Computer-controlled spot-scan imaging of crotoxin complex crystals with 400 keV electrons at near-atomic resolution

Low-dose cryo electron ptychography via non-convex Bayesian optimization

Electron ptychography has seen a recent surge of interest for phase sensitive imaging at atomic or near-atomic resolution. However, applications are so far mainly limited to radiation-hard samples, because the required doses are too high for imaging biological samples at high resolution. We propose the use of non-convex Bayesian optimization to overcome this problem, and show via numerical simulations that the dose required for successful reconstruction can be reduced by two orders of magnitude compared to previous experiments. As an important application we suggest to use this method for imaging single biological macromolecules at cryogenic temperatures and demonstrate 2D single-particle reconstructions from simulated data with a resolution up to 5.4 Å at a dose of 20e⁻/Ų. When averaging over only 30 low-dose datasets, a 2D resolution around 3.5 Å is possible for macromolecular complexes even below 100 kDa. With its independence from the microscope transfer function, direct recovery of phase contrast, and better scaling of signal-to-noise ratio, low-dose cryo electron ptychography may become a promising alternative to Zernike phase-contrast microscopy.

Electron microscopic imaging of integrin

Rotary-shadowed samples often used for electron microscopy do not preserve native integrin conformations. Negatively stained integrins - or, more desirably, unstained integrins in a cryo-condition - are now being used with sophisticated imaging techniques. Additionally, a single-particle analysis (SPA) of integrins is advanced by the recent determination of several crystal structures of integrins. Nevertheless the conformational flexibility of integrins limits the ability of SPA to image physiologic conformations. To solve this problem, we apply electron tomography to purified integrin, thereby obtaining high-quality three-dimensional (3-D) images that fit well to the atomic structures. We have also taken typical SPA approaches to obtain a 3-D reconstruction of integrin, using conditions that favor the bent conformation.

Preferred orientations of LDL in vitreous ice indicate a discoid shape of the lipoprotein particle

The structure of the human low-density lipoprotein (LDL) was analyzed in vitreous ice using cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM). In relatively thick cryo-EM preparations, random orientation of LDL particles produced various types of projections on the microscope screen, including circular projections with a high-density ring and rectangular projections with two high-density bands. However, in especially thin preparations, preferred, non-random orientations of the LDL particle produced only circular projections of the lipoprotein structure. In preparations with high LDL concentrations, ordered two-dimensional arrays, including hexagonal arrangements of circular projections and short stacks of rectangular projections, were observed. These observations are consistent with a discoid shape of the LDL particle, and suggest that surface tension forces may influence orientation of the LDL disc in thin aqueous films. Face-on orientation of LDL in especially thin cryo-EM preparations may explain earlier difficulties in identifying discoid features of the lipoprotein particle, and illustrates that some caution is warranted when attempts are made to reconstruct the three-dimensional structure of LDL from cryo-electron micrographs.

A low-dose electron diffraction assay for protection of protein structure against damage from drying

A new assay using low-dose electron diffraction to measure the protection of protein structure against damage from drying is described. When thin single crystals of catalase are dried within water alone, low-dose electron diffraction yields no Bragg spots. Drying within an experimental aqueous solution that permits detection of diffraction spots thereby indicates a positive result, and the extent of these Bragg reflections into the high angle range gives a quantitative measure of the degree of protection. Bragg spots out to 3.73.9 are recorded for drying within 100 mM solutions of the known structure-preserving sugars, sucrose, tannin, and trehalose. The ability of trehalose to maintain native protein structure during drying starts between 10 and 25 mM, and changes only slightly at concentrations above this threshold; with drying in 150-mM trehalose, catalase crystals yield diffraction spots out to 3.7. Drying within the organic nonsugar polymer polyvinylpyrrolidone gives Bragg spots to 4.0. This new assay should be useful to measure the unexamined structure-preserving capabilities of modified sugars, other nonsugars, and mixtures to identify which protective matrix maintains native protein structure to the greatest extent during drying; electron crystallography using that optimal matrix should yield protein structure at improved levels of high resolution.

Multivariate analysis of single unit cells in electron crystallography

High-resolution electron cryomicroscopy of two-dimensional protein crystals is associated with extremely noisy raw data in which even the crystal lattice often cannot be discerned. Correlation averaging procedures, aimed at calculating the total average of all unit cells of crystals in order to reduce noise, are now used routinely in electron crystallography. Multivariate statistical analysis (MSA) may be used for finding not only the average structure but also for quantifying the systematic departures from that average within the population of individual unit cells. We show that the MSA approach is applicable to single unit-cell images in the low-dose (< 10 electrons/A2), high-resolution (< 5 A) realm using 400 keV electron spot-scan images of ice-embedded gp32*I protein crystals. Our feasibility study opens a pathway toward exploiting these naturally occurring variations on the unit-cell theme in order to achieve higher-resolution three-dimensional reconstruction results, or to better understand the dynamic behaviour of molecules within two-dimensional crystals. We explain how single unit-cell images can be processed and classified into homogeneous groups, and we review how the results of such discriminate averaging may subsequently be exploited within the context of conventional "h, k"-space electron crystallographic approaches. Variations among the individual unit cells may thus be one of the most significant resolution-limiting factors currently experienced in electron crystallography. The quantitative assessment and exploitation of such variations may lead to an increased performance of electron crystallographic procedures.

Reduction of charging in protein electron cryomicroscopy

Charging causes a loss of resolution in electron cryomicroscopy with biological specimens prepared without a continuous carbon support film. Thin conductive films were deposited onto catalase crystals prepared across holes using ion-beam sputtering and thermal evaporation and evaluated for the effectiveness of charge reduction. Deposits applied by ion-beam sputtering reduced charging but concurrently resulted in structural damage. Coatings applied by thermal evaporation also reduced charging, and preserved the specimen structure beyond 5 A resolution as judged from electron diffraction patterns and images of glucose-embedded catalase crystals tilted to 45 degrees in the microscope. This study demonstrates for the first time the feasibility of obtaining high-resolution data from unstained, unsupported protein crystals with a conductive surface coating.

Evaluation of charging on macromolecules in electron cryomicroscopy

We describe procedures to assess charging of biological specimens under electron irradiation in an electron cryomicroscope. Charging can be observed by an expansion of the illuminating beam, blurring of electron diffraction patterns and by beam "footprints" on the specimen. Discharging can also be seen in the defocused electron diffraction mode. We investigated the influence of a variety of factors on the magnitude and visibility of charging. A reduction of charging is noticed when part of the adjacent carbon film is included in the irradiated specimen area.

An atomic model of the outer layer of the bluetongue virus core derived from X-ray crystallography and electron cryomicroscopy

BACKGROUND

Bluetongue virus (BTV), which belongs to the Reoviridae family and orbivirus genus, is a non-enveloped, icosahedral, double-stranded RNA virus. Several protein layers enclose its genome; upon cell entry the outer layer is stripped away leaving a core, the surface of which is composed of VP7. The structure of the trimeric VP7 molecule has previously been determined using X-ray crystallography. The articulated VP7 subunit consists of two domains, one which is largely alpha-helical and the other, smaller domain, is a beta barrel with jelly-roll topology. The relative orientations of these two domains vary in different crystal forms. The structure of VP7 and the organizations of 780 subunits of this molecule in the core of virus is central to the assembly and function of BTV.

RESULTS

A 23 A resolution map of the core, determined using electron cryomicroscopy (cryoEM) data, reveals that the 260 trimers of VP7 are organized on a rather precise T = 13 laevo icosahedral lattice, in accordance with the theory of quasi-equivalence. The VP7 layer occupies a shell that is between 260 A and 345 A from the centre of the core. Below this radius (230-260 A) lies the T = 1 layer of 120 molecules of VP3. By fitting the X-ray structure of an individual VP7 trimer onto the cryoEM BTV core structure, we have generated an atomic model of the VP7 layer of BTV. This demonstrates that one of the molecular structures seen in crystals of the isolated VP7 corresponds to the in vivo conformation of the molecule in the core.

CONCLUSIONS

The beta-barrel domains of VP7 are external to the core and interact with protein in the outer layer of the mature virion. The lower, alpha-helical domains of VP7 interact with VP3 molecules which form the inner layer of the BTV core. Adjacent VP7 trimer-trimer interactions in the T = 13 layer are mediated principally through well-defined regions in the broader lower domains, to form a structure that conforms well with that expected from the theory of quasi-equivalence with no significant conformational changes within the individual trimers. The VP3 layer determines the particle size and forms a rather smooth surface upon which the two-dimensional lattice of VP7 trimers is laid down.

Electron crystallography of macromolecular periodic arrays on phospholipid monolayers

Electron crystallography has the potential of yielding structural information equivalent to x-ray diffraction. The major difficulty has been preparing specimens with the required structural order and size for diffraction and imaging in the electron microscope. 2D crystallization on phospholipid monolayers is capable of fulfilling both of these requirements. Crystals can form as a result of specific interactions with a protein's ligand or an analog, suitably linked to a lipid tail; or on a surface of complementary head-group charge. With such choices, the availability of a suitable lipid is limited only by synthetic chemistry. Ultimately, it is the quality and regularity of the protein-protein interactions that determine the crystalline order, as it is with any protein crystal. In the case of streptavidin, the monolayer crystal diffracts beyond 2.5 A. A 3 A projection map reconstructed from electron diffraction amplitudes and phases from images shows density which can be interpreted as beta-sheets and clusters of side chains. It remains to be shown that the monolayer crystals are flat and diffract as well at high tilt angle as untilted. Technological issues such as charging must be resolved. With parallel advances in data collection and processing, electron crystallography of monolayer macromolecular crystals will eventually take its place beside x-ray crystallography and NMR as a routine and efficient structural technique.

Visualization of ordered genomic RNA and localization of transcriptional complexes in rotavirus

In double-stranded-RNA (dsRNA) viruses found in animals, bacteria and yeast, the genome is transcribed within the structurally intact core of the virion with extraordinary efficiency. The structural organization of the genome and the enzymes involved in the transcription inside any of these viruses, critical for understanding this process, is not known. Here we report what we believe is the first three-dimensional characterization of the viral genome and the transcription complex in a prototypical dsRNA virus. Rotavirus is a large (diameter 1,000 A) icosahedral virus composed of three capsid protein layers and 11 dsRNA segments. It is the most important cause of gastroenteritis in children, accounting for over a million deaths annually. We show that viral dsRNA forms a dodecahedral structure in which the RNA double helices, interacting closely with the inner capsid layer, are packed around the enzyme complex located at the icosahedral 5-fold axes. The ordered RNA accounts for about 4,500 out of a total 18,525 base pairs in the genome, the largest amount of icosahedrally ordered RNA observed in any virus structure to date. We propose that the observed organization of the dsRNA is conducive for an orchestrated movement of the RNA relative to the enzyme complex during transcription.

Performance of a slow-scan CCD camera for macromolecular imaging in a 400 kV electron cryomicroscope

The feasibility and limitations of a 1024 x 1024 slow-scan charge-coupled device (CCD) camera were evaluated for imaging in a 400kV electron cryomicroscope. Catalase crystals and amorphous carbon film were used as test specimens. Using catalase crystals, it was found that the finite (24 microns) pixel size of the slow-scan CCD camera governs the ultimate resolution in the acquired images. For instance, spot-scan images of ice-embedded catalase crystals showed resolutions of 8 A and 4 A at effective magnifications of 67,000 x and 132,000 x, respectively. Using an amorphous carbon film, the damping effect of the modulation transfer function (MTF) of the slow-scan CCD camera on the specimen's Fourier spectrum relative to that of the photographic film was evaluated. The MTF of the slow-scan CCD camera fell off more rapidly compared to that of the photographic film and reached the value of 0.2 at the Nyquist frequency. Despite this attenuation, the signal-to-noise ratio of the CCD data, as determined from reflections of negatively-stained catalase crystals, was found to decrease to approximately 50% of that of photographic film data. The phases computed from images of the same negatively-stained catalase crystals recorded consecutively on both the slow-scan CCD camera and photographic film were found to be comparable to each other within 12 degrees. Ways of minimizing the effect of the MTF of the slow-scan CCD camera on the acquired images are also presented.

Assembly of VP26 in herpes simplex virus-1 inferred from structures of wild-type and recombinant capsids

The 1250 A diameter herpes simplex virus-1 (HSV-1) capsid shell consists of four major structural proteins, of which VP26 (approximately 12,000 M(r)) is the smallest. Using 400 kV electron cryomicroscopy and computer reconstruction, we have determined the three-dimensional structures of the wild-type capsid and a recombinant baculovirus-generated HSV-1 capsid which lacks VP26. Their difference map demonstrates the presence of VP26 hexamers attached to all the hexons in the wild-type capsid, and reveals that the VP26 molecule consists of a large and a small domain. Although both hexons and pentons are predominantly composed of VP5, VP26 is not present on the penton. Based on the interactions involving VP26 and the hexon subunits, we propose a mechanism for VP26 assembly which would account for its distribution. Possible roles of VP26 in capsid stability and DNA packaging are discussed.

High-resolution electron microscopy of biological specimens in cubic ice

Images of two biological test specimens, catalase and TMV, were recorded in cubic ice, prepared by controlled devitrification at -130 degrees C and -75 degrees C or in vitrified buffer. Cubic ice provides a rigid support for biological specimens which is stable under the electron beam to within about 1 A, as shown by images of the ice lattice. Neither catalase nor TMV were disrupted by the crystallization of vitrified water. Electron diffraction patterns of highly oriented rafts of TMV extending to 2.3 A resolution were used to judge the quality of TMV images. Structural high-resolution details of TMV was better in cubic ice, and the success rate for recording good images was higher than in vitrified medium.

Three-dimensional structure of a single filament in the Limulus acrosomal bundle: scruin binds to homologous helix-loop-beta motifs in actin

Frozen, hydrated acrosomal bundles from Limulus sperm were imaged with a 400 kV electron cryomicroscope. Segments of this long bundle can be studied as a P1 crystal with a unit cell containing an acrosomal filament with 28 actin and 28 scruin molecules in 13 helical turns. A novel computational procedure was developed to extract single columns of superimposed acrosomal filaments from the distinctive crystallographic view. Helical reconstruction was used to generate a three-dimensional structure of this computationally isolated acrosomal filament. The scruin molecule is organized into two domains which contact two actin subunits in different strands of the same actin filament. A correlation of Holmes' actin filament model to the density in our acrosomal filament map shows that actin subdomains 1, 2, and 3 match the model density closely. However, actin subdomain 4 matches rather poorly, suggesting that interactions with scruin may have altered actin conformation. Scruin makes extensive interactions with helix-loop-beta motifs in subdomain 3 of one actin subunit and in subdomain 1 of a consecutive actin subunit along the genetic filament helix. These two actin subdomains are structurally homologous and are closely spaced along the actin filament. Our model suggests that scruin, which is derived from a tandemly duplicated gene, has evolved to bind structurally homologous but non-identical positions across two consecutive actin subunits.

High-resolution electron crystallography of protein molecules

Electron diffraction data and high-resolution images can now be used to obtain accurate, three-dimensional density maps of biological macromolecules. These density maps can be interpreted by building an atomic-resolution model of the structure into the experimental density. The Cowley-Moodie formalism of dynamical diffraction theory has been used to validate the use of kinematic diffraction theory (strictly, the weak phase object approximation) in producing such 3D density maps. Further improvements in the preparation of very flat (planar) specimens and in the retention of diffraction to a resolution of 0.2 nm or better could result in electron crystallography becoming as important a technique as X-ray crystallography currently is for the field of structural molecular biology.

Low-dose thickness measurement of glucose-embedded protein crystals by electron energy loss spectroscopy and STEM dark-field imaging

Electron energy loss spectroscopy and dark-field imaging in a scanning transmission electron microscope were used to determine the thickness of glucose-embedded crotoxin complex crystals. The results demonstrate the feasibility of identifying protein crystals with a thickness of half a unit cell (12.8 nm) under low-dose and low-temperature conditions. The accuracy of this method is limited by the amount of surface coating of the crystal's embedding glucose used for preserving the high-resolution structure of the protein. The histogram of the crystal thickness distribution and the spread of the anticipated crystal thickness allow us to make an estimate of the uncertainty in the glucose layer thickness. This approach can be incorporated as part of the experimental procedure in the three-dimensional data collection for structure determination of protein crystals with variable thicknesses. The measurement can be done on areas approximately 200 nm in diameter so that crystals of suitable thickness can be pre-selected before the high-resolution data is recorded. Accurate determination of the crystal thickness will optimize the data collection efficiency by avoiding the collection and subsequent analysis of unmatchable data for the three-dimensional reconstruction.

Electron crystallography of macromolecules

Numerous technical advances in electron crystallography have facilitated determination of the three-dimensional structures of macromolecules, especially those that form two-dimensional or helical periodic arrays. Several recent studies have demonstrated the utility of this technique for visualizing secondary structure such as alpha-helices and beta-sheets of membrane proteins and, in one case, the entire polypeptide backbone. Electron crystallography, therefore, has great potential as a tool for studying structural problems that are relevant to both molecular biology and biotechnology.

Teaching electron diffraction and imaging of macromolecules

Electron microscopic analysis can be used to determine the three-dimensional structures of macromolecules at resolutions ranging between 3 and 30 A. It differs from nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy or x-ray crystallography in that it allows an object's Coulomb potential functions to be determined directly from images and can be used to study relatively complex macromolecular assemblies in a crystalline or noncrystalline state. Electron imaging already has provided valuable structural information about various biological systems, including membrane proteins, protein-nucleic acid complexes, contractile and motile protein assemblies, viruses, and transport complexes for ions or macromolecules. This article, organized as a series of lectures, presents the biophysical principles of three-dimensional analysis of objects possessing different symmetries.

Prospects for using an IVEM with a FEG for imaging macromolecules towards atomic resolution

Specimen preparation and imaging techniques for biological macromolecules have been improved to the point where attention to the electron-optical imaging conditions becomes a significant factor for achieving high resolution. A field emission gun (FEG) can provide an illumination source with a better spatial and temporal coherence suitable for imaging near atomic resolution. Our computational analysis of carbon film images taken between Scherzer focus and 1.1 microns underfocus (20x Scherzer focus) with the Hitachi 200 kV microscope with a cold field emission gun shows detectable contrast beyond 3.5 A resolution. In biological imaging, a large defocus is often used to optimize the low-resolution contrast in order to facilitate the subsequent steps in computer reconstruction. An intermediate-voltage electron microscope (IVEM) would optimize the contrast at high resolution by reducing the temporal coherent effects. In theory, the IVEM would give a greater depth of field so that large macromolecular assemblies such as viruses and cellular structures can be interpreted and reconstructed reliably using the projection approximation. These experimental and theoretical considerations provide a rationale for designing a future IVEM with a FEG suitable for biological macromolecule imaging close to atomic resolution.