Large variations in skeletal muscle carnitine level fail to modify energy metabolism in exercising rats

Carnitine Profile and Effect of Suppletion in Children with Renal Fanconi Syndrome due to Cystinosis

BACKGROUND

Cystinosis is an autosomal recessive disorder marked by intralysosomal cystine accumulation. Patients present with generalized proximal tubular dysfunction called renal Fanconi syndrome. Urinary carnitine loss results in plasma and muscle carnitine deficiency, but no clinical signs of carnitine deficiency have been described. Also, the optimal dose of carnitine supplementation is undefined. This study aimed to determine whether currently recommended carnitine doses result in adequate correction of plasma carnitine.

METHODS

Five cystinosis patients with renal Fanconi syndrome, aged 2-18 years, were included. L-carnitine was prescribed 50 mg/kg/day since diagnosis: median 36 (range 18-207) months. Total and free plasma and urine carnitine and carnitine profiles were measured at study onset, after stopping L-carnitine for 3 months and 3 months after reintroducing L-carnitine 50 mg/kg/day.

RESULTS

At study onset, plasma free carnitine was normal in all patients, total carnitine (1/5), acetylcarnitine (3/5), and several short- and medium-chain acylcarnitines ≤10 carbons (5/5) were increased indicating carnitine over-supplementation. Three months after cessation, carnitine profiles normalized and 3/5 patients showed plasma carnitine deficiency. Three months after reintroduction, plasma free carnitine normalized in all patients, however, carnitine profiles were disturbed in 4/5 patients. Urine free carnitine, acetylcarnitine, and acylcarnitines ≤10 carbons were increased in all patients independent of carnitine supplementation.

CONCLUSION

Administration of recommended doses L-carnitine (50 mg/kg/day) resulted in over-supplementation. Although the drug is considered to be rather safe, long-term effects of over-supplementation remain unknown warranting cautious use of high doses. Plasma carnitine profile might be used as a monitor, to prevent overdosing.

Carnitine and Sports Medicine: Use or Abuse?

Carnitine has important roles in skeletal muscle bioenergetics. Skeletal muscle carnitine deficiency is associated with profound impairment of muscle function. It has thus been natural to ask if carnitine supplementation can improve skeletal muscle function and athletic performance in healthy individuals. Oral carnitine doses of several grams cause no significant clinical toxicity, further encouraging the use of carnitine as a supplement. Despite this strong foundation and 20 years of research, no compelling evidence exists that carnitine supplementation can improve physical performance in healthy subjects. The available data have been reviewed in recent publications. Several key issues are relevant to a potential therapeutic benefit of carnitine supplementation, and addressing these may provide insight into trials of carnitine therapy in healthy subjects: (1) Can carnitine supplementation increase skeletal muscle carnitine content in healthy subjects? Muscle carnitine content is not easily increased with carnitine supplementation. This reflects both the systemic pharmacokinetics of carnitine and the systems controlling transmembrane transport of carnitine in skeletal muscle. (2) How much carnitine is required to support optimal metabolism in skeletal muscle? Data are not available to definitively define the relationship between muscle carnitine content and muscle metabolic function. Extrapolation of data from several models suggests that very low amounts of carnitine are required to support muscle function. (3) Does carnitine supplementation alter energy homeostasis in healthy subjects? Several, but not all, studies suggest that subjects on carnitine supplementation have altered regulation of fuel homeostasis. However, the mechanisms of these changes, the tissues affected, and the relevance of these phenomena to exercise performance are all ill defined. (4) How can changes in performance be assessed in healthy subjects? Most studies have failed to demonstrate an objective performance improvement in healthy subjects taking carnitine. However, these negative studies must be interpreted with caution. Performance studies in athletes are conducted against a background of aggressive training regimens and nutritional interventions. Small changes, which may be very important to the athlete, may be very hard to objectify in the laboratory. Assessments must differentiate between changes in maximal aerobic capacity, ability to sustain effort at varied workloads, and the subject's perception of exertion. The interaction of carnitine supplementation with exercise training may be particularly important on theoretical and experimental bases. Systematic research in each of these areas is required to better understand the physiology, biochemistry, and pharmacology of carnitine supplementation. While data do not allow a conclusion to be drawn that carnitine is beneficial, the negative has not been proven either.

The role of carnitine and carnitine supplementation during exercise in man and in individuals with special needs

Carnitine is critical for normal skeletal muscle bioenergetics. Carnitine has a dual role as it is required for long-chain fatty acid oxidation, and also shuttles accumulated acyl groups out of the mitochondria. Muscle requires optimization of both of these metabolic processes during peak exercise performance. Theoretically, carnitine availability may become limiting for either fatty acid oxidation or the removal of acyl-CoAs during exercise. Despite the theoretical basis for carnitine supplementation in otherwise healthy persons to improve exercise performance, clinical data have not demonstrated consistent benefits of carnitine administration. Additionally, most of the anticipated metabolic effects of carnitine supplementation have not been observed in healthy persons. The failure to demonstrate clinical efficacy of carnitine may reflect the complex pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics of carnitine supplementation, the challenges of clinical trial design for performance endpoints, or the adequacy of endogenous carnitine content to meet even extreme metabolic demands in the healthy state. In patients with end stage renal disease there is evidence of impaired cellular metabolism, the accumulation of metabolic intermediates and increased carnitine demands to support acylcarnitine production. Years of nutritional changes and dialysis therapy may also lower skeletal muscle carnitine content in these patients. Preliminary data have demonstrated beneficial effects of carnitine supplementation to improve muscle function and exercise capacity in these patients. Peripheral arterial disease (PAD) is also associated with altered muscle metabolic function and endogenous acylcarnitine accumulation. Therapy with either carnitine or propionylcarnitine has been shown to increase claudication-limited exercise capacity in patients with PAD. Further clinical research is needed to define the optimal use of carnitine and acylcarnitines as therapeutic modalities to improve exercise performance in disease states, and any potential benefit in healthy individuals.

Sodium pivalate reduces cardiac carnitine content and increases glucose oxidation without affecting cardiac functional capacity

This study determined how selected functional, metabolic, and contractile properties were impacted by sodium pivalate, a compound which creates a secondary carnitine deficiency. Young male rats received either sodium pivalate (20 mM, PIV) or sodium bicarbonate (20 mM, CONTR) in their drinking water. After 11-12 weeks cardiac function and glucose oxidation rates were measured in isolated, perfused working heart preparations. Hearts were also analyzed for carnitine content, activities of hexokinase (HK), citrate synthase (CS), and B-hydroxyacyl CoA dehydrogenase (HOAD), and myosin isoenzyme distribution. Sodium pivalate treatment significantly reduced cardiac carnitine content and increased glucose oxidation but did not alter cardiac functional capacity. HK activity was increased in the PIV group (p < 0.05), and HOAD activity decreased (p < 0.05). CS activity and myosin isoform distribution (VI > 85%) remained unchanged. These results demonstrate that pivalate treatment of this duration and the accompanying carnitine deficiency shift cardiac substrate utilization without compromising cardiac functional capacity.

Canine hereditary ceroid-lipofuscinosis: evidence for a defect in the carnitine biosynthetic pathway

The ceroid-lipofuscinoses are a group of autosomal-recessive hereditary lysosomal storage diseases that have been characterized in humans and other mammalian species. In a canine model for the juvenile form of the human disease, a major constituent of the storage bodies is the subunit c protein of mitochondrial ATP synthase that contains an epsilon-N-trimethyllysine (TML) residue. TML is a precursor in carnitine biosynthesis. To determine whether accumulation of the TML-containing protein could result from a defect in the carnitine biosynthetic pathway, plasma carnitine and trimethyllysine levels were measured in homozygous affected, heterozygous carriers, and in normal dogs. When compared top normal animals, mean carnitine levels were reduced by 67% in affected and 50% in carrier dogs. Mean plasma TML levels were elevated almost 50% above control levels in the carriers, but were decreased by approximately 25% in the affected animals. The changes in plasma carnitine and TML levels in the carriers are consistent with the possibility that the disease involves a defect in the carnitine biosynthetic pathway. Secondary effects of the disease process may account for the apparently contradictory decrease in plasma TML levels in affected animals.

Effects of acute hypercarnitinemia during increased fatty substrate oxidation in man

To test whether carnitine availability is rate-limiting for fat oxidation under conditions of augmented oxidative use of fatty substrates, two series of studies were performed. In study no. 1, L-carnitine (1 g + 0.5 g/h intravenously [i.v.]) or saline was given to eight volunteers during a 4-hour infusion of a 10% triglyceride emulsion, thereby increasing plasma free-carnitine levels from 38 +/- 4 to 415 +/- 55 mumol/L. Fat infusion increased plasma triglyceride levels (80%) and lipid oxidation (30%), and decreased (28%) carbohydrate oxidation (as measured by indirect calorimetry); hypercarnitinemia had no influence on these responses. In study no. 2 in 12 healthy subjects a bolus of L-carnitine (3 g) or saline was administered 40 minutes before aerobic exercise (bicycling for 40 minutes at 60 W), followed by 2 minutes of anaerobic exercise (250 W) and 50 minutes of recovery. Oxygen consumption (VO2), increased to 18.3 +/- 0.7 mL.min-1 x kg-1 during aerobic exercise, reached a maximum of 46.0 +/- 0.8 mL.min-1 x kg-1 during the anaerobic bout, and returned to baseline within a few minutes, with no difference between control and carnitine. At virtually identical mean energy expenditure rates (196 +/- 7 v 197 +/- 7 J.min-1 x kg-1, saline v carnitine), after carnitine administration the entire exercise protocol was sustained by a lower mean carbohydrate oxidation rate (42.1 +/- 3.6 v 36.5 +/- 2.3 mumol.min-1 x kg-1, P < .03) and a higher mean lipid oxidation rate (6.7 +/- 1.0 v 8.3 +/- 0.7 mumol.min-1 x kg-1, P < .05).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Biochemical study of different conditions of type 2C muscle fiber in rat

Type 2C muscle fibers were histochemically and biochemically examined under three different conditions in rats: in the neonatal stage, after neonatal denervation and on regenerating process after bupivacaine-induced injury. On histochemical examination, soleus was found to contain up to 90% of type 2C fiber in every condition, whereas both gastrocnemius and extensor digitorum longus contained 40-70%. On biochemical analysis, triglyceride was the smallest and glycogen was the largest in amounts in neonatal muscles, triglyceride was the largest and glycogen was lowest in amount in neonatal denervated muscles, while both triglyceride and glycogen were low in amounts in bupivacaine-treated muscles. These results suggested that although histochemical characteristics are the same, significant differences in biochemical properties exist between type 2C fibers in these three different conditions.