Laboratory properties of cold-adapted influenza B live vaccine strains developed in the US and USSR, and their B/Ann Arbor/1/86 cold-adapted reassortant vaccine candidates

Development of Cross-Reactive Live Attenuated Influenza Vaccine Candidates against Both Lineages of Influenza B Virus

BACKGROUND

Influenza viruses continue to cause a significant social and economic burden globally. Vaccination is recognized as the most effective measure to control influenza. Live attenuated influenza vaccines (LAIVs) are an effective means of preventing influenza, especially among children. A reverse genetics (RG) system is required to rapidly update the antigenic composition of vaccines, as well as to design LAIVs with a broader spectrum of protection. Such a system has been developed for the Russian LAIVs only for type A strains, but not for influenza B viruses (IBV).

METHODS

All genes of the B/USSR/60/69 master donor virus (B60) were cloned into RG plasmids, and the engineered B60, as well as a panel of IBV LAIV reassortants were rescued from plasmid DNAs encoding all viral genes. The engineered viruses were evaluated in vitro and in a mouse model.

RESULTS

The B60 RG system was successfully developed, which made it possible to rescue LAIV reassortants with the desired antigenic composition, including hybrid strains with hemagglutinin and neuraminidase genes belonging to the viruses from different IBV lineages. The LAIV candidate carrying the HA of the B/Victoria-lineage virus and NA from the B/Yamagata-lineage virus demonstrated optimal characteristics in terms of safety, immunogenicity and cross-protection, prompting its further assessment as a broadly protective component of trivalent LAIV.

CONCLUSIONS

The new RG system for B60 MDV allowed the rapid generation of type B LAIV reassortants with desired genome compositions. The generation of hybrid LAIV reassortants with HA and NA genes belonging to the opposite IBV lineages is a promising approach for the development of IBV vaccines with broad cross-protection.

Assessment of trivalent live influenza vaccines in MDCK cell line

We applied a one-step reverse transcriptase real-time PCR (rRT-PCR) analysis using TaqMan technique to evaluate the infectious titers of vaccine strains containing in trivalent live influenza vaccines (LAIVs). The cold-adapted reassortant influenza viruses A/H1N1 pdm09, A/H3N2, B/Yamagata and B/Victoria, included in the composition of the LAIV in 2015-2016, 2017-2018 and 2018-2019 flu season were studied for reproductive activity in MDCK cells as part of a mono-vaccine and tri-vaccine. For this we have developed a set of specific primers and probes. Method validation was performed using ELISA-test after mouse monoclonal antibodies to hemagglutinin (HA) staining of MDCK monolayer. Influenza B viruses B/Yamagata and B/Victoria were studied in MDCK cells in mono-infection and coinfection with different multiplicity of infection (MOI) using quantitative rRT-PCR.•RT-PCR analysis was adjusted to assess the growth characteristics of cold-adapted reassortant influenza viruses in MDCK cell line. The greatest suppression in the composition of the tri-vaccine was exposed to the H1N1 pdm09 LAIV component.•Influenza B viruses are least suppressed in trivalent LAIV. Influenza viruses B/Yamagata and B/Victoria reproduced as part of a mixed preparation not lower, if not better than as a mono-preparation at an MOI of 0.1. At an MOI of 0.01, the reproduction of both B/Yamagata and B/Victoria in the mixture was reduced compared to mono-vaccine.•The interference of trivalent LAIV vaccine viruses in MDCK cells was minimal at low dilutions. This indicates that it is undesirable to reduce the titers of vaccine viruses, including at the stages of transportation and storage of LAIV.

A New Master Donor Virus for the Development of Live-Attenuated Influenza B Virus Vaccines

Influenza B viruses (IBV) circulate annually, with young children, the elderly and immunocompromised individuals being at high risk. Yearly vaccinations are recommended to protect against seasonally influenza viruses, including IBV. Live attenuated influenza vaccines (LAIV) provide the unique opportunity for direct exposure to the antigenically variable surface glycoproteins as well as the more conserved internal components. Ideally, LAIV Master Donor Viruses (MDV) should accurately reflect seasonal influenza strains. Unfortunately, the continuous evolution of IBV have led to significant changes in conserved epitopes compared to the IBV MDV based on B/Ann Arbor/1/1966 strain. Here, we propose a recent influenza B/Brisbane/60/2008 as an efficacious MDV alternative, as its internal viral proteins more accurately reflect those of circulating IBV strains. We introduced the mutations responsible for the temperature sensitive (ts), cold adapted (ca) and attenuated (att) phenotype of B/Ann Arbor/1/1966 MDV LAIV into B/Brisbane/60/2008 to generate a new MDV LAIV. In vitro and in vivo analysis demonstrated that the mutations responsible of the ts, ca, and att phenotype of B/Ann Arbor/1/1966 MDV LAIV were able to infer the same phenotype to B/Brisbane/60/2008, demonstrating its potential as a new MDV for the development of LAIV to protect against contemporary IBV strains.

Study of Neuraminidase-Inhibiting Antibodies in Clinical Trials of Live Influenza Vaccines

Background: Currently, the immunogenicity of influenza vaccines is assessed by detecting an increase of hemagglutination inhibition (HI) antibodies. As neuraminidase (NA)-based immunity may be significant in protecting against influenza infection, detection of neuraminidase inhibiting (NI) antibodies may improve the assessment of the immunogenicity of influenza vaccines. Methods: We investigated the immune response to NA in people after immunization with live influenza vaccines (LAIVs). A number of A/H7NX or A/H6NX viruses were used to detect NI antibodies, using an enzyme-linked lectin assay (ELLA). Results: Seasonal LAIV immunization stimulated an increase in NI antibodies not only to homologous A/H1N1 influenza, but also to A/H1N1pdm09 and A/H5N1 influenza. After A/17/California/09/38 (H1N1) pdm09 LAIV vaccination, there was no statistical relationship between post-vaccinated antibody seroconversion and two surface glycoproteins in serum samples obtained from the same individuals (p = 0.24). Vaccination with LAIV of H5N2, H2N2, H7N3, and H7N9 subtypes led to 7%–29.6% NI antibody seroconversions in the absence of HI antibody conversions. There was relatively low coordination of hemagglutinin (HA) and NA antibody responses (r = 0.24–0.59). Conclusions: The previously noted autonomy for HI and NI immune responses was confirmed when assessing the immunogenicity of LAIVs. Combining the traditional HI test with the detection of NI antibodies can provide a more complete assessment of LAIV immunogenicity.

Alternative Strategy for a Quadrivalent Live Attenuated Influenza Virus Vaccine

Seasonal influenza viruses infect 1 billion people worldwide and are associated with ∼500,000 deaths annually. In addition, the never-ending emergence of zoonotic influenza viruses associated with lethal human infections and of pandemic concern calls for the development of better vaccines and/or vaccination strategies against influenza virus. Regardless of the strategy, novel influenza virus vaccines must aim at providing protection against both seasonal influenza A and B viruses. In this study, we tested an alternative quadrivalent live attenuated influenza virus vaccine (QIV) formulation whose individual components have been previously shown to provide protection. We demonstrate in proof-of principle studies in mice that the QIV provides effective protection against lethal challenge with either influenza A or B virus.

Influenza virus infections continue to pose a major public health threat worldwide associated with seasonal epidemics and sporadic pandemics. Vaccination is considered the first line of defense against influenza. Live attenuated influenza virus vaccines (LAIVs) may provide superior responses compared to inactivated vaccines because the former can better elicit a combination of humoral and cellular responses by mimicking a natural infection. Unfortunately, during the 2013–2014, 2014–2015, and 2015–2016 seasons, concerns emerged about the effectiveness of the only LAIV approved in the United States that prevented the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) from recommending its use. Such drawbacks open up the opportunity for alternative LAIV strategies that could overcome such concerns. Previously, we developed a combined strategy of temperature-sensitive mutations in the PB2 and PB1 segments and an epitope tag in the C terminus of PB1 that effectively attenuates influenza A viruses of avian and mammalian origin. More recently, we adopted a similar strategy for influenza B viruses. The resulting attenuated (att) influenza A and B viruses were safe, immunogenic, and protective against lethal influenza virus challenge in a variety of animal models. In this report, we provide evidence of the potential use of our att strategy in a quadrivalent LAIV (QIV) formulation carrying H3N2 and H1N1 influenza A virus subtype viruses and two antigenic lineages of influenza B viruses. In naive DBA/2J mice, two doses of the QIV elicited hemagglutination inhibition (HI) responses with HI titers of ≥40 and effectively protected against lethal challenge with prototypical pandemic H1N1 influenza A and influenza B virus strains.

IMPORTANCE Seasonal influenza viruses infect 1 billion people worldwide and are associated with ∼500,000 deaths annually. In addition, the never-ending emergence of zoonotic influenza viruses associated with lethal human infections and of pandemic concern calls for the development of better vaccines and/or vaccination strategies against influenza virus. Regardless of the strategy, novel influenza virus vaccines must aim at providing protection against both seasonal influenza A and B viruses. In this study, we tested an alternative quadrivalent live attenuated influenza virus vaccine (QIV) formulation whose individual components have been previously shown to provide protection. We demonstrate in proof-of principle studies in mice that the QIV provides effective protection against lethal challenge with either influenza A or B virus.

Development and identification of a new Vero cell-based live attenuated influenza B vaccine by a modified classical reassortment method

BACKGROUND

It was to generate a new Vero and cold-adapted live attenuated influenza B vaccine with enough safety and immunogenicity.

METHODS

According to modified classical reassortment method, the donor strain was B/Yunnan/2/2005Vca(B), and the parental virus strain was B/Brisbane/60/2008wt. After co-infection in Vero cells, the prepared antibody serum inhibited the donor strain growth, and screening conditions inhibited the parental virus growth, which induced the growth of the new reassortant virus B/Brisbane/60/2008Vca(B) grow. Through intraperitoneal injection (i.j.) and intranasal injection (n.j.) we evaluated the safety and immunogenicity of the vaccine.

RESULTS

A high-yield of the reassortant virus was produced in Vero cells at 25°C, similar to the donor strains. After sequencing, it was found that B/Brisbane/60/2008Vca(B) Hemagglutinin (HA) and Neuraminidase (NA) gene fragments were from B/Brisbane/60/2008wt, while the other 6 gene fragments were from B/Yunnan/2/2005Vca(B). The n.j. immune pathway experiments showed no significant differences between the treatment and the PBS control group with respect to weight changes (P > 0.5). Furthermore, the new strain had a sufficient geometric mean titter (GMT) against B/Brisbane/60/2008wt.

CONCLUSION

The new reassortant live attenuated influenza B vaccine was safe and having enough immune stimulating ability.

Development of an Alternative Modified Live Influenza B Virus Vaccine

Influenza B virus (IBV) is considered a major human pathogen, responsible for seasonal epidemics of acute respiratory illness. Two antigenically distinct IBV hemagglutinin (HA) lineages cocirculate worldwide with little cross-reactivity. Live attenuated influenza virus (LAIV) vaccines have been shown to provide better cross-protective immune responses than inactivated vaccines by eliciting local mucosal immunity and systemic B cell- and T cell-mediated memory responses. We have shown previously that incorporation of temperature-sensitive (ts) mutations into the PB1 and PB2 subunits along with a modified HA epitope tag in the C terminus of PB1 resulted in influenza A viruses (IAV) that are safe and effective as modified live attenuated (att) virus vaccines (IAV att). We explored whether analogous mutations in the IBV polymerase subunits would result in a stable virus with an att phenotype. The PB1 subunit of the influenza B/Brisbane/60/2008 strain was used to incorporate ts mutations and a C-terminal HA tag. Such modifications resulted in a B/Bris att strain with ts characteristics in vitro and an att phenotype in vivo Vaccination studies in mice showed that a single dose of the B/Bris att candidate stimulated sterilizing immunity against lethal homologous challenge and complete protection against heterologous challenge. These studies show the potential of an alternative LAIV platform for the development of IBV vaccines.IMPORTANCE A number of issues with regard to the effectiveness of the LAIV vaccine licensed in the United States (FluMist) have arisen over the past three seasons (2013-2014, 2014-2015, and 2015-2016). While the reasons for the limited robustness of the vaccine-elicited immune response remain controversial, this problem highlights the critical importance of continued investment in LAIV development and creates an opportunity to improve current strategies so as to develop more efficacious vaccines. Our laboratory has developed an alternative strategy, the incorporation of 2 amino acid mutations and a modified HA tag at the C terminus of PB1, which is sufficient to attenuate the IBV. As a LAIV, this novel vaccine provides complete protection against IBV strains. The availability of attenuated IAV and IBV backbones based on contemporary strains offers alternative platforms for the development of LAIVs that may overcome current limitations.

Design of alternative live attenuated influenza virus vaccines

Each year due to the ever-evolving nature of influenza, new influenza vaccines must be produced to provide protection against the influenza viruses in circulation. Currently, there are two mainstream strategies to generate seasonal influenza vaccines: inactivated and live-attenuated. Inactivated vaccines are non-replicating forms of whole influenza virus, while live-attenuated vaccines are viruses modified to be replication impaired. Although it is widely believed that by inducing both mucosal and humoral immune responses the live-attenuated vaccine provides better protection than that of the inactivated vaccine, there are large populations of individuals who cannot safely receive the LAIV vaccine. Thus, safer LAIV vaccines are needed to provide adequate protection to these populations. Improvement is also needed in the area of vaccine production. Current strategies relying on traditional tissue culture-based and egg-based methods are slow and delay production time. This chapter describes experimental vaccine generation and production strategies that address the deficiencies in current methods for potential human and agricultural use.

Protective efficacy in mice of monovalent and trivalent live attenuated influenza vaccines in the background of cold-adapted A/X-31 and B/Lee/40 donor strains

Influenza virus continues to take a heavy toll on human health and vaccination remains the mainstay of efforts to reduce the clinical impact imposed by viral infections. Proven successful for establishing live attenuated vaccine donor strains, cold-adapted live attenuated influenza vaccines (CAIVs) have become an attractive modality for controlling the virus infection. Previously, we developed the cold-adapted strains A/X-31 and B/Lee/40 as novel donor strains of CAIVs against influenza A and B viruses. In this study, we investigated the protective immune responses of both mono- and trivalent vaccine formulations in the mouse model. Two type A vaccines and one type B vaccine against A/New Caledonia/20/99 (H1N1), A/Panama/2007/99 (H3N2), and B/Shangdong/7/97 in the background of the A/X-31 ca or B/Lee/40 ca were generated by a reassortment procedure and evaluated for their immunogenicity and protective efficacy. Each monovalent vaccine elicited high levels of serum antibodies and conferred complete protection against homologous wild type virus infection. As compared to the monovalent vaccines, trivalent formulation induced higher levels of type A-specific serum antibodies and slightly lower levels of type B-specific antibodies, suggesting an immunological synergism within type A viruses and an interference in the replication of type B virus. Relatively lower type B-specific immunogenicity in trivalent vaccine formulation could be effectively implemented by increasing the vaccine dose of influenza B virus. These results of immunogenicity, protection efficacy, and immunological synergism between type A vaccines provide an experimental basis for optimal composition of trivalent vaccines for subsequent developments of multivalent CAIVs against seasonal and pandemic influenza viruses.

Bench-to-bedside review: vaccine protection strategies during pandemic flu outbreaks

Vaccination is the most effective means for the prevention of influenza, including pandemic strains. An ideal pandemic influenza vaccine should provide effective protection with the fewest number of doses in the shortest amount of time, and among the greatest proportion of the population. The current manufacturing processes required for embryonated chicken-egg-based influenza vaccines are limited in their ability to respond to pandemic situations - these limitations include problems with surge capacity, the need for egg-adapted strains, the possibility of contamination, and the presence of trace egg protein. Several vaccine strategies to circumvent the deficiencies intrinsic to an egg-based influenza vaccine are in various phases of development. These include the use of cell-culture-based growth systems, concomitant use of adjuvants, whole virus vaccines, recombinant protein vaccines, plasmid DNA vaccines, virus-like particle vaccines, and universal flu vaccines.

Genetic and phenotypic stability of cold-adapted influenza viruses in a trivalent vaccine administered to children in a day care setting

The genetic and phenotypic stability of viruses isolated from young children following intranasal administration of the trivalent live-attenuated influenza virus vaccine (LAIV, marketed in the United States as FluMist) was evaluated by determination of genomic sequence and assessment of the cold-adapted (ca), temperature-sensitive (ts) and attenuated (att) phenotypes. The complete genomic sequence was determined for 56 independent isolates obtained from children following vaccination (21 type A/H1N1, 12 A/H3N2, 1 A/H3N1 and 22 type B viruses), 20% of which had no nucleotide misincorporations compared with administered vaccine. The remaining isolates had from one to seven changes per genome. None of the observed misincorporations resulted in predicted amino acid codon substitutions at sites previously shown to contribute to the ca, ts or att phenotypes, and all vaccine-derived isolates retained ca and ts phenotypes consistent with the observation that none of the vaccine recipients displayed distinctive symptoms. The results indicate that LAIV strains undergo very limited genetic change following replication in vaccine recipients and that those changes did not affect vaccine attenuation.

Characterization of live influenza vaccine donor strain derived from cold-adaptation of X-31 virus

A human influenza A virus X-31 (high-yielding strain) was cold-adapted for possible future use as live attenuated vaccine. Mutant influenza viruses were selected during successive serial passage in embryonated hens' eggs at progressively lower sub-optimal temperature (30, 27 degrees C followed by 24 degrees C). The cold-passaged mutant exhibited both temperature-sensitivity (ts) and cold-adapted (ca) phenotypes. The pathogenicity and immunogenicity of X-31 ca virus were studied in mice following intranasal inoculation. The mice did not show clinical signs even at high titer infection. Immunization of mice with X-31 ca virus elicited high titers of neutralizing antibody and provided complete protection against homologous and heterologous virus challenges. To assess the genetic stability, the X-31 ca virus was passaged at 37 degrees C in MDCK cells or inoculated into mice. Revertant virus was not found in the lungs of any of the mice and the supernatants of the MDCK culture. We conclude that the X-31 ca candidate vaccine virus exhibits the desired level of attenuation, immunogenicity, and protective efficacy required for live attenuated vaccine and merits further evaluation at clinical level.

Comparative study of influenza virus replication in Vero and MDCK cell lines

The choice of a cell line for the production of influenza vaccines is determined by how well the virus is able to replicate and how easily the cell line can be maintained. Madin-Darby canine kidney (MDCK) cells have long been known to successfully support influenza growth. Vero cells are also another well studied candidate cell line. In this work, we have compared these two cell lines for their ability to propagate type A and type B cold-adapted and wild type influenza viruses. The growth of these viruses has been measured as plaque forming units (via plaque assay) as well as viral particle formation (via a novel quantitative RT-PCR assay) to assess the suitability of these cell lines to support the development of live attenuated influenza vaccines. The novel qRT-PCR assay outlined in this work was demonstrated to be an efficient, sensitive and reproducible method for measuring wild type (wt) and cold-adapted (ca) influenza strains. Replicates of six per sample consistently showed an average variation around +/-10%. In this study we have also found qRT-PCR to be a useful method for differentiating between wt and ca influenza strains based on their differing growth characteristics at varying temperatures. This can subsequently be used to assess reassortants prepared from ca donor strains for the purposes of live viral vaccine development. For type A and B influenza viruses studied in this work, MDCK cells supported a more rapid viral growth (measured in terms of genome copies) compared with Vero cells. For the type A viruses studied here, the genome copies: infectious unit (genome copy, gc:infectious unit, iu) ratio was found to be more favorable for Vero cells compared with MDCK cells. For the type B viruses studied in this work, the gc:iu was equivalent in both cell lines tested. Ultimately, however, the use of any new cell line would need to be approved by regulatory agencies prior to its commercial application.

Cell-based assay for the determination of temperature sensitive and cold adapted phenotypes of influenza viruses

The determination of temperature sensitive (ts) and cold adapted (ca) phenotype for influenza A and B strains has been conducted traditionally using embryonated chicken eggs. As attempts are made to move away from the use of eggs in the manufacturing process of influenza vaccines, it will become useful to develop cell-based assays to support cell culture-based vaccine production. In this study, MDCK cells have been evaluated as a tool for determining the ts and ca phenotypes associated with live attenuated influenza viruses. Direct comparisons were made of these phenotypes carried out in eggs. Reassortants made from the Russian live attenuated influenza donor strains A/Leningrad/134/17/57 (H2N2) and B/USSR/60/69 were prepared entirely in MDCK cells and their phenotypes evaluated using the MDCK cell-based assay. It is concluded that MDCK cells are more sensitive than eggs for the measurement of ts and ca phenotype of influenza viruses (particularly for influenza A) and they provide an alternative means for screening candidate reassortants prior to determining their genome composition.

Preparation and characterisation of attenuated cold-adapted influenza A reassortants derived from the A/Leningrad/134/17/57 donor strain

The development of a rapid cell culture method for the preparation of cold-adapted (ca) influenza A reassortant viruses is described and compared with a currently used egg method. Mixtures of the ca donor A/Leningrad/134/17/57-ca (A/Len/17) and A/Beijing/32/92 (A/Beij/32), a recent H3N2 epidemic strain, were used to co-infect chicken embryo kidney (CEK) cell cultures; reassortant progeny were selected using an infectious centre assay. The assay was capable of detecting interference where the infectivity ratio for A/Len/17 and A/Beij/32 was 1:7. Progeny viruses were characterised genetically by amplification of defined regions within each of the six internal genes by PCR and identification of the products by restriction enzyme analysis. Reassortants were also tested for ca and temperature-sensitive (ts) phenotype and the identity of the surface antigens. The infectious centre assay was shown to be an effective method for isolating reassortant progeny that possessed the haemagglutinin and neuraminidase surface antigens of A/Beij/32. Reassortants with the six internal genes derived from the donor strain and possessing the ca and ts phenotype were readily obtained when (a) an infectivity ratio of 1:49 was used and (b) two plaque-to-plaque isolations of progeny virus were made after growth at 25 degrees C and one at 34 degrees C, both in the presence of antiserum to the donor strain.

Evaluation in children of cold-adapted influenza B live attenuated intranasal vaccine prepared by reassortment between wild-type B/Ann Arbor/1/86 and cold-adapted B/Leningrad/14/55 viruses

A reassortant cold-adapted (ca) influenza B experimental live attenuated intranasal vaccine was evaluated for safety and immunogenicity in children by means of a blind, placebo controlled study. The vaccine contained the haemagglutinin and neuraminidase genes, and the gene for its non-structural proteins from wild-type (wt) B/Ann Arbor/1/86 virus, the contemporary strain at the time of the study. Other genes were derived from ca B/Leningrad/14/55 virus. No increase in illness rates was seen in the children from ages 3-15 years given vaccine at maximum potency (a one in two dilution of infectious allantoic fluid, having a titre of 10(7.0) EID50) compared to children given placebo. About 60% of seronegative children, ages 3-7 years, exhibited a detectible antibody response following one dose of intranasal vaccine, with the seroresponse rate rising to greater than 70% after two doses of vaccine. Immunogenicity was lowest in seropositive children age 8-15 years, reaching a maximum of 36% after two doses. Results indicated that the vaccine was highly attenuated, and probably of adequate immunogenicity for kindergarten age children. The lower immunogenicity in older children suggests the vaccine might be overly attenuated for use in school-age children who are more likely to have a history of prior natural infection with influenza B virus. Further clinical and epidemiological studies of protection are needed to fully assess this.