IHF, a host protein that is required for de novo assembly of all previously characterized Tn10 transpososomes. We suggest that disintegration substrates are able to form both transposon end and target type contacts with transposase because of their enhanced conformational flexibility. This probably allows the conformation of DNA within the complex that prevents the destructive disintegration reaction, and is responsible for relaxing the DNA sequence requirements for STT formation relative to other Tn10 transpososomes.

Mechanisms of metal ion action in Tn10 transposition

Tn10/IS10 transposition involves assembly of a synaptic complex (or transpososome) in which two transposon ends are paired, followed by four distinct chemical steps at each transposon end. The chemical steps are dependent on the presence of a suitable divalent metal cation (Me(2+)). Transpososome assembly and structure are also affected by Me(2+). To gain further insight into the mechanisms of Me(2+) action in Tn10/IS10 transposition we have investigated the effects of substituting Mn(2+) for Mg(2+), the physiologic Me(2+), in transposition. We have also investigated the significance of an Me(2+)-assisted conformational change in transpososome structure. We show that Mn(2+) has two previously unrecognized effects on the Tn10 donor cleavage reaction. It accelerates the rates of hairpin formation and hairpin resolution without significantly affecting the rate of the first chemical step, first strand nicking. Mn(2+) also relaxes the specificity of first strand nicking. We also show that Me(2+)-assisted transpososome unfolding coincides with a structural transition in the transposon-donor junction that may be necessary for hairpin formation. Possible mechanisms for these observations are considered.

Asymmetric processing of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 cDNA in vivo: implications for functional end coupling during the chemical steps of DNA transposition

Retroviral integration, like all forms of DNA transposition, proceeds through a series of DNA cutting and joining reactions. During transposition, the 3' ends of linear transposon or donor DNA are joined to the 5' phosphates of a double-stranded cut in target DNA. Single-end transposition must be avoided in vivo because such aberrant DNA products would be unstable and the transposon would therefore risk being lost from the cell. To avoid suicidal single-end integration, transposons link the activity of their transposase protein to the combined functionalities of both donor DNA ends. Although previous work suggested that this critical coupling between transposase activity and DNA ends occurred before the initial hydrolysis step of retroviral integration, work in the related Tn10 and V(D)J recombination systems had shown that end coupling regulated transposase activity after the initial hydrolysis step of DNA transposition. Here, we show that integrase efficiently hydrolyzed just the wild-type end of two different single-end mutants of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 in vivo, which, in contrast to previous results, proves that two functional DNA ends are not required to activate integrase's initial hydrolysis activity. Furthermore, despite containing bound protein at their processed DNA ends, these mutant viruses did not efficiently integrate their singly cleaved wild-type end into target DNA in vitro. By comparing our results to those of related DNA recombination systems, we propose the universal model that end coupling regulates transposase activity after the first chemical step of DNA transposition.

The nicking step in V(D)J recombination is independent of synapsis: implications for the immune repertoire

In all of the transposition reactions that have been characterized thus far, synapsis of two transposon ends is required before any catalytic steps (strand nicking or strand transfer) occur. In V(D)J recombination, there have been inconclusive data concerning the role of synapsis in nicking. Synapsis between two 12-substrates or between two 23-substrates has not been ruled out in any studies thus far. Here we provide the first direct tests of this issue. We find that immobilization of signals does not affect their nicking, even though hairpinning is affected in a manner reflecting its known synaptic requirement. We also find that nicking is kinetically a unireactant enzyme-catalyzed reaction. Time courses are no different between nicking seen for a 12-substrate alone and a reaction involving both a 12- and a 23-substrate. Hence, synapsis is neither a requirement nor an effector of the rate of nicking. These results establish V(D)J recombination as the first example of a DNA transposition-type reaction in which catalytic steps begin prior to synapsis, and the results have direct implications for the order of the steps in V(D)J recombination, for the contribution of V(D)J recombination nicks to genomic instability, and for the diversification of the immune repertoire.

Substrate recognition and induced DNA deformation by transposase at the target-capture stage of Tn10 transposition

The bacterial transposon Tn10 inserts preferentially into sites that conform to a 9 bp consensus sequence: 5' NGCTNAGCN 3'. However, this sequence is not on its own sufficient to confer target specificity as the base-pairs flanking this sequence also contribute significantly to target-site selection. We have performed a series of "contact-probing experiments" to define directly the protein-DNA interactions that govern target-site selection in the Tn10 system. The HisG1 hotspot for Tn10 insertion was the main focus here. We infer that there is a rather broad zone ( approximately 24 bp) of contact between transposase and target DNA in the target-capture complex. This includes base-specific contacts at all of the purine residues in the consensus positions of the target core and primarily backbone contacts out to 7-8 bp in the two flanking regions immediately adjacent to the core. Also, highly localized sites of chemical hypersensitivity are identified that reveal symmetrically disposed deformations in DNA structure in the target-capture complex. Furthermore, the level of strand transfer is shown to be reduced by phosphorothioate substitution of phosphate groups at or close to the sites of target DNA deformation. Interestingly, for one particular target DNA, a mutant form of HisG1 called MutF, the above phosphorothioate inhibition of strand transfer is suppressed by replacing Mg(2+) with Mn(2+). Based on these results a model for sequence-specific target capture is proposed which attempts to define possible relationships between transposase interactions with the target core and flanking sequences, transposase-induced DNA deformation of the target site and divalent metal ion binding to the target-capture complex.

Tn10 transpososome assembly involves a folded intermediate that must be unfolded for target capture and strand transfer

Tn10 transposition, like all transposition reactions examined thus far, involves assembly of a stable protein-DNA transpososome, containing a pair of transposon ends, within which all chemical events occur. We report here that stable Tn10 pre-cleavage transpososomes occur in two conformations: a folded form which contains the DNA-bending factor IHF and an unfolded form which lacks IHF. Functional analysis shows that both forms undergo double strand cleavage at the transposon ends but that only the unfolded form is competent for target capture (and thus for strand transfer to target DNA). Additional studies reveal that formation of any type of stable transpososome, folded or unfolded, requires not only IHF but also non-specific transposase-DNA contacts immediately internal to the IHF-binding site, implying the occurrence of a topo- logically closed loop at the transposon end. Overall, transpososome assembly must proceed via a folded intermediate which, however, must be unfolded in order for intermolecular transposition to occur. These and other results support key features of a recently proposed model for transpososome assembly and morphogenesis.

Integrating DNA: transposases and retroviral integrases

Transposable elements appear quite disparate in their organization and in the types of genetic rearrangements they promote. In spite of this diversity, retroviruses and many transposons of both prokaryotes and eukaryotes show clear similarities in the chemical reactions involved in their transposition. This is reflected in the enzymes, integrases and transposases, that catalyze these reactions and that are essential for the mobility of the elements. In this chapter, we examine the structure-function relationships between these enzymes and the different ways in which the individual steps are assembled to produce a complete transposition cycle.

All three residues of the Tn 10 transposase DDE catalytic triad function in divalent metal ion binding

Tn 10/IS 10 transposition involves excision of the transposon from a donor site and subsequent joining of the excised transposon to a new target site. These steps are catalyzed by the Tn 10 -encoded transposase protein and require the presence of a suitable divalent metal ion. Like other transposase and retroviral integrase proteins, Tn 10 transposase appears to contain a single active site which includes a triad of acidic amino acid residues generally referred to as the DDE motif. In addition to its role in catalysis, the Tn 10 transposase DDE motif also functions in target capture, a step that in vitro is greatly facilitated by the presence of a suitable divalent metal ion. We show that cysteine residue substitutions at each of the DDE motif residues in Tn 10 transposase result in a change in the divalent metal ion requirements for catalysis, such that Mn2+but not Mg2+can be used. This switch in metal ion specificity provides evidence that each of the DDE motif residues functions directly in metal ion binding. We also show differential effects of DDE mutations on metal ion-assisted target capture. A number of models, including a two metal ion active site, are considered to explain these effects.

IS911 transposon circles give rise to linear forms that can undergo integration in vitro

High levels of expression of the transposase OrfAB of bacterial insertion sequence IS911 leads to the formation of excised transposon circles, in which the two abutted ends are separated by 3 bp. Initially, OrfAB catalyses only single-strand cleavage at one 3' transposon end and strand transfer of that end to the other. It is believed that this molecule, in which both transposon ends are held together in a single-strand bridge, is then converted to the circular form by the action of host factors. The transposon circles can be integrated efficiently into an appropriate target in vivo and in vitro in the presence of OrfAB and a second IS911 protein OrfA. In the results reported here, we have identified linear transposon forms in vivo from a transposon present in a plasmid, raising the possibility that IS911 can also transpose using a cut-and-paste mechanism. However, the linear species appeared not to be derived directly from the plasmid-based copy by direct double-strand cleavages at both ends, but from preformed excised transposon circles. This was confirmed further by the observation that OrfAB can cleave a cloned circle junction both in vivo and in vitro by two single-strand cleavages at the 3' transposon ends to generate a linear transposon form with a 3'-OH and a three-nucleotide 5' overhang at the ends. Moreover, while significantly less efficient than the transposon circle, a precleaved linear transposon underwent detectable levels of integration in vitro. The possible role of such molecules in the IS911 transposition pathway is discussed.

Hairpin coding end opening is mediated by RAG1 and RAG2 proteins

Despite the importance of hairpin opening in antigen receptor gene assembly, the molecular machinery that mediates this reaction has not been defined. Here, we show that RAG1 plus RAG2 can open DNA hairpins. Hairpin opening by RAGs is not sequence specific, but in Mg2+, hairpin opening occurs only in the context of a regulated cleavage complex. The chemical mechanism of hairpin opening by RAGs resembles RSS cleavage and 3' end processing by HIV integrase and Mu transposase in that these reactions can proceed through alcoholysis. Mutations in either RAG1 or RAG2 that interfere with RSS cleavage also interfere with hairpin opening, suggesting that RAGs have a single active site that catalyzes several distinct DNA cleavage reactions.

Drosophila P-element transposase is a novel site-specific endonuclease

We developed in vitro assays to study the first step of the P-element transposition reaction: donor DNA cleavage. We found that P-element transposase required both 5' and 3' P-element termini for efficient DNA cleavage to occur, suggesting that a synaptic complex forms prior to cleavage. Transposase made a staggered cleavage at the P-element termini that is novel for all known site-specific endonucleases: the 3' cleavage site is at the end of the P-element, whereas the 5' cleavage site is 17 bp within the P-element 31-bp inverted repeats. The P-element termini were protected from exonucleolytic degradation following the cleavage reaction, suggesting that a stable protein complex remains bound to the element termini after cleavage. These data are consistent with a cut-and-paste mechanism for P-element transposition and may explain why P elements predominantly excise imprecisely in vivo.

The Tn10 synaptic complex can capture a target DNA only after transposon excision

Tn10 transposes nonreplicatively. Staged in vitro reactions demonstrate that a Tn10 synaptic complex can become committed to a particular target DNA molecule via a noncovalent interaction in the absence of strand transfer. Commitment occurs only after double-strand cleavage at both transposon ends (in "double-end break" [DEB] complexes). Stable noncovalent DEB-target DNA cocomplexes can be detected, but no cocomplexes occur with synaptic complexes containing uncleaved ends. Preincubation of DEB complexes with target DNA accelerates the rate of strand transfer. Postcleavage target capture is remarkable for Tn10; Mu and Tn7 select a target site prior to cleavage. Promiscuous target selection may favor evolution of IS-based composite elements while being suicidal for other types of transposons.

Ku86 is not required for protection of signal ends or for formation of nonstandard V(D)J recombination products

Ku, a heterodimer of 70- and 86-kDa subunits, serves as the DNA binding component of the DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK). Cells deficient for the 86-kDa subunit of Ku (Ku86-deficient cells) lack Ku DNA end-binding activity and are severely defective for formation of the standard V(D)J recombination products, i.e., signal and coding joints. It has been widely hypothesized that Ku is required for protection of broken DNA ends generated during V(D)J recombination. Here we report the first analysis of V(D)J recombination intermediates in a Ku-deficient cell line. We find that full-length, ligatable signal ends are abundant in these cells. These data show that Ku86 is not required for the protection or stabilization of signal ends, suggesting that other proteins may perform this function. The presence of high levels of signal ends in Ku-deficient cells prompted us to investigate whether these ends could participate in joining reactions. We show that nonstandard V(D)J recombination products (hybrid joints), which involve joining a signal end to a coding end, form with similar efficiencies in Ku-deficient and wild-type fibroblasts. These data support the surprising conclusion that Ku is not required for some types of V(D)J joining events. We propose a novel RAG-mediated joining mechanism, analogous to disintegration reactions performed by retroviral integrases, to explain how formation of hybrid joints can bypass the requirement for Ku and DNA-PK.

3'-end processing and kinetics of 5'-end joining during retroviral integration in vivo

Retroviral replication depends on integration of viral DNA into a host cell chromosome. Integration proceeds in three steps: 3'-end processing, the endonucleolytic removal of the two terminal nucleotides from each 3' end of the viral DNA; strand transfer, the joining of the 3' ends of viral DNA to host DNA; and 5'-end joining (or gap repair), the joining of the 5' ends of viral DNA to host DNA. The 5'-end joining step has never been investigated, either for retroviral integration or for any other transposition process. We have developed an assay for 5'-end joining in vivo and have examined the kinetics of 5'-end joining for Moloney murine leukemia virus (MLV). The interval between 3'-end and 5'-end joining is estimated to be less than 1 h. This assay will be a useful tool for examining whether viral or host components mediate 5'-end joining. MLV integrates its DNA only after its host cell has completed mitosis. We show that the extent of 3'-end processing is the same in unsynchronized and aphidicolin-arrested cells. 3'-end processing therefore does not depend on mitosis.

Switching from cut-and-paste to replicative Tn7 transposition

The bacterial transposon Tn7 usually moves through a cut-and-paste mechanism whereby the transposon is excised from a donor site and joined to a target site to form a simple insertion. The transposon was converted to a replicative element that generated plasmid fusions in vitro and cointegrate products in vivo. This switch was a consequence of the separation of 5'- and 3'-end processing reactions of Tn7 transposition as demonstrated by the consequences of a single amino acid alteration in an element-encoded protein essential for normal cut-and-paste transposition. The mutation specifically blocked cleavage of the 5' strand at each transposon end without disturbing the breakage and joining on the 3' strand, producing a fusion (the Shapiro Intermediate) that resulted in replicative transposition. The ability of Tn7 recombination products to serve as substrates for both the limited gap repair required to complete cut-and-paste transposition and the extensive DNA replication involved in cointegrate formation suggests a remarkable plasticity in Tn7's recruitment of host repair and replication functions.

The three chemical steps of Tn10/IS10 transposition involve repeated utilization of a single active site

Nonreplicative transposition by Tn10/IS10 involves three chemical steps at each transposon end: cleavage of the two strands plus joining of one strand to target DNA. These steps occur within a synaptic complex comprising two transposon ends and monomers of IS10 transposase. We report four transposase mutations that individually abolish each of the three chemical steps without affecting the synaptic complex. We conclude that a single constellation of residues, the "active site," directly catalyzes each of the three steps. Analyses of reactions containing mixtures of wild-type and catalysis-defective transposases indicate that a single transposase monomer at each end catalyzes the cleavage of two strands and that strand transfer is carried out by the same monomers that previously catalyzed cleavage. These and other data suggest that one active site unit carries out all three reactions in succession at one transposon end.

Identification and characterization of the linear IS3 molecules generated by staggered breaks

Insertion sequences IS3 encodes two, out-of-phase, overlapping open reading frames, orfA and orfB. The OrfAB transframe protein that is IS3 transposase is produced by -1 translational frameshifting between orfA and orfB. Efficient production of the IS3 transposase in the cells harboring the IS3-carrying plasmid has been shown to generate miniplasmids as well as characteristic minicircles, called IS3 circles, consisting of the entire IS3 sequence and one of the 3-base pair sequences flanking IS3 in the parental plasmid. Here, we show that the IS3 transposase also generates the linear molecules of IS3 with 3-nucleotide overhangs at the 5'-ends. The nucleotide sequences of the overhangs are the same as those flanking IS3 in the parental plasmid, suggesting that the linear IS3 molecules are generated from the parental plasmid DNA by staggered double strand breaks at the end regions of IS3. The linear IS3 molecules are likely to be the early intermediates in the transposition reaction, which proceeds in a non-replicative manner.

An in vivo transposase-catalyzed single-stranded DNA circularization reaction

Expression of the bacterial insertion sequence IS911 transposase in vivo leads to excision and circularization of IS911-based transposons. We show here that transposase produces an unusual molecular form generated by single-strand cleavage, transfer, and ligation of one end of the element to the opposite end. When the transposon is carried by a circular plasmid, this results in the formation of a "figure-eight" molecule in which a single strand of the transposon is circularized while the corresponding strand of the vector backbone retains a single-strand interruption at this position. The results show that a 3' end of the transposon is transferred to the opposite target end. Transposase is therefore capable of introducing single-strand cleavages at the ends of the element, an activity similar to that of retroviral integrases with which it shares significant similarities in amino acid sequence. Kinetic studies demonstrate that the figure-eight accumulates earlier than transposon circles after transposase induction and disappears before circles after inhibition of transposase expression, raising the possibility that the figure-eight molecules are precursors to the circles. Therefore, IS911 excision as a circle may not occur by double-strand cleavage leading to its prior separation from the vector backbone in a linear form but could proceed by consecutive circularization of each strand.

Enhanced and coordinated processing of synapsed viral DNA ends by retroviral integrases in vitro

We have designed novel substrates to investigate the first step in retroviral integration: the site-specific processing of two nucleotides from the 3' ends of viral DNA. The substrates consist of short duplex oligodeoxynucleotides whose sequences match those of the U3 and U5 ends of viral DNA but are covalently synapsed across the termini by short, single-strand nucleotide linkers. We show here that the optimal separation between termini in a synapsed-end substrate for avian sarcoma/leukosis virus (ASV) IN is 2 nucleotides. This places the two conserved 5'-CA-3' processing sites 6 nucleotides apart, a separation equal to the staggered cut in target DNA produced by this enzyme during the subsequent joining reaction. Based on estimates of initial reaction rates, this synapsed-end substrate is processed by IN at > 10-fold higher efficiency than observed with an equivalent mixture of U3 and U5 single-end (uncoupled) substrates. Enhanced processing is maintained at low IN concentrations, suggesting that the synapsed-end substrate may facilitate enzyme multimerization. Enhanced processing by HIV-1 IN, which produces a 5-bp stagger during integration, was observed with a synapsed-end substrate in which the separation between processing sites was 5 nucleotides. These observations provide estimates of the distances between active sites in the multimeric IN-DNA complexes of ASV and HIV-1. Our results also show that processing of paired U3 and U5 ends need not be coupled temporally. Finally, we observed that substrates that paired a wild-type with a mutated terminus were cleaved poorly at both ends. Thus, in vitro processing of the synapsed-end substrates requires specific recognition of the sequences at both ends. These findings provide new insights into the mechanism of integrative recombination by retroviral integrases and, by extension, other prokaryotic and eukaryotic transposases that are related to the viral enzymes.

Disassembly of the Mu transposase tetramer by the ClpX chaperone

Mu transposition is promoted by an extremely stable complex containing a tetramer of the transposase (MuA) bound to the recombining DNA. Here we purify the Escherichia coli ClpX protein, a member of a family of multimeric ATPases present in prokaryotes and eukaryotes (the Clp family), on the basis of its ability to remove the transposase from the DNA after recombination. Previously, ClpX has been shown to function with the ClpP peptidase in protein turnover. However, neither ClpP nor any other protease is required for disassembly of the transposase. The released MuA is not modified extensively, degraded, or irreversibly denatured, and is able to perform another round of recombination in vitro. We conclude that ClpX catalyzes the ATP-dependent release of MuA by promoting a transient conformational change in the protein and, therefore, can be considered a molecular chaperone. ClpX is important at the transition between the recombination and DNA replication steps of transposition in vitro; this function probably corresponds to the essential contribution of ClpX for Mu growth. Deletion analysis reveals that the sequence at the carboxyl terminus of MuA is important for disassembly by ClpX and can target MuA for degradation by ClpXP in vitro. These data contribute to the emerging picture that members of the Clp family are chaperones specifically suited for disaggregating proteins and are able to function with or without a collaborating protease.

The two single-strand cleavages at each end of Tn10 occur in a specific order during transposition

During Tn10 transposition, the element is excised from the donor site by double-strand cleavages at the two transposon ends. Double-strand cleavage is a central step in the nonreplicative transposition reaction of many transposons in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Evidence is presented to show that the Tn10 double-strand cut is made by an ordered, sequential cleavage of the two strands. The transferred strand is cut first, and then the nontransferred strand is cleaved. The single-strand nicked intermediate is seen to accumulate when Mn2+ is substituted for Mg2+ in the reaction or when certain mutant transposases are used. The fact that the transferred strand is cleaved before the non-transferred strand implies that the order of strand cleavages is not the determining factor that precludes a replicative mechanism of transposition.

Negative and positive regulation of Tn10/IS10-promoted recombination by IHF: two distinguishable processes inhibit transposition off of multicopy plasmid replicons and activate chromosomal events that favor evolution of new transposons

Tn10 is a composite transposon; inverted repeats of insertion sequence IS10 flank a tetracycline-resistance determinant. Previous work has identified several regulatory processes that modulate the interaction between Tn10 and its host. Among these, host-specified DNA adenine methylation, an IS10-encoded antisense RNA and preferential cis action of transposase are particularly important. We now find that the accessory host protein IHF and the sequences that encode the IHF-binding site in IS10 are also important regulators of the Tn10 transposition reaction in vivo and that these determinants are involved in two distinguishable regulatory processes. First, IHF and the IHF-binding site of IS10, together with other host components (e.g., HU), negatively regulate the normal intermolecular transposition process. Such negative regulation is prominent only for elements present on multicopy plasmid replicons. This multicopy plasmid-specific regulation involves effects both on the transposition reaction per se and on transposase gene expression. Second, specific interaction of IHF with its binding site stimulates transposon-promoted chromosome rearrangements but not transposition of a short Tn10-length chromosomal element. However, additional considerations predict that IHF action should favor chromosomal transposition for very long composite elements. On the basis of these and other observations we propose that, for chromosomal events, the major role of IHF is to promote the evolution of new IS10-based composite transposons.

A Drosophila protein homologous to the human p70 Ku autoimmune antigen interacts with the P transposable element inverted repeats

P transposable elements in Drosophila are mobilized via a cut-and-paste mechanism. This mode of transposition requires repair of both a double-strand break at the donor DNA site and gapped DNA at the target site. Biochemical studies have identified a cellular non-P element-encoded DNA binding protein, termed the inverted repeat binding protein (IRBP), that specifically interacts with the outer half of the 31-bp terminal inverted repeats. Protein sequence information was used to isolate cDNA clones encoding IRBP. Sequence analysis shows that IRBP is related to the 70-kDa subunit of the human Ku autoimmune antigen. The mammalian Ku antigen binds free DNA termini and has been implicated in immunoglobulin VDJ recombination, DNA repair, and transcription. In addition, Ku is the DNA binding subunit of the double-strand DNA-dependent protein kinase. Cytogenetic mapping indicates that the IRBP gene maps to chromosomal position 86E on the right arm of the third chromosome.

Complete transposition requires four active monomers in the mu transposase tetramer

A tetramer of Mu transposase (MuA) cleaves and joins multiple DNA strands to promote transposition. Derivatives of MuA altered at two acidic residues that are conserved among transposases and retroviral integrases form tetramers but are defective in both cleavage and joining. These mutant proteins were used to analyze the contribution of individual monomers to the activity of the tetramer. The performance of different protein combinations demonstrates that not all monomers need to be catalytically competent for the complex to promote an individual cleavage or joining reaction. Furthermore, the results indicate that each pair of essential residues is probably donated to the active complex by a single monomer. Although stable, tetramers composed of a mixture of mutant and wild-type MuA generate products cleaved at only one end and with only one end joined to the target DNA. The abundance of these abortive products and the ratios of the two proteins in complexes stalled at different steps indicate that the complete reaction requires the activity of all four monomers. Thus, each subunit of MuA appears to use the conserved acidic amino acids to promote one DNA cleavage or one DNA joining reaction.

Formation of a stable complex between the human immunodeficiency virus integrase protein and viral DNA

The integrase (IN) protein of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) mediates two distinct reactions: (i) specific removal of two nucleotides from the 3' ends of the viral DNA and (ii) integration of the viral DNA into target DNA. Although IN discriminates between specific (viral) DNA and nonspecific DNA in physical in vitro assays, a sequence-specific DNA-binding domain could not be identified in the protein. A nonspecific DNA-binding domain, however, was found at the C terminus of the protein. We examined the DNA-binding characteristics of HIV-1 IN, and found that a stable complex of IN and viral DNA is formed in the presence of Mn2+. The IN-viral DNA complex is resistant to challenge by an excess of competitor DNA. Stable binding of IN to the viral DNA requires that the protein contains an intact N-terminal domain and active site (in the central region of the protein), in addition to the C-terminal DNA-binding domain.

Co-chairman's remarks: genetic recombination in the molecular era

The present status of some general questions about DNA recombination is assessed. Topics include the mechanisms of synapsis and strand exchange, and the functions of recombination in nature.

Division of labor among monomers within the Mu transposase tetramer

A single tetramer of Mu transposase (MuA) pairs the recombination sites, cleaves the donor DNA, and joins these ends to a target DNA by strand transfer. Analysis of C-terminal deletion derivatives of MuA reveals that a 30 amino acid region between residues 575 and 605 is critical for these three steps. Although inactive on its own, a deletion protein lacking this region assembles with the wild-type protein. These mixed tetramers carry out donor cleavage but do not promote strand transfer, even when the donor cleavage stage is bypassed. These data suggest that the active center of the transposase is composed of the C-terminus of four MuA monomers; one dimer carries out donor cleavage while all four monomers contribute to strand transfer.

Preferential cis action of IS10 transposase depends upon its mode of synthesis

A number of bacterial DNA-binding proteins, including IS element transposases, act preferentially in cis. We show below that the degree of preferential cis action by IS10 transposase depends upon its mode of synthesis at steps subsequent to transcription initiation. Cis preference is increased several fold by mutations that decrease translation initiation, by the presence of IS10-specific antisense RNA and by plasmids that increase the level of cellular RNases. Conversely, cis preference is decreased by mutations that increase translation initiation; in some cases, cis preference is nearly abolished. Mutations that alter the rate of transcription initiation have no effect. In light of other observations, we suggest that cis preference is strongly dependent upon the rate at which transcripts are released from their templates and/or the half-life of the transposase message. These observations provide further evidence that inefficient translation plays multiple roles in the biology of IS10.

Formation of the tandem repeat (IS30)2 and its role in IS30-mediated transpositional DNA rearrangements

Plasmids carrying two IS30 elements in the same orientation, as in the composite transposon Tn2706, are structurally unstable in Escherichia coli. A primary segregation product is formed by site-specific deletion of the sequences carried between the two IS30 elements. The resulting covalently closed replicon carries the two IS30 elements as tandem repeats separated by only 2 bp. This (IS30)2 structure is extremely unstable, but it can nevertheless be isolated on its vector plasmid and, after purification, can be reintroduced into host cells by transformation. Among the descendants of transformants of recA- bacteria, replicated copies of the introduced (IS30)2 structure are still present, together with various kinds of segregation products which provide evidence for the efficient generation of DNA rearrangements. Most abundant is the product of another site-specific recombination between two identical ends of the IS30 elements involved, which results in the presence of just one intact IS30 on the plasmid. Apart from this, and depending on the presence of appropriate targets for IS30 transposition, various transposition products of (IS30)2 are also seen. Intramolecular reactions lead to DNA inversions and deletions with breakpoints other than IS30 ends. In intermolecular reactions inverse transposition occurs at high frequency and one also obtains simple transposition and cointegration. A mutational study revealed the requirement in cis of one intact IS30 transposase gene and of both proximal ends of the two IS30 elements concerned not only for the formation of (IS30)2, but also for its further rearrangement reactions, including the efficient formation of site-specific deletions. A model is proposed, which postulates that (IS30)2 intermediates play a key role in IS30 transposition pathways in which the formation of (IS30)2 may be rate-limiting. Once this structure is formed, it gives rise to a burst of transpositional rearrangements in the subclone carrying (IS30)2. Evolutionary implications of these findings are discussed.

Impairment of V(D)J recombination in double-strand break repair mutants

Cells maintain the integrity of their genome through an intricate network of repair systems that recognize and remove lesions from DNA. The only known site-directed recombination process in vertebrates is the V(D)J recombination of lymphocyte antigen receptor genes. A large panel of cell lines deficient in DNA repair were tested for the ability to perform V(D)J recombination after introduction of the RAG-1 and RAG-2 genes. Two mutants failed to generate normal V(D)J recombination, and further analysis provided evidence for two distinct nonlymphoid-specific genes that encode factors involved in both DNA repair and V(D)J recombination.

Elimination of Tec elements involves a novel excision process

Approximately 60,000 transposon-like elements of the Tec1 and Tec2 families excise en masse from the micronuclear genome during formation of a macronucleus in Euplotes crassus. The circular product has been shown previously to contain the element inverted repeats joined head to head. To elucidate the mechanism of Tec excision, we have further characterized the circular products. DNA sequence analysis of cloned inverted repeat junctions and of population of supercoiled Tec circles shows that the inverted repeat junctions consist of both copies of the target site duplication surrounding 10 additional bases. The 10 bp differs for each junction. We demonstrate that the circles are highly sensitive to S1, mung bean and Bal 31 nucleases, and the site of sensitivity maps to the junction. Alkaline gel electrophoresis indicates that the junction does not contain a nick or gap; thus, a likely explanation for the nuclease sensitivity is the existence of a heteroduplex DNA structure at the junction. On the basis of these results, we present a model of Tec excision and discuss the relationship of Tec excision to IES elimination and chromosome fragmentation in E. crassus.

Mechanistic aspects of DNA transposition

The past year has seen a number of important advances in our understanding of the mechanisms of DNA transposition. The molecular details of the protein-protein, protein-DNA and chemical-reaction steps in several transposition systems have been revealed and have highlighted remarkable uniformity in some areas, ranging from bacterial to retroviral mechanisms.