Immunologically mediated membrane damage: the mechanism of complement action and the similarity of lymphocyte-mediated cytoxicity

Complement can neutralize HIV-1 plasma virus by a C5-independent mechanism

A previous study showed a portion of HIV-1 plasma virus was lysed by the addition of exogenous human AB+ seronegative complement. The current study was performed to determine whether infectious plasma virus was inactivated by complement. Incubation of plasma virus with AB+-seronegative serum resulted in substantial decreases in infectious titers, demonstrating that infectious plasma virus is susceptible to complement-mediated inactivation. Although complement also induced some lysis of plasma virus samples, virus was neutralized to a significantly higher degree, suggesting neutralization did not occur solely by lysis. Additionally, C5-deficient complement substantially neutralized virus, indicating coating of virus by early complement components was an important mechanism of neutralization. A portion of some freshly isolated plasma virus samples bound to complement receptor 2 in the absence of exogenous complement, indicating that early complement components bound virus in vivo. Furthermore, plasma virus samples that had less C3 deposited on their surface in vivo had higher infectious titers than samples with a larger fraction with surface C3. These findings suggest that complement can neutralize HIV-1 plasma virus in vivo by coating with complement proteins. This is the first study to provide evidence that coating by complement leads to functional inactivation of a virus in vivo.

Ca2+-activated K+ efflux limits complement-mediated lysis of human erythrocytes

The lytic effect of complement on human erythrocytes has been reported by others to increase when Na+ is substituted for K+ in the external medium. In this paper we have investigated the hypothesis that net loss of K+ through a K+ transport pathway protects erythrocytes from complement-induced colloidosmotic swelling and lysis. Antibody-sensitized human erythrocytes containing different intracellular cation concentrations (nystatin treatment) were exposed to low concentrations of guinea pig serum in media of different cation composition; complement lysis was assessed by the release of hemoglobin and the volume of the surviving cells estimated by their density distribution profiles. Complement-dependent swelling and lysis of erythrocytes (a) were limited by the presence of an outwardly directed K+ electrochemical gradient and (b) were enhanced by carbocyanine, a specific inhibitor of the Ca2+-activated K+ transport pathway, and by absence of Ca2+ in the external medium. We propose that during complement activation a rising cytosolic calcium triggers the Ca2+-activated K+ permeability pathway, the Gardos effect, produces a net K+, Cl- and water loss, and thus limits the colloidosmotic swelling and lysis of erythrocytes.

Complement induces a transient increase in membrane permeability in unlysed erythrocytes

The effects of low concentrations of human serum on antibody-sensitized sheep erythrocytes (EA) were studied. We report that exposure to low concentrations of serum induced a large but transient increase in the membrane permeability of those EA that do not lyse. This change in the permeability of the erythrocyte membrane resulted in net uptake of Na+ and decrease in cell K+, without affecting the total internal cation content. Although exposure to serum also allowed for net uptake of larger molecules like L-glucose, it did not lead to cell swelling. Experiments with sera genetically deficient in one of the terminal complement components showed that C8, but not C9, was required to produce the observed change in membrane permeability. Therefore, we propose that the C5b-8 complex can mediate the transient increase in permeability observed in unlysed erythrocytes during complement activation by whole serum.

Is serum the optimal source for HLA antibodies?

The cytotoxic reactivity of 18 predefined class I HLA serum antibodies was compared with that of antibody preparations containing anticoagulants. ACD-A, EDTA, 4% citrate and heparin plasmas all showed lower cytotoxicity than serum antibodies. Recalcification of both platelet-rich and platelet-poor ACD-A plasma did not fully restore the antibody reactivity, suggesting a detrimental effect of calcium chelation. This effect was exclusive of volume or of any platelet or plasma protein involvement. The changes in pH contributed to the lower reactivity and to the increased lympholytic effect, whereas adjusting the pH toward the serum value improved the reactivity. Heat-inactivated antibodies showed only a slightly reduced cytotoxicity. Heparin had the least effect of all anticoagulants on the reactivity, although in heparin there was a definite dose-dependent decline in cytotoxic titer which was probably related to anticomplementary activity. Calcium chelators, such as EDTA and citrate, showed marked cytotoxic inhibition at half the usual complement concentration. This effect was more pronounced when the anticoagulant and lymphocytes were incubated prior to cytotoxicity testing. At the complement concentrations used, the inhibitory effects of the citrate anticoagulants appeared to be primarily calcium-related. Inhibition tests, serial titrations and testing of varying calcium concentrations confirmed the superiority of serum as antibody source.

Novel fluorescence method to visualize antibody-dependent hydrogen peroxide-associated "killing" of liposomes by phagocytes

We have developed a new methodology to examine effector-cell-mediated immune attack using liposomes as targets. Hydrogen peroxide-associated killing of liposomes was observed with fluorescence intensification microscopy. Liposomes were composed of 98-99 mol % egg phosphatidylcholine and 1-2 mol % dinitrophenyl lipid hapten. Anti-dinitrophenyl IgG antibody was used to opsonize liposomes. Liposomes were loaded with dihydroxymandelic acid (DHMA) and peroxidase. Macrophage- or neutrophil-mediated recognition of liposomes triggers the release of H2O2 and other oxidative products. Upon interaction of H2O2 or OH radical with liposome contents, DHMA dimerizes forming a fluorescent derivative. Our studies indicate that individual living neutrophils and macrophages deposit oxidative products in a heterogenous fashion among bound targets.

Novel fluorescence method to visualize antibody-dependent hydrogen peroxide-associated "killing" of liposomes by phagocytes

We have developed a new methodology to examine effector-cell-mediated immune attack using liposomes as targets. Hydrogen-peroxide-associated killing of liposomes was observed with fluorescence intensification microscopy. Liposomes were composed of 98-99 mol % egg phosphatidylcholine and 1-2 mol % dinitrophenyl lipid hapten. Anti-dinitrophenyl IgG antibody was used to opsonize liposomes. Liposomes were loaded with dihydroxymandelic acid (DHMA) and peroxidase. Macrophage- or neutrophil-mediated recognition of liposomes triggers the release of H2O2 and other oxidative products. Upon interaction of H2O2 or OH radical with liposome contents, DHMA dimerizes forming a fluorescent derivative. Our studies indicate that individual living neutrophils and macrophages deposit oxidative products in a heterogeneous fashion among bound targets.

Molecular weight of the membrane C5b-9 complex of human complement: characterization of the terminal complex as a C5b-9 monomer

The hydrodynamic properties of the detergent-solubilized, terminal membrane complex of serum complement components C5-C9 [C5b-9(m)] were studied to obtain an estimate of its molecular weight. In a solution of Triton X-100/deoxycholate, the protein complex binds 17% Triton X-100 and 11% deoxycholate by weight. The sedimentation coefficient of the protein-detergent complex is 26 S as determined by sucrose density gradient ultracentrifugation, and gel filtration indicated a molecular radius of 11 nm. It was ascertained by electron microscopy that these hydrodynamic parameters apply to mono-dispersed C5b-9(m) complexes, which were observed as nonaggregated, hollow protein cylinders and were identical to the complement "lesions" formed on target membranes. The calculated molecular weight of the protein-detergent complex is approximately 1,286,300 to which the protein moiety contributes approximately 1,000,000. The results indicate that the C5b-9(m) complex formed on biological membranes is a monomer entity of the C5-C9 complement components.

Permeability characteristics of complement-damaged membranes: evaluation of the membrane leak generated by the complement proteins C5b-9

Permeability characteristics of the membrane lesion generated by the terminal complement proteins are considered in light of recent observations that the measured diffusion of solute across complement-damaged membranes does not conform to the "doughnut hole" model of a discrete transmembrane pore formed by the inserted C5b-9 complex. By using the measured kinetics of steady-state tracer isotope diffusion of nonelectrolytes across resealed erythrocyte ghost membranes treated with C5b-9, a new transport model is developed. This model considers the apparent membrane lesion strictly in terms of the operational criteria of a functional conducting pathway for the observed diffusing solute, independent of a priori assumptions about the geometry or molecular properties of the membrane lesion. With this definition of the unit membrane lesion and the assumption that the exclusion size of the conducting pathway varies directly with the multiplicity of bound C5b-9 (as suggested by previous measurements under conditions of varying input of C5b-9), numerical estimates of te apparent permeability of the complement-damaged membrane to four diffusing nonelectrolytes are derived. These results suggest that the pathway for a particle diffusing across the complement lesion cannot be a pore and is functionally equivalent to an aqueous leak pathway, free of pore constraints. Implications of these results are discussed in terms of current molecular models for the mechanism of membrane damage by the complement proteins.

Two mechanisms of cell-mediated cytotoxicity: Ca++ transport modulation by lymphotoxin and transmembrane channel formation by antibody and nonadherent spleen cells

Lymphotoxin is a protein with a MW of 45,000 daltons derived from activated lymphocytes that kills target cells nonspecifically. Kinetic studies indicate that there is a lag period of about 4 hours before cytotoxicity becomes apparent, even at high concentrations of lymphotoxin. Therefore, the role of lymphotoxin in cell-mediated cytotoxicity would be restricted to situations in which more rapid mechanisms are not operative. It has found that lymphotoxin increases the rate of 45Ca++ uptake by the mouse L-cells used as targets. This effect and the cytotoxicity are abrogated by ouabain. A lymphotoxin-resistent L-cell mutant did not display the 45Ca++ uptake effect. It is not known whether the Ca++ effect is primary or secondary. Neutralization experiments with anti-lymphotoxin have indicated that there are at least two distinct pathways by which immune lymphocytes can destroy target cells in vitro--one that involves secretion of a nonspecific soluble factor, i.e., lymphotoxin, and another that probably requires intimate contact between the plasma membranes of the target and killer cells. This "membrane contact" mechanism may involve formation of channels in the target cell membranes. The transmembrane channel concept is a working hypothesis that is based on experiments by Henkart and Blumenthal in which it was found that antibody and lymphocytes jointly produce ion-conducting channels in planar bilayers of "oxidized cholesterol." In order to supplement and extend this approach we have made an exploratory study of 86Rb+ and 51Cr marker release from lecithin/cholesterol/dicetyl phosphate liposomes by antibody and nonadherent mouse spleen cells. Evidence is presented indicating that the antibody and cells cause direct synergistic marker release from liposomes into the fluid medium. This indicates that they have the capacity to damage phospholipid bilayers. Hence, it seems worthwhile to conduct further studies of the liposome model in order to uncover the mechanism of membrane damage and to assess its relevance to cell-mediated cytotoxicity.