Absence of natural killer (NK) cell activity against oligodendrocytes in multiple sclerosis

Human NK cells kill resting but not activated microglia via NKG2D- and NKp46-mediated recognition

Microglia are resident macrophage-like APCs of the CNS. To avoid escalation of inflammatory processes and bystander damage within the CNS, microglia-driven inflammatory responses need to be tightly regulated and both spatially and temporally restricted. Following traumatic, infectious, and autoimmune-mediated brain injury, NK cells have been found in the CNS, but the functional significance of NK cell recruitment and their mechanisms of action during brain inflammation are not well understood. In this study, we investigated whether and by which mechanisms human NK cells might edit resting and activated human microglial cells via killing in vitro. IL-2-activated NK cells efficiently killed both resting allogeneic and autologous microglia in a cell-contact-dependent manner. Activated NK cells rapidly formed synapses with human microglial cells in which perforin had been polarized to the cellular interface. Ab-mediated NKG2D and NKp46 blockade completely prevented the killing of human microglia by activated NK cells. Up-regulation of MHC class I surface expression by TLR4 stimulation protected microglia from NK cell-mediated killing, whereas MHC class I blockade enhanced cytotoxic NK cell activity. These data suggest that brain-infiltrating NK cells might restrict innate and adaptive immune responses within the human CNS via elimination of resting microglia.

The role of natural killer cells in curbing neuroinflammation

Natural killer (NK) cells are evolutionarily early lymphocytes that lack antigen-specific receptors and, hence, are considered to be part of the innate immune system. The majority of research on NK cells has focused on their ability to lyse "target cells", generally identified by low or absent MHC Class I expression, such as tumor cells and virus infected cells. However, an alternative role of these leukocytes as regulators of adaptive (and potentially destructive) immune responses, in particular organ-specific autoimmune diseases, has been increasingly recognized. Here we discuss the growing body of evidence that NK cells limit damage in autoimmune demyelinating disease by inhibiting autoreactive T cell responses without harming resident neurons or glia.

NK cell-mediated lysis of autologous human oligodendrocytes

Although considered an autoimmune disease, the mechanisms underlying oligodendrocyte (OL)/myelin injury in multiple sclerosis (MS) remain to be established. We utilized in vitro assays to demonstrate that human OLs, as well as other glial elements (astrocytes, microglia), were susceptible to injury mediated by peripheral blood-derived mononuclear cell preparations (MNCs) enriched for natural killer (NK cells) by depleting CD3(+) +/- CD19(+) cells through use of either magnetic beads or cell sorting. Cytotoxic effects of the NK cell-enriched effectors were dependent on pre-exposure of these cells to IL-2. Furthermore, we found that autologous OLs were as susceptible to injury mediated by IL-2 activated NK cells as were heterologous OLs. In context of the tissue injury that occurs in MS, our results suggest that the inflammatory milieu in MS lesions could provide conditions required for NK cell activation and that such effector cells can bypass the putative protective effects of self-MHC class I molecules that may be expressed on OLs.

A role for natural killer cells in the immunopathogenesis of multiple sclerosis

Seventeen relapsing-remitting (R/R) multiple sclerosis (MS) patients and age/sex matched controls were studied every 6 weeks for 2 years. Disease activity, determined both clinically and by serial MRI, was correlated with natural killer (NK) cell functional activity (FA) and phenotype. Mean NK cell FA is significantly lower in MS patients, compared to controls (P < 0.001), while variability around the means is significantly greater (P < 0.01). The spectrum of mean NK cell FA, observed in the patient cohort, along with cyclical nature of the FA and phenotype over time, observed in both patients and controls, may begin to explain the discrepant results reported in previous studies. In R/R MS, there is a significant correlation between reductions (valleys) in NK cell FA and the development of active lesions on MRI, new (P < 0.001) or enlarging (P = 0.05). More importantly, a significant number of active lesions, new (P = 0.01) and enlarging (P = 0.02), are preceded by a reduction in NK cell FA. The correlation between the onset of clinical attacks and valleys of NK cell FA is also significant (P = 0.002). When taken together, the results suggest that reductions (valleys) in NK cell FA represent periods of susceptibility for the development of active lesions on MRI and clinical attacks. A significant positive correlation is also identified between mean NK cell FA for each R/R MS patient and total number of active MRI lesions developed by that patient over the 2 years (P = 0.001). The results would suggest that R/R MS patients with a higher mean NK cell FA are at greater risk for the development of active lesions. These results support the proposal that NK cells may play a role in the immunopathogenesis of R/R MS.

Non-MHC-Restricted Cell-Mediated Lysis of Human Oligodendrocytes In Vitro: Relation with CD56 Expression

Oligodendrocytes and their myelin membranes are the apparent target of the autoimmune response that characterizes the human adult central nervous system-demyelinating disease multiple sclerosis. Human oligodendrocytes do not express MHC class II molecules, a requirement for MHC-restricted injury mediated by myelin-reactive CD4+ T cells, the cell type implicated in initiating the disease process. In this study we observed that human adult central nervous system-derived oligodendrocytes can be susceptible to non-MHC-restricted lysis mediated by myelin basic protein-reactive CD4+ T cell lines. Cytotoxicity was significantly greater (37 ± 4 vs 7 ± 3%) with cell lines in which a high proportion of cells (mean, 28 ± 6%) expressed CD56 compared with cytotoxicity mediated by low CD56 cell lines (8 ± 2%). High CD56 cell lines, when rested in IL-2, lost cytotoxic activity and had reduced expression of CD56 (mean, 5 ± 2%). CD4+ T cells isolated from short term (3-day) anti-CD3/IL-2-activated mononuclear cell cultures did not express CD56 and were not cytotoxic to oligodendrocytes unless lectin was added. In contrast, an enriched population of non-T cells extracted from the same activated MNC cultures expressed CD56 as well as other NK cell-associated surface molecules and was cytotoxic. These results indicate the potential susceptibility of human oligodendrocytes to non-MHC-restricted injury mediated by both Ag-reactive and nonspecific cellular immune effector cells, with CD56 expression being a common feature of the effector cells.

Natural resistance against tumors grafted into the brain in association with histocompatibility-class-I-antigen expression

The role of MHC-class-I-antigen expression in intracerebral anti-tumor natural resistance was examined using MHC-positive Lym+ and MHC-negative Lym- lymphoma cell lines. Lym+ was sensitive to MHC-class-I-restricted CTL-mediated lysis, while lym- was resistant. Both lines were susceptible to NK-cell-mediated lysis. There was no difference in in vitro growth rate of in vivo intraperitoneal tumorigenicity between them. Inoculation of Lym+ cells into the brain caused upregulation of the intracellular MHC mRNA to the same level as after treatment with interferon-gamma, resulting in an increase in cell-surface MHC expression. Although inoculated Lym- cells also underwent an increase in cytosolic MHC mRNA, the cell-surface MHC expression remained negative. Immunoprecipitation revealed that the terminal glycosylation did not occur normally in Lym-. An in vivo intracerebral tumorigenicity assay, using 2 groups of untreated and NK-cell-depleted syngeneic mice, showed that Lym+ was less tumorigenic than Lym-. In T-cell-depleted mice, however, no difference was detected between them. In addition, when Lym+ and Lym- cells were inoculated into the brain of allogeneic or syngeneic preimmunized mice (immunized with tumor cells), Lym+ was rejected, while Lym- was accepted. When allogeneic mice had received treatment for T-cell depletion before intracerebral inoculation, no rejection was observed in Lym+. On the other hand, Lym- cells, when injected i.p. into NK-depleted mice, had greater killing activity than Lym+ cells, while in T-cell-depleted mice Lym- was less tumorigenic than Lym+. These results suggest that MHC-positive tumor cells grafted into the brain may be rejected by CTL in an MHC-dependent manner, whereas MHC-negative tumor cells can escape from T-cell-mediated immunosurveillance and grow progressively in the brain, due to absence of intracerebral natural resistance mediated by NK cells.

Constitutive and inducible expression of heat shock protein HSP72 in oligodendrocytes in culture

The stress-induced HSP72 expression in bovine oligodendrocytes (OL) in culture was investigated following exposure to heat stress, oxidative stress and cytokines by immunoblotting and immunocytochemistry. Under the unstressed condition, HSP72 was expressed in a small number (3%) of OL. After exposure to heat stress, the level of HSP72 expression in OL was elevated significantly and an intense HSP72 immunolabelling was identified in almost all OL, while HSP72 was not induced by exposure to hydrogen peroxide (10 microM) or glucose oxidase (20 mU ml-1). The level of HSP72 expression was not elevated by treatment with interleuken (IL)-1 alpha (10 ng ml-1), IL-1 beta (10 ng ml-1), tumour necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha (200 ng ml-1), or TNF-beta (200 ng ml-1). Our results indicate that HSP72 is upregulated in cultured bovine OL by heat stress but not by oxidative stress or cytokines such as IL-1 and TNF.

Oligodendrocyte lysis by CD4+ T cells independent of tumor necrosis factor

The capacity of human CD4+ T cells to lyse heterologous human oligodendrocytes in an 18-hour chromium 51-release assay was compared to that of systemic blood-derived macrophages and central nervous system-derived microglia. CD4+ T cells, activated with either phytohemagglutinin, anti-CD3 antibody, or antigen (myelin basic protein), could induce lysis of the oligodendrocytes whereas macrophages and microglia, activated with interferon-gamma and lipopolysaccharide, could not. The CD4+ T-cell effect was not inhibited with an anti-tumor necrosis factor-alpha-neutralizing antibody. Both the CD4+ T cells and the macrophages could induce lysis of tumor necrosis factor-sensitive rodent cell lines, Wehi 164, and L929; these effects were inhibited with anti-tumor necrosis factor antibody. Pretreatment of the CD4+ T cells with cyclosporine or mitomycin C did not inhibit oligodendrocyte lysis. These results indicate that at least in vitro, CD4+ T cells can induce a form of oligodendrocyte injury that is not reproduced by macrophages or microglia or by tumor necrosis factor. The non-major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted injury of oligodendrocytes induced by both myelin antigen-reactive and mitogen-stimulated T cells may provide a basis whereby cytotoxic CD4+ T cells could interact with a target cell that does not express MHC class II molecules. Our results suggest that immune-mediated oligodendrocyte/myelin injury, as is postulated to occur in the disease multiple sclerosis, may involve multiple effector mechanisms.

Role of histocompatibility antigen gene and protooncogene expressions in intracerebral tumorigenicity of mouse neuroblastoma

The role of N-myc, c-src, and major histocompatibility complex (MHC, H-2 in the mouse) class I antigen gene expressions in dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO)-induced differentiation and intracerebral tumorigenicity was examined using a mouse MNB85 neuroblastoma cell line. A fluorescence-activated cell sorter disclosed cell-surface MHC enhancement by DMSO, causing an increase in cytotoxic T-lymphocyte sensitivity. Southern blot analysis verified a single copy of the proto-oncogenes and MHC deoxyribonucleic acids in both untreated and DMSO-treated MNB85 cells. Northern blot analysis indicated that DMSO treatment induced a decrease in N-myc and an increase in c-src and MHC messenger ribonucleic acids. Nuclear run-off transcription assay revealed down-regulation of N-myc at a posttranscriptional level, contrasted with primary up-regulation of c-src at a transcriptional level. Immunoprecipitation after treatment with enzyme endo-beta-N-acetyl-glycoseamidase H proved that the terminal glycosylation of MHC heavy-chain gene products normally occurs in the Golgi apparatus of MNB85 cells. Intracerebral tumorigenicity assay showed that cells highly MHC-expressed by DMSO were less tumorigenic than untreated cells in association with DMSO-augmented cytotoxic T-lymphocyte susceptibility. These results suggest that proto-oncogenes may be linked to cellular differentiation, while cell-surface MHC gene expression influences intracerebral immunosurveillance.

Lysis of human glial cells by major histocompatibility complex-unrestricted CD4+ cytotoxic lymphocytes

We have investigated lysis of cultured human glial cells by non-major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted or 'promiscuous' CD(4+)-T lymphocytes, activated either under relatively long-term limiting dilution culture conditions in the presence of phytohemagglutinin (PHA) and interleukin (IL)-2, or under short-term PHA-activated bulk culture conditions. Specific effector:target cell ratio-dependent lysis of oligodendrocytes (OGCs) by CD4+ T lymphocytes, generated under both of the above conditions, was observed in an 18-h 51Cr-release assay, but not in a 5-h assay. The extent of CD4 T-cell-mediated OGC lysis was less than for the tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha-sensitive cell line U937, but greater than for TNF-resistant cell lines (K562, EL4). The effect could not be reproduced by T-cell culture supernatants or by high concentrations of recombinant TNF-alpha or beta. Anti-TNF-alpha antibody did not inhibit CD4-mediated lysis of OGC or U937 cells, but did inhibit U937 lysis induced by recombinant TNF-alpha, added in amounts exceeding those secreted by CD4 T cells. Human astrocytes and microglia were also susceptible to CD4+ T-cell-mediated lysis. Our results suggest that non-antigen non-MHC-restricted CD4+ T-cell-mediated injury of human glial cells can occur and may be dependent or enhanced by effector:target cell contact.

A morphological and ultrastructural investigation of normal mouse brain tissue after intracerebral injection of tumor necrosis factor

Morphological and ultrastructural changes in normal mouse brain tissue were investigated after intracerebral stereotactic injections of tumor necrosis factor (specific activity: 2.0 x 10(6) U/mg protein) into the right frontal lobe. The mice received either a single infusion or multiple tumor necrosis factor infusions in three different dose groups (10, 100, or 500 U). Compared with sham-treated control mice that received adjusted intracerebral injections of purified albumin, the tumor necrosis factor-treated mice in all dose groups did not show any specific in vivo behavioral abnormalities during the 2 months of study following the infusions. Histological studies revealed hemorrhage attributable to the mechanics of the intracerebral infusions, a thickening of the arachnoid membranes, a reactive gliosis, and neutrophilic and/or mononuclear cell infiltration along the infusion pathway. A local neutrophilic response was prominent 1 day after tumor necrosis factor injection. An immunohistochemical analysis indicated that the mononuclear cell infiltration consisted of lymphocytes and macrophages. Except for the transient neutrophilic infiltration, these histological alterations did not differ from those seen in the sham-treated control groups, and most nonspecific reactive changes disappeared within 8 weeks after the injections. Furthermore, an ultrastructural study showed no apparent pathological changes in the cytoplasmic organelles of neuronal, glial, and endothelial cells in the tumor necrosis factor-injected mouse specimens. These results suggest that the tumor necrosis factor injections caused no specific toxicity and did not alter the parenchymal and stromal cells comprising normal mouse brain tissue.

Oligodendroglial cell death induced by oxygen radicals and its protection by catalase

The cytotoxic effects of oxygen radicals have been studied in enriched population of mature bovine oligodendrocytes in culture. Oxygen radicals were generated enzymatically by glucose and glucose oxidase, and hypoxanthine and xanthine oxidase combinations. Cytotoxicity was assessed by trypan blue exclusion and percentage lactate dehydrogenase release into the culture media. Incubation of bovine oligodendrocytes with these oxygen radical-generating systems for 4 hr resulted in significant cell death, especially in the glucose oxidase system. The oligodendrocytes were completely protected by catalase from the cytotoxic effects of both oxygen radical generating systems. However, superoxide dismutase, dimethylsulfoxide and antioxidants such as vitamin E and glutathione did not protect oligodendrocytes from the oxidant-mediated cytotoxicity. It appears that hydrogen peroxide produced in these oxygen radical-generating systems gives rise to toxic radicals that induce the cell death of bovine oligodendrocytes in culture.

Lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) and adherent LAK (A-LAK) activity in multiple sclerosis

The cytotoxic activity of lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells against enriched cultures of oligodendrocytes (OL) was investigated in multiple sclerosis (MS) and controls. Human LAK cells, derived from macrophage-depleted peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) and incubated with recombinant human interleukin-2 (IL-2) (20-80 U/ml), mediated high levels of cytotoxicity against Raji cells but low levels of cytotoxicity against primary cultures of bovine OL. Cytotoxicity was not enhanced by incubation with a high level of IL-2 (500 U/ml). No statistically significant differences in LAK cell activity against bovine OL were observed among the study groups. Enriched adherent LAK (A-LAK) cells mediated greater levels of cytotoxicity against both bovine OL and tumor cell lines than unfractionated LAK cells. Flow cytometric analysis indicated that A-LAK effector cells were CD4-, CD8+, and CD16+. Furthermore, A-LAK cells mediated lysis of OL derived from several different animal species. Our results suggest that LAK and A-LAK cells can mediate cytolysis of OL in culture similar to that observed with a number of different tumor cell lines. However, no significant difference in cytolysis was identified between MS and control groups in this study.

Cytolysis of oligodendrocytes is mediated by killer (K) cells but not by natural killer (NK) cells

The cytotoxic activity of killer (K) cells against enriched cultures of bovine oligodendrocytes (BOL) was investigated in multiple sclerosis (MS) and controls. Human K cells mediated cytotoxicity to primary cultures of BOL in the presence of anti-BOL antiserum in all study groups, while BOL were resistant to human natural killer (NK) cells. Cytotoxic activity was significantly reduced in MS when compared to age-matched normal controls but not when compared to other neurologic disease (OND) patients. K cell-mediated lysis of BOL could also be induced with anti-galactocerebroside antibody but not with other antibodies including those specific for OL antigens (myelin basic protein, proteolipid apoprotein, and 2',3'-cyclic nucleotide 3'-phosphodiesterase). Enrichment of the effector population indicated that antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC) to BOL was mediated by large granular lymphocytes, and the effector population was further characterized by flow cytometry. The effector cells mediating ADCC could be inhibited by protein A of Staphylococcus aureus, and by K562 cells in cold competition assay. These observations indicate that oligodendrocytes are resistant to NK cells but are susceptible to cytolysis mediated by K cells. This may represent a potentially important immune mechanism in the pathogenesis of MS.