Rapid small-scale isolation of herpes simplex virus DNA

Phylogenetic and Genomic Characterization of Whole Genome Sequences of Ocular Herpes Simplex Virus Type 1 Isolates Identifies Possible Virulence Determinants in Humans

Purpose

There are limited data on the prevalence and genetic diversity of herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) virulence genes in ocular isolates. Here, we sequenced 36 HSV-1 ocular isolates, collected by the Bascom Palmer Eye Institute, a university-based eye hospital, from three different ocular anatomical sites (conjunctiva, cornea, and eyelid) and carried out a genomic and phylogenetic analyses.

Methods

The PacBio Sequel II long read platform was used for genome sequencing. Phylogenetic analysis and genomic analysis were performed to help better understand genetic variability among common virulence genes in ocular herpetic disease.

Results

A phylogenetic network generated using the genome sequences of the 36 Bascom Palmer ocular isolates, plus 174 additional strains showed that ocular isolates do not group together phylogenetically. Analysis of the thymidine kinase and DNA polymerase protein sequences from the Bascom Palmer isolates showed multiple novel single nucleotide polymorphisms, but only one, BP-K14 encoded a known thymidine kinase acyclovir resistance mutation. An analysis of the multiple sequence alignment comprising the 51 total ocular isolates versus 159 nonocular strains detected several possible single nucleotide polymorphisms in HSV-1 genes that were found significantly more often in the ocular isolates. These genes included UL6, gM, VP19c, VHS, gC, VP11/12, and gG.

Conclusions

There does not seem to be a specific genetic feature of viruses causing ocular infection. The identification of novel and common recurrent polymorphisms may help to understand the drivers of herpetic pathogenicity and specific factors that may influence the virulence of ocular disease.

Disease parameters following ocular herpes simplex virus type 1 infection are similar in male and female BALB/C mice

Sex related differences in the incidence or severity of infection have been described for multiple viruses. With herpes simplex viruses, the best example is HSV-2 genital infection where women have a higher incidence of infection and can have more severe infections than men. HSV-1 causes several types of infections including skin and mucosal ulcers, keratitis, and encephalitis in humans that do not appear to have a strong biological sex component. Given that mouse strains differ in their MHC loci it is important to determine if sex differences occur in multiple strains of mice. Our goal was to answer two questions: Are virus related sex differences present in BALB/C mice and does virulence of the viral strain have an effect? We generated a panel of recombinant HSV-1 viruses with differing virulence phenotypes and characterized multiple clinical correlates of ocular infection in BALB/c mice. We found no sex-specific differences in blepharitis, corneal clouding, neurovirulence, and viral titers in eye washes. Sex differences in neovascularization, weight loss and eyewash titers were observed for some recombinants, but these were not consistent across the phenotypes tested for any recombinant virus. Considering these findings, we conclude that there are no significant sex specific ocular pathologies in the parameters measured, regardless of the virulence phenotype following ocular infection in BALB/c mice, suggesting that the use of both sexes is not necessary for the bulk of ocular infection studies.

Genomic analysis for virulence determinants in feline herpesvirus type-1 isolates

Feline herpesvirus type 1 (FHV-1) is a widespread cause of respiratory and ocular disease in domestic cats. A spectrum of disease severity is observed in host animals, but there has been limited prior investigation into viral genome factors which could be responsible. Stocks of FHV-1 were established from oropharyngeal swabs obtained from twenty-five cats with signs of infection housed in eight animal shelters around the USA. A standardized numerical host clinical disease severity scoring scheme was used for each cat from which an isolate was obtained. Illumina MiSeq was used to sequence the genome of each isolate. Genomic homogeneity among isolates was relatively high. A general linear model for fixed effects determined that only two synonymous single nucleotide polymorphisms across two genes (UL37/39) in the same isolate (from one host animal with a low disease severity score) were significantly associated (p ≤ 0.05) with assigned host respiratory and total disease severity score. No variants in any isolate were found to be significantly associated with assigned host ocular disease severity score. A concurrent analysis of missense mutations among the viral isolates identified three genes as being primarily involved in the observed genomic variation, but none were significantly associated with host disease severity scores. An ancestral state likelihood reconstruction was performed and determined that there was no evidence of a connection between host disease severity score and viral evolutionary state. We conclude from our results that the spectrum of host disease severity observed with FHV-1 is unlikely to be primarily related to viral genomic variations, and is instead due to host response and/or other factors.

Recombination Analysis of Herpes Simplex Virus 1 Reveals a Bias toward GC Content and the Inverted Repeat Regions

Herpes simplex virus 1 (HSV-1) causes recurrent mucocutaneous ulcers and is the leading cause of infectious blindness and sporadic encephalitis in the United States. HSV-1 has been shown to be highly recombinogenic; however, to date, there has been no genome-wide analysis of recombination. To address this, we generated 40 HSV-1 recombinants derived from two parental strains, OD4 and CJ994. The 40 OD4-CJ994 HSV-1 recombinants were sequenced using the Illumina sequencing system, and recombination breakpoints were determined for each of the recombinants using the Bootscan program. Breakpoints occurring in the terminal inverted repeats were excluded from analysis to prevent double counting, resulting in a total of 272 breakpoints in the data set. By placing windows around the 272 breakpoints followed by Monte Carlo analysis comparing actual data to simulated data, we identified a recombination bias toward both high GC content and intergenic regions. A Monte Carlo analysis also suggested that recombination did not appear to be responsible for the generation of the spontaneous nucleotide mutations detected following sequencing. Additionally, kernel density estimation analysis across the genome found that the large, inverted repeats comprise a recombination hot spot.

IMPORTANCE

Herpes simplex virus 1 (HSV-1) virus is the leading cause of sporadic encephalitis and blinding keratitis in developed countries. HSV-1 has been shown to be highly recombinogenic, and recombination itself appears to be a significant component of genome replication. To date, there has been no genome-wide analysis of recombination. Here we present the findings of the first genome-wide study of recombination performed by generating and sequencing 40 HSV-1 recombinants derived from the OD4 and CJ994 parental strains, followed by bioinformatics analysis. Recombination breakpoints were determined, yielding 272 breakpoints in the full data set. Kernel density analysis determined that the large inverted repeats constitute a recombination hot spot. Additionally, Monte Carlo analyses found biases toward high GC content and intergenic and repetitive regions.

Genomic, phylogenetic, and recombinational characterization of herpes simplex virus 2 strains

Herpes simplex virus 2 (HSV-2) is a major global pathogen, infecting 16% of people 15 to 49 years old worldwide and causing recurrent genital ulcers. Little is known about viral factors contributing to virulence, and there are currently only two genomic sequences available. In this study, we determined nearly complete genomic sequences of six additional HSV-2 isolates, using Illumina MiSeq. We report that HSV-2 has a genomic overall mean distance of 0.2355%, which is less than that of HSV-1. There were approximately 100 amino-acid-encoding and indels per genome. Microsatellite mapping found a bias toward intergenic regions in the nonconserved microsatellites and a genic bias in all detected tandem repeats. Extensive recombination between the HSV-2 strains was also strongly implied. This was the first study to analyze multiple HSV-2 sequences, and the data will be valuable in future evolutionary, virulence, and structure-function studies.

IMPORTANCE

HSV-2 is a significant worldwide pathogen, causing recurrent genital ulcers. Here we present six nearly complete HSV-2 genomic sequences, and, with the addition of two previously sequenced strains, for the first time genomic, phylogenetic, and recombination analysis was performed on multiple HSV-2 genomes. Our results show that microsatellite mapping found a bias toward intergenic regions in the nonconserved microsatellites and a genic bias in all detected tandem repeats and confirm that chimpanzee herpesvirus 1 (ChHV-1) is a separate species and that each of the HSV-2 strains is a genomic mosaic.

Multiplex sequencing of seven ocular herpes simplex virus type-1 genomes: phylogeny, sequence variability, and SNP distribution

PURPOSE

Little is known about the role of sequence variation in the pathology of HSV-1 keratitis virus. The goal was to show that a multiplex, high-throughput genome-sequencing approach is feasible for simultaneously sequencing seven HSV-1 ocular strains.

METHODS

A genome sequencer was used to sequence the HSV-1 ocular isolates TFT401, 134, CJ311, CJ360, CJ394, CJ970, and OD4, in a single lane. Reads were mapped to the HSV-1 strain 17 reference genome by high-speed sequencing. ClustalW was used for alignment, and the Mega 4 package was used for phylogenetic analysis (www.megasoftware.net). Simplot was used to compare genetic variability and high-speed sequencing was used to identify SNPs (developed by Stuart Ray, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD, http://sray.med.som.jhml.edu/SCRoftware/simplot).

RESULTS

Approximately 95% to 99% of the seven genomes were sequenced in a single lane with average coverage ranging from 224 to 1345. Phylogenetic analysis of the sequenced genome regions revealed at least three clades. Each strain had approximately 200 coding SNPs compared to strain 17, and these were evenly spaced along the genomes. Four genes were highly conserved, and six were more variable. Reduced coverage was obtained in the highly GC-rich terminal repeat regions.

CONCLUSIONS

Multiplex sequencing is a cost-effective way to obtain the genomic sequences of ocular HSV-1 isolates with sufficient coverage of the unique regions for genomic analysis. The number of SNPs and their distribution will be useful for analyzing the genetics of virulence, and the sequence data will be useful for studying HSV-1 evolution and for the design of structure-function studies.

Sequence variation in the herpes simplex virus U(S)1 ocular virulence determinant

PURPOSE

The herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) U(S)1 gene encodes host-range and ocular virulence determinants. Mutations in U(S)1 affecting virulence are known in strain OD4, but the genomic variation across several strains is not known. The goal was to determine the degree of sequence variation in the gene from several ocular HSV isolates.

METHODS

The U(S)1 gene from six ocular HSV-1 isolates, as well as strains KOS and F, were sequenced, and bioinformatics analyses were applied to the data.

RESULTS

Strains 17, F, CJ394, and CJ311 had identical amino acid sequences. With the other strains, most of the variability was concentrated in the amino-terminal third of the protein. MEME analysis identified a 63-residue core sequence (motif 1) present in all α-herpesvirus U(S)1 homologs that were located in a region identified as structured. Ten amino acids were absolutely conserved in all the α-herpesvirus U(S)1 homologs and were all located in the central core. Consensus-binding motifs for cyclin-dependent kinases and pocket proteins were also identified.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that significant sequence variation exists in the U(S)1 gene, that the α22 protein contains a conserved central core region with structurally variable regions at the amino- and carboxyl termini, that 10 amino acids are conserved in α-herpes U(S)1 homologs, and that additional host proteins may interact with the HSV-1 U(S)1 and U(S)1.5 proteins. This information will be valuable in designing further studies on structure-function relationships and on the role these play in host-range determination and keratitis.

Flip-Flop HSV-BAC: bacterial artificial chromosome based system for rapid generation of recombinant herpes simplex virus vectors using two independent site-specific recombinases

BACKGROUND

Oncolytic herpes simplex virus (HSV) vectors that specifically replicate in and kill tumor cells sparing normal cells are a promising cancer therapy. Traditionally, recombinant HSV vectors have been generated through homologous recombination between the HSV genome and a recombination plasmid, which usually requires laborious screening or selection and can take several months. Recent advances in bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) technology have enabled cloning of the whole HSV genome as a BAC plasmid and subsequent manipulation in E. coli. Thus, we sought a method to generate recombinant oncolytic HSV vectors more easily and quickly using BAC technology.

RESULTS

We have developed an HSV-BAC system, termed the Flip-Flop HSV-BAC system, for the rapid generation of oncolytic HSV vectors. This system has the following features: (i) two site-specific recombinases, Cre and FLPe, are used sequentially to integrate desired sequences and to excise the BAC sequences, respectively; and (ii) the size of the HSV-BAC-insert genome exceeds the packaging limit of HSV so only correctly recombined virus grows efficiently. We applied this to the construction of an HSV-BAC plasmid that can be used for the generation of transcriptionally-targeted HSV vectors. BAC sequences were recombined into the UL39 gene of HSV ICP4-deletion mutant d120 to generate M24-BAC virus, from which HSV-BAC plasmid pM24-BAC was isolated. An ICP4 expression cassette driven by an exogenous promoter was re-introduced to pM24-BAC by Cre-mediated recombination and nearly pure preparations of recombinant virus were obtained typically in two weeks. Insertion of the ICP4 coding sequence alone did not restore viral replication and was only minimally better than an ICP4-null construct, whereas insertion of a CMVIE promoter-ICP4 transgene (bM24-CMV) efficiently drove viral replication. The levels of bM24-CMV replication in tumor cells varied considerably compared to hrR3 (UL39 mutant).

CONCLUSION

Our Flip-Flop HSV-BAC system enables rapid generation of HSV vectors carrying transgene inserts. By introducing a tumor-specific-promoter-driven ICP4 cassette into pM24-BAC using this system, one should be able to generate transcriptionally-targeted oncolytic HSV vectors. We believe this system will greatly facilitate the screening of a plethora of clinically useful tumor-specific promoters in the context of oncolytic HSV vectors.

Enhanced isolation of low frequency herpes simplex virus recombinants using green-fluorescent protein and FACS

The generation of recombinant herpes simplex virus to study the effect of engineered mutations on viral biology relies on the isolation of recombinants from a mixed population of viruses following a marker transfer procedure. Currently, the E. coli lacZ or green-fluorescent protein (GFP) genes are most frequently used as markers for isolation and isolation of recombinants relies on visual screening of plaques. Alternatively, novel restriction site changes can be inserted into a gene followed by screening of individual plaques for the novel change. These methods are inefficient when the frequency of recombinants in the pool of viruses is low. Using GFP as a selection marker, a FACS procedure that results in a substantial enrichment of the frequency of recombinants is described. Cells were infected at a multiplicity of infection (MOI) of 1.0 in the presence of acyclovir and at 10h post-infection, either the GFP+ or GFP- cells were sorted by FACS, and the sorted cells were plated on fresh cells. After three rounds of selection, the frequency of GFP+ recombinants rose from 0.1 to 3-4%. A mutant virus with a GFP insertion in the US1 gene (alpha22 protein) was generated and then used to isolate a virus with a mutation, Y116C, in the alpha22 protein.

The antiviral agent 5-chloro-1,3-dihydroxyacridone interferes with assembly and maturation of herpes simplex virus

Antiviral drug screening and exploratory mechanistic work identified 5-chloro-1,3-dihydroxyacridone as a lead inhibitor of herpes simplex virus (HSV) replication, one without a primary effect on either HSV DNA or late viral protein synthesis (Antivir. Res. 45 (2000) 123). In this report, drug effects on viral DNA cleavage and packaging, HSV capsid production and virion morphogenesis in infected Vero cells were studied systematically in order to better localize the sensitive stage of the replication cycle. Maturation of replicating HSV DNA and virion production at late times were inhibited in the same dose-dependent fashion, suggesting that the drug might directly inhibit the cleavage and packaging processes. Based on density centrifugation analysis however, this possibility appears unlikely because overproduction of neither A- or B-capsids occurred upon drug treatment. Interestingly, similar studies coupled with either Western immunoblot or ultrastructural analysis showed that B-capsids with apparent normal protein composition accumulated at reduced levels (maximally about two- to three-fold) in drug-treated cells. Limited attempts to isolate drug-resistant viral mutants using standard approaches proved unsuccessful. In summery, 5-chloro-1,3-dihydroxyacridone inhibits one or more steps of HSV assembly since treatment results in reduced levels of capsids (particularly B-type) and reduced levels of encapsidated DNA. The action of the acridone derivative is an unusual one, with distinctive features when compared to a recently reported class of HSV encapsidation inhibitor and to the late replication defects of relevant viral mutants.

A simple procedure for expression and purification of selected non-structural (alpha and beta) herpes simplex virus 1 (HSV-1) proteins

The expression and isolation of herpes simplex virus 1 (HSV-1) immediate early (alpha) IE63 (ICP27) and of the early (beta) thymidine kinase (Tk) polypeptides in Escherichia coli JM 109 cells transformed with the PinPoint Xa-1 (Promega) plasmid construct carrying either the HSV-1 UL54 or UL23 genes are described. The resulting biotinylated fusion protein(s) could be easily induced and were purified in appropriate amounts by means of a monomeric avidin-conjugated resin (SoftLink Soft Release Avidin Resin, Promega) provided that: (1) the exponential growth of the selected transformed cells was monitored carefully; (2) the post-induction harvest interval was properly chosen; and (3) the period for adsorption to the avidin resin suitably adjusted. The isolated protein(s), although partially digested in the case of the IE63 polypeptide, were suitable antigen(s) for immunization of various animal species. Co-purification of trace amounts of endogenous biotinylated protein(s) produced in E. coli was eliminated by shortening the duration of adsorption to the avidin resin.

Rapid small-scale isolation of SV40 virions and SV40 DNA

A rapid method for the small-scale isolation of SV40 virions and SV40 DNA is presented. CV-1 monkey epithelial cells are transfected with linear SV40 DNA. After the onset of transfection, cells are lysed by several freeze/thaw cycles and virions are isolated using polyethylene glycol (PEG) precipitation of DNase I treated lysates. Viral DNA is released by proteinase K and dithiothreitol treatment of the isolated virions followed by phenol/chloroform extraction and ethanol precipitation. This method yields on average 7.5x10(4) plaque forming units (PFUs) and DNA of adequate purity and concentration to be used for restriction analysis on ethidium bromide agarose gels from a single 35-mm tissue culture dish.

Herpes simplex virus 1 (HSV-1) strain HSZP glycoprotein B gene: comparison of mutations among strains differing in virulence

The nonpathogenic HSZP strain of HSV-1 induces large polykaryocytes due to a syn3 mutation (His for Arg at residue 858) in the C-terminal endodomain of glycoprotein B (gB) (40). We determined the nucleotide (nt) sequence of the UL27 gene specifying the gB polypeptide of HSZP (gBHSZP) and found 3 mutations in its ectodomain at aminoacids (aa) 59, 79 and 108. The ANGpath virus, which also has a syn3 mutation in the C-terminal endodomain of gB (Val for Ala at residue 855) is pathogenic for adult mice (39), but can be made nonpathogenic by replacing the gBANGpath gene by the corresponding gBKOS sequence (21). The gBANGpath had three ectodomain mutations (at aa 62, 77 and 285), while gBKOS had at least four ectomain mutations (aa 59, 79, 313, and 553). Two mutations (aa 59 and 79) in the latter, located in the variable antigenic site IV/D1 were common for gBKOS and gBHSZP. These together with the gBANGpath mutations at aa 62 and 77 create a cluster of 4 mutations in diverse region of the N-terminal part of gB (between aa 59-79), in which the gBs of pathogenic ANGpath and 17 viruses differ from the gBs of nonpathogenic HSZP and KOS viruses. The lower pathogenicity of KOS as related to gBKOS, is furthermore associated with the change of Ser to Thr at aa 313 (locus III/D2). The possibility is discussed that mutations in both above mentioned antigenic loci could result in higher immunogenicity of the corresponding antigenic epitopes, which, in turn, would contribute to the decreased virulence of HSZP and KOS viruses.

1,3-Dihydroxyacridone derivatives as inhibitors of herpes virus replication

The nuclear enzyme DNA topoisomerase II is a candidate pharmacological target for treating herpes virus infections and the novel catalytic inhibitors, 7-chloro-1,3-dihydroxyacridone (compound 1), and 1,3,7-trihydroxyacridone (2) are potential lead compounds [Bastow, K.F., Itoigawa, M., Furukawa, H., Kashiwada, Y., Bori, I.D., Ballas, L.M., Lee, K.-H., 1994. Antiproliferative actions of 7-substituted 1,3-dihydroxyacridones; possible involvement of DNA topoisomerase II and protein kinase C as biochemical targets. Bioorg. Med. Chem. 2, 1403-1411; Vance, J.R., Bastow, K.F., 1999. Inhibition of DNA topoisomerase II catalytic activity by the antiviral agents 7-chloro,1,3-dihydroxyacridone and 1,3,7-trihydroxyacridone. Biochem. Pharmacol. 58, 703-708]. In this report, four new 1,3-dihydroxyacridone analogs with functional groups at either the 5-, 6- or 8-positions (compounds 3-6) were synthesized. Target compounds, three other analogs including compounds 1 and 2 and three anticancer drugs that inhibit DNA topoisomerase II (etoposide, amsacrine and aclarubicin) were then evaluated as selective inhibitors of herpes simplex virus (HSV) replication in cell culture and as enzyme inhibitors in vitro. Etoposide and amsacrine inhibited HSV but acted non-selectively. In general, the activities of 1,3-dihydroxyacridone derivatives as selective anti-HSV agents and as enzyme inhibitors varied inversely suggesting that DNA topoisomerase II probably is not the critical antiviral target. The 5-Cl congener (compound 3) was the most selective agent (about 26-fold under a stringent assay condition) but was not an enzyme inhibitor. Results of exploratory mechanistic studies with compounds 1 and 3 show that HSV replication was blocked at a stage after DNA and late protein synthesis. The acridone derivatives were also tested against human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) replication but none of them were active.

An improved rapid method for purification of herpes simplex virus DNA using cesium trifluoroacetate

A method for purification of herpes simplex virus DNA from cell culture is described which yields highly purified viral DNA within 8 h. The method involves the freezing and thawing of virus-infected cells followed by isopycnic centrifugation of the lysate supernatant in cesium trifluoroacetate. It was found that this method recovered DNA from most of the cell-associated virus particles in such sufficient purity that the DNA was digestible with restriction enzymes and could be used to transfect cells without the need for additional purification steps. Purification of viral DNA from cells that were not subjected to freezing and thawing was less efficient due to the amount of viral DNA that remained cell-associated.

Recombinants are isolated at high frequency following in vivo mixed ocular infection with two avirulent herpes simplex virus type 1 strains

Mixed infections with different strains of herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) may result in more severe disease than infection with either strain alone. This phenomenon is important because it may facilitate the identification of virulence genes through the transfer of virulence determinants between complementing strains, and it may pose a problem in the use of attenuated HSV strains for vaccines and gene delivery vectors. In this study, we have compared the percentage of recombinants present after mixed infection with HSV-1 strains OD4 and 994 in vitro and in vivo. After corneal inoculation, we found that 74% of randomly picked isolates from the trigeminal ganglia were recombinants, compared with 59% from the cornea. Twenty-six percent of randomly picked isolates were recombinant following mixed infection of Vero cells in vitro. Seventeen recombinant strains isolated from the in vivo mixed infections were assayed for ocular virulence, and they were found to exhibit a wide range of virulence phenotypes. The presence of virulent recombinants suggests that recombination plays a role in the increased disease observed in this mixed infection, and the broad range of virulence indicates that there may be multiple genetic factors involved in the increased virulence observed after mixed infection with these two strains. The recombinants were also tested for their ability to grow in NIH 3T3 fibroblasts, and though some correlation was observed between growth in vitro and ability to cause ocular disease, improved growth in murine cells does not sufficiently explain the increased virulence observed in some recombinants.