Photoactivated state of rhodopsin and how it can form

Interdisciplinary biophysical studies of membrane proteins bacteriorhodopsin and rhodopsin

The centenary of the birth of H. Gobind Khorana provides an auspicious opportunity to review the origins and evolution of parallel advances in biophysical methodology and molecular genetics technology used to study membrane proteins. Interdisciplinary work in the Khorana laboratory in the late 1970s and for the next three decades led to productive collaborations and fostered three subsequent scientific generations whose biophysical work on membrane proteins has led to detailed elucidation of the molecular mechanisms of energy transduction by the light-driven proton pump bacteriorhodopsin (bR) and signal transduction by the G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) rhodopsin. This review will highlight the origins and advances of biophysical studies of membrane proteins made possible by the application of molecular genetics approaches to engineer site-specific alterations of membrane protein structures.

Activation of neurotrophin signalling with light‑inducible receptor tyrosine kinases

Optogenetics combined with protein engineering based on natural light-sensitive dimerizing proteins has evolved as a powerful strategy to study cellular functions. The present study focused on tropomyosin kinase receptors (Trks) that have been engineered to be light-sensitive. Trk belongs to the superfamily of receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs), which are single-pass transmembrane receptors that are activated by natural ligands and serve crucial roles in cellular growth, differentiation, metabolism and motility. However, functional variations exist among receptors fused with light-sensitive proteins. The present study proposed a signal transduction model for light-induced receptor activation. This model is based on analysis of previous light-induced Trk receptors reported to date and comparisons to the activation mechanism of natural receptors. In this model, quantitative differences on the dimerization induced from either top-to-bottom or bottom-to-up may lead to the varying amplitude of intracellular signals. We hypothesize that the top-to-bottom propagation is more favourable for activation and yields better results compared with the bottom-to-top direction. The careful delineation of the dimerization mechanisms fine-tuning activation will guide future design for an optimum cellular output with the precision of light.

The arrestin-1 finger loop interacts with two distinct conformations of active rhodopsin

Signaling of the prototypical G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) rhodopsin through its cognate G protein transducin (G_t) is quenched when arrestin binds to the activated receptor. Although the overall architecture of the rhodopsin/arrestin complex is known, many questions regarding its specificity remain unresolved. Here, using FTIR difference spectroscopy and a dual pH/peptide titration assay, we show that rhodopsin maintains certain flexibility upon binding the "finger loop" of visual arrestin (prepared as synthetic peptide ArrFL-1). We found that two distinct complexes can be stabilized depending on the protonation state of E3.49 in the conserved (D)ERY motif. Both complexes exhibit different interaction modes and affinities of ArrFL-1 binding. The plasticity of the receptor within the rhodopsin/ArrFL-1 complex stands in contrast to the complex with the C terminus of the G_t α-subunit (GαCT), which stabilizes only one specific substate out of the conformational ensemble. However, G_t α-subunit binding and both ArrFL-1-binding modes involve a direct interaction to conserved R3.50, as determined by site-directed mutagenesis. Our findings highlight the importance of receptor conformational flexibility and cytoplasmic proton uptake for modulation of rhodopsin signaling and thereby extend the picture provided by crystal structures of the rhodopsin/arrestin and rhodopsin/ArrFL-1 complexes. Furthermore, the two binding modes of ArrFL-1 identified here involve motifs of conserved amino acids, which indicates that our results may have elucidated a common modulation mechanism of class A GPCR-G protein/-arrestin signaling.

Allosteric Coupling of Drug Binding and Intracellular Signaling in the A2A Adenosine Receptor

Signaling across cellular membranes, the 826 human G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) govern a wide range of vital physiological processes, making GPCRs prominent drug targets. X-ray crystallography provided GPCR molecular architectures, which also revealed the need for additional structural dynamics data to support drug development. Here, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy with the wild-type-like A2A adenosine receptor (A2AAR) in solution provides a comprehensive characterization of signaling-related structural dynamics. All six tryptophan indole and eight glycine backbone 15N-1H NMR signals in A2AAR were individually assigned. These NMR probes provided insight into the role of Asp522.50 as an allosteric link between the orthosteric drug binding site and the intracellular signaling surface, revealing strong interactions with the toggle switch Trp 2466.48, and delineated the structural response to variable efficacy of bound drugs across A2AAR. The present data support GPCR signaling based on dynamic interactions between two semi-independent subdomains connected by an allosteric switch at Asp522.50.

The Molecular Switching Mechanism at the Conserved D(E)RY Motif in Class-A GPCRs

The disruption of ionic and H-bond interactions between the cytosolic ends of transmembrane helices TM3 and TM6 of class-A (rhodopsin-like) G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) is a hallmark for their activation by chemical or physical stimuli. In the bovine photoreceptor rhodopsin, this is accompanied by proton uptake at Glu(134) in the class-conserved D(E)RY motif. Studies on TM3 model peptides proposed a crucial role of the lipid bilayer in linking protonation to stabilization of an active state-like conformation. However, the molecular details of this linkage could not be resolved and have been addressed in this study by molecular dynamics (MD) simulations on TM3 model peptides in a bilayer of 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC). We show that protonation of the conserved glutamic acid alters the peptide insertion depth in the membrane, its side-chain rotamer preferences, and stabilizes the C-terminal helical structure. These factors contribute to the rise of the side-chain pKa (> 6) and to reduced polarity around the TM3 C terminus as confirmed by fluorescence spectroscopy. Helix stabilization requires the protonated carboxyl group; unexpectedly, this stabilization could not be evoked with an amide in MD simulations. Additionally, time-resolved Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy of TM3 model peptides revealed a different kinetics for lipid ester carbonyl hydration, suggesting that the carboxyl is linked to more extended H-bond clusters than an amide. Remarkably, this was seen as well in DOPC-reconstituted Glu(134)- and Gln(134)-containing bovine opsin mutants and demonstrates that the D(E)RY motif is a hydrated microdomain. The function of the D(E)RY motif as a proton switch is suggested to be based on the reorganization of the H-bond network at the membrane interface.

Origin and control of the dominant time constant of salamander cone photoreceptors

Recovery of the light response in vertebrate photoreceptors requires the shutoff of both active intermediates in the phototransduction cascade: the visual pigment and the transducin–phosphodiesterase complex. Whichever intermediate quenches more slowly will dominate photoresponse recovery. In suction pipette recordings from isolated salamander ultraviolet- and blue-sensitive cones, response recovery was delayed, and the dominant time constant slowed when internal [Ca²⁺] was prevented from changing after a bright flash by exposure to 0Ca²⁺/0Na⁺ solution. Taken together with a similar prior observation in salamander red-sensitive cones, these observations indicate that the dominance of response recovery by a Ca²⁺-sensitive process is a general feature of amphibian cone phototransduction. Moreover, changes in the external pH also influenced the dominant time constant of red-sensitive cones even when changes in internal [Ca²⁺] were prevented. Because the cone photopigment is, uniquely, exposed to the external solution, this may represent a direct effect of protons on the equilibrium between its inactive Meta I and active Meta II forms, consistent with the notion that the process dominating recovery of the bright flash response represents quenching of the active Meta II form of the cone photopigment.

Structure and pH sensitivity of the transmembrane segment 3 of rhodopsin

Activation of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) originates in ligand-induced protein conformational changes that are transmitted to the cytosolic receptor surface. In the photoreceptor rhodopsin, and possibly other rhodopsin-like GPCRs, protonation of a carboxylic acid in the conserved E(D)RY motif at the cytosolic end of transmembrane helix 3 (TM3) is coupled to receptor activation. Here, we have investigated the structure of synthetic peptides derived from rhodopsin TM3. Polarized FTIR spectroscopy reveals a helical structure of a 31-mer TM3 peptide reconstituted into PC vesicles with a large tilt of 40-50 degrees of the helical axis relative to the membrane normal. Helical structure is also observed for the TM3 peptide in detergent micelles and depends on pH, especially in the C-terminal sequence. In addition, the fluorescence emission of the single tyrosine of the D(E)RY motif in the TM3 peptide exhibits a pronounced pH sensitivity that is abolished when Glu is replaced by Gln, demonstrating that protonation of the conserved Glu side chain affects the structure in the environment of the D(E)RY motif of TM3. The pH regulation of the C-terminal TM3 structure may be an intrinsic feature of the E(D)RY motif in other class I receptors, allowing the coupling of protonation and conformation of membrane-exposed residues in full-length GPCRs.

The role of Glu181 in the photoactivation of rhodopsin

The visual pigment rhodopsin is a prototypical seven transmembrane helical G protein-coupled receptor. Photoisomerization of its protonated Schiff base (PSB) retinylidene chromophore initiates a progression of metastable intermediates. We studied the structural dynamics of receptor activation by FTIR spectroscopy of recombinant pigments. Formation of the active state, Meta II, is characterized by neutralization of the PSB and its counterion Glu113. We focused on testing the hypothesis of a PSB counterion switch from Glu113 to Glu181 during the transition of rhodopsin to the still inactive Meta I photointermediate. Our results, especially from studies of the E181Q mutant, support the view that both Glu113 and Glu181 are deprotonated, forming a complex counterion to the PSB in rhodopsin, and that the function of the primary counterion shifts from Glu113 to Glu181 during the transition to Meta I. The Meta I conformation in the E181Q mutant is less constrained compared with that of wild-type Meta I. In particular, the hydrogen bonded network linking transmembrane helices 1, 2, and 7, adopts a conformation that is already Meta II-like, while other parts of the receptor appear to be in a Meta I-like conformation similar to wild-type. We conclude that Glu181 is responsible, in part, for controlling the extraordinary high pK(a) of the chromophore PSB in the dark state, which very likely decreases upon transition to Meta I in a stepwise weakening of the interaction between PSB and its complex counterion during the course of receptor activation. A model for the specific role in coupling chromophore isomerization to protein conformational changes concomitant with receptor activation is presented.

Role of the Retinal Hydrogen Bond Network in Rhodopsin Schiff Base Stability and Hydrolysis

Little is known about the molecular mechanism of Schiff base hydrolysis in rhodopsin. We report here our investigation into this process focusing on the role of amino acids involved in a hydrogen bond network around the retinal Schiff base. We find conservative mutations in this network (T94I, E113Q, S186A, E181Q, Y192F, and Y268F) increase the activation energy (E(a)) and abolish the concave Arrhenius plot normally seen for Schiff base hydrolysis in dark state rhodopsin. Interestingly, two mutants (T94I and E113Q) show dramatically faster rates of Schiff base hydrolysis in dark state rhodopsin, yet slower hydrolysis rates in the active MII form. We find deuterium affects the hydrolysis process in wild-type rhodopsin, exhibiting a specific isotope effect of approximately 2.5, and proton inventory studies indicate that multiple proton transfer events occur during the process of Schiff base hydrolysis for both dark state and MII forms. Taken together, our study demonstrates the importance of the retinal hydrogen bond network both in maintaining Schiff base integrity in dark state rhodopsin, as well as in catalyzing the hydrolysis and release of retinal from the MII form. Finally, we note that the dramatic alteration of Schiff base stability caused by mutation T94I may play a causative role in congenital night blindness as has been suggested by the Oprian and Garriga laboratories.

Rhodopsin photoproducts in 2D crystals

The published electron microscope and X-ray structures of rhodopsin have made available a detailed picture of the inactive dark state of rhodopsin. Yet, the photointermediates of rhodopsin that ultimately lead to the activated receptor species still await a similar analysis. Such an analysis first requires the generation and characterization of the photoproducts that can be obtained in crystals of rhodopsin. We therefore studied with Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) difference spectroscopy the photoproducts in 2D crystals of bovine rhodopsin in a p22(1)2(1) crystal form. The spectra obtained by cryotrapping revealed that in this crystal form the still inactive early intermediates batho, lumi, and meta I are similar to those obtained from rhodopsin in native disk membranes, although the transition from lumi to meta I is shifted to a higher temperature. However, at room temperature, the formation of the active state, meta II, is blocked in the crystalline environment. Instead, an intermediate state is formed that bears some features of meta II but lacks the specific conformational changes required for activity. Despite being unable to activate its cognate G protein, transducin, to a significant extent, this intermediate state is capable of interacting with functional transducin-derived peptides to a limited extent. Therefore, while unable to support formation of rhodopsin's active state meta II, 2D p22(1)2(1) crystals proved to be very suitable for determining 3D structures of its still inactive precursors, batho, lumi, and meta I. In future studies, FTIR spectroscopy may serve as a sensitive assay to screen crystals grown under altered conditions for potential formation of the active state, meta II.

Fourier transform IR spectroscopy study for new insights into molecular properties and activation mechanisms of visual pigment rhodopsin

Fourier transform IR (FTIR) spectroscopy has been successfully applied in recent years to examine the functional and structural properties of the membrane protein rhodopsin, a prototype G protein coupled receptor. Unlike UV-visible spectroscopy, FTIR spectroscopy is structurally sensitive. It may give us both global information about the conformation of the protein and very detailed information about the retinal chromophore and all other functional groups, even when these are not directly related to the chromophore. Furthermore, it can be successfully applied to the photointermediates of rhodopsin, including the active receptor species, metarhodopsin II, and its decay products, which is not expected presently or even in the near future from crystallographic approaches. In this review we show how FTIR spectroscopy has significantly contributed to the understanding of very different aspects of rhodopsin, comprising both structural properties and the mechanisms leading to receptor activation and deactivation.

Unusual thermal and conformational properties of the rhodopsin congenital night blindness mutant Thr-94 --> Ile

Naturally occurring point mutations in the opsin gene cause the retinal diseases retinitis pigmentosa and congenital night blindness. Although these diseases involve similar mutations in very close locations in rhodopsin, their progression is very different, with retinitis pigmentosa being severe and causing retinal degeneration. We report on the expression and characterization of the recently found T94I mutation associated with congenital night blindness, in the second transmembrane helix or rhodopsin, and mutations at the same site. T94I mutant rhodopsin folded properly and was able to bind 11-cis-retinal to form chromophore, but it showed a blue-shifted visible band at 478 nm and reduced molar extinction coefficient. Furthermore, T94I showed dramatically reduced thermal stability, extremely long lived metarhodopsin II intermediate, and highly increased reactivity toward hydroxylamine in the dark, when compared with wild type rhodopsin. The results are consistent with the location of Thr-94 in close proximity to Glu-113 counterion in the vicinity of the Schiff base linkage and suggest a role for this residue in maintaining the correct dark inactive conformation of the receptor. The reported results, together with previously published data on the other two known congenital night blindness mutants, suggest that the molecular mechanism underlying this disease may not be structural misfolding, as proposed for retinitis pigmentosa mutants, but abnormal functioning of the receptor by decreased thermal stability and/or constitutive activity.

Rhodopsin with 11-cis-locked chromophore is capable of forming an active state photoproduct

The visual pigment rhodopsin is characterized by an 11-cis retinal chromophore bound to Lys-296 via a protonated Schiff base. Following light absorption the C(11)=C(12) double bond isomerizes to trans configuration and triggers protein conformational alterations. These alterations lead to the formation of an active intermediate (Meta II), which binds and activates the visual G protein, transducin. We have examined by UV-visible and Fourier transform IR spectroscopy the photochemistry of a rhodopsin analogue with an 11-cis-locked chromophore, where cis to trans isomerization around the C(11)=C(12) double bond is prevented by a 6-member ring structure (Rh(6.10)). Despite this lock, the pigment was found capable of forming an active photoproduct with a characteristic protein conformation similar to that of native Meta II. This intermediate is further characterized by a protonated Schiff base and protonated Glu-113, as well as by its ability to bind a transducin-derived peptide previously shown to interact efficiently with native Meta II. The yield of this active photointermediate is pH-dependent and decreases with increasing pH. This study shows that with the C(11)=C(12) double bond being locked, isomerization around the C(9)=C(10) or the C(13)=C(14) double bonds may well lead to an activation of the receptor. Additionally, prolonged illumination at pH 7.5 produces a new photoproduct absorbing at 385 nm, which, however, does not exhibit the characteristic active protein conformation.

Rhodopsin: insights from recent structural studies

The recent report of the crystal structure of rhodopsin provides insights concerning structure-activity relationships in visual pigments and related G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs). The seven transmembrane helices of rhodopsin are interrupted or kinked at multiple sites. An extensive network of interhelical interactions stabilizes the ground state of the receptor. The ligand-binding pocket of rhodopsin is remarkably compact, and several chromophore-protein interactions were not predicted from mutagenesis or spectroscopic studies. The helix movement model of receptor activation, which likely applies to all GPCRs of the rhodopsin family, is supported by several structural elements that suggest how light-induced conformational changes in the ligand-binding pocket are transmitted to the cytoplasmic surface. The cytoplasmic domain of the receptor includes a helical domain extending from the seventh transmembrane segment parallel to the bilayer surface. The cytoplasmic surface appears to be approximately large enough to bind to the transducin heterotrimer in a one-to-one complex. The structural basis for several unique biophysical properties of rhodopsin, including its extremely low dark noise level and high quantum efficiency, can now be addressed using a combination of structural biology and various spectroscopic methods. Future high-resolution structural studies of rhodopsin and other GPCRs will form the basis to elucidate the detailed molecular mechanism of GPCR-mediated signal transduction.

Conformations of the active and inactive states of opsin

The signaling state metarhodopsin II of the visual pigment rhodopsin decays to the apoprotein opsin and all-trans retinal, which are then regenerated to rhodopsin by the visual cycle. Opsin is known to have at neutral pH only a small residual constitutive activity toward its G protein transducin, which is thought to play a considerable role in light adaptation (bleaching desensitization). In this study we show with Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy that after metarhodopsin II decay, opsin exists in two conformational states that are in a pH-dependent equilibrium at 30 degrees C with a pK of 4.1 in the presence of hydroxylamine scavenging the endogenous all-trans retinal. Despite the lack of the native agonist in its binding pocket, the low pH opsin conformation is very similar to that of metarhodopsin II and is likewise stabilized by peptides derived from rhodopsin's cognate G protein, transducin. The high pH form, on the other hand, has some conformational similarity to the inactive metarhodopsin I state. We therefore conclude that the opsin apoprotein displays intrinsic conformational states that are merely modulated by bound all-trans retinal.

Rhodopsin: structural basis of molecular physiology

The crystal structure of rod cell visual pigment rhodopsin was recently solved at 2.8-A resolution. A critical evaluation of a decade of structure-function studies is now possible. It is also possible to begin to explain the structural basis for several unique physiological properties of the vertebrate visual system, including extremely low dark noise levels as well as high gain and color detection. The ligand-binding pocket of rhodopsin is remarkably compact, and several apparent chromophore-protein interactions were not predicted from extensive mutagenesis or spectroscopic studies. The transmembrane helices are interrupted or kinked at multiple sites. An extensive network of interhelical interactions stabilizes the ground state of the receptor. The helix movement model of receptor activation, which might apply to all G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) of the rhodopsin family, is supported by several structural elements that suggest how light-induced conformational changes in the ligand-binding pocket are transmitted to the cytoplasmic surface. The cytoplasmic domain of the receptor is remarkable for a carboxy-terminal helical domain extending from the seventh transmembrane segment parallel to the bilayer surface. Thus the cytoplasmic surface appears to be approximately the right size to bind to the transducin heterotrimer in a one-to-one complex. Future high-resolution structural studies of rhodopsin and other GPCRs will form a basis to elucidate the detailed molecular mechanism of GPCR-mediated signal transduction.

Confronting complexity: the interlink of phototransduction and retinoid metabolism in the vertebrate retina

Absorption of light by rhodopsin or cone pigments in photoreceptors triggers photoisomerization of their universal chromophore, 11-cis-retinal, to all-trans-retinal. This photoreaction is the initial step in phototransduction that ultimately leads to the sensation of vision. Currently, a great deal of effort is directed toward elucidating mechanisms that return photoreceptors to the dark-adapted state, and processes that restore rhodopsin and counterbalance the bleaching of rhodopsin. Most notably, enzymatic isomerization of all-trans-retinal to 11-cis-retinal, called the visual cycle (or more properly the retinoid cycle), is required for regeneration of these visual pigments. Regeneration begins in rods and cones when all-trans-retinal is reduced to all-trans-retinol. The process continues in adjacent retinal pigment epithelial cells (RPE), where a complex set of reactions converts all-trans-retinol to 11-cis-retinal. Although remarkable progress has been made over the past decade in understanding the phototransduction cascade, our understanding of the retinoid cycle remains rudimentary. The aim of this review is to summarize recent developments in our current understanding of the retinoid cycle at the molecular level, and to examine the relevance of these reactions to phototransduction.

Electrical approach to study rhodopsin activation in single cells with early receptor current assay

The ERC is a conformation-dependent charge motion similar to the gating currents of ionic channels. Both the waveforms and bandwidth of ERCs and ionic channel gating currents are similar, providing support to the initial suggestion that the ERP was a kind of gating current. In ionic channels the electrostatic field promotes motion of alpha-helical elements that stimulate large-scale molecular events that promote opening of the ionic pore. In ionic channels gating currents of expressed channel mutants has contributed significantly to understanding the mechanism of activation. Given the known role of electrical processes to rhodopsin activation, the ERC approach applied to mutant and wild-type visual pigments is likely to lead to a fuller understanding of the mechanism of conformational activation. This method is currently well suited to investigate the later phases of rhodopsin activation that are thought to be electrostatic in nature. We anticipate that ERC studies will make significant contributions to understanding how the breakdown of the electrostatic interaction between the PSB and its counterion is initiated and propagated to induce the proton uptake on the cytoplasmic surface of the pigment and the shaping of the transducin docking domain. We encourage collaboration to apply the ERC methodology to interesting mutant pigments and retinal analogs. We expect that the ERC methodology can soon be applied to understand rapid charge displacements associated with photochemistry (i.e., R1), the effects of transduction proteins on R2, and the measurement of electrical processes during cone visual pigment activation.

The ecology of visual pigments

The visual systems of vertebrates have adapted to function in photic environments ranging from the broad spectrum of full sunlight to almost total darkness, including the restricted spectral ranges found in different coloured aquatic environments. Such adaptations are immediately obvious at the level of retinal photoreceptors. The basic vertebrate photoreceptor pattern consists of rods and four spectrally distinct classes of cone that span the spectrum from the near ultraviolet to the far red. This arrangement is found in many diurnal species including shallow-living teleosts, reptiles and birds, but is noticeably absent in mammals. In freshwater teleosts the visual pigments may be porphyropsins which have maximum sensitivities displaced to longer wavelengths than their equivalent rhodopsins. Water acts as a monochromator, so that with increasing depth the spectral range of the ambient light is restricted, primarily at long wavelengths. Therefore, at depth the down-welling daylight is not only attenuated in intensity, but is restricted to a narrow spectral band centred around 470 nm. Closely related species that live at increasing depths show a loss of long-wave-sensitive cones and a displacement of the maximum sensitivities of middle-wave-sensitive cones and rods to shorter wavelengths. Such species offer a natural model for determining specific amino acids in opsin responsible for the spectral tuning of these middle-wave-sensitive pigments.

Signalling states of photoactivated rhodopsin

In microseconds after photoexcitation, rhodopsin forms the Meta I intermediate from lumirhodopsin. In this conversion, contacts between retinal and the apoprotein are formed, which result in a defined arrangement of donor and acceptor groups for proton translocations. A system of protonation-dependent coupled equilibria is now adopted, comprising Meta intermediates I, II and III, and their isospectral subforms. Some Meta states were identified as signalling states, in which the receptor interacts with transducin (Gt), rhodopsin kinase (RK) and arrestin. The binding of Gt or arrestin shifts the equilibrium to Meta II, while RK does not, indicating exposure of the RK binding site(s) before Meta II is formed. On contact with the activated receptor, each signalling protein responds with a conformational change, which transforms it into a functionally active state. The bell-shaped pH/rate profiles which are seen for the activation of both the G protein and the receptor kinase, indicate the necessary protonation and deprotonation of groups with different pKa. The right wing of the profile reflects the formation of the protonated subconformation (termed MIIb) of Meta II. For the interaction with Gt, recent work suggests a 'sequential fit' mechanism, involving the recognition of the C-terminal peptide of the Gt alpha subunit and of the farnesylated C-terminus of the gamma subunit. Isolated peptides derived from these portions of the G protein mimic the left wing of the pH/rate profile. We discuss the sequential fit as a time-ordered sequence of microscopic recognition and conformational interlocking in the interaction with the G protein.

Normal and mutant rhodopsin activation measured with the early receptor current in a unicellular expression system

The early receptor current (ERC) represents molecular charge movement during rhodopsin conformational dynamics. To determine whether this time-resolved assay can probe various aspects of structure-function relationships in rhodopsin, we first measured properties of expressed normal human rhodopsin with ERC recordings. These studies were conducted in single fused giant cells containing on the order of a picogram of regenerated pigment. The action spectrum of the ERC of normal human opsin regenerated with 11-cis-retinal was fit by the human rhodopsin absorbance spectrum. Successive flashes extinguished ERC signals consistent with bleaching of a rhodopsin photopigment with a normal range of photosensitivity. ERC signals followed the univariance principle since millisecond-order relaxation kinetics were independent of the wavelength of the flash stimulus. After signal extinction, dark adaptation without added 11-cis-retinal resulted in spontaneous pigment regeneration from an intracellular store of chromophore remaining from earlier loading. After the ERC was extinguished, 350-nm flashes overlapping metarhodopsin-II absorption promoted immediate recovery of ERC charge motions identified by subsequent 500-nm flashes. Small inverted R(2) signals were seen in response to some 350-nm flashes. These results indicate that the ERC can be photoregenerated from the metarhodopsin-II state. Regeneration with 9-cis-retinal permits recording of ERC signals consistent with flash activation of isorhodopsin. We initiated structure-function studies by measuring ERC signals in cells expressing the D83N and E134Q mutant human rhodopsin pigments. D83N ERCs were simplified in comparison with normal rhodopsin, while E134Q ERCs had only the early phase of charge motion. This study demonstrates that properties of normal rhodopsin can be accurately measured with the ERC assay and that a structure-function investigation of rapid activation processes in analogue and mutant visual pigments is feasible in a live unicellular environment.

Signal transfer from rhodopsin to the G-protein: evidence for a two-site sequential fit mechanism

Photoactivation of the retinal photoreceptor rhodopsin proceeds through a cascade of intermediates, resulting in protein-protein interactions catalyzing the activation of the G-protein transducin (Gt). Using stabilization and photoregeneration of the receptor's signaling state and Gt activation assays, we provide evidence for a two-site sequential fit mechanism of Gt activation. We show that the C-terminal peptide from the Gt gamma-subunit, Gtgamma(50-71)farnesyl, can replace the holoprotein in stabilizing rhodopsin's active intermediate metarhodopsin II (MII). However, the peptide cannot replace the Gtbeta gamma complex in direct activation assays. Competition by Gtgamma(50-71)farnesyl with Gt for the active receptor suggests a pivotal role for Gtbeta gamma in signal transfer from MII to Gt. MII stabilization and competition is also found for the C-terminal peptide from the Gt alpha-subunit, Gtalpha(340-350), but the capacity of this peptide to interfere in MII-Gt interactions is paradoxically low compared with its activity to stabilize MII. Besides this disparity, the pH profiles of competition with Gt are characteristically different for the two peptides. We propose a two-site sequential fit model for signal transfer from the activated receptor, R*, to the G-protein. In the center of the model is specific recognition of conformationally distinct sites of R* by Gtalpha(340-350) and Gtgamma(50-71)farnesyl. One matching pair of domains on the proteins would, on binding, lead to a conformational change in the G-protein and/or receptor, with subsequent binding of the second pair of domains. This process could be the structural basis for GDP release and the formation of a stable empty site complex that is ready to receive the activating cofactor, GTP.

Opioid receptor three-dimensional structures from distance geometry calculations with hydrogen bonding constraints

Three-dimensional structures of the transmembrane, seven alpha-helical domains and extracellular loops of delta, mu, and kappa opioid receptors, were calculated using the distance geometry algorithm, with hydrogen bonding constraints based on the previously developed general model of the transmembrane alpha-bundle for rhodopsin-like G-protein coupled receptors (Biophys. J. 1997. 70:1963). Each calculated opioid receptor structure has an extensive network of interhelical hydrogen bonds and a ligand-binding crevice that is partially covered by a beta-hairpin formed by the second extracellular loop. The binding cavities consist of an inner "conserved region" composed of 18 residues that are identical in delta, mu, and kappa opioid receptors, and a peripheral "variable region," composed of 19 residues that are different in delta, mu, and kappa subtypes and are responsible for the subtype specificity of various ligands. Sixteen delta-, mu-, or kappa-selective, conformationally constrained peptide and nonpeptide opioid agonists and antagonists and affinity labels were fit into the binding pockets of the opioid receptors. All ligands considered have a similar spatial arrangement in the receptors, with the tyramine moiety of alkaloids or Tyr1 of opioid peptides interacting with conserved residues in the bottom of the pocket and the tyramine N+ and OH groups forming ionic interactions or H-bonds with a conserved aspartate from helix III and a conserved histidine from helix VI, respectively. The central, conformationally constrained fragments of the opioids (the disulfide-bridged cycles of the peptides and various ring structures in the nonpeptide ligands) are oriented approximately perpendicular to the tyramine and directed toward the extracellular surface. The results obtained are qualitatively consistent with ligand affinities, cross-linking studies, and mutagenesis data.

G-protein diseases furnish a model for the turn-on switch

How does a trimeric G protein on the inside of a cell membrane respond to activation by a transmembrane receptor? G-protein mutations in patients with hypertension and inherited endocrine disorders enhance or block signals from stimulated receptors. In combination with three-dimensional crystal structures and results from biochemical experiments, the phenotypes produced by these mutations suggest a model for the molecular activation mechanism that relays hormonal and sensory signals transmitted by many transmembrane receptors.

Variations on a molecular switch: transport and sensory signalling by archaeal rhodopsins

The archaeal rhodopsins are a family of seven-transmembrane-helix, visual pigment-like proteins found in Halobacterium salinarum and related halophilic Archaea. Two, bacteriorhodopsin (BR) and halorhodopsin (HR), are transport rhodopsins that carry out light-driven electrogenic translocation of protons and chloride, respectively, across the cell membrane. The other two, sensory rhodopsins I and II (SRI and SRII), are phototaxis receptors that send signals to tightly bound transducer proteins that in turn control a phosphorylation cascade modulating the cell's flagellar motors. Recent progress has cast light on how nature has modified the common design of these proteins to carry out their distinctly different functions: electrogenic ion transport and non-electrogenic signal transduction. A key shared mechanism between BR and SRII appears to be an interhelical salt bridge locked conformational switch that is released by photoisomerization of retinal. In BR disruption of the lock opens a cytoplasmic half-channel that ensures uptake of the transported proton from the cytoplasmic side of the membrane at a critical time in the pumping cycle. Transducer-free SRI uses the same mechanism to carry out light-driven proton transport, but interaction with its transducer blocks the cytoplasmic half-channel thereby interrupting the transport cycle. In SRI, transducer interaction also disrupts the salt bridge in the dark, poising the receptor in an intermediate conformation able to produce opposite signals depending on the colour of the stimulus light. A model for signalling is proposed in which the salt bridge-controlled half-channel is used to modulate interaction with the Htr proteins when the receptor signalling states are formed.

Rhodopsin: a prototypical G protein-coupled receptor

A variety of spectroscopic and biochemical studies of recombinant site-directed mutants of rhodopsin and related visual pigments have been reported over the past 9 years. These studies have elucidated key structural elements common to visual pigments. In addition, systematic analysis of the chromophore-binding pocket in rhodopsin and cone pigments has led to an improved understanding of the mechanism of the opsin shift, and of particular molecular determinants underlying color vision in humans. Identification of the conformational changes that occur on rhodopsin photoactivation has been of particular recent concern. Assignments of light-dependent molecular alterations to specific regions of the chromophore have also been attempted by studying native opsins regenerated with synthetic retinal analogs. Site-directed mutagenesis of rhodopsin has also provided useful information about the retinal-binding pocket and the molecular mechanism of rhodopsin photoactivation. Individual molecular groups have been identified to undergo structural alterations or environmental changes during photoactivation. Analysis of particular mutant pigments in which specific groups are locked into their respective "off" or "on" states has provided a framework to identify determinants of the active conformation, as well as the minimal number of intramolecular transitions required to switch between inactive and active conformations. A simple model for the active state of rhodopsin can be compared to structural models of its ground state to localize chromophore-protein interactions that may be important in the photoactivation mechanism. This review focuses on the recent functional characterization of site-directed mutants of bovine rhodopsin and some cone pigments. In addition, an attempt is made to reconcile previous key findings and existing structural models with information gained from the analysis of site-directed mutant pigments.

Chromophore structural changes in rhodopsin from nanoseconds to microseconds following pigment photolysis

Rhodopsin is a prototypical G protein-coupled receptor that is activated by photoisomerization of its 11-cis-retinal chromophore. Mutant forms of rhodopsin were prepared in which the carboxylic acid counterion was moved relative to the positively charged chromophore Schiff base. Nanosecond time-resolved laser photolysis measurements of wild-type recombinant rhodopsin and two mutant pigments then were used to determine reaction schemes and spectra of their early photolysis intermediates. These results, together with linear dichroism data, yielded detailed structural information concerning chromophore movements during the first microsecond after photolysis. These chromophore structural changes provide a basis for understanding the relative movement of rhodopsin's transmembrane helices 3 and 6 required for activation of rhodopsin. Thus, early structural changes following isomerization of retinal are linked to the activation of this G protein-coupled receptor. Such rapid structural changes lie at the heart of the pharmacologically important signal transduction mechanisms in a large variety of receptors, which use extrinsic activators, but are impossible to study in receptors using diffusible agonist ligands.

The steric trigger in rhodopsin activation

Rhodopsin is the seven transmembrane helix receptor responsible for dim light vision in vertebrate rod cells. The protein has structural homology with the other G protein-coupled receptors, which suggests that the tertiary structures and activation mechanisms are likely to be similar. However, rhodopsin is unique in several respects. The most striking is the fact that the receptor "ligand", 11-cis retinal, is covalently bound to the protein and is converted from an "antagonist" to an "agonist" upon absorption of light. NMR studies of rhodopsin and its primary photoproduct, bathorhodopsin, have generated structural constraints that enabled docking of the 11-cis and all-trans retinal chromophores into a low-resolution model of the protein proposed by Baldwin. These studies also suggest a mechanism for how retinal isomerization leads to rhodopsin activation. More recently, mutagenesis studies have extended these results by showing how the selectivity of the retinal-binding site can be modified to favor the all-trans over the 11-cis isomer. The structural constraints produced from these studies, when placed in the context of a high-resolution model of the protein, provide a coherent picture of the activation mechanism, which we show involves a direct steric interaction between the retinal chromophore and transmembrane helix 3 in the region of Gly121.

A local electrostatic change is the cause of the large-scale protein conformation shift in bacteriorhodopsin

During light-driven proton transport bacteriorhodopsin shuttles between two protein conformations. A large-scale structural change similar to that in the photochemical cycle is produced in the D85N mutant upon raising the pH, even without illumination. We report here that (i) the pKa values for the change in crystallographic parameters and for deprotonation of the retinal Schiff base are the same, (ii) the retinal isomeric configuration is nearly unaffected by the protein conformation, and (iii) preventing rotation of the C13-C14 double bond by replacing the retinal with an all-trans locked analogue makes little difference to the Schiff base pKa. We conclude that the direct cause of the conformational shift is destabilization of the structure upon loss of interaction of the positively charged Schiff base with anionic residues that form its counter-ion.

Constitutive signaling by the phototaxis receptor sensory rhodopsin II from disruption of its protonated Schiff base-Asp-73 interhelical salt bridge

Sensory rhodopsin II (SRII) is a repellent phototaxis receptor in the archaeon Halobacterium salinarum, similar to visual pigments in its seven-helix structure and linkage of retinal to the protein by a protonated Schiff base in helix G. Asp-73 in helix C is shown by spectroscopic analysis to be a counterion to the protonated Schiff base in the unphotolyzed SRII and to be the proton acceptor from the Schiff base during photoconversion to the receptor signaling state. Coexpression of the genes encoding mutated SRII with Asn substituted for Asp-73 (D73N) and the SRII transducer HtrII in H. salinarum cells results in a 3-fold higher swimming reversal frequency accompanied by demethylation of HtrII in the dark, showing that D73N SRII produces repellent signals in its unphotostimulated state. Analogous constitutive signaling has been shown to be produced by the similar neutral residue substitution of the Schiff base counterion and proton acceptor Glu-113 in human rod rhodopsin. The interpretation for both seven-helix receptors is that light activation of the wild-type protein is caused primarily by photoisomerization-induced transfer of the Schiff base proton on helix G to its primary carboxylate counterion on helix C. Therefore receptor activation by helix C-G salt-bridge disruption in the photoactive site is a general mechanism in retinylidene proteins spanning the vast evolutionary distance between archaea and humans.

How receptors talk to trimeric G proteins

Stimulated by hormones and sensory stimuli, serpentine receptors promote the release of GDP that is bound to the alpha subunit of trimeric G proteins and its replacement by GTP. Recent investigations have begun to define the sizes, shapes, and relative orientations of receptors and G proteins, the surfaces through which they interact with one another, and conformational changes in both sets of molecules that underlie receptor-catalyzed guanine-nucleotide exchange.

Molecular mechanism of photosignaling by archaeal sensory rhodopsins

Two sensory rhodopsins (SRI and SRII) mediate color-sensitive phototaxis responses in halobacteria. These seven-helix receptor proteins, structurally and functionally similar to animal visual pigments, couple retinal photoisomerization to receptor activation and are complexed with membrane-embedded transducer proteins (HtrI and HtrII) that modulate a cytoplasmic phosphorylation cascade controlling the flagellar motor. The Htr proteins resemble the chemotaxis transducers from Escherichia coli. The SR-Htr signaling complexes allow studies of the biophysical chemistry of signal generation and relay, from the photobiophysics of initial excitation of the receptors to the final output at the level of the flagellar motor switch, revealing fundamental principles of sensory transduction and more broadly the nature of dynamic interactions between membrane proteins. We review here recent advances that have led to new insights into the molecular mechanism of signaling by these membrane complexes.

The effects of amino acid replacements of glycine 121 on transmembrane helix 3 of rhodopsin

Rhodopsin is a member of a family of G protein-coupled receptors with seven transmembrane (TM) helices. In rhodopsin, Gly121 is a highly conserved amino acid residue near the middle of TM helix 3. TM helix 3 is known to be involved in chromophore-protein interactions and contains the chromophore Schiff base counterion at position 113. We prepared a set of seven single amino acid replacement mutants of rhodopsin at position 121 (G121A, Ser, Thr, Val, Ile, Leu, and Trp) and control mutants with replacements of Gly114 or Ala117. The mutant opsins were expressed in COS cells and reconstituted with either 11-cis-retinal, the ground-state chromophore of rhodopsin, or all-trans-retinal, the isomer formed upon receptor photoactivation. The replacement of Gly121 resulted in a relative reversal in the selectivity of the opsin apoprotein for reconstitution with 11-cis-retinal over all-trans-retinal in COS cell membranes. The mutant pigments also were found to be thermally unstable to varying degrees and reactive to hydroxylamine in the dark. In addition, the size of the residue substituted at position 121 correlated directly to the degree of blue-shift in the lambdamax value of the pigment. These results suggest that Gly121 is an important and specific component of the 11-cis-retinal binding pocket in rhodopsin.

Rhodopsin activation blocked by metal-ion-binding sites linking transmembrane helices C and F

A large superfamily of receptors containing seven transmembrane (TM) helices transmits hormonal and sensory signals across the plasma membrane to heterotrimeric G proteins at the cytoplasmic face of the membrane. To investigate how G-protein-coupled receptors work at the molecular level, we have engineered metal-ion-binding sites between TM helices to restrain activation-induced conformational change in specific locations. In rhodopsin, the photoreceptor of retinal rod cells, we substituted histidine residues for natural amino acids at the cytoplasmic ends of the TM helices C and F. The resulting mutant proteins were able to activate the visual G protein transducin in the absence but not in the presence of metal ions. These results indicate that the TM helices C and F are in close proximity and suggest that movements of these helices relative to one another are required for transducin activation. Thus a change in the orientations of TM helices C and F is likely to be a key element in the mechanism for coupling binding of ligands (or isomerization of retinal) to the activation of G-protein-coupled receptors.

Agonist-specific conformational changes in the yeast alpha-factor pheromone receptor

The yeast alpha-factor pheromone receptor is a member of the G-protein-coupled receptor family. Limited trypsin digestion of yeast membranes was used to investigate ligand-induced conformational changes in this receptor. The agonist, alpha-factor, accelerated cleavage in the third intracellular loop, whereas the antagonist, desTrp1,Ala3-alpha-factor, reduced the cleavage rate. Thus, the enhanced accessibility of the third intracellular loop is specific to the agonist. alpha-Factor inhibited cleavage weakly at a second site near the cytoplasmic terminus of the seventh transmembrane helix, whereas the antagonist showed a stronger inhibition of cleavage at this site and at another site in the C-terminal domain of the receptor. The alpha-factor-induced conformational changes appeared to be inherent properties of the receptor, as they were retained in G-protein-deficient mutants. Moreover, a mutant receptor (ste2-L236H) that affects the third loop and is defective for G-protein coupling retained the ability to undergo the agonist-induced conformational changes. These results are consistent with a model in which G-protein activation is limited by the availability of specific contacts between the G protein and the third intracellular loop of the receptor. The antagonist appears to promote a distinct conformational state that differs from either the unoccupied or the agonist-occupied state.

Mechanisms of opsin activation

Rhodopsin is constrained in an inactive conformation by interactions with 11-cis-retinal including formation of a protonated Schiff base with Lys296. Upon photoisomerization, major structural rearrangements that involve protonation of the active site Glu113 and cytoplasmic acidic residues, including Glu134, lead to the formation of the active form of the receptor, metarhodopsin II b, which decays to opsin. However, an activated receptor may be generated without illumination by addition of all-trans-retinal or its analogues to opsin, as measured in this study by the increased phosphorylation of opsin by rhodopsin kinase. The potency of stimulation depended on the chemical and isomeric nature of the analogues and the length of the polyene chain with all-trans-C17 aldehyde and all-trans-retinal being the most active and trans-C12 aldehyde being the least active. Certain cis-isomers, 11-cis-13-demethyl-retinal and 9-cis-C17 aldehyde, were also active. Most of the retinal analogues tested did not regenerate a spectrally identifiable pigment, and many were incapable of Schiff base formation (ketone, stable oximes, and Schiff base-derivatives of retinal). Thus, receptor activation resulted from formation of non-covalent complexes with opsin. pH titrations suggested that an equilibrium exists between partially active (protonated) and inactive (deprotonated) forms of opsin. These findings are consistent with a model in which protonation of one or more cytoplasmic carboxyl groups of opsin is essential for activity. Upon addition of retinoids, the partially active conformation of opsin is converted to a more active intermediate similar to metarhodopsin II b. The model provides an understanding of the structural requirements for opsin activation and an interpretation of the observed activities of natural and experimental opsin mutants.