Mass action kinetics of vesicle aggregation and fusion

Pseudopeptosomes: non-lipidated vesicular assemblies from bispidine-appended pseudopeptides

We report a novel molecular topology-based approach for creating reproducible vesicular assemblies in different solvent environments (including aqueous) using specifically designed pseudopeptides. Deviating from the classical "polar head group and hydrophobic tail" model of amphiphiles, we showed (reversible) self-assembly of synthesized pseudopeptides into vesicles. Naming these new type/class of vesicles "pseudopetosomes", we characterized them by high-resolution microscopy (scanning electron, transmission electron, atomic force, epifluorescence and confocal) along with dynamic light scattering. While accounting for hydropathy index of the constituent amino acids (side chains) of pseudopeptides, we probed molecular interactions, resulting in assembly of pseudopeptosomes by spectroscopy (fourier-transform infrared and fluorescence). Molecular characterization by X-ray crystallography and circular dichroism revealed "tryptophan (Trp)-Zip" arrangements and/or hydrogen-bonded one-dimensional assembly depending on specific pseudopeptides and solvent environments. Our data indicated that pseudopeptosomes are formed in solutions by self-assembly of bispidine pseudopeptides (of Trp, leucine and alanine amino-acid constituents) into sheets that transform into vesicular structures. Thus, we showed that assembly of pseudopeptosomes utilizes the full spectrum of all four weak interactions essential in biological systems. Our findings have direct implications in chemical and synthetic biology, but may also provide a new avenue of investigations on origins of life via pseudopeptosome-like assemblies. We also showed that these designer peptides can act as carriers for cellular transport.

Aspects of Biological Replication and Evolution Independent of the Central Dogma: Insights from Protein-Free Vesicular Transformations and Protein-Mediated Membrane Remodeling

Biological membrane remodeling is central to living systems. In spite of serving as “containers” of whole-living systems and functioning as dynamic compartments within living systems, biological membranes still find a “blue collar” treatment compared to the “white collar” nucleic acids and proteins in biology. This may be attributable to the fact that scientific literature on biological membrane remodeling is only 50 years old compared to ~ 150 years of literature on proteins and a little less than 100 years on nucleic acids. However, recently, evidence for symbiotic origins of eukaryotic cells from data only on biological membranes was reported. This, coupled with appreciation of reproducible amphiphilic self-assemblies in aqueous environments (mimicking replication), has already initiated discussions on origins of life beyond nucleic acids and proteins. This work presents a comprehensive compilation and meta-analyses of data on self-assembly and vesicular transformations in biological membranes—starting from model membranes to establishment of Influenza Hemagglutinin-mediated membrane fusion as a prototypical remodeling system to a thorough comparison between enveloped mammalian viruses and cellular vesicles. We show that viral membrane fusion proteins, in addition to obeying “stoichiometry-driven protein folding”, have tighter compositional constraints on their amino acid occurrences than general-structured proteins, regardless of type/class. From the perspective of vesicular assemblies and biological membrane remodeling (with and without proteins) we find that cellular vesicles are quite different from viruses. Finally, we propose that in addition to pre-existing thermodynamic frameworks, kinetic considerations in de novo formation of metastable membrane structures with available “third-party” constituents (including proteins) were not only crucial for origins of life but also continue to offer morphological replication and/or functional mechanisms in modern life forms, independent of the central dogma.

Liposome Fusion Mediated by Hydrophobic Magnetic Nanoparticles Stabilized with Oleic Acid and Modulated by an External Magnetic Field

Membrane fusion is considered relevant in countless scientific areas and biotechnological processes, ranging from vital life events to biomedicine, pharmaceuticals, and materials engineering, among others. In this study, we employed hydrophobic oleic acid (OA)-coated magnetite (Fe₃O₄) nanoparticles (MNP-OA) as a platform to induce the fusion of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphatidylcholine liposomes [large unilamellar vesicles (LUVs)] in a colloidal dispersion. This fusion was monitored through dynamic light scattering, turbidimetry, and fluorescence assay using the well-known Tb/dipicolinic acid (DPA) complex formation assay. MNP-OA have shown to be able to induce fusion with the mixing of liposomal inner content with direct dependence on the nanoparticle concentration added to the LUVs. Moreover, changes in the permeability of the liposome bilayer, upon the addition of MNP-OA to liposomes, were evaluated by studying the leakage of carboxyfluorescein and of the co-encapsulated Tb/DPA complex. These assays allowed us to determine that MNP-OA did not significantly modify liposome permeability during the fusion process. Transmission electron microscopy and confocal microscopy revealed that MNP-OA remained embedded in the lipid bilayer without producing membrane rupture, liposome deformation, or destruction. In addition, we evaluated the effect of applying a low-intensity magnetic field to the LUVs/MNP-OA system and observed that the nanoparticles considerably increased their fusogenic activity under this external stimulus, as well as they are capable of responding to low magnetic fields of around 0.45 mT. These results revealed the potential of hydrophobic magnetic nanoparticles, stabilized with OA, to act as a fusogen, thus representing a valuable tool for biotechnological applications.

A method for quantitative interpretation of fluorescence detection of poly(ethylene glycol)-mediated 1-palmitoyl-2-[[[2-[4-(phenyl-trans-1,3,5-hexatrienyl) phenyl]ethyl]oxyl]carbonyl]3-sn-phosphatidylcholine (DPHpPC) transfer and fusion between phospholipid vesicles in the dehydrated state

A method has been developed for calculating the expected fluorescence lifetime of the DPH p PC probe distributed between different membrane environments. We show how this method can be used to distinguish between lipid transfer and fusion between large unilamellar vesicles occurring in the presence of poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG). This application of the calculation took into consideration the heterogeneity of microenvironments experienced by the probe in a sample containing vesicle aggregates of different sizes. Assuming that the aggregate size distribution was a delta function of the aggregate size, comparison of the calculated and observed lifetimes yielded an estimate of the vesicle aggregate size. For vesicles of varying compositions in the presence of dehydrating concentrations of PEG, this method suggested that only small aggreggates formed. For vesicles that could be demonstrated by other means not to have fused, the data were consistent with lipid transfer occurring only between the outer leaflets of two to four vesicles, even at high PEG concentrations. For vesicles that could be demonstrated to fuse by contents mixing and size changes, the fluorescence lifetime data were consistent with lipid transfer between both the inner and the outer leaflets of two to four fused vesicles. At very high PEG concentrations, where extensive rupture and large, multilamellar products were previously observed, the lifetime data were consistent with much more extensive lipid transfer within larger aggregates. The agreement of predictions made on the basis of lifetime measurements with other observations attests to the validity of the fluorescence lifetime method. In addition, the model and data presented here provide evidence that fusion occurs between small numbers of PEG-aggregated vesicles before the removal of PEG.

Fluorescence lifetimes of diphenylhexatriene-containing probes reflect local probe concentrations: Application to the measurement of membrane fusion

An important process in the life of a cell is fusion between cellular membranes. This is the process by which two cellular compartments surrounded by different membranes join to become a single compartment surrounded by a single membrane, without significant loss of compartment contents. To demonstrate fusion, the cell biophysicist must demonstrate all three critical aspects of the process: (1) mixing of membrane components, (2) mixing of compartment contents; and (3) retention of compartment contents. Most commonly, accomplishing this involves the use of fluorescence probes. The general theme to the methods described involves some form of concentration-dependent quenching. An unique method developed in our laboratory utilizes the concentration dependence of the fluorescence lifetime of a phosphatidylcholine containing carboxyethyl diphenylhexatriene at position 2 and palmitic acid at position 1 of glycerol (DPHpPC). The fluorescence lifetime of this molecule and that of its parent fluorophore diphenylhexatriene (DPH) shorten dramatically as their two-dimensional concentrations in a membrane increase. This "lifetime quenching" can be described by dimer formation that reduces the symmetry of the DPH excited state. This phenomenon allows one to use the fluorescence lifetime to gain insight into the local concentration of probe in microscopic regions of a membrane. One application of this is in distinguishing lipid transfer between the outer leaflets of two contacting membrane bilayers from fusion between these membranes that leads to mixing of lipids in both the inner and outer leaflets of the membrane bilayers. This allows a single measurement to demonstrate fusion between membrane pairs.

The elementary mass action rate constants of P-gp transport for a confluent monolayer of MDCKII-hMDR1 cells

The human multi-drug resistance membrane transporter, P-glycoprotein, or P-gp, has been extensively studied due to its importance to human health and disease. Thus far, the kinetic analysis of P-gp transport has been limited to steady-state Michaelis-Menten approaches or to compartmental models, neither of which can prove molecular mechanisms. Determination of the elementary kinetic rate constants of transport will be essential to understanding how P-gp works. The experimental system we use is a confluent monolayer of MDCKII-hMDR1 cells that overexpress P-gp. It is a physiologically relevant model system, and transport is measured without biochemical manipulations of P-gp. The Michaelis-Menten mass action reaction is used to model P-gp transport. Without imposing the steady-state assumptions, this reaction depends upon several parameters that must be simultaneously fitted. An exhaustive fitting of transport data to find all possible parameter vectors that best fit the data was accomplished with a reasonable computation time using a hierarchical algorithm. For three P-gp substrates (amprenavir, loperamide, and quinidine), we have successfully fitted the elementary rate constants, i.e., drug association to P-gp from the apical membrane inner monolayer, drug dissociation back into the apical membrane inner monolayer, and drug efflux from P-gp into the apical chamber, as well as the density of efflux active P-gp. All three drugs had overlapping ranges for the efflux active P-gp, which was a benchmark for the validity of the fitting process. One novel finding was that the association to P-gp appears to be rate-limited solely by drug lateral diffusion within the inner monolayer of the plasma membrane for all three drugs. This would be expected if P-gp structure were open to the lipids of the apical membrane inner monolayer, as has been suggested by recent structural studies. The fitted kinetic parameters show how P-gp efflux of a wide range of xenobiotics has been maximized.

Mechanism of pH-triggered collapse of phosphatidylethanolamine liposomes stabilized by an ortho ester polyethyleneglycol lipid

The mechanism of pH-triggered destabilization of liposomes composed of a polyethyleneglycol-orthoester-distearoylglycerol lipid (POD) and phosphatidyl ethanolamine (PE) has been studied using an ANTS/DPX leakage and a lipid-mixing assay. We developed a kinetic model that relates POD hydrolysis to liposome collapse. This minimum-surface-shielding model describes the kinetics of the pH-triggered release of POD/PE liposomes. In the model, when acid-catalyzed hydrolysis lowers the mole percentage of POD on the liposome surface to a critical level, intervesicular lipid mixing is initiated, resulting in a burst of contents release. Two phases of content leakage are observed: a lag phase and a burst phase. During the lag phase, less than 20% of liposomal contents are released and the leakage begins to accelerate when approaching to the transition point. During the burst phase, the leakage rate is dependent on interbilayer contact. The burst phase occurs when the surface density of the PEG lipid is 2.3 +/- 0.6 mol%, regardless of the pH. Vesicles containing 4 mol% of a pH-insensitive PEG-lipid conjugate and 10% POD did not leak contents or collapse at any pH. These data are consistent with the stalk theory to describe the lamellar-to-inverted hexagonal phase transition and set a lower bound of approximately 16 PE lipids on the external monolayer as the contact site required for lipid mixing between two bilayers.

Cationic triple-chain amphiphiles facilitate vesicle fusion compared to double-chain or single-chain analogues

Cationic, triple-chain amphiphiles promote vesicle fusion more than structurally related double-chain or single-chain analogues. Two types of vesicle fusion experiments were conducted, mixing of oppositely charged vesicles and acid-triggered self-fusion of vesicles composed of cationic amphiphile and anionic cholesteryl hemisuccinate (CHEMS). Vesicle fusion was monitored by standard fluorescence assays for intermembrane lipid mixing, aqueous contents mixing and leakage. Differential scanning calorimetry was used to show that triple-chain amphiphiles lower the lamellar-inverse hexagonal (L(alpha)-H(II)) phase transition temperature for dipalmitoleoylphosphatidylethanolamine. The triple-chain amphiphiles may enhance vesicle fusion because they can stabilize the inversely curved membrane surfaces of the fusion intermediates, however, other factors such as extended conformation, packing defects, chain motion, or surface dehydration may also contribute. From the perspective of drug delivery, the results suggest that vesicles containing cationic, triple-chain amphiphiles (and cationic, cone-shaped amphiphiles in general) may be effective as fusogenic delivery capsules.

The pre-transmembrane region of the human immunodeficiency virus type-1 glycoprotein: a novel fusogenic sequence

We have investigated membrane interactions and perturbations induced by NH(2)-DKWASLWNWFNITNWLWYIK-COOH (HIV(c)), representing the membrane interface-partitioning region that precedes the transmembrane anchor of the human immunodeficiency virus type-1 gp41 fusion protein. The HIV(c) peptide bound with high affinity to electrically neutral vesicles composed of dioleoylphosphatidylcholine, dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine and cholesterol (molar ratio, 1:1:1), and induced vesicle leakage and lipid mixing. Infrared spectra suggest that these effects were promoted by membrane-associated peptides adopting an alpha-helical conformation. A sequence representing a defective gp41 phenotype unable to mediate both cell-cell fusion and virus entry, was equally unable to induce vesicle fusion, and adopted a non-helical conformation in the membrane. We conclude that membrane perturbation and adoption of the alpha-helical conformation by this gp41 region might be functionally meaningful.

Oligonucleotide-cationic liposome interactions. A physicochemical study

Cationic liposomes are effective in delivering antisense oligonucleotides into cells in culture, but their interactions with the oligonucleotides are poorly understood. We studied the aggregation and fusion reactions during the formation of cationic lipid/oligonucleotide complexes in solution and their interactions with lipid bilayers. Phosphorothioate oligonucleotides (15-mer) were complexed with cationic liposomes composed of dimethyldioctadecylammonium bromide (DDAB) and dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine (DOPE) at 8:15 molar ratio or of a commercial formulation DOTAP (N-(1-(2,3-dioleoyloxy)propyl)-N,N,N-trimethylammoniummethylsul fate), at different ratios with apparent -/+ charge ratios of 0.03-5.6. Mean size of the complexes increased with -/+ ratio so that at charge ratios 0.4-2.0 the size increased by at least an order magnitude due to the oligonucleotide induced aggregation. Resonance energy transfer experiments showed that in addition to aggregation oligonucleotides induced fusion of cationic liposomes, but the fusion was rate-controlled by the initial aggregation step. Rate constants for oligonucleotide induced aggregation were dependent on lipid concentration and were in the range of (0.2-1).10(7) M-1 s-1 and (1-10).10(7) M-1 s-1 for DDAB/DOPE and DOTAP, respectively. Increase in oligonucleotide concentration induced the aggregation and fusion until at high -/+ ratios electrostatic repulsion of negative surfaces inhibited further aggregation and fusion. DOTAP/oligonucleotide complexes did not induce leakage of calcein from neutral EPC liposomes, but did cause leakage at -/+ charge ratios of < 0.7 and > 2.0 from EPC/DOPE liposomes. Also at -/+ charge ratios below 0.8 DOTAP/oligonucleotide complexes induced leaking from negatively charged DPPC/DPPG liposomes. These results indicate that either phosphatidylethanolamine or negative charge are required in the cell membrane for fusion of cationic liposome-oligonucleotide complexes. The ratio of oligonucleotide to cationic lipid is critical in determining the physicochemical properties of the mixture.

pH- and ionic strength-dependent fusion of phospholipid vesicles induced by pardaxin analogues or by mixtures of charge-reversed peptides

The fusogenic properties of the neurotoxin paradaxin and eight of its analogues with small unilamellar vesicles (SUV), composed of egg phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylserine (PC/PS), were investigated. Fusion was demonstrated by a lipid-mixing assay and by an increase in vesicle size as revealed by electron microscopy. The lipid-mixing assay was performed at either neutral (pH 6.8) or acidic (pH 4.5) conditions, in solutions containing either high or low salt concentrations. A low level of fusion could be induced at neutral pH only by pardaxin derivatives with amino groups at both the peptide's backbone and N-terminus. However, a marked enhancement in the fusogenic activity occurred when amino groups were present also in the C-terminus. Pardaxin analogues in which amino groups were substituted by carboxylic groups induced elevated levels of fusion only at high salt concentrations where enhancement of aggregation occurs, and acidic pH, which increased alpha-helicity. The influence of mutual interactions between pardaxin's analogues possessing complementary charges on the lipid-mixing process was also studied. At neutral pH and high salt, an inactive acidic analogue increased the fusogenic activity of a complementary-charged basic peptide. However, such mutual interactions at low salt concentrations reduced the fusogenic activity of the pardaxin analogues. Analogues containing D-amino acids were not fusogenic, thus demonstrating the structural specificity of these observations. The results indicate that the charge, alpha-helical structure, and aggregation of peptide monomers play an important role in the fusogenic ability of polypeptides.

Ca2+ action on the stability of egg phosphatidylcholine sonicated vesicles during freeze-thaw cycles

The stability of unilamellar vesicles during freeze-thaw cycles strongly depends on the Ca2+ concentration in the aqueous solution. Experiments performed at equal ionic strengths with Na+ and Ca2+ solutions indicate that the effect observed is specific for Ca2+. This is interpreted to be a consequence of the adsorption of Ca2+ on the vesicle bilayers. The variation of lipid and Ca2+ concentrations indicates that stability is achieved at a particular Ca2+/lipid ratio of 8 mol/mol above which vesicles are stable. The stability appears to be mainly conferred by the external Ca2+ in both slow and rapid cycles, independent of the ionic vesicle content. However, internal Ca2+ seems to increase the stability according to the F/T cycle rate to some extent in the absence of Ca2+ in the external solution.

Reduction of the in vitro hemolytic activity of soybean lecithin liposomes by treatment with a block copolymer

The in vitro hemolytic activity of liposomes made of soybean L-alpha-lecithin towards diluted (0.0086 v/v) human erythrocytes was used to investigate the effect of surface coating on the interaction of liposomes with cells. The increase in apparent volume of the block copolymer of ethylene glycol and propylene glycol, Pluronic F-127, in the presence of liposomes supports the hypothesis of either adsorption or penetration of the copolymer at the surface of the liposomes. When the liposomes are pre-incubated with Pluronic F-127, their lytic activity towards fresh erythrocytes is significantly reduced while it remains unchanged towards erythrocytes aged in vitro. It is also found that aging the liposomes has little effect on their lytic activity while aging of the erythrocytes makes them more fragile towards the liposomes. The results are discussed in terms of steric hindrance.

Fusion of enveloped viruses with cells and liposomes. Activity and inactivation

The fusion of viruses with cells and liposomes is reviewed with focus on the analysis of the final extents and kinetics of fusion. Influenza virus and Sendai virus exhibit 100% of fusion capacity with cells at pH 5 and pH 7.5, respectively. On the other hand, there may be in certain cases, a limit on the number of virions that can fuse with a single cell, that is significantly below the limit on binding. It still remains to be resolved whether this limit reflects a limited number of possible fusion sites, or a saturation limit on the amount of viral glycoproteins that can be incorporated in the cellular membrane, like the case of virus fusion with pure phospholipid vesicles, in which the fusion products were shown to consist of a single virus and several liposomes. Both viruses demonstrate incomplete fusion activity towards liposomes of a variety of compositions. In the case of Sendai virus, fusion inactive virions bind essentially irreversibly to liposomes. Yet, preliminary results revealed that such bound, unfused virions can be released by sucrose gradient centrifugation. The separated unfused virions subsequently fuse when incubated with a "fresh" batch of liposomes. We conclude, therefore, that the fraction of initially bound unfused virions does not consist of dective particles, but rather of particles bound to liposomes via "inactive" sites. Details of the low pH inactivation of fusion capacity of influenza virus towards cells and liposomes are presented. This inactivation is caused by protonation and exposure of the hydrophobic segment of HA2, and affects primarily the fusion rate constants. Some degree of inactivation also occurs when virions are bound to cellular membranes.

Molecular mechanisms of calcium-induced membrane fusion

We have reviewed studies on calcium-induced fusion of lipid bilayer membranes and the role of synexin and other calcium-binding proteins (annexins) in membrane fusion. We have also discussed the roles of other cations, lipid phase transitions, long chain fatty acids and other fusogenic molecules. Finally, we have presented a simple molecular model for the mechanism of lipid membrane fusion, consistent with the experimental evidence and incorporating various elements proposed previously.

Stability and fusion of lipid vesicles containing headgroup-modified analogues of phosphatidylethanolamine

We have used lipid mixing, contents mixing and contents-leakage assays to characterize the divalent cation-mediated interactions of vesicles composed of various headgroup-modified analogues of phosphatidylethanolamine, PE (N- and C-2-alkylated derivatives, and analogues with increased separations of the phosphoryl and amino groups) together with a low mole percentage of phosphatidylserine (PS). Vesicles containing different structural analogues of PE exhibit marked differences, both in the threshold divalent cation concentrations that are required to initiate vesicle-vesicle interactions and in the rates of contents mixing and leakage observed at suprathresholds divalent cation concentrations. The efficiencies of divalent cation-promoted contents leakage, and to a slightly lesser extent those of contents mixing, for PS/PE (analogue) vesicles show a marked inverse correlation with the lamellar-to-hexagonal II transition temperature (TH) of the PE (analogue) component. However, the destabilization kinetics for such vesicles show no abrupt changes over the temperature range around the equilibrium TH value measured for the vesicle lipids. Vesicles combining PS with different PE analogues exhibit divalent cation thresholds for aggregation that are not correlated with the TH values of the PE (analogue) components but appear instead to be correlated with the equilibrium interbilayer separations measured in multilamellar dispersions of these species. We have identified headgroup-modified analogues of PE that can be used to prepare vesicles that fuse more rapidly under a given set of conditions, or that show a bette ratio of fusion-to-contents-leakage rates, than do PE-containing vesicles. These results may be useful both for understanding better the bases for the high fusion-supporting ability of PE and for the preparation of lipid vesicles 'tailored' for particular practical applications.

Membrane fusion activity of influenza virus. Effects of gangliosides and negatively charged phospholipids in target liposomes

Fusion of influenza virus with liposomes composed of negatively charged phospholipids differs from fusion with biological membranes or zwitterionic liposomes with ganglioside receptors [Stegmann, T., Hoekstra, D., Scherphof, G., & Wilschut, J. (1986) J. Biol. Chem. 261, 10966-10969]. In this study, we investigated how the kinetics and extent of fusion of influenza virus, monitored with a fluorescence resonance energy-transfer assay, are influenced by the surface charge and the presence of receptors on liposomal membranes. The results were analyzed in terms of mass action kinetic model, providing separate rate constants for the initial virus-liposome adhesion, or aggregation, and for the actual fusion reaction. Incorporation of increasing amounts of cardiolipin (CL) or phosphatidylserine (PS) into otherwise zwitterionic phosphatidylcholine (PC)/phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) vesicles results in a gradual shift of the pH threshold of fusion to neutral, relative to the pH threshold obtained with PC/PE vesicles containing the ganglioside GD1a, while also the rate of fusion increases. This indicates the emergence of a fusion mechanism not involving the well-documented conformational change in the viral hemagglutinin (HA). However, only with pure CL liposomes this nonphysiological fusion reaction dominates the overall fusion process; with pure PS or with zwitterionic vesicles containing CL or PS, the contribution of the nonphysiological fusion reaction is small. Accordingly, preincubation of the virus alone at low pH results in a rapid inactivation of the viral fusion capacity toward all liposome compositions studied, except pure CL liposomes. The results of the kinetic analyses show that with pure CL liposomes the rates of both virus-liposome adhesion and fusion are considerably higher than with all other liposome compositions studied.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Cholesterol affects divalent cation-induced fusion and isothermal phase transitions of phospholipid membranes

The influence of cholesterol on divalent cation-induced fusion and isothermal phase transitions of large unilamellar vesicles composed of phosphatidylserine (PS) was investigated. Vesicle fusion was monitored by the terbium/dipicolinic acid assay for the intermixing of internal aqueous contents, in the temperature range 10-40 degrees C. The fusogenic activity of the cations decreases in the sequence Ca2+ greater than Ba2+ greater than Sr2+ much greater than Mg2+ for cholesterol concentrations in the range 20-40 mol%, and at all temperatures. Increasing the cholesterol concentration decreases the initial rate of fusion in the presence of Ca2+ and Ba2+ at 25 degrees C, reaching about 50% of the rate for pure PS at a mole fraction of 0.4. From 10 to 25 degrees C, Mg2+ is ineffective in causing fusion at all cholesterol concentrations. However, at 30 degrees C, Mg2+-induced fusion is observed with vesicles containing cholesterol. At 40 degrees C, Mg2+ induces slow fusion of pure PS vesicles, which is enhanced by the presence of cholesterol. Increasing the temperature also causes a monotonic increase in the rate of fusion induced by Ca2+, Ba2+ and Sr2+. The enhancement of the effect of cholesterol at high temperatures suggests that changes in hydrogen bonding and interbilayer hydration forces may be involved in the modulation of fusion by cholesterol. The phase behavior of PS/cholesterol membranes in the presence of Na+ and divalent cations was studied by differential scanning calorimetry. The temperature of the gel-liquid crystalline transition (Tm) in Na+ is lowered as the cholesterol content is increased, and the endotherm is broadened. Addition of divalent cations shifts the Tm upward, with a sequence of effectiveness Ba2+ greater than Sr2+ greater than Mg2+. The Tm of these complexes decreases as the cholesterol content is increased. Although the transition is not detectable for cholesterol concentrations of 40 and 50 mol% in the presence of Na+, Sr2+ or Mg2+, the addition of Ba2+ reveals endotherms with Tm progressively lower than that observed at 30 mol%. Although the presence of cholesterol appears to induce an isothermal gel-liquid crystalline transition by decreasing the Tm, this change in membrane fluidity does not enhance the rate of fusion, but rather decreases it. The effect of cholesterol on the fusion of PS/phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) vesicles was investigated by utilizing a resonance energy transfer assay for lipid mixing. The initial rate of fusion of PS/PE and PS/PE/cholesterol vesicles is saturated at high Mg2+ concentrations. With Ca2+, saturation is not observed for cholesterol-containing vesicles.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Kinetic measurements of fusion of phosphatidylserine-containing vesicles by electron microscopy and fluorometry

Large unilamellar vesicles (REV) containing phosphatidylserine and phosphatidylethanolamine at a ratio of 1:3 were induced to fuse by adding calcium (4 mM). The kinetics of fusion was monitored by fluorometry using terbium or dipicolinic acid-containing vesicles. The morphology and the states of vesicle aggregation and fusion were examined at approx. 2, 30, 60, 150 and 900 s after calcium addition, by rapid quenching and freeze-fracture electron microscopy. The size and the state of aggregation of vesicles are quantitated from 4000 randomly selected vesicles. The aggregation and fusion kinetics as assayed by fluorescence volume mixing is very well simulated and predicted by the mass action model. The model essentially predicts the time course of the distribution of the aggregates and the increase in size of fused particles as measured by electron microscopy, although in some cases the predicted fusion rate exceeds that by morphometric measurement. No morphological features can be defined as fusion intermediates, although bead-like and rim-like materials may be attributed to the remnants of broken diaphragms between fusion partners.

Kinetics of melittin-induced fusion of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine small unilamellar vesicles

We have studied the kinetics of fusion of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine small unilamellar vesicles at 51 degrees C which is induced by bee venom melittin at a protein-to-lipid molar ratio of 1/60. This was done by following with a stopped-flow fluorometer the reduction in the ratio of the excimer to monomer fluorescence intensities of 1-palmitoyl-2-(10-pyrenyldecanoyl)-sn-glycero-3-phosphorylcholine that accompanies fusion. At a low melittin concentration and low ionic strength, for which case the protein is monomeric, the value of the rate constant for fusion is 0.006 s-1. This is much smaller than that of 0.06 s-1 obtained for a high melittin concentration at low ionic strength, i.e. for the protein in the tetrameric form which is not induced by a high salt concentration. The value of the rate constant for fusion for a low melittin concentration in the presence of 2 M NaCl, i.e. for the protein in the tetrameric form which is induced by a high salt concentration, is 0.12 s-1. This is twice as large as that for fusion induced by the tetramer in a low ionic strength solution. These findings show that the state of aggregation of the protein in solution and, to a lesser extent, electrostatic interactions play an important role in the kinetics of melittin-induced fusion of vesicles.

Effects of cholesterol on the divalent cation-mediated interactions of vesicles containing amino and choline phospholipids

We have used assays of lipid probe mixing, contents mixing and contents leakage to monitor the divalent cation-mediated interactions between lipid vesicles containing phosphatidylserine (PS) as a minority component together with mixtures of phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), phosphatidylcholine (PC) or sphingomyelin, and cholesterol in varying proportions. The initial rates of calcium- and magnesium-induced lipid probe quenching between vesicles, which reflect primarily the rates of vesicle aggregation, are strongly reduced as progressively higher proportions of PC or sphingomyelin are incorporated into PE/PS vesicles. The initial rates of divalent cation-induced contents mixing and contents leakage for PE/PS vesicles are also strongly reduced when choline phospholipids are incorporated into the vesicles in even low molar proportions. Sphingomyelin has a more potent inhibitory effect on these processes than does PC at an equal level in the vesicle membranes. The inclusion of cholesterol in these vesicles, at levels up to 1:2 moles sterol/mole phospholipid, has little effect on the rates of calcium- or magnesium-induced vesicle aggregation. However, cholesterol significantly enhances the initial rates of vesicle contents mixing and contents leakage in the presence of divalent cations when the vesicles contain choline as well as amino phospholipids. This effect is substantial only when the level of cholesterol exceeds the level of choline phospholipids in the vesicles. These results may have significance for the fusion of certain cellular membranes in mammalian cells, whose cytoplasmic faces have lipid compositions very similar to those of the vesicles examined in this study.

Effect of synexin on aggregation and fusion of chromaffin granule ghosts at pH 6

Fusion of chromaffin granule ghosts was induced by synexin at pH 6, 37 degrees C, in the presence of 10(-7) M Ca2+. To study the kinetics and extent of this fusion process we employed two assays that monitored continuously mixing of aqueous contents or membrane mixing by fluorescence intensity increases. In both assays chromaffin granule ghosts were either labeled on the membrane or in the included aqueous phase. The ratios of blank to labeled chromaffin granule ghosts were varied from 1 to 10. The results were analyzed in terms of a mass action kinetic model, which views the overall fusion reaction as a sequence of a second-order process of aggregation followed by a first-order fusion reaction. The model calculations gave fare simulations and predictions of the experimental results. The rate constants describing membrane mixing are more than 2-fold larger than those for volume mixing. The analysis also indicated that the initial aggregation and fusion processes, up to dimer formation, were extremely fast. The rate constant of aggregation was close to the limit in diffusion-controlled processes, whereas the fusion rate constant was about the same as found in fastest virus-liposome fusion events at pH 5. A small increase in volume was found to accompany the fusion between chromaffin granule ghosts. Using ratios of synexin to chromaffin granule ghost protein of 0.13, 0.41 and 1.15 indicated that the overall fusion rate was larger for the intermediate (0.41) case. The analysis showed that the main activity of synexin was an enhancement of the rate of aggregation. At intermediate or excessive synexin concentrations it, respectively, promoted moderately, or inhibited the actual fusion step.

Ca2+-induced fusion of large unilamellar phosphatidylserine/cholesterol vesicles

The effect of cholesterol on the Ca2+-induced aggregation and fusion of large unilamellar phosphatidylserine (PS) vesicles has been investigated. Mixing of aqueous vesicle contents was followed continuously with the Tb/dipicolinate assay, while the dissociation of pre-encapsulated Tb/dipicolinate complex was taken as a measure of the release of vesicle contents. Vesicles consisting of pure PS or PS/cholesterol mixtures at molar ratios of 4:1, 2:1 and 1:1 were employed at three different lipid concentrations, each at four different Ca2+ concentrations. The results could be well simulated in terms of a mass-action kinetic model, providing separately the rate constants of vesicle aggregation, c11, and of the fusion reaction itself, f11. In the analyses the possibility of deaggregation of aggregated vesicles was considered explicitly. Values of both c11 and f11 increase steeply with the Ca2+ concentration increasing from 2 to 5 mM. With increasing cholesterol content of the vesicles the value of c11 decreases, while the rate of the actual fusion reaction, f11, increases. Remarkably, the effect of cholesterol on both aggregation and fusion is quite moderate. The presence of cholesterol in the vesicle bilayer does not affect the leakage of vesicle contents during fusion.

Divalent cation induced fusion and lipid lateral segregation in phosphatidylcholine-phosphatidic acid vesicles

The interactions of unilamellar vesicles containing phosphatidylcholine (PC) and phosphatidic acid (PA) in the presence of calcium and magnesium were examined by fluorometric assays of vesicle lipid mixing, contents mixing, and contents leakage and by spray-freezing freeze-fracture electron microscopy. These results were correlated with calorimetric and fluorometric measurements of divalent cation induced lateral segregation of lipids in these vesicles under comparable conditions. PA-PC vesicles in the presence of calcium show a rapid but limited intermixing of vesicle lipids and contents, the extent of which increases as the vesicle size decreases or the PA content increases. Calcium produces massive aggregation and efficient mixing of the contents of vesicles containing high proportions of dioleoyl-PA or egg PA, but vesicle coalescence in the latter case is followed rapidly by vesicle collapse and massive leakage of contents. The effects of magnesium are similar for vesicles of very high PA content. However, in the presence of magnesium, vesicles containing lower amounts of PA exhibit "hemifusion", a mode of interaction in which vesicles aggregate and mix approximately 50% of their lipids, apparently representing the lipids of the outer monolayer of each vesicle, without significant mixing of vesicle contents or collapse of the vesicles. Fluorometric measurements of lipid lateral segregation demonstrate that lateral redistribution of lipids in PA-PC vesicles begins at submillimolar concentrations of divalent cations and shows no abrupt change at the "threshold" divalent cation concentration, above which coalescence of vesicles is observed. By correlating calorimetric and fluorometric measurements of lipid lateral segregation and mixing of vesicle components, we can demonstrate that lipid segregation is at least strongly correlated with calcium-promoted coalescence of PA-PC vesicles and is essential to the magnesium-promoted interactions of vesicles of low PA contents.

Fusion of Sendai virus with negatively charged liposomes as studied by pyrene-labelled phospholipid liposomes

Sendai virus particles fuse with negatively charged liposomes but not with vesicles made of zwitterionic phospholipids. The liposome-virus fusion process was studied by dilution of the concentration-dependent excimer-forming fluorophore 2-pyrenyldodecanoylphosphatidylcholine contained in the liposomes by the viral lipids. The data were analyzed in the framework of a mass action kinetic model. This provided analytical solutions for the final levels of probe dilution and numerical solutions for the kinetics of the overall fusion process, in terms of rate constants for the liposome-virus adhesion, deadhesion and fusion. This analysis led to the following conclusions: At neutral pH and 37 degrees C, only 15% of the virus particles can fuse with the phospholipid vesicles, although all the virions may aggregate with the liposomes. The rate constants for aggregation, fusion and deadhesion are of the orders of magnitude of 10(7) M-1 X s-1, 10(-3) s-1 and 10(-2), s-1, respectively. The fraction of active virus increases with temperature. At acidic pH, both the fraction of 'fusable' virus and the rate of fusion increase markedly. The optimal pH for fusion is 3-4, where most of the virus particles are active. At higher pH values, an increasing fraction of the virus particles become inactive, probably due to ionization of viral glycoproteins, whereas at pH values below 3.0 the fusion is markedly reduced, most likely due to protonation of the negatively charged vesicles. While only 15% of the virions fuse with the liposomes at pH 7.4 and 37 degrees C, all the liposomes lose their content (Amselem, S., Loyter, A. Lichtenberg, D. and Barenholz, Y. (1985) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 820, 1-10). We therefore propose that release of entrapped solutes is due to liposome-virus aggregation, and not to fusion. Both trypsinization and heat inactivation of the virus particles inhibit not only the fusion process but also the release of carboxyfluorescein. This demonstrates the obligatory role of viral membrane proteins in liposome-virus aggregation. Reconstituted vesicles made of the viral lipid and the hemagglutinin/neuraminidase (HN) glycoprotein fuse with negatively charged liposomes similar to the intact virions. This suggests that the fusion of virions with negatively charged vesicles, unlike the fusion of the virus with biological membranes, requires only the HN and not the fusion glycoprotein.

Membrane fusion: lipid vesicles as a model system

In many cellular functions the process of membrane fusion is of vital importance. It occurs in a highly specific and strictly controlled fashion. Proteins are likely to play a key role in the induction and modulation of membrane fusion reactions. Aimed at providing insight into the molecular mechanisms of membrane fusion, numerous studies have been carried out on model membrane systems. For example, the divalent-cation induced aggregation and fusion of vesicles consisting of negatively charged phospholipids, such as phosphatidylserine (PS) or cardiolipin (CL), have been characterized in detail. It is important to note that these systems largely lack specificity and control. Therefore conclusions derived from their investigation can not be extrapolated directly to a seemingly comparable counterpart in biology. Yet, the study of model membrane systems does reveal the general requirements of lipid bilayer fusion. The most prominent barrier to molecular contact between two apposing bilayers appears to be due to the hydration of the polar groups of the lipid molecules. Thus, dehydration of the bilayer surface and fluctuations in lipid packing, allowing direct hydrophobic interactions, are critical to the induction of membrane fusion. These membrane alterations are likely to occur only locally, at the site of intermembrane contact. Current views on the way membrane proteins may induce fusion under physiological conditions also emphasize the notion of local surface dehydration and perturbation of lipid packing, possibly through penetration of apolar amino acid segments into the hydrophobic membrane interior.

Kinetic and structural aspects of reconstitution of phosphatidylcholine vesicles by dilution of phosphatidylcholine-sodium cholate mixed micelles

Dilution of mixed micellar dispersions of egg phosphatidylcholine (PC) and sodium cholate beyond a critical value results in formation of cholate-containing PC vesicles. The structure of the resultant vesicles and some mechanistic aspects of this process have been investigated by the use of light scattering and nuclear magnetic resonance techniques. The main findings and conclusions are the following: Both the state of aggregation (micellar or vesicular) and the apparent equilibrium size distribution of micelles or vesicles obtained by dilution of the PC-cholate mixed micellar dispersions are a function of the cholate to PC molar ratio in the mixed aggregates (micelles or vesicles). When this effective ratio (Re) is higher than 0.4, the dispersion is micellar, and the size of the mixed micelles increases with decreasing Re; when Re less than 0.3, the dispersion is essentially vesicular, and the mean hydrodynamic radius of the vesicles is an increasing function of Re; in dispersions with 0.3 less than Re less than 0.4, mixed micelles and vesicles coexist. Addition of cholate to vesicular dispersions, to Re values below 0.3, results in vesicle size growth through a concentration-independent lipid-exchange mechanism. Addition of cholate to higher Re values results in micellization (solubilization) of the vesicles. On the other hand, dilution of vesicular dispersions does not affect the size of the vesicles. Apparent equilibration of a mixed micellar dispersion following dilution to Re values below 0.3 is slow (many hours). The overall process involves a series of three subsequent categories of steps: (i) a rapid (approximately 1-2 min) prevesiculation equilibration of micellar sizes.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Effect of cholesterol on Ca2+-induced aggregation of liposomes and calcium diphosphatidate membrane traversal

Sonicated cholesterol-phosphatidylcholine (PC) liposomes containing 4 mol % phosphatidic acid (PA) aggregate in 10 mM Ca2+, slowly at low molar fractions of cholesterol (up to 30%) and 15 times faster at higher concentrations; the inflection point is at ca. 35 mol % bilayer cholesterol. O-[[(Methoxyethoxy)ethoxy]ethyl]cholesterol (OH-blocked cholesterol) does not give this rate enhancement. If PC is replaced by diether PC (CO groups abolished), cholesterol does not accelerate aggregation at concentrations in the bilayer below 50 mol %. No change in Ca2+-induced aggregation rates was observed if the ester CO groups of the bridge-forming PA only were replaced by CH2 (diether PA) in liposomes containing PC and cholesterol. PA-mediated Ca2+ membrane traversal seems to be accelerated by the addition of cholesterol to the PC-PA membrane, but analysis shows that the effect is due to the bilayer condensation effect of cholesterol resulting in an increase in the surface concentration of PA and that membrane cholesterol in fact slightly reduces the rate of Ca(PA)2 traversal; OH-blocked cholesterol, however, increases this rate 3-fold. It appears that lipid OH and CO groups interact, directly or with the mediation of water, in establishing the structure of the membrane "hydrogen belts", i.e., the strata containing those hydrogen-bond donors and acceptors. Cholesterol hydroxyl above 33 mol % (saturation of a 2:1 PC/cholesterol complex?) causes a restructuring of the hydrogen belts that facilitates membrane-water-membrane dehydration, the prerequisite for liposome aggregation by trans-Ca(PA)2 formation. On the other hand, the formation of the dehydrated cis-Ca(PA)2 complex that precedes Ca2+ membrane traversal is not accelerated by presence of the cholesterol hydroxyl group.

Fusion of influenza virus with cardiolipin liposomes at low pH: mass action analysis of kinetics and extent

The kinetics and extent of low pH induced fusion between influenza virus and large unilamellar cardiolipin liposomes were investigated with an assay for lipid mixing based on fluorescence resonance energy transfer. The results were analyzed in terms of a mass action kinetic model, which views the overall fusion reaction as a sequence of a second-order process of virus-liposome adhesion or aggregation followed by the first-order fusion reaction itself. The fluorescence development during the course of the fusion process was calculated by numerical integration, employing separate rate constants for the initial aggregation step and for the subsequent fusion reaction. Analytical solutions were found for several limiting cases. Deaggregation of virus--liposome aggregates was explicitly taken into account but was found to be a minor effect under the conditions studied. The calculations gave good simulations and predictions for the kinetics and extent of fusion at different virus/liposome concentrations and ratios. At pH 5.0 and 37 degrees C, very high rate constants for aggregation and fusion were obtained, and essentially all of the virus particles were involved in the fusion process. Experiments at different virus/liposome ratios showed that fusion products may consist of a single virus particle and several liposomes but not of a single liposome and several virus particles. At pH 6.0, the rate constant for aggregation was the same as at pH 5.0, but the rate constant of fusion was about 5-fold lower, and only 25-40% of the virus particles were capable of fusing with the liposomes. The analytical procedure presented enables elucidation of the crucial role of the composition of target membrane vesicles in the initial adhesion and subsequent fusion of the virus at various pH values.

Ca2+-induced fusion of phosphatidylserine vesicles: mass action kinetic analysis of membrane lipid mixing and aqueous contents mixing

We have investigated the initial kinetics of Ca2+-induced aggregation and fusion of phosphatidylserine large unilamellar vesicles at 3, 5 and 10 mM Ca2+ and 15, 25 and 35 degrees C, utilizing the Tb/dipicolinate (Tb/DPA) assay for mixing of aqueous vesicle contents and a resonance energy transfer (RET) assay for mixing of bilayer lipids. Separate rate constants for vesicle aggregation as well as deaggregation and for the fusion reaction itself were determined by analysis of the data in terms of a mass action kinetic model. At 15 degrees C the aggregation rate constants for either assay are the same, indicating that at this temperature all vesicle aggregation events that result in lipid mixing lead to mixing of aqueous contents as well. By contrast, at 35 degrees C the RET aggregation rate constants are higher than the Tb/DPA aggregation rate constants, indicating a significant frequency of reversible vesicle aggregation events that do result in mixing of bilayer lipids, but not in mixing of aqueous vesicle contents. In any conditions, the RET fusion rate constants are considerably higher than the Tb/DPA fusion rate constants, demonstrating the higher tendency of the vesicles, once aggregated, to mix lipids than to mix aqueous contents. This possibly reflects the formation of an intermediate fusion structure. With increasing Ca2+ concentrations the RET and the Tb/DPA fusion rate constants increase in parallel with the respective aggregation rate constants. This suggests that fusion susceptibility is conferred on the vesicles during the process of vesicle aggregation and not solely as a result of the interaction of Ca2+ with isolated vesicles. Aggregation of the vesicles in the presence of Mg2+ produces neither mixing of aqueous vesicle contents nor mixing of bilayer lipids.

Promotion and inhibition of vesicle fusion by polylysine

Polylysine induced rapid aggregation of large unilamellar vesicles composed of phosphatidylcholine-cardiolipin (1:1 molar ratio) but not their fusion. Application of the terbium-dipicolinic acid fusion assay showed that addition of polylysine at nanomolar concentrations enabled a significant lowering of the Ca2+ threshold concentration for vesicle fusion from 9 to 1 mM. Analysis of the kinetics of fusion with a mass-action kinetic model showed that polylysine enhanced significantly the rate of aggregation but affected only slightly the rate of fusion per se. Maximal enhancement of overall fusion rates occurred at a charge ratio (polylysine/cardiolipin) of about 0.5. At larger polylysine concentrations, e.g., at charge ratios greater than 3, polylysine inhibited vesicle fusion.

Fusogenic capacities of divalent cations and effect of liposome size

The initial kinetics of divalent cation (Ca2+, Ba2+, Sr2+) induced fusion of phosphatidylserine (PS) liposomes, LUV, is examined to obtain the fusion rate constant, f11, for two apposed liposomes as a function of bound divalent cation. The aggregation of dimers is rendered very rapid by having Mg2+ in the electrolyte, so that their subsequent fusion is rate limiting to the overall reaction. In this way the fusion kinetics are observed directly. The bound Mg2+, which by itself is unable to induce the PS LUV to fuse, is shown to affect only the aggregation kinetics when the other divalent cations are present. There is a threshold amount of bound divalent cation below which the fusion rate constant f11 is small and above which it rapidly increases with bound divalent cation. These threshold amounts increase in the sequence Ca2+ less than Ba2+ less than Sr2+, which is the same as found previously for sonicated PS liposomes, SUV. While Mg2+ cannot induce fusion of the LUV and much more bound Sr2+ is required to reach the fusion threshold, for Ca2+ and Ba2+ the threshold is the same for PS SUV and LUV. The fusion rate constant for PS liposomes clearly depends upon the amount and identity of bound divalent cation and the size of the liposomes. However, for Ca2+ and Ba2+, this size dependence manifests itself only in the rate of increase of f11 with bound divalent cation, rather than in any greater intrinsic instability of the PS SUV. The destabilization of PS LUV by Mn2+ and Ni2+ is shown to be qualitatively distinct from that induced by the alkaline earth metals.

Kinetics of pH-dependent fusion between influenza virus and liposomes

The pH-dependent fusion between influenza virus and liposomes (large unilamellar vesicles) has been investigated as a model for the fusion step in the infectious entry of the virus into cells. Fusion was monitored continuously, with a fluorescence assay based on resonance energy transfer (RET) [Struck, D. K., Hoekstra, D., & Pagano, R. E. (1981) Biochemistry 20, 4093-4099], which allows an accurate quantitation of the fusion process. Evidence is presented indicating that the dilution of the RET probes from the liposomal bilayer into the viral membrane is not due to transfer of individual lipid molecules. The initial rate and final extent of the fusion reaction increase dramatically with decreasing pH, fusion being virtually complete within 1 min at pH 4.5-5.0. From experiments in which the ratio of virus to liposomes was varied, it is concluded that virus-liposome fusion products continue to fuse with liposomes, but not with virus. Fusion is most efficient with liposomes consisting of negatively charged phospholipids, while phosphatidylcholine and sphingomyelin are inhibitory. The reaction is completely blocked by an antiserum against the virus and inhibited by pretreatment of the virus with trypsin. The effect of proteolytic pretreatment at pH 7.4 is enhanced after preincubation of the virus at pH 5.0, consistent with the occurrence of a low pH induced, irreversible, conformational change in the viral fusion protein, the hemagglutinin (HA), exposing trypsin cleavage sites. When, after initiation of the fusion reaction at pH 5.0, the pH is readjusted to neutral, the process is arrested instantaneously, indicating that the low pH induced conformational change in the HA protein, in itself, is not sufficient to trigger fusion activity.

H+- and Ca2+-induced fusion and destabilization of liposomes

A new liposome fusion assay has been developed that monitors the mixing of aqueous contents at neutral and low pH. With this assay we have investigated the ability of H+ to induce membrane destabilization and fusion. The assay involves the fluorophore 1-aminonaphthalene-3,6,8-trisulfonic acid (ANTS) and its quencher N,N'-p-xylylenebis(pyridinium bromide) (DPX). ANTS is encapsulated in one population of liposomes and DPX in another, and fusion results in the quenching of ANTS fluorescence. The results obtained with the ANTS/DPX assay at neutral pH give kinetics for the Ca2+-induced fusion of phosphatidylserine large unilamellar vesicles (PS LUV) that are very similar to those obtained with the Tb3+/dipicolinic acid (DPA) assay [Wilschut, J., & Papahadjopoulos, D. (1979) Nature (London) 281, 690-692]. ANTS fluorescence is relatively insensitive to pH between 7.5 and 4.0. Below pH 4.0 the assay can be used semiquantitatively by correcting for quenching of ANTS due to protonation. For PS LUV it was found that, at pH 2.0, H+ by itself causes mixing of aqueous contents, which makes H+ unique among the monovalent cations. We have shown previously that H+ causes a contact-induced leakage from liposomes composed of phosphatidylethanolamine and the charged cholesteryl ester cholesteryl hemisuccinate (CHEMS) at pH 5.0 or below, where CHEMS becomes protonated. Here we show that H+ causes lipid mixing in this pH range but not mixing of aqueous contents. This result affirms the necessity of using both aqueous space and lipid bilayer assays to comprehend the fusion event between two liposomes.