Inescapable footshock exposure differentially alters antigen- and mitogen-stimulated spleen cell proliferation in rats

Pre-clinical toxicology considerations for vaccine development

Vaccine development requires pre-clinical toxicology studies, following good laboratory practice (GLP), before first in human (phase I) use. Many factors are critical in the final outcome of any pre-clinical toxicology study. The study design is one of these critical factors and should be carefully planned to avoid any false negative and/or false positive results. Preparation is another most critical factor in a successful study. Major changes in any procedure during the course of study should be avoided by all means. For example, if the protocol specified the tail as the site of blood collection and this procedure was used for the control group at the day of necropsy, this collection site should never be replaced by another site (e.g. foot, eye, or heart) in all other treatment groups. Food restrictions and acute restraint stress affect clinical pathology data and should be avoided in rodents. Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC) guidelines for frequent blood collections (weekly, monthly, or at necropsy) in any animal species should be strictly followed. Clinical pathology data will be profoundly affected by any diversion from the recommended volumes. If CO₂ is specified in the protocol for anesthesia and/or euthanasia, ensuring enough quantity to use for all groups at necropsy is a very important factor. Using two different anesthetics in any study (e.g. CO₂ vs. pentobarbital) may result in false positive or false negative results in clinical chemistry parameters. Quality assurance elements (SOPs, instrument validation, lab certification etc.) affect the data interpretation and the final outcome of any toxicology study. SOPs should be up to date and written clearly. All lab instruments should be validated and all laboratories should be certified.

Laboratory environment and bio-medical experience: the impact of administration technique on the quality of immune-behavior data results in stress experience

Introduction: Often in an experiment, the control group and the intact group are not identified because most scientists neglect the fact that the sets of manipulation as technical administrations may be considered as an undesirable stress on the clarity of the data obtained from a scientific research specifically if it focuses on studying the effects of stress.

Methods: This study was conducted in two parts using 40 male Wistar rats. The first part aimed to treat a group of rats by repeated injections i.p route (1 mL/kg) of placebo or NaCl (0.9%) and the other by direct oral administration of NaCl (0.9%). Both groups spent 1 h of jet air stress with stressed group. Our objective was to consider the effects that these manipulations would have on the validity of behavioral results (the elevated plus maze test, the open field, the light/dark box test) and immune data (immune cell count) during this stress experience. The second part was devoted to the measurement of ACTH, IL6, and CRP in these experimental groups.

Results: Unlike oral administration, repeated intra-peritoneal injections cause a significant increase of plasma obtained levels of the adrenocorticotropin hormone (ACTH), interleukin-6 (IL-6) and the C-reactive protein (CRP) using injections of placebo: NaCl 0.9% (1 mL/kg) and it may have side effect on significant immune and behavioral alterations data quality induced by 1 h of air jet in the animal’s cage identified by the leukocyte formula and behavioral tests.

Conclusion: In an experimental protocol conducted on animal models, it is essential to opt for painless techniques such as oral administration instead of painful injections to avoid confusion at the behavioral and immunological results from biomedical experiments specifically one that focuses on the stress study.

Restoration of electric footshock-induced immunosuppression in mice by Gynostemma pentaphyllum components

The immunomodulatory effects of the ethanol extract of Gynostemma pentaphyllum (GP-EX) were examined in electric footshock (EFS)-stressed mice. The mice were orally administered various doses of GP-EX for 7 days before exposure to EFS (duration: 3 min, interval: 10 s, intensity: 2 mA) once a day from day 8 for 14 days with continuous daily feeding of GP-EX. Oral administration of GP-EX to mice prevented EFS stress-induced immunosuppression as determined by the lymphoid organ (thymus and spleen) weight and cellularity. In addition, oral administration of GP-EX restored EFS-suppressed functional properties of mature lymphocytes in terms of concanavalin A-induced proliferation of splenocytes and lipopolysaccharide-induced cytokine production (TNF-α, IL-1β). Furthermore, we found that mice that were orally administered with GP-EX generated much more potent ovalbumin-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses upon intravenous ovalbumin injection compared to the untreated controls. These results demonstrate that oral administration of the ethanol extract of Gynostemma pentaphyllum could increase host defense in immunocompromised situations such as stress-induced immunosuppression.

Acute restraint stress enhances calcium mobilization and proliferative response in splenic lymphocytes from mice

Calcium (Ca2+ ) plays an essential role in lymphocyte activation and maturation. Acute and chronic stress has been shown to modulate the lymphocyte immune response; but the relationship between cytosolic free Ca2+ concentration ([Ca2+ ]i) and the immune response in lymphocytes following exposure to stress has not been examined. In the present study, we investigated the effects of acute restraint stress on [Ca2+ ]i and the proliferation of splenic lymphocytes from mice. We observed that 2 h of restraint significantly increased plasma corticosterone levels in mice. On examining [Ca2+ ]i and the proliferation ex vivo of splenic lymphocytes isolated from restraint-stressed mice using fura-2 and 3-(4,5-dimethyl-2-thiazolyl)-2,5-diphenyl-2H-tetrazolium bromide, respectively, we found that acute restraint stress caused a significant increase in resting [Ca2+ ]i and significantly enhanced the ability of concanavalin A (Con A; a T-cell-selective mitogen) to increase [Ca2+ ]i but not that of lipopolysaccharide (LPS; a B-cell-selective mitogen). In addition, acute restraint stress significantly enhanced Con A-stimulated but not LPS-stimulated lymphocyte proliferation. Overall, there was a positive correlation between [Ca2+ ]i and T-cell proliferation following acute restraint stress. The enhancements of [Ca2+ ]i and T-cell proliferation were completely suppressed by verapamil (a Ca2+ channel blocker). These results suggest that acute restraint stress enhances Con A-stimulated T-cell proliferation by increasing [Ca2+ ]i via stimulation of Ca2+ entry.

Endocrine and immunological correlates of behaviorally identified swim stress resilient and vulnerable rats

Animal models of stress-induced depression have identified a bimodal reactivity to stress, namely 'resilience' and 'vulnerability.' Possible corresponding differences in endocrine and immunological responses between these groups have not been delineated. Male Sprague-Dawley rats were divided into three groups: stress (n=25), confined controls (n=7), and home cage controls (n=7). Stress rats were exposed to 80, 5-s inescapable cold water swim trials (15 degrees C). Twenty-four hours later, the stress rats were tested on an instrumental swim escape test (SET) but now they had access to an omnidirectional lever that terminated the stress. Immediately after the SET, trunk blood was collected to assay for serum corticosterone (CORT), and spleens were removed and natural killer cell activity (NKCA) and concanavalin A (CON-A) induced lymphocyte proliferation determined. Subjects in the stress treatment group were divided into distinct 'resilient' and 'vulnerable' categories by a median split for average escape latencies across the last 25 trials of the SET. Stress rats secreted more CORT than controls and vulnerable rats secreted greater levels than resilient rats. NKCA was greatest in control rats, and was decreased in the stress rats although the resilient and the vulnerable groups did not differ. Conversely, CON-A-induced lymphocyte proliferation was greatest in stress rats, vulnerable rats exhibiting more proliferation than resilient rats, but both were greater than both control groups. Stress animals were hypothermic throughout the swim stress procedures but exhibited a stress-induced fever following the initial swim trials. The observed differences may have important predictive and theoretical utility for vulnerable and resilient profiles.

Glucocorticoids produced during exercise may be necessary for optimal virus-induced IL-2 and cell proliferation whereas both catecholamines and glucocorticoids may be required for adequate immune defense to viral infection

Prolonged, exhaustive exercise has been associated with impaired immune responsiveness and increased susceptibility to infection. We have shown that one bout of exercise to fatigue followed by viral challenge increases mortality. Stress hormones such as corticosteroids and catecholamines have been suggested as potential mediators of exhaustive exercise-induced immunosuppression. The purpose of this study was to determine whether the administration of pharmacological agents to block the effect of catecholamines or corticosteroids would minimize the immunosuppression associated with this type of exercise. Mice either exercised to fatigue or were exposed to control conditions, and mice received an i.p. injection of either nadolol (beta-adrenergic receptor antagonist), RU486 (glucocorticoid type II receptor antagonist), or vehicle. Fifteen minutes post-exercise, mice were exposed to viral infection (Herpes simplex virus; HSV) via an intranasal route, and cells were collected 3 days post-infection. The results showed that exercise suppressed HSV-specific cell proliferation, HSV-specific IL-2, and IFN-gamma, but did not alter these same immune parameters when the mitogen ConA was used to stimulate cells. In addition, exercise reduced NK cell cytotoxicity, alveolar cell TNFalpha, and peritoneal IL-1beta, but did not affect IL-10. The pharmacological blockade did not attenuate the exercise-associated immunosuppression. In fact, RU486 treatment exacerbated the exercise-induced decline in HSV-induced IL-2 production and cell proliferation. RU486 and nadolol treatment also tended to decrease IL-10, IFN-gamma, TNFalpha (nadolol only), and IL-1beta (RU486 only) in both exercise and control mice, suggesting that stress hormones may be necessary during infection for optimal responsiveness. These findings suggest that suppression of immune defenses during viral infection persists for at least 3 days post-exercise, and stress hormones may be essential for optimal immune defense to viral challenge, rather than detrimental.

Stress applied during primary immunization affects the secondary humoral immune response in the rat: involvement of opioid peptides

The effect of unpredictable, inescapable and uncontrollable electric tail shocks (ES) on the humoral immune response to bovine serum albumin (BSA) was investigated in the rat. Contributions of the procedures that accompany shock delivery, such as witnessing the ES procedure (stress witnessing, SW) and exposure to the apparatus for shock delivery (apparatus control, AC) to the changes in specific immunity induced by ES were also tested. All procedures were applied during primary and/or secondary immunization. It was demonstrated that exposure to ES during primary immunization with BSA significantly suppressed specific anti-BSA antibody production after secondary and tertiary immunization with the same antigen. Exposure to the SW procedure during primary immunization with BSA enhanced the specific antibody level after secondary immunization, while exposure to the apparatus alone did not influence the development of either the primary or secondary humoral immune response to BSA. Both ES-induced suppression and SW-induced potentiation of the humoral immune response were partially inhibited by prior treatment with the opioid receptor antagonist naloxone. Additionally, treatments with the opioid peptides methionine- and leucine-enkephalin decreased anti-BSA antibody level, mimicking to some extent the effects of ES. It is suggested that ES and endogenous opioid peptides had long-term effects on humoral immunity through mechanisms involving immunologic memory.

Stressor-induced modulation of immune function: a review of acute, chronic effects in animals

The present paper reviews recent studies on the effects of stress on immune function in laboratory animals. The emphasis is on those studies where a simultaneous comparison of acute and chronic stress regimens was determined, although additional relevant studies are also reviewed. The effects of stress on basic measurements of cellular and humoral immune measures are discussed, including the growing number of studies that have reported alterations in macrophage functions. The latter are key elements in the innate immune response, and like measurements of T cell function and antibody production, are inhibited and enhanced by stressor exposure. This review does not focus on the mechanisms by which stress alters immune function, there being little to add conceptually in terms of what was reported previously (see Kusnecov AW, Rabin BS, Int Arch Allergy Immunol 1994;105:107-121.). However, a question is raised in the conclusion as to how stressor effects on immune function should be interpreted, for it is clear that immunological processes in and of themselves elicit central nervous system responses that neurochemically and endocrinologically do not differ from those produced in response to psychological stressors. Therefore, at least in the short term stressor-induced immune changes may not necessarily reflect maladaptive adjustments, although, as demonstrated by some studies reviewed in this paper, they may pose a serious risk to health should stressor exposure be persistent and uncontrolled.

Moderate exercise is associated with enhanced antigen-specific cytokine, but not IgM antibody production in aged mice

It has been suggested that moderate exercise may modulate the immune response in the elderly. We investigated whether moderate exercise had an effect on the immune response to viral infection in both young (2-4 months) and older (16-18 months) male BALB/cJ mice. Exercised (EX) mice ran on a treadmill for 8 weeks at a gradually increasing speed and duration whereas control (CON) mice were only handled briefly during each exercise session and then returned to their cages. Mice were infected with herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) 24 h post-exercise. Serum IgM anti-HSV antibody, HSV-1 specific Th1/Th2 cytokine production by spleen cells, and cytokine production by alveolar cells were measured 7 days post-infection. In the aged mice, exercise was associated with an enhanced production of the HSV-1 specific Th1-associated cytokines, interleukin (IL)-2 and interferon (IFN)-gamma, but had no effect on the Th2-associated cytokine IL-10 or IgM antibody. No effect of exercise was observed in young mice. IL-12 production was not altered by exercise, but aging was associated with altered IL-12 production in a tissue-specific manner. In conclusion, moderate exercise was associated with increased antigen-specific IL-2 and IFN-gamma production in response to viral challenge in older mice.

Chronic restraint stress induces severe disruption of the T-cell specific response to tetanus toxin vaccine

Chronic stress is known to induce immunological disorders. In the present study we examined the consequences of chronic restraint stress on the immune response to tetanus toxin in mice. We investigated the repartition of subsets of lymphoid cells in blood and spleen, the functional ability of lymphocytes to proliferate and to produce cytokines, and antibody titres against tetanus toxin following stress. We report discordance of the stimulation index of lymphocytes in the restraint group: the proliferating rate severely decreased following stimulation with a relevant antigen, whereas it increased with mitogen. Thus, we report a decrease in cytokine production with relevant antigen (interferon-gamma and interleukin-10), without a T helper type 1 and 2 secretion imbalance. Moreover, we observed an alteration in the humoral response, including a delay in isotype maturation and an immunoglobulin G1/G2a imbalance.

Differential immune reactivity to stress in BALB/cByJ and C57BL/6J mice: in vivo dependence on macrophages

Inbred BALB/cByJ and C57BL/6J mice not only differ in their neuroendocrine and behavioral reactivity to stress, but also their ability to mount appropriate immune responses to various pathogens. Because evidence suggests that stress may bias humoral or cell-mediated immune responses in these mouse strains, we assessed the effects of acute (1 h) physical restraint on the humoral immune response to keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH). Restraint exposure in close proximity to immunization with KLH enhanced the number of primary antigen-specific IgM and IgG producing splenic B cells in BALB/cByJ mice, but not in C57BL/6J mice. These effects might be determined at the level of macrophage antigen presenting cells, because BALB/cByJ mice immunized with KLH as a particulate antigen (i.e., encapsulated in liposomes) displayed the same stressor enhanced antibody response as they did to free, unencapsulated KLH. In addition, these mice showed enhanced production of the IgG1 subtype of IgG, but not the IgG2a subtype. Conversely, stressed C57BL/6J mice revealed an enhanced IgG2a response, although this was observed only under conditions of immunization with liposome-encapsulated KLH. In a final experiment involving only the BALB/cByJ strain, the depletion of macrophages in the spleen by administration of liposomes containing dichloromethylene biphosphonate (DMDP) 2 days before immunizing the mice with free KLH and restraint exposure, blocked the restraint-induced enhancement of humoral immune responses. These data suggest a possible intermediary role for macrophages in stressor-induced immunomodulation in vivo, which may be a potential point of divergence that explains the differential immune reactivity to KLH of BALB/cByJ and C57BL/6J mice exposed to an acute stressor.

Suppression of lymphocyte mitogenesis in different rat strains exposed to footshock during early diurnal and nocturnal time periods

The present study examined stressor interactions with genotype and light/dark cycle. Male Brown Norway (BN), Fischer 344 (F344), Lewis (from two different vendors: Lew/CR and Lew/H) and Sprague Dawley (SD) rats were exposed to footshock either in the early light or early dark circadian phase. Immediately after footshock, the spleen and whole blood proliferation to PHA and Con A was assessed. To provide endocrine indices of stress, serum was measured for corticosterone and interleukin-6 (IL-6). All rats showed significant increases in serum corticosterone and IL-6 following footshock either in the light or the dark. Rat strain differences were noted in the IL-6 response, while the corticosterone response was strong for all strains. The criterion for 'suppression' of lymphocyte proliferation was p < .05 (as determined by ANOVA) compared to non-shocked controls. Spleen: with the exception of BN rats, the other strains showed suppressed spleen cell proliferation to PHA and Con A both in the light and the dark. BN rats failed to show suppression of mitogenic activity to PHA when footshock was given in the light. Peripheral blood lymphocytes: suppression in Lew rats from either vendor, and in F344 and BN rats, did not vary with time of day nor with the type of mitogen tested. SD rats did not show suppression to PHA if shocked in the light. These results highlight the generality of stressor-induced mitogenic lymphocyte proliferation during the early diurnal and nocturnal periods of the day.

Effect of a conditioned aversive stimulus on the immune response in three strains of rats

In the present study we investigated the effect of a brief exposure (15 s) to a conditioned aversive stimulus (CS) on the proliferative response of spleen and peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) in Lewis, Fischer 344 and Sprague-Dawley rats. Plasma levels of ACTH and corticosterone were also measured. For conditioning, rats were exposed to 10 presentations of a 5 s duration foot-shock (1.6 mA) preceded by a 15 s tone. Seven days later, animals were exposed to the auditory signal without electric shock. Significant differences were found in both the kinetics and the magnitude of altered mitogenic responsiveness of PBL between the different strains of rats. Enhancement of PBL responsiveness to mitogens was observed in Fischer and Sprague-Dawley rats immediately after exposure to the CS. A significant decrease in the response of PBL to mitogens was found in Lewis and Sprague-Dawley rats 10 min after exposure to the CS. The PBL response of Sprague-Dawley and Fischer rats returned to baseline at 30 min, but not in Lewis rats. Proliferative activity of spleen lymphocytes in response to the CS was suppressed from baseline in all rat strains, but the timing and degree of suppression differed. Fischer rats had the largest percentage of suppression. The earliest suppression of spleen mitogenic function after exposure to the CS was in Fischer rats, while the Lewis rats had the latest onset of suppression, with the Sprague-Dawley rats being intermediate. Plasma levels of ACTH and corticosterone peaked at 10 min in all strains of rats. The magnitude of hormonal elevation differed in the different rat strains, suggesting that corticosterone may not have a variable immunomodulatory role in each strain. These data suggest that a brief psychological stressor results in activation of the HPA axis and is associated with strain-dependent alterations of lymphocyte responsiveness to non-specific mitogens. The short-term exposure to a CS which produces different parameters of lymphocyte functional modulation, provides a useful tool to study the mechanisms of stressor-induced immune alteration.

The protective effects of stress control may be mediated by increased brain levels of benzodiazepine receptor agonists

Control over stress protects against many of the deleterious effects of stress exposure, but the endogenous mediators responsible for these prophylactic effects have remained elusive. Using behavioral pharmacology, in vitro radioligand binding and neurochemical analyses, we demonstrate that exposure to escapable stress results in brain and behavior changes reminiscent of benzodiazepine administration. The stress control group shows significant protection against picrotoxinin-induced seizures, reductions in [35S]t-butylbicyclophosphorothionate (TBPS) binding and a 3-fold increase of benzodiazepine-like substances in brain in comparison to both yoked-inescapable shock and non-shock controls. These observations suggest that coping behavior leads to the release of endogenous benzodiazepine-like compounds in brain which protect the organism from stress pathology.