Role of the aziridinium moiety in the in vivo cholinotoxicity of ethylcholine aziridinium ion (AF64A)

Selective neurotoxins, chemical tools to probe the mind: the first thirty years and beyond

For centuries, starting with the advent of the microscope, cytotoxins have been known to non-selectively destroy nerves and other tissue cells. However, neurotoxins restricted in effect to one kind of neuron are an invention of the 20th century. One might reasonably trace the origins of this field to 1960 when the Nobel Laureates, R. Levi- Montalcini and S Cohen, showed that an antibody to nerve growth factor effectively prevented development of sympathetic nerves in the absence of overt changes in dorsal root ganglia and other neural and non-neural tissues. The year 1967 marks discovery of 6-hydroxydopamine, the first of dozens of chemically-selective neurotoxins. As stated by the physiologist W.B. Cannon, neural function can be deduced by denoting absence-deficits. A wealth of knowledge in neuroscience has been realized through use of neurotoxins. In the 21st century we foresee neurotoxins for virtually all neurochemically-identifiable or receptor-specific neurons, acting at/via functional proteins or characteristic DNA sites. These tools will provide us with a better means to probe the mind and thereby lead to a fuller understanding of the intricate roles of identifiable neuronal systems in integrative neuroscience.

AF64A-induced changes in N-myc expression in the LA-N-2 human neuroblastoma cell line are modulated by choline and hemicholinium-3

Due to AF64A's structural similarity to choline, AF64A can selectively affect cholinergic neurons, which possess a high affinity choline transport system for acetylcholine synthesis. The mechanism by which AF64A selectively produces its cytotoxic effect is unknown. However, based on previous studies that demonstrate that DNA lesions produced by AF64A caused premature termination of N-myc transcription in vitro, it is possible that AF64A may affect the transcription of genes necessary for developmental maintenance in cholinergic cells. Using the LA-N-2 cells as a model to study the effects of AF64A in a purely cholinergic system, we investigated the effects of AF64A on the expression of the N-myc gene and monitored cell growth. AF64A produced a maximal decrease in N-myc mRNA with a return to steady state levels at later time points. Moreover, a decrease in cell numbers in AF64A-treated cells was observed, and these cells did not double in number at their respective doubling time as compared to control. In other studies, a causal relationship between a reduction in N-myc and an inhibition of cell growth and replication has been reported. While these studies do not allow us to conclude that AF64A is specific for N-myc, the data do, nevertheless, suggest that AF64A affects cell growth and/or replication by down-regulating the expression of N-myc which is involved in differentiation and cell growth in neuroblastomas. Presence of choline or hemicholinium-3 prevented the AF64A-induced decrease of N-myc levels by competing with, or inhibiting the choline transport mechanism by which AF64A enters the cell, respectively.

AF64A-induced cytotoxicity and changes in choline acetyltransferase activity in the LA-N-2 neuroblastoma cell line are modulated by choline and hemicholinium-3

The cholinergic neurotoxin AF64A (ethylcholine aziridinium) has been used to selectively destroy the cholinergic system. Due to its structural similarity to choline, this compound may be selectively taken up by the cholinergic terminal via the high-affinity choline transport (HAChT) system to produce persistent and selective cholinergic deficits. The mechanism by which it exerts its cholinotoxicity remains to be elucidated. We have examined the effects of AF64A in the human neuroblastoma cell line, LA-N-2, which has an intact sodium-coupled choline uptake system, and is capable of synthesizing acetylcholine (ACh). AF64A (25, 50 and 100 microM) produced dose-dependent increases in cell kill as measured by colony formation assay. The addition of increasing concentrations (10(-5), 10(-4) and 10(-3) M) of choline and hemicholinium-3 (HC-3) protected the cells from the cytotoxic effects of AF64A. At the same doses, AF64A also decreased choline acetyltransferase (ChAT) activity. In the presence of the highest concentration of choline or HC-3 (10(-3) M) which produced complete protection against AF64A's cytotoxicity in the colony formation assay, ChAT activity was restored to control values. These results demonstrate that agents that utilize (i.e., choline) or inhibit (i.e., HC-3) the choline uptake system prevented AF64A-induced cytotoxicity and decreases in ChAT activity, in a manner similar to that which has been observed in chick and rat primary cholinergic cultures in vitro. The LA-N-2 neuroblastoma cell line thus serves well as an in vitro model of the cholinergic neuron and provides a useful system to study the mode of cholinotoxicity induced by AF64A.

Cholinotoxic effects on acetylcholinesterase gene expression are associated with brain-region specific alterations in G,C-rich transcripts

To study the mechanisms underlying cholinotoxic brain damage, we examined ethylcholine aziridinium (AF64A) effects on cholinesterase genes. In vitro, AF64A hardly affected cholinesterase activities yet inhibited transcription of the G,C-rich AChE DNA encoding acetylcholinesterase (AChE) more than the A,T-rich butyrylcholinesterase (BChE) DNA. In vivo, intracerebroventricular injection of 2 nmol of AF64A decreased AChE mRNA in striatum and septum by 3- and 25-fold by day 7, with no change in BChE mRNA or AChE activity. In contrast, hippocampal AChE mRNA increased 10-fold by day 7 and BChE mRNA and AChE activity decreased 2-fold. By day 60 post-treatment, both AChE mRNA and AChE levels returned to normal in all regions except hippocampus, where AChE activity and BChE mRNA were decreased by 2-fold. Moreover, differential PCR displays revealed persistent induction, specific to the hippocampus of treated rats, of several unidentified G,C-rich transcripts, suggesting particular responsiveness of hippocampal G,C-rich genes to cholinotoxicity.

Effects of the neurotoxin ethylcholine mustard aziridinium in rat brain reaggregate cultures

The toxicity was studied of ethylcholine mustard aziridinium (ECMA) in rat brain reaggregate cultures. The objective was to define optimum conditions for selective effects on cholinergic neurones. Single treatments with 12.5-50 mum-ECMA caused approximately 35% loss of choline acetyltransferase (ChAT) activity in 2 hr, increasing to 70-80% in 72-120 hr. The 2-hr, but not the longer-term loss of activity was prevented by the choline transport blocker hemicholinium-3 (40 mum). Significant loss of ChAT activity could not be obtained with less than 12.5 mum-ECMA. Approximately 55% irreversible inhibition of muscarinic receptor binding also occurred in 2 hr. However, after 12.5 mum-ECMA, binding recovered to control values within 48 hr. These persisted throughout the longer-term more extensive loss of ChAT activity, which suggests that receptor recovery localized to cells other than cholinergic neurones. After 25-50 mum-ECMA, muscarinic receptor binding did not recover, which suggests more widespread cytotoxicity destroying cells other than the cholinergic neurones. More pronounced leakage of lactate dehydrogenase and reduced reaggregate concentrations of total and neurofilament protein were consistent with more generalized cytotoxicity after 25 or 50 mum-ECMA. Examination of ECMA treated reaggregates or cerebellar monolayer cultures by light microscopy confirmed this. Concentrations of 12.5 mum-ECMA therefore represent the optimum for achieving selective toxic effects on cholinergic neurones in the cultures. After ECMA, reaggregate concentrations of 5-hydroxyindole acetic acid were markedly increased (100-300%), which suggests increased activity of 5HT neurones. This demonstrates that reaggregate cultures might be used to study trans-synaptic neurochemical sequelae of brain cholinergic neurone loss.

Inhibition of high affinity choline uptake in the rat brain by neurotoxins: effect of monosialoganglioside GM1

Mustard derivatives of ethyl-choline and hemicholinium-3 have been suggested as possible specific cholinergic neurotoxins. In this study a structural analog of hemicholinium-3, a,a'-bis[di(2-chloroethyl)amino]-4,4'-2-biacetophenone (toxin 7), was added to synaptosomes prepared from the cortex, striatum or hippocampus of rat brain. Synaptosomal high affinity choline uptake (HACU) was significantly decreased in a dose-dependent manner by addition of toxin 7, while synaptosomal uptake of GABA or dopamine was not changed. Incubation of cortical synaptosomes with the monosialoganglioside GM1 prevented the decrease in HACU seen following administration of toxin 7. This preventative effect of GM1 was greater if GM1 was added prior to or concomitant with toxin 7, than if GM1 was added following toxin 7. Two newly synthesized hemicholinium-3 analogs, 4-[3'-di(2-chloroethyl)aminopropionyl]biphenyl (toxin 5) and 4-[3'-di(2-bromoethyl)aminopropionyl]biphenyl (toxin 6) caused a large decrease in HACU when added to cortical synaptosomes, this decrease was significantly greater than that seen with the same dose of toxin 7 or ethyl-choline aziridinium (AF64A). Ultrastructural changes in the synaptosomal membrane following incubation with toxin 7 or toxin 7 with GM1 were examined by electron microscopy. Development of a compound which is both a potent neurotoxin, and is specific for cholinergic neurons will allow new insights into the normal function of the cholinergic system in the CNS and provide animal models of disease states in which cholinergic degeneration is an important element.