Control of cell number in the developing visual system. II. Effects of partial tectal ablation

Dynamic Alterations of Retinal EphA5 Expression in Retinocollicular Map Plasticity

The topographically ordered retinocollicular projection is an excellent system for studying the mechanism of axon guidance. Gradients of EphA receptors in the retina and ephrin-As in the superior colliculus (SC) pattern the anteroposterior axis of the retinocollicular map, but whether they are involved in map plasticity after injury is unknown. Partial damage to the caudal SC at birth creates a compressed, complete retinotopic map in the remaining SC without affecting visual response properties. Previously, we found that the gradient of ephrin-A expression in compressed maps is steeper than normal, suggesting an instructive role in compression. Here we measured EphA5 mRNA and protein levels after caudal SC damage in order to test the hypothesis that changes in retinal EphA5 expression occur that are complementary to the changes in collicular ephrin-A expression. We find that the nasotemporal gradient of EphA5 receptor expression steepens in the retina and overall expression levels change dynamically, especially in temporal retina, supporting the hypothesis. This change in receptor expression occurs after the change in ephrin-A ligand expression. We propose that changes in the retinal EphA5 gradient guide recovery of the retinocollicular projection from early injury. This could occur directly through the change in EphA5 expression instructing retino-SC map compression, or through ephrin-A ligand signaling instructing a change in EphA5 receptor expression that in turn signals the retinocollicular map to compress. Understanding what molecular signals direct compensation for injury is essential to developing rehabilitative strategies and maximizing the potential for recovery.

The Impact of Ecological Niche on Adaptive Flexibility of Sensory Circuitry

Evolution and development are interdependent, particularly with regard to the construction of the nervous system and its position as the machine that produces behavior. On the one hand, the processes directing development and plasticity of the brain provide avenues through which natural selection can sculpt neural cell fate and connectivity, and on the other hand, they are themselves subject to selection pressure. For example, mutations that produce heritable perturbations in neuronal birth and death rates, transcription factor expression, or availability of axon guidance factors within sensory pathways can markedly affect the development of form and thus the function of stimulus decoding circuitry. This evolvability of flexible circuits makes them more adaptable to environmental variation. Although there is general agreement on this point, whether the sensitivity of circuits to environmental influence and the mechanisms underlying development and plasticity of sensory pathways are similar across species from different ecological niches has received almost no attention. Neural circuits are generally more sensitive to environmental influences during an early critical period, but not all niches afford the same access to stimuli in early life. Furthermore, depending on predictability of the habitat and ecological niche, sensory coding circuits might be more susceptible to sensory experience in some species than in others. Despite decades of work on understanding the mechanisms underlying critical period plasticity, the importance of ecological niche in visual pathway development has received little attention. Here, I will explore the relationship between critical period plasticity and ecological niche in mammalian sensory pathways.

Loss of AP-2delta reduces retinal ganglion cell numbers and axonal projections to the superior colliculus

Background

AP-2δ is the most divergent member of the Activating Protein-2 (TFAP2) family of transcription factors. AP-2δ is restricted to specific regions of the CNS, including a subset of ganglion cells in the retina. Retinal ganglion cells (RGCs), the only output neurons of the retina, are responsible for transmitting the visual signal to the brain.

Results

AP-2δ knockout results in loss of Brn3c (Pou4f3) expression in AP-2δ -positive RGCs. While AP-2δ-/- mice have morphologically normal retinas at birth, there is a significant reduction in retinal ganglion cell numbers by P21, after eye opening. Chromatin immunoprecipitation indicates that Brn3c is a target of AP-2δ in the retina. Using fluorochrome-conjugated cholera toxin subunit B to trace ganglion cell axons from the eye to the major visual pathways in the brain, we found 87 % and 32 % decreases in ipsilateral and contralateral projections, respectively, to the superior colliculus in AP-2δ-/- mice. In agreement with anatomical data, visually evoked responses recorded from the brain confirmed that retinal outputs to the brain are compromised.

Conclusions

AP-2δ is important for the maintenance of ganglion cell numbers in the retina. Loss of AP-2δ alters retinal axonal projections to visual centers of the brain, with ipsilaterial projections to the superior colliculus being the most dramatically affected. Our results have important implications for integration of the visual signal at the superior colliculus.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s13041-016-0244-0) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Regulation of ephrin-A expression in compressed retinocollicular maps

Retinotopic maps can undergo compression and expansion in response to changes in target size, but the mechanism underlying this compensatory process has remained a mystery. The discovery of ephrins as molecular mediators of Sperry's chemoaffinity process allows a mechanistic approach to this important issue. In Syrian hamsters, neonatal, partial (PT) ablation of posterior superior colliculus (SC) leads to compression of the retinotopic map, independent of neural activity. Graded, repulsive EphA receptor/ephrin-A ligand interactions direct the formation of the retinocollicular map, but whether ephrins might also be involved in map compression is unknown. To examine whether map compression might be directed by changes in the ephrin expression pattern, we compared ephrin-A2 and ephrin-A5 mRNA expression between normal SC and PT SC using in situ hybridization and quantitative real-time PCR. We found that ephrin-A ligand expression in the compressed maps was low anteriorly and high posteriorly, as in normal animals. Consistent with our hypothesis, the steepness of the ephrin gradient increased in the lesioned colliculi. Interestingly, overall levels of ephrin-A2 and -A5 expression declined immediately after neonatal target damage, perhaps promoting axon outgrowth. These data establish a correlation between changes in ephrin-A gradients and map compression, and suggest that ephrin-A expression gradients may be regulated by target size. This in turn could lead to compression of the retinocollicular map onto the reduced target. These findings have important implications for mechanisms of recovery from traumatic brain injury.

Modeling activity and target-dependent developmental cell death of mouse retinal ganglion cells ex vivo

Programmed cell death is widespread during the development of the central nervous system and serves multiple purposes including the establishment of neural connections. In the mouse retina a substantial reduction of retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) occurs during the first postnatal week, coinciding with the formation of retinotopic maps in the superior colliculus (SC). We previously established a retino-collicular culture preparation which recapitulates the progressive topographic ordering of RGC projections during early post-natal life. Here, we questioned whether this model could also be suitable to examine the mechanisms underlying developmental cell death of RGCs. Brn3a was used as a marker of the RGCs. A developmental decline in the number of Brn3a-immunolabelled neurons was found in the retinal explant with a timing that paralleled that observed in vivo. In contrast, the density of photoreceptors or of starburst amacrine cells increased, mimicking the evolution of these cell populations in vivo. Blockade of neural activity with tetrodotoxin increased the number of surviving Brn3a-labelled neurons in the retinal explant, as did the increase in target availability when one retinal explant was confronted with 2 or 4 collicular slices. Thus, this ex vivo model reproduces the developmental reduction of RGCs and recapitulates its regulation by neural activity and target availability. It therefore offers a simple way to analyze developmental cell death in this classic system. Using this model, we show that ephrin-A signaling does not participate to the regulation of the Brn3a population size in the retina, indicating that eprhin-A-mediated elimination of exuberant projections does not involve developmental cell death.

Compensatory and transneuronal plasticity after early collicular ablation

Plasticity within the visual system was assessed in the quokka wallaby following unilateral superior collicular (SC) ablation at postnatal days (P) 8-10, prior to the arrival of retinal ganglion cell (RGC) axons. At maturity (P100), projections were traced from the eye opposite the ablation, and total RGC numbers were estimated for both eyes. Ablations were partial (28-89% of SC remaining) or complete (0-5% of SC remaining). Projections to the visual centers showed significant bilateral (P < 0.05) increases in absolute volume. Minor anomalous projections also formed within the deep, surviving non-retino-recipient layers of the ablated SC and via a small bundle of RGC axons recrossing the midline to innervate discrete patches in the SC contralateral to the lesion. Total absolute volume of projections did not differ between partial and complete ablations; moreover, values did not differ from normal (P > 0.05). Compared with normal, total RGC numbers were significantly (P < 0.05) reduced in the eye opposite the ablation but increased (P < 0.05) in the other eye. Consequently, the sum of the two RGC populations did not differ from normal (P > 0.05). As in rodents, the visual system in quokka compensates following injury by maintaining a set volume of arborization but does so by forming only minor anomalous projections. Furthermore, increased RGC numbers in the eye ipsilateral to the lesion indicate that compensation occurs transneuronally, thus maintaining total numbers of projecting neurons. The implication is that the visual system acts in concert following unilateral injury to maintain set values for RGC terminal arbors as well as their cell bodies.

Two phases of increased cell death in the inner retina following early elimination of the ganglion cell population

Neurons in the inner nuclear layer (INL) of the vertebrate retina undergo considerable programmed cell death during development, but the determinants of this cell death remain largely unknown. The present study examines the role of retinal ganglion cells in support of INL neurons in the developing ferret retina. The retinal ganglion cell population was eliminated by optic nerve transection at postnatal day (P) 2, and the incidence of cell death was examined using terminal deoxytransferase dUTP nick-end labelling (TUNEL) at various ages during the first 3 postnatal weeks. Significant increases in TUNEL-positive cells were observed in the neuroblast layer (NBL) as early as P3, prior to synapse formation within the inner plexiform layer (IPL), and again in the INL at P22, the normal peak of naturally occurring cell death within the ferret's INL. A decrease in TUNEL-positive cells was found in the NBL at P8. These results show three phases of response to the loss of retinal ganglion cells and suggest that cells in the NBL/INL are normally dependent on retinal ganglion cells for their survival. Recent studies have shown that certain populations of retinal neurons are reduced in adult animals that had lost the population of ganglion cells during early development, so the present study also examined when this reduction could first be detected. The number of parvalbumin-immunoreactive amacrine cells was decreased significantly in the NBL of the manipulated eye as early as P8, when we could first label this population, and this difference persisted through adulthood. The fact that cell death in the NBL has already increased within 24 hours of ganglion cell elimination, coupled with the specificity of this effect on the adult complement of INL cell types, shows that cell-cell interactions controlling survival are already highly specific for particular types of retinal neuron early in development

What do developmental mapping rules optimize?

Convergence ratios between pre- and postsynaptic cells in the visual system vary widely between cell classes, areas of the visual field, between individuals and between species. Proper stabilization of the convergence and divergence of single visual neurons is critical for visual integration generally, and for specific functions such as those of rod and cone pathways, or the center and peripheral regions of the visual field. In early development, retinal ganglion cells, target cells and all their processes are produced in excess and stabilize at certain mature values. The intent of the investigations described here is to determine what features of cell connectivity are stabilized over normal variability by these developmental processes and how such stabilization is accomplished, using the developing mammalian retinotectal system as an example. Orderly compression of the retinotopic map into a half tectum was induced by a partial tectal ablation at birth in hamsters, increasing the ratio of retinal ganglion cells to superior colliculus target cells. The convergence problem is solved in this case by undersampling the spatial array with respect to normal, preserving local spatial resolution, but potentially reducing sensitivity or introducing aliasing artifacts. Receptive field sizes of single neurons are indistinguishable from normal, and reduction of branching of presynaptic axon arbors is the mechanism of the remapping. Behaviorally, though the entire visual field is still represented in the remaining colliculus, the solution has a cost in decreased probability and increased latency to orient to visual stimuli, particularly in the peripheral visual field. The generality of this solution for retinal and other central convergence regulation problems is evaluated.

Intrinsic changes in developing retinal neurons result in regenerative failure of their axons

The failure of mature mammalian central nervous system axons to regenerate after transection is usually attributed to influences of the extraneuronal milieu. Using explant cocultures of retina and midbrain tectum from hamsters, we have found evidence that these influences account for failure of regrowth of only a small minority of retinal axons. For most of the axons, there is a programmed loss of ability to elongate in the central nervous system. We show that there is a precipitous decline in the ability of retinal axons to reinnervate tectal targets when the retina is derived from pups on or after postnatal day 2, even when the target is embryonic. By contrast, embryonic retinal axons can regrow into tectum of any age, overcoming growth-inhibiting influences of glial factors.

Regulation of retinal ganglion cell axon arbor size by target availability: mechanisms of compression and expansion of the retinotectal projection

The ability of pre- and postsynaptic populations to achieve the proper convergence ratios during development is especially critical in topographically mapped systems such as the retinotectal system. The ratio of retinal ganglion cells to their target cells in the optic tectum can be altered experimentally either by early partial tectal ablation, which results in an orderly compression of near-normal numbers of retinal projections into a smaller tectal area, or by early monocular enucleation, which results in the expansion of a reduced number of axons in a near-normal tectal volume. Our previous studies showed that changes in cell death and synaptic density consequent to these manipulations can account for only a minor component of this compensation for the population mismatch. In this study, we examine other mechanisms of population matching in the hamster retinotectal system. We used an in vitro horseradish peroxidase labeling method to trace individual retinal ganglion cell axons in superior colliculi partially ablated on the day of birth, as well as in colliculi contralateral to a monocular enucleation. We found that individual axon arbors within the partially lesioned tectum occupy a smaller area, with fewer branches and fewer terminal boutons, but preserve a normal bouton density. In contrast, ipsilaterally projecting axon arbors in monocularly enucleated animals occupy a greater area than in the normal condition, with a much larger arbor length and greater number of boutons and branches compared with normal ipsilaterally projecting cells. Alteration of axonal arborization of retinal ganglion cells is the main factor responsible for matching the retinal and tectal cell populations within the tectum. This process conserves normal electrophysiological function over a wide range of convergence ratios and may occur through strict selectivity of tectal cells for their normal number of inputs.

Changes in synaptic density after developmental compression or expansion of retinal input to the superior colliculus

The retinal projection to the superior colliculus can be made abnormally dense by inducing a "compressed" retinal projection into a subnormal tectal volume, or abnormally sparse by monocular enucleation early in development. Any or all of the features of cell number, axonal arbor, dendritic arbor, and synaptic density could potentially be adjusted to compensate for such variations in the convergence of one cell population on another. We have examined the consequences of neonatal partial tectal ablation or monocular enucleation for synaptic length, density, and relative numbers of synapse classes in the superficial gray layer of the hamster superior colliculus. Monocular enucleation resulted in a reduction of synaptic density in the superficial gray layer of the colliculus ipsilateral to the remaining eye. This decrease in density was entirely accounted for by a reduction of the number of synapses with round vesicles, large asymmetric terminal specializations, and pale mitochondria characteristic of retinocollicular terminals (RLP synapses). There was no compensatory increase in any other synaptic class. RLP synapses were larger in monocular enucleates. Partial tectal ablation had no effect on synaptic density, nor on the relative proportions of different synaptic types. Synapses of the RLP class were slightly smaller than normal. These results suggest that synaptic density is normally at a maximum that cannot be altered by increases in potential input. However, density may be reduced by decreasing the number of inputs. Terminal classes do not appear to compete with each other within the collicular volume, suggesting that postsynaptic cells controls both the classes and numbers of their potential inputs.

Cell death and the creation of regional differences in neuronal numbers

Regional variations in cell death are ubiquitous in the nervous system. In the retina, cell death in retinal ganglion cells is elevated in the retinal periphery and may be important in setting up the initial conditions that produce central retinal specializations such as an area centralis or visual streak. In central visual system structures, pronounced spatial and spatiotemporal inhomogeneities in cell death are seen both in layers and regions of the lateral geniculate nucleus and superior colliculus; similar indications of inhomogeneities are seen in those nonvisual structures that have been examined. Cell death in the cortex is highly nonuniform, by layer and by cortical area. A variety of possible functions for these regional losses are proposed, in the context of a uniform mechanism for cell death that allows it to assume multiple functions.

Compensation for population size mismatches in the hamster retinotectal system: alterations in the organization of retinal projections

Unilateral partial ablation of the superior colliculus in the hamster results in a compression of the retinotopic map onto the remaining tectal fragment. In a previous electrophysiological study (Pallas & Finlay, 1989a), we demonstrated that receptive-field properties of single tectal units (including receptive-field size) remain unchanged, despite the increased afferent/target convergence ratios in the compressed tecta. The present study was done to investigate the mechanism that produces increased convergence from retina to tectum at the population level while maintaining apparent stability of convergence at the single neuron level. We injected comparable quantities of horseradish peroxidase into the tecta of normal adult hamsters and adult hamsters that had received neonatal partial tectal ablations of varying magnitude. We then compared the area of retina backfilled from the injection and the number and density of labeled retinal ganglion cells within it to the size of the remaining tectal fragment. As expected from earlier anatomical (Jhaveri & Schneider, 1974) and physiological (Finlay et al., 1979a; Pallas & Finlay, 1989a) studies demonstrating compression of the retinotectal projection, we found that the area of retina labeled from a single tectal injection site increases linearly with decreasing tectal fragment size. However, for fragment sizes down to 30% of normal, total number of retinal ganglion cells projecting to the injection site remains in or above the normal range. For large lesions (less than 30% of tectum remaining), total number of labeled retinal ganglion cells declines from normal, despite the fact that a larger absolute area of retina is represented on each unit of tectum under these conditions. Comparison of retinal ganglion cell density with tectal fragment size shows an initial decline with decreasing fragment size, which becomes sharper with very large lesions (small tectal fragments). The maintenance of the normal number of retinal ganglion cells innervating each patch of tectum could be accomplished by an elimination of the tectal collaterals of some retinal ganglion cells. Our results suggest that, in addition to collateral elimination, reduction in the size of ganglion cell arbors is occurring, since the peak density of backfilled ganglion cells declines less rapidly than backfilled retinal area increases, especially for small lesions. However, arbor reduction and collateral elimination must occur in such a way that individual tectal cells represent the same amount of visual space as normal. Thus, collateral elimination and arbor reduction are two mechanisms that operate to maintain afferent/target convergence ratios (and thus receptive-field properties) over large variations in afferent availability.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Ontogenesis of neocortical asymmetry: a [3H]thymidine study

Previous research has demonstrated that symmetric regions in one brain are, on the whole, larger than their asymmetric counterparts in another brain, and that side differences in the volumes of homologous architectonic areas are the result of a decrease in neuronal number in the smaller of the two areas. Therefore, understanding mechanisms by which neuronal numbers are regulated during development may be essential to the investigation of the ontogeny of asymmetry. The radial unit hypothesis of Rakic postulates four factors that determine the number of neurons within a neocortical region: (i) early progenitor cell division; (ii) late cell division; (iii) the effect of thalamocortical and corticocortical afferents, which govern, in part, boundary placement; and (iv) ontogenetic cell death. We report here on experiments that address the development of anatomical asymmetry in the light of this hypothesis. Pregnant Wistar rats were injected with [3H]thymidine on several dates during embryogenesis and their pups killed at several postnatal ages. An estimate of the total number of neurons contained within area 17 and area 18a of each hemisphere was determined and the percentage of those which were labeled was calculated. There were no side differences in this measure between either symmetric or asymmetric architectonic areas although there were consistent differences between areas 17 and 18a. This indicated that while late neuroblast division may be important for cytoarchitectonic differentiation, it may play little or no role in interhemispheric asymmetry.

Conservation of receptive-field properties of superior colliculus cells after developmental rearrangements of retinal input

The formation of topographic maps requires not only that afferents synapse with the appropriate targets, but that the spatial relationships between the afferents be maintained. During development, in addition to the formation of the topographic map, the connectivity patterns responsible for the receptive-field properties of the target cells are being formed. The extent of interaction between these two processes is unknown. The present study addresses this question by manipulating afferent/target ratios during development, thus altering the topography of the map, and studying the effects of this alteration on the receptive-field properties of single target cells in the adult. Partial unilateral lesions of the superior colliculus (SC) were made in neonatal hamsters. These lesions result in a compression of the retinotopic map onto the remaining collicular fragment. Single cells were recorded from the superficial gray layer of the SC in the adult in response to visual stimuli. Receptive-field properties observed in lesioned animals were compared to those in normal animals and in sham operates. Receptive-field properties were largely unaffected by the change in the topographic map. There was no difference in the receptive-field size of single tectal cells of lesioned and unlesioned animals. Stimulus velocity and stimulus size tuning functions remained the same. This raises the possibility that, rather than the expected increase in convergence of retinal ganglion cells (RGC) onto single collicular cells, single SC cells receive input from ganglion cells representing the same amount of retinal area as in unlesioned animals. The excess ganglion cells created by the partial target removal would then project elsewhere and/or reduce their arbor within the SC. Regardless of the mechanism, it is clear from our results that circuitry in the retinotectal system of the hamster can compensate for conditions of increased afferent availability and thus maintain receptive-field properties.

Number of neurons in individual laminae of areas 3B, 4 gamma, and 6a alpha of the cat cerebral cortex: a comparison with major visual areas

The number of neurons per mm3 of tissue (number per volume) and the number under 1 mm2 of cortical surface (number per column) have been estimated for each lamina of seven cytoarchitectural areas of the cat cortex by using a method of size frequency distribution. The areas studied consisted of four visual areas (the binocular and monocular portions of area 17: 17B and 17M; area 18; and the posteromedial lateral suprasylvian area: PMLS), a somatosensory area (3B), and two motor areas (4 gamma and 6a alpha). For both series of measurements, significant differences could be demonstrated among the seven areas studied (one-way ANOVA; P less than .001). The number of neurons per volume in the binocular and monocular regions of area 17 (approximately 49,000/mm3) is 85% greater than that of each of the other regions (approximately 27,000) with a P less than .01 on an a posteriori Tukey test, but there are no significant differences between the latter areas. The number of neurons per column is greater in the binocular portion of area 17 (78,000 under 1 mm2 of cortical surface) than in any other area (P less than .01). Other sensory areas (17M, 18, PMLS, and 3B) have fewer neurons per column (P less than .01) and the numbers do not vary significantly between these regions (range from 56,100 to 61,900). Areas 4 gamma and 6a alpha have still fewer neurons (approximately 44,000; P less than .01, except P less than .05 when compared to PMLS). Thus, the seven areas studied fall under three different categories. Motor areas have the smallest number of neurons per column, sensory areas have more, and the greatest number is found in the binocular region of area 17. It appears that these differences are principally (but not exclusively) due to variations in the number of neurons in layer IV: These variations are largely responsible for the differences that we have found between the binocular portion of area 17 and other sensory areas as well as between the latter and motor areas. We thus cannot confirm the view of Rockel et al. (Brain 103:221-244, '80) that there is a basic uniformity of the number of neurons per unit of cortical surface in different cortical areas of the cat.

Cotransplantation of embryonic mouse retina with tectum, diencephalon, or cortex to neonatal rat cortex

Retinae from embryonic mice were transplanted to the occipital cortex of neonatal rats together with their normal target regions, tectum or diencephalon, from embryonic mice or rats. In control experiments, retinae were cotransplanted with embryonic rat occipital cortex. In over 80% of the experimental animals, both transplants differentiated and grew. Ganglion cells in the retinae cotransplanted close to tectum or diencephalon survived for at least 15 weeks. Their survival was associated with the development of a distinct optic fiber layer and outgrowth of axons from the transplanted mouse retina. Specific innervation of distinct patches within the cotransplanted rat tectum or diencephalon was demonstrated by the use of an anti-mouse antibody. The innervated regions, which could be as far away as 1.3 mm from the retinae, were correlated with cytological features of the cotransplanted tectum or diencephalon. By contrast, the host cortex was never innervated by the transplanted retinae. In the control animals in which the retinae were cotransplanted with occipital cortex and in four animals in which the cotransplants lay more than 2.7 mm apart, no ganglion cells were identified and there was no evidence of an optic fiber layer, outgrowth of axons, or innervation. These results support the idea that in order to survive, retinal ganglion cells need to innervate an appropriate target region. Further, the specific innervation of regions within the cotransplanted tectum or diencephalon suggests that these target regions are able to exert a tropic influence on the axons of retinal ganglion cells, even in the absence of many of the normal structure cues.

Control of cell number in the developing visual system. III. Effects of visual cortex ablation

The effect of unilateral deletion of the visual cortex on early cell death and eventual cell number in various structures of the visual system was examined. At minimum, this manipulation potentially provides excess retinal afference to the superior colliculi, partially denervates the superior colliculi, reduces normal retinal terminal area and opens up potential target space for the retina and superior colliculus in those areas where they share terminal space with the visual cortex. All layers of the superior colliculus, bilaterally, showed an initial decrease in the rate of cell death relative to normal followed by an increase in cell death rates. No change in the number or distribution of cells in the retinal ganglion cell layer resulted despite a substantial loss of retinal terminal area, and a substantial alteration of the pattern of retinal central termination. These results are interpreted as evidence for two stages in normally occurring cell death, a first in which axons compete to colonize any available terminal space, and a second in which axon-to-target specificity must be matched. These results also provide evidence that the amount of target required for neuron survival is clearly variable.