Whole-mammal mutagenicity tests: evaluation of five methods

The role of dose rate in radiation cancer risk: evaluating the effect of dose rate at the molecular, cellular and tissue levels using key events in critical pathways following exposure to low LET radiation

PURPOSE

This review evaluates the role of dose rate on cell and molecular responses. It focuses on the influence of dose rate on key events in critical pathways in the development of cancer. This approach is similar to that used by the U.S. EPA and others to evaluate risk from chemicals. It provides a mechanistic method to account for the influence of the dose rate from low-LET radiation, especially in the low-dose region on cancer risk assessment. Molecular, cellular, and tissues changes are observed in many key events and change as a function of dose rate. The magnitude and direction of change can be used to help establish an appropriate dose rate effectiveness factor (DREF).

CONCLUSIONS

Extensive data on key events suggest that exposure to low dose-rates are less effective in producing changes than high dose rates. Most of these data at the molecular and cellular level support a large (2-30) DREF. In addition, some evidence suggests that doses delivered at a low dose rate decrease damage to levels below that observed in the controls. However, there are some data human and mechanistic data that support a dose-rate effectiveness factor of 1. In summary, a review of the available molecular, cellular and tissue data indicates that not only is dose rate an important variable in understanding radiation risk but it also supports the selection of a DREF greater than one as currently recommended by ICRP ( 2007 ) and BEIR VII (NRC/NAS 2006 ).

Approaches for identifying germ cell mutagens: Report of the 2013 IWGT workshop on germ cell assays(☆)

This workshop reviewed the current science to inform and recommend the best evidence-based approaches on the use of germ cell genotoxicity tests. The workshop questions and key outcomes were as follows. (1) Do genotoxicity and mutagenicity assays in somatic cells predict germ cell effects? Limited data suggest that somatic cell tests detect most germ cell mutagens, but there are strong concerns that dictate caution in drawing conclusions. (2) Should germ cell tests be done, and when? If there is evidence that a chemical or its metabolite(s) will not reach target germ cells or gonadal tissue, it is not necessary to conduct germ cell tests, notwithstanding somatic outcomes. However, it was recommended that negative somatic cell mutagens with clear evidence for gonadal exposure and evidence of toxicity in germ cells could be considered for germ cell mutagenicity testing. For somatic mutagens that are known to reach the gonadal compartments and expose germ cells, the chemical could be assumed to be a germ cell mutagen without further testing. Nevertheless, germ cell mutagenicity testing would be needed for quantitative risk assessment. (3) What new assays should be implemented and how? There is an immediate need for research on the application of whole genome sequencing in heritable mutation analysis in humans and animals, and integration of germ cell assays with somatic cell genotoxicity tests. Focus should be on environmental exposures that can cause de novo mutations, particularly newly recognized types of genomic changes. Mutational events, which may occur by exposure of germ cells during embryonic development, should also be investigated. Finally, where there are indications of germ cell toxicity in repeat dose or reproductive toxicology tests, consideration should be given to leveraging those studies to inform of possible germ cell genotoxicity.

Whole genome sequencing for quantifying germline mutation frequency in humans and model species: cautious optimism

Factors affecting the type and frequency of germline mutations in animals are of significant interest from health and toxicology perspectives. However, studies in this field have been limited by the use of markers with low detection power or uncertain relevance to phenotype. Whole genome sequencing (WGS) is now a potential option to directly determine germline mutation type and frequency in family groups at all loci simultaneously. Medical studies have already capitalized on WGS to identify novel mutations in human families for clinical purposes, such as identifying candidate genes contributing to inherited conditions. However, WGS has not yet been used in any studies of vertebrates that aim to quantify changes in germline mutation frequency as a result of environmental factors. WGS is a promising tool for detecting mutation induction, but it is currently limited by several technical challenges. Perhaps the most pressing issue is sequencing error rates that are currently high in comparison to the intergenerational mutation frequency. Different platforms and depths of coverage currently result in a range of 10-10(3) false positives for every true mutation. In addition, the cost of WGS is still relatively high, particularly when comparing mutation frequencies among treatment groups with even moderate sample sizes. Despite these challenges, WGS offers the potential for unprecedented insight into germline mutation processes. Refinement of available tools and emergence of new technologies may be able to provide the improved accuracy and reduced costs necessary to make WGS viable in germline mutation studies in the very near future. To streamline studies, researchers may use multiple family triads per treatment group and sequence a targeted (reduced) portion of each genome with high (20-40 ×) depth of coverage. We are optimistic about the application of WGS for quantifying germline mutations, but caution researchers regarding the resource-intensive nature of the work using existing technology.

Exposure to residential indoor air induces heritable DNA mutations in mice

Exposure to the mixed indoor air pollutants released from synthetic materials and chemical products poses a serious public health problem, but little evidence has been provided to clarify whether such pollutants at environmentally relevant concentrations produce inheritable germline mutations. In the present study, mice were exposed to samples of indoor air from a newly decorated apartment bedroom. Results showed expanded simple tandem repeat (ESTR) mutations occurring in the germline of control and exposed parents, which were also detected in their offspring using three probes, Ms6-hm, Hm-2, and MMS10. Data indicated that mice being exposed to indoor air triggered a significant increase in frequency of ESTR mutations, which may be due primarily to a rise in mutations inherited through the paternal germline. These results suggest that exposure to a mixture of pollutants in indoor air obtained from an apartment in China induced ESTR mutations. Thus, humans exposed to polluted indoor apartment air in China may be at risk for developing germline mutations.

Transgenic lambda medaka as a new model for germ cell mutagenesis

To address the need for improved approaches to study mutations transmitted to progeny from mutagen-exposed parents, we evaluated lambda transgenic medaka, a small fish that carries the cII mutation target gene, as a new model for germ cell mutagenesis. Mutations in the cII gene in progeny derived from ethyl-nitrosourea (ENU)-exposed males were readily detected. Frequencies of mutant offspring, proportions of mosaic or whole body mutant offspring, and mutational spectra differed according to germ cell stage exposed to ENU. Postmeiotic germ cells (spermatozoa/late spermatids) generated a higher frequency of mutant offspring (11%) compared to premeiotic germ cells (3.5%). Individuals with cII mutant frequencies (MF) elevated more than threefold above the spontaneous MF (3 x 10(-5)) in the range of 10(-4) to 10(-3) were mosaic mutant offspring, whereas those with MFs approaching 1 x 10(-2) were whole body mutant offspring. Mosaic mutant offspring comprised the majority of mutant offspring derived from postmeiotic germ cells, and unexpectedly, from spermatogonial stem cells. Mutational spectra comprised of two different mutations, but at identical sites were unusual and characteristic of delayed mutations, in which fixation of a second mutation was delayed following fertilization. Delayed mutations and prevalence of mosaic mutant offspring add to growing evidence that implicates germ cells in mediating processes postfertilization that contribute to genomic instability in progeny. This model provides an efficient and sensitive approach to assess germ cell mutations, expands opportunities to increase understanding of fundamental mechanisms of mutagenesis, and provides a means for improved assessment of potential genetic health risks.

Detection of induced male germline mutation: correlations and comparisons between traditional germline mutation assays, transgenic rodent assays and expanded simple tandem repeat instability assays

Several rodent assays are capable of monitoring germline mutation. These include traditional assays, such as the dominant lethal (DL) assay, the morphological specific locus (SL) test and the heritable translocation (HT) assay, and two assays that have been developed more recently--the expanded simple tandem repeat (ESTR) and transgenic rodent (TGR) mutation assays. In this paper, we have compiled the limited amount of experimental data that are currently available to make conclusions regarding the comparative ability of the more recently developed assays to detect germline mutations induced by chemical and radiological agents. The data suggest that ESTR and TGR assays are generally comparable with SL in detecting germline mutagenicity induced by alkylating agents and radiation, though TGR offered less sensitivity than ESTR in some cases. The DL and HT assays detect clastogenic events and are most susceptible to mutations arising in post-spermatogonial cells, and they may not provide the best comparisons with TGR and ESTR instability. The measurement of induced ESTR instability represents a relatively sensitive method of identifying agents causing germline mutation in rodents, and may also be useful for bio-monitoring exposed individuals in the human population. Any future use of the TGR and ESTR germline mutation assays in a regulatory testing context will entail more robust and extensive characterization of assay performance. This will require substantially more data, including experiments measuring multiple endpoints, a greatly expanded database of chemical agents and a focus on characterizing stage-specific activity of mutagens in these assays, preferably by sampling epididymal sperm exposed at defined pre-meiotic, meiotic and post-meiotic stages of development.

Expanded simple tandem repeat (ESTR) mutation induction in the male germline: lessons learned from lab mice

Expanded simple tandem repeat (ESTR) DNA loci that are unstable in the germline have provided the most sensitive tool ever developed for investigating low-dose heritable mutation induction in laboratory mice. Ionizing radiation exposures have shown that ESTR mutations occur mainly in pre-meiotic spermatogonia and stem cells. The average spermatogonial doubling dose is 0.62-0.69 Gy for low LET, and 0.18-0.34 Gy for high LET radiation. Chemical alkylating agents also cause significant ESTR mutation induction in pre-meiotic spermatogonia and stem cells, but are much less effective per unit dose than radiation. ESTR mutation induction efficiency is maximal at low doses of radiation or chemical mutagens, and may decrease at higher dose ranges. DNA repair deficient mice (SCID and PARP-1) with elevated levels of single and double-strand DNA breaks have spontaneously elevated ESTR mutation frequencies, and surprisingly do not show additional ESTR mutation induction following irradiation. In contrast, ESTR mutation induction in p53 knock-outs is indistinguishable from that of wild-type mice. Studies of sentinel mice exposed in situ to ambient air pollution showed elevated ESTR mutation frequencies in males exposed to high levels of particulate matter. These studies highlight the application of the ESTR assay for assessing environmental hazards under real-world conditions. All ESTR studies to date have shown untargeted mutations that occur at much higher frequencies than predicted. The mechanism of this untargeted mutation induction is unknown, and must be elucidated before we can fully understand the biological significance of ESTR mutations, or use these markers for formal risk assessment. Future studies should focus on the mechanism of ESTR mutation induction, refining dose responses, and developing ESTR markers for other animal species.

Transmission of mutations in the lacI transgene to the offspring of ENU-treated Big Blue male mice

The purpose of the study was to determine: 1) if male germ cells of Big Blue mice carrying newly induced mutations in the lacI transgene were effective in fertilization; 2) if offspring arising from such mutant sperm had the mutation in germ cells and multiple somatic tissues; and 3) how the frequency of mutants induced in the lacI transgene compared to the frequency induced in endogenous genes traditionally employed to study germ cell mutagenesis in mice. Male B6C3F(1) mice hemizygous for the lambda/lacI transgene were treated weekly with 100 mg/kg body weight of the mammalian germ cell mutagen N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (ENU). The cumulative dose for each treated animal was 300 mg ENU/kg body weight. Ten weeks later the treated mice were mated to T stock females and the resulting offspring were screened for specific-locus mutations at six loci affecting external appearance, as well as for mutations in the lacI transgene in multiple somatic tissues and germ cells. Five offspring carrying recessive specific-locus mutations were observed among 597 offspring screened (mutant frequency = 139.6 x 10(-5) per locus). Four offspring carrying lacI mutations were observed among 280 offspring screened (mutant frequency = 35.7 x 10(-5) per locus (assuming 40 target loci)). Each of the four lacI mutant offspring carried a different mutation. Three of the mutations were A:T-->G:C transitions and one a G:C-->A:T transition. Consistent with the expectation that a mutation induced in a parental germ cell and transmitted to a conceptus would exist in every cell of the offspring, each mutant mouse had identical mutations in all somatic tissues sampled, as well as in its germ cells. These data provide preliminary evidence for the biological validity of assessing induced, heritable mutations using transgenic mice, without the need for generating an F(1) generation.

Male-mediated behavioral abnormalities

The assessment of behavioral development in the progeny of males exposed to known mutagenic chemicals is a potentially sensitive endpoint for detecting transmissible abnormalities. A genetic component is demonstrated as these behavioral abnormalities can also be passed on to the F2 generation. In this review, experimental studies exploring transmission of behavioral deficits from paternal exposure to drugs, chemicals and radiation are addressed. Additionally included is a brief synopsis of recent work performed in our laboratory investigating such abnormalities in offspring from male rats exposed to ionizing radiations. The implications of these behavioral endpoints to humans is also discussed.

Simultaneous induction of mutagenic and cancerogenic effects in T x HT mice with transplacental ethylnitrosourea treatment

The relationship between mutagenesis and carcinogenesis was investigated in T x HT crossbred mice using diaplacental application of ethylnitrosourea (ENU) at different stages of embryonal development. Mutagenesis was detected by induction of coat color spots, and the carcinogenic response was investigated in a long-term follow-up study of the F1-generation. The animals were particularly sensitive to induction of tumors at the central nervous system (CNS)-skull/vertebra interface (30% and 20% in ENU-treated male and female offspring, respectively, compared with less than 1% in controls). There was a correlation between the appearance of these tumors and the presence of color spots. This correlation was low but statistically significant in female offspring. Three other types of tumors showed a correlation with the presence of coat color spots. Liver tumors were significantly increased in color spot-positive females but unchanged in males. Lung tumors were reduced in color spot-positive males and appeared earlier in color spot-positive females. There was a lower incidence of lymphoma/leukemia in all spot-positive mice. The reduction in tumor incidence beyond the spontaneous rate in spot-positive animals might be caused by a high cytolethal response to ENU in the relevant organs and tissues.

Dominant cataract and recessive specific-locus mutations detected in offspring of procarbazine-treated male mice

The induction of dominant cataract mutations by procarbazine was studied concomitantly with the induction of specific-locus mutations in treated male mice. The most effective dose in the specific-locus test, 600 mg/kg of procarbazine, and a fractionated dose of 5 X 200 mg/kg were used. The frequencies of dominant cataract mutations were higher, but not significantly different from the historical control. The ratio between the number of recovered specific-locus and dominant cataract mutations was in accordance with that found in our experiments with gamma-rays (Ehling et al., 1982; Kratochvilova, 1981) or in experiments with ethylnitrosourea (Favor, 1986). A total of 3 dominant cataract mutations were recovered in the offspring of procarbazine-treated spermatogonial stem cells. Two mutations had complete penetrance while the third exhibited a reduced penetrance of approximately 70%. The viability and fertility of the heterozygotes of all 3 mutations were not affected. Only 1 mutation was shown to be viable as a homozygote.

International Commission for Protection Against Environmental Mutagens and Carcinogens. ICPEMC Working Paper No. 2. Diet, mutation and cancer

Experimental research designed to determine the effects of variations in diet on the carcinogenic and mutagenic processes is difficult to conduct and even more difficult to interpret in terms of the likely response that such variations will have on the expression of human cancer and mutation. Although some of these difficulties may be due to a failure to persuade adequate numbers of highly trained nutritionists to enter into this type of research, a more germaine reason may be that the high level of complexity of both diet and the disease processes is such as to confound present efforts at interpretation. It is suggested that a stepwise analysis of the effects of dietary factors on each critical stage in carcinogenesis or mutagenesis may ultimately lead to results that are more easily interpreted in terms of human response. To this end it is proposed that studies of DNA-carcinogen or DNA-mutagen adduct formation, or other DNA damage, DNA replication and relevant DNA repair at the target site may be a useful guide to the effect of nutritional changes on mutation and/or cancer initiation. DNA replication at various stages of carcinogenesis, modification of hormonal levels, modification of immune response, or other factors as influenced by diet may provide markers for cancer development. The integration of this data to give an overall perception of the effects of nutrition is briefly discussed.

The mouse spot test. Evaluation of its performance in identifying chemical mutagens and carcinogens

The published results on 60 chemicals and X-rays investigated in the mouse spot test were compared with data on the same chemicals tested in the bacterial mutation assay (Ames test) and lifetime rodent bioassays. The performance of the spot test as an in vivo complementary assay to the in vitro bacterial mutagenesis test reveals that of 60 agents, 38 were positive in both systems, 6 were positive only in the spot test, 10 were positive only in the bacterial test and 6 were negative in both assays. The spot test was also considered as a predictor of carcinogenesis; 45 chemicals were carcinogenic of which 35 were detected as positive by the spot test and 3 out of 6 non-carcinogens were correctly identified as negative. If the results are regarded in sequence, i.e. that a positive result in a bacterial mutagenicity test reveals potential that may or may not be realized in vivo, then 48 chemicals were mutagenic in the bacterial mutation assay of which 38 were active in the spot test and 31 were confirmed as carcinogens in bioassays. 12 chemicals were non-mutagenic to bacteria of which 6 gave positive responses in the spot test and 5 were confirmed as carcinogens. These results provide strong evidence that the mouse coat spot test is an effective complementary test to the bacterial mutagenesis assay for the detection of genotoxic chemicals and as a confirmatory test for the identification of carcinogens. The main deficiency at present is the paucity of data from the testing of non-carcinogens. With further development and improvement of the test it is probable that the predictive performance of the assay in identifying carcinogens should improve, since many of the false negative responses may be due to inadequate testing.

Long-term infertility and dominant lethal mutations in male mice treated with adriamycin

Sperm production and fertility were studied in male mice treated with adriamycin (ADR) at 6 or 8 mg/kg. Testicular sperm production and epididymal sperm counts were markedly reduced after ADR treatment. Gradual recovery of counts occurred, but sperm counts had not reached control levels even more than 1 year after treatment. Epididymal sperm showed treatment-induced morphological abnormalities throughout the experiment; the frequencies of sperm with detached tails and the frequencies of sperm with morphologically abnormal heads remained elevated about 2-3-fold above control. According to the frequency of vaginal plugs, treated male mice mated at control rates with untreated females during the post-treatment sterile period. However, after some fertility was regained the fertilization rate (calculated as the fraction of eggs, flushed from the oviduct 2 days after mating, that had been fertilized and had cleaved) was markedly reduced and remained depressed for the remainder of the experiment. The fertilization rate reached only 0.29 at 23-32 weeks after 8 mg/kg ADR and 0.76 at 16-23 weeks after 6 mg/kg ADR; both values were significantly below the control value of 0.94. Dominant lethal mutations in the zygotes flushed from the oviduct were measured in culture by the loss of the zygote's ability to develop to a stage characterized by trophectoderm outgrowths and formation of an inner cell mass. The frequencies of dominant lethal mutations detected in vitro were 1.7 or 7.4% after 6 mg/kg, and 32 or 40% after 8 mg/kg ADR; each value was calculated in two different ways, with 3 of these 4 values significantly different from zero. We conclude that even after mice regain fertility following ADR exposure, the level of fertility remains permanently subnormal as evidenced by a lack of fertilization of eggs that is probably due to the decreased quantity and quality of spermatozoa produced. Furthermore, ADR can induce genetic damage in stem spermatogonia, which can be transmitted through fertile spermatozoa. Thus, there may be a genetic risk to the offspring of cancer patients treated with ADR chemotherapy, but at present we are unable to quantitate that risk.

Tests for heritable genetic damage and for evidence of gonadal exposure in mammals

Tests for the induction of genetic damage in mammalian germ cells provide the data needed for human genetic risk assessment and are used as standards for judging the ability of shorter-term tests to predict genetic hazard. In this review, 15 mammalian germ-cell tests and their variants are described. These tests are of two general types: (a) those designed to detect certain classes of genetic damage (gene mutations, chromosome breakage and/or rearrangement, and chromosome mis-segregation), regardless of whether or not the endpoint scored has any significance to human health, and (b) those designed to detect phenotypes that have human health implications, while the nature of the genetic damage is not usually known. Exposure to a mutagenic agent presents no genetic hazard if the chemical or its metabolites fail to reach the reproductive cells. Tests for gonadal exposure are, therefore, important, as preliminaries or components of studies on germ-cell mutagenicity. Seven of these tests and their variants are briefly described in the second part of the paper.

DNA single-strand breaks, double-strand breaks, and crosslinks in rat testicular germ cells: measurements of their formation and repair by alkaline and neutral filter elution

This work describes a neutral and alkaline elution method for measuring DNA single-strand breaks (SSBs), DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs), and DNA-DNA crosslinks in rat testicular germ cells after treatments in vivo or in vitro with both chemical mutagens and gamma-irradiation. The methods depend upon the isolation of testicular germ cells by collagenase and trypsin digestion, followed by filtration and centrifugation. 137Cs irradiation induced both DNA SSBs and DSBs in germ cells held on ice in vitro. Irradiation of the whole animal indicated that both types of DNA breaks are induced in vivo and can be repaired. A number of germ cell mutagens induced either DNA SSBs, DSBs, or cross-links after in vivo and in vitro dosing. These chemicals included methyl methane sulfonate, ethyl methane sulfonate, ethyl nitrosurea, dibromochlorpropane, ethylene dibromide, triethylene melamine, and mitomycin C. These results suggest that the blood-testes barrier is relatively ineffective for these mutagens, which may explain in part their in vivo mutagenic potency. This assay should be a useful screen for detecting chemical attack upon male germ-cell DNA and thus, it should help in the assessment of the mutagenic risk of chemicals. In addition, this approach can be used to study the processes of SSB, DSB, and crosslink repair in DNA of male germ cells, either from all stages or specific stages of development.

Induction and manifestation of hereditary cataracts

A cataract is an opacity of the lens causing a reduction of visual function. The organogenesis of the lens in various mammals is similar. Therefore, a cataract mutation in mice can be directly compared with cataracts in man. Screening for dominant cataracts in mice was combined with the scoring of specific locus mutations. This combination increases the number of scorable loci, allows the comparison of unselected and selected loci and makes possible a systematic comparison of dominant and recessive mutations. In a combined experiment, dominant cataract and specific locus mutations were scored in the same offspring of mice after treatment of spermatogonia. In radiation experiments the induced frequency of dominant cataracts in spermatogonia was after single exposure 4.5 - 5.5 X 10(-5) mutations/gamete/Gy and for specific locus mutations 1.6 - 2.8 X 10(-5) mutations/locus/Gy. In experiments with ethylnitrosourea (ENU) the induced frequency of dominant cataracts was 0.7 - 1.3 X 10(-5) (mutations/gamete)/(mg ENU/kg body weight) and for specific locus mutations 2.6 - 3.3 X 10(-6) (mutations/locus)/(mg ENU/kg body weight). The radiation-induced mutation rate can be used for the direct estimation of the genetic risk in humans. The genetically significant population dose for 19 000 offspring in Hiroshima and Nagasaki was estimated to be 1.1 X 10(6) man-rem, absorbed at high dose rate. For the 19 000 offspring one would expect less than 1 radiation-induced dominant cataract and a total of 20 - 25 dominant mutations. If the number of dominant and recessive loci are equal one would expect in addition the induction of 250 recessive mutations in this population. Chemically induced dominant cataract mutations could be used to determine the allowable level of exposure for a single compound. The genetically characterized mutations will be an ideal source for studies in the field of developmental genetics. The investigation of alpha-, beta-, and gamma-crystallins by electrophoretic methods, the activity determinations of enzymes and the systematic use of cDNA hybridization may lead to an understanding of the genesis of dominant cataracts in mice and man.

The use of sister-chromatid exchange in Chinese hamster primary lung cell cultures to measure genotoxicity

Primary cell cultures derived from Chinese hamster lung (CHL) were established, and their response for the induction of sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) by direct- and indirect-acting mutagens was characterized. An increase in SCE frequency was induced in CHL cells by 3-methylcholanthrene (MCA), benzo[a]pyrene (BaP), and 2-aminoanthracene (2AA). The SCE frequency increased slightly after exposure to cyclophosphamide, but did not respond to the hepatocarcinogen dimethylnitrosamine (DMN). A slight increase in SCE frequency by DMN was observed in the CHL system with use of Aroclor-1254-induced rat liver homogenate fraction (S9). This response to DMN in CHL cells was lower than that seen when CHO cells were the target in the presence of S9. At low (1) and high (20) passages, the CHL cells responded with a similar dose-related increase in SCE frequency to direct- (ethyl methanesulfonate, EMS) and indirect-(MCA) acting mutagens. This response indicates that even after prolonged culturing in vitro, the cells retained the ability to metabolically activate xenobiotic promutagens. The induction of SCE by MCA occurred at concentrations that also induced macromolecular binding. SCE induction was also examined in primary lung cell cultures from animals exposed by nose-only inhalation to MCA aerosol. A significant increase in SCE frequency above controls was observed in cells from animals after a single exposure to MCA. No detectable increase in SCE frequency was observed after repeated inhalation exposures. Because CHL cells are of lung origin and showed metabolic activity, the CHL system appears to be appropriate for study of the genotoxic potential of inhaled compounds.

Comparison of types of chemically induced genetic changes in mammals

The present paper reviews the currently available in vivo systems for detection of chemically induced mutations and chromosome aberrations and summarizes the data of the relevant tests for mammalian germ-cell mutations (specific-locus test and heritable translocation test). The value of in vivo screening tests (somatic mutations and sperm abnormalities) for predicting specific-locus mutations is illustrated by comparing doubling doses. The results from the mammalian germ-cell mutation tests (specific-locus test and heritable translocation test) constitute the base-line for an assessment of predictability. Radiation and chemically induced specific-locus mutations differ in a number of respects, suggesting a need for caution in making risk estimates for chemical mutagen exposures in terms of radiation-equivalent doses. In vivo nondisjunction tests are discussed. Finally, unsolved problems and difficulties in generalizing qualitative and quantitative correlations between test systems are outlined. It is concluded that even qualitative predictions from data on somatic cells to germ cells are at best insecure because germ-cell specificity cannot be foretold, not to mention the fact that quantitative extrapolations from the results of in vivo screening tests, in general, are fraught with even more uncertainties. There is an acute need for collection of more data from studies involving germ cells.

The unique role of rodents in the detection of possible human carcinogens and mutagens

Some of the probable reasons underlying the observation that not all chemicals shown to be genotoxic in vitro are capable of eliciting tumours in rodents or humans are discussed using appropriate examples. It is suggested that a substantial proportion of the resources currently available for conducting rodent carcinogenicity bioassays should be employed in the short-term evaluation in vivo of some of the many hundreds of chemicals recently defined as genotoxic in vitro, rather than in the protracted evaluation of a few chemicals, often of unknown activity in vitro, for carcinogenicity. A decision tree approach to the evaluation of chemicals for human mutagenic/carcinogenic potential is presented which is at variance with the construction and philosophy of many of the current legislative guidelines. The immediate need for the adoption of one of the available short-term in vivo liver assays, and/or the development of a short-term in vivo rodent assay capable of concomitantly monitoring different genetic end-points in a range of organs or tissues is emphasized.

The detection of viable heritable translocations by chromosome banding procedures

Ethyl methanesulfonate was tested for its ability to induce viable heritable translocations in progeny of male rats given a single IP injection prior to breeding. Reproductively competent Wistar rats were used as the test animals. Males were treated with either 75 or 150 mg/kg EMS or vehicle control. Neonates were used for primary tissue culture; the fibroblasts were harvested for cytogenetic analysis of chromosomes banded by Giemsa banding procedures. Since the cells examined were somatic cells, it was necessary to karyotype only two to three per neonate to ascertain inherited translocations. A reduction in fertility was observed in males treated with EMS. A statistically significant (p less than 0.05) dose-related increase in heritable translocations was observed in the F1 generation of treated animals.

Analysis of results from a collaborative study of the dominant lethal assay

A dominant lethal (DL) mutation is a genetic change that results in the death of the conceptus that inherits it. The assay is normally carried out in mice and the production of DL mutation by the test chemical is characterised by an increase in non-viable embryos. A distinct advantage of the DL assay is that it is an in vivo, mammalian, germ cell assay and is therefore pertinent to the fundamental question of chemical mutagenesis, i.e.: is a chemical likely to produce genetic changes that can be transferred to the offspring? The two principal criticisms of the assay are that the main type of genetic damage it detects is chromosomal breakage that leads to death of the conceptus, and that the assay is considered to be relatively insensitive. The Association of the British Pharmaceutical Industry (ABPI) Working Party on Mutagenicity was established in 1974. Its principal objective was to consider the problem of mutagenicity and associated matters in relation to the development of new medicines and to make recommendations and proposals for collaborative work if indicated. The dominant lethal assay is one of several tests for mutagenicity chosen for evaluation by collaborative study. The objective of the collaborative study was to gain more information about the validity and dependability of the dominant lethal assay. The present report concerns an analysis of the differences between compounds, laboratories and statistical methods utilising the data from the collaborative study.

Dominant cataract mutations and specific-locus mutations in mice induced by radiation or ethylnitrosourea

In a combined experiment, dominant cataract mutations and specific-locus mutations were scored in the same offspring. In radiation experiments, a total of 15 dominant cataract and 38 specific-locus mutations was scored in 29396 offspring. In experiments with ethylnitrosourea (ENU), a total of 12 dominant cataracts and 54 specific-locus mutations was observed in 12712 offspring. The control frequency for dominant cataracts was 0 in 9954 offspring and for specific-locus mutations 11 in 169955 offspring. The ratio of radiation-induced recessive visible to dominant mutations was about 2.5:1. The difference was even more pronounced for ENU-induced mutations. The ratio of recessive visibles to dominant cataracts for chemically induced mutations in spermatogonia was about 5.4:1. The two characteristic features of radiation-induced specific-locus mutations--the augmenting effect of dose fractionation and the quantitative differences in the mutation rates between spermatogonial and post-spermatogonial stages--can also be demonstrated for the induction of dominant cataracts. The dominant cataract mutations recovered can be categorized into 7 phenotypic classes: total opacity, nuclear and zonular cataract, nuclear cataract, anterior pyramidal cataract, anterior polar cataract, anterior capsular cataract, and vacuolated lens. The largest class of mutations, a total of 11, affected the anterior polar region, while the number of total opacities in both experiments was 5. The only noteworthy difference observed between the radiation- and ENU-induced mutations recovered was that, of the 2 radiation-induced total lens opacities, both were associated with an iris anomaly and microphthalmia whereas the ENU-induced total opacities were not.

The mouse specific-locus test with agents other than radiations: interpretation of data and recommendations for future work

The mouse specific-locus test with visible markers (SLT) has been the only extensively used method for detecting and quantifying the induction of heritable point mutations (intragenic changes and small deficiencies) in mammals. Mutations are detected in first-generation offspring; and scoring is simple, objective, and rapid. Different germ-cell stages can be sampled, including those of greatest pertinence for genetic risk assessment. The differential probability of involving the various loci of the marked set makes the method capable of detecting qualitative (as well as quantitative) differences between the actions of mutagens. Control SLT frequencies for males reported by 4 sets of investigators are in excellent agreement and were summed as a "historical control" (801406 observations) for use in our calculations. Experimental results were classified as positive, negative, or inconclusive based upon a multiple-decision procedure produced by the testing of the following 2 hypotheses: (1) the mutation frequency (induced + spontaneous) of treated mice is not higher than the spontaneous mutation frequency, and (2) the induced mutation frequency of treated mice is no less than 4 times the historical-control mutation frequency. Each hypothesis was tested at the 5% significance level. Because of the low mutation frequency in a very large control, the SLT is capable of yielding positive results in relatively small samples. We reviewed 58 publications, SLT results have been reported for 25 chemical agents, of which 17 (representing 21 chemical classes) gave results that were positive or negative by our criteria. The frequency of positive agents was 6 of 14, 5 of 5, and 0 of 1 conclusively tested, respectively, in spermatogonia, post-spermatogonial stages, and unspecified male germ cells. Depending on the chemical used, post-spermatogonial stages can be of greater, less, or equal sensitivity relative to spermatogonia. The SLT was strongly positive for some chemicals that are not mutagenic (or only weakly so) in lower systems, and there are several examples of the reverse situation. Factors which presumably operated to cause these differences (e.g., metabolism, transport, repair in germ cells) are likely also to operate for transmitted point mutations in man.